1904 Tour de France
|Route of the 1904 Tour de France
Followed clockwise, starting in Montgeron and ending in Paris
|Dates||2–24 July 1904 |
|Distance||2,428 km (1,509 mi)|
|Winning time||96h 05' 55" (25.265 km/h or 15.699 mph)|
|Winner||Henri Cornet (France)|
|Second||Jean-Baptiste Dortignacq (France)|
|Third||Aloïs Catteau (Belgium)|
The 1904 Tour de France was the second Tour de France, held from 2 to 24 July. With a route similar to its previous edition, 1903 Tour de France winner Maurice Garin seemed to have repeated his win by a small margin over Lucien Pothier, while Hippolyte Aucouturier won four of the six stages. But the race became a victim of its own success, plagued by scandals; cyclists were accused of having taken trains during the race. Twelve cyclists, including the first four of the final classification and all stage winners, were disqualified by the Union Vélocipédique Française (UVF). Henri Cornet, originally the fifth-place finisher, was awarded the victory four months after the race. The problems caused the Tour de France to be provisionally cancelled, the 1905 Tour de France was run with different rules from the 1903 and 1904 edition.
The initial Tour de France of 1903 had been a large success, and it was quickly decided to organize it again in 1904. The route was identical, with the same six stages. The rules were the same as in 1903, with one exception: cyclists could not enter in just one stage, but had to join for the entire race. The favourites for the victory were Garin, Pothier and Aucouturier, who had performed well in the 1903 Tour de France. Among the competitors was Henri Paret who, at 50 years old, still holds the record of oldest Tour de France cyclist.
In the 1903 Tour de France, the organisation guaranteed that the first 50 cyclists in the final general classification would earn at least 5 francs per day. In 1904, if not more than 50 cyclists would finish, also cyclists who dropped out during the race would still get 5 francs for the days they had been in the race. This rule was added to attract cyclists who otherwise would not enter, because the Tour needed enough competitors to remain credible.
In the first stage, the riders fell after only a few kilometres. Lipman broke a finger, and became the first rider to abandon this Tour. Around 100 km in the race, Lucien Pothier lost ten minutes to the main group, led by Maurice Garin, because of a broken bicycle. In Cosne, at 174 km, Pothier had reached the leading group. Aucouturier had lost more than one hour at that point. Just before the next control post in Nevers, Aucouturier fell on his face, and continued the race covered in blood. In the last part of the race, Maurice Garin and Lucien Pothier rode away from the others. They were attacked by four masked men in a car, but still finished as the first two, with Garin beating Pothier by 50 m. The many flat tires and crashes of Aucouturier, seemingly the results of sabotage, gave him a time loss of several hours.
After the stage, three cyclists were punished: Aucouturier and Samson received fines of 500 and 250 francs, Aucouturier for having a cyclist not in the race following him, Samson for riding in the slipstream of a car. Chevallier, who had finished third, was disqualified for resting in a car for 45 minutes. During the stage, Ferdinand Payan had been disqualified. Some sources indicate he was helped by a motor, other that he was helped by riders not in the race. In that first stage, Garin had asked the race official Lefèvre for food, which was illegal. Lefèvre, who knew that Garin was the star of the race, broke the rules and gave him the food, because he did not want to be responsible for Garin leaving the race because of hunger. The news that Garin had received illegal help quickly spread, and caused the fanatical crowd to take action.
For the second stage, the organisers had made the option to postpone the start by two hours, in case the mistral wind was making cycling difficult. This was not necessary, so the riders started at midnight as planned. During this stage, Antoine Fauré lead close to his hometown, and 200 fans tried to stop the rest of the cyclists from following him. Garin hurt his hand during the incident, and Giovanni Gerbi was knocked unconscious, and had to give up with broken fingers. The situation was only solved after race officials fired shots in the air. Further on, nails and broken glass had been spread along the road, which caused many flat tires. Because of this help, Fauré was the first on top of the Col de la République, but was taken over by the favourites later. Aucouturier won the sprint. When the riders reached Marseille, they complained that there had been too many incidents in this stage, and the stage results should be cancelled. In the last part, they had been stopped by a large group of cyclists. Maurice Garin had been attacked, and his arm had been injured: he finished the stage steering with only one hand. There was so much confusion at the last controle post, that the exact arrival times of the cyclists were not recorded.
In the third stage, the Tour reached Nîmes, near the home town of Payan, whose fans were angry because of his disqualification. They threw rocks at the riders, and barricaded the road. The cyclists had troubles passing through Nîmes, and several were injured. The most important event for the general classification was when César Garin's bicycle was broken by attackers; he had to find a new bicycle, which took him 15 minutes. Further on, nails and broken glass were spread along the road. Many riders punctured, but there were no serious falls. The cyclists passed this part walking. After Nîmes, a leading group of five cyclists was formed: Maurice Garin, Pothier, Aucouturier, Cornet and Beaugendre. Aucouturier and Cornet escaped, and Aucouturier won, beating Cornet in the sprint.
The fourth stage was run without the incidents that plagued the first three stages. Pothier, Maurice and César Garin and Beaugendre reached Bordeaux together, and the stage was decided by the final kilometre in the velodrome, where Pothier recorded the fastest time.
In the fifth stage, nails on the road again causing punctures. As mechanical assistance was not allowed, Cornet had to ride the last 40 km on two flat tires. Aucouturier won this stage, his third one, but was way behind in the general classification, which Garin lead, with only 28 seconds margin to Pothier.
In the sixth stage, Aucouturier, Garin and Dortignac escaped in the last kilometres. Aucouturier signed first at the control post in Ville-d'Avray. From that point, the race was neutralised until the velodrome Parc-des-Princes, where the riders would ride the final kilometre. At the moment that the riders arrived in Paris, it started to rain. The organisers decided together with the cyclists to exclude the final kilometre from the race, and make the control post in Ville-d'Avray the end of the race. This made Aucouturier the winner of the stage. Maurice Garin finished second, which made him the overall winner.
Initial results before disqualifications
Initially, Maurice Garin was the winner, having led the race from start to end. Hippolyte Aucouturier won four stages. In total, 27 cyclists finished. For each cyclist, the times they had needed in each stage was added up for the general classification. The cyclist with the least accumulated time after the last stage was the winner.
|1||2 July||Montgeron–Lyon||Plain stage||467 km (290 mi)||Maurice Garin (FRA)||Maurice Garin (FRA)|
|2||9 July||Lyon–Marseille||Stage with mountain||374 km (232 mi)||Hippolyte Aucouturier (FRA)||Maurice Garin (FRA)|
|3||13 July||Marseille–Toulouse||Plain stage||424 km (263 mi)||Hippolyte Aucouturier (FRA)||Maurice Garin (FRA)|
|4||17 July||Toulouse–Bordeaux||Plain stage||268 km (167 mi)||Lucien Pothier (FRA)||Maurice Garin (FRA)|
|5||20 July||Bordeaux–Nantes||Plain stage||425 km (264 mi)||Hippolyte Aucouturier (FRA)||Maurice Garin (FRA)|
|6||23 July||Nantes–Paris||Plain stage||471 km (293 mi)||Hippolyte Aucouturier (FRA)||Maurice Garin (FRA)|
|1||Maurice Garin (FRA)||93h 06' 24"|
|2||Lucien Pothier (FRA)||+6' 28"|
|3||César Garin (FRA)||+1h 51' 03"|
|4||Hippolyte Aucouturier (FRA)||+2h 52' 26"|
|5||Henri Cornet (FRA)||+2h 59' 27"|
|6||Jean-Baptiste Dortignacq (FRA)||+5h 15' 36"|
|7||Philippe Jousselin (FRA)||+8h 33' 42"|
|8||Aloïs Catteau (BEL)||+12h 00' 56"|
|9||Camille Fily (FRA)||+15h 36' 42"|
|10||Jean Dargassies (FRA)||+16h 04' 01"|
During the race, nine riders were excluded because of, among other actions, illegal use of cars or trains. The Tour organizers were happy with the result, but the Union Vélocipédique Française (UVF) started an investigation after complaints from other cyclists. Their investigative committee heard testimony from dozens of competitors and witnesses, and, in December 1904, disqualified all the stage winners and the first four finishers (Maurice Garin, Pothier, César Garin, and Aucouturier). Ten of those disqualified were banned for one year, Garin for two years and the remaining two for life. In total, 29 riders were punished. The reasons for the disqualification were never made public.
Fifth-placed Henri Cornet, aged 19, then became the youngest ever winner of the Tour. Cornet had also been warned after he had received a lift by a car. Only 15 cyclists from the original 27 that finished were not disqualified.
Following the disqualifications, the Tour de France came nearest in history to being permanently cancelled. The race organiser Henri Desgrange, said he would never run the race again because it had been overtaken by the "blind emotions" of those who attacked or helped riders as they passed. Desgrange was also upset that the UVF had imposed judgement on his race when he had already disciplined riders as he saw fit.
An angry exchange ensued between Desgrange and the UVF but the letters and the detailed complaints that led to the UVF's actions were lost when the Tour de France archives were transported south in 1940 to avoid the German invasion and were never seen again.
Until the end of his life, Garin always said that he was the rightful winner of the 1904 Tour de France, but according to Les Woodland, Garin confessed to a friend that he had cheated.
After the disqualifications, the first four cyclists of the initial classification were disqualified. In the new classification, only 15 cyclists had finished:
|1||2 July||Montgeron–Lyon||Plain stage||467 km (290 mi)||Michel Frédérick (SUI)||Michel Frédérick (SUI)|
|2||9 July||Lyon–Marseille||Stage with mountain||374 km (232 mi)||Antoine Fauré (FRA)||Emile Lombard (BEL)|
|3||13 July||Marseille–Toulouse||Plain stage||424 km (263 mi)||Henri Cornet (FRA)||Henri Cornet (FRA)|
|4||17 July||Toulouse–Bordeaux||Plain stage||268 km (167 mi)||François Beaugendre (FRA)||François Beaugendre (FRA)|
|5||20 July||Bordeaux–Nantes||Plain stage||425 km (264 mi)||Jean-Baptiste Dortignacq (FRA)||Henri Cornet (FRA)|
|6||23 July||Nantes–Paris||Plain stage||471 km (293 mi)||Jean-Baptiste Dortignacq (FRA)||Henri Cornet (FRA)|
|1||Henri Cornet (FRA)||96h 05' 55"|
|2||Jean-Baptiste Dortignacq (FRA)||+2h 16' 14"|
|3||Aloïs Catteau (BEL)||+9h 01' 25"|
|4||Jean Dargassies (FRA)||+13h 04' 30"|
|5||Julien Maitron (FRA)||+19h 06' 15"|
|6||Auguste Daumain (FRA)||+22h 44' 36"|
|7||Louis Coolsaet (BEL)||+23h 44' 20"|
|8||Achille Colas (FRA)||+25h 09' 50"|
|9||René Saget (FRA)||+25h 55' 16"|
|10||Gustave Drioul (BEL)||+30h 54' 49"|
Because of the scandals associated with this Tour, Desgrange wanted to stop the race. He however changed his mind, and the rules were changed to prevent cyclists from cheating: the 1905 Tour de France would be decided with a points system. Tour de France 1904 winner Cornet would enter the Tour de France for seven more times, but would never again play an important role.
- Augendre, Jacques (2009). "Guide Historique" (PDF) (in French). Amaury Sport Organisation. Archived from the original on 3 October 2009. Retrieved 2 October 2009.
- "No centenary party for 1904 Tour of shame". Reuters. 8 July 2004. Archived from the original on 3 May 2009. Retrieved 18 March 2009.
- "The Tour – Year 1904". Amaury Sport Organisation. Retrieved 29 December 2009.
- "2ème Tour de France 1904" (in French). Memoire du cyclisme. Archived from the original on 27 May 2009. Retrieved 20 May 2009.
- McGann, Bill; McGann, Carol (2006). The Story of the Tour de France. Dog Ear Publishing. pp. 10–13. ISBN 1-59858-180-5. Retrieved 29 December 2009.
- "Tour de France Trivia". Retrieved 2012-07-22.
- Thompson, Christopher S. (2006). The Tour de France: a cultural history. University of California Press. p. 152. ISBN 0-520-24760-4.
- "Vélocipédie". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 3 July 1904. p. 4. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Vélocipédie". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 4 July 1904. p. 4. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Vélocipédie – coureurs punis". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 6 July 1904. p. 4. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Vélocipédie – Le le Tour de France". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 10 July 1904. p. 4. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "1904: Henri Cornet wint na diskwalificatie van winnaars" (in Dutch). tourdefrance.nl. 19 March 2003. Archived from the original on 3 May 2009. Retrieved 18 March 2009.
- "Le Tour de France". Le Petit Parisien (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 10 July 1904. p. 5. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Vélocipédie – Le Tour de France". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 11 July 1904. p. 5. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "2ème Tour de France 1904 – 2ème étape" (in French). Memoire du cyclisme. Retrieved 9 March 2010.
- "Le Tour de France". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 15 July 1904. p. 4. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Le Tour de France". Le Petit Parisien (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 15 July 1904. p. 5. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Vélocipédie – Le Tour de France". Le Petit Parisien (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 17 July 1904. p. 5. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Le Tour de France – La fin de la cinquième étape". Le Petit journal (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 22 July 1904. p. 3. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- "Vélocipédie – Le Tour de France". Le Figaro (in French) (Gallica Bibliothèque Numérique). 25 July 1904. p. 6. Retrieved 16 March 2010.
- James, Tom (4 April 2001). "The Tour is finished...". VeloArchive. Archived from the original on 3 May 2009. Retrieved 18 March 2009.
- Abt, Samuel (5 March 2008). "Tour's early scandal still a mystery". International Herald Tribune. Retrieved 18 March 2009.
- "Tour records and winners". BBC. 30 June 2000. Retrieved 29 December 2009.
- Pelkey, Charles (3 December 2008). "The Explainer – Disqualified!". VeloNews. Retrieved 21 September 2009.
- Thomazeau, François (29 July 2007). "Plus ça change... they started cheating in 1904". Guardian. Retrieved 18 March 2009.
- "Past results for Henri Cornet (FRA)". ASO. Archived from the original on 27 May 2009. Retrieved 20 May 2009.
- Seray, Jacques (1999). 1904: The Tour de France Which Was to Be the Last. Ann Arbor Press. ISBN 0-9649835-2-4.