2008 San Diego F/A-18 crash

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
2008 San Diego F/A-18 crash
Smoke seen after the crash
Accident summary
Date December 8, 2008 (2008-12-08)
Summary Mechanical failure[1] due to negligent maintenance[2]
Site University City, San Diego, California
32°51′38″N 117°11′54″W / 32.860656°N 117.198195°W / 32.860656; -117.198195Coordinates: 32°51′38″N 117°11′54″W / 32.860656°N 117.198195°W / 32.860656; -117.198195
Crew 1[3]
Fatalities 4
Survivors 1 (pilot)
Aircraft type F/A-18D Hornet
Operator United States Marine Corps
Flight origin USS Abraham Lincoln (CVN-72)
Destination Marine Corps Air Station Miramar

The San Diego F/A-18 crash was the crash of a United States Marine Corps (USMC) F/A-18 Hornet in a residential area of San Diego, California on December 8, 2008. The pilot, First Lieutenant Dan Neubauer (28) from VMFAT-101, was the only crewmember on board the two-seat aircraft; he ejected successfully, landing in a tree. The jet crashed into the University City residential area, destroying two houses and damaging a third. A total of 4 residents in one house, two women and two children, were killed.

A USMC investigation concluded that poor maintenance caused the engine malfunction. Errors by the pilot and USMC personnel on the ground led to the aircraft crashing into the San Diego residential neighborhood. As a result, in early 2009 the pilot was temporarily grounded and thirteen other officers and enlisted personnel were relieved and/or disciplined. The Marine Corps notified other F/A-18 squadrons of the engine and fuel problems discovered during the investigation.

Crash[edit]

On December 8, 2008 Lt Neubauer was piloting an F/A-18D-30-MC Hornet (Lot 12), BuNo 164017,[4][5][6][3] from VMFAT-101, based at MCAS Miramar. Along with several other VMFAT-101 aircraft, he was conducting day and night carrier qualifications (catapult launches and tailhook arrested carrier landings) aboard the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln offshore 60 miles southwest of San Diego.[7] Neubauer was the only crewmember on board the two-seat aircraft.[3][8]

After taking off from the carrier at 11:11 a.m.,[9] Neubauer reported an oil caution light for the right engine, and shut it down after efforts to clear the problem failed. After declaring emergency, he was first directed towards Naval Air Station North Island, but was redirected by superior officers to his home base of MCAS Miramar when about 50 miles (80 km) away from North Island. Neubauer attempted to make an arrested landing at Miramar but the jet lost power in its second engine while on final approach. Eyewitnesses reported the jet flew slowly eastbound at a low altitude and was dumping fuel (which is not uncommon for an emergency landing). The pilot said that as he broke through the clouds at 2,500 feet (760 m), his left engine's thrust slipped dangerously low, and he unsuccessfully tried to start the right engine. The left engine lost more thrust, before its generator dropped offline and the jet lost electrical power.[9]

The jet flew over University City High School and crashed into the residential area just past the school about two miles from the Miramar's runway 6L.[9] Neubauer waited "until the last possible moment" to eject from the plane, bailing out at an altitude of just 400 feet (120 m), having attempted to steer away from homes on the ground before the crash.[1][2][10] He ejected successfully, landing in a tree in Rose Canyon, just behind a home. The jet crashed into the University City residential area at Cather Ave and Huggins St (between the high school and exit 24 of Interstate 805), destroying two houses and damaging three others. A total of 4 residents in one house, two women and two young children, were killed.[11][12]

Neubauer was taken to a military hospital and treated for unspecified mild injuries,[13][14] and reported being "horrified" by the crash at that time.[9] Killed on the ground in one home were Young Mi Lee, 36; her 15-month old baby, Grace; her 2-month-old newborn daughter, Rachel; and her mother, Suk Im Kim, 60, who had recently arrived from South Korea to help care for her daughter’s newborn.[9][10][15][16][17] The other house destroyed belonged to John and Sunny Wu, who lived there with their two daughters. None of the family was home at the time of the crash, but the home and everything in it were lost.[12][18]

Aftermath[edit]

In the aftermath of the crash, University City residents renewed previous calls for the US military to relocate aircraft from the base to a more remote location. In a counterpoint, homeowners in University City signed disclosure forms saying they were aware of overflying jets and that this "...extraordinarily rare event...got enormous publicity [and] the risk of living in University City and having a plane fall on you is millions to one."[19] Miramar was also the location of the Navy Fighter Weapons School before it was moved to the more remote Naval Air Station Fallon.

Marine commanders apologized for the crash and defended the decision to order Neubauer to land at Miramar instead of North Island, which isn't surrounded by residences, stating that double-engine failures are extremely rare. Said Colonel Christopher O'Connor, Miramar's commander, "We are not contemplating changing our emergency procedures at this time. We very seldom fly over the area. We take being good neighbors very seriously."[20]

On December 15, 2008, Marine officials stationed in South Korea helped receive Suk Im Kim's remains at Incheon International Airport and transport them to her home in Damyang. The next day, United States Forces Korea commander General Walter L. Sharp sent a delegation to Kim's home headed by Republic of Korea Army Major General Yong-goo Jang and U.S. Marine Corps Major General Frank Panther to express condolences to Kim's son-in-law, Dong-yun Yoon.[21]

As of July 2010, US$700,000 in claims had been paid by the government.[22][23] Young Mi Lee's husband, Don Yoon, publicly forgave Neubauer during a news conference the day after the crash.[10] Said Sunny Wu of the crash, "I don't want to blame anybody. I think everyone makes mistakes sometimes. Just as long as you can learn from your mistake, it's fine."[9]

In July 2010, Yoon sued Boeing and the United States government for an unspecified amount. In the suit, Yoon alleges that the government violated many of its procedures in its operation of the mishap aircraft and that Boeing was responsible for the defects in the aircraft's fuel systems which caused the crash.[22] Yoon later stated that the compensation offer from the US government for the loss of his four family members and his home was "insulting". Yoon's lawsuit against the US Navy was heard in a federal district court in San Diego in December 2011.[24] On 28 December 2011, U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Miller awarded Yoon, his father-in-law, and mother-in-law's three adult children a total of $17.8 million in damage compensation from the U.S. government.[25] The US government appealed the award, and the appellate decision is pending.[26]

The Wu family lived in a temporary home for two years until their home was rebuilt. Their homeowner's insurance did not cover all the cost of the reconstruction, temporary lodging expense, or replacement of all their lost possessions. More surprising, according to the Wu family, is that they have yet to receive any compensation from the US Navy. The family has filed a lawsuit against the US government for compensation for their damages. Said Sunny Zhuang-Wu, "I didn’t know the military would be so difficult." Four other lawsuits against the US Navy for crash damage are pending.[12]

Investigation[edit]

On March 3, 2009, an investigation by the Marine Corps concluded that the accident was preventable. The report was generally scathing in its criticism of the conduct of the participants including: the pilot, the commander of the squadron involved, its top maintenance officer, operations officer, and operations duty officer, all of whom were relieved of duty as a result of the investigation. Nine other Marines have received other disciplinary action.[2]

From the report, it appeared that the jet in question had a known track record of trouble in its left engine for several months. Maintenance was deferred after mechanics detected problems in the fuel flow system, a practice that was allowed at the time under established maintenance rules and procedures (since altered to forbid this practice); the aircraft had flown 146 times since the problem was identified. When the right engine was shut down due to low oil-pressure, the left engine did not receive enough fuel for flight, leading to the crash.[23] Forty similar aircraft throughout the fleet have been grounded to investigate similar fuel issues.

Following the pilot's report of the failure of the jet's right engine, controllers aboard the Abraham Lincoln, as well as a civilian air traffic controller, directed the pilot to land at NAS North Island – the closest divert field. Squadron officials, however, ordered the pilot to land at MCAS Miramar after a brief discussion, which the investigation deemed "collectively bad decision-making by the duty officer, by the operations officer and by the squadron's commanding officer." The pilot also failed to consult his emergency procedures checklist during the emergency, as well as unnecessarily lengthening his approach to Miramar by making a 270-degree left turn after bypassing North Island, rather than a shorter 90-degree right turn.[9][27] Specifically, the report criticized Neubauer for not questioning the order to divert to Miramar more forcefully, which he had briefly questioned. The squadron operations officials had underestimated the urgency of the situation, and placed undue emphasis on returning the pilot to his home field, having in mind the pilot's familiarity with that base, the longer runway, and better repair resources.[9][28]

Despite criticism, Neubauer was returned to a probationary flight status and allowed to resume training in late April 2009, in a decision made by Lieutenant General George J. Trautman, III, the Deputy Commandant for Aviation.[29] It is an aviation maxim that the pilot in command has the final word in the operation of his aircraft. It is another maxim that in an emergency situation, and losing one of two engines IS an emergency, the aircraft shall be landed at the nearest suitable airfield, in this case NAS North Island. The pilot has final responsibility for the operation of his aircraft. It's Lt. Neubauer's failure to land at the nearest suitable airfield that is the primary cause of this accident. He is the one responsible and if he were a civilian he would have lost his pilot certificate and been charged most likely with criminal negligence.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b "Korean Widower Doesn't Blame Pilot for F-18 Crash". Associated Press (Fox News Channel). December 10, 2008. Archived from the original on 6 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  2. ^ a b c "Marines sack 4 over deadly California plane crash". CNN.com (CNN). March 3, 2009. Archived from the original on 3 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-04. 
  3. ^ a b c Steve, Liewer; Martinez, Angelica & Baker, Debbi (December 8, 2008). "Three dead as military jet crashes into University City neighborhood". SignOnSanDiego.com (The San Diego Union-Tribune). Archived from the original on 27 February 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  4. ^ Hersham, Surrey (February–March 2009). "Recent Casualties". Combat Aircraft (UK: Ian Allan Publishing) 10 (1): 20. 
  5. ^ "3 Dead, 1 Missing After F/A-18 Crashes Into Neighborhood". KGTV. December 8, 2008. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  6. ^ Marosi, Richard; Perry, Tony (December 9, 2008). "F/A-18 military jet slams into San Diego neighborhood". Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). Archived from the original on 20 February 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  7. ^ "F-18 crashes in California". MarinesTV. United States Marine Corps. December 8, 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  8. ^ Steve Liewer & Rick Rogers (March 5, 2009). "Marines To Overhaul Repair, Air-Safety Rules". The San Diego Union-Tribune. p. 1.  Missing |last1= in Authors list (help);
  9. ^ a b c d e f g h Liewer, Steve (March 25, 2009). "Pilot's statement points to confusion". SignOnSanDiego.com (The San Diego Union-Tribune). Archived from the original on 28 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  10. ^ a b c Marosi, Richard; Perry, Tony (December 10, 2008). "San Diego man mourns loss of family, forgives Marine pilot in jet crash". Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). Archived from the original on 16 February 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  11. ^ Spagat, Elliot (December 10, 2008). "Rep. seeks F/A-18 records following crash". Associated Press (Army Times Publishing Company). Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  12. ^ a b c Kovach, Gretel C., "Five Lawsuits Pending In University City Crash", San Diego Union-Tribune, 30 December 2011.
  13. ^ J. Lynn Lunsford & Yochi Dreazen (December 9, 2008). "Military Jet Crashes In San Diego". Wall Street Journal (Dow Jones & Company). p. 3. 
  14. ^ Rogers, Rick (December 13, 2008). "Marines Defend Protocol For Flights". The San Diego Union-Tribune. pp. B1. Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  15. ^ Spagat, Elliot (December 9, 2008). "Records sought on jet type that killed 4 in crash". Associated Press. USA Today. Retrieved 2014-06-01. 
  16. ^ "Three dead in San Diego jet crash". BBC. 2008-12-08. Archived from the original on 10 December 2008. Retrieved 2008-12-10. 
  17. ^ Spagat, Elliot (2008-12-10). "Widower overwhelmed after F-18 crash kills his family". Associated Press. Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on 18 December 2008. Retrieved 2008-12-10. 
  18. ^ Gao, Helen, "Two Families Who Lost Their Homes In Jet Crash Trying To Rebuild Lives", San Diego Union-Tribune, January 31, 2009.
  19. ^ Phan, Hieu Tran; Steve Liewer & Rick Rogers (December 14, 2008). "Crash Renews Calls For Base To Be Vacated". SignOnSanDiego.com (The San Diego Union-Tribune). Retrieved 2009-04-03. 
  20. ^ Rogers, Rick, "Marines Defend Protocol For Flights", San Diego Union-Tribune, December 13, 2008.
  21. ^ Jung, Sung-ki, "USFK Pays Respect to Korean Victims", Korea Times, December 17, 2008, p. 22.
  22. ^ a b Kovach, Gretel C., "U.S., Boeing Sued Over Miramar Jet Crash", San Diego Union-Tribune, July 29, 2010.
  23. ^ a b Liewer, Steve; Rogers, Rick (March 4, 2009). "A chain of wrong decisions". The San Diego Union-Tribune (Copley Press). Retrieved 2009-03-05. 
  24. ^ Watson, Julie, "Family sues over F/A-18 crash that killed 4", Associated Press/Military Times, 12 December 2011.
  25. ^ Watson, Julie, Associated Press, "Gov't to pay family $17.8M for military jet crash", Stars and Stripes, 28 December 2011.
  26. ^ Moran, Greg, "Government Appeals $17.8 Million Jet-Crash Award", U-T San Diego, 7 March 2012, p. B2.
  27. ^ Perry, Tony (March 4, 2009). "Poor maintenance, critical errors caused jet crash, report says". Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). Archived from the original on 28 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-05. 
  28. ^ Blood, Michael R. (March 24, 2009). "Documents: F/A-18 pilot horrified jet hit home". Marine Corps Times (Army Times Publishing Company). Retrieved 2009-03-25. 
  29. ^ Perry, Tom (April 22, 2009). "Marine pilot in San Diego jet crash will fly again". Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). Archived from the original on 25 April 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-23.