ManagerGary Johnson signed seven players before the close of the summer transfer window. The season started with victory away at Millwall but the club then slipped into the relegation zone and only briefly escaping the relegation zone in September. Yeovil remained in the relegation zone from October until the end of the season. The signing of Ishmael Miller on loan briefly improved their survival chances helping the club to record a four-match unbeaten run in November and December followed by a five-match run in February and March but in the end Yeovil were relegated with a game to spare.
On 6 July, prior to Yeovil's first pre-season friendly against Poole Town, the club confirmed they had agreed terms with Dorchester Town for the transfer of Kieffer Moore for an "undisclosed fee". Four more trialists joined the side for the friendly, former Brighton & Hove Albion full back Marcos Painter, former Reading centre-back Angus MacDonald, former Crystal Palace defender Aaron Akuruka and midfielder Junior Konadu-Yiadom. Yeovil won the friendly 3–1 with goals form Kieffer Moore, James Hayter and Joe Edwards. The following week saw a further rotation of trialists with Ferry, Nyatanga and Painter departing and Zimbabwean international left-sided player Onismor Bhasera joining the club on trial. 10 July saw the club confirm three signings firstly the former England U20 striker Michael Ngoo on loan from Liverpool until the end of the 2013–14 season, secondly the confirmation of the signing of Dorchester Town striker Kieffer Moore on a two-year contract, and midfielder Billy Clifford on a six-month loan from Chelsea. That evening the Glovers played local rivals Weymouth a "behind closed doors" friendly match, Yeovil won the match 7–0 with a newly signed loanee Michael Ngoo scoring a first half hat-trick, before Kieffer Moore scored a second half hat-trick from Kieffer Moore with trialist Junior Konadu-Yiadom rounding off the scoring.
On 12 July, the club embarked short pre-season bonding trip to southern Portugal, with the club confirming only one trialist was present on the trip former Northampton defender Seth Nana Twumasi. The following day the club played an unofficial friendly match against Portuguese Segunda Liga side SC Farense, taking place at the Browns Leisure Complex in Quarteira where the Glovers had been training. Yeovil lost the friendly 2–0 and had to play part of the second half with 10-men following the sending off of Chelsea loanee Billy Clifford for a second bookable offence. Yeovil returned home to play Torquay United in a friendly, on 16 July, where their squad included former Southampton defender Danny Seaborne. Despite dominating the game in terms of possession and chances two late Torquay goals condemned the Glovers to a second consecutive 2–0 defeat. A third consecutive defeat without scoring followed with a 5–0 defeat against Premier League side Swansea City in the club's first home friendly. After the game the club confirmed the signing of former Southampton defender Seaborne on a two-year contract. On 23 July, Yeovil confirmed the signing of Swansea City defender Alan Tate on loan until 2 January 2014, the club made the announcement of the signing by producing a mocked-up picture of an easel outside Huish Park following the arrival of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge's son the day before. Tate made his debut that evening in a 2–1 friendly victory over Exeter City courtesy of goals from Ed Upson and Paddy Madden. The players who didn't feature prominently in the club's final home friendly played a Bristol City U21 side, on 25 July. The Yeovil XI won the match 3–1 thanks to a brace from Sam Hoskins and a goal from Liverpool loanee Michael Ngoo. Yeovil then travelled to Home Park to play Plymouth Argyle on 27 July, Yeovil's side featured a new trialist in the shape of former Port Vale midfielder Ryan Burge. The Glovers won the match 2–1 with first half goals from Madden and Hayter. Yeovil's final game of pre-season was a trip to The New Lawn to play Forest Green Rovers. A weakened Yeovil side featuring three new trialists, Swansea City full back Curtis Obeng, former Oxford United left sided players Liam Davis and midfielder Ben Long, won the match 5–3 with two goals from Michael Ngoo, a goal each from Sam Hoskins and trialists Ryan Burge and an own goal. Yeovil's pre-season preparation featured nine matches in all with six victories and three defeats Yeovil scoring 22 goals and conceding 16. The following day the club announced the signing of Liam Davis on a two-year contract, and at the club's photocall confirmed that Nathan Ralph and Lewis Young both agreed new short term deals with the club as well as former Northampton Town defender Seth Nana Twumasi.
Yeovil's Championship season started with a trip to The Den to face Millwall, on 3 August. Yeovil won the match 1–0 thanks to a late goal from midfielder Ed Upson. On 6 August, Yeovil travelled to Southend to face Southend United in a Football League Cup first round tie, a first half goal from Kevin Dawson was enough for Yeovil to record a 1–0 victory and progress to the second round. The draw for the second round of the League Cup took place, on 8 August, and presented Yeovil with a home tie against Championship rivals Birmingham City. Yeovil then faced Birmingham City in their first home match in the Championship, the game started badly with goalkeeper Marek Štěch breaking his hand in two places after just eight minutes, Yeovil lost the match 1–0 through an unfortunate own-goal from centre back Danny Seaborne. After the match it was confirmed that striker Paddy Madden had been called up to the Republic of Ireland national team squad for the first time for their friendly against Wales. On 12 August, it was announced that Welsh international goalkeeper Wayne Hennessey had been lined up to join the club on loan from Wolverhampton Wanderers for an initial month, following the injury to Štěch, but this loan was scrapped after Hennessey suffered an injury setback while on international duty. On 14 August, striker Paddy Madden made his international debut as a 69th minute substitute in the Republic of Ireland's 0–0 draw against Wales. On 16 August, Yeovil signed Cardiff City midfielder Joe Ralls on loan until January 2014. Prior to Yeovil's match with Burnley, the club confirmed the signings of Manchester United goalkeeper Sam Johnstone on a three-month loan deal, replacing the injured Wayne Hennessey, and former Northampton Town goalkeeper Chris Dunn on a one year contract as further goalkeeper cover. Yeovil lost the first competitive meeting of the two sides 2–0 after second half goals from Keith Treacy and Sam Vokes. On 19 August, Yeovil's fringe players faced their Exeter City counterparts in a friendly which Yeovil won 3–2 thanks to a brace from Kieffer Moore and a goal from Michael Ngoo. The following day the club confirmed that new goalkeeper Sam Johnstone had suffered a finger injury prior to the match against Burnley and would be returning to Manchester United. The following day the club confirmed that Wolves keeper Wayne Hennessey would be rejoining the club on loan for an initial month. On 22 August, Yeovil confirmed that versatile midfielder/full-back Joe Edwards had signed a one year contract extension to keep him at the club until the summer of 2015. The next day the club confirmed that former striker Andy Williams had re-signed for the club on a season long loan from Swindon Town. On 24 August, Yeovil lost their third consecutive match a 3–0 home defeat at the hands of Derby County. Following the match it was confirmed that Chelsea midfielder Billy Clifford had returned to his parent club prematurely, having featured only once during his loan spell.
Yeovil faced Birmingham City in their League Cup second round tie, on 27 August. With Birmingham leading 2–1 going into injury time at the end of normal time, Byron Webster made it 2–2 to send the tie into extra-time when he controversially chipped into an empty net after Birmingham goalkeeper Colin Doyle had kicked the ball out following an injury to Dan Burn. Yeovil initially refused to allow Birmingham to walk-in an equaliser, with the game in extra time defender Luke Ayling scored his first goal for Yeovil after 145 appearances to make it 3–2 to Yeovil in extra time with a left-footed drive. Then at the start of the second period of extra-time Lee Novak was allowed to score an unopposed equaliser after manager Gary Johnson decided Webster's goal had been "ungentlemanly". Yeovil eventually lost the game 3–2 on penalties. Prior to Yeovil's match with Reading it was confirmed that Irish striker Paddy Madden had suffered a knee injury and would be out for four weeks, and midfielder Lewis Young would be released from his short term contract. Yeovil's first League meeting with Reading resulted in a fourth consecutive league defeat after a controversial penalty from Reading striker Adam le Fondre handed Yeovil a 1–0 defeat to leave the Glovers in the relegation zone of the Championship.
The new month saw Yeovil face Leicester City at home and lost the match 2–1 but grabbed their first home league goal of the season through a James Hayter penalty. On 5 October, Yeovil travelled to the Riverside Stadium to face Middlesbrough, despite taking an early lead through Liam Davis Yeovil lost the match 4–1. A strong Yeovil reserves side faced Radstock Town in the Somerset Premier Cup, Yeovil won the game 8–0 with a first half hat trick from Paddy Madden. On 9 October, the club confirmed that Liverpool loanee Michael Ngoo his loan had been cancelled by mutual consent after dropping down the pecking order with Yeovil and returned to his parent club. On 15 October, Yeovil played local side Wincanton Town to formally switch on the club's new floodlights. The Glovers won the friendly 8–0. Scottish under-21 midfielder Fraser Fyvie arrived on loan from Wigan Athletic on loan until 1 January. Yeovil returned to Championship action, on 19 October, with a home match against Brighton & Hove Albion and picked up their first home point of the season with a 0–0 draw. New loan player Fyvie's debut only lasted 22 minutes after suffering a "grade two shoulder injury" keeping him out of action for around a month. In midweek Yeovil faced Conference South side Dorchester Town, Yeovil beating the Dorset club 6–0 in a friendly. On 25 October, the club announced that Wolves keeper Hennessey had extended his loan for a final month until 17 November. The following day Yeovil faced high flying Nottingham Forest at Huish Park. An eighth minute opener from Ed Upson set Yeovil on their way before Forest's Simon Cox had a penalty saved by Wayne Hennessey. Upson completed his brace with a goal from 25 yards, and although Forest immediately replied through Nathaniel Chalobah, Yeovil extended their lead just before half time when Byron Webster headed in from an Upson corner. Yeovil held on to win their first home league game of the season. On 31 October, the club announced the extension of Everton defender Shane Duffy's loan by a further month.
Yeovil travelled to Elland Road to face Leeds United on 2 November. A second half brace from Scottish forward Ross McCormack saw Yeovil lose the game 2–0 to slip to the foot of the Championship table. Following the game the club confirmed that striker Andy Williams had suffered a serious knee injury in training ruling him out for the rest of the season. Williams returned to parent club Swindon Town for treatment but officially remained on loan at Yeovil for the remainder of the season, with Yeovil still having to pay a portion of his wages. On 5 November, Yeovil faced Conference South side Weston-super-Mare in the second round of the Somerset Premier Cup, Yeovil won the match 4–1 but saw defender Luke Ayling sent off after being involved in a twenty man brawl. Ayling being suspended for three non-first team matches for his violent conduct. On 10 November, Yeovil played Wigan Athletic and for the fourth time this season suffered a 1–0 home defeat. The game marked the final match of Wayne Hennessey's loan spell, and with the club confirming that first choice keeper Marek Štěch would be out for a further month with his hand injury Stuart Taylor arrived on a month loan from Reading. During the international break Yeovil faced the Latvian national team in a friendly at Huish Park on 18 November, Taylor made his non-competitive debut in this game. A 75th minute goal from Valērijs Šabala was enough to earn Latvia a 1–0 victory. On 20 November, the club confirmed that just two days after joining the club goalkeeper Stuart Taylor was returning to Reading for "personal reasons". Yeovil traveled to Doncaster Rovers, on 22 November, with Chris Dunn making his debut in goal. Yeovil conceded early on but courtesy of a goal from former Doncaster player Byron Webster the game was level with ten minutes to go when Doncater were reduced to ten men with sending off of midfielder Dean Furman. Despite this Yeovil lost the match 2–1 after conceding a late goal. On 26 November, last season's top goalscorer Paddy Madden was placed on the transfer list by the club. The loan transfer deadline day on 28 November, saw Yeovil sign three players on month long loan deals, Everton midfielder John Lundstram, Nottingham Forest forward Ishmael Miller and Liverpool forward Adam Morgan whose loan is set to be made permanent in the new year, while defender Danny Seaborne joined League One side Coventry City on loan until January. On 30 November, Yeovil traveled to Watford with all three loan signings making their debuts. Yeovil won the match 3–0 courtesy of goals from Byron Webster, Joe Edwards and Ishmael Miller with a goal on his debut. Following the game the club confirmed that Everton defender Shane Duffy had extended his loan for a third and final month until 27 December.
On 3 December, Yeovil faced Blackpool and courtesy of a first half goal from John Lundstram to secure their second consecutive win, the match ended with Blackpool having three players sent off after the 90th minute. Yeovil continued their unbeaten run against Charlton Athletic, on 7 December, after coming from 2–0 behind at half time to draw the match 2–2 thanks to an own goal from Michael Morrison and an Ishmael Miller penalty. The next day saw Yeovil draw League One side Leyton Orient at home in the FA Cup third round. On 14 December, Yeovil faced Barnsley and extended their unbeaten run to four matches with a 1–1 draw after an early Joel Grant goal. After making only two appearances in the first two months of his loan midfielder Fraser Fyvie's return to parent club Wigan Athletic was confirmed on 16 December. On 19 December, the club confirmed that the short term contracts of defenders Joe Jones and Seth Nana Twumasi had been extended until the end of the season. Two days later Yeovil faced Blackburn Rovers and fell to a 1–0 defeat courtesy of a Jordan Rhodes goal. Former youth-team goalkeeper Matthew Cafer was released on 23 December, to join Southern Premier League side Weymouth. Boxing Day saw Yeovil travel to Bournemouth for the second consecutive season and fell to a repeat of their 2012 defeat losing 3–0 conceding three second half goals. After the Bournemouth match Yeovil confirmed that Everton defender Shane Duffy would be returning to the club on loan until the end of the season from the 1 January. On 28 December, despite Ishmael Miller giving Yeovil an early lead with his third goal of his loan spell Yeovil fell to a 5–1 defeat at Huddersfield Town.
A second trip to the East Midlands in a week saw Yeovil take on Nottingham Forest, on 2 February. Forest took the lead courtesy of a Byron Webster own goal before Kieffer Moore equalised for Yeovil, but goals from Simon Cox and Rafik Djebbour saw Yeovil fall to a 3–1 defeat. February then saw a run of four consecutive home matches for Yeovil, the first of these games was against Leeds United live on Sky Sports, on 8 February. Forest loanee Ishmael Miller headed Yeovil into the lead but he failed to extend Yeovil's advantage when he missed a penalty just before half time. The miss was punished almost immediately after the break with Ross McCormack scoring from long range before Stephen Warnock scored a wind-assisted long range free kick. The second home game saw Yeovil take on fellow strugglers Millwall, on 11 March, Joe Ralls second goal of the season volleyed in to give Yeovil a second half lead but a Steve Morison equaliser meant more points dropped from a winning position. On 18 February, Yeovil confirmed the signing of Spanish former FC Honka midfielder Rubén Palazuelos until the end of the season. The same day the club announced a loss of £454,000 for the year ending June 2013, and that evening Yeovil and Watford played out a 0–0 draw. On 20 February, Yeovil announced the signing of Huddersfield Town winger Duane Holmes on loan until the 23 March. Holmes made his debut against Doncaster Rovers, on 22 February, and was fouled for a penalty which James Hayter converted to give Yeovil their first home league win since November.
Kieffer Moore scored twice in two matches to take his tally for the season to five.
The 1 March, saw Yeovil travel to Reading. A headed goal from on loan defender Shane Duffy saw Yeovil take a first-half lead, before having Byron Webster sent off and conceding a penalty in the 66th minute. Despite Marek Štěch saving Adam le Fondre's penalty Reading equalised through a John Lundstram own goal from the resulting corner, just two minutes later Yeovil were reduced to nine men with Joe Ralls receiving a straight red card. Remarkably in the 88th minute Yeovil were reduced to eight men with Kieffer Moore being sent off for a second bookable offence, despite this Yeovil managed to hold out for a 1–1 draw. Following the match Yeovil successfully appealed the first of the three red cards shown to centre back Webster. On 7 March, midfielder Sam Foley joined League One side Shrewsbury Town on an initial month loan while defender Joe Jones had his loan at Woking extended for a further month. The following day a brace from on loan Ishmael Miller saw Yeovil beat Sheffield Wednesday 2–0 and extend their unbeaten run to five matches. On 10 March, after struggling for game time John Lundstram was recalled by Everton after his four-month stay. That week saw two consecutive defeats for Yeovil, first a 1–0 reverse at home against Ipswich Town, before a 3–0 defeat away at Queens Park Rangers on 15 March. Following the QPR match it was confirmed Huddersfield midfielder Duane Holmes's loan would be cut short with Yeovil sending the American back a week early. On 18 March, Yeovil traveled to Wigan Athletic who were on the back of an eight match winning run. After Štěch had saved a first half Jordi Gómez penalty Wigan took the lead through Nick Powell early in the second half. There then followed five goals in the final eight minutes, as Ishmael Miller struck twice to put Yeovil in front but they were immediately pegged back James McArthur equalised and a Byron Webster own goal put Wigan ahead but Luke Ayling bundled in a last-minute equaliser to level the game at 3–3. The following Saturday Yeovil faced Bolton Wanderers and despite Miller, with his 10th goal of the season, and Kevin Dawson giving Yeovil a half time lead. They were pegged back to 2–1 immediately after the break and a Miller missed penalty in the 80th minute proved costly as 10 man Bolton salvaged a point. After the match the club confirmed the signing of former Dorchester Town defender Calvin Brooks on non-contract terms until the end of the season, who was then immediately loaned out on a dual-registration deal to Western League Division One side Wincanton Town until the end of the season. On 25 March, Yeovil traveled to leaders Leicester City and led through a Joe Ralls free-kick until the final minute with a last minute Chris Wood goal depriving Yeovil of three points. The following Saturday saw Yeovil face relegation rivals Barnsley but suffered a damaging 4–1 defeat leaving Yeovil bottom of the table.
Before their match with Blackpool on 5 April, manager Gary Johnson confirmed that Nottingham Forest striker and Yeovil top scorer Ishmael Miller had left the club after walking out of a team meeting. Despite this Yeovil managed to record their first win in six matches with a 2–1 victory over fellow strugglers Blackpool thanks to goals from James Hayter and Tom Lawrence. Yeovil then traveled to Charlton Athletic, Astrit Ajdarevic fired in an early opener from outside the penalty area but Joel Grant quickly equalised but two goals in the first five minutes of the second half saw Charlton take a 3–1 lead and despite Kieffer Moore reducing the deficit Charlton held out. The defeat left Yeovil six points from safety with just five matches remaining. A second consecutive goal from Kieffer Moore helped end Bournemouth's five match winning run but a fortuitous Ryan Fraser goal held Yeovil to a 1–1 draw. On 16 April, the club announced that midfielder Sam Foley had been recalled from his loan at Shrewsbury Town. A goalless draw away at play-off chasing Blackburn Rovers on 18 April, followed by a 2–1 defeat at home to Huddersfield Town left Yeovil on the verge of relegation six points adrift and a far inferior goal difference with just two matches remaining, and the club's first relegation for 19 years was confirmed on 25 April with a 2–0 defeat away at Brighton. Yeovil ended their first Championship season, on 3 May, with a 4–1 home defeat against Middlesbrough.
Yeovil occupied a relegation position for the majority of the season and from October until the end of the season. The team won 4 matches, drew 6 and lost 13 at home, compared to winning 4, drawing 7 and losing 12 away from home. Joe Edwards was an everpresent recording the highest number of appearances during the season, appearing in all 50 of Yeovil's matches. Nottingham Forest loanee Ishmael Miller was top scorer in all competitions with 10 goals, followed by James Hayter with 8 goals.
The club's manager Gary Johnson, and Yeovil's backroom staff remained the same for the 2013–14 season, with Terry Skiverton as his assistant, former player Darren Way continuing as first team coach, Gareth Stewart as goalkeeping coach and Mike Micciche as physiotherapist after they all signed new two-year contracts in late May 2013. The only addition was the reappointment of former physiopherapist Simon Baker to assist Micciche. Yeovil's new home kit was first introduced prior to the 2013 Football League One play-off Final and is designed by Vandanel's sister company Sondico, with the design now boasting white sleeves and an entirely white back. For Yeovil's first two away matches of the season the club played in their new home kit whilst wearing green shorts, before on 23 August the club finally announced a new away kit with the same design as the home shirt but with the fluorescent yellow and black hoops on the front with the back being plain black with gold piping.
Source: BBC Sport
Rules for classification: 1) points; 2) goal difference; 3) number of goals scored (C) = Champion; (R) = Relegated; (P) = Promoted; (E) = Eliminated; (O) = Play-off winner; (A) = Advances to a further round.