Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri
|Ali Saleh Kahlah Al Marri|
|Criminal status||Incarceration: Naval brig at Charleston, SC
Federal Correctional Institution, Pekin
US Penitentiary, Florence, Supermax (starting March 2010)
|Conviction(s)||plea bargain - pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to provide material support to a foreign terrorist organization|
Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri (Arabic: علي صالح كحلة المري ) (b. 1966/1967) is a citizen of Qatar who is serving a 15-year sentence in a United States federal prison, with credit for the nearly eight years he was held in detention without charges. He pleaded guilty to one count in a plea bargain after his case was transferred in 2009 to the federal court system.
Al-Marri was a graduate student at Bradley University and a legal resident of the United States when arrested in December 2001 in Illinois by the federal government. Two years later he was indicted on charges of credit card fraud but in 2003, he was classified as an enemy combatant and transferred to military custody. He was detained for six years at the Naval Consolidated Brig at Charleston, South Carolina in solitary confinement. He is the only non-citizen known to have been held as an enemy combatant within the continental United States since the September 11 attacks.
In Al-Marri v. Wright (2008), the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals determined that, as a legal resident arrested in the United States, he was entitled to contest his detention in federal court. It ruled that he needed to be charged and tried, or released. The Supreme Court agreed to certiorari.
After a change in administrations, in 2009 the government transferred al-Marri's case to the Department of Justice and the federal civilian court system, making it moot at the Supreme Court. In a plea agreement, al-Marri pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to provide material support to a foreign terrorist organization on April 30, 2009.
Early life and education
Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri was born in Qatar in 1966/1967, as estimated by the United States government. He came to the United States to go to graduate school and was a legal resident. He attended Bradley University, a small private college in Illinois.
The Peoria Journal Star reports that al-Marri's initial arrest in December 2001 was at a routine traffic stop in Peoria, Illinois. He was held by federal authorities in civilian jails in Peoria and New York City as a material witness. FBI agent Ali Soufan's questioning of Mohammed al Qahtani led to the terrorism charges against al-Marri, as al Qahtani identified him as a relative.
In 2002, the government charged Al-Marri with making false statements to the FBI and to financial institutions, identity fraud, and credit card fraud. He was alleged to be in possession of more than 1750 credit card numbers, along with the names of the account holders, none of whom was his. He was also alleged to be in possession of falsified identification documents. Additionally, he was alleged to have used a telephone card to call a number in Dubai linked to Mustafa al-Hawsawi, a reputed al-Qaeda financier.
After searching al-Marri's computer, federal agents said they found folders labeled "jihad arena" and "chem," which (according to the government) contained information on hydrogen cyanide. This is a poisonous gas produced in large quantities in the U.S. and is among chemical warfare agents that cause general poisoning. They also reportedly found lectures by Osama bin Laden, and links to Web sites related to weaponry and satellite equipment.
After the Bush administration classified al-Marri as an "enemy combatant" in 2003, it dropped those federal charges and transferred him to military custody at Naval Consolidated Brig, in Charleston, South Carolina. He had been arrested while a legal resident of the United States.
Following the US Supreme Court decision in Rasul v. Bush (2004), which said that detainees had the right to challenge their detention, Al-Marri was allowed access to legal counsel in October 2004. His lawyers reported that al-Marri has described being subjected to extreme cold, with insufficient bedding and clothing. He has been deprived of all reading material except a Qur'an. His guards reportedly decline to inform him of which direction is East, which he needs for prayers. His cell's window is translucent (rather than transparent), and he has no clock, so he cannot know the proper times to say prayers. He reports having been deprived of personal hygiene items. The lack of such items have caused him to be unable to pray, because of ritual impurity.
In October 2008, the military released 91 pages of memos drafted in 2002 by officers at the Naval Consolidated Brig, Charleston, which showed that they had been concerned for the sanity of Al-Marri and other detainees confined to solitary. The memos indicate that officers were concerned that the mental states of the detainees Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri, Yasser Hamdi and José Padilla due to their isolation and lack of stimuli.
On November 13, 2006, the United States Department of Justice asserted in a six-page motion with the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit that, according to the Military Commissions Act of 2006, al-Marri should be tried in a military tribunal as an enemy combatant rather than in a civilian court. It said that the Military Commissions Act of 2006 removed federal court jurisdiction for habeas corpus or any other actions related to aliens determined by the US to be "enemy combatants."
After a long legal battle, the federal government released the previously classified justification for Al Marri's detention as an enemy combatant. On September 9, 2004, Jeffrey N. Rapp, Director of the Joint Intelligence Task Force for Combating Terrorism, had submitted a 16-page sworn statement containing many allegations against Al Marri, including:
- Al Marri was to hack into the US banking system, and "to wipe out balances and otherwise wreak havoc with banking records in order to damage the U.S. economy."
- Investigator had found information about hydrogen cyanide on Al Marri's laptop... "The highly technical information found on al-Marri's laptop computer far exceeds the interests of a merely curious individual."
On June 11, 2007, in al-Marri v. Wright, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Military Commissions Act of 2006 cannot deny al-Marri his constitutional rights to challenge his accusers and reason for detention. The court ruled that al-Marri must be released from military detention to either be freed or to be placed in US civilian detention, when the federal government would have to charge him with crimes and provide a trial.
The court held an en banc rehearing of the ruling on October 31, 2007. In its decision issued on July 15, 2008, the Court voted 5-4 that if the Government's allegations are true, al-Marri can be held in military detention indefinitely as an enemy combatant. But, they determined that he has not received sufficient due process to determine if these allegations are in fact true. The case is allowed to return to trial court but no particular proceedings have been specified.
On 9 November 2008, Jerry Markon, writing in the Washington Post, reported that al-Marri's lawyers had petitioned the United States Supreme Court to overturn the lower court ruling that allowed him to be treated as an enemy combatant in spite of being a legal resident of the USA. On December 5, 2008, the Supreme Court agreed to hear al-Marri's case.
On January 22, 2009, newly elected President Barack Obama issued a memorandum requiring that al-Marri's status be reviewed by his administration, in addition to those of detainees currently held at Guantanamo Bay.
New York Times editorials
The New York Times outlined the case of Ali al-Marri in an editorial on 24 November 2008, titled "Indefinite Detention". It criticized the George W. Bush administration's enemy combatant doctrine, and called on the Supreme Court justices to
"make clear that a president cannot trample on individual rights by imprisoning people indefinitely simply by asserting that they are tied to terrorism."
In an editorial of 8 December 2008, titled "Tortured Justice", the Times editorial board wrote:
"The extent of the damage to American liberties, and how lasting it will be, will be told in part by the outcome of two cases [Ali al-Marri's "enemy combatant" and Maher Arar's "extraordinary rendition"] that are to be heard by the federal courts." They said the Obama administration would have to decide "whether to defend the indefensible when the case comes to trial".
Following this review, the government transferred Al-Marri's case from military custody to the federal court system and went to trial. In a 2009 plea bargain, Al Marri pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to support a terrorist group. He was sentenced to 15 years in prison. He had already served eight years, much of it in solitary confinement.
On February 27, 2009, Attorney General Eric Holder announced that a federal grand jury in the Central District of Illinois had returned a two-count indictment charging Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri, 43, with providing material support to al-Qaeda and conspiring with others to provide material support to al-Qaeda. He said that the Office of the Solicitor General would move to dismiss al-Marri’s pending litigation before the U.S. Supreme Court, and that al-Marri would be transferred to Department of Justice custody for criminal prosecution as soon as the Supreme Court rules on that motion. On March 6, 2009 the U.S. Supreme court dismissed the application, remanded to the Fourth Circuit, and instructed the Fourth Circuit to dismiss the appeal as moot. In March 2009, al-Marri made his first appearance before a judge in Charleston, S.C. After denying al-Marri's request for bail, the South Carolina judge ordered his transportation to Illinois. Al-Marri pleaded not guilty before Judge Michael Mihm in a U.S. District Court of Illinois. Judge Mihm set the date of the trial for May 26. Mihm also ordered the prosecution to hand over evidence, such as a copy of al-Marri's hard drive, to the defense attorneys.
Al-Marri was transported afterward back to the Peoria federal court by the marshals and appeared before Mihm. He indicated to Mihm he understood the charges against him. In March 2009, Al Marri was returned to civilian custody in Peoria, from military custody.
On April 30, 2009 al-Marri entered a plea of guilty to one count of conspiracy to provide material support or resources to a foreign terrorist organization. He agreed in his plea that he attended terrorist training camps between 1998 and 2001, where he studied weapons and operational security. He met with Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and "offered his services" to aid al-Qaeda. Mohammed told him to travel to the United States by September 20, 2001 and wait for further instructions. Al-Marri said that while enrolled at Bradley University, he researched cyanide on the Internet and continued communicating with al-Qaeda.
On October 29, 2009, Al-Marri was sentenced to 8 years in prison, in consideration of the nearly eight years he had already been held. In March 2010, he was moved from Federal Correctional Institution, Pekin to the US Penitentiary, Florence Supermax security in Colorado. His projected release date is January 18, 2015.
On October 12, 2011, Tony Bartelme, writing in the Charleston Post and Courier reported on documents the paper had recently received from an 8-year-old Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request about the use of the consolidated Navy brig in Charleston in the "war on terror". Among those documents was a 2005 exchange of memos between the prison's commander, E.P. Giambastiani, to Charles Stimson, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Detainee Affairs. In the memos, Giambastiani requested that al-Marri, Hamdy and Padilla be transferred to Guantanamo.
According to Bartelme:
"Logbooks and other information obtained by al-Marri's Charleston attorney, Andy Savage, revealed that Defense Department and CIA agents interrogated al-Marri for months, at one point wrapping his head in duct tape and stuffing his mouth, a tactic Savage called dry-boarding."
This information was considered significant to the cases of the Guantanamo Bay homicide accusations, as there were reports in 2009 and 2010 that the three reported suicides in 2006 had been found with rags stuffed down their throats.
- Al-Marri v. Wright (2008)
- Jarallah al-Marri, his brother, former detainee at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Cuba.
- Yaser Esam Hamdi, former U.S. citizen who was held as an enemy combatant in the Continental U.S. See Supreme Court ruling Hamdi v. Rumsfeld (2004)
- Schwartz, John (October 29, 2009). "Admitted Qaeda Agent Receives Prison Sentence", New York Times
- "Al Qaeda Sleeper Agent Pleads Guilty to Terror Charges". Fox News. 2009-04-30. Archived from the original on 3 May 2009. Retrieved 2009-05-01.
- Another 'Enemy Combatant', CBS, June 23, 2003
- "Former ‘Enemy Combatant’ Pleads Guilty in Ill.", The New York Times, 30 April 2009
- Mayer, Jane, The Dark Side: The Inside Story of How the War on Terror Turned Into a War on American Ideals, 2008. p. 191
- "Hydrogen Cyanide". Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons. Retrieved 2009-01-14.
- Ashcroft, John (2006), Never Again: Securing America and Restoring Justice. New York: Hachette Book Group, ISBN 978-1-59995-680-0, pp. 165-167.
- "Al Qaeda suspect declared 'enemy combatant'," CNN 24 June 2003.
- Tony Bartelme (2011-10-12). "Memos detail Navy brig struggle: Military brass were denied OK to move terror suspects from Hanahan". Post and Courier. Retrieved 2011-10-15. "In early 2005, the Navy's brig in Hanahan had become a small but unique cog in the Bush administration's anti-terrorism apparatus -- the only prison on U.S. soil that housed people the president deemed "enemy combatants."" mirror
- "Cruel Confinement of 'Enemy Combatant' in United States: Complaint Provides First Look at Isolation and Abuse", Human Rights Watch, August 8, 2005
- "Supreme Court won't hear terrorism case", USA Today, October 4, 2004
- "Habeas corpus petition", Ali Saleh Kahlah Al-Marri v. Donald H. Rumsfeld
- Carol Cratty (2008-10-08). "Military concerned for detainees' sanity, records show". CNN. Archived from the original on 14 October 2008. Retrieved 2008-10-08. mirror
- "Al Marri v. Wright" (PDF). Department of Justice. Archived from the original on 5 July 2007. Retrieved 2007-06-11.
- "DOJ asserts MCA bars enemy immigrants, Gitmo detainees from judicial review". The Jurist. November 14, 2006. Retrieved 2007-06-11.
- Diana Gribbon Motz. "Al Marri v. Wright" (PDF). United States Department of Justice. Retrieved 2007-12-13.
- "Feds release al-Marri documents: Declassified papers detail alleged al-Qaida links, orders", Peoria Journal Star, April 12, 2004
- "US 'cannot hold enemy combatant'". BBC. June 11, 2007. Archived from the original on 23 June 2007. Retrieved 2007-06-11.
- Robert Schmidt (2007-06-11). "Enemy Combatant Can't Be Held by Military, Court Says (Update2)". Bloomberg. Retrieved 2007-06-11.
- "Decision on Rehearing En Banc", United States Court Of Appeals For The Fourth Circuit
- Jerry Markon (2008-11-09). "High Court May Consider Legality of Detention". Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-11-09.
- "US Court reviews enemy combatant". BBC. 2008-12-05. Archived from the original on 7 December 2008. Retrieved 2008-12-07.
- "Review of the Detention of Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri". The White House. 2009-01-22. Retrieved 2008-08-23.
- Editorial (2008-11-24). "Indefinite Detention". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 10 December 2008. Retrieved 2008-11-26.
- Editorial (2008-12-08). "Tortured Justice". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 8 December 2008. Retrieved 2008-12-09.
- "Al-Marri Indictment Today [UPDATED]". The New Yorker. 2009-02-26. Archived from the original on 28 February 2009. Retrieved 2009-02-26.
- "Ali Al-Marri Indicted for Providing Material Support to Al-Qaeda". Department of Justice. 2009-02-27. Archived from the original on 1 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-01.
- "Al-Marri Detention Case Vacated (Press Release)". Brennan Center for Justice. 2009-03-06. Archived from the original on 13 April 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-11.
- "Accused 'Sleeper Agent' Pleads Not Guilty in U.S.". Reuters. 2009-03-23. Archived from the original on 26 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-11.
- "At long last, prisoner EC#2 will get his day in court". Peoria Journal Star. 2009-03-05. Archived from the original on 19 March 2009. Retrieved 2009-03-15. mirror
- Shane, Scott (April 8, 2010."Qatari Envoy Was to Meet Al Qaeda Figure in Jail", New York Times
- "Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri". Prisoner locator. Federal Bureau of Prisons.
- Al-Marri v. Pucciarelli, defense lawyers, Brennan Center for Justice, New York University
- Adam Liptak, "In War of Vague Borders, Detainee Longs for Court", New York Times, January 5, 2007
- The Hard Cases, The New Yorker, February 23, 2009, analyzing the case and how the Obama administration will respond.
- Matt Apuzzo, Associated Press,"US residents in military brigs? Govt says it's war", USA Today, May 24, 2008
- Discredited Yoo Memos Led to “Enemy Combatant” Detainment and Denial of Habeas Corpus, Brennan Center for Justice, April 8, 2008.
- 4th Circuit Opinion in Convenient Form
- Brother campaigns for 'enemy combatant', BBC News, 2009-01-24.
- "Justice to review al-Marri's case", Charleston Journal, 23 January 2009
- "Order to review case of ‘enemy combatant’", Gulf Times.
- Free Ali Almarri, website