American Airlines Flight 965
An American Airlines Boeing 757-223 identical to the one involved in the crash
|Date||December 20, 1995|
|Summary||pilot error, resulting in plane going off course and Controlled flight into terrain|
|Site||near Buga, Valle del Cauca, Colombia
|Survivors||4 (initially 5)|
|Aircraft type||Boeing 757-223|
|Flight origin||Miami International Airport|
|Destination||Alfonso Bonilla Aragón Int'l Airport|
American Airlines Flight 965 was a regularly scheduled flight from Miami International Airport in Miami, Florida, United States to Alfonso Bonilla Aragón International Airport in Cali, Colombia. On December 20, 1995, the Boeing 757-200 flying this route (N651AA) crashed into a mountain in Buga, Colombia, killing 159 passengers and eight crew members. The crash was the first U.S.-owned 757 accident and the highest death toll of any accident in Colombia. It is also the highest death toll of any accident involving a Boeing 757 at that time. It was surpassed by Birgenair Flight 301 which crashed in 1996 with 189 fatalities. Flight 965 was the deadliest air disaster involving a U.S. carrier since the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 in 1988. Five passengers survived the crash, all of whom were seated within two rows of each other, but one died two days later of his injuries.
At that time, Flight 965 mainly carried people returning to Colombia for the Christmas holiday, vacationers, and businesspeople. A winter storm in the northeast United States caused the airline to delay the departure of the airliner for thirty minutes to allow for connecting passengers to board the flight, so Flight 965 pushed back from gate D33 in Miami at 5:14 pm, and then taxied to runway 27R, but seasonal congestion caused the Boeing 757 to take off two hours late. Some other passengers booked on Flight 965 missed the flight due to missed connections.
The cockpit crew consisted of Captain Nicholas Tafuri, 57, and First Officer Donald Williams, 39. Both pilots were considered to be highly skilled airmen. Tafuri had more than 13,000 hours of flying experience and Williams had almost 6,000 hours. The cabin crew consisted of Purser Pedro Pablo Calle and Flight Attendants Magdalena Borrero, Rosa Cabrejo, Teresa Delgado, Gilberto Restrepo, and Margaret "Maggie" Villalobos.
Cali's air traffic controllers had no functional radar to monitor the 757, as it had been blown up in 1992 by leftist guerrilla group FARC. Cali's approach uses several radio beacons to guide pilots around the mountains and canyons that surround the city. The airplane's flight management system already had these beacons programmed in, and should have, in theory, told the pilots exactly where to turn, climb, and descend, all the way from Miami to the terminal in Cali.
Since the wind was calm, Cali's controllers asked the pilots if they wanted to fly a straight-in approach to runway 19 rather than coming around to runway 01. The pilots agreed, hoping to make up some time. The pilots then erroneously cleared the approach waypoints from their navigation computer. When the controller asked the pilots to check back in over Tuluá, north of Cali, it was no longer programmed into the computer, and so they had to pull out their maps to find it. In the meantime, they extended the aircraft's speed brakes to slow it down and expedite its descent.
By the time the pilots found Tuluá's coordinates, they had already passed over it. In response to this, they attempted to program the navigation computer for the next approach waypoint, Rozo. However, the Rozo NDB was identified as R on their charts. Colombia had duplicated the identifier for the Romeo NDB near Bogotá, and the computer's list of stored waypoints did not include the Rozo NDB as "R", but only under its full name "ROZO". In cases where a country allowed duplicate identifiers, it often listed them with the largest city first. By picking the first "R" from the list, the captain caused the autopilot to start flying a course to Bogotá, resulting in the airplane turning east in a wide semicircle. By the time the error was detected, the aircraft was in a valley running roughly north-south parallel to the one they should have been in. The pilots had put the aircraft on a collision course with a 3,000-meter (9,800 feet) mountain. The air traffic controller, Nelson Rivera Ramírez, believed that some of the requests of the pilots did not make sense, but did not know enough non-aviation English to convey this.
Twelve seconds before the plane hit the mountain, named El Deluvio, the Ground Proximity Warning System activated, announcing an imminent terrain collision and sounding an alarm. Within a second of this warning the first officer disengaged the autopilot and the captain attempted to climb clear of the mountain; however, neither pilot had remembered to disengage the previously deployed speed brakes which reduced the rate of climb. At 9:41:28 pm Eastern Standard Time it struck trees at about 8,900 feet MSL on the east side of the mountain. The crash was six miles south of Tuluá VOR and 28 miles north of the approach end of runway 19 at Alfonso Bonilla Aragon International Airport. During the investigations, it was found that neither the Boeing fixed-base simulator nor the CDU/FMS simulator could be backdriven with the data obtained directly from the accident airplane's flight data recorder. Because the B-757 flight simulators could not be back driven during the tests, it could not be determined with precision whether the airplane would have missed the mountain/tree tops if the speedbrakes had been retracted during the escape attempt. However, the final report stated that if the flightcrew had retracted the speedbrakes one second after initiating the escape maneuver, the airplane could have been climbing through a position that was 150 feet above the initial impact point. Because the airplane would have continued to climb and had the potential to increase its rate of climb, it may well have cleared the trees at the top of the mountain.
Scavengers took engine thrust reversers, cockpit avionics, and other components from the crashed 757. The scavengers used Colombian military and private helicopters to go to and from the crash site. Many of the stolen unapproved aircraft parts re-appeared on the black market in Greater Miami parts brokers. In a response, the airline published a 14-page list stating all of the parts missing from the crashed aircraft. The list included the serial numbers of all of the parts.
In 1997 U.S. District Judge Stanley Marcus ruled that the pilots had committed "willful misconduct"; the ruling applied to American Airlines, which represented the deceased pilots. The judge's ruling was subsequently reversed in June 1999 by the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta, which also overturned the jury verdict and declared that the judge in the case was wrong in issuing a finding of fault with the pilots, a role which should have been reserved for the jury only.
American Airlines settled numerous lawsuits brought against it by the families of the victims of the accident. American Airlines filed a "third-party complaint" lawsuit for contribution against Jeppesen and Honeywell, which made the navigation computer database and failed to include the coordinates of Rozo under the identifier "R"; the case went to trial in United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida in Miami. At the trial, American Airlines admitted that it bore some legal responsibility for the accident. Honeywell and Jeppesen each contended that they had no legal responsibility for the accident. In June 2000, the jury found that Jeppesen was 30 percent at fault for the crash, Honeywell was 10 percent at fault, and American Airlines was 60 percent at fault.
Since 2002, all planes with more than six passengers are required to have an advanced terrain awareness warning system. No aircraft fitted with a TAWS/EGPWS suffered a controlled flight into terrain accident until July 28, 2010, when Airblue Flight 202 crashed into the Margalla Hills, Pakistan.
Crash investigation and final report
The crash was investigated by the Special Administrative Unit of Civil Aeronautics (Aeronáutica Civil) of the Republic of Colombia, with assistance from the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (U.S. NTSB) as well as other parties, including the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration, Allied Pilots Association, American Airlines, Boeing Commercial Airplane Group and Rolls Royce Engines.
The Aeronáutica Civil prepared a final report of its investigation in September 1996, which was released through the U.S. NTSB.
In its report, the Aeronáutica Civil determined the following probable causes of the accident:
- The flight crew's failure to adequately plan and execute the approach to runway 19 at SKCL and their inadequate use of automation.
- Failure of the flightcrew to discontinue the approach into Cali, despite numerous cues alerting them of the inadvisability of continuing the approach.
- The lack of situational awareness of the flightcrew regarding vertical navigation, proximity to terrain, and the relative location of critical radio aids.
- Failure of the flightcrew to revert to basic radio navigation at the time when the FMS-assisted navigation became confusing and demanded an excessive workload in a critical phase of the flight.
In addition, the Aeronáutica Civil determined that there were the following contributing factors to the accident:
- The flight crew's ongoing efforts to expedite their approach and landing in order to avoid potential delays.
- The flight crew's execution of the GPWS escape maneuver while the speedbrakes remained deployed.
- FMS logic that dropped all intermediate fixes from the display(s) in the event of execution of a direct routing.
- FMS-generated navigational information that used a different naming convention from that published in navigational charts.
The Aeronáutica Civil's report also included a variety of safety-related recommendations to the following parties (number of individual recommendations in parentheses):
Investigators later labeled the accident a non-survivable event.
This accident was featured on the television series Mayday in the episode "Lost", known in some countries as "Crash on the Mountain".
- Francisco Ferre Malaussena, Mariana Gomez de Ferre, and Felipe Antonio Ferre Gomez, the son, daughter-in-law, and grandson of former Miami mayor Maurice Ferre.
- Paris Kanellakis, a computer scientist at Brown University, died with wife, María Teresa Otoya, and children Alexandra and Stephanos.
- The survivors are Gonzalo Dussan Monroy, Michelle Dussan, Mercedes Ramirez, and Mauricio Reyes. Gonzalo "Gonzalito" Dussan, Jr., Michelle Dussan's brother and Gonzalo Dussan's son, was initially found alive but died on the operating table due to internal injuries. The survivors had been taken to a hospital in Cali. Gonzalo Dussan did not receive insurance benefits from the death of his companion and the mother of his children, Nancy Delgado, as Delgado and Dussan were not legally married. Ramirez is a central character in Exit Row: The True Story of an Emergency Volunteer, a Miraculous Survivor and the Crash of Flight 965 by Tammy L. Kling.
- Crews found a small brown dog alive, inside a carrier in the cargo hold. The dog was adopted by the Red Cross team in Cali, Colombia, for a few weeks (they renamed him "Milagro", which is Spanish for "miracle"), then an American Airlines employee who had worked the crash recovery in Cali adopted the dog and brought it to the United States.
- Japan Airlines Flight 123 crashed into mountainous area with 524 people on board and only 4 survivors
- Air New Zealand Flight 901
- Air Safety
- Crew Resource Management
- Enhanced Ground Proximity Warning System (EGPWS)
- Lists of accidents and incidents on commercial airliners
- "American Airlines jet crashes in the Andes." CNN. December 21, 1995. Retrieved on May 6, 2009.
- Acohido, Byron. "Did mistakes by crew doom flight to Cali?." The Seattle Times. January 18, 1997. Retrieved on May 6, 2009.
- Sider, Don. "Miracle on the Mountain." People (magazine). January 08, 1996. Retrieved on June 22, 2009.
- Aeronáutica Civil's Final Report
- "Family members await crash news". CNN. Retrieved 2008-03-29.
- "Lost," Mayday [TV documentary program]
- "The List of the 164 People on Flight 965." Associated Press at The New York Times. Saturday December 23, 1995. Retrieved on May 6, 2009.
- Edward F. Mickolus and Susan L. Simmons, Terrorism, 1992-1995: A Chronology of Events and a Selectively Annotated Bibliography
- AOPA "Lessons from Cali" Article
- "The AA965 Cali accident". Georgia Institute of Technology. Retrieved 2008-03-29. (Archive).
- Bajak, Frank. "'BOGUS PARTS' PLAGUE AIRLINES : SUBSTANDARD COMPONENTS PUT PUBLIC AT RISK." Associated Press at Daily News. December 8, 1996. Retrieved on June 8, 2009.
- Bajak, Frank. "BLACK MARKET OF THE SKIES SUBSTANDARD AIRPLANE PARTS POSE RISK" Associated Press at the Columbus Dispatch. Sunday December 8, 1996. Insight 5B.
- Wald, Matthew L. "American Airlines Ruled Guilty Of Misconduct in '95 Cali Crash." The New York Times. Friday September 12, 1997. Retrieved on August 24, 2009.
- "Cali Crash Case Overturned". Associated Press on CBS. June 16, 1999. Retrieved 2009-08-30.
- "Crash of American Airlines Boeing in Failure Knowledge Database". Hatamura Institute for the Advancement of Technology. Retrieved 2011-04-15.
- Enhanced Ground Proximity Warning System (EGPWS) - Honeywell Aerospace Engineering
- Forecasts 2009 - Safety and security are in the doldrums
- "NTSB Report Summary". NTSB. Archived from the original on 2009-02-13. Retrieved 2008-03-29.
Note: passenger number on NTSB summary is 156, vs. 155 on final report
- "RECORD—Extensions of Remarks." U.S. Government Printing Office. February 27, 1996. Retrieved on January 10, 2013.
- "NEW JERSEY DAILY BRIEFING;Crash Survivor Goes Home," The New York Times
- Sider, Don. "Miracle on the Mountain." People. January 8, 1996. Volume 45, No. 1. Retrieved on January 7, 2012.
- Sharkey, Joe. "NEW JERSEY DAILY BRIEFING;757 Survivor Denied Benefits." The New York Times. June 8, 1996. Retrieved on May 6, 2009.
- "Exit Row: The True Story of an Emergency Volunteer, a Miraculous Survivor and the Crash of Flight 965." Amazon.com. Retrieved on May 6, 2009.
- "Number of survivors reported drops to 4 Finding how many Americans on board difficult, official says." Associated Press. 23 December 1995.
- "Flight 965 to Colombia: Anatomy of a catastrophe." Kansas City Star. 14 January 1996.
|Pre-crash photo taken from Airliners.net|
- Final Accident Report - AA965 - Special Administrative Unit of Civil Aeronautics - Prepared for the World Wide Web by Peter Ladkin of Bielefeld University (Alt, Alt #2, Archive, Archive of Alt #2)
- (Spanish) Final Accident Report - AA965 (Archive) - Special Administrative Unit of Civil Aeronautics - Translation by Captain José Bestene Mattar and Maria Isabel Bobrez Orozco
- "At least four of 164 passengers survive U.S. jet crash in Colombia," CNN
- Zarrella, John. "Tearful relatives head to Colombia," CNN. December 22, 1995.
- "More survivors pulled from wreckage of U.S. jet," CNN. December 21, 1995.
- Dewar, Steuart. "Brown professor, wife, 2 children killed in crash" (Archive). The Associated Press, posted at Brown University.
- BBC Horizon Program interviewing Mercedes Ramirez Johnson, a survivor of AA flight 965
- CNN Evening News for Friday, 22 December 1995 Headline: Colombia / American Airlines Plane Crash Vanderbilt University Television Archive
- Mercedes Ramirez Johnson website
- Mercer, Pamela. "Pair Who Survived a Crash Relieved to Be on Home Soil." The New York Times. May 19, 1996.
- Piamba Cortes v. American Airlines Inc.
- B757 Cali Accident in the Compendium of Computer-Related Incidents with Commercial Aircraft including a copy of the Colombian accident report.
- Cockpit voice recording transcript