Anna Anderson

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Anna Anderson
Profile of the head and far shoulder of Anderson in her twenties. She has a prominent nose and mouth and a serious expression. Her one visible eye looks intently into the light. She is dressed plainly and her hair is gathered behind her head.
Born Franziska Schanzkowska
16 December 1896
Borreck Abbau/Borowilaß,[1] West Prussia, Kingdom of Prussia, German Empire (modern-day Poland)
Died 12 February 1984(1984-02-12) (aged 87)
Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
Cause of death
Pneumonia
Other names "Fräulein Unbekannt"
Anna Tschaikovsky
Anastasia Tschaikovsky
Anastasia Manahan
Spouse(s) Dr. John Eacott "Jack" Manahan (m. 1968)

Anna Anderson (16 December 1896 – 12 February 1984) was the best known of several impostors who claimed to be Grand Duchess Anastasia of Russia.[2][3] Anastasia, the youngest daughter of the last Tsar and Tsarina of Russia, Nicholas II and Alexandra, was killed along with her parents and siblings on 17 July 1918 by communist revolutionaries in Ekaterinburg, Russia; but the location of her body was unknown until 2007.[2][4][5]

In 1920, Anderson was institutionalized in a mental hospital after a suicide attempt in Berlin. At first, she went by the name Fräulein Unbekannt (German for Miss Unknown) as she refused to reveal her identity.[6] Later she used the name Tschaikovsky and then Anderson. In March 1922, claims that Anderson was a Russian grand duchess first received public attention. Most members of Grand Duchess Anastasia's family and those who had known her, including court tutor Pierre Gilliard, said Anderson was an impostor but others were convinced she was Anastasia. In 1927, a private investigation funded by the Tsarina's brother, Ernest Louis, Grand Duke of Hesse, identified Anderson as Franziska Schanzkowska, a Polish factory worker with a history of mental illness. After a lawsuit lasting many years, the German courts ruled that Anderson had failed to prove she was Anastasia, but through media coverage, her claim gained notoriety.[7]

Between 1922 and 1968, Anderson lived in Germany and the United States with various supporters and in nursing homes and sanatoria, including at least one asylum. She emigrated to the United States in 1968, and shortly before the expiry of her visa married Jack Manahan, a Virginia history professor who was later characterized as "probably Charlottesville's best-loved eccentric".[8] Upon her death in 1984, Anderson's body was cremated, and her ashes were buried in the churchyard at Castle Seeon, Germany. After the collapse of communism in the Soviet Union, the locations of the bodies of the Tsar, Tsarina, and all five of their children were revealed and multiple laboratories in different countries confirmed their identity through DNA testing.[2][4] DNA tests on a lock of Anderson's hair and surviving medical samples of her tissue showed that Anderson's DNA did not match that of the Romanov remains or that of living relatives of the Romanovs.[9][10] Instead, Anderson's mitochondrial DNA matched that of Karl Maucher, a great-nephew of Franziska Schanzkowska.[10] Most scientists, historians and journalists who have discussed the case accept that Anderson and Schanzkowska were the same person.[2][11][12][13][14]

Biography[edit]

Dalldorf asylum (1920–1922)[edit]

On 27 February 1920,[15] a young woman attempted to take her own life in Berlin by jumping off the Bendlerbrücke into the Landwehrkanal. She was rescued by a police sergeant and was admitted to the Elisabeth Hospital on Lützowstrasse. As she was without papers and refused to identify herself, she was admitted as Fräulein Unbekannt (Miss Unknown) to a mental hospital in Dalldorf (now Wittenau, in Reinickendorf), where she remained for the next two years.[6] She had scars on her head and body,[16] and spoke German with an accent described as "Russian" by medical staff.[17]

In early 1922, Clara Peuthert, a fellow psychiatric patient, claimed that the unknown woman was the Grand Duchess Tatiana of Russia, one of the four daughters of Tsar Nicholas II of Russia.[18] On her release, Peuthert told Russian émigré Captain Nicholas von Schwabe that she had seen Tatiana at Dalldorf.[19] Schwabe visited the asylum and accepted the woman as Tatiana.[20] Schwabe persuaded other émigrés to visit the unknown woman, including Zinaida Tolstoy, a friend of the Tsarina Alexandra. Eventually Baroness Sophie Buxhoeveden, a former lady-in-waiting to the Tsarina, visited the asylum with Tolstoy. On seeing the woman, Buxhoeveden declared "She's too short for Tatiana,"[21] and left convinced the woman was not a Russian grand duchess.[22] A few days later, the unknown woman noted, "I did not say I was Tatiana."[23]

A nurse at Dalldorf, Thea Malinovsky, claimed years after the patient's release from the asylum that the woman had told her she was another daughter of the Tsar, Anastasia, in the autumn of 1921.[24] However, the patient herself could not recall the incident.[25] Her biographers either ignore Malinovsky's claim,[26] or weave it into their narrative.[27]

Germany and Switzerland (1922–1927)[edit]

By May 1922, the woman was believed by Peuthert, Schwabe, and Tolstoy to be Anastasia, although Buxhoeveden said there was no resemblance.[28] Nevertheless, the woman was taken out of the asylum and given a room in the Berlin home of Baron Arthur von Kleist, a Russian émigré who had been a police chief in Russian Poland before the fall of the Tsar. The Berlin policeman who handled the case, Detective Inspector Franz Grünberg, thought that Kleist "may have had ulterior motives, as was hinted at in émigré circles: if the old conditions should ever be restored in Russia, he hoped for great advancement from having looked after the young woman."[29] She began calling herself Anna Tschaikovsky,[30] choosing "Anna" as a short form of "Anastasia",[31] although Peuthert "described her everywhere as Anastasia".[32] Tschaikovsky stayed in the houses of acquaintances, including Kleist, Peuthert, a poor working-class family called Bachmann, and at Inspector Grünberg's estate at Funkenmühle, near Zossen.[33] At Funkenmühle, Grünberg arranged for the Tsarina's sister, Princess Irene of Hesse and by Rhine, to meet Tschaikovsky, but Irene did not recognize her.[34] Grünberg also arranged a visit from Crown Princess Cecilie of Prussia, but Tschaikovsky refused to speak to her, and Cecilie was left perplexed by the encounter.[35] Later, in the 1950s, Cecilie signed a declaration that Tschaikovsky was Anastasia,[36] but Cecilie's family disputed her statement and implied that she was suffering from dementia.[37]

By 1925, Tschaikovsky had developed a tuberculous infection of her arm, and she was placed in a succession of hospitals for treatment. Sick and near death, she suffered significant loss of weight.[38] She was visited by the Tsarina's groom of the chamber Alexei Volkov; Anastasia's tutor Pierre Gilliard; his wife, Shura, who had been Anastasia's nursemaid; and the Tsar's sister, Grand Duchess Olga. Although they expressed sympathy, if only for Tschaikovsky's illness, and made no immediate public declarations, eventually they all denied she was Anastasia.[39] In March 1926, she convalesced in Lugano with Harriet von Rathlef at the expense of Grand Duchess Anastasia's great-uncle, Prince Valdemar of Denmark. Valdemar was willing to offer Tschaikovsky material assistance, through the Danish ambassador to Germany, Herluf Zahle, while her identity was investigated.[40] To allow her to travel, the Berlin Aliens Office issued her with a temporary certificate of identity as "Anastasia Tschaikovsky", with Grand Duchess Anastasia's personal details.[41] After a quarrel with von Rathlef, Tschaikovsky was moved to the Stillachhaus Sanatorium at Oberstdorf in the Bavarian Alps in June 1926, and von Rathlef returned to Berlin.[42]

At Oberstdorf, Tschaikovsky was visited by Tatiana Melnik, née Botkin. Melnik was the niece of Serge Botkin, the head of the Russian refugee office in Berlin, and the daughter of the imperial family's personal physician, Dr. Eugene Botkin, who had been murdered by the communists alongside the Tsar's family in 1918. Tatiana Melnik had met Grand Duchess Anastasia as a child and had last spoken to her in February 1917.[43] To Melnik, Tschaikovsky looked like Anastasia, even though "the mouth has changed and coarsened noticeably, and because the face is so lean, her nose looks bigger than it was."[44] In a letter, Melnik wrote: "Her attitude is childlike, and altogether she cannot be reckoned with as a responsible adult, but must be led and directed like a child. She has not only forgotten languages, but has in general lost the power of accurate narration ... even the simplest stories she tells incoherently and incorrectly; they are really only words strung together in impossibly ungrammatical German ... Her defect is obviously in her memory and eyesight."[45] Melnik declared that Tschaikovsky was Anastasia, and supposed that any inability on her part to remember events and her refusal to speak Russian was caused by her impaired physical and psychological state.[46] Either inadvertently through a sincere desire to "aid the patient's weak memory"[47] or as part of a deliberate charade,[3] Melnik coached Tschaikovsky with details of life in the imperial family.

Castle Seeon (1927)[edit]

Young woman wearing an apron and facing forwards
Franziska Schanzkowska, c. 1913

In 1927, under pressure from his family, Valdemar decided against providing Tschaikovsky any further financial support, and the funds from Denmark were cut off.[48] Duke George of Leuchtenberg, a distant relative of the Tsar, gave her a home at Castle Seeon.[49] The Tsarina's brother, Ernest Louis, Grand Duke of Hesse, hired a private detective, Martin Knopf, to investigate the claims that Tschaikovsky was Anastasia.[50] During her stay at Castle Seeon, Knopf reported that Tschaikovsky was actually a Polish factory worker called Franziska Schanzkowska.[51] Schanzkowska had worked in a munitions factory during World War I when, shortly after her fiancé had been killed at the front, a grenade fell out of her hand and exploded. She was injured in the head, and a foreman was killed in front of her.[52] She became apathetic and depressed, was declared insane on 19 September 1916,[53] and spent time in two lunatic asylums.[54] In early 1920, she was reported missing from her Berlin lodgings, and since then had not been seen or heard from by her family.[55] In May 1927, Franziska's brother, Felix Schanzkowski, was introduced to Tschaikovsky at a local inn in Wasserburg near Castle Seeon. Leuchtenberg's son, Dmitri, was completely certain Tschaikovsky was an impostor and that she was recognized by Felix as his sister,[56] but Leuchtenberg's daughter, Natalie, remained convinced of Tschaikovsky's authenticity.[57] Leuchtenberg himself was ambivalent.[58] According to one account, initially Felix declared that Tschaikovsky was his sister Franziska,[59] but the affidavit he signed spoke only of "strong resemblance", highlighted physical differences, and said she did not recognize him.[60] Years later, Felix's family said that he knew Tschaikovsky was his sister, but he had chosen to leave her to her new life, which was far more comfortable than any alternative.[61]

Visitors to Seeon included Prince Felix Yusupov, husband of Princess Irina Alexandrovna of Russia, who wrote, "I claim categorically that she is not Anastasia Nicolaievna, but just an adventuress, a sick hysteric and a frightful playactress. I simply cannot understand how anyone can be in doubt of this. If you had seen her, I am convinced that you would recoil in horror at the thought that this frightful creature could be a daughter of our Tsar."[62] Other visitors, however, such as Felix Dassel, an officer whom Anastasia had visited in hospital during 1916, and Gleb Botkin, who had known Anastasia as a child and was Tatiana Melnik's brother, were convinced that Tschaikovsky was genuine.[63]

United States (1928–1932)[edit]

By 1928, Tschaikovsky's claim had received interest and attention in the United States, where Gleb Botkin had published articles in support of her cause.[3][64] Botkin's publicity caught the attention of a distant cousin of Anastasia's, Xenia Leeds, a former Russian princess who had married a wealthy American industrialist.[65] Botkin and Leeds arranged for Tschaikovsky to travel to the United States on board the liner Berengaria at Leeds' expense.[66] On the journey from Seeon to the States, Tschaikovsky stopped at Paris, where she met Grand Duke Andrei Vladimirovich of Russia, the Tsar's cousin, who believed her to be Anastasia.[67] For six months Tschaikovsky lived at the estate of the Leeds family in Oyster Bay, New York.[68]

Black and white photograph of a thin, clean-shaven man seated at a piano
Pianist and composer Sergei Rachmaninoff paid for Anna to stay at the Garden City Hotel on Long Island, where she first used the name Anderson.

As the tenth anniversary of the Tsar's execution approached in July 1928, Botkin retained a lawyer, Edward Fallows, to oversee legal moves to obtain any of the Tsar's estate outside of the Soviet Union. As the death of the Tsar had never been proven, the estate could only be released to relatives 10 years after the supposed date of his death.[69] Fallows set up a company, called the Grandanor Corporation (an acronym of Grand Duchess Anastasia of Russia), which sought to raise funds by selling shares in any prospective estate.[70] Tschaikovsky claimed that the Tsar had deposited money abroad, which fed unsubstantiated rumors of a large Romanov fortune in England.[71] The surviving relatives of the Romanovs accused Botkin and Fallows of fortune hunting, and Botkin accused them of trying to defraud "Anastasia" out of her inheritance.[72] Except for a relatively small deposit in Germany, distributed to the Tsar's recognized relations, no money was ever found.[73] After a quarrel, possibly over Tschaikovsky's claim to the estate (but not over her claim to be Anastasia),[74] Tschaikovsky moved out of the Leeds' mansion, and the pianist Sergei Rachmaninoff arranged for her to live at the Garden City Hotel in Hempstead, New York, and later in a small cottage. To avoid the press, she was booked in as Mrs. Anderson, the name by which she was subsequently known.[75] In October 1928, after the death of the Tsar's mother, the Dowager Empress Marie, the 12 nearest relations of the Tsar met at Marie's funeral and signed a declaration that denounced Anderson as an impostor.[76] The Copenhagen Statement, as it would come to be known, explained: "Our sense of duty compels us to state that the story is only a fairy tale. The memory of our dear departed would be tarnished if we allowed this fantastic story to spread and gain any credence."[77] Gleb Botkin answered with a public letter to Grand Duchess Xenia Alexandrovna of Russia, which referred to the family as "greedy and unscrupulous" and claimed they were only denouncing Anderson for money.[78]

From early 1929 Anderson lived with Annie Burr Jennings, a wealthy Park Avenue spinster happy to host someone she supposed to be a daughter of the Tsar.[79] For 18 months Anderson was the toast of New York City society.[80] Then a pattern of self-destructive behavior began that culminated in her throwing tantrums, killing her pet parakeet,[81] and on one occasion running around naked on the roof.[82] On 24 July 1930, Judge Peter Schmuck of the New York Supreme Court signed an order committing her to a mental hospital.[83] Before she could be taken away, Anderson locked herself in her room, and the door was broken in with an axe. She was forcibly taken to the Four Winds Sanatorium in Westchester County, New York, where she remained for slightly over a year.[84] In August 1932, Anderson returned to Germany accompanied by a private nurse in a locked cabin on the liner Deutschland.[85] Jennings paid for the voyage, the stay at the Westchester sanatorium, and an additional six months' care in the psychiatric wing of a nursing home at Ilten near Hanover.[86] On arrival at Ilten, Anderson was assessed as sane,[87] but as the room was prepaid, and she had nowhere else to go, she stayed on in a suite in the sanatorium grounds.[88]

Germany (1932–1968)[edit]

Anderson's return to Germany generated press interest, and drew more members of the German aristocracy to her cause.[89] She again lived itinerantly as a guest of her well-wishers.[90] In 1932, the British tabloid News of the World published a sensational story accusing her of being a Romanian actress who was perpetrating a fraud.[91] Her lawyer, Fallows, filed suit for libel, but the lengthy case continued until the outbreak of World War II, at which time the case was dismissed because Anderson was living in Germany, and German residents could not sue in enemy countries.[89] From 1938, lawyers acting for Anderson in Germany contested the distribution of the Tsar's estate to his recognized relations, and they in turn contested her identity.[92] The litigation continued intermittently without resolution for decades; Lord Mountbatten footed some of his German relations' legal bills against Anderson.[93] The protracted proceedings became the longest-running lawsuit in German history.[94]

Anderson had a final meeting with the Schanzkowski family in 1938. Gertrude Schanzkowska was insistent that Anderson was her sister, Franziska,[95] but the Nazi government had arranged the meeting to determine Anderson's identity, and if accepted as Schanzkowska she would be imprisoned.[96] The Schanzkowski family refused to sign affidavits against her, and no further action was taken.[97] In 1939, World War II began with Germany's attack on the western half of Poland. In 1940, Edward Fallows died virtually destitute after wasting all his own money on trying to obtain the Tsar's non-existent fortune for the Grandanor Corporation.[98] Towards the end of the war Anderson lived at Schloss Winterstein with Louise of Saxe-Meiningen, in what became the Soviet occupation zone. In 1946, Prince Frederick of Saxe-Altenburg helped her across the border to Bad Liebenzell in the French occupation zone.[99]

Prince Frederick settled Anderson in a former army barracks in the small village of Unterlengenhardt, on the edge of the Black Forest, where she became a sort of tourist attraction.[100] Lili Dehn, a friend of Tsarina Alexandra, visited her and acknowledged her as Anastasia,[101] but when Charles Sydney Gibbes, English tutor to the imperial children, met Anderson he denounced her as a fraud.[102] In an affidavit, he swore "She in no way resembles the true Grand Duchess Anastasia that I had known ... I am quite satisfied that she is an impostor."[103] She became a recluse, surrounded by cats, and her house began to decay.[104] In May 1968, Anderson was taken to a hospital at Neuenbürg after being discovered semi-conscious in her cottage. In her absence, Prince Frederick cleaned up the property by order of the local board of health.[105] Her Irish Wolfhound and 60 cats were put to death.[106] Horrified by this, Anderson accepted her long-term supporter Gleb Botkin's offer to move to the United States.[107]

Final years (1968–1984)[edit]

Casually dressed balding old man with a large grey beard
Gleb Botkin, c. 1960

Botkin was living in the university town of Charlottesville, Virginia, and a local friend of his, history professor and genealogist John Eacott "Jack" Manahan, paid for Anderson's journey to the United States.[108] She entered the country on a six-month visitor's visa, and shortly before it was due to expire, Anderson married Manahan, who was 20 years her junior, in a civil ceremony on 23 December 1968. Botkin was best man.[109] Jack Manahan enjoyed this marriage of convenience,[110] and described himself as "Grand Duke-in-Waiting"[111] or "son-in-law to the Tsar".[112] The couple lived in separate bedrooms in a house on University Circle in Charlottesville, and also owned a farm near Scottsville.[113] Botkin died in December 1969.[114] In February of the following year, the lawsuits finally came to an end, with neither side able to establish Anderson's identity.[115]

Manahan and Anderson, now legally called Anastasia Manahan,[116] became well known in the Charlottesville area as eccentrics.[8][117] Though Jack Manahan was wealthy, they lived in squalor with large numbers of dogs and cats, and piles of garbage.[8][118] On 20 August 1979, Anderson was taken to Charlottesville's Martha Jefferson Hospital with an intestinal obstruction. A gangrenous tumor and a length of intestine were removed by Dr. Richard Shrum.[119]

With both Manahan and Anderson in failing health, in November 1983, Anderson was institutionalized, and an attorney, William Preston, was appointed as her guardian by the local circuit court.[120] A few days later, Manahan "kidnapped"[121] Anderson from the hospital, and for three days they drove around Virginia eating out of convenience stores. After a 13-state police alarm, they were found and Anderson was returned to a care facility.[122] In January she may have had a stroke, and on 12 February 1984, she died of pneumonia.[123] She was cremated the same day, and her ashes were buried in the churchyard at Castle Seeon on 18 June 1984.[124] Manahan died on 22 March 1990.[8]

DNA evidence[edit]

In 1991, the bodies of Tsar Nicholas II, Tsarina Alexandra, and three of their daughters were exhumed from a mass grave near Ekaterinburg. They were identified on the basis of both skeletal analysis and DNA testing.[125] For example, mitochondrial DNA was used to match maternal relations, and mitochondrial DNA from the female bones matched that of Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, whose maternal grandmother Princess Victoria of Hesse and by Rhine was a sister of Alexandra.[125] The bodies of Tsarevich Alexei and the remaining daughter were discovered in 2007. Repeated and independent DNA tests confirmed that the remains were the seven members of the Romanov family, and proved that none of the Tsar's four daughters survived the shooting of the Romanov family.[2][4][5]

A sample of Anderson's tissue, part of her intestine removed during her operation in 1979, had been stored at Martha Jefferson Hospital, Charlottesville, Virginia. Anderson's mitochondrial DNA was extracted from the sample and compared with that of the Romanovs and their relatives. It did not match that of the Duke of Edinburgh or that of the bones, confirming that Anderson was not Anastasia. However, the sample matched DNA provided by Karl Maucher, a grandson of Franziska Schanzkowska's sister, Gertrude (Schanzkowska) Ellerik, indicating that Karl Maucher and Anna Anderson were maternally related and that Anderson was Schanzkowska.[3][10] Five years after the original testing was done, Dr. Terry Melton of the Department of Anthropology, Pennsylvania State University, stated that the DNA sequence tying Anderson to the Schanzkowski family was "still unique", though the database of DNA patterns at the Armed Forces DNA Identification Laboratory had grown much larger, leading to "increased confidence that Anderson was indeed Franziska Schanzkowska".[126]

Similarly, several strands of Anderson's hair, found inside an envelope in a book that had belonged to Anderson's husband, Jack Manahan, were also tested. Mitochondrial DNA from the hair matched Anderson's hospital sample and that of Schanzkowska's relative Karl Maucher but not the Romanov remains or living relatives of the Romanovs.[10][127]

Assessment[edit]

Although communists had killed the entire imperial Romanov family in July 1918, including 17-year-old Grand Duchess Anastasia, for years afterwards communist disinformation fed rumors that members of the Tsar's family had survived.[128] The conflicting rumors about the fate of the family allowed impostors to make spurious claims that they were a surviving Romanov.[129]

Most of the impostors were dismissed; however, Anna Anderson's claim persisted.[130] Books and pamphlets supporting her claims included Harriet von Rathlef-Keilmann's book Anastasia, ein Frauenschicksal als Spiegel der Weltkatastrophe (Anastasia, A Woman's Fate as a Mirror of the World Catastrophe), which was published in Germany and Switzerland in 1928, though it was serialized by the tabloid newspaper Berliner Nachtausgabe in 1927. It was countered by works such as La Fausse Anastasie (The False Anastasia) by Pierre Gilliard and Constantin Savitch, published by Payot of Paris in 1929.[131] Conflicting testimonies and physical evidence, such as comparisons of facial characteristics, which alternately supported and contradicted Anderson's claim, were used to either bolster or counter the belief that she was Anastasia.[132] In the absence of any direct documentary proof or solid physical evidence, the question of whether Anderson was Anastasia was for many a matter of personal belief.[133] As Anderson herself said in her own idiomatic English, "You either believe it or you don't believe it. It doesn't matter. In no anyway whatsoever."[134] The German courts were unable to decide her claim one way or another, and eventually, after 40 years of deliberation, ruled that her claim was "neither established nor refuted".[135] Dr. Günter von Berenberg-Gossler, attorney for Anderson's opponents in the later years of the legal case, said that during the German trials "the press were always more interested in reporting her side of the story than the opposing bench's less glamorous perspective; editors often pulled journalists after reporting testimony delivered by her side and ignored the rebuttal, resulting in the public seldom getting a complete picture."[136]

In 1957, a version of Anderson's story, pieced together by her supporters and interspersed with commentary by Roland Krug von Nidda, was published in Germany under the title Ich, Anastasia, Erzähle (I, Anastasia, an autobiography).[137] The book included the "fantastic tale"[138] that Anastasia escaped Russia on a farm cart with a man called Alexander Tschaikovsky, whom she married and had a child by, before he was shot dead on a Bucharest street and the child, Alexei, disappeared into an orphanage. Even Anderson's supporters admitted that the details of the supposed escape "might seem bold inventions even for a dramatist",[139] while her detractors considered "this barely credible story as a piece of far-fetched romance".[139] Other works based on the premise that Anderson was Anastasia, written before the DNA tests, include biographies by Peter Kurth and James Blair Lovell. More recent biographies by John Klier, Robert Massie and Greg King that describe her as an impostor were written after the DNA tests proved she was not Anastasia.

Assessments vary as to whether she was a deliberate fraud, a young woman traumatized into adopting a new identity, or used by her supporters for their own ends. Pierre Gilliard denounced Anderson as "a cunning psychopath".[3][140] Writer Michael Thornton thought, "Somewhere along the way she lost and rejected Schanzkowska. She lost that person totally and accepted completely she was this new person. I think it happened by accident and she was swept along on a wave of euphoria."[141] Lord Mountbatten, a first cousin of the Romanov children, thought her supporters "simply get rich on the royalties of further books, magazine articles, plays etc."[142] Prince Michael Romanov, a grandson of Grand Duchess Xenia Alexandrovna of Russia, stated the Romanov family always knew Anderson was a fraud, and that the family looked upon her and "the three-ringed circus which danced around her, creating books and movies, as a vulgar insult to the memory of the Imperial Family."[136]

Fictional portrayals[edit]

Black and white photograph of a smiling lady with neck-length dark hair in a smart but plain dress with a collar and full length sleeves
Actress Ingrid Bergman won an Academy Award for her starring role as "Anna/Anastasia" in the 1956 film Anastasia. Though inspired by Anderson's claim, the film is largely fictional.[143]

Since the 1920s, many fictional works have been inspired by Anderson's claim to be Anastasia. In 1928, the silent film Clothes Make the Woman was based very loosely on her story. In 1953, Marcelle Maurette wrote a play based on Rathlef's and Gilliard's books called Anastasia,[144] which toured Europe and America with Viveca Lindfors in the title role. The play was so successful that in 1956 an English adaptation by Guy Bolton was made into a film, Anastasia.[145] The plot revolves around a group of swindlers who attempt to raise money among Russian émigrés by pretending that Grand Duchess Anastasia is still alive. A suitable amnesiac, "Anna", is groomed by the swindlers to impersonate Anastasia. Anna's origins are unknown and as the play progresses hints are dropped that she could be the real Anastasia, who has lost her memory. The viewer is left to decide whether Anna really is Anastasia.[146] Another film was released at the same time, Is Anna Anderson Anastasia? starring Lilli Palmer, which covers much the same ground, but the central character is "perhaps even more lost, mad and pathetic, but she, too, has moments when she is a woman of presence and dignity".[146]

Playwright Royce Ryton wrote I Am Who I Am about Anna Anderson in 1978. Like the earlier plays, it depicts Anderson as "a person of intrinsic worth victimized by the greed and fears of others" and did not attempt to decide her real identity.[147]

In 1965, the musical Anya, based on Guy Bolton's play and using the music of Sergei Rachmaninoff, opened on Broadway starring Constance Towers as Anya and Lillian Gish as the Dowager Empress—it was not successful.

Sir Kenneth MacMillan's ballet Anastasia, first performed in 1967, used I, Anastasia, an autobiography as inspiration and "is a dramatic fantasy about Anna Anderson, the woman who believes herself to be Anastasia ... Either in memory or imagination, she experiences episodes from Anastasia's past ... The structure is a kind of free-wheeling nightmare, held together by the central figure of the heroine, played by Lynn Seymour".[148] A contemporary reviewer thought Seymour's "tense, tormented portrait of the desperate Anna Anderson is quite extraordinary and really impressive".[149] Anna Anderson was also used as a narrative device in Youri Vámos' 1992 ballet for Theater Basel, Sleeping Beauty – Last Daughter of the Czar, based on Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's Sleeping Beauty.[150]

In December 1986, NBC ran a two-part fictionalized mini-series titled Anastasia: The Mystery of Anna which starred Amy Irving and won her a Golden Globe nomination. In the words of Hal Erickson, "Irving plays the leading character in a lady-or-the-tiger fashion, so that we never know if she truly swallows her own tale or if she's merely a clever charlatan."[151]

The central character ("Anastasia" or "Anya") of the 1997 animated fantasy Anastasia is portrayed as the actual Grand Duchess Anastasia, even though the film was released after DNA tests proved that Anna Anderson was not Anastasia.[152] The film is an entirely fictional musical entertainment, and in the words of one reviewer, "historical facts are treated with particular contempt".[153]

See also[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ http://pom-wpru.kerntopf.com/orte/borreck.htm
  2. ^ a b c d e Coble, Michael D; Loreille, Odile M; Wadhams, Mark J; Edson, Suni M; Maynard, Kerry; Meyer, Carna E; Niederstätter, Harald; Berger, Cordula; Berger, Burkhard; Falsetti, Anthony B; Gill, Peter; Parson, Walther; Finelli, Louis N. (11 March 2009), Mystery Solved: The Identification of the Two Missing Romanov Children Using DNA Analysis, PLoS ONE 4 (3): e4838, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0004838, PMC 2652717, PMID 19277206, retrieved 3 July 2009 
  3. ^ a b c d e Godl, John (August 1998), Anastasia: The Unmasking of Anna Anderson, The European Royal History Journal (Oakland: Arturo Beeche) (VI): 3–8 
  4. ^ a b c Rogaev, Evgeny I; Grigorenko, Anastasia P; Moliaka, Yuri K; Faskhutdinova, Gulnaz; Goltsov, Andrey; Lahti, Arlene; Hildebrandt, Curtis; Kittler, Ellen LW; Morozova, Irina (31 March 2009), Genomic identification in the historical case of the Nicholas II royal family, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106 (13): 5258–5263, doi:10.1073/pnas.0811190106, PMC 2664067, PMID 19251637, retrieved 8 September 2009 
  5. ^ a b Discovery solves mystery of last Czar's family, CNN, 30 April 2008, retrieved 1 July 2009 
  6. ^ a b Klier and Mingay, p. 93; Berlin Police report, quoted by von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 89
  7. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 109; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 10, 53
  8. ^ a b c d Tucker, William O., Jr. (5 July 2007), Jack & Anna: Remembering the czar of Charlottesville eccentrics, The Hook (Charlottesville, Virginia: Better Publications LLC), archived from the original on 25 February 2014, retrieved 3 July 2009 
  9. ^ Van der Kiste and Hall, p. 174
  10. ^ a b c d Stoneking, Mark; Melton, Terry; Nott, Julian; Barritt, Suzanne; Roby, Rhonda; Holland, Mitchell; Weedn, Victor; Gill, Peter; Kimpton, Colin; Aliston-Greiner, Rosemary; Sullivan, Kevin (9 January 1995), Establishing the identity of Anna Anderson Manahan, Nature Genetics 9 (1): 9–10, doi:10.1038/ng0195-9, PMID 7704032, retrieved 3 July 2009 
  11. ^ Sykes, Bryan (2001), The Seven Daughters of Eve, New York: Norton, p. 75, ISBN 0-393-02018-5 
  12. ^ Massie, p. 249
  13. ^ Gutterman, Steve (23 August 2007), Bones turn up in hunt for last czar's son, Associated Press, retrieved 3 July 2009 
  14. ^ Sieff, Martin (1 May 2008), Romanov mystery finally solved, United Press International, retrieved 3 July 2009 
  15. ^ Berlin Police report, quoted by von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 89
  16. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 82–84; Massie, p. 163
  17. ^ Nurse Erna Buchholz and Dr Bonhoeffer quoted by von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 95–96
  18. ^ I, Anastasia, p. 91; Klier and Mingay, p. 94; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 14
  19. ^ King and Wilson, p. 91; Klier and Mingay, p. 94, Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 16–17
  20. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 21; Welch, p. 103
  21. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 95; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 25; Massie, p. 163
  22. ^ I, Anastasia, p. 93; Hall, p. 340; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 25
  23. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 95; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 26
  24. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 12
  25. ^ I, Anastasia, p. 91
  26. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 93–94, just describes Peuthert's claim.
  27. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 88–89; Massie, p. 163
  28. ^ I, Anastasia, p. 93; Klier and Mingay, p. 95
  29. ^ Letter from Grünberg to his superior, Councillor Goehrke, quoted by Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 92
  30. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 96; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 53; Berlin police records, quoted by von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 112
  31. ^ von Nidda, I, Anastasia, p. 98; Klier and Mingay, p. 96
  32. ^ Grünberg's notes, quoted by von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 112
  33. ^ von Nidda, I, Anastasia, pp. 100–112; Klier and Mingay, pp. 97–98; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 29–63
  34. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 97–98; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 51–52; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 103, 106–107; Welch, p. 108
  35. ^ I, Anastasia, p. 115; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 64; Klier and Mingay, p. 98; Massie, p. 168
  36. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 343; Massie, p. 168; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 116
  37. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 343
  38. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 84–85; Massie, p. 172; Welch, p. 110
  39. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 99–103; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 99–124; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 135–169
  40. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 91; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 102
  41. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 130
  42. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 104; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 130–134; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 180–187
  43. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 138
  44. ^ Tatiana Melnik's declaration on oath, 1929, quoted (in negligibly different translations) by von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 193; King and Wilson, p. 172 and Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 141–142
  45. ^ Quoted (in two negligibly different translations) by Massie in p. 169 and von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 195
  46. ^ Massie, p. 170; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 197–198
  47. ^ Gilliard, Pierre (1929) La Fausse Anastasie quoted in von Nidda, p. 198
  48. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 151–153; Massie, p. 181
  49. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 105–106; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 151–153; Massie, p. 181
  50. ^ Anderson's supporters claimed that Ernest Louis' hostility towards Anderson arose from her allegation that they had last met when he had visited Russia in 1916. Anderson claimed that in the midst of a war between Russia and Germany, Ernest Louis had visited Russia to negotiate a separate peace. Ernest Louis denied the allegation, which if true would have been tantamount to treason. There was no conclusive proof either way. (See: Klier and Mingay, pp. 100–101; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 93–95; Massie, pp. 177–178; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 127–129)
  51. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 306–314; Klier and Mingay, p. 105; Massie, pp. 178–179
  52. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 282–283; Klier and Mingay, p. 224; Massie, p. 249
  53. ^ King and Wilson, p. 283; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 167
  54. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 415, note 93
  55. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 105, 224; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 166; Massie, pp. 178–179, 250
  56. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 106; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 415, note 80
  57. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 180; Massie, p. 181
  58. ^ King and Wilson, p. 160; Massie, p. 181
  59. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 106; Report of Dr. Wilhelm Völler, attorney to Harriet von Rathlef, in the Fallows collection, Houghton Library, quoted in Kurth, Anastasia, p. 172; Massie, p. 180
  60. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 106; Affidavit of Felix Schanzkowski, Fallows paper, Houghton Library, quoted in Kurth, Anastasia, p. 174
  61. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 224
  62. ^ Letter from Prince Felix Yusupov to Grand Duke Andrei Vladimirovich of Russia, 19 September 1927, quoted in Kurth, Anastasia, p. 186
  63. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 89, 135; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 193, 201
  64. ^ Klier and Mingay, p.108; Massie, p. 182
  65. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 108; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 202; Massie, p. 182
  66. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 202–204
  67. ^ King and Wilson, p. 208; Klier and Mingay, p. 109; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 204–206
  68. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 109; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 214–219; Massie, pp. 175–176, 181
  69. ^ Clarke, p. 187; Klier and Mingay, p. 110; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 220–221; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 242
  70. ^ Clarke, p. 185; Klier and Mingay, pp. 110, 112–113; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 233; Massie, p. 184
  71. ^ Clarke, pp. 188–190; Klier and Mingay, p. 103; Massie, pp. 183–185
  72. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 112, 121, 125; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 230–231; Massie, p. 183
  73. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 117
  74. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 110; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 221–222; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 242
  75. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 110; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 227; Massie, p. 181; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 244
  76. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 111; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 229; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 238–239
  77. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 111; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 229
  78. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 187–188; Klier and Mingay, pp. 111–112; Massie, p. 183
  79. ^ Massie, p. 182
  80. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 232; Massie, p. 182
  81. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 113; Letter from Wilton Lloyd-Smith, Miss Jennings' attorney, to Annie Jennings, 15 July 1930, quoted in Kurth, Anastasia, p. 250
  82. ^ Letter from Wilton Lloyd-Smith, Miss Jennings' attorney, to Annie Jennings, 22 August 1930, Fallows papers, Houghton Library, quoted in Kurth, Anastasia, p. 251; Massie, p. 182
  83. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 251–252
  84. ^ Massie, p. 182; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, pp. 250–251
  85. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 253–255; Massie, p. 186
  86. ^ Massie, p. 186
  87. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 125; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 259
  88. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 258–260
  89. ^ a b Klier and Mingay, p. 127
  90. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 271–279
  91. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 127; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 276
  92. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 115; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 289–356
  93. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 128; Massie, p. 189
  94. ^ King and Wilson, p. 236; Klier and Mingay, p. 115
  95. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 129; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 283; Massie, p. 180
  96. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 129
  97. ^ King and Wilson, p. 316; Klier and Mingay, p. 129
  98. ^ Klier and Mingay, p.123; Kurth Anastasia, p. 291; Massie, p. 184
  99. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 129; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 285–286
  100. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 130–131; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 263–266; Massie, p. 186
  101. ^ Klier and Mingay, pp. 153–154; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 288; Massie, p. 187
  102. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 304; Massie, p. 187
  103. ^ Massie, p. 187
  104. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 140; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 334; Massie, p. 191
  105. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 140; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 370–371
  106. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 140; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 371–372
  107. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 142; Kurth, Anastasia, pp. 371–372; Welch p. 253
  108. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 142; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 370; Massie, pp. 191–192
  109. ^ King and Wilson, p. 246; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 375
  110. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 375; Massie, p. 192
  111. ^ Massie, p. 192
  112. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 145
  113. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 381
  114. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 162; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 376
  115. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 236–238; Klier and Mingay, p. 139; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 377
  116. ^ King and Wilson, p. 247; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 375
  117. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 162; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 388
  118. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 162; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 381; Massie, p. 192
  119. ^ King and Wilson, p. 251; Massie, p. 194
  120. ^ King and Wilson, p. 252; Klier and Mingay, p. 163
  121. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 163; Massie, p. 193
  122. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 164; Massie, p. 193
  123. ^ King and Wilson, p. 253; Klier and Mingay, p. 164
  124. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 253–255; Klier and Mingay, p. 164; Massie, p. 193
  125. ^ a b Gill, Peter; Ivanov, Pavel L., Kimpton, Colin, Piercy, Romelle; Benson, Nicola; Tully, Gillian; Evett, Ian; Hagelberg, Erika; Sullivan, Kevin (February 1994), Identification of the remains of the Romanov family by DNA analysis, Nature Genetics 6 (2): 130–135, doi:10.1038/ng0294-130, PMID 8162066, retrieved 29 June 2009 
  126. ^ Godl, John (25 March 2000), Remembering Anna Anderson, Boise, Idaho: Archimandrite Nektarios Serfes, retrieved 3 July 2009 
  127. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 263–266; Massie, p. 246
  128. ^ King and Wilson, p. 67; Klier and Mingay, pp. 70–71, 82–84; Massie, pp. 144–145
  129. ^ King and Wilson, p. 71; Klier and Mingay, pp. 84, 91; Massie, pp. 144–145
  130. ^ King and Wilson, p. 2; Massie, pp. 144–162
  131. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 103; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 273
  132. ^ e.g. King and Wilson, pp. 229–232; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 76
  133. ^ King and Wilson, pp. 3–4; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 83
  134. ^ Interview on ABC television, broadcast 26 October 1976, quoted in Klier and Mingay, p. 230 and Kurth, Anastasia, p. 383
  135. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 139; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 377; Massie, p. 190
  136. ^ a b Godl, John (26 March 2000), Remembering Anna Anderson: Part II, Boise, Idaho: Father Nektarios Serfes, retrieved 7 September 2009 
  137. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 143; Kurth, Anastasia, p. 395; Massie, p. 294
  138. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 96
  139. ^ a b von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 81
  140. ^ Gilliard, Pierre (25 June 1927), L'Histoire d'une imposture, L'Illustration  quoted in Kurth, Anastasia, p. 179
  141. ^ Quoted by Klier and Mingay, p. 230
  142. ^ Letter from Mountbatten to Ian Jacob, 8 September 1958, Broadlands archive, quoted in Ziegler, Philip (1985), Mountbatten, London: Collins, p. 679, ISBN 0-00-216543-0 
  143. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 270; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 273
  144. ^ Klier and Mingay, p. 132
  145. ^ Kurth, Anastasia, p. 268; von Nidda in I, Anastasia, p. 274
  146. ^ a b The Problem of Anastasia: Two films on a single pitiful theme, The Times (53770), 20 February 1957: 11 
  147. ^ Wardle, Irving (18 August 1978), New angle on the Anastasia affair, The Times (60383): 10 
  148. ^ Percival, John (23 July 1971), Reworked ballet short on dancing, The Times (58232): 16 
  149. ^ Percival, John (11 October 1971), Anastasia, The Times (58295): 10 
  150. ^ Vàmos, Youri, Sleeping Beauty – Last Daughter of the Czar, retrieved 15 March 2010 
  151. ^ Erickson, Hal, Anastasia: The Mystery of Anna, All Movie Guide (Macrovision Corporation), retrieved 8 July 2009 
  152. ^ Goldberg, Carey (9 November 1997), After the Revolution, Comes 'Anastasia' the Cartoon, New York Times, retrieved 26 September 2010 
  153. ^ Anastasia, Sky Movies, retrieved 8 July 2009 

References[edit]

  • I, Anastasia: An autobiography with notes by Roland Krug von Nidda translated from the German by Oliver Coburn, London: Michael Joseph, 1958 
  • Clarke, William (2007), Romanoff Gold: The Lost Fortune of the Tsars, Stroud: Sutton Publishing, ISBN 978-0-7509-4499-1 
  • Hall, Coryne (1999), Little Mother of Russia: A Biography of Empress Marie Feodorovna, London: Shepheard-Walwyn, ISBN 0-85683-177-8 
  • King, Greg; Wilson, Penny (2011), The Resurrection of the Romanovs, Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons, ISBN 978-0-470-44498-6 
  • Klier, John; Mingay, Helen (1995), The Quest for Anastasia, London: Smith Gryphon, ISBN 1-85685-085-4 
  • Kurth, Peter (1983), Anastasia: The Life of Anna Anderson, London: Jonathan Cape, ISBN 0-224-02951-7 
  • Kurth, Peter (1995), Tsar, Toronto: Little, Brown, ISBN 0-316-50787-3 
  • Lovell, James Blair (1991), Anastasia: The Lost Princess, London: Robson Books, ISBN 0-86051-807-8 
  • Massie, Robert K. (1995), The Romanovs: The Final Chapter, London: Random House, ISBN 0-09-960121-4 
  • Van der Kiste, John; Hall, Coryne (2002), Once A Grand Duchess: Xenia, Sister of Nicholas II, Phoenix Mill: Sutton Publishing, ISBN 0-7509-2749-6 
  • Welch, Frances (2007), A Romanov Fantasy: Life at the Court of Anna Anderson, New York: W.W. Norton & Co, ISBN 978-0-393-06577-0 

External links[edit]