Australian referendum, 1946 (Social Services)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Constitution Alteration (Social Services) 1946 proposed to extend the powers of government over a range of social services. The question was put to a referendum in the Australian referendum, 1946 with two other (unrelated) questions. It was carried and inserted s51(xxiiiA) into section 51 of the Australian Constitution. The amendment was carried, inserting s51(xxiiiA) into the constitution.

Question[edit]

Do you approve of the proposed law for the alteration of the Constitution entitled 'Constitution Alteration (Social Services) 1946'?

Results[edit]

For Against
Votes  %54.39  %45.61
States 6 0
State On rolls Ballots issued For Against Informal
Votes  % Votes  %
New South Wales 1,858,749 1,757,150 897,887 %54.00 764,723 %46.00 94,540
Victoria 1,345,537 1,261,374 671,967 %55.98 528,452 %44.02 60,955
Queensland 660,316 612,170 299,205 %51.26 284,465 %48.74 28,500
South Australia 420,361 399,301 197,395 %51.73 184,172 %48.27 17,734
Western Australia 300,337 279,066 164,017 %62.26 99,412 %37.74 15,637
Tasmania 154,553 144,880 67,463 %50.58 65,924 %49.42 11,493
Armed forces*   37,021 22,824   13,211   986
Total for Commonwealth 4,739,853 4,453,941 2,297,934 %54.39 1,927,148 %45.61 228,859
  • Armed forces totals are also included in their respective states.

Discussion[edit]

This was one of the few (eight) referendum questions which were successfully passed.

Section 51 of the Australian Constitution grants the commonwealth legislative power. Prior to this amendment the only social services provision was s51(xxiii) that gave power to legislate for invalid and old-age pensions. This amendment introduced s51(xxiiiA), which reads:

s51(xxiiiA.) The provision of maternity allowances, widows' pensions, child endowment, unemployment, pharmaceutical, sickness and hospital benefits, medical and dental services (but not so as to authorise any form of civil conscription), benefits to students and family allowances:

Notably, federal legislation already existed on a number of these issues despite the lack of a clear constitutional basis: child endowment payments were introduced in 1941, widow’s pensions in 1942, and unemployment benefits (commonwealth) in 1945. These payments were based on the spending power (s81). However, in the Pharmaceutical Benefits Case (Attorney-General (Victoria); Ex rel Dale v Commonwealth) constitutional questions were raised about the validity of Commonwealth social security legislation based on s81. The High Court held unconstitutional the Pharmaceutical Benefits Act 1944, which sought to introduce a scheme of subsidised medications, because it was not supported by a section 51 head of power and could not be supported by s81.

The amendment was therefore intended to clarify and enshrine the existence of a power that was already being exercised and received bipartisan support. This perhaps explains why this amendment was carried, given that it was already accepted as an area of Commonwealth activity. In addition, a ‘no’ vote could have ended welfare programs from which voters were benefiting.

After the amendment the Social Services Consolidation Act 1947 was passed. In addition the Pharmaceutical Benefits scheme, held unconstitutional in the Pharmaceutical Benefits case, was reintroduced and passed as the Pharmaceutical Benefits Act 1947.

External sources[edit]

Preceded by
2nd State Debts Amendment (1928)
Australian referendum
1946
Succeeded by
Aboriginals Amendment (1967)