Death of Baby P
1 March 2006|
|Died||3 August 2007
Cause of death
Peter Connelly (also known as "Baby P", "Child A", and "Baby Peter") was a 17-month-old English boy who died in London after suffering more than fifty injuries over an eight-month period, during which he was repeatedly seen by Haringey Children's services and NHS health professionals. Baby P's real first name was revealed as "Peter" on the conclusion of a subsequent trial of Peter's mother's boyfriend on a charge of raping a two-year-old. His full identity was revealed when his killers were named after the expiry of a court anonymity order on 10 August 2009.
The case caused shock and concern among the public and in Parliament, partly because of the magnitude of Peter's injuries, and partly because Peter had lived in the London Borough of Haringey, North London, under the same child care authorities that had already failed ten years earlier in the case of Victoria Climbié. That had led to a public enquiry which resulted in measures being put in place in an effort to prevent similar cases happening.
Peter's mother Tracey Connelly, her boyfriend Steven Barker, and Jason Owen (later revealed to be the brother of Barker) were all convicted of causing or allowing the death of a child, the mother having pleaded guilty to the charge. A court order issued by the High Court in England had prevented the publication of the identity of Baby P; this was lifted on 1 May 2009 by Mr Justice Coleridge. An order sought by Haringey Council to stop publication of the identities of his mother and her boyfriend was granted, but expired on 10 August 2009.
The child protection services of Haringey and other agencies were widely criticised. Following the conviction, three inquiries and a nationwide review of social service care were launched, and the Head of Children's Services at Haringey was removed by direction of the government minister. Another nationwide review was conducted by Lord Laming into his own recommendations concerning Victoria Climbié's killing in 2000. The death was also the subject of debate in the House of Commons.
Peter Connelly was born to Tracey Connelly on 1 March 2006. In November, Connelly's new boyfriend, Steven Barker, moved in with her. In December, a GP noticed bruises on Peter's face and chest. His mother was arrested and Peter was put into the care of a family friend, but returned home to his mother's care in January 2007. Over the next few months, Peter was admitted to hospital on two occasions suffering from injuries including bruising, scratches and swelling on the side of the head. Connelly was arrested again in May 2007.
In June 2007, a social worker observed marks on Peter and informed the police. A medical examination concluded that the bruising was due to abuse. On 4 June, the baby was placed with a friend for safeguarding. Over a month later, on 25 July, Haringey Council's Children & Young People's Service obtained legal advice which indicated that the "threshold for initiating Care Proceedings...was not met".
On 1 August 2007, Baby Peter was seen at St. Ann's Hospital in north London by locum paediatrician Dr. Sabah Al-Zayyat. Serious injuries, including a broken back and broken ribs, very likely went undetected (the autopsy report believed these to have pre-dated Al-Zayyat's examination). A day later, Connelly was informed that she would not be prosecuted.
The next day, an ambulance was called and Peter was found in his cot, blue and clad only in a nappy. After attempts at resuscitation, he was taken to North Middlesex hospital with his mother but was pronounced dead at 12:20 pm. A post-mortem revealed he had swallowed a tooth after being punched. Other injuries included a broken back, broken ribs, mutilated fingertips and fingernails missing.
The police immediately began a murder investigation and Baby P's mother was arrested. So too were Barker, his brother Jason Owen and his 15-year-old girlfriend, who had fled to and were hiding in a campsite in Epping Forest.
On 11 November 2008, Owen, 36, and his brother Barker, 32, were found guilty of "causing or allowing the death of a child or vulnerable person". Connelly, 27, had pleaded guilty to this charge. Earlier in the trial, Owen and Connelly had been cleared of murder due to insufficient evidence. Barker was found not guilty of murder by a jury.
A second trial occurred in April 2009, when Connelly and Barker, under aliases, faced charges related to the rape of a two-year old girl. The girl was also on Haringey's child protection register. Barker was found guilty of rape, while Connelly was found not guilty of child cruelty charges. Their defence lawyers argued that this second trial was nearly undermined by bloggers publishing information (linking them to the death of Peter) which could have prejudiced the jury.
Sentencing for both trials together took place on 22 May 2009 at the Old Bailey. Connelly was ordered to be held indefinitely, until "deemed no longer to be a risk to the public and in particular to small children", with a minimum term of five years. Barker was sentenced to life imprisonment for the rape, with a minimum sentence of ten years, and a 12-year sentence for his role in the death of Peter, to run concurrently. Owen was also jailed indefinitely, and would serve at least three years. The sentences were criticised as too lenient by the NSPCC's chief executive, and the Attorney General considered referring them to the Court of Appeal for review, but concluded there was "no realistic prospect" of the Court of Appeal increasing the sentences. The three appealed against their sentences, Barker against both convictions and sentences.
Haringey Council initiated an internal audit Serious Case Review (SCR) after Peter's death. After completion of the court case, only an executive summary was released to the public. The full report was kept confidential, with only some employees of Haringey Council and Haringey Labour councillors allowed access. The two local MPs whose constituencies cover Haringey (Lynne Featherstone and David Lammy), leader of the opposition Robert Gorrie, and opposition spokesperson for Children's Services were asked to sign non-disclosure agreements to view the document. Ed Balls condemned the Serious Case Review and called for a second report with an independent adjudicator.
The Mail on Sunday on 15 March 2009 reported that details of the SCR had come into its possession. The article claimed that the executive summary of the SCR either conflicted or omitted details about how the case had been handled and the extent of the injuries suffered by Peter. Furthermore, there were instances of mishandling by officials, missed and delayed meetings, miscommunication among officials, and a failure to follow through with decisions related to the child's safety. It also noted among other issues that officials had not followed through with obtaining an "interim care order" that would have removed Peter from his home when they had agreed that legal grounds had existed for doing so six months before he died; key officials also failed to attend a 25 July 2007 meeting intended to decide if it would be necessary to remove Peter from his mother's home at that time.
External reports and inquiries
Lynne Featherstone MP was critical of Haringey Council, writing "I personally met with George Meehan and Ita O'Donovan - Haringey Council's leader and chief executive - to raise with them three different cases, where the pattern was in each case Haringey seeming to want to blame anyone who complained rather than to look at the complaint seriously. I was promised action - but despite repeated subsequent requests for news on progress - I was just stonewalled."
Three council workers, including one senior lawyer, were given written warnings about their actions.
The GMC separately examined the roles of two doctors — Dr. Jerome Ikwueke, a GP, and Dr. Sabah Al-Zayyat, who examined Peter two days before his death. Although Dr. Ikwueke had twice referred Peter to hospital specialists, the GMC's Interim Orders Panel suspended Dr. Ikwueke for 18 months. Dr. Al-Zayyat, who has been accused of failing to spot his injuries, was suspended pending an inquiry. Her contract with Great Ormond Street Hospital, responsible for child services in Haringey, has also been terminated.
Ed Balls, Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families, ordered an external inquiry into Haringey Council Social Services. The inquiry was not to examine the 'Baby P' case explicitly, but look into whether Haringey Social Services were following correct procedures in general. This report was presented to ministers on 1 December 2008. During a press conference that day, the Minister announced that, in an unusual move, he had used special powers to remove Sharon Shoesmith from her post of head of children's services at Haringey Council. She rejected calls for her resignation, saying that she wanted to continue to support her staff during the investigations, but was dismissed on 8 December 2008, by Haringey Council, without any compensation package. Shoesmith later brought legal proceedings against Ed Balls, Ofsted, and Haringey Council, claiming that the decisions which led to her dismissal were unfair. The High Court dismissed this claim in April 2010, although Shoesmith was still entitled to pursue an action for unfair dismissal in an Employment Tribunal. In May 2011, Shoesmith's appeal against that succeeded in the Court of Appeal; the Department of Education and Haringey Council said they intended to appeal to the Supreme Court against this decision. Their applications for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court were refused on 1 August 2011. It was reported by BBC News on 29 October 2013 that Sharon Shoesmith agreed a six-figure payout for unfair dismissal.
Also announced on 1 December 2008, were the resignations of Labour Council leader George Meehan and councillor Liz Santry, cabinet member for Children and Young People. These councillors had previously refused calls for their resignation during a 24 November council meeting. In April 2009, the council announced that its deputy director of children's services, two other managers and a social worker, who had been suspended pending an enquiry, had also all been dismissed.
Three further inquires were also ordered:
- The role of all agencies involved in Peter Connelly's case, including the health authority, police and Haringey Council, would be reviewed.
- The General Social Care Council would look into potential breaches of its code of practice.
- Lord Laming would conduct a nationwide review of his own recommendations after the Victoria Climbié inquiry.
The DES, now the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF), was sent a letter in February 2007 (six months before the death of Baby P), containing an allegation that child protection procedures were not being followed in Haringey, from a lawyer acting for a former social worker, who sent the letter to the then health secretary, Patricia Hewitt, who merely forwarded the letter on to the DCSF. Haringey Council then took out an injunction against the social worker, Nevres Kemal, banning her from speaking about child care in Haringey. Kemal's lawyer stated: "Hewitt bounced us onto the DES... the DES then advised us to write to the Commission for Social Care Inspection whom we had written to on the same day as we had written to Hewitt, copying in the letter to Hewitt and the relevant material. By that time of course they had an injunction against us so we couldn't go back to the inspectorate. The inspectorate had been properly advised at the time and had done nothing."
Dr Kim Holt, a consultant Paediatrician, who worked in a clinic run by Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital at St Ann's Hospital in Haringey, north London, said she and three colleagues wrote an open letter detailing problems at the clinic in 2006. She claimed baby Peter could have been saved if managers had listened to fears raised by senior doctors.
Report by Lord Laming
Lord Laming published his report, "The Protection of Children in England: A Progress Report" on 12 March 2009. It stated that too many authorities had failed to adopt reforms introduced following his previous review into welfare following the death of Victoria Climbié in 2000.
On 5 March 2012, the natural father of Baby P was awarded £75,000 in damages after The People wrongly stated in its 19 September 2010 edition that he was a convicted sex offender. Lawyers for the man, known only as "KC", said that the publishers of The People were guilty of "one of the gravest libels imaginable". Publishers MGN had previously apologised and offered to pay damages.
- Sam Jones (2008-11-12). "Sixty missed chances to save baby 'used as a punchbag'". London: The Guardian. Retrieved 2008-11-12.
- "The Case of Child A". Haringey Council. 2008-11-12. Retrieved 2008-11-12.[dead link]
- "Baby P man guilty of raping girl". BBC News. 2009-05-01. Retrieved 2009-05-01.
- Campbell, Duncan; Sam Jones and David Brindle (2008-11-12). "50 injuries, 60 visits - failures that led to the death of Baby P". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 2008-11-12.
- "Couple behind Baby P death named". BBC News. 10 August 2009. Retrieved 10 August 2009.
- White, Michael (2008-11-12). "Squabble over Baby P was not the Commons at its best". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 2008-11-12.
- "Men found guilty of baby's death". BBC News. 2008-11-11. Retrieved 2008-11-20.
- Gammell, Caroline (2009-08-11). "Baby P: the battle to name his mother Tracey Connelly and her boyfriend Steven Barker". The Guardian (London).
- Jackson, Guy (2009-05-23). "Mum, stepdad jailed for Baby P's death". Agence France-Presse.
- "What we know of the Baby P case". BBC News. 2008-11-17. Retrieved 2008-11-20.
- "Timeline: Key events in baby case". BBC News. 2008-11-14. Retrieved 2008-11-20.
- "Haringey Local Safeguarding Children Board, Serious Case Review "Child A" - Executive Summary" (PDF). Haringey Council. 2008-11-11. Retrieved 2008-11-20.[dead link]
- "Baby P: The full health dossier". BBC News. 2008-11-18. Retrieved 2008-11-20.
- "Baby P doctor 'deeply affected'". BBC News. 2008-11-19. Retrieved 2008-11-20.
- "Timeline: Key events in baby case". BBC. 2009-08-10. Retrieved 2009-10-14.
- "Nasty, brutish and short: The horrific life of Baby P". The Independent (London). 2008-11-16. Retrieved 2009-10-14.
- "Baby P: catalogue of failings resulted in death". Daily Telegraph (London). 2009-08-11. Retrieved 2009-08-20.
- Willetts, David (2009-08-14). "I found evil stepdad of Baby P in a tent with three machetes". Daily Sun (London). Retrieved 2009-10-14.
- "Two are cleared of murdering baby". BBC News. 2008-10-30. Retrieved 2008-11-25.
- Bennett, Rosemary; Fresco, Adam (2008-11-12). "Investigation called after child murder case with echoes of Climbie". The Times (London). Retrieved 2008-11-25.
- Sandra Laville (1 May 2009). "Baby P killer found guilty of raping two-year-old girl". London: Guardian. Retrieved 2012-02-17.
- Britton, Jeremy (2009-05-22). "Blogs threatened Baby Peter cases". BBC News. Retrieved 2009-05-27.
- "Three jailed over Baby P's death". BBC News. 2009-05-22. Retrieved 2009-05-27.
- "Reaction to Baby P sentences". BBC News. 2009-05-22. Retrieved 2009-05-27.
- "Baby P jail terms to be reviewed". BBC News. 2009-05-27. Retrieved 2009-05-27.
- "Baby P three in sentence appeal". BBC News. 2009-08-20. Retrieved 2009-08-20.
- Allen, Vanessa (2009-06-17). "Baby P jail sentences will NOT be increased as Attorney General backs down". Daily Mail (London). Retrieved 2009-10-14.
- "Haringey Full Council Meeting 24th November Webcast". Haringey Council. 2008-11-24. Retrieved 2008-11-24.
- Balls, Ed (2008-12-01). "Baby P: Ed Balls' statement in full". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 2009-10-14.
- Walters, Simon; Daniel Boffey (2009-03-15). "Baby P boss in £1m sex bias claim as we reveal explosive report Ed Balls refused to make public". Daily Mail (London). Retrieved 2009-03-17.
- "Review of Baby P's death leaked". BBC. 2009-03-15. Retrieved 2009-03-17.
- "A litany of failure by Haringey". Lynne Featherstone MP. Retrieved 2008-11-26.[dead link]
- "Doctor suspended in Baby P probe". BBC News. 2009-02-19. Retrieved 2009-02-19.
- "Doctor suspended in Baby P probe". BBC News. 2008-11-27. Retrieved 2008-11-27.
- Shoesmith v Ofsted  EWHC 852 (Admin) (23 April 2010)
- Bell, Vanessa (2008-12-03). "'Baby P was clumsy with a high pain threshold,' Council's astonishing verdict on toddler as it emerges officials are investigating ANOTHER abuse case". Daily Mail (London). Retrieved 2009-10-15.
- "Sacked Baby P chief defends case". BBC News. 2009-02-07. Retrieved 2009-03-17.
- "Statement on Sharon Shoesmith".
- Harrison, Angela (2010-04-23). "Baby Peter sacking was lawful". BBC News. Retrieved 2010-04-27.
- "'Up to Â£1m payout' for Sharon Shoesmith". The Independent (London). 2011-05-27.
- "Applications for Permission to Appeal" (PDF). Retrieved 2012-02-17.
- Baby Peter case: Sharon Shoesmith agrees six-figure payout BBC News, 29 October 2013. Retrieved 29 October 2013.
- "Official sacked over Baby P case". BBC News. 2008-12-01. Retrieved 2008-12-01.
- "Baby P councillors told to resign". BBC News. 2008-11-24. Retrieved 2008-11-25.
- "Councillors survive Baby P calls". BBC News. 2008-11-24. Retrieved 2008-11-25.
- Beckford, Martin (2009-04-29). "Baby P: Haringey Council sacks three managers and a social worker". The Telegraph (London). Retrieved 2009-10-15.
- Bingham, John (2008-11-14). "Baby P: Whistleblower's concerns about care scandal council 'pushed from pillar to post'". The Telegraph (London). Retrieved 2009-10-15.
- "Hospital criticised ahead of Baby P report". Health Service JOurnal. 7 December 2009. Retrieved 14 March 2014.
- The Lord Laming (2009-03-12). "The Protection of Children in England: A Progress Report" (PDF). The Stationery Office. Retrieved 2009-03-12.
- "Action pledged over child safety". BBC News. 2009-03-12. Retrieved 2009-03-12.
- "Baby P's father gets £75k libel damages from The People". BBC News. 2012-03-05. Retrieved 2012-03-05.