Barge Haulers on the Volga
Barge Haulers on the Volga or Burlaki (Russian: Burlaki na Volge, Бурлаки на Волге) is an 1870–1873 oil-on-canvas painting by the Russian realist painter and sculptor Ilya Repin. The work depicts 11 labouring men dragging a barge on the Volga River. The men seem to almost collapse forward in exhaustion under the burden of hauling a large boat upstream in heavy, hot weather.
The work is both a celebration of the men's dignity and fortitude, and a highly emotional condemnation of those who sanctioned such inhumane labour. Although they are presented as stoical and accepting, the men are largely defeated; only one stands out: in the centre of both the row and canvas, a brightly coloured youth fights against his leather binds and takes on a heroic poise.
Repin conceived the painting during his travels through Russia as a young man and depicts actual characters he encountered. It drew international praise for its realistic portrayal of the hardships of working men, and launched his career. Soon after its completion, the painting was purchased by Grand Duke Vladimir Alexandrovich and exhibited widely throughout Europe as a landmark of Russian realist painting. Barge Haulers on the Volga has been described as "perhaps the most famous painting of the Peredvizhniki movement [for]....its unflinching portrayal of backbreaking labour".
Repin was accepted into the Imperial Academy of Art in St Petersburg in 1863. The academy at the time was known for its deep conservatism and leaning towards academic art, a fact that bred a sense of revolt and desire for change in many of its students.
Barge Haulers is inspired by scenes witnessed by the artist while holidaying on the Volga in 1870. He made a number of preparatory studies, mostly in oil, while staying in Shiriaev Buerak, near Stavropol. The sketches include landscapes, and views of the Volga and barge haulers.
The characters depicted are based on actual people whom the artist came to know while preparing the work. He had had difficulty finding subjects to pose for him, even for a fee, because of a folklorish belief that a subject's soul would leave his possession once his image was put down on paper. The subjects include a former soldier, a former priest, and a painter. Although Repin depicted eleven men, women also performed the work and there were normally many more people in a barge-hauling gang; Repin selected these figures as representative of a broad swathe of the working classes of Russian society. That some had once held relatively high social positions dismayed the young artist, who had initially planned to produce a far more superficial work contrasting exuberant day-trippers (which he himself had been) with the careworn burlaks. Repin found a particular empathy with Kanin, the defrocked priest, who is portrayed as the lead hauler and looks outwards towards the viewer. The artist wrote,
- "There was something eastern about it, the face of a Scyth...and what eyes! What depth of vision!...And his brow, so large and wise...He seemed to me a colossal mystery, and for that reason I loved him. Kanin, with a rag around his head, his head in patches made by himself and then worn out, appeared none the less as a man of dignity; he was like a saint."
Barge Haulers on the Volga shows a row of eleven male burlaks dragging a barge on the Volga River that must be pulled upstream against the current. The men are dressed in rags and bound with leather harnesses. They are rendered as mostly stoical, although in obvious physical discomfort, with their bodies bowed in toil. The scene is rendered in a white, silvery light which has been described as "almost Venetian". In earlier studies, it was dominated by blue tones.
The men appear to be unsupervised and form the focus of the picture, with the barge relegated to a minor role at the rear of the frame. Further in the distance is a tiny steam-powered boat, perhaps a suggestion that the back-breaking labour of the barge haulers is no longer necessary in the industrial age. Also worthy of note is the inverted Russian flag flying from the main mast of the barge suggesting adding to the sense that something is not quite right. Repin echoes the stop-go rhythm of the labour in the undulating line of the workers' heads. In the preparatory studies, many of the figures were positioned differently; for example the second man was shown wearing a cap with his head bowed into his chest.
There is a general sense of mounting exhaustion and despair moving from left to right amongst the group; the last hauler seems oblivious to his surroundings and drifts from the line out towards the viewer. The exception is a fair-haired boy in the centre of the group. Set brightly against the uniform muted tones of his companions, his head is raised looking into the distance, while he pulls against his straps as if determined to free himself from his task.
Repin grew up in Chuguev in the Ukraine and was aware of the poverty and hardship of most rural life at that time. He spent two years travelling during which time he observed both the dachas of the rich and the toil of the common peasant. As such it can be considered a genre painting, but treated on the heroic scale of history painting, as was often the case in 19th-century works, especially after A Burial At Ornans by Gustave Courbet (1850). Barge Haulers drew direct comparisons from critics with Millet's works and Courbet's The Stone Breakers (also 1850), which showed labourers at the side of a road.
The painting is a relentlessly physical description of the men; Repin was attracted by their strength and superhuman effort. According to critic Vladimir Stassov, "They are like a group of forest Hercules with their dishevelled heads, their sun-tanned chests, and their motionlessly hanging, strong-veined hands. What glances from untamed eyes, what distended nostrils, what iron muscles!" In his description of their heavy brows and the lined foreheads, Repin does not neglect their spiritual torment; although he does not concentrate too much on any single man's personal intimate emotions. Any sense of personal hardship is of secondary importance to the portrayal of effort and human dignity.
Critical opinion and legacy
Repin considered Barge Haulers to be his first professional painting and it is the work that defined him as a master documentarian of social inequality. When first exhibited, it received enthusiastic reviews for its unsentimental depiction of lower-class labourers, which stood in stark contrast to the romanticised, classical or propagandist nature of most contemporary Russian art. The painting paved the way for Repin to join the Peredvizhniki (the Wanderers or Itinerants), an anti-academic realist movement formed in 1870. The Peredvizhniki sought not only to break away from the academic school, but also to subvert the manner in which art was viewed. By depicting scenes from ordinary life and holding exhibitions in the provinces they aimed to enlighten and make art more accessible to the masses.
The painting was widely discussed for its break with the traditions of the Academy. It earned Repin the respect of Stasov who believed that art shaped people's outlook and the way in which they viewed their own political situation. Stasov encouraged Repin to focus on Russian subject matter and after Barge Haulers became a close friend of the artist and enthusiastically praised each of Repin's paintings thereafter. Stasov wrote of the painting, "with a daring that is unprecedented amongst us [Repin] has abandoned all former conceptions of the ideal in art, and has plunged head first into the very heart of the people's life, the people's interests, and the people's oppressive reality... no one in Russia has ever dared take on such a subject". In return, Repin said that Stasov's "cry all over Russia was the first and the mightiest and it was heard in Russia by everyone capable of hearing. It was thanks to him that my glory spread."
Fyodor Dostoyevsky read about Repin's painting in the newspapers and assumed it was another Russian work whose artistry was secondary to its social message. He wrote, "Even the subject itself is terrible... I came expecting to see these barge-haulers all lined up in uniforms with the usual labels stuck to their foreheads... To my delight, all my fears turned out to be in vain... Not a single one of them shouts from the painting to the viewer, 'Look how unfortunate I am and how indebted you are to the people!'" To Dostoyevsky, Repin had avoided a common fault of contemporary Russian art, and in doing so had heightened the work's impact. He concluded, "[I saw] barge haulers, real barge haulers, and nothing more... you can't help but think you are indebted, truly indebted, to the people." Such a feeling of an "unpaid debt" owed by the higher society to the peasantry was a common idea of the Narodniks. Today the painting is regarded as seminal in the formation of Russian realism.
The painting has been criticised both for still bearing hallmarks of academic drawing and for having an overall yellowish tone. Although it won a prize at the Society for the Advancement of the Arts in 1872, Repin continued to rework the canvas until 1873 when it was exhibited at the Academy of Arts in Saint Petersburg.
Because of the work's popularity it has been widely parodied, and is often used as the basis for satirical political cartoons in Russia. It was inspired by the well-known Russian folk song "The Song of the Volga Boatmen".
Despite its progressive implications, Barge Haulers was bought by the Tsar's second son. It was lent for exhibition at the 1873 International Exhibition in Vienna, where it won a bronze medal. It was exhibited outside Russia again in 1878, when it was again widely praised by critics for marking a watershed in Russian art. After the Russian Revolution the grand duke's art collection was nationalized and transferred from Vladimir Palace to the Russian Museum.
- Frank, Joseph. "Dostoevsky: The Mantle of the Prophet, 1871–1881". Princeton University Press, 2003. 111. ISBN 0-691-11569-9
- Not long after Repin's painting, burlakis were replaced by steam powered tug-boats
- Gray, Rosalind Polly & Blakesley, Rosalind Polly. Russian genre painting in the nineteenth century. Alderley: Clarendon Press, 2000. ix. ISBN 0-19-820875-8
- Hilton, Alison. "The Exhibition of Experiments in St. Petersburg and the Independent Sketch". The Art Bulletin, Volume 70, No. 4, December, 1988. 677–698
- "Ilya Repin, Barge-Haulers on the Volga (1870–73)". The Museum of Russian Art. Retrieved 18 January 2010.
- King, Averil. "Russia's soul in paint: Averil King welcomes a well-illustrated account of Ilya Repin's powerful, virtuoso art". Apollo, October 2007. Retrieved on 27 February 2010.
- "Study of a Barge Hauler for the painting 'The Barge Haulers on the Volga' 1870–1873". Christie's, November 1997. Retrieved on 27 February 2010.
- Emerson, Caryl. The life of Musorgsky. In: "Musical lives". Cambridge University Press, 1999. 127. ISBN 0-521-48507-X
- Amery, Colin. "St Petersburg". Frances Lincoln, 2006. 134. ISBN 0-7112-2492-7
- Parker & Parker, 23
- Amery, Colin & Curran, Brian. "St Petersburg". Frances Lincoln, 2006. 134. ISBN 0-7112-2492-7
- Bolton (1999), 138
- Stasov , Vladimir Vasilyevich. "Letter to the Editor of 'St. Petersburg Gazette' (1873)". Saint Petersburg Gazette, no. 176, 18 March 1873. Retrieved 22 July 2010.
- Cohen, Aaron J. "Imagining the unimaginable: World War, modern art, & the politics of public culture in Russia, 1914–1917". Studies in war, society, and the military. University of Nebraska Press, 2008. 25. ISBN 0-8032-1547-9
- Valkenier (1993), 208
- Alpatov, 251
- Alpatov, 252
- Bolton, 114
- "Nineteenth-Century Russian Art: Ideological Realism". dartmouth.edu. Retrieved on 18 January 2010.
- Bolton, 156
- Chandler, Josh. "Vladimir Vasilievich Stasov and Soviet Socialist Realism". germslav.byu.edu. Retrieved on 27 February 2010.
- Miller, Robin Feuer. Dostoevsky's unfinished journey. Yale University Press, 2007. 11. ISBN 0-300-12015-X
- Parker Fran. "Russia on canvas: Ilya Repin". Pennsylvania State University Press, 1980. 26. ISBN 0-271-00252-2
- Kabanov, Elia (2011). "Бурлаки на Ниле". Retrieved 9 March 2011.
- "Государственный Русский музей". art.1september.ru. Retrieved on 31 July 2010.
- Alpatov, Mikhail. Russian Impact on Art. New York: Philosophical Library, 1950.
- Bolton, Roy. Russia & Europe in the Nineteenth Century. London: Sphinx Books, 1999. ISBN 1-907200-02-9
- Bolton, Roy & Strachan, Edward. Views of Russia & Russian Works on Paper. London: Sphinx Books, 2010. ISBN 978-1-907200-05-2
- Parker, Fan & Parker, Stephen Jan. Russia on canvas: Ilya Repin. Pennsylvania State University Press, 1981. ISBN 0-271-00252-2
- Rice, Tamara Talbot. A Concise History of Russian Art. New York: Frederick A. Praeger, 1963. ISBN 0-19-520002-0
- Sternin, Grigory. IIlya Efimovich Repin: Painter of Russian History. USSR, 1995. ISBN 0-569-08846-1
- Valkenier, Elizabeth Kridl. "The Writer as Artist's Model: Repin's Portrait of Garshin". Metropolitan Museum Journal, 28, 1993. 207–16
- Valkenier, Elizabeth Kridl. Ilya Repin and the World of Russian Art. New York: Columbia University Press, 1990. ISBN 0-231-06964-2