Best evidence rule

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The best evidence rule is a legal principle that holds an original copy of a document as superior evidence. The rule specifies that secondary evidence, such as a copy or facsimile, will be not admissible if an original document exists and can be obtained. [1] The rule has its roots in 18th century, British law.[2]

History and description[edit]

The best evidence rule has its origins in the 18th century case Omychund v Barker (1745) 1 Atk, 21, 49; 26 ER 15, 33. Wherein Lord Harwicke stated that no evidence was admissible unless it was "the best that the nature of the case will allow". [2][3]

According to Blackstone's Criminal Practice the best evidence rule in Britain and Wales as used in earlier centuries "is now all but defunct".[4] Lord Denning MR says that "nowadays we do not confine ourselves to the best evidence. We admit all relevant evidence. The goodness or badness of it goes only to weight and not to admissibility."[5]

In the USA the best evidence rule is part of Article X of the Federal Rules of Evidence (Rules 1001-1008).[6] The rule specifies the guidelines under which one of the parties of a court case may request that they be allowed to submit into evidence a copy of the contents of a document, recording or photograph at a trial when the "original document is not available."[6][7] If the party is able to provide an acceptable reason for the absence of the original then "secondary evidence" or copies of the content in the original document can be admitted as evidence. The best evidence rule is only applied in situations where a party attempts to substantiate a non-original document submitted as evidence during a trial. [7]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Staff writer. "Legal Terms and Definitions". Law Dictionary. ALM Network of Legal Publications. 
  2. ^ a b Staff writer. Rottenstein Law Group LLC. Rottenstein Law Group http://www.rotlaw.com/legal-library/what-is-the-best-evidence-rule/. Retrieved Feb 16, 2015.  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  3. ^ The Law of Evidence Dublin 1754
  4. ^ Hooper, Ormerod, Murphy and others (ed.). Blackstone's Criminal Practice (2008 ed.). Oxford. p. 2285. ISBN 978-0-19-922814-0. 
  5. ^ Garton v. Hunter [1969] 1 All ER 451, [1969] 2 QB 37
  6. ^ a b Miller, Colin. "Evidence: Best Evidence Rule". Center for Computer Assisted Legal Instruction. CALI. Retrieved Feb 16, 2015. 
  7. ^ a b Unknown author. "Best Evidence Rule". Cornell University Law School. Retrieved Feb 16, 2015. 

External links[edit]