Blackboard Inc.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Blackboard Inc)
Jump to: navigation, search
For the supplier of fundraising software, see Blackbaud.
Blackboard Inc
Type Privately held
Industry Educational technology
Founded Washington, D.C., U.S. 1997
Founders Michael Chasen, Matthew Pittinsky
Headquarters Washington, D.C., United States
Number of locations 18
Area served Worldwide
Key people Jay Bhatt, President and CEO
Services Platform and enterprise consulting, managed hosting, student and training services, online program management[1]
Employees 3,000[2]
Parent Providence Equity Partners

Blackboard Inc. is an enterprise technology company with corporate headquarters in Washington, D.C. that is primarily known as a developer of education software, in particular Blackboard Learn, its flagship learning management system.[3] The company's CEO is Jay Bhatt, who has led Blackboard since October 2012. Blackboard provides education, mobile, communication, and commerce software and related services to clients including education providers, corporations and government organizations. The firm has seven platforms called Learn, Transact, Engage, Connect, Mobile, Collaborate and Analytics that are offered in bundled solutions. Blackboard was founded by Michael Chasen, Matthew Pittinsky, Stephen Gilfus and Daniel Cane in 1997, and became a public company in 2004. It operated publicly until Providence Equity Partners purchased the company in 2011. As of January 2014, its software and services are used by approximately 17,000 schools and organizations in 100 countries.[4] Seventy-five percent of US colleges and universities and more than half of K–12 districts in the United States use its products and services.[5]


Early history[edit]

Blackboard Llc. was founded in 1997 by Michael Chasen and Matthew Pittinsky and began as a consulting firm contracting to the non-profit IMS Global Learning Consortium.[6] Chasen and Pittinsky started Blackboard upon leaving KPMG Consulting where they both had worked as part of the company’s Higher Education practice.[7] In 1998, the company merged with CourseInfo LLC, a small course management software provider that originated at Cornell University and was founded by Daniel Cane and Stephen Gilfus.[7][8] The combined company became known as Blackboard Inc. The first line of e-learning products was branded Blackboard CourseInfo,[9] until the CourseInfo brand was dropped in 2000.[10] The new company made a profit in its first year, and its sales in 1998 approached US$1 million.[7]

Company growth[edit]

In 2001, Blackboard acquired AT&T Campuswide and CEI Special Teams, developers of ID cards that can be used for campus commerce and security.[11] The firm began expansion overseas in the early 2000s, growing to include Asia, Australia and Europe in its service area.[12] As of January 2001, the company was providing its software services to over 1,500 clients.[13] Through a partnership with a Chinese education company, Blackboard also began providing software services to many universities in China.[14] By the late 1990s and early 2000s, the company had become the leading learning management system[15] This expansion was initially funded through venture capital from a number of investors, including Pearson PLC, Dell, AOL, The Carlyle Group and Novak Biddle Venture Partners.[13][16]

Blackboard went public in June 2004 under the stock market ticker BBBB.[17] Sale of shares in the initial public offering raised an estimated $70 million for the company.[15]

In October 2005, the company announced that it was acquiring WebCT Inc., its largest rival in the education software industry.[18] Through the acquisition, Blackboard gained over 1,400 institutional customers as well as 274 employees.[18] In the two years leading to the merger, Blackboard's most significant growth was in the elementary and secondary education client sector.[18] According to market research company Eduventures, the merger with WebCT increased the firm's share of the higher-education market to between 65 and 75 percent.[19]

Recent expansion[edit]

Over the next five years, the company invested in a series of new products and acquisitions, expanding beyond the learning management system market.[20] Among these: ANGEL Learning, an education software developer whose acquisition expanded Blackboard's client base to nearly 6,000 educational institutions, companies and government agencies, in 2009;[21] Stanford University student-run TerribyClever Design, LLC, whose iPhone application provided the basis for the Blackboard Mobile division to develop the service for other university campuses, in July 2009;[22] Blackboard Collaborate brought together Wimba, Inc. and Elluminate, Inc., in July 2010; Blackboard Analytics formed when the firm acquired iStrategy, a data analysis firm, in December 2010;[20] Blackboard Student Services was developed from Presidium Inc., a provider of administrative and academic support services, in January 2011.[23] The Transact unit expanded in August 2014 with the buyout of Cardsmith, a leading competitor in campus commerce and access platforms. [24]


On July 1, 2011, Blackboard agreed to a $1.64 billion buyout by an investor group led by Providence Equity Partners, which was completed on October 4.[25][26] Immediately following the acquisition, the company merged with Edline, which is also owned by Providence Equity Partners.[27] Edline provides online communications software for K-12 schools and, in June 2012, was renamed Blackboard Engage.[28][29] In March 2012 Blackboard acquired two companies based on Moodle's open-source software including Baltimore-based Moodlerooms Inc. and NetSpot of Adelaide, Australia.[30]

Jay Bhatt succeeded Chasen as CEO of the company in October 2012.[31] In January 2014, Blackboard purchased Austin-based online education company MyEdu, which provides education and career planning tools for college students. The acquisition was the first under Bhatt's leadership and was seen as a step toward a new focus on student-based software according to The Washington Post.[32]


Blackboard Inc. headquarters at 650 Massachusetts Ave NW, in Washington, D.C.

Blackboard Inc. is a provider of enterprise software and mobile applications, communications and commerce services, primarily to the education industry.[33] It is best known as the developer of Blackboard Learning System, a learning platform for higher education, K-12, and professional education institutions. It also offers its products and services to businesses and government organizations.[34] Since the late 2000s, the company has expanded beyond its learning management system. The company launched five separately licensed products and complementary services between 2008 and 2011, including communications, mobile, collaboration and analytics tools through technologies gained in the acquisition of companies such as iStrategy, Wimba, Elluminate[20] and Edline LLC.

Though previously a public company, following its 2011 buyout by Providence Equity Partners Blackboard now operates as a private company.[27][35] The company's leadership consists of president and CEO Jay Bhatt, CFO Bill Davis,[36] SVP of Product Management Mark Strassman, SVP of Product Development Gary Lang, SVP of International Matt Small, SVP of Marketing Tracey Stout,[37] SVP of Education Services Katie Blot,[38] SVP of K-12 Mark Belles,[39] SVP of Higher Education, Corporate & Government Markets Maurice Heiblum, and SVP of Blackboard Transact David Marr.[40] The company's headquarters are in Washington, D.C. and it has offices in Asia, Australia, Europe and in several locations in North America.[33]

Products and services[edit]

Blackboard Learn[edit]

The first product to be offered by the company was its course management software, first available in 1998.[9][17] The latest version, Blackboard Learn 9.1, was released in April 2010.[41] Blackboard Learn is a learning management system that provides a learning system for course delivery and management for institutions; a community and portal system for communication; a content management system for centralized control over course content; and a system to record and analyze student assessment results.[22][42][43]

Though Blackboard's Learn software is proprietary, developers are able to extend the functionality of the system, and create customized course management and delivery by developing software and applications known as Building Blocks[10] which allows third-party developers to create customizations and extensions for Blackboard Learn through open APIs and web services.[44] In 2011, the firm launched CourseSites, a free version of its Blackboard Learn and Collaborate software, for which it provides hosting and support.[45]

In 2012, TechCrunch writer Rip Empson commented that Blackboard's focus on acquisitions prevented the company from fully focusing on their software products, which has led to the continual introduction of additional features, known as feature creep.[46]

Other products[edit]

Blackboard Collaborate was created in July 2010[20] and is used by K-12 schools and higher education institutions for professional development and distance learning. It is written in Java. The Open University is one client for the software, which is being phased in as a replace for Elluminate.[47] The platform is also used by businesses for distance learning and for conferencing.[48]

The company launched Blackboard Mobile in 2009.[20] The platform provides students with access to teaching and learning content and campus information through mobile applications for iOS, Android, BlackBerry and WebOS devices.[49][50] Blackboard Mobile allows students to both access course materials, check grades, and participate in discussions,[49][51][52] and to access information about campus life and services.[53]

The company began providing its Blackboard Connect service in 2008,[20] for use by school districts and higher education institutions to send out mass phone, text and e-mail notifications.[22] The service can be used for routine alerts and notifications, academic or instructor notifications, or by school districts and communities to share time-sensitive information, such as in the case of natural disasters and campus emergencies.[54][55]

Blackboard Transact, formerly Blackboard Commerce Suite,[22][42] is transaction processing system tied to university ID cards, which can be used for meal plans, vending machines and laundry services, and an e-commerce front end for the transaction system.[56] The Transact system is NFC-compatible and its ID cards use contactless technology.[57][58] Blackboard Transact also includes a program for off-campus vendors that allow students to pay for goods using their college's campus card.[56]

Blackboard Analytics was developed after the company acquired iStrategy, a data analysis firm, in December 2010.[20] The Blackboard Analytics platform is a system for data warehousing and analysis, with applications for educational institutions to analyze student numbers, class scheduling, and financial information. The platform was created as a business intelligence tool specifically for higher education institutions and uses data from colleges' student information, human resources and financial information systems.[59]

In October 2011, following Blackboard's merger with Edline, a provider of online learning products for the K-12 market, Edline's products became known as Blackboard Engage.[28][29]


Blackboard's services include: managed hosting, platform consulting, enterprise consulting, online program management, training and student services.[1] The firm's managed hosting organization provides web hosting to support clients' IT infrastructure and online learning.[60] The company also provides services through its strategic consulting group, which offers varying degrees of consulting and training. Its services include customized mobile services for clients, and training and consulting for its software implementation and use.[61]

In early 2010, the company launched Blackboard Student Services, following the acquisition of Presidium Inc.[62] Student Services provides management services for student admissions and enrollment, financial aid, and student accounts and retention. It also provides IT and helpdesk support to students and faculty for learning management systems.[63]


In July 2014, Blackboard announced that it would begin offering bundles of its individual products in what the company calls solutions; its four bundles geared towards higher education are Learning Core, Learning Essentials, Learning Insight, and Learning Insight & Student Retention; each of the bundles includes Blackboard Learn.[64] The company also announced four additional higher education solutions that offer commerce and security options and five solutions geared toward K-12 education, geared for classroom learning and community engagement.[5]

Development of education software[edit]

Since Blackboard was founded in 1997, use of online learning management software by higher education institutions and other organizations has increased rapidly. The company's growth is closely linked with this development in education software.[20] [65] In the late 1990s, Blackboard Llc. co-founders Matthew Pittinsky and Michael Chasen and CourseInfo Llc. co-founders Stephen Gilfus and Daniel Cane noticed that there was a trend in higher education towards greater use of Internet-based education programs. The team created Blackboard Inc. to develop and market Internet-based learning management software.[7] In 1998, Blackboard was a participant in an IMS Global Consortium project to develop standards in online education.[6]

During the early 2000s Blackboard and rival company WebCT held the majority share of the education software market and were leaders in the move by colleges to wider use of online learning applications.[13][65] The services and products offered by learning technology companies diversified, and Blackboard and WebCT began to offer technology packages that provided administrative functions, in addition to online course management.[13]

Since the late 2000s, the increasing use of mobile devices and the appeal of mobile applications to students have become driving factors in the development of mobile learning systems.[49][52] In 2009, Blackboard acquired a company which had developed an iPhone application for students at Stanford University, and made the application available for other campuses and mobile devices.[22][42] Near the end of the 2000s, Blackboard share of the learning management software market began to decline. As of 2009, the company held 60 percent of the market[66] and, according to a report published by the Campus Computing Project, this decreased to 57 percent in 2010 and 50.6 percent in 2011.[67]

As of December 2013, Blackboard's Learning Management System had over 20,000 organizations signed up with more than 20 million users.[68]

Legal matters[edit]

The United States Patent and Trademark Office granted the company U.S. Patent 6,988,138 for "Internet-based education support system and methods" in January 2006. The patent established Blackboard's claims to the concept of connecting together web-based tools to create an interconnected university-wide course management system.[69] The firm announced the patent on July 26, 2006, and on the same day it filed a patent infringement lawsuit against rival education software company Desire2Learn Inc.[69][70] According to news reports, the awarding of the patent and the lawsuit against Desire2Learn led to concerns about patentability in the electronic learning community.

A website,, was set up anonymously, calling for a boycott of the company's products and offering an online petition to be signed by those who opposed the patent. In addition, some critics of the patent and lawsuit created a Wikipedia entry for the History of virtual learning environments to document existing examples of course management software.[69] The Software Freedom Law Center filed a request with the U.S. Patent Office to re-examine Blackboard's patent in November 2006, and in January 2007 the request was approved on the basis of prior art cited by the Center raising "substantial" questions.[71] To address the concerns raised within the education software and academic communities, in February 2007, the firm announced that it had made a pledge to not assert its patent rights against open-source and non-profit software developers.[72][73]

In February 2008, a federal jury in Texas ruled in favor of Blackboard Inc. in its patent infringement suit against Desire2Learn, finding the rival company liable for infringing on its patent.[74] One month later, in March 2008, the U.S. Patent Office issued a preliminary decision following its re-examination of Blackboard's patent application, which rejected the 44 claims made by the company. The Patent Office stated that it would give a final decision following a review of the patent.[75]

Following the ruling by the federal jury in February 2008, later that year Desire2Learn lodged an appeal with the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. A ruling was made by the Court of Appeals on July 27, 2009 that the 38 patent claims made by Blackboard in its suit against Desire2Learn were invalid.[76] The dispute was resolved, when Blackboard and Desire2Learn announced on December 15, 2009 that each company was settling all ongoing litigation between them and had made a cross-licensing agreement.[77][78] In April 2010, the firm abandoned patent 6,988,138, and in November that year the company's legal counsel announced the patent's "official termination" and stated that Blackboard had ended its appeals.[79]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ a b "Company Overview of Blackboard Inc.". BusinessWeek. 2013. Retrieved 3 June 2013. 
  2. ^ Steven Pearlstein (17 November 2012). "Blackboard’s departing founder, an opportunist who made his own luck". The Washington Post. Retrieved 27 May 2013. 
  3. ^ Nagel, David (July 13, 2011). "Blackboard Learn Expands Open Education Standards Support". THEJournal. Retrieved February 10, 2014. 
  4. ^ Rip Empson (January 16, 2014). "Education Giant Blackboard Buys MyEdu To Help Refresh Its Brand And Reanimate Its User Experience". TechCrunch. Retrieved May 29, 2014. 
  5. ^ a b Betsy Corcoran (July 23, 2014). "Blackboard's Jay Bhatt Strikes Up the Brass Band". Edsurge. Retrieved September 2, 2014. 
  6. ^ a b "GEO Interactive Re OEM Agreement". London Stock Exchange Aggregated Regulatory News Service. October 21, 1998. 
  7. ^ a b c d Leibovich, Mark (January 4, 1999). "Blackboard Chalks Up a Breakthrough; Its Educational Software Lets Colleges Put Classes on the Internet". The Washington Post. p. F05. 
  8. ^ Darlene Darcy (9 August 2009). "Years at Blackboard an education that turns employees into entrepreneurs". Washington D.C. Business Journal. Retrieved 3 June 2013. 
  9. ^ a b "Blackboard Announces Release Of Blackboard CourseInfo 2.0". Business Wire. November 2, 1998. 
  10. ^ a b "Blackboard Aims For Standard With Building Blocks Initiative". Educational Marketer 31 (33). November 20, 2000. 
  11. ^ Irwin, Neil (November 29, 2000). "Blackboard to Chalk Up 2 Acquisitions; Smart-Card Companies Augment Technology And Customer Base". The Washington Post. 
  12. ^ Hughlett, Roger (August 8, 2003). "Blackboard's success may erase bad feelings about dot-coms". Washington Business Journal 22 (14). p. 3. 
  13. ^ a b c d Daniels, Alex (January 29, 2001). "Big company on campus: Blackboard hopes an IPO will help it dominate the Internet education market". Washington Techway. p. 26. 
  14. ^ Knowlton, Brian (September 1, 2003). "U.S. firm makes grade in China". The International Herald Tribune. p. 11. 
  15. ^ a b Burn, Timothy (May 2006). "Michael Chasen: CEO of the Year". Washington Smart CEO. Retrieved May 15, 2011. 
  16. ^ Henry, Shannon (May 11, 2000). "Help for an Earning Curve". The Washington Post. p. E01. 
  17. ^ a b "Fastest Growing Companies 2004: Blackboard". Washington Business Journal 23 (22). October 1, 2004. p. 16. 
  18. ^ a b c "Makers of Online Systems Merge; Blackboard buys up rival in course-handling market". Education Week 25 (9). October 26, 2005. p. 8. 
  19. ^ Carnevale, Dan (February 17, 2006). "Justice Department Sees No Antitrust Concerns in Blackboard's Plan to Take Over WebCT". The Chronicle of Higher Education 52 (24). p. 37. 
  20. ^ a b c d e f g h Kolowich, Steve (February 22, 2011). "Blackboard's Next Phase". Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved April 10, 2011. 
  21. ^ Kennedy, Kathleen (May 20, 2009). "Blackboard Inc.Purchases Education Software Developer". Education Week 28 (32). p. 4. 
  22. ^ a b c d e Harlin, Kevin (January 8, 2010). "Blackboard Inc. Washington, D.C. Educational Software Maker Binds Students And Faculty". Investor's Business Daily. p. A06. 
  23. ^ Young, Jeff (January 12, 2011). "In Bid to Expand Into Student Services, Blackboard Buys Presidium". The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved August 30, 2011. 
  24. ^ "Blackboard Acquires CardSmith". PRNewswire. 
  25. ^ Fitzgerald, Drew (July 1, 2011). "Providence Equity Partners To Buy Blackboard For About $1.64B". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved August 26, 2011. 
  26. ^ "Providence Equity Partners Completes Acquisition of Blackboard Inc.". Blackboard Inc. Retrieved January 8, 2012. 
  27. ^ a b Jeff Clabaugh (5 October 2011). "Blackboard private, merges with Edline". Washington Business Journal. Retrieved 17 May 2013. 
  28. ^ a b Krista Giovacco (9 September 2011). "Providence Increases Blackboard Buyout Loan as Outflows Subside". Businessweek. Retrieved 17 May 2013. 
  29. ^ a b "Our Company is getting a new name!". Edline. 11 June 2012. Retrieved 17 May 2013. 
  30. ^ "Blackboard makes Moodle acquisitions". 
  31. ^ Nagel, David (15 October 2012). "Blackboard CEO Chasen To Step Down". THEJournal. Retrieved 23 January 2014. 
  32. ^ Overly, Steven (16 January 2014). "The Download: Blackboard makes first acquisition under CEO Jay Bhatt". The Washington Post. Retrieved 23 January 2014. 
  33. ^ a b "Blackboard Inc. Announces First Quarter of 2011 Conference Call". PR Newswire. April 21, 2011. Retrieved April 24, 2011. 
  34. ^ "Blackboard says received buyout offers; shares jump". Reuters. April 19, 2011. Retrieved April 24, 2011. 
  35. ^ Bill Flook (3 May 2013). "Big changes are underway at Blackboard. Here's Jay Bhatt's plan.". Washington Business Journal. Retrieved 17 May 2013. 
  36. ^ Tong Zhang (15 November 2012). "Michael Chasen calls D.C. a top tech city". Washington Business Journal. Retrieved 23 January 2014. 
  37. ^ Flook, Bill (28 June 2013). "Exclusive: Blackboard brings in Autodesk vets in centralization push". Washington Business Journal. Retrieved 23 January 2014. 
  38. ^ Joshua Kim (16 January 2013). "7 Questions for Katie Blot, President Blackboard Education Services". Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved 23 January 2014. 
  39. ^ "Nixa Public Schools earns national communication award". Christian County Headliner. 14 November 2013. Retrieved 23 January 2014. 
  40. ^ "Leadership". Blackboard. Retrieved 6 February 2014. 
  41. ^ Schaffhauser, Dian (March 2, 2011). "Skidmore College Moves to Blackboard 9.1". Campus Technology. Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  42. ^ a b c "Blackboard Inc. (BBBB) Upgraded by Zacks Investment Research to "Neutral"". American Banking News. March 16, 2011. 
  43. ^ "Getting to know Blackboard Learn". Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  44. ^ Batson, Trent (January 5, 2011). "Not Your Grandfather's Blackboard? My Recent Chat with Bb Learn President Ray Henderson". Campus Technology. Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  45. ^ "Put Your Courses Online for Free with CourseSites by Blackboard". Soft Chalk. May 12, 2011. Retrieved August 31, 2011. 
  46. ^ Rip Empson (18 October 2012). "Blackboard: With Both Co-founders Now Gone, It’s The End Of An Era For The Education Software Giant". TechCrunch. Retrieved 17 June 2013. 
  47. ^ "Open University turn to Blackboard Collaborate". Retrieved 15 January 2014. 
  48. ^ "Blackboard Predicts Strong Momentum for Web Conferencing". January 4, 2011. Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  49. ^ a b c Sherif, Iman (February 27, 2011). "When learning goes mobile for varsity students". Gulf News. Retrieved April 10, 2011. 
  50. ^ Jim Barthold (26 April 2012). "Blackboard Adds Augmented Reality to Campus iPhone Apps". Campus Technology. Retrieved 14 June 2013. 
  51. ^ Johnson, Henry M. Dialogue and the construction of knowledge in e-learning: Exploring students’ perceptions of their learning while using Blackboard’s asynchronous discussion board. European Journal of Open, Distance and E-Learning 05.01.2007 (2007) [ISSN 10275-207]
  52. ^ a b Darcy, Darlene (March 26, 2009). "Blackboard introduces iPhone application". Washington Business Journal. 
  53. ^ Keller, Josh (January 23, 2011). "As the Web Goes Mobile, Colleges Fail to Keep Up". The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  54. ^ Moreno, Nicole (March 15, 2011). "Being Alert in Case of an Emergency". Palo Alto Patch. Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  55. ^ Short, Robby (March 14, 2011). "Blackboard Connect emergency notification system launches". News-Star (Shawnee, Oklahoma). Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  56. ^ a b "With off-campus programs, more can be better". CR80 News. June 29, 2011. Retrieved September 1, 2011. 
  57. ^ Clark, Sarah (March 8, 2010). "Blackboard adds NFC and contactless support to campus card system". Near Field Communications World. Retrieved September 14, 2011. 
  58. ^ "Blackboard expands Support for NFC-STandards". 
  59. ^ Schaffhauser, Dian (February 8, 2011). "Blackboard Buys into Data Analytics". Campus Technology. Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  60. ^ Hutchinson, James (March 16, 2011). "Unis prepare for next Cloud wave". TechWorld. Retrieved September 6, 2011. 
  61. ^ "Strategic Solutions". Blackboard, Inc. Retrieved September 1, 2011. 
  62. ^ "Blackboard buys edu services co". Reuters. January 12, 2011. Retrieved September 6, 2011. 
  63. ^ "Student Services". Blackboard, Inc. Retrieved September 1, 2011. 
  64. ^ Michael Feldstein (18 July 2014). "Blackboard’s Big News that Nobody Noticed". e-Literate. Retrieved 2 September 2014. 
  65. ^ a b McCarthy, Ellen (June 18, 2004). "Blackboard Set to Go Public Today". The Washington Post. p. E04. 
  66. ^ Beth Kowitt (30 October 2009). "Blackboard software rules the schools". Retrieved 13 June 2013. 
  67. ^ Bill Flook (21 September 2012). "Blackboard lays off 90 as industry evolves". Washington Business Journal. Retrieved 13 June 2013. 
  68. ^
  69. ^ a b c Pope, Justin (October 15, 2006). "E-Learning Firm Sparks Controversy With Software Patent". The Washington Post. Associated Press. p. A07. 
  70. ^ "Case 9:06-cv-00155-RHC (Court documents)". IMMagic e-library. July 26, 2006. Retrieved April 28, 2011. 
  71. ^ Ben Hammer (5 February 2007). "Blackboard's patent may be in jeopardy after review". Washington Business Journal. Retrieved 8 May 2013. 
  72. ^ Hammer, Ben (February 19, 2007). "Blackboard: Patent won't be used against nonprofits". Washington Business Journal. 
  73. ^ "The Blackboard Patent Pledge". Blackboard Inc. Retrieved April 28, 2011. 
  74. ^ Darcy, Darlene (February 22, 2008). "Blackboard wins patent lawsuit". Washington Business Journal. 
  75. ^ Mangan, Katherine (April 11, 2008). "Patent Office Hands Blackboard a Setback". The Chronicle of Higher Education 54 (31). p. 4. 
  76. ^ Darcy, Darlene (July 27, 2009). "Court rules against Blackboard in patent case". Washington Business Journal. 
  77. ^ Darcy, Darlene (December 17, 2009). "Blackboard settles legal brawl". Washington Business Journal. 
  78. ^ Kolowich, Steve (December 16, 2009). "Clean slate". Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved April 28, 2011. 
  79. ^ Keller, Josh (November 30, 2010). "Blackboard Drops Appeals on Software Patent". Wired Campus. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved April 28, 2011. 

External links[edit]