Blue Dog Coalition
|Blue Dog Coalition|
|Political position||Center-left to Center-right|
|National affiliation||Democratic Party|
|Seats in the House|
|Politics of United States
The Blue Dog Coalition, commonly known as the Blue Dogs or Blue Dog Democrats, is a caucus of United States Congressional Representatives from the Democratic Party who identify themselves as moderates and conservatives.
It was formed in 1995 during the 104th Congress to give more conservative members from the Democratic party a unified voice after the Democrats' loss of Congress in the U.S. Congressional election of 1994. Blue Dog Coalition membership experienced a rapid decline in the 2010s, now having 19 seats in the 113th Congress.
- 1 History
- 2 Ideology
- 3 Funding
- 4 Political relationships
- 5 Membership
- 5.1 Members in the 113th Congress
- 5.2 2012 Election
- 5.3 Members who resigned in 112th Congress
- 5.4 Members who did not run for House re-election in 2010
- 5.5 Members defeated in 2010 election
- 5.6 2008 Election
- 5.7 2006 Election
- 5.8 2004 Election
- 5.9 2002 Election
- 5.10 2000 Election
- 5.11 1998 Election
- 5.12 1996 Election
- 5.13 Appointed to other office/elected to another office
- 5.14 Died in office
- 5.15 Left the Blue Dog Coalition
- 5.16 Became a Republican
- 5.17 Applied to join but was rejected
- 6 See also
- 7 References
- 8 External links
Founding members were Glen Browder and Bud Cramer of Alabama; Blanche Lambert Lincoln of Arkansas; Gary Condit of California; Nathan Deal of Georgia; William Lipinski of Illinois; Scotty Baesler of Kentucky; Billy Tauzin and Jimmy Hayes of Louisiana; Collin Peterson and David Minge of Minnesota; Michael Parker and Gene Taylor of Mississippi; Pat Danner of Missouri; William K. Brewster of Oklahoma; John S. Tanner of Tennessee; Ralph Hall, Charles Stenholm, Pete Geren and Greg Laughlin of Texas, Bill Orton of Utah; and Lewis F. Payne, Jr. and Owen Pickett of Virginia. Condit and Deal were co-chairmen. Browder headed the group’s budget task force.
The term "Blue Dog Democrat" is credited to Texas Democratic Rep. Pete Geren (who later joined the Bush Administration). Geren opined that the members had been "choked blue" by extreme Democrats from the Left. It is related to the political term "Yellow Dog Democrat," a reference to southern Democrats said to be so loyal they would even vote for a yellow dog if it were labeled Democrat. The term is also a reference to the "Blue Dog" paintings of Cajun artist George Rodrigue of Lafayette, Louisiana, as the original members of the coalition would regularly meet in the offices of Louisiana representatives Billy Tauzin and Jimmy Hayes, both of whom later joined the Republican Party; both had Rodrigue's paintings on their walls. An additional explanation for the term cited by members is "when dogs are not let into the house, they stay outside in the cold and turn blue," a reference to the Blue Dogs' belief they had been left out of a party that they believed had shifted to the political left.
Although its membership is not exclusively Southern, some view the Blue Dogs as the political successors to a now defunct-in-name Southern Democratic group known as the Boll Weevils, who played a critical role in the early 1980s by supporting President Ronald Reagan's tax cut plan. The Boll Weevils, in turn, may be considered the descendants of the Dixiecrats and the "states' rights" Democrats of the 1940s through the 1960s, and even the Bourbon Democrats of the late 19th century.
The coalition was notably successful in a special election of February 2004 in Kentucky to fill a vacant seat in the House of Representatives. They were also successful in the November 2004 elections, when three of the five races in which a Democrat won a formerly Republican House seat were won by Blue Dogs.
In 2005, the members of the Blue Dog Coalition voted 32 to 4 in favor of the bill to limit access to bankruptcy protection (S 256).
While the Blue Dog Coalition is made up of House members, the term "Blue Dog" is sometimes used informally for Democratic senators, governors, or state legislators who resemble the Blue Dog Coalition positions based on their politics. Recent such Senators include Ben Nelson (D-NE) and Joe Manchin (D-WV).
In 2007, 15 Blue Dog Coalition Members in safe seats refused to contribute party dues to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee. An additional 16 Blue Dogs have not paid any money to the DCCC but were exempt from party-mandated contributions because they were top GOP targets for defeat in 2008. One reason for the party-dues boycott is contained in remarks made by Rep. Lynn Woolsey (D-Calif.) encouraging leaders of anti-war groups to field primary challenges to any Democrat who does not vote to end the war in Iraq. Woolsey later stated that she was misunderstood, but the Blue Dogs have continued with the boycott. Donations to party Congressional Committees are an important source of funding for the party committees, permitting millions of dollars to be funneled back into close races.
In the summer of 2009, The Economist magazine said "[t]he debate over health care... may be the pinnacle of the group’s power so far" and quoted Charlie Stenholm, a founding Blue Dog, as saying that "this is the first year for the new kennel in which their votes are really going to make a difference."
The Blue Dog Coalition suffered serious losses in the 2010 midterm elections, losing over half of its seats to Republican challengers. Its members, who comprised roughly one quarter of the Democratic Party's caucus in the 111th Congress, accounted for half of the party's midterm election losses. Including retirements, Blue Dog numbers in the House were reduced from 54 members in 2008 to 26 members in 2010 and two of the Coalition's four leaders (Stephanie Herseth Sandlin and Baron Hill) failed to secure re-election.
Opposition to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and climate change legislation are believed to have contributed to the defeat of two conservative Democrats in the United States House of Representatives elections in Pennsylvania, 2012 by more liberal opponents.
Following the 2012 House of Representatives elections, the Blue Dog Coalition went from 27 members to 14 members. Speculation ensued that the centrist New Democrat Coalition would fill the power vacuum created by the Blue Dog Coalition's decline.
The Blue Dog Coalition is often involved in searching for a compromise between liberal and conservative positions. The Blue Dogs are viewed by some as a continuation of the socially conservative wing of the Democratic party; however, the only stated policy position of the Blue Dogs is fiscal conservatism.
Despite the Blue Dogs' differing degrees of economic and social conservatism, they claim they generally work to promote positions within the House of Representatives that bridge the gap between right-wing and left-wing politics. Blue Dogs are an important swing vote on spending bills and as a result have gained influence in Congress out of proportion to their numbers. They are frequently sought after to broker compromises between the Democratic and Republican leadership, generally lending a more centrist character to US politics.
The biggest single source of finance for the Blue Dog Political Action Committee is the health care industry, which donated $1.2 million in the 2009-10 election cycle. In July 2009, Blue Dog members who were committee members of the House Energy and Commerce Committee successfully delayed the House vote on the Health Insurance Reform Bill (HR3200) until after the Summer Recess. It was during this recess that the term “Obamacare” was first derisively adopted by Republicans on Capitol Hill It is widely proposed that Blue Dog opposition to the “public option” and this recess, with that summer's contentious Town Hall meetings, provided the healthcare law’s Republican opponents the opportunity to attack and subsequently get the public option dropped from the original, pre-recess, bill.
New Democrat Coalition
Members of the New Democrat Coalition, an affiliate of the Democratic Leadership Council (DLC), take moderate or liberal positions on social issues and moderate positions on economic issues and trade. The DLC aims to revitalize and strengthen the Democratic party, while the Blue Dogs emphasize bipartisanship.
Democrats who identify with the Blue Dogs tend to be more conservative on social issues than "New Democrats." Reflecting the group's Southern roots, many Blue Dogs are strong supporters of gun rights and receive high ratings from the National Rifle Association, some have pro-life voting records, and some get high ratings from immigration reduction groups and from the insurance industry. They supported the Republican and corporate-backed Bankruptcy Reform Act of 2005. As a caucus, however, Blue Dogs have never agreed on, or taken, a formal position on these issues, and some members may favor more socially liberal platforms.
On economic issues, Blue Dogs tend to be pro-business, favoring lower corporate tax rates, limiting public welfare spending and reducing Social Security benefits. Individually however, both New Democrats and Blue Dogs, may have differing positions on trade issues, and they include both supporters and strong critics of labor unions, protectionism, and free trade. Some Democrats are members of both the Blue Dog Coalition and the New Democratic Coalition, as was former Representative Gabrielle Giffords of Arizona.
Some in the Democratic Party's liberal wing promote primary challenges against Blue Dog Coalition members in an effort to unseat Democratic Party members they view as unreliable or too conservative. The editors of the left-wing weblog OpenLeft refer to Blue Dog Democrats who voted for war funding in May 2007 and voted to grant the Executive branch warrantless wiretapping powers as "Bush Dogs". Others in the party view these individuals as "Republicans in Democrats Clothing".
Blue Dog membership was nearly cut in half by the 2010 Election, in which 26 members were re-elected but 28 were either defeated or chose not to run for re-election.
Blue Dog membership was nearly cut in half again for the 113th Congress. Of the 27 Blue Dogs, 3 resigned (Giffords, Cardoza and Harman), while 10 chose not to run for re-election or were defeated. Of the remaining 14 members Adam Schiff left the coalition, but Pete Gallego (Texas), Kyrsten Sinema (Arizona), Ron Barber (Arizona), Nick Rahall (West Virginia), Dan Lipinski (Illinois), and Cheri Bustos (Illinois) joined them for the 113th Congress.
Freshman Blue Dogs in the House are sometimes nicknamed "Blue Pups".
Members in the 113th Congress
- Ron Barber (AZ-2)
- John Barrow (GA-12), Co-Chair for Administration
- Sanford Bishop (GA-2)
- Cheri Bustos (IL-17)
- Jim Cooper (TN-5), Co-Chair for Policy
- Jim Costa (CA-16)
- Henry Cuellar (TX-28)
- Pete Gallego (TX-23)
- Dan Lipinski (IL-3)
- Jim Matheson (UT-4)
- Mike McIntyre (NC-7)
- Mike Michaud (ME-2)
- Collin Peterson (MN-7)
- Nick Rahall (WV-3)
- Loretta Sanchez (CA-46)
- Kurt Schrader (OR-5), Co-Chair for Communications
- David Scott (GA-13)
- Kyrsten Sinema (AZ-9)
- Mike Thompson (CA-5)
- Jason Altmire (PA-4) - Lost renomination
- Joe Baca (CA-43) - Defeated
- Dan Boren (OK-2), Blue Dog Whip - Retired
- Tim Holden (PA-17) - Lost renomination
- Larry Kissell (NC-8) - Defeated
- Leonard Boswell (IA-3) - Defeated
- Ben Chandler (KY-6) - Defeated
- Mike Ross (AR-4), Co-Chair for Communications - Retired
- Heath Shuler (NC-11), Co-Chair for Administration - Retired
Members who resigned in 112th Congress
- Dennis Cardoza (CA-18) - Resigned in 2012
- Gabrielle Giffords (AZ-8) - Retired from the House in January 2012 to recover from injuries sustained in 2011 Tucson shooting
- Jane Harman (CA-36) - Resigned in 2011
Members who did not run for House re-election in 2010
- Robert Marion Berry (AR-1)
- Brad Ellsworth (IN-8) (ran for Senate in 2010, lost)
- Bart Gordon (TN-6)
- Charlie Melancon (LA-3), Blue Dog Co-Chair for Communications (ran for Senate in 2010, lost)
- Dennis Moore (KS-3)
- John Tanner (TN-8)
Members defeated in 2010 election
- Mike Arcuri (NY-24)
- Melissa Bean (IL-8)
- Allen Boyd (FL-2)
- Bobby Bright (AL-2)
- Chris Carney (PA-10)
- Travis Childers (MS-1)
- Kathy Dahlkemper (PA-3)
- Lincoln Davis (TN-4)
- Stephanie Herseth Sandlin (SD-AL), Blue Dog Co-Chair for Administration
- Baron Hill (IN-9), Blue Dog Co-Chair for Policy
- Frank Kratovil (MD-1)
- Betsy Markey (CO-4)
- Jim Marshall (GA-8)
- Walt Minnick (ID-1)
- Harry Mitchell (AZ-5)
- Patrick Murphy (PA-8)
- Scott Murphy (NY-20)
- Glenn Nye (VA-2)
- Earl Pomeroy (ND-AL)
- John Salazar (CO-3)
- Zack Space (OH-18)
- Gene Taylor (MS-4)
- Charlie Wilson (OH-6)
- Brad Carson (OK-2) - Ran for Senate in 2004 & Lost
- Chris John (LA-7) - Ran for Senate in 2004 & Lost
- Nick Lampson (TX-9) - Defeated following 2003 Texas redistricting
- Bill Lipinski (IL-3) - Retired
- Ken Lucas (KY-4) - Retired
- Max Sandlin (TX-1) - Defeated following 2003 Texas redistricting
- Charlie Stenholm (TX-17) - Defeated following 2003 Texas redistricting
- Jim Turner (TX-2) Retired following 2003 Texas redistricting
- Bill Orton (UT-3) - Defeated
- Glen Browder (AL-3) - Ran for Senate in 1996 & Defeated in the primary
- Lewis F. Payne, Jr. (VA-5) - Ran for the Lieutenant Governor of Virginia during the Virginia gubernatorial election, 1997 & Lost
- Pete Geren (TX-12) - Retired
- Charlie Rose (NC-7) - Retired
- Bill Brewster (OK-3) - Retired
Appointed to other office/elected to another office
Died in office
- Norman Sisisky (VA-4) - Died in office in 2001
Left the Blue Dog Coalition
Became a Republican
- Rodney Alexander (LA-5) - Became a Republican in 2004
- Nathan Deal (GA-9) - Became a Republican in 1995
- Ralph Hall (TX-4) - Became a Republican in 2004
- Jimmy Hayes (LA-7) - Became a Republican in 1995
- Virgil Goode (VA-5) - Became a Republican in 2002
- Parker Griffith (AL-5) - Became a Republican in 2009, rejoined the Democrats in 2014
- Michael Parker (MS-4) - Became a Republican in 1995
- Billy Tauzin (LA-3) - Became a Republican in 1995
Applied to join but was rejected
- Boll weevil
- Congressional Progressive Caucus
- Democratic Freedom Caucus
- Democrat In Name Only
- Libertarian Democrat
- New Democrat Coalition
- Red Tory
- Yellow dog Democrat, a person who will vote for any Democratic candidate
- Conservative Democrats
- Kane, Paul (January 15, 2013). "Blue Dog Democrats, whittled down in number, are trying to regroup". Washington Post. Retrieved July 23, 2014.
- "Coalition of Moderate 'Blue Dog' Dems Shrinking Fast". Fox News. Associated Press. August 19, 2011. Retrieved July 23, 2014.
- Davis, Susan. "U.S. House has fewer moderate Democrats". USA Today. Retrieved July 23, 2014.
- Wasserman, David (November 5, 2012). "Why 2012 Will Be a Watershed House Election". National Journal. Retrieved August 16, 2014.
- "History, Blue Dog Coalition". House.gov. Retrieved 2012-04-10.
- Naftali Bendavid (2009 July 28) 'Blue Dog' Democrats Hold Health-Care Overhaul at Bay The Wall Street Journal
- Certain, Geni (2012). Professor-Politician, The Biography of Alabama Congressman Glen Browder. NewSouth Books. p. 147. ISBN 978-1-58838-254-2.
- WordCraft, November 11, 2004
- Suddath, Claire (July 28, 2009). "A Brief History of Blue Dog Democrats". Time. Retrieved 2009-09-07.
- Safire, William (April 23, 1995). "On Language; Blue Dog Demo". New York Times. Retrieved 2009-09-07.
- "Blue Dog Democrats". Bluedogs.us. 2008-11-04. Retrieved 2010-03-17.
- Parties, Rules, and the Evolution of Congressional Budgeting, Lance T. LeLoup, 2005, pp. 185
- Encyclopedia of American Parties, Campaigns, and Elections, William C. Binning et al, 1999, pp. 307
- Thomson, Alex (2007). A Glossary of U.S. Politics and Government. Stanford University Press. p. 14. ISBN 978-0-8047-5730-0.
- Bresnahan, John (2007-10-24). "Blue Dogs refuse to pony up for DCCC". The Politico. Retrieved 2007-11-01.
- "The Democratic Party's centrists: Blue Dog days". The Economist. 2009-07-30.
- "Blue Dogs Shaved in Half - Blue Dog Democrats - Fox Nation". Fox News. 2010-11-03.
- Blue Dog wipeout: Half of caucus gone - On Congress - POLITICO.com
- "A vanishing breed: Blue Dogs". Los Angeles Times. 2010-11-03.
- "Why the Blue Dogs’ decline was inevitable". Washington Post. 2012-04-25.
- "New Dems hope to be a force in 113th Congress". The Hill. 2012-11-17.
- Hiltzik, Michael (2009-08-03). "What's so great about private health insurance? - Los Angeles Times". Latimes.com. Retrieved 2010-03-17.
- "Are the Blue Dogs Really Working For You? « Silver Buzz Cafe". Silverbuzzcafe.com. 2009-08-20. Retrieved 2010-03-17.
- "Two House Committees Approve Health Reform Bill". Child Welfare League of America. July 27, 2009. Retrieved February 26, 2013.
- Wallace, Gregory (June 25, 2012). "'Obamacare': The word that defined the health care debate". CNN. Retrieved February 26, 2013.
- Ball, Molly (November 16, 2012). "Blue Dogs Are Dwindling". The Atlantic. Retrieved February 27, 2013.
- Stolberg, Sheryl Gay (August 17, 2009). "’Public Option’ in Health Plan May Be Dropped". N Y Times. Retrieved February 26, 2013.
- "Retiring Blue Dog Democrat Heath Shuler Breaks His Pledge To Not Become A Lobbyist". Progressive Change Campaign Committee. November 27, 2012. Retrieved February 27, 2013.
- "Republicans and Blue Dogs Go After Social Security Under the Radar". Santa Rosa County Democrats. June 27, 2011. Retrieved February 27, 2013.
- Stoller, Matt (2007-08-30). "What is a Bush Dog Democrat? A FAQ...". OpenLeft. Retrieved 2007-11-01.
- Stoller, Matt (2007-08-30). "Why Profile a Bush Dog?". OpenLeft. Retrieved 2007-11-01.
- "Blue Dog Coalition Adds Four New Members". Office of Kurt Schrader. Retrieved 2014-01-15.
- "Rep. Lipinski Joins Blue Dog Coalition to Fight for Fiscal Discipline". Office of Dan Lipinski. Retrieved 2013-06-14.
- House's Blue Dogs Teaching Old Democrats New Tricks : Congress: After November whipping, these 21 lawmakers have rebuilt clout in the budget talks. They're being courted by Wh...
- Blue Dog Coalition homepage
- C-Span article by Ilona Nickels on Blue Dogs
- Right-Leaning "Blue Dogs" Lose Seats in 2010 Election - video report by Democracy Now!