Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions
The Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions Movement (BDS Movement) is a global campaign attempting to increase economic and political pressure on Israel to comply with the stated goals of the movement: the end of Israeli occupation and colonization of Palestinian land, full equality for Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel, and respect for the right of return of Palestinian refugees.
The campaign was started on 9 July 2005 by 171 Palestinian non-governmental organizations in support of the Palestinian cause for boycott, divestment and international sanctions against Israel. Citing a body of UN resolutions and specifically echoing the anti-apartheid campaigns against white minority rule in apartheid era South Africa, the BDS campaign called for "various forms of boycott against Israel until it meets its obligations under international law".
There is considerable debate about the scope, efficacy, and morality of the BDS movement. Critics argue that the BDS movement promotes the delegitimization of Israel. BDS supporters argue that both the movement (and criticism of the movement) are similar to the earlier boycotts of South Africa during its apartheid, a comparison that the critics categorically reject on the grounds of dissimilarity of the regimes in almost every aspect.
- 1 Background
- 2 Goals
- 3 Methods
- 4 Achievements
- 5 Supporters
- 6 Reaction
- 7 Criticism
- 8 See also
- 9 References
- 10 Notes
- 11 External links
Debate over a wide ranging boycott of Israel has been ongoing in the Middle East since 1945 when the Council of the Arab League called for an economic boycott against the Jews of Mandatory Palestine. Egypt (1979), the Palestinian Authority (1993), and Jordan (1994) signed peace treaties or agreements that ended their participation in the boycott of Israel. Mauritania, which never applied the boycott, established diplomatic relations with Israel in 1999. Algeria, Morocco, and Tunisia do not enforce the boycott. In 1994, following the Oslo Peace Accords, the Cooperation Council for the Arab States of the Gulf (GCC) ended their participation in the Arab boycott against Israel.
According to Julie Norman the circumstances in the Palestinian territories of Israeli occupation in combination with the Palestinian Authority acting as a quasi-state institution create unique challenges for civil resistance. Civil society groups have to challenge problems with their own government while keeping the focus of their activities on the occupying power. Julie Norman argues that in this situation withdrawal of consent by the Palestinian population does not undermine the power of the Israeli government provided it retains the support of the Israeli electorate. Thus activists are presented with a more difficult task than the removal of a dictator or political party from government as they must find opportunities for resisting the occupying force while simultaneously convincing the Israeli population and government of the requirement for change.
Rhea DuMont writes that local non-violent means such as direct action, community organizations, media reporting and sumud have enabled a wide range of people to be involved in the resistance to occupation. On a regional level non-violent methods allowed for collaboration between Palestinian and Israeli activists, NGO's and human rights organizations. Globally, they promote the direct participation by international activists and the creation of worldwide support networks and solidarity groups.
During the Second Intifada Palestinians began establishing new approaches that concentrated on developing international solidarity and support that could be used to apply pressure on Israel through non-violent means. Following this idea proposals for boycott began in 2002 and 2003, BDS campaigns were initiated, which have continued to develop and expand since the end of the intifada.
Although much has been said about BDS as a non-violent movement, BDS protests occasionally do turn violent. According to the Simon Wiesenthal Center, the BDS movement does not denounce politically motivated violence directed against Israelis or Jews.
According to the July 2005 call, the BDS campaign urges various forms of "non-violent punitive measures" against Israel until it "complies with the precepts of international law" by: "
- Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands and dismantling the Wall;
- Recognizing the fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality; and
- Respecting, protecting and promoting the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and properties as stipulated in UN Resolution 194."
The campaign uses the means of boycott, divestment and sanctions against Israel to achieve its goals. The BDS website describes its three pronged approach as, boycott: "targets products and companies (Israeli and international) that profit from the violation of Palestinian rights, as well as Israeli sporting, cultural and academic institutions [that] directly contribute to maintaining, defending or whitewashing the oppression of Palestinians as Israel deliberately tries to boost its image internationally through academic and cultural collaborations". Divestment "means targeting corporations complicit in the violation of Palestinian rights and ensuring that the likes of the university investment portfolios and pension funds are not used to finance such companies". Sanctions are described as "an essential part of demonstrating disapproval for a country's actions. Israel's membership of various diplomatic and economic forums provides both an unmerited veneer of respectability and material support for its crimes."
As well as promoting boycott, divestment and sanctions, the campaign seeks to establish a critical image of Israel in contrast to the one it presents to the world. According to Abigail Bakan and Yasmeen Abu-Laban the BDS campaign has been important in contesting what they describe as "the hegemonic framing of Israel as a victim state in the face of Palestinian 'terrorism'." Describing this aspect of the campaign they state:
The BDS movement has been framed to expose and challenge a series of corresponding repressive policies. These include the denial of the right of return of Palestinian refugees, militarised violence directed against Palestinian men, women and children, the confiscation of land from Palestinians, the demolition of Palestinian homes and the daily racism invoked by a series of policies directed at Palestinians that encumber their freedom of mobility, access to education and ability to earn a living.
In March 2009, large scale student demonstrations were held at several UK Universities to protest Israel's actions in Gaza. At Cardiff University the protests led to the University divesting all investments in BAE Systems, an arms manufacturer that co-operates with Israel. In May 2009, advertisements for tourism in Israel were removed from the London underground network in response to pressure from the Palestinian Solidarity Campaign. In July 2009, Dexia, a Belgian-French financial group, stopped all financial services to Israeli settlements in the West Bank.
A list of 2012 academic and cultural boycott successes has been compiled by the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel. In 2013, the Palestinian BDS National Committee published an interactive timeline listing some of the movement's key achievements.
In December 2012 the New Zealand Superannuation Fund excluded three Israeli companies from its portfolio because of their involvement in the construction of Israeli settlements and the Israeli West Bank barrier. The fund's manager for responsible investment stated that "Findings by the United Nations that the separation barrier and settlement activities were illegal under international law were central to the fund's decision to exclude the companies." The New Zealand Herald described "the fund's investments in the [Israeli] firms", which amounted to less than $83,000, as "insubstantial".
As of 2013, Luxembourg's state pension fund has blacklisted eight Israeli firms along with US firm Motorola Solutions for assisting in human rights violations and illegal settlements in the State of Palestine.
In December 2013, Dutch water company Vitens severed ties with Israel pointing to alleged violations of international law while engineering company Royal HaskoningDHV cancelled work on a project in East Jerusalem stating "involvement in the project could be in violation of international law." Frans Timmermans, the Netherlands' Foreign minister, who visited Israel in December 2013, later stated economic activities in the occupied territories are opposed by the Government.
In January 2014, the government of Norway announced that its pension fund will no longer invest in two Israeli companies (Africa Israel Investments and Danya Cebus) "due to [their] contribution to serious violations of individual rights in war or conflict through the construction of settlements in East Jerusalem". Norway's YMCA-YWCA joined the boycott in 2014, announcing that it will support "[a] broad economic boycott of goods and services from Israel and Israeli settlements".
In January 2014, Danske Bank, which is the largest bank in Denmark, blacklisted Israel's largest bank, Bank Hapoalim, for "acting against the rules of international humanitarian law" due to its funding of Jewish settlements in the West Bank. Previously, Danske Bank had withdrawn its investments from Africa Israel Investments Ltd. and Danya Cebus for the same reasons.
In April 2014, the Washington State Court of Appeals upheld a 2012 ruling, affirming the dismissal of a lawsuit against the Olympia Food Co-op for their 2011 decision to boycott Israeli products, mandating the plaintiffs pay $160,000 in statutory damages as well as other legal fees. In a press release, the Center for Constitutional Rights quoted one of the defendants and a Co-op staff member: "We are thrilled to hear that ... our right to freedom of speech has been upheld [..] Boycotts are a longstanding form of non-violent political expression; using the Court system to attempt to silence our right of expression clearly qualifies as a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation."
In May 2014, co-founder of Microsoft Bill Gates sold a large stake of his shares in G4S, a British security firm that operates in 125 countries, and has done business with Israel's prison system, security checkpoints, and military. Advocates of the BDS subsequently claimed that this Gates' decision was the result of "pressure on the Gates Foundation to divest from G4S". The Gates Foundation subsequently declined to comment on its reasons for the sale.
In June 2014, following the publishing open letters to The Guardian and protests at its AGM meeting, Ashley Almanza, G4S' chief executive stated the company's remaining contracts with Israel's prison system will not be renewed once they have expired. Almanza defended the company's business dealings, stating G4S "[does] not operate prisons" but rather "suppl[ies] prisons with security equipment" designed to increase safety without compromising human rights. According to The Guardian, a 2013 independent human rights report found that G4S "had no causal or contributory role in human rights violations".
In July 2014, UK department store John Lewis removed all SodaStream products from all its shelves, amid growing pressure from the public and declining sales. John Lewis' Oxford Street, London, store has been the site of biweekly BDS protests for its sale of SodaStream products. SodaStream operates its primary manufacturing facility in an Israeli settlement in the occupied West Bank. Additionally, after two years of weekly BDS protests, SodaStream closed its Brighton store in July 2014.
On 21 July 2014, the government of the Maldives announced the annulment of three bilateral trade agreements with Israel, and a government boycott of all Israeli goods. Mohamed Hussain Shareef, the minister at the President's Office, also announced that the government planned to ban the import of Israeli goods into the state.
English theoretical physicist and professor Stephen Hawking is a supporter of the BDS movement and supports an academic boycott of Israel. In 2013, Mr. Hawkings boycotted the President's Conference held by Israeli president Shimon Peres in protest at the Israeli occupation of Palestine. In 2013, Hawking announced that he will boycott the Israeli Presidential Conference, a prestigious conference sponsored by Israel's president, Shimon Peres. Hawking had accepted the invitation to attend the conference, then declined after receiving "a number of emails from Palestinian academics" asking him to respect the academic boycott against Israel. Hawking then stated what his original intent at the conference would have been had he attended "Had I attended, I would have stated my opinion that the policy of the present Israeli government is likely to lead to disaster." Among wanting to express his opinion on the prospect of a peace settlement, Hawking also intended to lecture on the West Bank. It was later found that among the 20 academics who lobbied Hawking to boycott were Professor Noam Chomsky and Professor Malcolm Levitt who advocated boycott as the proper method for scientist to respond to the "explicit policy" of "systemic discrimination" against the non-Jewish and Palestinian population.
In December 2013, the American Studies Association (ASA) decided to join the boycott of all Israeli academic institutions, a move that yielded multiple accusations of antisemitism. The New York Times reported that ASA's president Curtis Marez argued that America has "a particular responsibility to answer the call for boycott because it is the largest supplier of military aid to the state of Israel." Over 700 new members joined the organisation between the vote to boycott Israeli academic institutions was passed and April 2014. The ASA released a statement that said it had "collected more membership revenue in the past three months than in any other three-month period over the past quarter-century" and that their organization is "thriving". In response, a number of organizations and politicians accused the ASA of applying a double standard towards Israel.
In March 2014, in Ireland, members of NUI Galway Students' Union voted to join the BDS campaign in a 64% victory, making it the first Irish students' union to endorse a boycott of Israel. The vote is non-binding on the university.
In May 2014, the UK's National Union of Student's Black Students conference passed Motion 402: Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions by an "overwhelming" majority endorsing the Palestinian call at their national conference at the University of Warwick.
United Nations Special Rapporteur on "the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967", Richard A. Falk, in his 2012 report to the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) recommended that "businesses highlighted in the report – as well as the many other businesses that are profiting from the Israeli settlement enterprise – should be boycotted until they bring their operations into line with international human rights and humanitarian law and standards." He specifically named the United States' Caterpillar Inc., Hewlett Packard and Motorola; Israel's Ahava, Elbit Systems and Mehadrin; Sweden's Volvo Group and Assa Abloy; France's Veolia Environment; United Kingdom's G4S, Belgium's Dexia Group, Netherlands' Riwal Holding Group and Mexico's Cemex. At a news conference Falk said: "The focus on business activities is partly an expression of frustration about the inability to obtain compliance with these fundamental legal obligations of Israel and the ineffectiveness of the U.N. efforts to condemn settlement expansion." He also stated "The whole issue of Palestinian self-determination is at risk here."
Following the 2008–09 Gaza war Naomi Klein endorsed the campaign in two articles, one published in The Nation, the other in The Guardian, stating "[i]t's time. Long past time. The best strategy to end the increasingly bloody occupation is for Israel to become the target of the kind of global movement that put an end to apartheid in South Africa."
In 2010, a group of nearly 60 Israeli actors, directors, and playwrights released a statement declaring that they would not perform at the new theatre in Ariel, Israel’s fourth largest settlement, while urging "the boards to hold their activity within the sovereign borders of the State of Israel within the Green Line." Theodore Bikel, a Jewish American actor has also been vocal in the cultural boycott debate, also signed the petition. Following the publication of that letter, 150 Israeli academics and university faculty from across Israel voiced their support of the group of theatre professionals, releasing both a statement of support as well as a vow to engage in a cultural and academic boycott of the settlements. Signatories include Zeev Sternhell, Anat Biletzki, Shlomo Sand, Neve Gordon, Oren Yiftachel. The declaration was also supported several prominent Israeli authors, including A. B. Yehoshua, Amos Oz, David Grossman, and Sami Michael.
In Québec the political party Québec solidaire, the second largest public sector union Centrale des syndicats du Québec and the feminist organization Fédération des femmes du Québec have all supported the BDS campaign. Amir Khadir has sponsored a petition to the National Assembly of Quebec calling for the suspension of Québec's cooperation accord with Israel.
In 2006, the Canadian Union of Public Employees voted to join the boycott of Israel "until that state recognizes the Palestinian right to self-determination" and "until Israel meets its obligation to recognize the Palestinian people's inalienable right to self-determination and fully complies with the precepts of international law".
Israeli Apartheid Week
Israeli Apartheid Week is an annual series of university lectures and rallies against the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. The series is normally held in February or March. According to the organization, "the aim of IAW is to educate people about the nature of Israel as an apartheid system and to build BDS campaigns as part of a growing global BDS movement." Since IAW began in Toronto in 2005, it has since spread to at least 55 cities around the world including locations in Canada, France, Germany, India, Italy, Austria, Jordan, Japan, Korea, Brazil, Botswana, Malaysia, the United Kingdom, the United States, South Africa, Mexico, Norway, Australia, and Palestine.
Jewish and Israeli Support for BDS
In 2006 the Israeli peace activism group headed by Uri Avnery, Gush Shalom, published “a list of several hundred products made in areas beyond the Green Line. The list, containing many food products, also includes businesses operating in the Golan Heights.” Consequently, Gush Shalom appealed to Israel’s Supreme Court to rule the law as unconstitutional, joined by several minority rights groups, including: The Civil Rights Association, Yesh Din, Adalah, the Women’s Coalition for Peace, The Movement for Reform and Progressive Judaism, Knesset member Ahmed Tibi and The Arab Monitoring Committee Similarly taking a stand in the eye of the public, Israeli politician, Zahava Gal-On, head of the Meretz opposition party, “said that while she opposes international boycott efforts against Israel as a whole, she refrains from consuming settler products because there must be a ‘price to the occupation.’” Civilian support for the boycott of settlement goods continues to grow amongst Israelis, causing manufacturers and producers in the West Bank and Gaza to “encounter obstacles” in the marketing of their goods “Not just overseas, also in Tel Aviv”. Peter Beinart, a well-known American liberal Zionist has repeatedly written in support of a settlements boycott in order to “save Israel”. Beinart supports a targeted approach to boycotting West Bank settlements, specifically calling on American Jews: “We should lobby to exclude settler-produced goods from America’s free-trade deal with Israel. We should push to end Internal Revenue Service policies that allow Americans to make tax-deductible gifts to settler charities. Every time an American newspaper calls Israel a democracy, we should urge it to include the caveat: only within the green line”. In 2011, the liberal Zionist organization Meretz USA called on American Jews to boycott West Bank settlement goods to “Buy Israel - Don’t buy Settlements”. Naomi Paiss, the vice president of public affairs for the New Israel Fund shows support for the same type of targeted approach, claiming that “boycotting settlements is not anti-Israel” After a visit to the West Bank, Rabbi Ellen Lippmann has issued a statement retracting her initial opposition to the boycott of settlement goods: “I have changed my mind about the purchase of products made in the Jewish West Bank. All the rabbis I spoke to in Israel, who were not only RHR rabbis, are not buying West Bank products. I have decided to join them. Therefore, I will no longer oppose those who refuse to buy Ahava products.” The Australian Jewish Democratic Society, “has become the first Australian community-affiliated Jewish organization to adopt the view that some boycotts of Israel may indeed be justified”, according to their website. The group only supports “selected BDS actions designed to bring about an end to the Israeli occupation, blockade and settlement on Palestinian lands lying outside of the June 1967 Israeli borders.” The organization resolves to boycott settlement products as well “specific academics openly supportive of the Occupation”.
In 2013, a group of Palestinian, Israeli and other oral historians and academics from Europe, South Africa, Oceana, Asia, and the Americas issued an international call for the boycott of the “International Oral History Conference” organized by The Hebrew University of Jerusalem. In 2014, an international Jewish group, Jews for Palestinian Right of Return, issued a list of signatories endorsing the American Studies Association academic boycott of Israel. Peter Slezak, co-founder of Independent Australian Jewish Voices, Jewish human rights activist, and professor at the University of NSW stands in favour of the academic boycott through his vocal support of Sydney University’s Professor Jake Lynch. Jewish American academic, Colin Dayan has also written in support of a boycott of Israeli academic institutions. Charles H. Manekin, an orthodox Jewish studies and philosophy professor who divides his time between Israel and the United States, stated in 2014 that he is "sympathetic" to the BDS movement.
In 2010, a group of nearly 60 Israeli actors, directors, and playwrights released a statement declaring that they would not perform at the new theatre in Ariel, Israel’s fourth largest settlement, or in any other existing settlement. The statement reads: “We wish to express our disgust with the theater’s board’s plans to perform in the new auditorium in Ariel. The actors among us hereby declare that we will refuse to perform in Ariel, as well as in any other settlement. We urge the boards to hold their activity within the sovereign borders of the State of Israel within the Green Line.” Theodore Bikel, a Jewish American actor has also been vocal in the cultural boycott debate, has also signed the petition. Following the publication of that letter, 150 Israeli academics and university faculty from across Israel voiced their support of the group of theatre professionals, releasing both a statement of support as well as a vow to engage in a cultural and academic boycott of the settlements. The Israeli academic’s statement reads: "We will not take part in any kind of cultural activity beyond the Green Line, take part in discussions and seminars, or lecture in any kind of academic setting in these settlements.” Signatories include Zeev Sternhell, Anat Biletzki, Shlomo Sand, Neve Gordon, Oren Yiftachel. The declaration was also supported several prominent Israeli authors, A. B. Yehoshua, Amos Oz, David Grossman, and Sami Michael, as well as Israeli memorial sculptor and Israel Prize laureate Dani Karavan
In March 2014, an Israeli youth group, Conscientious Objectors of the Occupation, signed an open letter to Netanyahu “declaring their refusal of compulsory service in the Israeli military” on the grounds of their opposition to the Israeli Occupation of Palestinian territory. A petition published on the website of the Washington Post which states "We are Israeli reservists, We refuse to serve", has also gained over 50 signatures. The Australian Jewish Democratic society issued a statement of support for targeted boycotts, including “divestment from military Research and Development (R&D) and boycott of industrial/military activities unrelated to Israel’s defense and security”.
The NSW Greens State Conference prior to the 2011 NSW State Election adopted a resolution in support of BDS. In support of the statement, Senator Lee Rhiannon said it was "motivated by the universal principles of freedom, justice and equal rights" and also "I see the value of that tactic as a way to promoting Palestinian human rights." Following the election, Federal leader Bob Brown said that he had conveyed his disapproval of this policy emphasis to Rhiannon.
In December 2011, the NSW Greens reviewed their support the BDS campaign against Israel, bringing the branch more closely in line with the federal Greens Party position. However, they did vote to support BDS as a "legitimate political tactic". Rhiannon said that this was not a defeat, but rather, "The resolution recognizes the legitimacy of the BDS as a political tactic."
In October 2011, Izzat Abdulhadi, head of the General Delegation of Palestine to Australia said that he is against the "full-scale" BDS campaign, and condemned the occasionally violent protests at the Max Brenner stores in Australia, saying, "BDS is a non-violent process and I don't think it's the right of anybody to use BDS as a violent action or to prevent people from buying from any place."
In New South Wales in 2011, Walt Secord of the Labor Party's NSW Legislative Council, called on the NSW Minister for Police, Michael Gallacher, to "provide assurances for the protection of businesses with Israeli links" after two BDS protesters were arrested outside a Max Brenner store. Also in New South Wales, on 19 April 2011, the town council of Marrickville held a fiery meeting over whether to support the global BDS campaign. Though they struck down the motion, one councilor went on record hoping that Israelis and Palestinians could "live in peace in the future without Marrickville Council trying to interfere".
In August 2012, Liberal MP David Southwick said in parliament that Labor MP Martin Foley had links to the Boycotts, Divestment and Sanction (BDS) group, through union membership. Foley responded by saying "I seek his withdrawal of these comments where he has sought to associate [me] with this racist, anti-Semitic and anti-Israel boycott movement."
Following the incident, Prime Minister Julia Gillard said that the "campaign does not serve the cause of peace and diplomacy for agreement on a two-state solution between Israel and Palestine", and added that Australia has always had firm opposition to the BDS movement. Others, including former Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, also condemned the protests in a follow-up article by the Australian discussing protests at the University of New South Wales.
Representing the Coalition prior to the 2013 federal election, Liberal Party deputy leader Julie Bishop reaffirmed Gillard's stance by promising to cut off federal grants for individuals and institutions who support the BDS campaign. On 29 May 2013, Jewish Australian academics Andrew Benjamin, Michele Grossman, and David Goodman condemned the Coalition's election promise as "an anti-democratic gesture par excellence".
The most visible face of organizing in support of BDS in Canada is Israeli Apartheid Week, originally started in Toronto in 2005. Other organizations such as the Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) promote strategic boycotting of Canadian and Multinational corporations operating in Canada as a legitimate means of protest and pressure that is neither "anti-Israel" nor "anti-Semitic". The United Church of Canada voted to boycott products from Israeli settlements. In March 2014, the University of Windsor Student Alliance is considering plans to implement the results of a referendum vote in which the majority of voters called for the University to boycott companies with ties to Israel.
In February 2011, the Québec National Assembly voted against a motion that condemned boycotts of Québec businesses that sell products made in Israel and "reiterates Québec's support for the understanding on co-operation between the government of Québec and the government of the State of Israel, which was signed in Jerusalem in 1997 and renewed in 2007".
In 2014, amid growing public pressure in the European Union against the occupation, the governments of 12 EU nations have issued official warnings to its citizens not to engage in business, investments, or any financial activity in Israeli settlements in Palestine. In total, 12 of the EU nations have released the warnings, including the five largest EU nations: Spain, France, Germany, Italy, and the United Kingdom. The European Union and its member states do not recognize Israeli rule in the occupied Palestinian territories.
Supporting the Palestinian BDS call from within is an Israeli activist group launched in 2009 to support BDS from within Israel. The group concentrates on the cultural boycott by appealing to international personalities, artists and academics who consider visiting Israel. The 'Who profits?' project is another Israeli group involved in the BDS campaign that documents and publicizes how profits are made from the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories, including documentation of who benefits from the occupation. According to 'Who Profits?', both Israeli and international corporations are involved "in the construction of Israeli colonies and infrastructure in the Occupied Territories, in settlements' economy, in building walls and checkpoints, in the supply of specific equipment used in the control and repression of civilian population under occupation".[importance?]
On 11 July 2011, the Knesset passed a law making it a civil offence to publicly call for a boycott against the State of Israel, defined as "deliberately avoiding economic, cultural or academic ties with another person or another factor only because of his ties with the State of Israel, one of its institutions or an area under its control, in such a way that may cause economic, cultural or academic damage". According to the law, anyone calling for a boycott can be sued, and forced to pay compensation regardless of actual damages. At the discretion of a government minister, they may also be prevented from bidding in government tenders.
The new law drew a lot of criticism, including a petition by 32 Israeli law professors arguing that the law is unconstitutional and does grievous harm to the freedom of political expression and freedom of protest. Other pro-Israel advocates who are fully opposed to BDS, including Gerald Steinberg from NGO Monitor and Morton Klein from the Zionist Organization of America, have criticized the law by saying that there are many better avenues with which to counter BDS. On 10 December 2012 the Israeli Supreme Court froze the law and issued an interim order to the state of Israel to explain why the law should not be struck down. The court order gave the state until 14 March 2013 to respond. The final hearing on the issue will be before a nine-justice panel of the court presided over by Asher Grunis President of Supreme Court of Israel. Yehuda Weinstein Attorney General of Israel is reported to have called the law "borderline" defensible and admitted in defending the law in the hearing that it had serious problems.
A group of Israeli businessmen have started a sales website called "Shop-a-Fada" in order to promote Israeli products. Tal Brody is the honorary chairman of the initiative and said the purpose is to "fight back against those who think that they'll be able to destroy Israel by waging economic warfare".[importance?]
Some Jewish factory managers who employ Palestinian labor have condemned the boycott, claiming a boycott of Israeli products will result in the loss of Palestinian jobs.
In response to water company Vitens' BDS support, Kees van der Staaij of the Reformed Political Party and Joel Voordewind of the ChristianUnion jointly submitted a motion to the Dutch Parliament calling on the government "to indicate in a visible and convincing way that it encourages relations between Dutch and Israeli businesses and institutions" because "economic cooperation promotes peace, security, stability in the region." On 18 March 2014, the motion was passed by a large majority of the lower house of the Dutch Parliament.
Claiming "respect for international law, the positions of the EU and the protection of Romanian citizens", Romania announced in 2012 that it will not allow Romanian labourers to be sent to Israel unless guarantees are provided that they will not be employed in construction projects in the West Bank. Commenting on the refusal to grant this condition for Romanian workers, Israeli MK Michal Rozin stated that "Israelis are being harmed by the government's activity in the territories."
In 2011 the University of Johannesburg decided to suspend ties with Israeli Ben-Gurion University, while still allowing "individual faculty" to continue cooperating with the Israeli University on a water purification project, citing the University's support for the Israeli military. The decision was seen to affect projects in biotechnology and water purification. However, two days later, Ihron Rensburg, vice chancellor and principal of the university issued a statement saying that "UJ is not part of an academic boycott of Israel.... It has never been UJ's intention to sever all ties with BGU, although it may have been the intention of some UJ staff members."
On 31 August 2012, the Wits University Students' Representative Council (Wits SRC) adopted a declaration of academic and cultural boycott of Israel. Several days later, the Executive Committee of Wits Convocation, representing the alumni and academic staff of the university, distanced itself from the declaration. The South African Union of Jewish Students, sharply criticized the resolution, calling it "a vicious and one-sided resolution aimed at shutting down all debate and discussion surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict".
In March 2013, eleven student BDS supporters at the Wits University were arrested after they forced the cancellation of a concert by Israeli pianist Yossi Reshef. They were subsequently sentenced to community service. At a follow up concert held on 28 August 2013, which featured Israeli jazz saxophonist Daniel Zamir, dozens of BDS protesters gathered outside. Due to security measures implemented by the University, the protesters were unable to disrupt the performance, as they were kept outside by security personnel. However, concert goers were subject to verbal abuse including the singing of a song that included the lyrics "Dubula iJuda" (Shoot the Jew), at as well as chants of "There is no such thing as Israel" and "Israel apartheid". Some attendees were also pelted with sheets of paper. The actions of the protesters were condemned by University Vice-Chancellor Adam Habib and by the South African Jewish Board of Deputies. Muhammed Desai, coordinator of BDS South Africa later went on to justify the actions. Several days later, however, BDS released an official statement condemning the chants of "dubula ijuda". Desai was later called on to resign by BDS supporters.
On 22 April 2005, the Association of University Teachers (AUT) Council voted to boycott two Israeli universities: University of Haifa and Bar-Ilan University. The motions to AUT Council were prompted by the call for a boycott from Palestinian academics and others. The AUT Council voted to boycott Bar-Ilan because it runs courses at colleges in the occupied West Bank (in Ariel College) and "is thus directly involved with the occupation of Palestinian territories contrary to United Nations resolutions". It boycotted Haifa because it was alleged that the university had wrongly disciplined a lecturer. The action against the lecturer was supposedly for supporting a student who wrote about attacks on Palestinians during the founding of the state of Israel (he withdrew the claims when sued for libel and the University denied having disciplined the lecturer). The boycott, which was not compulsory, was set to last until Haifa "ceases its victimisation of academic staff and students who seek to research and discuss the history of the founding of the state of Israel". and by Universities UK.
After both internal and external backlash and condemnation, members of the AUT, headed by Open University lecturer Jon Pike - gathered enough signatures to call a special meeting on the subject. The meeting was held on 26 May 2005, at Friends Meeting House in London. At the meeting the AUT decided to cancel the boycott of both Israeli universities. Reasons cited for the decision were: the damage to academic freedom, the hampering of dialogue and peace effort between Israelis and Palestinian, and that boycotting Israel alone could not be justified.
At the 2006 annual conference of the United Kingdom lecturers' union, the National Association of Teachers in Further and Higher Education (NATFHE), members were asked to support a motion calling for a boycott of Israeli academics and universities that did not distance themselves from "apartheid policies". Although the motion was passed it ceased to be official policy just two days later when the union merged with the Association of University Teachers.
Prior to the NATFHE debate the Federation of Unions of Palestinian University Professors and Employees and the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel described the campaign in a letter to the Times Higher Education Supplement as "the only non-violent forms of action available to people of conscience the world over" adding, "We salute those who recognise that, since justice for Palestinians cannot be expected from the international centres of world power, they must organise to further the cause of justice and genuine peace." In contrast, Nobel laureate Steven Weinberg argued:
"it is never a good idea for academics to boycott colleagues in other countries on political grounds. During the Cold War, American and Soviet scientists were careful to keep intellectual communication open; this not only served the cause of science, but promoted personal relationships that led to initiatives in arms control. In a similar spirit, when I ran the Jerusalem Winter School of Theoretical Physics we did what we could to recruit Arab students from Muslim countries whose governments discriminated against Jews. We never dreamt of boycotting them."
In 2009, the UK's University and College Union passed a resolution to boycott Israeli academics and academic institutions by a large majority. Delegates stated that Israeli academics were complicit in their government's acts against Palestinians. However, the vote was immediately declared invalid as UCU attorneys repeated previous warnings that such a boycott would likely trigger legal action against the union.
Noam Chomsky, the 2011 Sydney Peace Prize recipient and a prominent activist for Palestinian human rights, has stated that he supports the "boycott and divestment of firms that are carrying out operations in the occupied territories" but the current BDS movement's "hypocrisy rises to heaven". He stated that the BDS campaign harms the "whole movement. It harms the Palestinians and it is a gift to the Israeli hardliners and their American supporters", because the BDS's "hypocrisy is so transparent... why not boycott the United States?.. Israeli crimes [are] a fragment of US crimes, which are much worse". He also argued that the Palestinian people don't support boycotting Israel and that the BDS movement is run by "one man NGOs" who falsely claim to represent the Palestinian people. In the same interview, he also criticized BDS founder Omar Barghouti for advocating a full boycott of Israel, despite having studied at Tel Aviv University. In May 2013, Chomsky, along with other professors such as Professor Malcolm Levitt, advised Professor Stephen Hawking to boycott an Israeli conference.
Liberal Zionist Peter Beinart, in his 2012 book The Crisis of Zionism, describes BDS as a "shrewd tactic" in that "[a]s a non-violent movement, it turns the world's attention away from terrorism, which has long undermined sympathy for the Palestinian cause. It gives activists frustrated by America's unwillingness to pressure Israel a mechanism to do so themselves. It harnesses new technologies that empower citizens to organize across national lines. And it capitalizes on the revulsion that many people whose nations were once colonized -- or were once colonizers -- feel toward an Israeli occupation with clear colonial features."
Norman Finkelstein, a harsh critic of Israel's occupation of Palestinian territory, has also expressed an ambivalent attitude towards BDS. He has supported economic boycott of Israel and said that BDS has the "right tactics", but that it needs to be "explicit on its goal" and that "the goal has to include recognition of Israel, or it won't reach the public". He is hostile towards the BDS movement in its current form, labeling it a "hypocritical, dishonest cult" led by "dishonest gurus" who want to "selectively enforce the law" and try to cleverly pose as human rights activists, whereas their real goal is the destruction of Israel. In addition, he said, "I'm getting a little bit exasperated with what I think is a whole lot of nonsense. I'm not going to tolerate silliness, childishness and a lot of leftist posturing. I loathe the disingenuousness. We will never hear the solidarity movement [back a] two-state solution." Furthermore, Finkelstein stated that the BDS movement has had very few successes, and that like a cult, the leaders pretend that they are hugely successful when in reality the general public rejects their extreme views.
As of 2012, "[n]o American university has divested from Israel and prominent campus presidents have said they would oppose such efforts." University of Pennsylvania President Amy Gutmann said in January 2012 that the university "has clearly stated on numerous occasions that it does not support sanctions or boycotts against Israel". She said that the school was not a sponsor of a BDS conference taking place on campus in February 2012.
In January 2012, The Forward published an article about Jewish presidents of universities, saying that "many college presidents" see BDS as a "red line" and "presidents who were previously disinclined to speak out against anti-Israel activity on campus in the name of preserving open dialogue found themselves publicly opposing the movement." According to an editorial by Judea Pearl, calls for academic boycotts of Israel usually fall on deaf ears because universities recognize the anti-academic character of the BDS campaign and understand that the history of the Arab-Israeli conflict is more complex than the BDS campaign asserts it to be.
To date, student governments at six of the 10 University of California system schools (Berkeley, Irvine, Riverside, San Diego, Santa Cruz, and UCLA) have passed resolutions calling for their schools to divest themselves of their investments in Israel. In response to this, Herb London, president of the London Center for Policy Research, wrote University of California President Janet Napolitano urging her to get personally involved in the debate at UC system schools about divesting themselves of investments in Israel.
According to Yehuda Ben Meir and Owen Alterman in an essay published in the Strategic Survey for Israel 2011 by the Institute for National Security Studies (Israel), the BDS campaign operates under a two-pronged approach in targeting Israel. The authors argue that BDS engages in defamation and demonization of Israel by depicting Israel as a racist, fascist, totalitarian, and apartheid state. They state that this is followed by the specific targeting of Israeli diplomatic, economic, academic, and cultural targets—regardless of their position or connection to the conflict, which they describe as incitement. Alan Dershowitz and the Israeli Action Network point to the Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas's support of a boycott specific to Israeli businesses that operate in Israeli settlements in the Palestinian Territories over a general boycott of Israel as evidence that the BDS is not in the Palestinians' favor.
In a 2009 opinion column for the The Jerusalem Post, Gil Troy argued that the BDS movement does not target Israel's policies, but rather targets Israel's legitimacy. The Israeli Reut Institute has argued that the BDS movement singles out Israel, and applies double standards that delegitimizes Israel.
Martin Raffel, who oversees the Israel Action Network, argued in March 2011 that Israel's supporters can respectfully debate artists who choose to boycott the West Bank town of Ariel, but that "not recognizing Israel as a Jewish democratic state is a completely different story".
The Economist in 2007 called the boycott "flimsy" and ineffective, noted that "blaming Israel alone for the impasse in the occupied territories will continue to strike many outsiders as unfair," and pointed out that the Palestinian leadership did not support the boycott. By early 2014, however, they noted that the campaign, "[o]nce derided as the scheming of crackpots", was "turning mainstream" in the eyes of many Israelis.
The director of communications for the New Israel Fund wrote in March 2012 that the BDS movement "has accomplished very little" and that it should be relegated "to the trash-heap of failed strategies, where it belongs". Naftali Balanson, writing a response, says "Even if BDS messaging were improved and there was no backlash among 'besieged' Israelis, BDS would still be immoral and inherently wrong."
According to the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, "BDS supports and promotes completely different values than those which currently stand at the heart of the Palestinian-Israeli negotiations."
In July 2014, Noam Chomsky warns that the boycott, divestment, and sanctions campaign could end up harming the Palestinian cause since the demand for a "right of return" for Palestinian refugees has failed to muster significant international support. He also said "if we boycott Tel Aviv University because Israel violates human rights at home, then why not boycott Harvard because of far greater violations by the United States?".
In September 2014, over 620 academics, most of whom are based in North America and Israel, signed an online petition which states that the undersigned "vigorously support free speech and free debate but we oppose faculty or student boycotts of Israel’s academic institutions, scholars and students." The petition states that the BDS movement "violates the very principle of academic freedom" and charges that it engages in "accusations and narratives" that are derived from "overstatements, cherry picked evidence, outright falsehood" or "disputed or highly biased data." Academics who have signed the petition include Alan Dershowitz, Eric Alterman, Judea Pearl and Deborah Dash Moore.
Criticism by artists and public figures
The Palestinian Authority officially supports "a boycott only against products made in West Bank settlements". Although the authority rejects Israeli occupation and settlements in the West Bank, an advisor to Abbas said, "We are neighbors with Israel, we have agreements with Israel, we recognize Israel, we are not asking anyone to boycott products of Israel."
The long-standing pro-Palestinian activist and political scientist Norman Finkelstein deemed the BDS movement a "cult". He argued that the worldwide movement was overly controlled by the Ramallah headquarters, made irrealistic claims so as to hide a wish to destroy Israel, and accused the movement of exaggerating its achievements and its capacity, most notably by maintaining that it represents the entire pro-Palestine movement. Finkelstein also asserted that the movement misrepresented and misinterpreted Israel's obligation under international law as defined by the International Court of Justice.
Israeli-born musician Gene Simmons, lead singer of Kiss, said that artists who avoid Israel — such as Elvis Costello, the Pixies and Roger Waters - would be better served directing their anger at Arab dictators. "The countries they should be boycotting are the same countries that the populations are rebelling," he said.
Other artists who have voiced opposition to the campaign include John Lydon, Umberto Eco, Joel and Ethan Coen, and Ziggy Marley. Novelist Ian McEwan, upon being awarded the Jerusalem Prize, was urged to turn it down, but said that "If I only went to countries that I approve of, I probably would never get out of bed.... It's not great if everyone stops talking."
Creative Community for Peace, founded in late 2011, is an anti-BDS organization made up of music executives and music representatives of bands including Aerosmith, Celine Dion, Lady Gaga, Jennifer Lopez and Justin Timberlake.
Replies to criticism
|This section requires expansion with: examples and additional citations. (April 2014)|
One line of critique says that the boycott is futile, in that it will not gather momentum or that it will strengthen the hardcore Zionists and weaken the will to make compromises for peace. In an op-ed in Haaretz, Gideon Levy concedes that boycott may "enhance the sense of victimhood, isolationism and nationalism" in the short run, but that in the long run, it "could result in a major change in attitude", especially if Israeli businesses put pressure on the government.
Allegations of antisemitism
The Anti-Defamation League, the Simon Wiesenthal Center and Israeli officials categorize the BDS movement as antisemitic. Abraham Foxman penned an advertisement that ran in The New York Times that criticized Brooklyn College's political science department for sponsoring a conference promoting BDS. In the ad, Foxman referred to the BDS movement as antisemitic "at its very core".
- The "double-standards" argument claims that the BDS campaign singles-out Israel, or that it judges the state with standards different from those used to judge other political situations. For example, Charles Krauthammer writes: "Israel is the world's only Jewish state. To apply to the state of the Jews a double standard that you apply to none other, to judge one people in a way you judge no other, to single out that one people for condemnation and isolation – is to engage in a gross act of discrimination." Retired Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz compares the way BDS proponents "single-out" Israel for its human rights violations with the way Harvard president A. Lawrence Lowell defended his decision to impose anti-Jewish quotas in the beginning of the twentieth century. When asked why there should be a quota on Jews, Lowell replied, "Jews cheat." When reminded that Christians cheat too, Lowell responded, "You're changing the subject. We are talking about Jews now."
- The claim that BDS objectives are detrimental to Jewish people, either because its call to uphold UN Resolution 194 would "mean eradicating Israel", hence leading "to the coming of a second Holocaust" or because it encourages terrorism and impedes peace.
- The accusation that supporters of the campaign make anti-Semitic statements or engage in anti-Semitic activity. For example, some supporters compare Israel's contemporary treatment of Arabs to Nazi Germany's treatment of Jews during the Holocaust and deny Israel's right to self-determination. The Australian attributes BDS supporters with anti-Semitic activity including the publication of material on the internet that denies the Holocaust and promotes attacks against "Jews and Jew lovers".
- Seeing similarities between BDS and historical acts of discrimination against Jewish minorities, such as historic antisemitic boycotts, in particular the Nazi boycott of Jewish businesses.
Replies to allegations
Several replies have been made to the allegations presented above:
- Jay Michaelson wrote an editorial in The Jewish Daily Forward critical of Foxman's position. His editorial mentioned that several leaders of the BDS movement are themselves Jewish and state that the ADL, "with every pro-censorship stance it takes ... loses more and more credibility and cheapens the meaning of the term 'anti-Semitism' itself".
- The claim that BDS targets the state of Israel and its institutions, rather than individuals for their citizenship, or their beliefs.
- The human rights argument claims that BDS' demands are fully compatible with, and derived from, international standards for human rights. From this Judith Butler draws the conclusion that equating BDS with antisemitism amounts to the assertion, that those standards are antisemitic.
- The "double-standards" argument has seen several types of rejoinders.
- One approach rejects the "double-standards" allegation, claiming that the situation in Israel is unique in some sense, different from other situations in which human rights violations are committed, and this uniqueness justifies boycotting Israel but not other countries. For example, some argue that Israel is one of the most highly subsidized American allies and that thanks to their unique political and historical relationships with Israel, Americans have a special responsibility to the status of human rights in that country. Another reason for treating the Israeli case differently is that the call for boycott is the result of a unified effort by numerous civil societies whose members see themselves as the victims of Israeli human rights violations, and that such a unified effort is not paralleled in otherwise comparable political contexts today. An example for this latter effect can be found in the words of scientist Stephen Hawking, explaining that his decision to withdraw from Israel's Presidential Conference was motivated by calls from Palestinian academics, who were unanimous in their conviction that he "should respect the boycott".
- Another rejoinder holds that eventually, all countries must be held accountable to human rights standards, but that there is no standard answer to the question which should be held accountable first. This logic is reflected in an article published in the Chicago Tribune, in which Professor of Law George Bisharat criticized the argument that it is antisemitic to boycott Israel before other human rights abusers, writing "There has never been a "worst first" rule for boycotts. Activists urging divestment from apartheid South Africa were not racist because they failed to simultaneously condemn the demonstrably worse Cambodian dictator Pol Pot. Nor were U.S. civil rights protesters required to inventory the world and only protest if our nation exceeded the abuses of others. Boycotts are justified whenever they are necessary and promise results."
- A third approach accuses those who invoke the "double-standards" argument of hypocrisy, noting that they invoke it only against critics of Israeli violence, not against critics of Palestinian violence.
- The Ad hominem argument claims that personal attacks of BDS supporters are logically irrelevant, because they focus on individuals' character, acts and/or motivation, rather than on the arguments for or against the BDS initiative in and of themselves. This line of argumentation chimes with the words of University of California, Berkeley Professor of Sociology Claude S. Fischer, when he writes, "It is certainly true that anti-Semitism fuels the BDS movement. But most of the fuel — and the greatest problem for Western defenders of Israel — is the occupation, its settlements and the ugliness it often brings. That is why, for example, one of the powerful voices at the Berkeley BDS meeting for the proposal was that of an Israeli graduate student who had fought with the IDF in Lebanon. Fischer suggests that the right-wing Israeli "hard-core may stop up their ears, shut their eyes and yell 'anti-Semite' as loud as they can, but" they ought to listen to people who have legitimate criticisms of Israel and allow them into the mainstream conversation.
- Critique of an assumption implicit in the allegation, that being Jewish necessarily implies identification with the state of Israel. For example, Butler argues that the allegation of anti-Semitism springs necessarily from a false "generalizations about all Jews", presuming that "they all share the same political commitments" while ignoring a view prevalent among some Jews who were "exceedingly critical" of the state. A similar line of reasoning was developed by Omar Barghouti, who claims that those who criticize BDS as an attack on all the Jewish people are equating the latter with state of Israel, a position "as absurd and bigoted as claiming that a boycott of a self-defined Islamic state like Saudi Arabia, say, because of its horrific human rights record, would of necessity be Islamophobic".
- Barghouti, Omar (2011). Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions: The Global Struggle for Palestinian Rights. Haymarket Books. ISBN 978-1-60846-114-1.
- Brackman, Harold. "Boycott Divestment Sanctions (BDS) Against Israel: An Anti-Semitic, Anti-Peace Poison Pill". Simon Wiesenthal Center. March 2013. 1 June 2013.
- Marcelo Svirsky (28 October 2011). Arab-Jewish activism in Israel-Palestine. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. p. 121. ISBN 978-1-4094-2229-7. Retrieved 3 June 2013.
- Mitchell G. Bard; Jeff Dawson (2012). "Israel and the Campus: The Real Story". AICE. Retrieved 27 October 2013.
- Charles Tripp (25 February 2013). The Power and the People: Paths of Resistance in the Middle East. Cambridge University Press. p. 125. ISBN 978-0-521-80965-8. Retrieved 3 June 2013.
- Nathan Guttman (13 April 2010). "Want to delegitimize Israel? Be careful who you mess with". Haaretz. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Boycotts that aid the Palestinians by Ben White, Al Jazeera, 16 August 2013.
- What's So Wrong With BDS? by Jerry Haber, The Daily Beast, 7 February 2013.
- Israel is new South Africa as boycott calls increase by Jonathan Owen, The Independent, 3 June 2012.
- "Truth, Lies & Stereotypes" (PDF). StandWithUs. Retrieved 29 December 2006.
- Christopher C. Joyner (1984). "The transnational boycott as economic coercion in international law: policy, place, and practice". Vanderbilt Journal of International Law 17 (2): 206–286.
- This article incorporates public domain material from the Congressional Research Service document "Arab League Boycott of Israel.".
- Joyce Shems Sharon. "The Arab Boycott Against Israel and Its Unintended Impact on Arab Economic Walfare". May 2003.
- Julie M. Norman (24 June 2010). The Second Palestinian Intifada: Civil Resistance. Taylor & Francis. p. 11. ISBN 978-0-203-84829-6. Retrieved 6 June 2013.
- Rhea A. DuMont (1 January 2013). Conflict Transformation: Essays on Methods of Nonviolence. McFarland. p. 49. ISBN 978-1-4766-0121-2. Retrieved 6 June 2013.
- Daniel Coleman; Erin Goheen Glanville; Wafaa Hasan; Agnes Kramer-Hamstra (26 April 2012). Countering Displacements: The Creativity and Resilience of Indigenous and Refugee-ed Peoples. University of Alberta. p. 81. ISBN 978-0-88864-592-0. Retrieved 7 June 2013.
- Julie M. Norman (2009). The Activist and the Olive Tree: Nonviolent Resistance in the Second Intifada. ProQuest. pp. 281–. ISBN 978-1-109-16669-9. Retrieved 6 June 2013.
- Salusinzky, Imre. "Palestinian consul rejects BDS violence". The Australian. 26 October 2011. 6 June 2013.
- "Simon Wiesenthal Center Report: BDS 'a Thinly-Veiled, Anti-Israel and Anti-Semitic "Poison Pill"'. The Algemeiner. 19 March 2013. 7 June 2013.
- "Introducing the BDS Movement". Palestinian BDS National Committee. Retrieved 22 February 2012.
- Abigail Bakan; Yasmin Abu-Laban (2009). "Palestinian resistance and international solidarity: the BDS campaign". Race and Class 51 (1): 29–54. doi:10.1177/0306396809106162. Retrieved 4/6/2013. Check date values in:
- NZ Super Fund excludes three Israeli firms on ethical grounds, The New Zealand Herald, 12 December 2012.
- New Zealand government fund divests from Israeli firms over settlement construction, Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA), (republished in Haaretz), 16 December 2012.
- Dutch firm severs ties with Mekorot over West Bank policy by Herb Keinon, Sharon Udasin, The Jerusalem Post, 10 December 2013.
- Explaining Royal HaskoningDHV's decision to terminate involvement in wastewater treatment project in East Jerusalem, Royal HaskoningDHV, 14 January 2014.
- Denmark's largest bank blacklists Israel's Hapoalim over settlement construction by Barak Ravid, Haaretz, 1 February 2014.
- Norwegian YMCA embraces boycott Israel policy, Jewish Telegraphic Agency (reprinted in The Jerusalem Post), 2 March 2014.
- Norwegian youth group YMCA-YWCA boycotts Israel, Press TV, 4 March 2014.
- Jewish NGO wants YMCA rapped for Israel boycott, The Local, 14 March 2014.
- "Appeals Court Upholds Olympia Food Co-op's Boycott of Israeli Goods". Center for Constitutional Rights.
- Appeals Court upholds Olympia Food Co-op's boycott of Israeli goods by Jeremy Pawloski, The Olympian 7 April 2014.
- "Bill Gates sells shares in U.K. firm linked to Israeli security services". Haaretz. 31 May 2014.
- BDS backers rejoice after Gates sells shares of UK security firm with ties to Israel, The Jerusalem Post, 30 May 2014.
- Gates Foundation sells stake in Britain's G4S, Reuters, 7 June 2014.
- Desmond Tutu tells G4S to stop supplying to Israel prisons by Rupert Neate, The Guardian, 4 June 2014.
- "United Methodist Church Divests From Security Firm Targeted For Work In Palestinian Territories". Huffington Post. 12 June 2014.
- Plimmer, Gill (5 June 2014). "G4S to end Israeli jail contracts within three years". Financial Times.
- G4S must end its complicity in Israel's abuse of child prisoners, Open Letter published in The Guardian, 4 June 2014.
- "BDS bursts SodaStream's U.K. bubble". Haaretz. 3 July 2014. Retrieved 18 July 2014.
- Rilwan, Ahmed (21 July 2014). "Maldives to boycott Israeli products, annul bilateral agreements". Minivan News. Retrieved 22 July 2014.
- "Maldives to boycott Israeli products". Sun Online (21 July 2014). Retrieved 22 July 2014.
- Harriet Sherwood, Matthew Kalman in Israel and Sam Jones (9 May 2013). "Stephen Hawking: Furore deepens over Israel boycott". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 9 May 2013.
- Robert Booth and Harriet Sherwood (10 May 2013). "Noam Chomsky helped lobby Stephen Hawking to stage Israel boycott". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 11 May 2013.
- Greenberg, David. "The ASA's Boycott of Israel Is Not as Troubling As It Seems". The New Republic. 19 December 2013. 2 January 2014.
- "2013 Top Ten Anti-Semitic/Anti-Israel Slurs". Simon Wiesenthal Center. 2013. 30 December 2013.
- Redden, Elizabeth. "Backing the Israel Boycott". Inside Higher Ed. 17 December 2013. 2 January 2014.
- Cravatts, Richard L. "Answering back to the academic boycotters of Israel". Jewish Journal. 2 January 2014. 2 January 2014.
- World in brief - 24 April 2014, Times Higher Education, 24 April 2014.
- Pérez-Peña, Richard (2013-12-15). "Scholars' Group to Disclose Result of Vote on an Academic Boycott of Israel". The New York Times. Retrieved 2013-12-23.
- 134 members of US Congress denounce ASA's Israel boycott by Maya Shwayder, The Jerusalem Post, 19 January 2014.
- Congressional Letter: Academic Boycott of Israel is 'Thinly Veiled Bigotry' by Lori Lowenthal Marcus, Jewish Press 10 January 2014 (updated: 14 January 2014.)
- US academia split over boycott targeting Israel by Marcella Bombardieri, Boston Globe, 25 December 2013.
- Boycott of Israeli universities: A repugnant attack on academic freedom by Michael S. Roth, Los Angeles Times, 19 December 2013.
- Dozens of universities reject academic boycott of Israel (update) by Valerie Strauss, The Washington Post, 23 December 2013.
- Some hard questions about the Western European double standard against Israel by Alan Dershowitz, The Jerusalem Post 12 March 2014.
- Irish student union endorses Israel boycott, Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA) [republished in Haaretz, 7 March 2014.
- "NUS Black Students conference endorses BDS, slams Israeli 'systemic' racism". Middle-East Monitor. 19 May 2014.
- "Human Rights Council elects Advisory Committee Members and approves a number of Special Procedures mandate holders". United Nations. 26 March 2008. Archived from the original on 1 January 2009. Retrieved 1 January 2009.
- Wayne Schoenfeld, Richard Falk Calls for Corporate Israel Boycott; U.N. Official Backs Calls To Shun Occupation-Backing Firms, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 25 October 2012.
- Michelle Nichols, U.N. expert calls for boycott of companies in Jewish settlements Reuters, 25 October 2012.
- Klein, Naomi (10/1/2009). "Enough. It's time for a boycott". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 6 April 2013. Check date values in:
- Klein, Naomi (2009-1-26). "Israel: Boycott, Divest, Sanction". The Nation. Retrieved 6 April 2013. Check date values in:
- Mackey, Robert. "Boycott of Theater in Israeli Settlement Grows". http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com.
- Guttman, Nathan. "Why Some Jewish Stars Support Israeli Artistic Boycott". Forward.com.
- Levinson, Chaim. "150 academics, artists back actors' boycott of settlement arts center". haaretz.com.
- Fyler, Boaz. "Yehoshua, Oz, Grossman back boycott of Ariel". ynetnews.com.
- Jerome Klassen; Gregory Albo (2013-01-10). Empire's Ally: Canada and the War in Afghanistan. University of Toronto Press. p. 407. ISBN 978-1-4426-1304-1.
- Adam Horowitz and Philip Weiss (28 June 2010). "The Boycott Divestment Sanctions Movement". The Nation. Retrieved 31 March 2014.
- CUPE joins boycott of Israel, National Post, 26 May 2006.
- CUPE in Ontario votes to boycott Israel, CBC News, 27 May 2006.
- CUPE Ontario's Resolution 50: Towards peace and justice in the Middle East, CUPE Ontario International Solidarity Committee, Page 2.
- Lewis, Jerry (6 July 2014). "UK's largest union backs boycott of Israel". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
- "About Israeli Apartheid Week". Retrieved 2010-03-03.
- Campuses awash in tension over Israel apartheid week", National Post, 2 March 2009
- "Israeli Apartheid Week 2009 may be coming to a campus near you", The Jerusalem Post, 29 January 2009[dead link]
- How did the most humane state in history become demonized? - Opinion
- The Canadian Jewish News - Israel Apartheid Week gains momentum
- The Australian Jewish News - BDS, bombs and rock 'n' roll
- "Israeli Apartheid Week" starts today The Jerusalem Post (03-03-2012)
- Maltz, Judy. "Boycott = anti-Semitism? Some Israelis avoid settlement products too".
- Keller, Adam. "Supreme Court to rule on legality of settlement boycott.". www.jpost.com.
- Scharf, Isaac. "Israeli settlements also face pressure from within". news.yahoo.com.
- Beinart, Peter. "To Save Israel, Boycott the Settlements". nytimes.com.
- Kane, Alex. "‘Progressive Zionist’ group in U.S. calls for settlement boycott". alexbkane.wordpress.com.
- Paiss, Naomi. "Boycotting settlements is not anti-Israel.". jewishjournal.com.
- Robbins, Annie. "Rabbi Ellen Lippmann changes her mind on the boycott". Mondoweiss.com.
- "AJDS resolution on Boycotts, Divestment & Sanctions of Israel". ajds.org.au.
- Keller, Uri. "The Economy of the Occupation: A Socioeconomic Bulletin". bdsmovement.net. The Alternative Information Center.
- "‘Jews For Palestinian Right of Return’ endorse American Studies Association boycott of Israeli academic institutions". Mondoweiss.net.
- Slezak, Peter. "Anti-Semitism and BDS: Beyond misrepresentations". abc.net.au.
- Dayan, Colin. "Why I support the ASA boycott of Israeli academic institutions". america.aljazeera.com.
- A Conflict of Faith: Devoted to Jewish Observance, but at Odds With Israel by Mark Oppenheimer, New York Times, February 14, 2014.
- Mackey, Robert. "Boycott of Theater in Israeli Settlement Grows". http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com.
- Guttman, Nathan. "Why Some Jewish Stars Support Israeli Artistic Boycott". Forward.com.
- Levinson, Chaim. "150 academics, artists back actors' boycott of settlement arts center". haaretz.com.
- Fyler, Boaz. "Yehoshua, Oz, Grossman back boycott of Ariel". ynetnews.com.
- Nevel, Donna. "Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) and the American Jewish Community". tikkun.org.
- Haber, Jerry. "Liberal Zionism in the Era of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions Movement". thedailybeast.com.
- Horowitz, Adam. "‘Without doubt, the biggest loser in this well publicized BDS campaign was SodaStream’: Reactions to Johansson leaving Oxfam". Mondoweiss.net.
- Konrad, Edo. "Israeli teens tell Netanyahu: We will not take part in occupation". 972mag.com.
- "AJDS resolution on Boycotts, Divestment & Sanctions of Israel". http://www.ajds.org.au.
- Strauss Group Ltd. Annual Report, 31 December 2012
- "Two Australian BDS protesters found guilty of assault". Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 30 July 2012. Retrieved 30 July 2012.
- "Israel boycotts now official NSW Greens policy". The Australian Jewish News. 9 December 2010. Retrieved 9 May 2011.
- Kerr, Christian (29 August 2011). "Greens senator Lee Rhiannon stands by Israel boycott". The Australian. Retrieved 30 August 2011.
- Massola, James; Kelly, Joe (1 April 2011). "Greens leader Bob Brown slaps down Lee Rhiannon on Israel boycott policy". The Australian. Retrieved 9 May 2011.
- "Greens NSW Reviews BDS". Greens NSW. Retrieved 8 February 2012.
- "Local Australian political party drops Israel boycott". Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA). 6 December 2011. Retrieved 8 February 2012.
- Imre Salusinszky (26 October 2011). "Palestinian consul rejects BDS violence". The Australian. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Gareth Narunsky (24 June 2011). "Police called to action on BDS". The Australian Jewish News. Retrieved 13 July 2011.
- Aikman, Amos; Shanahan, Leo (20 April 2011). "Greens forced to back down on Israel boycott". The Australian.
- Ric Willmot. "Martin Foley, Victorian Labor MP scared of Year 12 student". Retrieved 27 October 2013.
- Julia Gillard denounces activists as anti-Israel protest turns anti-Semitic
- Ean Higgins and Christian Kerr (3 May 2013). "Jihad Sheila link to anti-Jewish posts". The Australian. Retrieved 14 May 2013.
- Ean Higgins (29 May 2013). "In a democracy freedom of expression had to allow a capacity for dissent". The Australian. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- United Church of Canada approves boycott of settlement goods
- Boycott of Israel delayed by University of Windsor students, CBC News, 14 March 2014.
- Irish student union joins boycott Israel campaign, Press TV, 9 March 2014.
- Khadir blocks debate on anti-Israel boycott motion by Janice Arnold, Canadian Jewish News, Staff Reporter, 17 February 2011.
- Barbara Kay: Quebec strikes a blow against anti-Israel heels by Barbara Kay, National Post, 4 March 2011.
- Jonathan Lis (11 July 2011). "Israel passes law banning calls for boycott". Haaretz.; description "New Version of Boycott Prohibition Bill Approved for Final Reading". Association for Civil Rights in Israel. 27 June 2011. which includes a link to download the English translation of the current version of the bill.
- Tomer Zarchin and Jonathan Lis (14 July 2011). "Dozens of Israeli law professors protest against the boycott law". Haaretz.
- Gerald M. Steinberg (23 February 2011). "Transparency for NGOs is not anti-democratic". Haaretz. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- "Site launched to counter boycotts of Israeli goods". The Jerusalem Post. Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA). 15 May 2012. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Elior Levy (20 May 2012). "'Palestinians will lose jobs if boycott persists'". Ynetnews. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Swiss government, Dutch lawmakers denounce boycotts of Israel, Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA), 21 March 2014.
- Dutch MP tells 'Post': Boycotting Israel is wrong by Moshe Arenstein, The Jerusalem Post, 10 January 2014.
- Israel-Romania row over settlements building, Al Jazeera, 11 December 2013.
- Romania stops sending construction workers to Israel over settlements by Jonathan Lis, Haaretz, 10 December 2013.
- Romanian FM expected to address labor disagreement during visit by Herb Keinon, The Jerusalem Post, 22 December 2013.
- Ben Hartman (24 March 2011). "University of Johannesburg votes to sever ties with BGU". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Matthew Kalman (25 March 2011). "U. of Johannesburg Official: 'UJ Is Not Part of an Academic Boycott of Israel'". The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved 9 September 2012.
- Ant Katz (1 September 2012). "Wits students join UJ boycott". My shtet. Retrieved 4 September 2012.
- "South African university distances itself from student boycott of Israel". Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA). 4 September 2012. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Student BDS supporters sentenced for disrupting Israeli pianist, Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA), 22 January 2014.
- Emelia Motsai (29 August 2013). BDS protests Daniel Zamir concert at Wits Wits Vuvuzela. Retrieved 2 January 2014
- David Lev. (1 September 2013. South African BDS Protesters: 'Shoot the Jew' Arutz Sheva. Retrieved 2 January 2014.
- South Africa BDS leader defends call to 'kill the Jew' by Sam Sokol, The Jerusalem Post, 2 September 2013.
- BDS distances itself from "shoot the Jew" by Emelia Motsai, Wits Vuvuzela, 3 September 2013.
- "Palestinian academics call for international academic boycott of Israel". Birzeit University. 7 July 2004. Retrieved 22 May 2005.
- "The University of Haifa Response to the AUT Decision". University of Haifa. 15 May 2008. Retrieved 15 May 2008.
- Curtis, Polly (24 May 2005). "Second Opinion". London: The Guardian. Retrieved 16 May 2008.
- BBC News (22 April 2005). "Academics back Israeli boycotts". Retrieved 31 December 2009.
- "Joint Hebrew university--al-quds university statement on academic cooperation signed in London". Hebrew University. Retrieved 15 May 2008.
- Ewing, Jim (6 April 2005). "NPC Says: Don't take Academia Hostage". National Postgraduate Committee. Retrieved 12 August 2007.
- "Academics vote against Israeli boycott". London: The Guardian. 26 May 2005. Retrieved 22 May 2005.
- "Lecturers call for Israel boycott". BBC News. 30 May 2006. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Steven Weinberg and Palestinian academics, 'A Nobel laureate and Palestinian academics on Natfhe's proposed boycott of Israel', Times Higher Education Supplement, 26 May 2006, Pg. 16 No. 1744.
- "British union votes to boycott Israeli universities, academics". Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA). 1 June 2009. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Jessica Shepherd (27 May 2009). "Lecturers vote to boycott Israeli universities". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- "Oxford students reject boycott Israel motion". Jewish Journal 27 February 2013. 27 February 2013.
- "Netanyahu dismisses Kerry warning about price of failure in peace talks". www.theguardian.com (AP). 2 February 2014. Retrieved 2 February 2014.
- Stephen Hawking joins academic boycott of Israel
- "Noam Chomsky". The Agenda with Steve Paikin. TVOntario. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSXpg-Izcik#t=21m40s. Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- Noam Chomsky Interviewed by Frank Barat, on Israel/Palestine (4/4). 2010. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Peter Beinart (27 March 2012). The Crisis of Zionism. Henry Holt and Company. p. 190. ISBN 978-1-4299-4346-8. Retrieved 5 June 2013.
- "Norman Finkelstein Interview with Frank Barat: BDS Campaign". Imperial College London. 2012-09-02.
- Marcus Dysch (16 February 2012). "Finkelstein disowns 'silly' Israel boycott". The Jewish Chronicle Online. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Semple, Kirk; Kuntzman, Gersh (28 March 2012). "With Lopsided Vote, Food Co-op Rejects Effort to Boycott Israeli-Made Products". The New York Times. Retrieved 31 March 2012.
- "Study: No anti-Semitism, anti-Israel push at most college campuses". Jewish Journal. 23 October 2012. 23 October 2012.
- "Penn distances itself from BDS conference". Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA). 5 January 2012. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Naomi Zeveloff (20 January 2012). "College Leaders Balance Israel and Speech". The Forward. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Pearl, Judea. "Boycott Israel? Not On My Campus". Editorial. Jewish Journal. 3–9 January 2014: 9. Print.
- [Meir, Y. B., & Alterman, O. (2011). The Delegitimization Threat: Roots, Manifestations, and Containment. Strategic Survey for Israel. Tel Aviv: The Institute For National Security Studies, 121–137.]
- Dershowitz, Alan. "Israel and the myopic BDS movement". The Boston Globe. 26 December 2013. 1 January 2014.
- Guttman, Nathan. "Academic Backers of Boycott Israel Movement Take Aim at Bigger Targets". The Jewish Daily Forward. 18 December 2013. 1 January 2014.
- "Delegitimizing the delegitimizers". Retrieved 13 August 2010.
- "The Reut Institute: The BDS Movement Promotes Delegitimization against Israel". Retrieved 13 August 2010.
- Stewart Ain (15 March 2011). "Consensus Seen Taking Shape On Boycotts". The Jewish Week. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- "Boycotting Israel: New pariah on the block". The Economist. 13 September 2007.
- "A campaign that is gathering weight". The Economist. 8 February 2014.
- Naomi Paiss (16 March 2012). "A Leftist's Critique of BDS". Open Zion (The Daily Beast). Retrieved 9 September 2012.
- Balanson, Naftali (November 2010). "Moral Argument Against BDS". ZEEK (The Jewish Daily Forward). Retrieved 6 March 2011.
- Rosen, Ehud. "What is the Real BDS Endgame? The Elimination of Israel". jcpa.org. Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.
- "Chomsky says BDS tactics won't work, may be harmful to Palestinians". The Jerusalem Post. 3 July 2014.
- Hundreds in academic world sign anti-BDS petition, Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA), September 22, 2014.
- 'Petition to Oppose Boycotts of Israel's Academic Institutions, Scholars, and Students' by Daniel Halper, The Weekly Standard, September 18, 2014.
- Perez-Pena, Richard and Jodi Rudoren. "Boycott by Academic Group Is a Symbolic Sting to Israel". The New York Times. 16 December 2013. 18 December 2013.
- Norman Finkelstein Interview with Frank Barat: BDS Campaign | Imperial College London
- Normanfinkelstein.com: Beyond the mad BDS psychosis
- Norman Finkelstein Throws Wrench In Anti-Israel Movement’s Claim To A Rights-Based Agenda
- Finkelstein renews attack on BDS “cult,” calls Palestinians who pursue their rights “criminal”
- "Lead singer of Kiss Gene Simmons slams Israel boycotters". Haaretz. Associated Press. 11 March 2011. Retrieved 23 March 2011.
- "John Lydon – Lydon Slams Critics Over Israel Show – Contactmusic News". Contactmusic.com. Retrieved 13 December 2010.
- "Israel boycotters target authors, artists". Ynet. 5 March 2011. Retrieved 23 March 2011.
- Amit Kling (15 May 2012). "Coen Brothers: Boycotting Israel is a mistake". Haaretz. City Mouse Online, Haaretz Service. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Karolyn Coorsh (20 July 2011). "Reggae star Ziggy Marley rejects calls to boycott Israel". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Danielle Berrin (25 April 2012). "Music moguls to artists: Don't boycott Israel". Jewish Journal. Retrieved 16 September 2012.
- Levine, Andrew. "The Crisis of Liberal Zionism". CounterPunch.
- Levy, Gideon. "The Israeli patriot's final refuge: boycott". haaretz.
- Fishman, Joel S. "The BDS Message Of Anti-Zionism, Anti-Semitism, And Incitement To Discrimination". Israel Affairs 18.3 (2012): 412–425. Academic Search Complete. Web. 8 June 2013.
- Hallward, Maia Carter, and Patrick Shaver. "'War By Other Means' Or Nonviolent Resistance? Examining The Discourses Surrounding Berkeley's Divestment Bill". Peace & Change 37.3 (2012): 389–412. Academic Search Complete. Web. 8 June 2013.
- "Anti-Israel groups push product, performers boycott". USA Today. 17 March 2013. 8 June 2013.
- "The Wrong Way To Fight BDS". The Jewish Daily Forward. 21 February 2013. 11 June 2013.
- "Is BDS Hate Speech?" The Jewish Daily Forward. 14 February 2013. 2 June 2013.
- Foxman, Abraham. "An Open Letter on Academic Freedom and University Responsibility". ADL. 2 June 2013.
- Krauthammer:Poison of anti-Semitism continues to proliferate 9 January 2014
- Dershowitz. "Boycotting Israeli universities: A victory for bigotry". Haaretz. 17 December 2013. 23 December 2013.
- Oz, Amos (2007-01-01). "Doves should re-examine their perch". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 2007-05-21.
- Judith Butler's Remarks to Brooklyn College on BDS, The Nation, 7 February 2013
- "Dershowitz: Boycotts abet terrorism". Retrieved 5 May 2011.
- The European Union's Working Definition of Antisemitism lists “comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis" as an example of antisemitic behavior. qtd. in "Boycotts, Divestment, and Sanctions ...."
- "Boycotts, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) Resource Page". NGO Monitor. 14 July 2011. 1 June 2013.
- Kerr, Christian Julia Gillard denounces activists as anti-Israel protest turns anti-Semitic. The Australian. 30 April 2013. 7 June 2013.
- "SWC Commends UEFA for Holding Under-21 European Championship in Israel, Blasts Attempts to Cancel/Boycott the Event". Targeted News Service. 21 May 2013. ProQuest. Web. 8 June 2013.
- Michaelson, Jay. "The Wrong Way To Fight BDS". The Jewish Daily Forward. 21 February 2013. 11 June 2013.
- "Safi", "Michael" ("25 March 2014"). "Israeli boycott case: Sydney academic's lawyers say claims are pumped up". The Guardian. Check date values in:
- Jay Michaelson. "There's a Good Reason for 'Singling Out' Israel The Jewish Daily Forward. 25 January 2014. 23 December 2013.
- Harriet Sherwood, Matthew Kalman and Sam Jones Stephen Hawking: Furore deepens over Israel boycott, The Guardian, 9 May 2013.
- Applause for the academic boycott of Israel by George Bisharat, Chicago Tribune, 30 January 2014.
- Chomsky, Noam (1999). Fateful Triangle: The United States, Israel and the Palestinians.
- Fischer, Claude S. Letter - Campus inundated with anti-Israel propaganda, Jweekly, 13 June 2013.
- [http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/01/opinion/sunday/why-the-boycott-movement-scares-israel.html Why the boycott movement scares Israel, The New York Times, 31 January 2014.
|Wikisource has original text related to this article:|
Supportive of BDS
- Global BDS Campaign
- BRICUP (the British Committee for the Universities of Palestine) the body that promotes the academic boycott in the UK
- PACBI (Palestinian campaign for the academic and cultural boycott of Israel)
- Palestinian United Call for BDS against Israel by the Boycott National Committee
- Jello Biafra: "Caught in the crossfire: Should musicians boycott Israel?" on Al Jazeera website (critically supportive)
Critical of BDS
- BDSISRAEL Canadian Anti-BDS Association - Countering BDS Movement
- Jiulio Meotti, Is BDS campaign working?, Ynetnews, 31 August 2011
- NGO Monitor, Israeli anti-BDS organisation
- "Boycott Divestment Sanctions (BDS) Against Israel: An Anti-Semitic, Anti-Peace Poison Pill", Simon Wiesenthal Center, March 2013
- Delegitimation of Israel and Israel Attachments Among Jewish Young Adults:The College Campus and Other Contributing Factors, a paper by The Jewish People Policy Institute