The Butler Road stop was relatively little-used for much of its existence. In 1958, for example, only four of the 27 total northbound weekday commuter trains stopped at the station. In 1978, only three of the 22 total northbound weekday trains stopped there.
Butler Road, the road itself, has been renamed Oyster Point Boulevard. The Peninsula Commute service was renamed Caltrain in 1985, the name by which it is still known.