Camp Lejeune water contamination

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Camp Lejeune water contamination problem occurred at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune from 1953 to 1987.[1] During that time, United States Marine Corps (USMC) service members and their families living at the base apparently bathed in and ingested tap water that was contaminated with harmful chemicals. An undetermined number of former base residents later developed cancer or other ailments, which many blame on the contaminated drinking water. Victims claim that USMC leaders concealed knowledge of the problem and did not act properly in trying to resolve it or notify former base residents that their health might be at risk.

In 2009 the U.S. federal government initiated investigations into the allegations of contaminated water and failures by U.S. Marine officials to act on the issue. At least one of the reports found a higher rate of cancers and other ailments among Marines stationed at Camp Lejeune during the contamination time period. In August 2012, President Obama signed the Janey Ensminger Act into law to begin providing medical care for people who may have been affected by the contamination.

Contamination[edit]

Early reports[edit]

From at least 1953 through 1985, Marines and their families at Lejeune's main family housing areas of Tarawa Terrace and Hadnot Point drank and bathed in water contaminated with toxins at concentrations up to 3400 times levels permitted by safety standards. As a result, at least 850 former residents filed claims for nearly $4 billion from the military. The contamination appears to have affected the water from two of the eight water treatment plants on the base.[2] The main chemicals involved were volatile organic compounds (VOCs) such as perchloroethylene (PCE), a dry cleaning solvent, and trichloroethylene (TCE), a degreaser; however, more than 70 chemicals have been identified as contaminants at Lejeune.[3] The base's wells were shut off in the mid-1980s, after which the water met federal standards, then they were placed back online in violation of the law.[3][4] The Marine Corps at Camp Lejeune is now preparing to supply water to Onslow County, NC. There is a long history of lost documents, poor management, and deceptive lab testings and results. The National Resource Council of the National Academies released a report based upon a literature review of PCE and TCE in July 2009. The report failed to assess other contaminants, such as benzene and vinyl chloride, and concluded that the water at the base was tainted between 1950 and 1985, but that the contamination could not be linked to any health problems.[5][6] However, an October 2010 letter from the Director of the government agency tasked to study health effects at Superfund sites, such as Camp Lejeune, illustrated the limitations of the 2009 literature review and advised that there "was undoubtedly a hazard associated with drinking the contaminated water at Camp Lejeune." [7]

In 1980 the base began testing the water for trihalomethanes in response to new regulations from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). That same year, a laboratory from the U.S. Army Environmental Hygiene Agency began finding halogenated hydrocarbons in the water. In March 1981 one of the lab's reports, which was delivered to U.S. Marine officials, stated, "Water is highly contaminated with other chlorinated hydrocarbons (solvents)!"[8]

Possible sources of the contamination include solvents from a nearby, off-base dry cleaning company, from on-base units using chemicals to clean military equipment, and leaks from underground fuel storage tanks.[2] In 1982, a private company, Grainger Laboratories, contracted by the USMC to examine the problem provided the base commander with a report showing that the wells supplying water for the base were contaminated with trichloroethylene and tetrachloroethylene. The contractor delivered repeated warnings to base officials, including base chemist Elizabeth Betz, that the water was contaminated. A representative from Grainger, Mike Hargett, stated that he went with Betz in July 1982 to inform an unnamed Marine lieutenant colonel who was deputy director of base utilities about the problems with the water. According to Hargett, the Marine was unwilling to discuss Hargett's concerns. In August 1982, a Grainger chemist, Bruce Babson, sent a letter to the base commander, Marine Major General D.J. Fulham, warning him that the base wells appeared to be poisoned. The water from the contaminated wells, however, continued in use at the base.[8][9]

Grainger continued to warn Marine officials of problems with the water in December 1982, March 1983, and September 1983. In a spring 1983 report to the EPA, Lejeune officials stated that there were no environmental problems at the base. In June 1983, North Carolina's water supply agency asked Lejeune officials for Grainger's lab reports on the water testing. Marine officials declined to provide the reports to the state agency. In December 1983 Lejeune officials scaled back the water testing performed by Grainger.[8]

Further reports[edit]

In July 1984, a different company contracted under the EPA's Superfund review of Lejeune and other sites found benzene in the base's water, along with PCE and TCE. Marine officials shut down one of the contaminated wells in November 1984 and the rest in early 1985. The Marines notified North Carolina of the contamination in December 1984. At this time the Marines did not disclose that benzene had been discovered in the water and stated to the media that the EPA did not mandate unacceptable levels of PCE and TCE.[8]

In 1997 the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) investigated the well water and concluded that cancerous effects in personnel exposed to the water was unlikely. According to a federal investigation, ATSDR investigators overlooked evidence of benzene in the water when preparing the report.[10]

On 28 April 2009 the ATSDR admitted that the water had been contaminated with benzene and withdrew the 1997 report.[11] The benzene most likely occurred as a result of 800,000 gallons of fuel that leaked from the base fuel farm during the years in question. The fuel leaks occurred near the main well that serves Hadnot Point, location of enlisted and officer's quarters and the base hospital.[12] For unknown reasons, the presence of benzene in the water had been omitted from the official report that the USMC submitted for federal health review in 1992, in spite of the USMC being aware of the presence of the chemical. The report had been prepared by a contractor, Baker Corp.[13] State officials had also reportedly informed the ATSDR in 1994 about the presence of benzene in the water.[10]

Responses and actions[edit]

Notifications and responses to initial investigations[edit]

In 1999 the USMC began to notify former base residents that they might have consumed contaminated water. The notifications were directed by a federal health study examining possible birth defects among children born at the base during the contamination years.[9]

In 2005 the US Department of Justice and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) investigated the USMC's handling of the issue, and reported that they found no criminal conduct by USMC officials. In 2007, however, one of the EPA investigators told Congress that he had recommended obstruction of justice charges against some Camp Lejeune officials, but had been overruled by Justice department prosecutors.[9]

In 2007, Jerry Ensminger, a retired Marine master sergeant, found a document dated 1981 that described a radioactive dump site near a rifle range at the camp. According to the report, the waste was laced with strontium-90, an isotope known to cause cancer and leukemia.[3] According to Camp Lejeune's installation restoration program manager, base officials learned in 2004 about the 1981 document.[3] Ensminger served in the Marine Corps for 24 and a half years, and lived for part of that time at Camp Lejeune. In 1985 his 9-year-old daughter, Janey, died of cancer.[3]

An advocacy group called The Few, The Proud, The Forgotten was created to inform possible victims of the contamination at Lejeune. The group's website includes an introduction with some basic information about the contamination at Lejeune, including that many health problems various types of cancer, leukemia, miscarriages and birth defects, have been noted in people who drank the contaminated water. According to their site, numerous base housing areas were affected by the contamination, including Tarawa Terrace, Midway Park, Berkeley Manor, Paradise Point, Hadnot Point, Hospital Point, and Watkins Village.[14]

In 2008, the USMC began a Congressionally required notification campaign to notify former base residents of the issue. An online health registry now contains more than 135,000 names.[9]

In at least three instances the United States Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has agreed that a former servicemember's cancer was caused by his exposure to the contaminated water. Paul Buckley, a USMC veteran who was diagnosed with incurable hematological malignancy, was stationed at Camp Lejeune in the 1980s.[15] In March 2010 the VA decided that Buckley's cancer was directly linked to his ingestion of contaminated water at Camp Lejeune and awarded him 100% disability benefits.[16] Also, Jim Watters, who was stationed at the Naval Regional Medical center as a Navy Medical Service Corps Officer from 1977–1979, was diagnosed in 2007 with Renal Cell Carcinoma(RCC). According to Watters, after several denials from the VA he finally was able to prove his RCC was "as likely as not" caused by his exposure to the highly contaminated water and was awarded 100% disability by the VA in 2009.[17] On 22 February 2012, the VA agreed that retired Marine Frank Rachowicz' terminal cancer was caused by exposure to the contaminated water at Camp Lejeune.[18]

Lawsuits[edit]

Laura Jones[edit]

On July 6, 2009 Laura Jones, who has lymphoma, filed a suit against the U.S. government over the contaminated water at the base. Jones previously lived at the base where her husband, a Marine, was stationed.[5]

The U.S. Navy requested a dismissal of the case, stating that the statute of limitations had expired and that regulations at the time did not include contaminants such as trichloroethylene, tetrachloroethylene, vinyl chloride and benzene. U.S. District Judge Terrence Boyle, however, rejected the Navy's arguments and ruled that the suit could go forward. Said Boyle, "The Department of the Navy's unwillingness to release information regarding contamination at Camp Lejeune or to provide notice to former residents remains relevant in that such conduct limited the information available to potential clients."[19] Boyle dismissed a claim by the Navy in November 2010 that Jones had violated the 10-year statute of repose. Said Boyle, "To summarily bar such claims from entering the courthouse would be a profound miscarriage of justice."[20]

Joel Shriberg[edit]

In January 2011, retired Marine Joel P. Shriberg filed suit against the US Government, claiming that Lejeune's contaminated water caused his breast cancer. Shriberg was stationed at Lejeune from September 1957 through April 1959.[21]

Federal government intervention and further study[edit]

2009-2010[edit]

In October 2009 North Carolina Congressman Brad Miller announced his intention to add a companion bill to Richard Burr's "Caring for Camp Lejeune Veterans Act of 2009" to provide assistance to possible victims of the Lejeune water contamination. The proposed bills would authorize treatment at a US Veterans Administration facility to any veteran or family member who was based at Camp Lejeune during the time the water was contaminated and suffers from adverse health effects.[6][22] In response to Miller's recommendation that the Navy reassess the issue, the Navy announced in December 2009 that it would review the 1998 study into the water contamination at the base.[23][24]

Miller and Burr's proposed bill, renamed "Caring for Camp Lejeune Veterans Act of 2011", was approved by the Veteran's Affairs Committee on 29 June 2011 and was sent to the full House and Senate for approval. The bill was expected to cost $3.9 billion over 10 years and directed the Department of Defense to pay, and the VA to provide the care, for victims of the water contamination.[25][26]

In February 2010, Senator Richard Burr stated that he would hold the nominations of two top Navy civilian officials- Paul Luis Oostburg Sanz as Navy general counsel and Jackalyne Pfannenstiel as assistant Navy secretary for installations and the environment, until the Navy confirmed that it had funded and initiated programs to study the mortality rate of possible victims of the contamination and a plan to compensate any victims for their injuries.[27] The Navy notified Burr the week of March 1, 2010 that it had released $8.8 million to fund the requested study and Burr allowed the nominations of Sanz and Pfannenstiel to go forward. The study will be conducted by the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR).[28]

In March 2010 a congressional investigation led by Miller asked the Navy and a contractor, Baker Environmental Inc., for documents related to the contamination issue. Miller also asked for access to the Navy's electronic database of documents related to the contamination, which heretofore had not been made publicly accessible. Said Miller, "We want to know what did [the Navy and the Marine Corps] know about the water, when did they know, and what did they do about it?"[29]

On March 22, 2010 the ATSDR formally complained to the USMC for withholding details of and access to databases containing more than 700,000 electronic documents related to the water contamination. Said ATSDR Deputy Director Thomas Sinks, "It's interesting that there is information that we continue to discover that we need to go through." The Navy/USMC responded by providing access to ATSDR to the databases and denied that there was any intent to withhold documents from the investigation, saying that all of the documents had already been provided in hard copy. Access to the databases, however, was not provided to two panels advising the US Government on the contamination issue, with the USMC saying that the panel members must use the Freedom of Information Act to obtain access to the documents.[30]

In September 2010 Miller and the oversight subcommittee of the United States House Committee on Science and Technology held hearings into the contamination. The committee focused in part on the 1997 ATSDR report and on a booklet the USMC released in July 2010 about the contamination which Miller described as "more public relations than public health."[10] Congressional investigators and the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry have asked the Marine Corps to retract the booklet, which contains information its critics have called, "misleading."[31]

2011-present[edit]

In April 2011, five members of Congress, including Senator Bill Nelson of Florida, Senators Kay Hagan and Richard Burr and Representative Brad Miller of North Carolina, and Representative John Dingell of Michigan, sent the Navy a letter criticizing the service's continued behavior regarding the water contamination issue. In the letter, the members accused the Navy of continuing to mischaracterize the 2009 report by the National Academy of the Sciences' National Research Council, which concluded there was no concrete link between the chemicals trichloroethylene and tetrachloroethylene and a host of ailments suffered by veterans and family. The Navy states that the report also assessed benzene exposure, which is false, according to the members' letter. Also, the letter criticized the Navy for not agreeing to a communications protocol with the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) to allow that agency to review all Navy public relations material related to the contamination issue. The letter pointed out that the Marine website with information on the contamination did not contain direct links to the ATSDR website documenting their study of the issue.[32]

In June 2011 the Agency for Toxic Substances & Disease Registry began sending a survey to approximately 350,000 former employees or residents of Camp Lejeune. The purpose of the survey was to determine what diseases may be linked to the water contamination. The agency's report is expected to be completed in 2014.[33]

In 2011 a documentary film on the water contamination was produced and released by Wider Film Projects/Tracks Films called Semper Fi: Always Faithful. The film, directed by Tony Hardmon and Rachel Libert, made the 15 film short list for consideration for a 2012 Academy Award for best documentary feature.[34]

On 20 April 2012, members of both the House and Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committees signed a letter to President Obama asking that health care for Camp Lejeune contamination victims be expedited. Veterans Affairs Secretary Eric Shinseki responded that providing healthcare to Camp Lejeune veterans was "premature." The Government Accountability Office, on 2 May 2012 issued a report recommending that the DoD update its processes for addressing possible health effects from toxic exposure. Retired Marine drill instructor Jerry Ensminger started a petition requesting that the US Government begin providing health care to Camp Lejeune veterans exposed to the toxic water.[35]

In February 2014 the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued its report on the effects of the water contamination. The report found that Lejeune Marines had about a 10 percent higher risk of dying from any type of cancer compared to the Marines stationed at Camp Pendleton. Lejeune Marines had a 35 percent higher risk of kidney cancer, a 42 percent higher risk of liver cancer, a 47 percent higher risk of Hodgkin lymphoma, a 68 percent higher risk of multiple myeloma, and double the risk of ALS.[36]

Janey Ensminger Act[edit]

On 18 July 2012 the US Senate passed a bill, called the Janey Ensminger Act in honor of Jerry Ensminger and his daughter Janey who died of cancer at age 9, authorizing medical care to military and family members who had resided at the base between 1957 and 1987 and developed conditions linked to the water contamination. The measure applies to up to 750,000 people.[37] The House approved the bill on 31 July 2012.[38] President Obama signed the bill into law on 6 August 2012.[39]

The bill applies to 15 specific ailments believed to be linked to the contamination, including cancer of the esophagus, lung, breast, bladder or kidney; leukemia; multiple myeloma; myleodysplasic syndromes; renal toxicity; hepatic steatosis; female infertility; miscarriage; scleroderma; and/or neurobehavioral effects or non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. The Department of Veterans Affairs is assigned by the bill to provide the medical care. To fund the medical care, the bill extends higher fees for VA home loan guarantees to 1 October 2017.[40]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Martha Waggoner, Allen G. Breed (2013-01-18). "Agency: N.C. Camp Lejeune water contaminated in 1953". Associated Press. Retrieved 2013-01-27. 
  2. ^ a b Altman, Howard, "Lejeune Water Haunts Marines", Tampa Tribune, 16 January 2011, p. 1.
  3. ^ a b c d e Thompson, Estes (2007-07-10). "EPA investigating whether radioactive waste was buried at pollution-plagued Camp Lejeune". ABC News, Associated Press. Retrieved 2007-09-29. 
  4. ^ Camp Lejeune Water Study - US Marine Corps
  5. ^ a b Washington Times, "Contaminated Water At Base Spurs Suit", July 7, 2009, p. 6.
  6. ^ a b Maurer, Kevin (Associated Press), "Congressman to introduce bill on Lejeune water", Military Times, October 6, 2009.
  7. ^ October 22, 2010 letter from Dr. Poitier, ATSDR to Donald Schregardus, Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Navy
  8. ^ a b c d Barrett, Barbara, "Warnings about Camp Lejeune's tainted water unheeded for years", Stars and Stripes, April 18, 2010.
  9. ^ a b c d Zucchino, David, "The Few, The Proud, The Stricken: A rare cancer cluster is found in families who used tainted Camp Lejeune water. Some fault Marine officials." Los Angeles Times, August 26, 2009, p. 10.
  10. ^ a b c Barrett, Barbara, "Congress Wants Answers On Water Contamination At Lejeune", Raleigh News & Observer, 14 September 2010, p. 1.
  11. ^ http://www.salem-news.com/articles/april282009/astdr_release_4-28-09.php
  12. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Marine Base's Ex-Residents, Many Ill, Only Now Learning Of Toxic Water", Raleigh News & Observer, February 14, 2010.
  13. ^ Maurer, Kevin, (Associated Press), "Report on Marines’ water omitted cancer chemical", Stars and Stripes, February 18, 2010.
  14. ^ The Few, The Proud, The Forgotten. 2008-02-04. Access date 2008-02-06
  15. ^ Sawyer, Diane, and Steve Osunsami, "Toxic Water", ABC World News, March 19, 2010.
  16. ^ Jontz, Sandra, "VA Ruling On Former Marine's Illness May Affect Thousands", Stars and Stripes, March 27, 2010.
  17. ^ Jim Watters used information from several U.S. government web sites to show the irrefutable link between exposure to massive amounts of trichloroethylene and RCC. The VA has decided other similar cases in favor of veterans who were exposed to trichloroethylene at Camp Lejeune and other military bases but the numbers are very small (4 -5). Information on these decisions can be found at the web site VA.GOV under the section on Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA). Information from these BVA decisions will be helpful to veterans filing claims with the VA for illnesses caused by trichloroethylene, tetrachloroethylene and benzene. (search the BVA database using the key words trichloroethylene, tetrachloroethylene or benzene).
  18. ^ Mason, Anthony, "Contaminated Water", CBS Evening News, 28 May 2012
  19. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Judge: Lejeune Suit Can Proceed", Raleigh News & Observer, February 25, 2010.
  20. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Judge Refuses To Dismiss Camp Lejeune Water Exposure Lawsuit", McClatchy News Service, 10 November 2010.
  21. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Suit Blames Lejeune For Cancer", Raleigh News & Observer, 25 January 2011.
  22. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Vote On Lejeune Contamination Expected This Month", McClatchy, 10 June 2011.
  23. ^ Maurer, Kevin, "Navy to pay for review of Lejeune water study", Military Times, December 4, 2009.
  24. ^ Maurer, Kevin, "Rep. wants fed probe of Lejeune water reports" Military Times, February 18, 2010.
  25. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Health Care For Camp Lejeune Veterans Clears Senate Hurdle", McClatchy, 29 June 2011 (wire service report).
  26. ^ Philpott, Tom, "Commissary Savings At Risk To Help Ill Lejeune Vets", Kitsap Sun, 1 July 2011.
  27. ^ Maze, Rick, "Navy nominations held up by Lejeune studies", Military Times, February 22, 2010.
  28. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Navy Antes Up For Lejeune Study", Raleigh News & Observer, March 3, 2010.
  29. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Miller Sets Deadline To Get The Facts On Lejeune Water Pollution", Raleigh News & Observer, March 10, 2010.
  30. ^ Levesque, William R., "Marines Keeping Files Secret?", St. Petersburg Times, March 30, 2010, p. 1.
  31. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Camp Lejeune Water Pamphlet Comes Under Fire", Raleigh News & Observer, 1 February 2011.
  32. ^ Barrett, Barbara, "Lawmakers Blast Navy Over Lejeune Water Contamination", The McClatchy Company, 15 April 2011.
  33. ^ Sun, Lena H., "Survey Seeks Data On Camp Lejeune Illnesses", Washington Post, 27 June 2011, p. 15.
  34. ^ Fears, Darryl, "Film Examines Camp Lejeune Tragedy", Washington Post, 22 January 2012, p. 3; Imdb.com, "Semper Fi: Always Faithful (2011)".
  35. ^ Wilcox, Amanda, "Push Continues For Lejeune Toxic Water Victims", Jacksonville Daily News, 31 May 2012
  36. ^ Fox, Maggie, "Camp Lejeune Study Finds Higher Cancer Death Risk", NBC News, 20 February 2014
  37. ^ Ordonez, Franco, (McClatchy), "Senate Passes Lejeune Water-Contamination Bill", Raleigh News & Observer, 19 July 2012
  38. ^ Ordonez, Franco, "Congress Helps Camp Lejeune Families Hurt By Tainted Water", McClatchy, 1 August 2012
  39. ^ Ordonez, Franco, and Barbara Barrett, (McClatchy), "Obama Signs Law Giving Health Care To Lejeune Tainted-Water Victims", Raleigh News & Observer, 7 August 2012
  40. ^ Philpott, Tom, "'First step of justice' for ailing Camp Lejeune vets, families", Stars and Stripes, 9 August 2012

External links[edit]