Category talk:Member states of the European Union

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
WikiProject European Union (Rated Category-class)
WikiProject icon This category is within the scope of WikiProject European Union, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of the European Union on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.
Category page Category  This category does not require a rating on the project's quality scale.

(The following discussion was at Category talk:EU countries, a category which has since been deleted. -[[User:Aranel|Aranel ("Sarah")]] 18:45, 7 Nov 2004 (UTC))

Naming of category[edit]

I object to the naming of this article. It should be titled "EU member states" if people really want just the 25 member pages to link to it. Otherwise, England, Scotland and Wales should be linked here, as well as Ireland (island of).

Another problem, Republic of Ireland is not the official name of the state. Éire, or Ireland is the official name. Republic of Ireland is merely an official description. Now that is used commonly for most purposes, but for EU treaties for example, they always are signed by "IRELAND" not "Republic of Ireland". Thus, the member should be listed as Ireland, not Republic of Ireland.

Zoney 11:20, 16 Jun 2004 (UTC)

The Category:Countries was created and is today holding political entities, i.e. sovereign states, in its hierarchy. However, there is a point that by countries could also be understood countries which are not nation states, as exemplified above. Changing the name of this category would solve the problem here, but it would potentially lead to confusion at Category:European countries, if non-independent or non-united countries were listed there. Wouldn't there be a way to solve the problem with out changing all categorization of country articles and subcategories under the Countries category.
The non-independent countries, like England and Scotland, are contained within one sovereign state and belongs under that category, in this case the United Kingdom. Non-united countries like Irland are the real issue here. Since Ireland is not a single united political entity, it would need to be specified in what sense is a country; historically, culturally, geographically and/or others? Examples of other non-united countries in Europe and elsewhere should also be taken into account otherwise the whole discussion would be moot. Categorizing it in a way as to where only Ireland would fit, would take the meaning out of this discussion.
I believe that the naming related to Ireland used in the Wikipedia articles should also work for the categories. The issue of naming the articles should be raise there, not here. -- Mic 17:51, 16 Jun 2004 (UTC)

I agree the general case is a difficult issue - there's always plenty of confusion arising in sports teams, for example, over what constitutes a 'country' (and 'nationality'). For the EU though, member states solves the problem and is the official/correct terminology, so I'd also support a name change here. -- EuroTom 04:57, 17 Jun 2004 (UTC)

Yes - in case I wasn't clear - I consider renaming to EU member states the best solution. It doesn't entirely solve the question of Ireland - but I guess the Rep. of Ireland article and not Ireland (the official name of the State used in EU treaties) will have to be linked. Bah! Zoney 11:02, 17 Jun 2004 (UTC)