Cello Concerto (Dvořák)
The Cello Concerto in B minor, Op. 104, B. 191, is the last solo concerto by Antonín Dvořák. It was written in 1894–1895 for his friend, the cellist Hanuš Wihan, but was premiered by the English cellist Leo Stern.
The piece is scored for a full romantic orchestra (with the exception of a 4th horn), containing two flutes (second doubling piccolo), two oboes, two clarinets, two bassoons, three horns, two trumpets, three trombones, tuba, timpani, triangle (last movement only), and strings, and is in the standard three-movement concerto format:
- Allegro (B minor then B major; about 15 minutes)
- Adagio, ma non troppo (G major; about 12 minutes)
- Finale: Allegro moderato – Andante – Allegro vivo (B minor then B major; about 13 minutes)
Total duration: approximately 40 minutes.
In 1865, early in his career, Dvořák started a Cello Concerto in A major (B. 10). The piece was written for Ludevít Peer, whom he knew well from the Provisional Theatre Orchestra in which they both played. He handed the cello score (with piano accompaniment) over to Peer for review but neither bothered to finish the piece. It was recovered from his estate in 1925.
Hanuš Wihan, among others, had asked for a cello concerto for quite some time, but Dvořák always refused, stating that the cello was a fine orchestral instrument but totally insufficient for a solo concerto. According to Josef Michl, Dvořák was fond of the middle register, but complained about a nasal high register and a mumbling bass. In a letter to a friend, Dvořák wrote that he himself was probably most surprised by his decision to write a cello concerto despite these long held reservations.
Dvořák wrote the concerto while in New York for his third term as the Director of the National Conservatory. In 1894 one of the teachers at the Conservatory, Victor Herbert, also a composer, finished his Cello Concerto No. 2 in E minor, Op. 30, and premiered it in a series of concerts, commencing on 9 March. Dvořák heard at least two performances of the piece and was inspired to fulfill Wihan's request in composing a cello concerto of his own. Herbert had been principal cellist in the orchestra that premiered Dvořák's "New World" Symphony on 16 December 1893, and wrote his concerto in the same key, E minor. Herbert's middle movement was in B minor, which may have inspired Dvořák to write his concerto in the same key. It was started on 8 November 1894 and completed on 9 February 1895.
After seeing the score, Hanuš Wihan made various suggestions for improvement, including two cadenzas, one at the end of the third movement. But Dvořák accepted only a few minor changes and neither of the cadenzas. The third movement was a tribute to the memory of his recently deceased sister-in-law, Josefina Kaunitzova, née Čermakova. Specifically, the slow, wistful section, before the triumphant ending, quotes his series of songs "The Cypresses", Čermakova's favorite piece. Dvořák wrote to his publishers:
I give you my work only if you will promise me that no one – not even my friend Wihan – shall make any alteration in it without my knowledge and permission, also that there be no cadenza such as Wihan has made in the last movement; and that its form shall be as I have felt it and thought it out.
The finale, he insisted, should close gradually with a diminuendo
... like a breath ... then there is a crescendo, and the last measures are taken up by the orchestra, ending stormily. That was my idea, and from it I cannot recede.
Hanuš Wihan first privately performed the concerto with the composer in Lužany in September 1895. Although he had rejected most of Wihan's suggested changes, Dvořák still very much wanted Wihan to premiere the work publicly and had promised him that role. An account of the sequence of events whereby it did not happen is given by Clapham. Francesco Berger, Secretary of the London Philharmonic Society, wrote to Dvořák in November 1895 to invite him to conduct a concert of some of his works in London. Dvořák agreed and proposed to conduct the premiere of his Cello Concerto with Wihan as soloist. Berger proposed the date 19 March 1896, but that date was not convenient for Wihan (it may have clashed with concert dates for the Bohemian Quartet, to which Wihan was already contracted). The Philharmonic Society insisted on the date and hired the English cellist Leo Stern without consulting Dvořák. The composer then at first refused to come for the concert. "Berger was horrified and greatly embarrassed," as the concert had already been advertised. Clapham conjectures that Wihan released Dvořák from his promise. Stern traveled to Prague to prepare his performance under Dvořák's supervision. By early March, all was agreed, and the premiere took place on 19 March in Queen's Hall, London, with Dvořák conducting. The cello played by Stern was the 1684 "General Kyd", one of only about 60 cellos made by Stradivarius.
After the London performance, Stern again played the solo part in what may have been the second public performance, in Prague on 11 April 1896, and later again in London. In December 1896 and during 1897-1898 the concerto was performed by a few cellists and conductors in England and the United States, including Stern in Chicago in January 1897. Wihan went on to perform the concerto with great success, first in January 1899 at The Hague, and later for the first time under Dvořák's baton in Budapest on 20 December 1899. Despite there having been so many public performances before Wihan's first, he and Dvořák remained firm friends.
The concerto was published in 1896 by N. Simrock, Berlin.
The large-scale sonata-form first movement starts with a lengthy introduction by the orchestra, which states both themes and allows the soloist to expand on each. The first theme is played throughout the movement and during the last part of the third movement, giving the concerto a cyclic structure. The solo cello begins with a quasi improvisando section stating the theme in B major followed by triple-stopped chords. The cello then plays the theme again in E major. This concerto requires a lot of technical ability, especially in the coda, where the cello plays octaves and many double stops. The solo cello ends with trills then a high B octave. The movement ends tutti with the restatement of the first theme marked grandioso and fortissimo.
Following this opening essay is the lengthy Adagio, a lyrical movement which features a cadenza-like section which is accompanied mainly by flutes. The cello plays double stops accompanied by left-hand pizzicato on open strings. The movement ends with the cello playing harmonics very quietly.
The final movement is formally a rondo. It opens with the horn playing the main theme quietly. A gradual crescendo leads into a dramatic woodwinds and strings section. The solo cello enters by playing the modified main theme loudly which is marked risoluto. The orchestra plays the new modified theme again. Then the cello enters with a melody played on the A string played with thirty-second notes on the D string. This fast section leads into a section marked poco meno mosso, dolce, and piano. A crescendo and accelerando leads into a fast arpeggio played in sixteenth-note triplets. A fast scale leads into a loud tutti section presenting new material. The cello enters and a gradual decrescendo to another restatement of the theme marked piano. This is followed by a contrasting, loud restatement of the theme played by woodwinds accompanied by strings and brass. This is followed by a moderato section in C major and eventually meno mosso which slowly modulates from A major to C-sharp major to B-flat major and finally goes to the original tempo in B major. This is followed by another quiet and slow section which uses material from the first movement and second movement. The concerto ends allegro vivo presented by full orchestra.
Dvořák's friend and mentor Johannes Brahms had written a double concerto for violin and cello in 1887, eight years before Dvořák's cello concerto. He corrected the proofs of Dvořák's concerto for the composer and hence he knew the work intimately from the score. In 1896, Robert Hausmann had played it at his home with Brahms' piano accompaniment, and Brahms is reported as saying: "If I had known that it was possible to compose such a concerto for the cello, I would have tried it myself!" On 7 March 1897, Brahms heard Hugo Becker's performance of the piece in a concert of the Vienna Philharmonic, and he said to his friend Gänsbacher before the concert: "Today you will hear a real piece, a male piece!"
Dvořák's original score, before he accepted a few of the numerous changes suggested by Hanuš Wihan, has been described as "much more musical", and this version has been performed from time to time. Some of Dvořák's music written in America, such as the American String Quartet, written in Spillville, Iowa, and the New World Symphony, was notably influenced by the American environment, specifically pentatonic scales used in African-American and Native American Music. For the Cello Concerto such influence is less clear. One author suggests that there was little American influence on the concerto. Another author tells a story that one day when Dvořák was in New York but not at the Conservatory, said to be ill, a visitor to his home found him there composing. "His only illness was a fever of composition ... The remains of many past meals were strewn around the room, where he had been barricaded, probably for several days." Although the time is not specified, it might be understandable that in the later part of his sojourn at the Conservatory, when his salary had been cut and still not paid regularly, Dvořák could have felt less obligation to his duties.
Among all cello concertos, Dvořák's has been called "supreme," "the greatest", and the "king." But as three of these four references are from books on Dvořák, one may want to look more widely. There are many compositions for cello and orchestra by various composers, but there are none, for example, by J. S. Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, or Brahms. In an online poll for "greatest cello concerto" there were 173 total votes, with 74 votes for Dvořák's in first place, 50 for Edward Elgar's in second, 25 votes for either of two concerti by Dmitri Shostakovich, and fewer for others. From the Yo-Yo Ma discography, he recorded in 1989 a set of five "great" cello concertos: Dvořák's, Elgar's, Schumann's, Saint-Saens', and Haydn's second, in D. Yo-Yo Ma also issued two other recordings of Dvořák's concerto, some others of Haydn's various concertos, and one additional recording each of Elgar's and Saint-Saëns'.
To compare just Dvořák's and Elgar's concertos, there is an online Elgar Cello Concerto discography and two published ones by John Yoell on Dvořák's up through the early 1990s. Yoell was done and published in honor of the 150th anniversary of Dvořák's birth in 1841. Yoell says in his preface that his discography is "selective," but in a foreword to the same book, p. vii, Jarmil Burghauser says that up through 1987 there had been 56 recordings of Dvořák's concerto. Yoell actually lists 62 recordings, so for this piece the listing may be comprehensive. It would fit with Burghauser's number if in four years, six new recordings had been issued. The Elgar's discography, starting with recordings in 1928 and 1930 and going up through one in 2013, lists 44 recordings (29 of them, by the way, by British orchestras; 11 different orchestras). Up through 1987, to compare with Burghauser's count, just 19 recordings of the Elgar are listed (13 of them by British orchestras). It appears then that by a wide margin, Dvořák's concerto has had more recordings than Elgar's, seemingly the closest competitor. For example, Yoell lists 10 recordings of the Dvořák with Mstislav Rostropovich as soloist. His two recordings of the Elgar were of live performances in 1958 and 1964, issued much later in 1998 and 1994 respectively.
Performed by John Michel
Performed by Hans Goldstein with the Milwaukee Youth Orchestra
Performed by John Michel
Performed by John Michel
|Problems playing these files? See media help.|
- European Archive Copyright free LP recording of the Dvořák Cello Concerto, performed by Zara Nelsova (cello), Josef Krips (conductor), and the London Symphony Orchestra (for non-American viewers only) at the European Archive.
- Mischel Cherniavsky, cello; October 18, 1943; Music Hall Theatre, Seattle
- "New York Times, 12 September 1904". New York Times. 1904-09-12. Retrieved 2014-01-21.
- Michael Steinberg, The Concerto
- "Guild Music". Guild Music. Retrieved 2014-01-21.
- Battey, Robert, "Thoughts of Home," Chapter 22 of Tibbets (ed.) (1993)
- Clapham 1979, Norton, p. 148
- Clapham 1979, Norton, pp. 86, 148-149
- "Hanus Wihan". Cellist.nl. Retrieved 2014-01-21.
- "Unearthing Johannes, Robert Kameczura". Sobs.org. 2004-01-05. Retrieved 2014-01-21.
- Florence May, "Johannes Brahms" Vol 2, Munich 1983, P. 301
- Florence May, Johannes Brahms Vol 2, Munich 1983, p. 303
- "Dimitry Markevitch, Some Thoughts on More Rational Cello Fingerings". Cello.org. 1999-05-05. Retrieved 2014-01-21.
- Emmanuel Rubin, "Dvořák at the National Conservatory," Chapter 6 of Tibbets (ed., 1993), p. 71
- Harold C. Schonberg, The Lives of the Great Composers, Norton, New York, 1980
- Clapham, John (1979), Dvořák, Norton, New York
- Yoell, John H., "Dvořák in America: A Discography," Appendix C of Tibbets (ed.) (1993), pp. 404-417; on the cello concerto, pp. 412-414
- http://www.talkclassical.com/8320-best-cello-concerto, accessed 10 April 2014
- Yoell, John H. (1991), Antonín Dvořák on Records, New York: Greenwood Press, "Discographies, No. 46," pp. 76-80 on the cello concerto
- Clapham, John. "Antonín Dvořák, Musician and Craftsman". St. Martin's Press, New York, 1966.
- Clapham, John, Dvořák. New York: Norton, 1979.
- Dvořák, Antonín: Violoncellový koncert op. 104. (Violoncello e piano) Praha: Editio Bärenreiter, 2004. H 1200
- Smaczny, Jan. Dvořák: Cello Concerto. Cambridge Music Handbooks. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1999.
- Tibbets, John C. (ed.), Dvořák in America, Portland, OR: Amadeus Press, 1993.