Central Superior Services of Pakistan
|This article is part of the series:
Politics and government of
The Central Superior Services (denoted as CSS; or Bureaucracy) is an elite permanent bureaucratic authority, and the civil service that is responsible for running the civilian bureaucratic operations and government secretariats and directorates of the Cabinet secretariat. The civil service defined itself as "key wheels on which the entire engine of the state has to move." Derived from the colonial legacy of the former British Empire-controlled Indian Civil Service, the civil came into its modern formation immediately after the establishment of Pakistan as a "Civil Service of Pakistan." During its time of formation, the bureaucracy produced world prestige statesman, notably Ghulam Ishaq Khan who would go onto become country's President, and had an influence and partial influence on many of state's defence, internal, foreign and financial policies. As an aftermath of 1971 war, it was re-organized and reestablished under the "Chapter I: Part-XII, Article 240" of the Constitution of Pakistan which gave its new picture and constitutional status. The civil bureaucracy (specifically the Pakistan Administrative Service) closely collaborated with the military establishment of Pakistan Armed Forces in issues concerning the national security. The bureaucracy is consisted of total of 12 directorates that provide vital office and secretariat related duties to the Government of Pakistan.
The civil service exams are competitive while it is not restricted to only male domination and provide equal opportunities to male and females depending on their qualification. The CSS Examinations are open to both male and female and are held in the start of every year to recruit the civil servants for the bureaucracy. The exams are conducted and supervised by the Federal Public Service Commission and its chairman publicly announced the successful candidates through television and print media outlets.
Constitutional structure 
The Constitution of Pakistan lays down separate services for the central government and the provisional governments. Although, both types of the governments are required to regulate their civil services through the "Article 240 of Chapter I of Part XII", in case of the central reservation of the government and by the provisional assembly decrees for officers subjected in legislative list of the provinces. The idea of civil service was established by the Queen Elizabeth and the British Empire during the colonial period of the British Indian Empire. It was derived into as "Pakistan Civil Service" in 1947 and reorganized and re-established into its modern form in 1973. The Constitution of Pakistan describe the constitutional status as below:
Appointment to service of Pakistan and conditions of service: (a) in the case of the civil services of the Federation, posts in connection with the affairs of the Federation and Civil Services by the Parliament).
(b) in the case of the services of a provinces, the posts in connection with the affairs of the provinces, by act of the Provincial Assembly.
Existing rules: All rules and orders in force immediately before the commencing day shall, so far as consistent with the provisions of the Constitution.
Public Service Commission: The Parliament in relation to the affairs of the Federation, and the Provincial Assemblies of the Provinces in relation to affairs of the Provinces, may, by law, provide for the establishment and constitution of a Public Service Commission.—Part XII: Chapter 1: Services and Miscellaneous [Article 240-242], source
Naming Convention 
The Constitution of Pakistan does not set the legal name for the civil service and there is no service named as "Central Superior Services of Pakistan" (or CSS). The constitution allowed the government appointed officer and chairman of the Federal Public Service Commission to choose the name. The term "CSS" emerged during the first public examination of the civil service for the appointment on posts at officer entry level in the occupational groups of All-Pakistan Unified Group (APUG). The FPSC holds the combine competitive exam annually under the title advertised as exam for "Central Superior Services"— the term of colonial days which survived reforms. Similarly, the use of word "Central" instead of that "Federal"; as well as the term "Superior" are also the legacy of the past. These were relevant when there was central government under 1956 constitution and classes existed in the civil service. The 1973 constitution abolished all classes in the civil service as the concept of occupational groups was introduced.
Following the foundations laid in the Constitution, the federal government promulgated The Civil Servants Act, 1973 and each province enacted its own Civil Servants Acts. The law allow civil service of federation, and of provinces, to be regulated as per rules notified under these enactments. Consequently, both sets of governments have notified Civil Servants (Appointment, Transfer and Promotion) Rules, 1974. The qualification and method (the way) of filling of all posts is regulated by these rules. The posts at initial officer level i.e. BS-17, are classified to be filled by way of promotion or transfer and by direct recruitment under share fixed for each category. The recommendation for appointment in BS-17, under direct recuritment share, is done by FPSC, which is established under its own law as a requirement of the Constitution. The rest of posts reserved for departmental officers under promotion quota and posts under appointment by transfer is confined for officers inducted through lateral entry or for hardship cases coming from surplus pool. In practical terms, those appointed on posts in direct appointment quota in each occupational groups through CCS Exam have natural advantage. They join service at young age as compared to departmental officers, and therefore reach to the highest slots. Since the number of direct officers at entry level is less but their quota in posts in BS-18 to BS-22 is fixed on higher side so their promotion are on fast phase. This arrangements makes the civil attractive for talented individuals and instill sense of superiority and pride. Currently, CSS Exam is conducted by FPSC includes the following Occupational Groups.
- Pakistan Customs Services (PCS)
- Commerce & Trade Group (PCG)
- Foreign Service of Pakistan (FSP)
- Inland Revenue Service of Pakistan (IRS)
- Information Group (IG)
- Military Lands & Cantonment Group (MLCG)
- Office Management Group (OMG)
- Pakistan Administrative Service (DMG)
- Pakistan Audit and Accounts Service (PAAS)
- Police Service of Pakistan (PSP)
- Postal Group (PG)
- Railways (Commercial & Transport) Group (RCTG)
History of civil services in Pakistan 
|“||(...)... Civil Service is the back-bone of the State [of Pakistan] . Governments are formed. Governments are defeated; Prime Ministers come and go; Ministers come and go; but you stay on, and therefore, there is a very great responsibility placed on your shoulders.....||”|
The civil Bureaucracy is a colonial legacy in this part of the world. The British used to rule the native population through Indian Civil Service (ICS) and most of the officers in ICS were British themselves. It was in the early 20th Century that the Indians also started competing against the British and many Indians eventually made it to the ICS. With the partition of India in 1947, the term 'Central Superior Services' was used in Pakistan and the concept of All-Pakistan Services continued. The latter consisted of the Civil Service of Pakistan and the Police Service of Pakistan, whereas the Central Services included the Pakistan Foreign Service and a broad category of Finance and other services. The Finance category included the Pakistan Audit and Accounts Service, Pakistan Railway Accounts Service, Pakistan Military Accounts Service, Pakistan Taxation Service, and the Pakistan Customs and Excise Service. The Central Services other than these included the Pakistan Postal Service, Pakistan Military Land and Cantonment Service, Central Secretariat Service, and Central Information Service. Each of these services had its own cadre and composition rules, specifying the total cadre strength in terms of its number of positions.
With the Civil Services Reforms of 1973 a new system of Common Training Program or CTP was introduced and all of these occupational groups (12 at that time) were required to go through a mandatory combined training at Civil Services Academy (CSA), Lahore. The batch of officers who attended CSA in 1973 is recognized as “1st Common”. Up till 5th Common the allocation of occupational groups was done after the culmination of Common Training Program but from 6th Common onwards this task has also been assumed by FPSC. Even till this day it is an official procedure that once the Probationary Officers successfully complete their CTP then they undergo some further Specialized Training Program (STP) in their own professional academies.
Armed forces and civil services of Pakistan 
Commissioned officers of Pakistan Army, Pakistan Air Force, and Pakistan Navy have their own quota of 10% in all service groups of the Central Superior Services but historically they have only joined the Pakistan Administrative Service (previously known as the District Management Group), Foreign Service of Pakistan (FSP), and Police Service of Pakistan (PSP). Usually officers of Captain Rank are short listed by General Head Quarters (GHQ) and selected against this quota after the permission directly by Chief of Army Staff before interview process. The interviews are conducted by a committee headed by the Chairman Federal Public Service Commission, same as in the case of regular candidates. Only the written exam is waived.
Reform of civil services 
Despite the fact that Civil Services of Pakistan have been still running on the pattern set out by British Raj (no major change has been performed), the Musharraf government started a major reform process of it. The task was to be performed by National Commission of Government Reforms (NCGR) under the chairmanship of Dr. Ishrat Hussain, the former governor of State Bank of Pakistan. The final report that was published in September 2007 stated that four CSS cadres i.e., Pakistan Railway Service, Pakistan Postal Service, Commerce and Trade Group, and the Information Service of Pakistan, should be axed. According to the recommendation, Postal and Railway Service should be made autonomous commercial bodies, Commerce and Trade and Information Services be suspended till further notice. The report also highlighted broad changes in the examination system, with the recommendation of a personality test be made part of the selection process.
CSS Examination and statistics 
In 2011, approximately 12,000 candidates participated in the open public examination of the civil service; only 8.0% of them were qualified for 388 government jobs.
Every year CSS exams held in the whole country. The exams were conducted by the Federal Public Service Commission of Pakistan(FPSC). FPSC conducts the CSS exams and also recruit the passed candidates on the different departments of Civil Service. A number of candidates every year appears in these exams all over the Pakistan.
Criticism-- Age policy, Qualification criteria, syllabus and suggestions for improvement 
Currently, the age limit set for the Central Superior Services exam is from 21 to 28 years. In old good days it used to be up to 35 years. From time to time, anti-bureaucratic and elitist elements kept cutting it down, obviously with the intentions of weakening the bureaucratic structure of Pakistan by disallowing the talented and mature people who wanted to join their country`s administration. Failed former dictator Pervaiz Musharraf soon after coming into power delivered bureaucracy the final blow in 2001. The controversial and oppressively tight age limit in the CSS exam restrains students of the middle and lower social classes from joining the Civil Service of their country as it takes them more time to prepare for the said exam and compete with the students belonging to the country`s elite class since students belonging to the underprivileged class have to pursue part-time jobs along with their studies in order to sustain their families. In 2008 the Establishment Division forwarded a proposal to the PPP government seeking age relaxation which was bluntly put down by the government concerned showing PPP`s hostile stance against any age relaxation move. In the underdeveloped and terror hit, floods and poverty hit country like Pakistan, the age bracket is supposed to be widened back to 35 years so to curb the prevailing sense of despair and unemployment among the country`s youth who are increasingly becoming disappointed with the status quo and searching better opportunities in the foreign countries resulting in the worst brain drain in the history of Pakistan. The appeals to the President, Prime Minister, Chairman FPSC, Chief Justice and the Establishment Division to relax the upper age limit in the Central Superior Services Exam by 5 years have continuously been appearing in the print media for many years but nothing seems to move. The students holding higher degrees as M.Phil and PhD cannot take the said exam because by the time they complete studies from local and foreign universities they have crossed the prescribed age limit. That way country is losing its well educated, competent and talented candidates. Having said that, the exam for the Central superior Services has clearly lost its competitiveness. Lately, Age limit affectees have petitioned Peshawar and Lahore High Courts hoping to seek justice but a strong lobby is trashing any effort made to change the status quo. The affected students argue that enhancing the age limit will hurt no one but help enhance competition and give better officers to the country`s failing bureaucratic apparatus. After all it is called a competitive exam, if it really is one then the door should be opened to all competitors and the age discrimination at once removed before it is too late. Furthermore, the syllabus of the CSS exam has become outdated and has lost vitality. All that the syllabus offers can be covered by a high school student from any developed country since the same things keep repeating in the exam. Lastly, the qualification criterion of the Bachelor`s degree should be replaced with the Master`s degree. That will motivate students not to quit at graduation but to move towards higher education in a country where already the politicians, most of them, are only graduates and a considerable amount of them bearing fake degrees. Time for the people at the helm of the government to take desperate measures as "desperate times call for desperate measures".
See also 
- Government Officials. "Civil Service of Pakistan". Government of Pakistan. Government of Pakistan. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- Government of Pakistan. "District Management Group". District Management Group. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- Author. "Journey of System". Geo Television Series (Educational Directorate). Geo Documentaries. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- Constitution of Pakistan. "Part XII: Chapter 1: Services (Miscellaneous Article 240)". Constitution of Pakistan. Constitution of Pakistan. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- CSS. "Directorates of Civil Services". Government of Pakistan.
- Government of Pakistan. "Eligibility and Rules of CSS". Eligibility and Rules of CSS. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- CSS in Pakistan
- Editorial and Authorship reports and summaries (February 2010). "Reforming Pakistan's civil service". Asia Report (International Crises Group) 1 (1): 11–15.
- Customs Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Commerce & Trade Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Foreign Service of Pakistan -Civil Service of Pakistan
- Income Tax Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Information Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Military Lands and Cantonment Group - civil Service of Pakistan
- Office Management Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- District Management Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Accounts Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Police Service of Pakistan - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Postal Group - Civil Service of Pakistan
- Siddiqi, M. A. (April 25, 2011). "A guide to the CSS: Want to change Pakistan? Try joining the government as an honest bureaucrat". The Express Tribune.
- CSS Exams in Pakistan