Centre for Applied Nonviolent Action and Strategies
||The neutrality of this article is disputed. (April 2014)|
The Centre for Applied Nonviolent Action and Strategies (CANVAS) is a non-profit, non-governmental, educational institution focused on the use of nonviolent conflict. It was founded in 2004 by Srđa Popović and the CEO of Orion Telecom, Slobodan Đinović. Both were former members of the Serbian youth resistance movement, Otpor!, which supported the overthrow of Slobodan Milošević in October 2000. Drawing upon the Serbian experience, CANVAS seeks to educate pro-democracy activists around the world in what it regards as the universal principles for success in nonviolent struggle.
Established in Belgrade, CANVAS has worked with pro-democracy activists from more than 50 countries, including Iran, Zimbabwe, Burma, Venezuela, Ukraine, Georgia, Palestine, Western Sahara, West Papua, Eritrea, Belarus, Azerbaijan and Tonga and, recently, Tunisia and Egypt.
CANVAS’ training and methodology has been successfully applied by groups in Georgia (2003), Ukraine (2004), Lebanon (2005), The Maldives (2008) and Egypt (2011). It works only in response to requests for assistance.
The core of CANVAS’s work is rather to spread the word of “people power” to the world than to achieve victories against one dictator or another. CANVAS' big mission is to explain to the world what a powerful tool nonviolent struggle is when it comes to achieving freedom, democracy and human rights.
CANVAS was established in Belgrade in 2004. Its founding members, Slobodan Đinović and Srđa Popović, were leaders of the Serbian youth resistance movement Otpor! (Serbian for Resistance!), which played an instrumental role in deposing Slobodan Milošević in 2000. CANVAS sees itself as the successor to a host of non-violent campaigners from India's Mohandas Gandhi to Martin Luther King Jr. CANVAS has become known for its work with nonviolent democratic movements worldwide through the transfer of knowledge on strategies and tactics of nonviolent struggle.
Its founder's dream is to be a world where political change comes through nonviolent struggle. CANVAS says it brings a more rigorous, strategic model and skill-set to the process, as well as an encyclopaedic knowledge of recent global protest history.
Established in Belgrade in October 1998, Otpor! emerged as a response to the introduction that year of repressive laws relating to the universities and mass media. Following the war in Kosovo and NATO air-strikes in 1999, Otpor! began its political campaign against Milosevic throughout the country. Espousing the principle of nonviolence, it used an array of tactics, from slogans and chants to rock concerts and Monty Python street humour, to galvanise the Serbian population against Milosevic. Otpor! adopted as its symbol of resistance a clenched fist, black on white or white on black – a subversion of the communist imagery of a red fist which was favored by Milosevic. Duda Petrovic, who designed the symbol explained, "I never knew it would be so important […] I drew it not out of ideals, but because I was in love with the Otpor girl who asked me to do it.
Authors credited Otpor's methods for stripping away the fear, fatalism and passivity that keep a dictator’s subjects under oppression as well as turning passivity into action by making it easy — even cool — to become a revolutionary. The movement branded itself with hip slogans and graphics and rock music. It was influenced by nonviolent struggle leaders like Mohandas Gandhi, Nelson Mandela and Martin Luther King, but also by pop-culture and humor such as the famous UK comedy series, "Monty Python`s Flying Circus". Otpor's unified message and diverse membership proved much more attractive to young activists than the deeply divided opposition parties of the time. Instead of long speeches, Otpor relied on humor and street theater that mocked the regime.
Over a period of two years, Otpor! grew from a dozen or so students into a grassroots movement of over 70,000 people. Otpor! became one of the defining symbols of the anti-Milošević struggle and his subsequent overthrow. By aiming their activities at the pool of youth abstainers and other disillusioned voters, Otpor contributed to one of the biggest turnouts ever for the September 24, 2000 federal presidential elections with a turnout of more than 4,77 million voters or 72% of total electorate. Its campaign called "He Is Finished!" against Milosevic was seen by many as a key factor in his electoral defeat in September 2000 and subsequent overthrow.
Following Otpor!’s success in Serbia, civic activists in other countries contacted Otpor! leaders with a view to emulating their success. One of Otpor!’s leaders, Djinovic, traveled to Belarus on a number of occasions to meet with a student movement. However, the student movement was reportedly infiltrated soon after and it collapsed.
Otpor!’s counterparts in Georgia, Ukraine and Lebanon were more successful. In Georgia, Otpor! leaders had begun working with a student movement called Kmara ("Enough!") in 2002. Kmara went on to play a prominent role in securing the resignation of President Eduard Shevardnadze in November 2003 during the Rose Revolution. In Ukraine, Otpor! worked with the Pora ("It’s time") youth movement - a key player in Ukraine’s Orange Revolution, which took place between November 2004 and January 2005.
The decision to set up a training centre was taken in 2003, while Djinovic and Popovic were in South Africa working with Zimbabwean activists. Popovic was a member of parliament at the time, a position he gave up in 2004 to concentrate on revolutionary activism. Djinovic had set up Serbia’s first wireless internet provider in 2000. He currently funds approximately half of CANVAS’ work.
Headquartered in Belgrade, CANVAS is run by Slobodan Djinovic and Srdja Popovic. It has four and a half members of staff who are paid as contractors and operates a network of international trainers with experience in successful democratic movements.
CANVAS teachings can be summarised in a few simple principles: Power in society is not fixed, and can shift very swiftly from one social group to another. It can become fragile and can be redistributed, especially in non-democratic regimes. Ultimately, power in society comes from the obedience of the people. And those people – each of whom is individually a small source of power – can change their minds, and refuse to follow commands. In addition to that essential principles for the success of the movement are unity, planning and non-violent discipline. There must be a shared vision of tomorrow and a grand strategy for how to attain it. No movement can succeed if it bites off more than it can chew; instead, successful movements win small victories and build on them. In an interview with Octavian Manea, Popovic was quoted as to say, "The power of “nonviolent struggle” lies in the mobilization of a great number of people around a common vision of tomorrow, building common strategy, followed by efficient nonviolent tactics and of course maintaining an offense and nonviolent discipline against your opponent." 
Preparation is seen by CANVAS as paramount. Former CANVAS trainer Ivan Marovic was quoted as saying in a February 2011 Foreign Policy article, "Revolutions are often seen as spontaneous... It looks as if people just went into the street. But it’s the result of months or years of preparation. It is very boring until you reach a certain point, where you can organise mass demonstrations or strikes. If it is carefully planned, by the time they start, everything is over in a matter of weeks."
As part of the planning process, CANVAS teaches activists to identify "pillars of support" – institutions or organisations such as the police, the army, organised religion and the educational establishment – to be won over. "It is crucial for nonviolent movements to pull people out of the pillars of support like the police or military, rather than push people inside these pillars and appear threatening or aggressive to them," Popovic was quoted as saying in an article published in Sojourners Magazine in May 2011. To disarm the police in Serbia, Otpor! deployed such tactics as delivering cookies and flowers to police stations.
CANVAS also views the creation of a strong brand with the potential to attract widespread support as key to a movement’s success. Slogans, songs and identity symbols – such as Otpor!’s clenched fist - all play an important role in this regard. Together with clear articulation of a movement’s aims, CANVAS's teachings cover topics including nonviolent movements` group identity, clear communication strategies with its target audiences and the development of solidarity among its activists in case they are arrested, detained or fired from their work. An important part of the curriculum is focused on how movements facing oppression can overcome fear and its adverse effects on people's morale and build enthusiasm.
For CANVAS, special attention should be given to developing movements` nonviolent discipline as "a single act of violence can destroy the credibility of a nonviolent movement". Accordingly, it teaches its students in techniques to avoid violence and how to face violence, particularly from the police and security forces.
Methods for knowledge transfer
CANVAS disseminates its knowledge through a variety of media, including workshops, books, DVDs and specialised courses. Its workshops have reportedly been attended by over 1,000 people from 37 countries.
In 2007, CANVAS published its book for students, "Canvas Core Curriculum: A Guide To Effective Nonviolent Struggle." It has also published a handbook manual for activists entitled "Non-Violent Struggle – 50 Crucial Points", which has been translated into Spanish, French, Serbian, Arabic and Persian. The publication has been downloaded some 20,000 times in the Middle East, mostly by Iranians. CANVAS has also released an education film, "Bringing Down a Dictator." CANVAS curriculum is easily adaptable and is designed to be taken anywhere.
In January 2008, CANVAS started a joint graduate program at University of Belgrade’s Faculty of Political Science named Strategies and Methods of Nonviolent Social Change. The certified course is based on CANVAS’ core curriculum. CANVAS members regularly teach and present an academic version of their Core Curriculum and hold workshops on strategy and organization of nonviolent struggle at variety of educational institutions worldwide, including: Harvard (Kennedy School Of Law), Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy (TUFTS, Boston, MA), John Hopkins (SAIS), Columbia University, Rutgers (NJ), Colorado College (CO), Georgetown University (DC)...
Since October 2011. Executive director of CANVAS Srdja Popovic holds the status of visiting Scholar at Harriman Institute, one of the most prestigious graduate schools of public policy in the world School of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University .
CANVAS has attracted publicity for its work with dissident groups in various countries. The clenched fist symbol was flying high on white flags in 2003 in Georgia, when nonviolent protesters stormed the country's parliament after the election fraud in an action that led to the toppling of former autocratic President Eduard Shevardnadze. Recently, more substantial media attention was given to their successful work with groups from the Maldives and, more recently and most notably, in Egypt.
In Egypt, it emerged that Mohammed Adel, one of the leaders of the April 6 Youth Movement, which became one of the most important organisers of the uprising in Egypt that led to the resignation of President Hosni Mubarak in February 2011, had received training from CANVAS. Adel traveled to Belgrade to attend a 5-day CANVAS course in the strategies of nonviolent revolution in the summer of 2009. As he informed Al Jazeera English in an interview on 9 February 2011, he "got trained in how to conduct peaceful demonstrations, how to avoid violence, and how to face violence from the security forces, and then how to train others in how to demonstrate peacefully and how to organise and get people on the streets."
Aside from the successes of its on the field workshops, CANVAS has contributed to the field of study of strategic nonviolent resistance, and continues to regularly comment on current political social movements. CANVAS coined the term Laughtivism that is used to describe the use of humor in nonviolent struggle and that has been implemented by the New York based group The Yes Men and also the term dilemma action which describes a tactic of nonviolent resistance of putting one's opponent in a lose-lose situation.
CANVAS is a non-profit institution which relies solely on private funding; there is no charge for workshops and revolutionary know-how can be downloaded for free on the Internet. CANVAS’ biggest individual funder is its founding member and media mogul, Slobodan Djinovic. Djinovic privately funds about half of CANVAS’ operating costs. CANVAS does not accept funding from individual governments.
The governments of Belarus and Iran, as well as former Venezuelan leader Hugo Chavez, have accused CANVAS of being a "revolution-exporter". CANVAS denies this, emphasizing its role as educator and empowerer of peaceful methods. CANVAS leaders often stress that "in order to be successful, nonviolent movements must avoid taking any advice from foreigners, must be home-grown" and that "nonviolent revolutions cannot be exported-or imported".
In 2011, the hacker collective Anonymous broke into the computer network of corporate intelligence agency Stratfor, and the subsequently leaked e-mails were published by WikiLeaks. Included was correspondence between Srda Popovic and analysts at Stratfor, and Wikileaks tweeted that CANVAS was "used by Stratfor to spy on opposition groups."
In December 2013 Steve Horn and US Uncut co-founder Carl Gibson published an article that sought to shed light on Popovic's interactions with Stratfor, and criticized him for his apparently extensive interaction with Stratfor analysts, which ranged from passing them intelligence to inviting them to his wedding. The article garnered heavy criticism from the New York-Based culture-jammer Andy Bichlbaum (who served with Popovic on the board of Waging Nonviolence at the time).Gibson and Horn stood by their original critique,pointing out that Popovic served as a liaison between Stratfor and Muneer Satter, a prominent investment banker who worked at the time for Goldman Sachs,  and that CANVAS funding was arranged by US Ambassador Michael McFaul.
The use of Otpor!'s symbol of the clenched fist by many grassroots movements around the world has encouraged rumors that they are directly affiliated with CANVAS. The symbol, however, is not patented and CANVAS has, in fact, welcomed the reuse of the symbol by resistance movements in any nonviolent struggle, including those with whom the organization has had no direct contact. Notably, the symbol has been utilized by activists in such countries as Russia, Venezuela, Serbia, Kenya, and Egypt.
CANVAS has been listed as a terrorist organization by United Arab Emirates.
In November 2011. Foreign Policy Magazine credited Srdja Popovic, Executive director of CANVAS as one of their "Top 100 Global Thinkers" for his role in spreading the idea and educating activists about nonviolent social change.
Speculation to the Nobel Peace Prize 2012: PRIO Director's Speculations mentions CANVAS leader, Srdja Popovic, among the candidates for the award. With nonviolent resistance in the headlines in much of 2011, Popovic and his organization has been instrumental in disseminating knowledge of non-violence globally.
- Nonviolent Struggle: 50 Crucial Points (2006), available in English, Spanish, French, Arabic, Fars, and Serbian 
- CANVAS Core Curriculum: A Guide to Effective Nonviolent Struggle (2007), available in English, Arabic, and Persian
- A Brief History of Otpor (2008), available in English
- Making Oppression Backfire (2013), available in Arabic
- "Who We Are -Slobodan-Djinovic". CANVAS. Retrieved February 24, 2013.
- Rosenberg, Tina (16.02.2011) Revolution U – What Egypt learned from the students who overthrew Milosevic, Foreign Policy. Retrieved 20.07.2011
- Di Giovanni, Janine (18.03.2011) Blueprint for a revolution, Financial Times.
- "SOCIETY Magazin - The Expertise Behind Nonviolent Revolutions". Society.at. Retrieved 2011-08-28.
- "Bringing Down The Dictator: Main Characters"
- Reuters: Serbian activist teaches lessons in revolution Thu Jun 16, 2011
- Nikolayenko, Olena, Otpor, The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Social and Political Movements
- Cohen, Roger (26.11.2000) Who really brought down Milosevic, New York Times, Retrieved 20.07.2011
-  , Wayne Grytting, "Gandhi Meets Monty Python", October 2011
- Analysis: Otpor's Challenge to Milosevic
-  , Tina Rosenberg, "Join The Club" How Peer Pressure can transform the society, March 2011
- , Janusz Bugajski, "Political Parties in Eastern Europe" 2002
- ; Serbian Ousters Of Milosevic Made Mark in Egypt, DUSAN STOJANOVIC and JOVANA GEC, Associated Press, February 22, 2011
- Egypt: Seeds of change, Al Jazeera English (09.02.2011)
- Tunring the tide;Nonviolent power for social change, September 2011
- So you want a revolution...;The Independent, 11 September 2011
- Manea, Octavian and Srdja Popovic, "The Non-Violent Struggle as Asymmetric Warfare: Interview with Srdja Popovic", 26 March 2012, Small Wars Journal, http://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/nonviolent-struggle-as-asymmetric-warfare-interview-with-srdja-popovic, 30 May 2012
- Berger, Rose Marie (May 2011) Nothing spontaneous about it, Sojourners Magazine (Vol. 40, No. 5, pp.20)
- Wölfl, Adelhaid (10.03.2011) Gewaltloser kampf, 50 entscheidended punkte – Serbiche beratung bei revolutionen, Der Standard. Serbicshe beratung, Retrieved 20.07.2011
- Apps, Peter, "Serbian ActivistTeaches Lessons in Revolution", 16 June 2011, Reuters, http://uk.reuters.com/article/2011/06/16/uk-revolution-idUKTRE75F2E820110616, 30 May 2012
- Canvas, Otpor, Pora: Serbia’s brand is non-violent revolution, Cafebable.com. (31.03.2011), Retrieved 20.07.2011
- Wölfl, Adelhaid (10.03.2011) Gewaltloser kampf, 50 entscheidended punkte – Serbiche beratung bei revolutionen, Der Standard
- Roser, Thomas (28.02.2011). Von Gandhi lernen Die Welt Drucken Bewerten. Retrieved 20.07.2011
- Williams, Emma, "A Velvet Fist", May /June 2012, Intelligent Life, http://moreintelligentlife.com/content/ideas/a-velvet-fist?page=0%2C1, 30 May 2012
- , Downloaded 20.07.2011
- "Nonviolent Struggle: Lessons From Serbia Applied in North Africa - Dupont Circle - Washington DC". events.jhu.edu. 2010-03-29. Retrieved 2011-08-28.
- "SIPA: School of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University". Calendar.columbia.edu. 2011-04-05. Retrieved 2011-08-28.
- Columbia, SIPA 5 April 2011.
- Harvard, Kennedy School Of Law, October 2011
- Bade, Gavin (16 October 2012). "'Professor of Revolution' gives GU a crash course in nonviolent action". Vox Populi. Retrieved 6 November 2012.
- Columbia, SIPA November 2011
- Leibovitz, Liel, "The Revolutionist" March 2012, The Atlantic, http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2012/03/the-revolutionist/8881/, 30 May 2012
- Egypt: Seeds of change, Al Jazeera English
- Fantasy Island: Democracy Edition;Mother Jones, March/April 2010
- Amy Goodman, "Stratfor, Wikileaks, and the Obama Administration's War Against the Truth", The Guardian (1 March 2012).
- Wikileaks twitter, 8:00 AM - 16 Nov 2013
- Carl Gibson and Steve Horn, "Exposed: Globally Renowned Activist Collaborated with Intelligence Firm Stratfor," Counterpunch (Dec 3 2013)
- Carl Gibson and Steve Horn, "Exposed: Globally Renowned Activist Collaborated with Intelligence Firm Stratfor," Occupy.com (12 February 2013).
- Andy Bichlbaum "How Yellow Journalism Screws the Left" Yeslab.org, Dec 4, 2013
- "How Yellow Journalism Screws the Left," The Huffington Post (12-04-2013).
- "Are activists being used as spies?" Waging Nonviolence, Nov 20, 2013
- Carl Gibson and Steve Horn, "How Defending Private Intelligence Collaborators Screws Grassroots Activists" Occupy.com (5 Dec 2013).
- "Does a Globally Renowned Activist Have Ties to Global Intelligence Firm Stratfor?," Acronym TV (8 Dec 2013).
- "RE: meeting with Goldman Sachs partner," Wikileaks: The Global Intelligence Files.
- "RE: putting you and George in touch, 2010-05-14," Wikileaks: The Global Intelligence Files.
- "Wikileaks Exposed US' Efforts To Destabilize Venezuela" Popularresistance.org, February 19th, 2014
- Paul Dobson, "WikiLeaks reveals imperialist plots against Venezuela" Green Left Weekly, February 24, 2013
- Robert Amsterdam, "Oleg Kozlovsky: Romantics Learn to Use Their Fists" RobertAmsterdam.com, July 24, 2007
- Nicholas Schmidle, "Fantasy Island: Democracy Edition" Mother Jones, March/April 2010
- Jeroen de Zeeuw, "Assessing Democracy Assistance: Kenya" FRIDE, May 2010
- Foreign Policy Magazine: 2011 Top Global Thinkers;Foreign Policy Magazine, December 2011