Charles P. White
|60th Secretary of State of Indiana|
January 6, 2011 – February 4, 2012
|Preceded by||Todd Rokita|
|Succeeded by||Jerry Bonnet(interim)
|Member of the Fishers City Council|
|Born||Charles Patrick White
1969 (age 45–46)
|Children||2 sons, 1 daughter|
|Residence||Hamilton County, Indiana|
|Alma mater||Wabash College (B.A.)
Valparaiso University (J.D.)
He was removed from office on February 4, 2012 after a jury convicted him on six felony counts including perjury, theft and voter fraud. On February 23, he was sentenced to one year's house arrest, a sentence which has been stayed pending his appeal.
Secretary of State
White, a member of the town council of Fishers, an Indianapolis suburb, and a former chairman of the Hamilton County Republican Party, ran against Democratic architect Vop Osili in an election to succeed Republican incumbent Todd Rokita, who was term limited.
An issue in the campaign was whether White continued to serve on the Fishers council even after moving out of Fishers, and illegally voted in his old precinct in the May Republican primary. In February 2009, White moved to a condo in another part of Hamilton County. However, he claimed his former home, in which his ex-wife still lives, as his official residence. White subsequently admitted to voting in the wrong precinct, but blamed a hectic schedule for his failure to change his address. Nonetheless, White won in a landslide amid the massive Republican wave that swept through Indiana.
The state Democratic Party filed suit a month after the election, claiming that White was not eligible to run. The Democrats claimed that a state law requiring Secretary of State candidates to be registered voters means they must be registered legally. The state Recount Commission dismissed the Democrats' claim on a party-line vote, and White was sworn in on January 6, 2011.
In March 2011, White was indicted on seven felony counts including voter fraud, perjury and theft. He is charged with intentionally voting in the wrong precinct in the primary, continuing to serve on the Fishers council and drawing his salary after allegedly moving out of his district in Fishers even thou he was voted at large and not moving into a condo he purchased quickly enough. He was released from a Hamilton County jail after posting a $10,000 bond.
Shortly after the news broke, Governor Mitch Daniels and Indiana's other statewide elected officials urged White to step aside while the charges are pending. Conviction on even one charge would have automatically ousted White as Secretary of State; Indiana, like most states, does not allow convicted felons to hold office.
On April 7, 2011, Marion County Circuit Court judge Louis Rosenberg ordered the Recount Commission to reconsider the Democrats' legal challenge to White's place on the ballot. Rosenberg could have issued a ruling on his own authority, but chose not to do so. If the challenge succeeds, Vop Osili would become Secretary of State by default. By comparison, if White were forced out of office as a result of his felony case, Daniels would be able to appoint his successor The ruling specifically required the Recount Commission to make a finding on the legality of White's registration. Rosenberg retains control of the case and could issue a ruling himself if he isn't satisfied with the Recount Commission's work. Subsequently, White recused himself from the case; the Secretary of State is chairman of the Recount Commission. White was cleared by the Recount Commission in a bi-partisan 3-0 vote, saying that he intended to use his wife's home as his permanent address. However, the state party asked Rosenberg to review the decision, arguing that it put too much weight on White's testimony and ignored documents listing his new address. Rosenberg heard the case on November 23, even though White was absent.
Earlier, WISH-TV political reporter Jim Shella wrote in his blog that the Democrats' challenge to White's ballot status could have implications beyond the Secretary of State race. According to Shella, if the Democrats were to prevail, the Republicans would have legally received no votes in the Secretary of State's race. This would drop them below the 10 percent threshold required to retain major-party status in the state (major party status is determined by Secretary of State results). After Rosenberg remanded the eligibility challenge back to the Recount Commission, Shella wrote that from White's perspective, he would be better off settling the criminal case before the fate of his office is decided. He could potentially get the felony counts reduced to misdemeanors in a plea deal, which would allow him to keep his law license even if he had to leave office. However, Shella wrote, if he is forced out of office, he would have no bargaining chip in any plea negotiations.
On December 22, 2011, Rosenberg ruled that White had in fact violated election law, and that he had been ineligible to run. Rosenberg ordered the Recount Commission to remove White from office and certify Osili, who has since been elected to the Indianapolis City-County Council, as his replacement. White immediately announced he would appeal, and asked Rosenberg to stay his ruling until a higher court can hear the case. The next day, Rosenburg issued a temporary stay on his own ruling until January 3, 2012. On January 4, Rosenburg ruled that White could stay in office while his appeal works its way through the courts.
Conviction of voter fraud
On February 4, 2012, a jury found White guilty of six of seven felony charges, including false registration, voting in another precinct, submitting a false ballot, theft, and two counts of perjury. He was acquitted on one fraud charge. The felony convictions automatically removed White from office, though he presumably could have regained the post if his convictions had been downgraded to misdemeanors and Rosenberg's ruling awarding the office to Osili had been overturned on appeal. Daniels immediately appointed White's deputy, Jerry Bonnet, as interim Secretary of State.
On February 23, Hamilton County Superior Court Judge Steven Nation sentenced White to one year of house arrest, 30 hours of community service and a $1,000 fine. Nation refused to downgrade White's charges to misdemeanors, saying that his actions in the 2010 election were deliberate and therefore "violated the trust of the people." The conviction ends any chance of White regaining office even if his appeal of Rosenberg's ruling is successful.
- "Indiana Secretary of State". South Bend Tribune. October 24, 2010. Retrieved March 7, 2012.
- "Indiana Secretary of State Charles P. White". Official website of the Indiana Secretary of State. Retrieved 2011-01-05.
- Indiana election chief found guilty of voter fraud (Associated Press)
- "Baldwin Oratorical Winners". Wabash College. Retrieved March 7, 2012.
- Annis, Robert (March 3, 2011). "Indiana Secretary of State Charlie White indicted, faces 7 felony counts". The Indianapolis Star.
- Ritchie, Carrie (April 7, 2011). "Challenge to Charlie White's election is ruled valid". The Indianapolis Star.
- "State of Indiana vs. Charles White". State of Indiana Criminal and Citation Case Records.
- "In re Complaint of Voter Fraud and Expansion of Authority of Special Prosecutor". March 3, 2011. (text of indictment).
- Main, Dalton (March 3, 2011). "Daniels Encourages White to Step Down Until Charges Are Resolved". WFPL.
- Shella, Jim. Charlie White's Dilemma. WISH-TV, 2011-04-08.
- "White recuses self from recount". Post-Tribune. May 14, 2011. Retrieved 2011-05-24.
- Complaint on White to be heard on Nov. 23. Indianapolis Star, 2011-10-11.
- Ritchie, Carrie. White is a no-show in court. Indianapolis Star, 2011-11-24.
- Shella, Jim. Charlie White could damage GOP more than you think. WISH-TV, 2011-03-11.
- Ruling by Louis Rosenberg
- Ritchie, Carrie; Schneider, Mary Beth. Order allows Indiana Secretary of State Charlie White to hold office pending hearing. The Indianapolis Star, 2011-12-24.
- Shella, Jim. Judge Rules Charlie White can Stay (for now). WISH-TV, 2012-01-04.
- Indiana election chief found guilty of voter fraud, other charges; faces removal from office, Washington Post/Associated Press, February 4, 2012
- "Daniels Names Interim Secretary of State". Inside Indiana Business. 4 February 2012. Retrieved 4 February 2012.
- Ritchie, Carrie. Indiana ex-Secretary of State Charlie White gets 1 year of home detention. The Indianapolis Star. 2012-02-24. URL:http://www.indystar.com/article/20120224/LOCAL/202240331/Ex-secretary-state-gets-year-home-detention. Accessed: 2012-02-24. (Archived by WebCite® at http://www.webcitation.org/65h3zfsMK)