|This article does not cite any references or sources. (December 2009)|
Founded in 1991
|Minor league affiliations|
|Major league affiliations|
|Minor league titles|
|Division titles||1992 (1st half)
1994 (1st half)
1995 (2nd half)
1996 (2nd half)
1999 (1st half)
2000 (1st half)
2002 (2nd half)
|Manager: Mike Brown (1991-1993)
Mike Young (1994)
Jeff Datz (1995)
Joel Skinner (1996)
Jack Mull, Boyd Coffie, Harry Spilman (1997)
Eric Wedge (1998)
Brad Komminsk (1999)
Ricky Gutierrez (2000)
Ted Kubiak (2001)
Torey Lovullo (2002)
The RedStixx played home games at Golden Park, except during 1996. The team's home games were moved to Ragsdale Field on the campus of Columbus State University, while Golden Park was renovated to accommodate events of the 1996 Olympics. The name "RedStixx" refers to the Red Sticks, a faction of Creek Indians of the area.
In 1991, the South Atlantic League expanded, adding two teams, including one in Columbus. The team carried the nickname of the parent club, the Cleveland Indians, during its inaugural year. They took the name "RedStixx" for the remainder of their existence.
In 2002, the team announced their intention to move to Eastlake, Ohio following that year's regular season. The team renamed themselves the Lake County Captains. Although the Redstixx left Columbus, a new team, the South Georgia Waves arrived in town the next year.
Season-by-season records 
Note: W = Wins, L = Losses
|1991||73||69||5th||Did Not Qualify|
|1992||77||62||2nd 1||Lost in 1st round to Myrtle Beach Hurricanes 2-0.|
|1993||86||56||2nd||Did Not Qualify|
|1994||87||51||1st 1||Lost in 1st round to Savannah Cardinals 2-0.|
|1995||80||62||3rd 2||Lost in 1st round to Augusta GreenJackets 2-0.|
|1996||79||63||4th 2||1st round: beat Augusta GreenJackets 2-1.
2nd round: Lost to Savannah Sand Gnats 2-0.
|1997||62||76||12th||Did Not Qualify|
|1998||59||81||7th||Did Not Qualify|
|1999||70||71||7th 1||Lost in 1st round.|
|2000||67||70||7th 1||1st round: beat Augusta GreenJackets.
Finals: Lost to Delmarva Shorebirds 3-0.
|2001||77||59||3rd||Did Not Qualify|
|2002||79||60||3rd 2||1st round: beat Capital City Bombers.
Finals: Lost to Hickory Crawdads 3-2.
1- 1st half division champion
2- 2nd half division champion
1991: Columbus Indians
1992-2002: Columbus RedStixx