Comic Art Convention
|Comic Art Convention|
Program book for the 1969 inaugural Comic Art Convention. Cover art by Hal Foster.
|Location(s)||New York City (1968–1976, 1978–1983)
|Organized by||Phil Seuling|
The Comic Art Convention was an American comic-book fan convention held annually New York City, New York, over Independence Day weekend from 1968 through 1983, except for 1977, when it was held in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and 1978 to 1979, when it was held concurrently in New York and Philadelphia. The first large-scale comics convention, and one of the largest gatherings of its kind until the Comic-Con International in San Diego, California, it grew into a major trade and fan convention. It was founded by Phil Seuling, a Brooklyn, New York City, teacher, who later developed the concept of comic-book direct marketing, which led to the rise to the modern comic book store.
The New York Comic Art Convention's growth in popularity coincided with the increasing media attention on comics that had been building since the mid-1960s, feeding off the then novel notions of comics being a subject worthy of serious critical study and collectibility.
Circa 1961, enterprising fans including Jerry Bails, Shel Dorf, Bernie Bubnis, and future Marvel Comics editor-in-chief Roy Thomas began following the pattern of the long-established science fiction fandom by publishing fanzines, corresponding with one another and with comic-book editors (most notably DC Comics' Julius Schwartz), and eventually arranging informal and later professional, commercial conventions. Among the first were the 1964 Tri-State Con (a.k.a. the New York Comicon) and that same year's precursor to the Detroit Triple Fan Fair (officially established in 1965). The only previously known comics fandom, for the 1950s' EC Comics, did not progress so far along.
As Seuling described his convention's genesis, "In 1964, about a hundred people found themselves in a New York City union meeting hall, a large open room with wooden folding chairs, looking around at each other oddly, surprised, not really knowing what they were there for, a bit sheepish, waiting for whatever was going to take place to begin. ... It was the first comics convention ever [and t]hat one-day assembly ... grew step by step into an annual tradition in New York and then elsewhere." In 1965, the Academy of Comic-Book Fans and Collectors hosted a convention at New York's Broadway Central Hotel, continuing that tradition in 1966 and 1967. The so-called "Academy Cons" featured such industry professionals as Otto Binder, Bill Finger, Gardner Fox, Mort Weisinger, James Warren, Roy Thomas, Gil Kane, Stan Lee, Bill Everett, Carmine Infantino, and Julius Schwartz.
As Seuling told it, "In 1968, I became involved in [staging] my first convention. The following year began the current series called the Comic Art Convention". (The 1968 show, officially known as the International Convention of Comic Book Art, was co-produced with SCARP, the short-lived Society for Comic Art Research and Preservation, Inc.) Guests of honor at the 1968 show were Stan Lee and Burne Hogarth
The 1969 convention, the first official Comic Art Convention, was held Independence Day weekend at the Statler Hilton Hotel in New York City, and the guest of honor was Hal Foster. Admittance to the convention cost $3.50 for a three-day ticket, with daily passes at $1.50. Admittance was free with a hotel room rental, which cost $15-and-up per day.
The final two years of the 1961-1969 Alley Awards, sponsored by Alter Ego magazine and the Academy of Comic-Book Fans and Collectors, were presented at the Comic Art Convention. After the demise of the Alley, later years featured the Goethe Awards (later renamed the "Comic Fan Art Awards").
As his comic-book distribution business occupied more time, and as other comics conventions, most notably in San Diego and Chicago, became larger, more prominent, and more commercially rather than fan-driven, Seuling segued his Independence Day-centered Comic Art Convention into the smaller, generally mid-June "Manhattan Con".
The Comic Art Conventions provided the primary nexus for fans and the largely New York City-based industry during the Silver Age and the Bronze Age of comic books. As well, many of the Golden Age creators were still alive and in attendance at panels and for interviews, which helped lay the groundwork for the medium's historical scholarship.
The reputation of the Convention spread throughout fandom via an annual write-up published in The Buyer's Guide to Comics Fandom by columnist Murray Bishoff. Besides reporting on convention events, Bishoff also provided fans around the country with a benchmark market report by surveying attending dealers regarding what was selling and whether prices realized were above or below those quoted in the de facto standard, The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide.
Will Eisner, creator of the The Spirit in 1940, credited the 1971 Comic Art Con for his return to comics. In a 1983 interview with Seuling, he said, "I came back into the field because of you. I remember you calling me in New London, [Connecticut], where I was sitting there as chairman of the board of Croft Publishing Co. My secretary said, 'There's a Mr. Seuling on the phone and he's talking about a comics convention. What is that?' She said, 'I didn't know you were a cartoonist, Mr. Eisner.' 'Oh, yes,' I said, 'secretly; I'm a closet cartoonist.' I came down and was stunned at the existence of the whole world. ... That was a world that I had left, and I found it very exciting, very stimulating".
Eisner later elaborated about meeting underground comics creators and publishers, including Denis Kitchen: "I went down to the convention, which was being held in one of the hotels in New York, and there was a group of guys with long hair and scraggly beards, who had been turning out what spun as literature, really popular 'gutter' literature if you will, but pure literature. And they were taking on illegal [sic] subject matter that no comics had ever dealt with before. ... I came away from that recognizing that a revolution had occurred then, a turning point in the history of this medium. ... I reasoned that the 13-year-old kids that I'd been writing to back in the 1940s were no longer 13-year-old kids, they were now 30, 40 years old. They would want something more than two heroes, two supermen, crashing against each other. I began working on a book that dealt with a subject that I felt had never been tried by comics before, and that was man's relationship with God. That was the book A Contract with God...." 
Following Sueling's death in 1984 and continuing until 1987, Creation Entertainment continued producing annual conventions in New York City, usually taking place over the weekend following Thanksgiving (Creation had begun hosting New York shows in c. 1976). From 1993–1995, promoter Fred Greenberg hosted two Great Eastern Conventions annually at venues including the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center and the New York Coliseum. Other companies, including Dynamic Forces, held New York City conventions but all were on a smaller scale than the Seuling shows. Changes in the industry, popular culture, and the resurgent city itself since the troubled 1960s and '70s made large-scale comic-book conventions difficult to hold profitably. Jonah Weiland of ComicBookResources.com also noted that "...dealing with the various convention unions made it difficult for most groups to get a show off the ground."
In 1996, Greenberg, at a very late point, cancelled what had been advertised as a larger-than-usual Great Eastern Conventions show, which the fan press had suggested might herald a successor to the Comic Art Con. As a substitute event, promoter Michael Carbonaro and others on the spur of the moment mounted the first Big Apple Convention in the basement of Manhattan's Church of St. Paul the Apostle. These small shows nonetheless attracted many comics creators and pop-culture figures, and by 2000 the convention had moved to the Metropolitan Pavilion on West 18th Street in Manhattan, and by the mid-2000s were taking place at the Penn Plaza Pavilion at the Hotel Pennsylvania — the very same location of the original Comic Art Conventions.
In 2002, the first MoCCA Art Festival, focused on alternative comics and the small press, was held at New York City’s Puck Building; it has been held annually since. In 2006, the first New York Comic Con was held in the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center; it also has been held annually since.
Dates and locations
- Conventions held in New York City unless otherwise noted.
- July 4–7, 1968: Statler Hilton Hotel, 33rd Street and Seventh Avenue — as International Convention of Comic Book Art
- July 4–6, 1969: Statler Hilton Hotel — Penn Top/Sky Top Rooms
- July 3–5, 1970: Statler Hilton Hotel
- July 2–4, 1971: Statler Hilton Hotel
- July 1–5, 1972: Statler Hilton Hotel
- July 4–8, 1973: Hotel Commodore, 42nd Street and Park Avenue
- July 4–8, 1974: Hotel Commodore
- July 3–7, 1975: Hotel Commodore
- July 2–6, 1976: McAlpin Hotel, 34th Street and Broadway
- July 1–5, 1977: Hotel Sheraton, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (no New York con this year)
- July 2–5: Americana Hotel, New York City
- July 8–9: Philadelphia
- June 30-July 1: Statler Hilton Hotel, New York City
- July 14–15: Sheraton Hotel, Philadelphia
- July 4–6, 1980: Statler Hilton Hotel
- July 3–5, 1981: Statler Hilton Hotel
- July, 3-5, 1982: Sheraton Hotel, Seventh Ave. and 56th Street, New York City
- July 2–4, 1983: Sheraton Hotel, New York City — as International Science Fiction and Comic Art Convention (presentation of the Saturn Awards)
- Schelly, Bill. "Jerry Bails' Ten Building Blocks of Fandom," Alter Ego vol. 3, #25 (June 2003) pp. 5-8.
- Schelly, Bill. Founders of Comic Fandom: Profiles of 90 Publishers, Dealers, Collectors, Writers, Artists and Other Luminaries of the 1950s and 1960s (McFarland, 2010), p. 131.
- Duncan, Randy; and Smith, Matthew J. The Power of Comics: History, Form and Culture (Continuum International Publishing Group, 2009), p. 183.
- Skinn, Dez. "Early days of UK comics conventions and marts," DezSkinn.com. Accessed Mar. 3, 2013.
- Schelly, Bill. Founders, p. 8.
- Seuling, Phil. 1977 Comic Art Convention program book (Sea Gate Distributors, 1977), p. 5
- Thomas, Roy. "Splitting the Atom: More Than You Could Possibly Want to Know About the Creation of the Silver Age Mighty Mite!" The Alter Ego Collection, Volume 1 (TwoMorrows Publishing, 2006), p. 99.
- Schelly, Bill. "The Kaler Con: Two Views: Bigger And Better Than The Benson Con Just Three Weeks Before?? (Part VIII of '1966: The Year Of (Nearly) Three New York Comics Conventions')," Alter-Ego #64 (Jan. 2007).
- Thompson, Maggie. Newfangles #6 (Jan. 1968).
- Schelly, Bill. Founders, p. 107.
- Groth, Gary. "Editorial: Con Games", The Comics Journal #76 (Oct. 1, 1982), pp. 4-6.
- "The 1969 Comic Art Convention Progress Report". SplashPages.com. Archived from the original on October 4, 2007. Additional Webcitation archive, February 20, 2011.
- "The 1971 Goethe Awards" (ballot), Graphic Story World vol. 2, #2 (whole #6) (July 1972), p. 29.
- Miller, John Jackson. "Goethe/Comic Fan Art Award winners, 1971-74," CBGXtra (July 19, 2005).
- "Biographies: Fredric Wertham, M.D.". Comic Art & Graffix Gallery. Archived from the original on July 16, 2011.
- Groth, Gary. "Will Eisner: Chairman of the Board", The Comics Journal #267, May 2005.WebCitation archive
- Transcript, Will Eisner's keynote address, Will Eisner Symposium: The 2002 University of Florida Conference on Comics and Graphic Novels
- Weiland, Jonah (June 10, 2005). "Battling Conventions? Talking with the NY Comic Con and Megacon Organizers". ComicBookResources.com. Archived from the original on February 20, 2011. (Requires scroll down)
- "Newswatch: NYC Comics Convention Cancelled, Fans Irate," The Comics Journal #185 (Mar. 1996), pp. 18-19.
- Pate, Brian "Mike Carbonaro Retiring From Convention Promoting with Final 2012 NYCBM Show," Convention Scene (Mar. 30, 2012).
- "Big Apple Comic Book, Art & Toy Show". BigAppleCon.com. November 10–12, 2000. Archived from the original on September 30, 2000.
- "The National Comic Book, Art & Sci-Fi Expo". BigAppleCon.com. November 19–21, 2004. Archived from the original on October 13, 2004.
- "Big Apple Comic Book, Art, Toy & Sci-Fi Expo". BigAppleCon.com. June 7–8, 2008. Archived from the original on May 9, 2008.
- "Big Apple Comic Book, Art, Toy & Sci-Fi Epo". BigAppleCon.com. November 14–16, 2008. Archived from the original on September 30, 2008.
- Later refurbished as Hotel Pennsylvania.
- "Old Comic Book Art is on Display Here," New York Times (July 5, 1969), p. 16.
- Building later demolished; Hyatt Hotel built on site.
- 1980 Comic Art Convention Official Program Book by Sea Gate Distributors, Phil Seuling, Robbographica Studios & Cat Yronwode
- 1981 Comic Art Convention Official Program Book by Phil Seuling and Gwenn Seuling/Sea Gate Distributors
- "Happenings: Other Events," New York Magazine (July 5–12, 1982), p. 134.
- 1975, 1976, 1977 Comic Art Convention program books
- Los Angeles Times, January 7, 2001, Home Edition: "Making It: A Pioneering Spirit in Pen and Ink — Graphic Novel's Father Has Been Innovator in Comics Since the '30s" by Susan Vaughn
- Lovece, Frank, "Cons: New York 1974!",The Journal Summer Special, 1974 (fanzine published by Paul Kowtiuk, Maple Leaf Publications; editorial office then at Box 1286, Essex, Ontario, Canada N0R 1E0)
- The Comics Journal #46 (May 1979): Convention ad, inside back cover