Comparison of VMware Fusion and Parallels Desktop

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Represented by their respective products, VMware and Parallels are the two major commercial competitors in the Mac consumer virtualization market. Both products are based on hypervisor technology and allow users to run an additional 32- or 64-bit x86 operating system in a virtual machine alongside Mac OS X on an Intel-powered Mac. The similarity in features and functionality between VMware Fusion and Parallels Desktop for Mac has given occasion for much comparison.

Features[edit]

Feature Product
VMware Fusion v4.0 icon.png
VMware Fusion 5.0 (Not latest version)
Parallelsdesktop.png
Parallels Desktop 9 for Mac
Installing Windows on Mac
Easy Install with Automatic Windows Setup Yes Yes
Run off existing Boot Camp partition Windows XP (32-bit), Windows Vista (32-bit and 64-bit), Windows 7 (32-bit and 64-bit) Windows XP (32-bit), Windows Vista (32-bit and 64-bit), Windows 7 (32-bit and 64-bit), Windows 8
Allows suspending of VM running off the Boot Camp partition Yes Yes
Import Physical Windows PC to VM Yes Yes
Import Boot Camp partition to VM Yes Yes
Full Support for Windows 7 Yes Yes
Full Support for Windows 8 Yes Yes
Import Third Party VMs (Parallels, VMware, VirtualPC for Mac) Yes Yes
Mac
Automatically adjust Windows for best look on Mac Book Pro Retina Yes Yes
Support Higher Synthetic screen resolutions in Full-Screen mode without scrolling (e.g. Run Windows in 1920x1200 mode on a 1440x900 monitor) Yes Yes
Migrate Windows 2000 PC to Mac Yes Yes
Migrate Windows XP to Mac Yes Yes
Migrate Windows 7 to Mac Yes Yes
Migrate Linux to Mac No Yes
Migrate PC over wireless network Yes Yes
Migrate PC over Ethernet Yes Yes
Migrate PC over FireWire Yes Yes
Migrate PC over USB No Yes
Migrate PC over External disk No Yes
Windows documents migration to appropriate folders to Mac No Yes
Migration of the Internet bookmarks and settings from Internet Explorer, Firefox, or Chrome on PC to the default browser on the Mac. No Yes
Open in Internet Explorer plugin for Safari No Yes
Running Windows Apps on Mac
Run Windows apps like Mac apps (Unity/Coherence) Yes Yes
Run Windows apps in Retina resolution (Unity/Coherence) No Yes
Support Mountain Lion Dictation in Windows 7/8 No Yes
Support Mavericks Dictionary in Windows 7/8 No Yes
Exclude Dock in Unity/Coherence Yes Yes
Windows Start Menu in Dock No Yes
Windows Start Menu in menu Yes Yes
Windows application folder in Dock No Yes
Windows application folder in menu bar Yes No
Always On Application Menu available to launch Windows apps at any time Yes Yes
Quit Individual Window applications Yes Yes
Use Command ` to switch between open windows in a Windows app Yes Yes
Assign Windows applications to a Mac OS X Space Yes Doesn't keep windows from app together
Shared Folders to access Mac files/folders from Windows Yes Yes
Access Windows tray icons in Unity/Coherence Yes Yes
Arrow icon in the Mac menu bar for customizing Windows tray icons in Coherence. No Yes
Progress for downloads and other operations is displayed on the Windows 7 applications icons in the Dock. No Yes
Windows 7 Jump Lists are supported for Windows applications in the Dock No Yes
Grouping of all windows of a single Windows application under the same application icon in the Dock. No Yes
Active screen corners No Yes
Launch Windows or Mac internet applications from hyperlinks Yes Yes
Windows applications can be set as the default applications for handling CDs and DVDs inserted into the Mac. No Yes
Enable Apple Gestures to work with Windows applications No Yes
Enable Apple Magic Mouse Gesture support with Windows applications No Yes
Enable Apple Remote to work with Windows applications No Yes
Launch Mac applications from any Windows file (Shared Applications/SmartSelect) Yes Yes
Automatically mount storage and network devices to guest OS Yes Yes
Suspend/Resume To Where You Last Left Off Yes Yes
Pause VM if no application running to reduce Mac OS load. No Yes
Mirrored/Remapped Desktop, Music, Documents, and Pictures Folders Yes Yes
Mirrored/Remapped iCloud, PhotoStream, DropBox, and GoogleDrive Folders No Yes
Contextual menu items "Run on Mac" and "Show in Finder" for Shared Folders No Yes
Remapping Windows Keyboard Shortcuts to Mac Shortcuts Yes, completely customizable Yes, completely customizable
Keyboard shortcut (F6 or Fn + F6) for hiding/showing Parallels Desktop and all its windows. No Yes
Virtual Links - aliases to Mac OS files from Windows virtual machines Yes Yes
Copy/Paste Text between Windows / Mac Yes, Plain and Rich (RTF) Text up to 4 MB Yes, Plain and Rich (RTF) Text
Drag and Drop Text between Windows / Mac Yes, Plain and Rich (RTF) Text up to 4 MB No
Drag and Drop Files Between Windows / Mac Yes Yes
Copy/Paste Graphics between Windows / Mac Yes Yes
Passthrough "Driverless" Printing to Mac Printers Yes Yes
Mouse adaptation to work with Windows 8 UI in window view mode No Yes
Making Windows Safer on Mac
Multiple Snapshots support Yes Yes
AutoProtect Automatic Snapshots Yes Yes
TimeMachine backups can be synced with Automatic snapshots, to reduce the space required for backups. No Yes
Automatically revert VM to start state upon termination No Yes
Virtual machine encryption with AES algorithm for better security of your data (empowered by AES-NI hardware support on i5 and i7 CPUs) No Yes
Mac OS Parental Controls are automatically applied to the virtual machine for managing children’s computer usage No Yes
Windows AntiVirus & AntiSpyware Included 12-month subscription to McAfee VirusScan Plus. User Prompted to Install 1-month subscription to Kaspersky Internet Security or Dr.Web Security Space. User Prompted to Install
Mac OS AntiVirus Included No 1-month subscription to Kaspersky Security for Mac or Dr.Web for Mac OS X. User Prompted to Install
Lock down application and virtual machine settings to prevent changes No Yes
Isolated Virtual Machines No Yes
Designed for Mac (Fit and Finish)
Optimized for OS X Mavericks, Mountain Lion, Lion Yes Yes
Optimized for Snow Leopard Runs on 64-bit kernel, 64-bit VMM, 64-bit helper application, 32-bit GUI Runs on 64-bit kernel, 64-bit VMM, 64-bit helper application, 64-bit GUI
UI Built from Ground Up for Mac Cocoa and GTK+ frameworks Nokia Qt library with Carbon and Cocoa frameworks.
Welcome Screen to Simplify Initial Setup Yes Yes
Mac-like Settings and Preferences Windows Yes Yes
Apply different colors to virtual machines to find them in Finder or in the virtual machines list No Yes
Customizable Toolbars Yes Yes
Default virtual machine to launch on application startup Yes Yes
Virtual Machine Library Yes Yes
Live View of Running Virtual Machines in Library/Settings Yes Yes
Live View of Running Virtual Machine in Dock No Yes
Startup in Last View Format Yes Yes
Reduce the virtual hard disk size as its unused space grows Yes Yes
Apple Help (Searchable with Mac Design) Yes Yes
Single File Virtual Machine Packages Yes Yes
QuickLook/Cover Flow Integration Yes Yes
Mount Running Virtual Machines in Finder No Yes
Mount Stopped Virtual Machines in Finder Yes Yes
Use iSight in OS X and Windows No Yes
Advanced Platform
32-bit Guest Operating Systems Yes Yes
64-bit Guest Operating Systems Yes Yes
Multi-CPU virtual machines Up to 8 processors per VM & Multi Core (as of VMWare Fusion 3.1) Up to 8 processors per VM & Multi Core
Virtual CPU supports AES-NI when running on i5 and i7 CPUs No Yes
Maximum RAM per virtual machine 8 GB 16 GB
Support for IPv6, the next-generation version of the Internet Protocol, in shared, bridged and host-only networking. No Yes
Windows Aero (WDDM for Windows Vista and Windows 7) Yes Yes
DirectX 9 Graphics Support Yes Yes
DirectX 10 Graphics Support No yes
OpenGL 3D Graphics Support for Windows Vista & Windows 7 guest OS OpenGL 2.1 (as of VMWare Fusion 3.1) OpenGL 2.1
OpenGL 3D Graphics Support for Windows XP guest OS OpenGL 2.1 OpenGL 2.1
OpenGL 3D Graphics Support for Linux guest OS No OpenGL 2.1
Multiple monitor/display support Up to 10, each display is separate unique display to Windows Up to 10, each display is separate unique display to Windows
Hardware Assisted Video/Movie Playback Yes Yes
Maximum video RAM per VM 288 MB 1 GB
USB 2.0 passthrough support Yes Yes
Support for external surround sound 5.1 USB or FireWire devices work simultaneously in Mac and the virtual machine. No Yes
64-bit Native Engine 64-bit VMM, 64-bit kernel extensions, 64-bit helper application, 32 GUI 64-bit VMM, 64-bit kernel extensions, 64-bit helper application, 32 GUI
Power Management/Battery Passthrough Yes Yes
Bluetooth support (as USB device) Yes Yes
Firewire passthrough support No No
Pass Firewire and Thunderbolt storage devices to VM No Yes
Virtual IDE Controller Yes Yes
Virtual SCSI Controller Yes Yes
Virtual SAS Controller Yes Yes, using software emulation in guest OS
Shared Smart Card Yes Yes
Low Level Access to Network Interfaces (promiscuous mode / WiFi monitor mode etc.) Yes
Advanced Tools
Virtual Disk Management yes yes
Resize Virtual Disks Yes Yes
Advanced Network Management Requires modifying networking scripts Yes
Control VMs with Scripting option Yes Yes
Supports Intel VT-x hardware virtualization engine Yes Yes
Network (PXE) Boot Yes Yes
Support switching graphics card on Mac Book Pro for longer battery live No Yes
Run More Operating Systems on Mac
Run Multiple Operating Systems at One Time Yes, run up to 20 with available memory Yes
Supported x86 Operating Systems Over 140 operating systems Over 60 operating systems
Run Linux virtual machines Yes Yes
Linux Easy Install with Automatic Setup Yes Yes
Linux virtual machine support Window resize, time sync, shared folders, drag and drop Window resize, time sync, shared folders, drag and drop
Run Linux virtual machine in Unity/Coherence Yes (Ubuntu and Red Hat with Gnome) Yes
Run Mac OS X Server virtual machines Yes Yes
Run Mac OS X virtual machine in Unity/Coherence No Yes
Import VHD Test Drives Yes Yes
Run Virtual Appliances Over 1200 available Fewer than 100 available
iPhone/iPad mobile client
Allows to work with remote VM on iPhone/iPad No Parallels Access for iPad

Minimum system requirements[edit]

Requirement Product
VMware Fusion 4.0 Parallels Desktop 9
Host OS Mac OS X 10.6.7 or later; Mac OS X 10.7 recommended Mac OS X 10.6.8 or later; Mac OS X 10.7.5 or later; Mac OS X 10.8.4 or later; Mac OS X 10.9 or later
RAM 2 GB (4 GB Recommended) 2 GB (4 GB Recommended)
Disk space for product 750 MB 750 MB (SSD drive Recommended)

2007 Benchmark tests[edit]

On August 16, 2007, CNET published the results of several benchmarks[1] in which Fusion demonstrated better performance than Parallels Desktop for Mac in SMP-aware applications, which Fusion supports while Parallels does not. It should also be noted that Boot Camp is a tool for natively booting Windows XP on Intel Macintosh and is not a virtualization product. This comparison is of limited value today, as Parallels Desktop has had 4 major upgrades and VMware Fusion has had 3.

Fusion chart01.png Fusion chart02.png

This comparison was tested on an eight-core, 2.66 GHz MacPro running Mac OS X 10.4.10, Parallels Desktop 3.0 for Mac (build 4560) and VMware Fusion 1.0 (build 51348). Fusion and Parallels were both set to 1,024 MB of system memory and a 32 GB hard disk. Fusion was set to 128 MB of graphics memory, and Parallels Desktop for Mac was set to 64 MB of graphics memory (the maximum for each at that time).[1]

2008 Benchmark tests[edit]

In Volume 24, Issue 02 of MacTech, the editors published the results of one-step and task tests between VMware Fusion 1.0, Parallels Desktop 3.0 and Boot Camp and used a PC running Windows XP as a baseline comparison in a native PC environment.[2]

  • One-step Test: After clicking the mouse or pressing a key, this test requires no further human action.
  • Task Test: This tests the interaction between Mac OS X and the virtual environment and requires multiple tests throughout the process.

MacTech found that the faster the physical host computer, the more similarly Parallels Desktop and VMware Fusion performed. MacTech did not test multiple processor performance. The following graphs displays the results in seconds. Shorter bars indicate faster performance.

Mactech---cross-platform.png Mactech---network---file-io.png

Each test was run on a MacBook (2 GB RAM; 1.83 GHz Core Duo processor), a MacBook Pro (4 GB RAM; 2.16 GHz Core 2 Duo processor) and a Mac Pro (4 GB RAM; Quad Core configuration with two 2.66 GHz Dual-Core Intel Xeon processors). MacTech tested Parallels Desktop 3.0 for Mac Build 5160 and VMware Fusion 1.0 Build 51348. All tests were done on clean host systems with new installations of Mac OS X 10.4.10 and Office installations and included all of the most up-to-date patches. No third party software was installed other than Mac OS X, VMware Fusion, Parallels Desktop, Windows XP, Windows Vista, Adobe Reader and Microsoft Office.

2009 Benchmark tests[edit]

In March, 2009, Volume 25, Issue 04, MacTech[3] published the results of a new series of benchmark tests that compared the performance between VMware Fusion 2.0.1 and Parallels Desktop 4.0 for Mac (build 3540), both running Mac OS X 10.5.5.

In most of MacTech’s tests, Parallels Desktop performed 14-20% faster than Fusion; however, Fusion ran 10% faster than Parallels Desktop when running Windows XP 32-bit on 2 virtual processors.[4]

OS/Environment Result
Windows XP, 32-bit, 1 Processor Parallels Desktop runs 14% faster
Windows Vista, 32-bit, 1 Processor Parallels Desktop runs 14% faster
Windows XP, 32-bit, 2 Processors VMware Fusion runs 10% faster
Windows Vista, 32-bit, 2 Processors Parallels Desktop runs 20% faster
Windows XP, 64-bit, 2 Processors Parallels Desktop runs 15% faster

The tests were performed on the White MacBook, MacBook Pro, iMac and MacPro. Both Fusion and Parallels Desktop were optimized for virtual machine performance. MacTech’s test included launch and CPU tests, File and Network IO, Footprint, Application Launch, Application Performance and 3D and HD Graphics. In many cases, tests were performed after both Adam and Successful launches and were timed using a stopwatch.

Test Suite Performance Winner
Windows Launch Performance Parallels Desktop for Mac
CPU Parallels Desktop for Mac, except for 2 of the 14 tests
Footprint on Mac Parallels Desktop for Mac
Application Launch VMware Fusion
Application Performance Both products did well, except for IE where Parallels Desktop is 80-91% faster[5]
3D and HD Performance Dependent on game1, video and Windows environment.

1 3D Games tested were Civilization IV: Colonization and Portal. In Civilization, Parallels Desktop has faster FPS (Frames Per Second) and performed better on slower machines while Fusion has better, more detailed graphics. Fusion has difficulty showing the startup video, but Parallels Desktop's graphics are not as rich. When running Portal, Fusion is faster but its graphics are visibly lighter, while Parallels Desktop has better graphics and visual details.[6]

Cross-platform task tests[edit]

MacTech’s cross platform tests timed how long it took users to perform multi-step tasks that moved data between Mac OS X and Windows. VMware Fusion, which is designed for increased isolation from the host, requires more manual steps to move data between the host and the virtual environment. Parallels Desktop, which is designed to run transparently with the Mac OS X host, requires fewer steps to perform the same tasks. Therefore, Parallels Desktop was faster.

Networking and file I/O tests[edit]

Parallels Desktop occasionally displayed lag anomalies while VMware Fusion's virtual drive performance was very close to that of a physical drive. VMware Fusion preferred a bridged connection for reliable performance, and Parallels Desktop was consistent regardless of the type of virtual network adaptor used.

Simultaneous use of VM and host OS[edit]

Parallel Desktop 5 always uses wired memory for hosted OS, while VMWare Fusion 3.0 uses active memory that can be swapped. Giving better performance to hosted VM, this leaves less memory to host OS programs and causes more swapping if you use VM and host OS programs at the same time.

2010 Benchmark tests[edit]

In 2010 MacTech,[7] Volume 26, Issue 01, published the results of a new series of benchmark tests showing a performance advantage for Parallels Desktop 5 across all subcategories, with an average of 30% faster.

ITPro's November 2010 performance testing results were mixed, with Parallels being slightly faster, overall.[8]

See also[edit]

References[edit]