Comparison of browser synchronizers

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The following tables compare general and technical information for a number of web-based browser synchronizers. Please see the individual products' articles for further information. Unless otherwise specified in footnotes, comparisons are based on the stable versions.

Transmute is excluded because it is a MS Windows-based offline tool (with privacy advantages). Xmarks used to provide an option to avoid the Xmarks server, which required using a WebDAV or FTP server to store bookmarks, however this feature is no longer reasonably available.[citation needed] If any other tools offer a privacy advantage, list them in this paragraph or add a column to the tables.

Another aspect of synchronization not covered in this table is OPML import and export. Exporting OPML enables many other tools to read the feeds, bookmarks/favorites and other browser data. There may be significant differences in capability between multiple levels of subscription – some tools such as Transmute have three levels of subscription.[citation needed]

General[edit]

Client Creator Software license Latest release
BookmarkSync Jack Dean Proprietary Windows:

3.0.0 (August 2010; 4 years ago (2010-08)) [±]

Mac OS X:
1.0.4 (September 14, 2005; 9 years ago (2005-09-14)) [±]

Opera Link Opera Software Proprietary Opera:
Windows, OS X

24.0.1558.64 (September 26, 2014; 4 days ago (2014-09-26)[1]) [±]

Windows (Presto)

12.17 (April 23, 2014; 5 months ago (2014-04-23)[2]) [±]

Linux, FreeBSD
12.16 (July 4, 2013; 14 months ago (2013-07-04)[3]) [±]
Opera Mini:
Android 7.5.5 (July 25, 2014; 2 months ago (2014-07-25)) [±]
iOS 8.0.0 (June 26, 2014; 3 months ago (2014-06-26)) [±]
BlackBerry 8.0[4] (March 12, 2014; 6 months ago (2014-03-12)) [±]
Symbian 7.1 (January 25, 2013; 19 months ago (2013-01-25)) [±]
J2ME 8.0[4] (March 12, 2014; 6 months ago (2014-03-12)) [±]
SiteBar Server Ondrej Brablc GPL 3.3.9
Firefox Sync Mozilla Foundation Mozilla Public License 1.8 (August 10, 2011; 3 years ago (2011-08-10)) [±]
Xmarks Xmarks Proprietary Firefox: 4.2.5 (January 10, 2014; 8 months ago (2014-01-10)) [±]

IE: 1.3.5 [±]
Safari: 1.4.3 [±]
Chrome: 1.0.24 (January 16, 2013; 20 months ago (2013-01-16)) [±]

Client Creator Software license Latest release

Operating system support[edit]

PC operating system Mobile operating system
Client Windows OS X Linux FreeBSD iOS Android BlackBerry OS Symbian Windows Phone other
BookmarkSync Yes Yes No No No No No No No No
Opera Link Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Solaris, Java ME, S60, UIQ3, BREW
Firefox Sync Yes Yes Yes Yes[5] Yes Yes No No Yes OpenSolaris[6]
Xmarks Yes Yes Yes No Xmarks Premium Xmarks Premium Xmarks Premium No Xmarks Premium No
Client Windows OS X Linux FreeBSD iOS Android BlackBerry OS Symbian Windows Phone other

Syncable Browsers[edit]

Client Internet Explorer Mozilla Firefox Opera Safari Google Chrome other
BookmarkSync Yes Yes Yes Yes (Mac Only) No SeaMonkey
Opera Link No No Yes No No Opera Mini, Opera Mobile
Firefox Sync No Yes No No No Firefox for Mobile[7]SeaMonkey
Xmarks Yes Yes No, but there is a sync viewer in a menu Yes (Mac Only) Yes No
Client Internet Explorer Mozilla Firefox Opera Safari Google Chrome other

Syncable Items[edit]

Client Bookmarks Favicons Browsing history Form history Web feed subscriptions Search engine plugins Passwords Dictionary Other
BookmarkSync Yes No No No No No No No No
Opera Link Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes in <= 12.16 No Personal bar, speed dial, notes, typed browser history, content blocker list
Firefox Sync Yes No but planned to be added in future Last 60 days[8] Yes Yes No Yes No open tabs, tab groups, personas, preferences, add-ons (up to 25MB by default)[8]
Xmarks Yes Yes Yes (Firefox) No Yes Yes Yes (deprecated) No open tabs
Client Bookmarks Favicons Browsing history Form history Web feed subscriptions Search engine plugins Passwords Dictionary Other

Features[edit]

Client Encrypted transfer Encrypted storage Server changing Web-based UI Exporting Link verification Duplicate link checker Notes
Arado Websearch ? No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes It doesn't provide any server for built-in internet based sync.
BookKit ? No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Official site no longer exists: http://www.bookkit.com/
Bookmark Yes Yes No Yes No No No Server-side backup, restore of bookmarks, sync profiles so that only certain bookmarks sync to certain browsers. Feb 12, 2012: Doesn't work properly with IE9 (bookmarks don't appear on web UI).
Bookmark Base ? Yes ? ? XBEL Yes Yes Bookmark editor, different browsers. It doesn't provide any server for built-in internet based sync: its portability is based on USB drives. Official site no longer exists: http://www.bookmarkbase.com/
BookmarkSync Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Feb 12, 2012: Sync doesn't work properly.
Bookmark Sync and Sort ? No ? ? ? ? ?
Chipmark ? No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Provides IE plug-in and Firefox extension. Feb 12, 2012: Registration process in official site https://www.chipmark.com fails with the following message: "There was an error communicating with our mail server, or the email address entered was not valid. Registration was not successful. Please try again at a later time.".
Link Commander ? No ? ? XBEL ? ? It doesn't provide any server for built-in internet based sync.
Network Menus ? No ? ? ? ? ? Feb 12, 2012: Stops IE9 from loading when trying to install the plug-in.
Opera Link Yes[9] No No Yes Yes No Yes (only webbased)
oSync ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Portable Bookmarks ? Yes ? ? XBEL ? ? It doesn't provide any server for built-in internet based sync: its portability is based on USB drives.
Power Favorites ? Yes ? ? XBEL Yes Yes Extensions for Firefox and Opera. http://www.desksware.com/bookmark-manager.htm. Feb 12, 2012: It doesn't automatically sync with IE9 (export/import based).
SyncBookmarks ? No ? ? XBEL ? ? Feb 12, 2012: Last modified timestamp on official download site (http://syncbkmk.sourceforge.net/download/index.html) is 01/02/2007 04:28:512012.
Firefox Sync Yes Yes Yes No No No No Data is encrypted on the client and not accessible even to Mozilla server operators.[10]
xbelSync ? No ? ? XBEL ? ? It doesn't provide any server for built-in internet based sync.
Xmarks Yes[1] Partial[11] Yes Yes Yes No Yes (web) Server-side backup, restore of bookmarks, sync profiles so that only certain bookmarks sync to certain browsers; password storage is deprecated, Xmarks recommends using LastPass instead.
Zinkmo ? No ? Yes ? Yes Yes IE plug-in. Feb 12, 2012: Official site http://www.zinkmo.com/ is down.
Client Encrypted transfer Encrypted storage server changing webbased UI exporting Link Verification Duplicate Link Checker Notes

History[edit]

History of bookmarks (favorites) sync:

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Security update to Opera Stable 24". 2014-09-26. Retrieved 2014-09-26. 
  2. ^ "Opera 12.17 out". 2014-04-23. Retrieved 2014-04-23. 
  3. ^ "Opera 12.16 changelog". 2013-07-04. Retrieved 2013-11-13. 
  4. ^ a b "New Opera Mini for Java and BlackBerry - Opera Software". 
  5. ^ "weave port". FreshPorts. 2009-10-09. Retrieved 2009-08-01. 
  6. ^ mconnor (2009-07-29). "Weave 0.5 Released". Mozilla. Retrieved 2009-08-01. 
  7. ^ mconnor (2009-06-27). "Weave 0.4.0 Released". Mozilla. Retrieved 2009-06-30. 
  8. ^ a b "What is Firefox Sync?". Firefox Help. Retrieved 11 April 2012. 
  9. ^ "Opera Link explained". Opera Software. 7 September 2007. Retrieved 2009-06-06. 
  10. ^ "How secure is my Sync data?". Firefox Help. Retrieved 11 April 2012. 
  11. ^ Encrypted password storage is supported