The term first came into use in England during the mid 17th century, and was in wide use by the late 17th century. However, the use of adult male falsettos in polyphony, commonly in the alto range, was common in all-male sacred choirs for some decades previous, as early as the mid-16th century, and modern-day ensembles such as the Tallis Scholars and The Sixteen maintain the use of male altos in period works. During the Romantic period, the popularity of the countertenor voice waned and few compositions were written with that voice type in mind.
In the second half of the 20th century, the countertenor voice went through a massive resurgence in popularity, partly due to pioneers such as Alfred Deller, by the increased popularity of Baroque opera and the need of male singers to replace the castrati roles in such works. Although the voice has been considered largely an early music phenomenon, there is a growing modern repertoire.
The countertenor in history
In polyphonic compositions of the 14th and early 15th centuries, the contratenor was a voice part added to the basic two-part contrapuntal texture of discant (superius) and tenor (from the Latin tenere which means to hold, since this part "held" the music's melody, while the superius descanted upon it at a higher pitch). Though having approximately the same range as the tenor, it was generally of a much less melodic nature than either of these other two parts. With the introduction in about 1450 of four-part writing by composers like Ockeghem and Obrecht, the contratenor split into contratenor altus and contratenor bassus, which were respectively above and below the tenor. Later the term became obsolete: in Italy, contratenor altus became simply altus, in France, haute-contre, and in England, countertenor. Though originally these words were used to designate a vocal part, they are now used to describe singers of that part, whose vocal techniques may differ (see below).
In the Catholic Church during the Renaissance, St Paul's admonition "mulieres in ecclesiis taceant" ("let the women keep silence in the churches" – I Corinthians 14:34) still prevailed, and so women were banned from singing in church services. Countertenors, though rarely described as such, therefore found a prominent part in liturgical music, whether singing a line alone or with boy trebles or altos; (in Spain there was a long tradition of male falsettists singing soprano lines). However, employment of countertenors never extended to early opera, the rise of which coincided with the arrival of a fashion for castrati, who took, for example, several roles in the first performance of Monteverdi's Orfeo (1607). Castrati were already prominent by this date in Italian church choirs, replacing both falsettists and trebles; the last soprano falsettist singing in Rome, Juan [Johannes de] San[c]tos (a Spaniard), died in 1652. In Italian opera, by the late seventeenth century, castrati predominated, while in France, the modal high tenor, called the haute-contre, was established as the voice of choice for leading male roles. In England Purcell wrote significant music for a higher male voice that he called a "counter-tenor", for example, the roles of Secrecy and Summer in The Fairy Queen (1692). "These lines have often challenged modern singers, who have been unsure whether they are high tenor parts or are meant for falsettists". In Purcell's choral music the situation is further complicated by the occasional appearance of more than one solo part designated "countertenor", but with a considerable difference in range and tessitura. Such is the case in Hail, bright Cecilia (The Ode on St Cecilia's Day 1692) in which the solo "'Tis Nature's Voice" has the range F3 to B♭4 (similar to those stage roles cited previously), whereas, in the duet "Hark each tree" the countertenor soloist sings from E4 to D5 (in the trio "With that sublime celestial lay". Later in the same work, Purcell's own manuscript designates the same singer, Mr Howel, described as "a High Contra tenor" to perform in the range G3 to C4; it is very likely that he took some of the lowest notes in a well-blended "chest voice" – see below).
"The Purcell counter-tenor 'tenor' did not flourish in England much beyond the early years of the [eighteenth] century; within twenty years of Purcell's death Handel had settled in London and opera seria, which was underpinned entirely by Italian singing, soon became entrenched in British theatres". In parallel, by Handel's time, castrati had come to dominate the English operatic stage as much as that of Italy (and indeed most of Europe outside France). They also took part in several of Handel's oratorios, though countertenors, too, occasionally featured as soloists in the latter, the parts written for them being closer in compass to the higher ones of Purcell, with a usual range of A3 to E5. They also sang the alto parts in Handel's choruses, and it was as choral singers within the Anglican church tradition (as well as in the secular genre of the glee) that countertenors survived throughout the 18th and 19th centuries. Otherwise they largely faded from public notice.
The modern countertenor
The most visible icon of the countertenor revival in the twentieth century was Alfred Deller, an English singer and champion of authentic early music performance. Deller initially called himself an "alto", but his collaborator Michael Tippett recommended the archaic term "countertenor" to describe his voice. In the 1950s and 60s, his group, the Deller Consort, was important in increasing audiences' awareness (and appreciation) of Renaissance and Baroque music. Deller was the first modern countertenor to achieve fame, and has had many prominent successors. Benjamin Britten wrote the leading role of Oberon in his setting of A Midsummer Night's Dream (1960) especially for him; the countertenor role of Apollo in Britten's Death in Venice (1973) was created by James Bowman, the best-known amongst the next generation of English countertenors. Russell Oberlin was Deller's American counterpart, and another early music pioneer. Oberlin's success was entirely unprecedented in a country that had seen little exposure to anything before Bach, and it paved the way for the recent great success of countertenors there also.
Today, countertenors are much in demand in many forms of classical music. In opera, many roles originally written for castrati are now sung and recorded by countertenors, as are some trouser roles originally written for female singers. The former category is much more numerous, and includes Orfeo in Gluck's Orfeo ed Euridice and many Handel roles, such as the name parts in Giulio Cesare and Orlando, and Bertarido in Rodelinda. This is also the case in several of Mozart's early operas, including Amintas in Il Re Pastore and Cecilio in Lucio Silla. Many modern composers other than Britten have written, and continue to write, countertenor parts, both in choral works and opera, as well as songs and song-cycles for the voice. Men's choral groups such as Chanticleer and the King's Singers employ the voice to great effect in a variety of genres, including early music, gospel, and even folk songs. Other recent operatic parts written for the countertenor voice include Edgar in Aribert Reimann's Lear (1978), the title role in Philip Glass's Akhnaten (1983), Claire in John Lunn's The Maids (1998), the Refugee in Jonathan Dove's Flight (1998), and Trinculo in Thomas Adès's The Tempest (2004). In 2013 the Romanian countertenor Cezar Ouatu participated with his song "It's my life" in the Eurovision Song Contest.
The countertenor voice
A trained countertenor will typically have a vocal center similar in placement to that of a contralto or mezzo-soprano. Peter Giles, a professional countertenor and noted author on the subject, defines the countertenor as a musical part rather than as a vocal style or mechanism. In modern usage, the term "countertenor" is essentially equivalent to the medieval term contratenor altus (see above). In this way, a countertenor singer can be operationally defined as a man who sings the countertenor part, whatever vocal style or mechanism is employed. The countertenor range is generally equivalent to an alto range, extending from approximately G3 (g) to D5 (d″) or E5 (e″). In actual practice, it is generally acknowledged that a majority of countertenors sing with a falsetto vocal production for at least the upper half of this range, although most use some form of "chest voice" (akin to the range of their speaking voice) for the lower notes. The most difficult challenge for such a singer is managing the lower middle range, for there are normally a few notes (around B♭3) that can be sung with either vocal mechanism, and the transition between registers must somehow be blended or smoothly managed.
In response to the (in his view) pejorative connotation of the term falsetto, Giles refuses to use it, calling the upper register "head voice." Many voice experts would disagree with this choice of terminology, reserving the designation "head voice" for the high damped register accompanied by a relatively low larynx that is typical of modern high operatic tenor voice production. The latter type of head voice is, in terms of the vocal cord vibration, actually more similar to "chest voice" than to falsetto, since it uses the same "speaking voice" production (referred to as "modal" by voice scientists), and this is reflected in the timbre.
Controversy over the terms male soprano, male alto, and countertenor
Particularly in the British choral tradition, the terms male soprano and male alto serve to identify men who rely on falsetto vocal production, rather than the modal voice, to sing in the soprano or alto vocal range. Elsewhere, the terms have less universal currency. Some authorities do accept them as descriptive of male falsettists, although this view is subject to controversy; they would reserve the term "countertenor" for men who, like Russell Oberlin, achieve a soprano range voice with little or no falsetto, equating it with haute-contre and the Italian tenor altino. Adherents to this view maintain that a countertenor will have unusually short vocal cords and consequently a higher speaking voice and lower range and tessitura than their falsettist counterparts, perhaps from D3 to D5. Operatic vocal classification, on the other hand, prefers the terms "countertenor" and "sopranist" to "male soprano" and "male alto," and some scholars consider the latter two terms inaccurate owing to physiological differences between male and female vocal production. The sole known man who can claim to be a true male soprano by that definition is Michael Maniaci, whose modal voice falls in the soprano range, like a woman's, because his larynx never fully developed during puberty.
|Joad||Athalia||George Frideric Handel||1733|
|David||Saul||George Frideric Handel||1738|
|Alto part||Israel in Egypt||George Frideric Handel||1739|
|Athamas||Semele||George Frideric Handel||1743|
|Joseph||Joseph and his Brethren||George Frideric Handel||1744|
|Hamor||Jephtha||George Frideric Handel||1752|
|Oberon||A Midsummer Night's Dream||Benjamin Britten||1960|
|David||Chichester Psalms||Leonard Bernstein||1965|
|Voice of Apollo||Death in Venice||Benjamin Britten||1973|
|Prince Go-Go||Le Grand Macabre||György Ligeti||1978|
|Military Governor||A Night at the Chinese Opera||Judith Weir||1987|
|Mephistophiles||Historia von D. Johann Fausten||Alfred Schnittke||1994|
|Claire (travesti)||The maids||John Lunn||1998|
|The Refugee||Flight||Jonathan Dove||1998|
|Trinculo||The Tempest||Thomas Adès||2004|
|Artemis (travesti)||Phaedra||Hans Werner Henze||2007|
|Prospero||The Enchanted Island||Pasticcio||2011|
|Ferdinand||The Enchanted Island||Pasticcio||2011|
|First Angel/Boy||Written on Skin||George Benjamin||2012|
- Stark, James (2003), Bel Canto: A History of Vocal Pedagogy
- Giles, Peter (1982), The Countertenor. Muller Publishing
- see http://sophia.smith.edu/~rsherr/frmst1.htm
- the nature of the haute-contre voice has been the subject of much debate, but it is now generally accepted that haute-contres sang in what voice scientists term "modal", perhaps using falsetto or falsettone for their highest notes (cf. Lionel Sawkins, Haute-contre, in Sadie, Stanley (ed.), The New Grove Dictionary of Opera, II, pp. 668-69, Grove (Oxford University Press), New York, 1997, ISBN 978-0-19-522186-2, and Mary Cyr, On performing 18th-century Haute-Contre Roles, "Musical Times", vol 118, 1997, pp. 291–5, later reproduced in Cyr, M., Essays on the Performance of Baroque Music. Opera and Chamber Music in France and England, essay no. IX, Ashgate Variorum, Aldeshot (UK)/Burlington, VT (USA), 2008, ISBN 978-0-7546-5926-6)
- Potter, J. (2009), Tenor, History of a voice, Yale University Press, New Haven/London, p. 19 (included footnote 35). ISBN 978-0-300-11873-5
- Giles, Peter (2005), A Basic Countertenor Method
- Appelman, D. Ralph (1986). The Science of Vocal Pedagogy: Theory and Application
- J.B. Steane, Countertenor, in The New Grove Dictionary of Opera, cited, I, p. 999.
- Ardran and Wulstan in their article "The Alto or Countertenor Voice" (Music and Letters, Vol 48/1, January 1967) agree with the view of Giles noted below; others disagree strongly – see, for example, Neal Zaslaw: 'The enigma of the Haute-Contre' (Musical Times, Vol. 115, No. 1581 (Nov., 1974), pp. 939-941); Mary Cyr: 'On performing 18th-century haute-contre roles' (Musical Times, vol 118, April 1977); Simon Ravens: 'A sweet shrill voice' : The countertenor and vocal scoring in Tudor England (Early Music 1998; XXVI: 123-136).
- Giles, "liberal" in his use of the word countertenor, proposes this latter term for such voices
- McKinney, James (1994). The Diagnosis and Correction of Vocal Faults. Genovex Music Group. ISBN 978-1-56593-940-0.
- Times Article October 2007
- Role conceived for treble, soprano or high countertenor (Paul Griffiths, Grand Macabre, Le, in Sadie, II, p. 511).
- Role created by the tenor David Knutson, but conceived for both tenor and countertenor (Andrew Clements, Lear, in Sadie, II, p. 1115).
- Music by various baroque composers, including George Frideric Handel, Antonio Vivaldi, and Jean-Philippe Rameau (cf.: The Enchanted Island: The Music, The Metropolitan Opera).
- Appelman, D. Ralph (1986). The Science of Vocal Pedagogy: Theory and Application. Indiana University Press. ISBN 978-0-253-20378-6.
- Boldrey, Richard (1994). Guide to Operatic Roles and Arias. Caldwell Publishing Company. ISBN 978-1-877761-64-5.
- Giles, Peter (1982). The Countertenor. Muller Publishing Co.
- Giles, Peter (2005). A Basic Countertenor Method. Kahn & Averill Publishers. ISBN 978-1-871082-82-1.
- Hennen, Peter. "Nature's Way: Vocal Production in Social Context". The Countertenor Voice (Feb 2011).
- Herr, Corinna (2nd edition 2013). Gesang gegen die 'Ordnung der Natur'? Kastraten und Falsettisten in der Musikgeschichte. Baerenreiter Verlag. ISBN 978-3-761-82187-9.
- Howell, Ian. "Countertenor Technique: An Introduction to Concepts". The Countertenor Voice (Apr 2011).
- Howell, Ian. "Vocal Technique: The Flex". The Countertenor Voice (July 2011).
- Howell, Ian. "Are We Post-Anglican Yet?". The Countertenor Voice (Jan 2011).
- Mormile, Alessandro, "Controtenori. La rinascita dei 'nuovi angeli' nella prassi esecutiva dell'opera barocca", Varese, Zecchini Editore, 2010, 88-6540-000-5, pagg. 218
- Sadie, Stanley (ed.), The New Grove Dictionary of Opera, Grove (Oxford University Press), New York, 1997. ISBN 978-0-19-522186-2
- Smith, Brenda (2005). Choral Pedagogy. Plural Publishing, Inc. ISBN 978-1-59756-043-6.
- Stark, James (2003). Bel Canto: A History of Vocal Pedagogy. University of Toronto Press. ISBN 978-0-8020-8614-3.