Criticism of Sikhism
|Part of a series on|
|Criticism of religion|
|By religious figure|
Sikhism has been criticized in one way or another by proponents of other theories. Various scholars have described the elements of Sikhism to be with the religion that were founded before. Sikhs continues to face discrimination due to their presence and past activities.
William Hewat McLeod cited the tension between the doctrine of God's transcendence in Sikhism and a supposed ability of God to communicate with people. McLeod says Sikh thinkers have been unable to give a convincing account of how God can communicate with people at all if this being is indeed transcendent.
Dayanand Saraswati, in his book Satyarth Prakash, criticized Sikhism, he called Guru Nanak a "rogue", and wrote about the hymns of the Guru Granth Sahib that they are falsehood, he further adds that Sikhism is snare to rob and cheat simple folk of their wealth and property. A Sikh had wrote him as opposition to his remarks about the religion in the book. Dayanand Saraswati answered him back saying writing that his opinion had undergone a change, when he visited Punjab, and the remarks about Sikhism will be deleted on next edition. These remarks were never removed and after untimely death of Dayanand Saraswati, and the later editions of Satyarth Prakash were even more critical towards Sikhism.
Ernest Trumpp had concluded that Adi Granth was not worth translating in full--"the same few ideas, he thought, being endlessly repeated." Trump viewed Adi Granth to be lacking theological transcendence and lacking systematic unity.
Sikhism cites that the concept of Ek Onkar (One God) was created by the Gurus while this concept was already taught in the Vedas, other later scriptures such as Bhagavad Gita, Torah, Quran, that came about long before the religion of Sikhism, said the same. Although, it has been suggested by some that Sikhism's monotheism differs from other religions.
Guru Nanak opposed polytheistic practices. Nanak, during his trip to Mecca had debate with mullahs of Mecca, in his debate, Nanak had asserted that Kaaba was only a black stone, which is Lingam, of Lord Shiva. Along with Islam, others such as Jainism, Hinduism, were also targeted by Nanak. However it has been alleged that later gurus of Sikhism added the practices that can be linked with polytheism,  most notably waving fan over Guru Granth Sahib, during worship.
One of view of Sikhism is that it is a syncretism of Hinduism and Islam, having evolved from Hinduism in the context of a multiplicity of syncretic movements in Medieval India while taking the idea of monotheism from Islam. This view is commonly believed, but is outdated within scholarship.
Sikh groups have put pressure on universities, and there has been a movement among some Sikhs to stifle academic criticism of Sikhism in North America.
Attitude to women
Sikhism is commonly held to promote gender equality compared to other religions. However, some cultural traditions still lead to male children being prized more highly than girls, and to beliefs in traditional gender roles.
There have also been claims that Sikhism's ban on hair removal interferes with women's freedom to follow modern fashions for grooming, and on the other hand that this ban is not applied equally to men and women, with women policed less rigidly.
Relations with other religions and communities
There is a history of tension between Sikhism and Islam. This goes back to the persecution of Sikhs by the Mughal emperors in India, but has manifested in more recent distrust between the communities in the UK, including hostility to inter-community romantic relationships.
Immediately after Operation Blue Star, some Sikh communities started demanding for a separate nation, they called it "Khalistan movement", during this movement, Sikhs had been involved in terrorism, most popular incident being Air India Flight 182, in which 268 Canadian citizens died. Many of the Sikh groups were banned from the numerous countries, who had been convicted with terrorist activities. And Sikhs around the world have been convicted for funding these terrorist groups. Due to such negative impact, the support for Khalistan Movement has been commonly regarded as act of terrorism, many have been arrested for affirming support for the movement.
Although the present situation in Punjab is usually regarded as peaceful; and the militant movement(Khalistan) has been weakened. By 22 May 2004, Manmohan Singh became 13th Prime Minister of India, and to date he remains the Prime Minister of the country.
On 2004, France had passed a law which banned many religious signs in schools. This ban included turbans, which plays important role in Sikh religion. Since the number of Sikhs in France is very small, the French education minister was unaware that there were any Sikhs in France. This law lead to Sikhs protesting against the law across Europe, India, as well as other regions. This issue is heatedly debated. European Court of Human Rights dismissed the petition. Although UN's human right body supported the petition on January 2012, citing that turbans don't pose a threat to ground security.
- Mandair, A.-P. S., Religion and the Specter of the West (Columbia University Press, 2009), p. 261.
- "Reduced to Ashes: The Insurgency and Human Rights in Punjab ..., Volume 1", p.16
- Institute of Sikh Studies, Chandigarh
- "Sikhism: A Guide for the Perplexed", by Arvind-Pal Singh Mandair, p. 87
- Sikhs in Europe: Migration, Identities and Representations. p. 101.
- "Divine Message Of God To Mankind Vedas" by J.M. Mehta, Chapter '12. Worship of God'.
- Zaehner, Robert Charles. The Bhagavad-Gita. p. 141.
- "Modern Scholarship in the Study of Torah", p.165, by Shalom Carmy
- "One God in One Man" By C. T. Benedict, page.179
- Kelemen, Lawrence Charles. Permission to Receive: Four Rational Approaches to the Torah's Divine Origin. p. 27.
- Needham Cust, Robert. Linguistic and Oriental Essays. p. 41.
- (Guru Granth Sahib, Ang, 556)
- Pruthi, Raj. Sikhism and Indian Civilization. p. 16.
- "The Guru Granth Sahib and Sikhism", p. 28, by Anita Ganeri
- "Hindu Religion: Customs and Manners; Describing the Customs and Manners, Religious, Social and Domestic Life, Arts and Sciences of the Hindus", p. 78, by Paul Thomas
- Dhanjal, B., "Sikhism" in Holm & Bowker (eds.), Picturing God (Continuum, 1994), p. 192.
- Hawley & Mann, "Introduction" in Studying the Sikhs (SUNY Press, 1993), p. 3.
- Singh, Nikky-Guninder Kaur. Sikhism: An Introduction. p. 101.
- Kaur, Shiha (13 April 2010). "Sikhism - A Feminist Religion?". The F Word.
- Singh, Nikky-Guninder Kaur. The Feminine Principle in the Sikh Vision of the Transcendent. p. 1.
- Abdulrahim, Raja (October 9, 2011). "A decision on the razor's edge". LA Times.
- Hundal, Sunny (September 12, 2013). "Sikhs v Muslims: why the debate on grooming isn’t about the women themselves". Liberal Conspiracy. Retrieved 9 October 2013.
- "Congressional Record, V. 152, PT. 17, November 9, 2006 to December 6, 2006", p. 606
- UN human rights body backs French Sikhs on turbans
- Sikhs protest against French ban
- Sikhs stage protest in Delhi over French turban ban
- Canadian Public Opinion Poll, 2nd October 2013