Difficile lectu (Mozart)
The work was entered by the composer into his personal catalog on 2 September 1788 as part of a set of ten canons; it was probably written some time during the years 1786-1787.
Although some of the canons in the 1788 set have serious (that is, religious) lyrics, K. 559 was evidently meant entirely for fun. The work features two bilingual puns and some scatological humor. The lyrics are—ostensibly—in Latin, though as they are given in sequence they do not make sense in this language:
- Difficile lectu mihi mars et jonicu difficile.
The humor of the work consists of hearing these words instead as vulgar phrases of German and Italian.
The German pun is based on the strong Bavarian accent of the tenor-baritone Johann Nepomuk Peyerl (1761–1800), who can be presumed to have been the lead singer in the first performance (see below). As Jean-Victor Hocquard points out, the pseudo-Latin lyrics lectu mihi mars, as Peyerl would have sung them, resemble Bavarian German leck du mi im Arsch, which in a literal English rendering is "lick thou me in-the arse". More idiomatically, the phrase could be translated, "kiss my arse" (American English "kiss my ass").
The second pun in the canon is based on the single Latin word jonicu. Winternitz (1958) explains that when this word is sung repeatedly and rapidly, as in the canon, its syllables are liable to be heard rearranged as a taboo word of dialectal Italian, cujoni, which means "balls, testicles", akin to Spanish cojones.
Michael Quinn writes, "Mozart clearly relished the incongruity resulting from ribald verse set as a canon, traditionally regarded as the most learned of all compositional techniques."
A tale concerning how the canon was composed and first sung was offered by Gottfried Weber, a musicologist and editor of the early 19th century. In an 1824 issue of Caecilia, the journal he edited, Weber published a facsimile of the original manuscript of the canon (see below). In his commentary, Weber included the following.
- "The story is as follows. The otherwise outstanding Peierl had a number of remarkable idiosyncrasies of pronunciation, which Mozart often poked fun of in friendly interactions with him and with other friends. One evening, at a merry gathering, Mozart had the idea of writing a canon in which the few Latin words "Difficile lectu" etc. would emerge in Peyerl's pronunciation in a comical way, with the expectation that he would not notice this and would be fooled. At the same time, on the reverse side of the same sheet of paper Mozart wrote the mocking canon "O du eselhafter Peierl" ("Oh, you asinine Peierl"), K. 560a.
- The joke succeeded. After the strange Latin words had emerged from Peyerl's mouth in the anticipated comical way —to the satisfaction of all present— Mozart turned over the page, and had the group, instead of applauding, sing the triumphal mocking canon "O du eselhafter Peierl".
Weber does not say where his story came from.
For more on Mozart's habit of favoring his friends with vulgar mockery, see Joseph Leutgeb.
The autograph (original manuscript copy) has survived; it is a "tiny slip of paper" (Searle) on the reverse side of which is —as Weber noted— the original copy of K. 560a. In a number of places the lyrics are blurry and difficult to read, a condition Weber attributed to stray droplets of champagne.
A sketch for K. 559 is also preserved; its existence suggests that, contrary to what Weber recounted, Mozart must have planned his joke in advance. Both the autograph and the sketch can be viewed at the NMA website; see External Links below.
The canon is probably one of the less frequently performed of Mozart's works. It illustrates the composer's multilingualism and his taste for light-hearted scatological humor.
- More scatological canons:
- Maria Anna Thekla Mozart (the cousin to whom Mozart wrote a number of cheerfully scatological letters).
- Mozart and scatology
- Preface to Neue Mozart Ausgabe edition (External link below)
- Source: Preface to the NMA edition. The honoree of the canon, Johann Nepomuk Peierl (see below) lived in Vienna only between late 1785 and 1787.
- Hocquard (1999, 203)
- For discussion of the German idiom, see Leck mich im Arsch.
- Hocquard's explanation presumes a dialectal pronoun mi "me". Copeman and Scheer (1996, 262) note that the Latin pronoun mihi was sometimes pronounced by German singers as [ˈmiçi], which would have been a good match for Standard German [mɪç] mich.
- Quinn (2007, 59)
- Original German: "Die Geschichte aber ist folgende. Der sonst treffliche Peierl hatte einige wunderliche Eigenheiten der Wortausprache, über welche Mozart in freundlichem Umgange mit ihm und anderen Freunden, oft schertze. Am einem Abende solchen fröhlichen Beisammenseins kam Mozarten der Einfall, ein Paar lateinische Wörter "Difficile lectu mihi" u.s.w. bei deren Absingen Peierls Aussprache in komischem Lichte hervortreten musste, zu einem Canon zu verarbeiten; und, in der Erwartung, dass dieser die Absicht nicht merken und in die Falle gehen werde, schrieb er gleich auf der Rückseite desselben Blattes den Spottkanon: O! du eselhafter Peierl!. Der Scherz gelang, und kaum waren jene wunderlichen lateinischen Worte aus Peierls Munde in der erwarteten komischen Weise zu allgemeinen Behagen gehört worden, so drehete Mozart das Blatt um, und liess nun die Gesellschaft, statt Applaus, den kanonischen Triumph- und Spottgesang anstimmen: O! du eselhafter Peierl!.
- Weber 1824, 179
- Searle 1986
- Copeman, Harold and Vera U. G. Scheer (1996) "German Latin," in Timothy McGee, ed., Singing Early Music. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
- Hocquard, Jean-Victor (1999) Mozart ou la voix du comique. Maisonneuve & Larose, p. 203.
- Quinn, Michael (2007) "Canon", in Cliff Eisen and Simon P. Keefe, eds., The Cambridge Mozart Encyclopedia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Searle, Arthur (1986) "Stefan Zweig Collection," Early Music, Vol. 14, No. 4 (Nov., 1986), pp. 616–618
- Weber, Gottfried (1824) "Originalhandschrift von Mozart" (An original manuscript of Mozart), Caecilia 1:179–182 at Google Book Search
- Winternitz, Emanuel (1958) "Gnagflow Trazom: An Essay on Mozart's Script, Pastimes, and Nonsense Letters", Journal of the American Musicological Society, Vol.11, No. 2/3 (Summer-Autumn, 1958), pp. 200–216.