Federation of Conservative Students

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Federation of Conservative Students (FCS) was the student organisation of the British Conservative Party from the late 1940s to 1986. It was created to act as a bridge between the student movement and the Conservative Party. In its final years it became known colloquially as "Maggie's Militant Tendency",[1] in reference to then Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and to a divisive group within the Labour Party, the Militant tendency. The FCS was then broken up by the Chairman of the Conservative Party, Norman Tebbit, after one of its members had accused previous former Prime Minister Harold Macmillan of war crimes in extraditing Cossacks to the Soviet Union.[2] The FCS was replaced by the Conservative Collegiate Forum.

History[edit]

The organisation was created in the late 1940s to act as a bridge between the student movement and the Conservative Party, It was initially named the Federation of University Conservative and Unionists Associations (FUCUA). By the late 1970s the organisation had moved considerably left of the Conservative party.[3]

Paradigm shift[edit]

The policies of Margaret Thatcher had a polarising effect on British politics and the student left moved towards radicalism in their response to them. Many students' unions would pass motions instituting a policy of "No Platform for Racists or Fascists". Starting in the early 1980s, the organisation adopted a more confrontational approach toward the left-leaning National Union of Students. Leaders, most notably from Scotland, started advocating "voluntary students' unions". They organised campaigns aimed at disaffiliating individual students' unions from the NUS to weaken the so-called block vote, and deprive it of taxpayers' money which the NUS used for various causes.[4] Posters and other publicity material became much more provocative and hard-hitting.[3]

Factionalism[edit]

In the early years FCS was moderate in its outlook and elected a number of National Chairmen reflecting a mainstream outlook. These included Mark Carlisle MP and Andrew Neill and Anthony Buck MP. [5]

However the 1970s saw increasing factionalism mirroring the internal conflict's between Monday Club supporters of Enoch Powell and the Heathite leadership. In its last years, the FCS, perhaps reflecting the debate within the Conservative party of the 1980s and the generally fractious nature of student politics, was notably prone to factionalism. The three main factions were:

Authoritarians[edit]

The authoritarian faction centred around the student Monday Club, and was known for its more traditional British nationalism, an isolationist posture in relation to foreign affairs, opposition (as espoused by Enoch Powell) to immigration, scepticism about liberal economics, and staunch support for the Union.[6]

Libertarians[edit]

The Libertarian faction (the "Libs") was closely linked to the Libertarian Alliance run by Chris Tame,[7] and the Adam Smith Institute, run by Dr Madsen Pirie.[3]

The libertarian faction was the largest faction in the FCS in its last few years. Its overall dominance is illustrated by the passage of a libertarian motion in favour of free migration at the Leicester conference, shortly before the demise of the FCS, which was opposed by both the wet and the authoritarian factions.[8]

Under Glendening, elected Chairman in 1984, the FCS became more controversial than ever as it embraced social libertarianism in addition to the already established endorsement of economic liberalism; issues such as supporting the legalisation of drugs were no longer taboo."[3]

Many former leaders of the libertarian faction, such as Mark MacGregor, went on to hold senior office in the Conservative Party. Other notable members of "the Libs" were: Brian Monteith,[9] Lloyd Beat,[10] Marc-Henri Glendening, Marc Gordon, Mark Allatt, Robbie Gibb, Adrian Lee, Steve Nicholson, Douglas Smith[11][12] David Hoile,[13] and Harry Phibbs.[14] John Bercow and Andrew Rosindell were once also members, although they had also been part of the authoritarian faction.[15]

Moderates[edit]

The Moderate faction had controlled the FCS until 1980. Some of them were members of the Tory Reform Group (TRG). Eight prominent members of the moderate faction including several former chairmen joined the SDP in 1981.[3]

Despite a relatively high number of supporters and control of some large student bodies, they only once gained influence in the national federation after 1980, through a controversial last minute alliance with the authoritarian faction in 1983.

The moderate faction was usually referred to by its' opponents as the "Wets" in an allusion to the contemporary nickname for the anti-Thatcherite wing of the parliamentary party, although after 1980 this description was often vehemently rejected[citation needed] by members of the moderate faction in FCS themselves in favour of titles such as the "Party Faction"[citation needed] and "Conservative Student Unionists." This was partly because they saw themselves as seeking to represent the mainstream of the party and not just the left, and partly because this faction did contain a significant proportion of prominent members such as Paul Goodman and Mark Francois[citation needed] who later became MPs perceived to be to the right of the party leadership.

In many universities the TRG organised itself as a complementary political society to the main Conservative group. This is a policy that the TRG has maintained since, although the last of these societies, the Oxford TRG Society, merged with Oxford's Conservative Association in 2007.[16]

Controversy[edit]

Political stance[edit]

In the 1980s the FCS was noted for being more radical than the main party, more Thatcherite than Thatcher – ministers invited to speak at conferences were routinely chastised for not going far enough.[3]

In addition to supporting no-holds-barred privatisation, controversial positions embraced included the support for American intervention in Grenada, RENAMO, the UNITA rebels in Angola, and the Contras in Nicaragua.[14] "Hang Nelson Mandela" slogans[17] were apparently worn by some leading members.[13] The Federation made badges with the words "Nicaragua Must be Free". Ironically, some Labour students began wearing them without realising their origin and intended meaning.[18]

Some delegates to the Loughborough conference wore T-shirts with the slogan "Morning Cloud, remember the Belgrano". In October 1985 they were accused of physically intimidating Edward Heath.[19]

The satirical magazine Private Eye alleged that members of the FCS at Aberystwyth wore springbok jerseys, racially abused ethnic minority bar staff at the student bar and organised a night out in Aberystwyth town centre to celebrate the anniversary of Adolf Hitler's rise to power in Germany. Following that incident, all members of the FCS were banned from giving speeches or organising meetings at the institute under the students' union's 'No Platform for Racists or Fascists' policy.[20]

Alleged riot at Loughborough University[edit]

There was some damage during the 1985 FCS conference at Loughborough University, leading to press reports of a "riot". The officers elected at that conference were mainly of the libertarian faction who espouse many of the controversial libertarian ideals which have embarrassed the party leadership.[21] Although it was clear that some damage was done, the so-called riot was vastly exaggerated, the final bill for repairs that the University presented came to under £20, and there would not be enough evidence to close the FCS as the then Party Chairman John Selwyn Gummer wanted. Nevertheless, reports of "riots" in the media, including the Daily Star and the Daily Mirror, motivated Gummer immediately to suspend the FCS's £30,000 annual grant.[21]

The Daily Telegraph wrote that the "students cleared up the mess after the offending party, and journalists who saw the room the morning after reported a damaged door handle, a missing light bulb and beer stains on the carpet in a corridor to be the only visible signs of damage."[22] Inspector Patricia Perry of Loughborough Police Station said "there was no physical damage".[citation needed] In a letter to The Times, Professor Peter Havard-Williams of Loughborough University stated "The damage itself was not more than that done by many other conferences and was not excessive."[23] Mark MacGregor suggested that Gummer's actions were politically motivated: "Unfortunately, many of our supporters will see this as a move against the leaders they have elected. Our supporters are from working-class backgrounds, and the party establishment seems to feel that we don't quite fit in."[23]

In The Observer, Toby Young wrote: "As nights of mob terror go, last Monday's party at the Federation of Conservative Students' Conference was pretty tame".[24] Both Young and Sir Alfred Sherman believed that Gummer's actions were motivated by his opposition to the libertarian ideology of some of the FCS' members which closely resembled some of Mrs Thatcher's personal beliefs. Sherman wrote that Gummer's actions were "directed against the Prime Minister".[25] Tim Hames and Nick Robinson later admitted that the bill presented for damage was less than £20,[26] and that the media reports were as a result of an "astute spinning operation" by Wet delegates from the University of Oxford, who "directed journalists to students who offered harrowing accounts of the boorish behaviour of libertarian activists."[26]

Demise[edit]

The FCS was disbanded by Norman Tebbit, who succeeded Gummer as the party chairman. This was for publishing an article, penned by Harry Phibbs, following Nikolai Tolstoy's accusation that former Conservative Prime Minister Harold Macmillan was complicit in war crimes for his involvement in the forced repatriation of Cossack prisoners of war to Soviet Russia in the aftermath of World War II.[2][3]

Past chairmen[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Happold, Tom (8 October 2003). "Tory youth group accused of take-over plot". The Guardian Unlimited (London). 
  2. ^ a b John Stevens (21 August 1986). "Tories sue student editor over Macmillan war crimes charges". Sydney Morning Herald. p. 9. 
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Phibbs, Harry (30 October 2006). "FCS twenty years on – Harry Phibbs remembers his days in the Federation of Conservative Students". 
  4. ^ "No2NUS". 
  5. ^ BBC Desert Island Discs Interview 2007
  6. ^ "Right Now! A forum for eugenecists". Searchlight magazine. July 1998. 
  7. ^ Glendening, Marc (5 April 2006). "Chris Tame". The Guardian. 
  8. ^ "The Federation of Conservative Students – Tory Diary". ConservativeHome. 
  9. ^ Macleod, Angus (12 July 2005). "Tory turmoil as Monteith leaves post". The Times (London). 
  10. ^ "Former Scottish Tory candidate found hanged". Evening News. 16 August 2000. [dead link]
  11. ^ "New Model Tories: Tory tribes". The Independent (London). 24 September 2006. 
  12. ^ Elliot, John (22 June 2003). "Top Tory aide is king of the urban swingers". The Sunday Times (London). 
  13. ^ a b Hyde, Marina (27 September 2001). "Diary". The Guardian. 
  14. ^ a b Nadler, Jo-Anne (4 December 2004). "The curse of Tory Boy". The Guardian (London). 
  15. ^ "The most expensive MP at Westminster". The Guardian. 4 November 2002. 
  16. ^ Wisnom, Selena (28 November 2007). "OUTRG merges with OUCA". Cherwell. Retrieved 26 June 2013. 
  17. ^ "Hang Nelson Mandela poster". from The South African Exiles Home Page. 
  18. ^ Nadler, Jo-Anne. Too Nice to be a Tory: It's My Party and I'll Cry If I Want To. Simon & Schuster, 2004. p. 81. 
  19. ^ Denham, Andrew; Garnett, Mark (2002). Keith Joseph. Acumen. p. 434. 
  20. ^ [need quotation to verify] (1181). Private Eye. March 2007. p. 15. 
  21. ^ a b Evans, Timothy (1996). Conservative Radicalism: A Sociology of Conservative Party Youth Structures and Libertarianism 1970–1992. Berghahn Books. p. 36 (footnotes 107 and 108, citing the Daily Telegraph of 4 April 1985). ISBN 1-57181-872-3. 
  22. ^ Norman, Margot (6 April 1985). "unknown title". The Daily Telegraph. p. 37. 
  23. ^ a b "Letters to the Editor". The Times. 12 April 1985. 
  24. ^ "Letters to the Editor". The Observer. 7 April 1985. 
  25. ^ "Letters to the Editor". Sunday Times. 14 April 1985. 
  26. ^ a b Hames, Tim. "A Burst of Freedom". BBC Radio 4. 
  27. ^ Archer, Graeme (27 February 2004). "Michael Hooker". The Daily Telegraph (London). 
  28. ^ Asthana, Anushka (11 October 2003). "Sir Antony Buck". The Times (London). 
  29. ^ Asthana, Anushka (20 July 2005). "Lord Carlisle of Bucklow". The Times (London). 
  30. ^ Pierce, Andrew (17 June 2005). "The backstreet bruiser hoping to knock sense into the Tories". The Times (London). 
  31. ^ Kite, Melissa (5 November 2002). "Frontbencher refused to 'go missing' again". The Times (London).