First same-sex marriage in Spain
Two women, Marcela Gracia Ibeas and Elisa Sanchez Loriga, attempted to get married in A Coruña (Galicia, Spain). To achieve it Elisa had to adopt a male identity: Mario Sánchez, as listed on the marriage certificate. It is the first attempt at same-sex marriage in Spain for which there is recorded evidence. It was performed by the Church, in the parish church of St. Jorge of the same city. Subsequently the parish priest discovered the deception, and was denounced and persecuted. Nevertheless, the marriage certificate was never annulled.
Their matrimonial union took place more than 100 years before the law would permit gay Spanish people to get married. The two worked as teachers at a time when the vast majority of the Galician population was illiterate.
This event could be considered a precedent for same-sex marriage in Spain. News of their wedding was spread to all Spain and to various European countries. The couple is believed to have escaped to Argentina, and it is unknown what happened to them after that.
First encounter, separation and reunion
Marcela and Elisa met while studying in the Teacher-Training College for Teachers in A Coruña, where the future teachers of elementary education were educated. Their friendship gave way to a more intimate relationship. Marcela's parents, seeing that the friendship was growing beyond that socially permitted and fearing a possible scandal, sent their daughter to Madrid. Time went by and both, one in A Coruña and the other in Madrid, finished their studies. They were reunited again when Elisa was appointed as a temporary teacher at Couso, a small parish of Coristanco in A Coruña. Nearby, in Vimianzo, in the village of Calo, Marcela established herself already as a superior teacher. As a consequence of the same, they decided to live together in Calo, where Elisa worked. In 1889, Marcela had to go to teach classes at Dumbría while Elisa remained in Calo, but they stayed in contact until Elisa moved to the town where Marcela lived.
False identity and marriage
In 1901, Elisa adopted a masculine appearance (with which she appeared in the Teaching College to apply for a certificate of study), fabricated a past, and was transformed into Mario. For this invented past, she took as reference a cousin of hers killed in a shipwreck. Furthermore, she made up that she had passed her childhood in London and that her father was an atheist. Considering this last circumstance, the father Cortiella, parish priest of San Jorge, baptized Mario on 26 May 1901 (furthermore, he received first communion), and subsequently married the couple on 8 June 1901 after the publication of the banns. The marriage ceremony was short; the sponsors bore witness to its validity; and the couple passed the night of the wedding in the boarding house Corcubión, on the street of San Andrés.
Finally, the neighbours could not remain indifferent as before, with what was at the moment known as a "marriage without man". The couple were exposed by Galician and Madrid newspapers and, as a consequence of this, both quickly lost their jobs, were excommunicated, and were issued an arrest warrant. It appears that, so that the excommunication could take place, the parish priest requested a doctor examine Mario to check if he was a man or a woman. Mario agreed. When the doctor issued his verdict, Mario attempted to pass for a hermaphrodite whose condition had been diagnosed in London. The Civil Guard pursued the couple to the town of Dumbrías, where they both worked as teachers. There is evidence that they passed for Vigo and Oporto in their escape. The last that is known of them is that they managed to board a ship destined for America (possibly Argentina, as so many other Spaniards of the era), where they spent their honeymoon and, finally, stayed to live. One of the cases that one of the courts took against them was closed. Several years later, some residents of Dumbría spread a rumour about the death of Elisa and the subsequent marriage of Marcela to a man. This rumour has not been confirmed.
It is possible to stress that the wedding, according to the Diocesan Archive, is still valid. Neither the Church nor the civil registry annulled the marriage certificates, so this is the first recorded same-sex marriage in Spain.
On 18 December 2008, the book Elisa e Marcela – Alén dos homes (Elisa and Marcela – Beyond men) was published in A Coruña. The 300-page book, written in Galacian, tells the story of the two women from the time they fled Coruña in 1901 until 1904. It narrates the events in Porto, Portugal, where they were imprisoned, tried, and later released. They fled to Argentina after the Spanish government demanded their extradition from Portugal.
Before leaving Porto for the Americas, Marcela gave birth to a girl. After they landed in Buenos Aires, Elisa (under the alias of Maria) married Christian Jensen, a man 24 years her senior, in 1903. Marcela, under the alias of Carmen, stayed there with his sister and her daughter.
After time, when Elisa refused to consummate the marriage with Christian, he became suspicious. Upon investigation, he discovered that Maria and Carmen were in fact Elisa and Marcela, which the press had realised long ago.
Once again, the courts were faced with trying to annul Jensen's marriage. Since the marriage was between a man and a woman, and therefore valid, no charges were brought against Elisa. After that time, in 1904, there no further record of Marcela and Elisa.
Social and legal impact
Nowadays this event is considered one of the oldest precursors to same-sex marriage in Spain. In the media the courage of these two women is emphasized, stressing that they went into history as the first gay marriage in Spain.
Isaías Lafuente (editor in chief of Cadena SER), in his book Agrupémonos Todas, looks at the highlights of feminism in the twentieth century and indicates the story of Marcela and Elisa as one of the most significant events related to the movement occurring in Galicia (another is the figure of Emilia Pardo Bazán).
The group Milhomes founded the Marcela and Elisa Award, which, with the help of the FELGTB, is already in its sixth edition. They also claim a long street with their name in A Coruña, with little success so far.
In 1902 the book La sed de amar, by the Extremaduran writer Felipe Trigo, was published in Spain. This was a book of great impact in that period. It includes the story of Marcela and Elisa, using the names of Rosa and Claudia, respectively. The profile of these two women and the story of their relationship is transcribed to the fiction of the book with almost total equivalence to the real story. Felipe Trigo's own footnotes in one edition of the book state that the story is real and happened in A Coruña in 1901.
Very first documented same-sex marriage in 1061
A same-sex marriage between the two men Pedro Díaz and Muño Vandilaz in the Galician municipality of Rairiz de Veiga in Spain occurred on 16 April 1061. They were married by a priest at a small chapel. The historic documents about the church wedding were found at Monastery of San Salvador de Celanova.
First legal same-sex marriage in 2005
Although the first known attempt at same-sex marriage is that of Marcela and Elisa, same-sex marriage was legalized in Spain in 2005, by law 13/2005. The first legal same-sex marriage in Spain took place on 11 July of that year, in Tres Cantos, Madrid, between Emilio Menendez and Carlos Baturin, who had lived as a couple for more than thirty years. The first marriage of two women under the law was 11 days later, in Barcelona.
- García Solano, Manuel (30 June 2002). "SON DOS MUJERES Y SE CASARON EN 1901". El Mundo (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- "El primer matrimonio gay en España". 20 minutos (in Spanish). 8 June 2006. Retrieved 20 May 2007.
- Rivas, Manuel (9 March 2007). "Sae da sombra a poesía amatoria de Blanco Amor". El País (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- "Marcela y Elisa: Maestras náufragas, por Espido Freire" (in Spanish). Campus. 7 June 2006. Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- "La boda homosexual que la Iglesia olvidó anular". La Opinión (in Spanish). 24 September 2006. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- "Arzobispado de Pamplona – Resumen Diario de Prensa" (in Spanish). Iglesia Navarra. 9 May 2002. Archived from the original on 28 September 2007. Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- Fernández, Carlos (8 June 2001). "La primera boda sin hombre". La Voz de Galicia (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- "La boda homosexual que la Iglesia olvidó anular Pág 2". La Opinión (in Spanish). 24 September 2006. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 17 June 2007.
- "Elisa e Marcela – Alén dos homes", Colección "Libros da Brétema" (in Spanish) (Editorial Nigratrea), November 2008
- "Lesbianas: La homosexualidad 'invisible'". El Mundo (in Spanish). 30 June 2002. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 21 June 2007.
- "Fallado el Premio Marcela y Elisa" (in Spanish). FELGT. 8 June 2007. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 21 June 2007.
- "Marcela y Elisa" (in Spanish). Milhomes. 2007. Archived from the original on 6 September 2007. Retrieved 17 June 2007. At that time, Milhomes was headed by Jose Carlos Alonso Sánchez.
- Watkins, Almea (2005). El erotismo en las novelas de Felipe Trigo (in Spanish). Sevilla: Renacimiento. p. 102. ISBN 84-8472-207-4.
- Ciallella, Louise (Winter 2006). "Making Emotion Visible:Felipe Trigo and La sed de amar (educación social)". Decimonónica 3 (1): 28–43. Retrieved 15 August 2009.
- Carlos Callón. "Callón gaña o Vicente Risco de Ciencias Sociais cun ensaio sobre a homosexualidade na Idade Media" (in Galician). Retrieved 1 March 2011.