George Douglas of Pittendreich
George Douglas of Pittendreich (died 1552) was a member of the powerful Douglas family who struggled for control of the young James V of Scotland in 1528. His second son became James Douglas, 4th Earl of Morton and Regent of Scotland. Initially, George Douglas promoted the marriage of Mary, Queen of Scots and Prince Edward of England. After war was declared between England and Scotland he worked for peace and to increase the power of Mary of Guise, the widow of James V.
George Douglas was the brother of Archibald Douglas, 6th Earl of Angus, and so was called 'Master of Angus' in his lifetime. His parents were George Douglas, Master of Angus, and Elizabeth Drummond, daughter of Lord Drummond. The Douglas family gained custody of the young James V in 1526. After the king escaped from them, and laid siege to Tantallon Castle in 1529, the family members and allies were forfeited of their lands and titles by the Parliament of Scotland.
George had married Elizabeth Douglas, the daughter and heir of David Douglas of Pittendreich near Elgin. When the Douglases were re-instated in 1543, Pittendreich was the legal representative of the Earl of Morton whose lands were also forfeited. When the Morton lands were restored, George married his son James, the future Regent, to Morton's youngest daughter, Elizabeth Douglas. The 3rd Earl of Morton's eldest daughter Margaret married James Hamilton, 2nd Earl of Arran and another daughter married Lord Maxwell. Sadly, these three sisters were all affected by mental ill-health.
George's eldest son David Douglas, who became the 7th Earl of Angus, married Margaret Hamilton, the daughter of John Hamilton of Samuelston who was a brother of Regent Arran. Arran gave his nephew a dowry of £1000 from the royal exchequer in November 1552.
George had a son, George, and a daughter, Elizabeth, outside his marriage. The son married the Douglas heiress of Parkhead, and became George Douglas of Parkhead. His daughter by Lady Dundas, Elizabeth, married Smeton Richeson.
In the King's minority
In August 1526, the Earl of Lennox tried to abduct James V from the Palace of Holyroodhouse. The Douglases transferred the King to the house of the Archbishop of St Andrews in the Cowgate, where George Douglas could keep a more secure watch with 40 men. When Lennox and Angus joined in battle 2 miles west of Linlithgow on 4 September 1526, George Douglas was set to bring a force raised in Edinburgh and the young King. The King tried to delay George, and at Corstorphine, close to Edinburgh, George raised his voice to James V and threatened him.
In May 1528, James V escaped from the Douglases, and George's custody, to his mother at Stirling Castle. According to Scottish chronicle historians, including Robert Lindsay of Pitscottie, James escaped from Falkland Palace at night. In Pitscottie's story, when George Douglas discovered the King had gone, he first rode towards Ballinbreich Castle, but learned from the Earl of Rothes that the king was not there. George then returned to Falkland, and the Earl of Angus, George and his brother Archibald rode to Stirling. They learnt that James had declared them excluded from six miles of his presence. Subsequently, the family were forfeited by the Parliament of Scotland, and although James's siege of their castle of Tantallon was unsuccessful, they went into exile in England.
Working for peace and the English marriage
Reports of Solway Moss
A letter of George Douglas is the earliest source of the story that James V made Oliver Sinclair of Pitcairn commander of his army before the battle of Solway Moss. The story was doubted by the modern historian Jamie Cameron who points out that the exiled George had much to gain by fabricating such an incident. After the death of James V, George Douglas and his brother the Earl returned to Scotland in January 1543, in the company of a number of Lords taken prisoner at Solway Moss. Viscount Lisle, the Lord Warden of the Border, heard that George was welcomed in Scotland, and stayed with Arran till midnight on 15 January 1543 at Holyroodhouse. The next day he met David Beaton and they embraced. Arran declared that the Douglases would be restored to their lands.
Towards the treaty of Greenwich
On 18 March 1543 George made a contract with James Douglas, 3rd Earl of Morton; he would pay the Earl £2000, he would help the Earl recover the lands he had resigned (under duress) to James V, and George's son James, the future Regent, would marry the Earl's daughter Elizabeth.
At first George was in favour of the marriage of Mary, Queen of Scots to Prince Edward of England. He was in London briefly in April 1543 as a representative of the Parliament of Scotland. In Scotland, George planned with the English ambassador Ralph Sadler another diplomatic mission to England with the Lord Maxwell to discuss sending Mary into England. Sadler wrote to Henry VIII on 1 May 1543 that George had recommended the Earl of Glencairn as a wiser man than Maxwell, and had said to him;
"Two things moved me the rather to be content to go; one was that Henry VIII, besides good pledges for the deliverance of the young Queen within two years of her lawful age, should have the Governor's son, James Hamilton (who, if the said young Queen fail, shall be Prince of this land) into your court for Henry VIII's daughter (Princess Elizabeth), which is the best pledge Henry VIII can devise to have for the better obtaining of all his purpose in time. ... The second cause, is that in case Henry VIII refuse these offers, I may nevertheless confer with his Highness upon the estate of this country, and say my poor mind how the same is to be conquered by force."
The family historian, David Hume of Godscroft records a story that George Douglas is supposed to have used to build consensus for the English marriage. In this tale a physician at court accepted the impossible task of teaching a donkey to speak. Other doctors had failed and been executed. This physician accepted telling the king it would take ten years and be very expensive. His friends asked why he had done this, and his answer was, - in ten years, I, the donkey or the king might be dead, and in the meantime I have had my wage. George was supposed to have argued that Mary's marriage was like this, the English threat was already present, but it would be years before she was of age and the marriage concluded.
George and Glencairn went to meet Henry VIII at Hampton Court on 20 May 1543, George stayed only for a few days. Eustace Chapuys noted he was expected to return with favorable news for Henry. Thomas Wriothesley helped draft the proposals George carried back to Scotland. Mary would be send to England at 8 or at most 10 years old, and marry Edward when she was twelve. George arrived back in Edinburgh on 29 May and Ralph Sadler said he presented the English articles on 4 June.
On 1 July, George was back in London as a commissioner completing the Treaty of Greenwich which was intended to bring peace between England and Scotland and secure the royal marriage plan. George then attempted to reconcile Arran and Cardinal Beaton who was opposed to the marriage. Before the ratification of the treaty by the Scottish lords on 25 August, George held a meeting with the Cardinal at St Andrews Castle on 15 August 1543 assisted by the Earl Marischal and James Kirkcaldy of Grange. The Cardinal gave Regent Arran the Lord Seton as a hostage for George's safety. George told Sadler after the meeting that the Cardinal was compliant and wished only to obtain Henry's and Arran's favour but feared the Scottish abbeys would be suppressed. Cardinal Beaton refused to come to the ratification on account of the feelings of his party and the personal malice of Arran's wife, Margaret Douglas. (She was the eldest daughter of the 3rd Earl of Morton.) The ratification was delayed but George's negotiation at St. Andrews prevented armed conflict. Despite George's efforts, Regent Arran and the Scottish Parliament eventually rejected the treaty in December 1543, resulting in the war of the Rough Wooing.
The Rough Wooing
After the first English raids of 1544 there were moves to depose Arran as regent and give the role to Mary of Guise. George and the Earl of Angus were among her supporters and were imprisoned in Blackness Castle. Edward Seymour, Lord Hertford landed an army at Leith on 3 May 1544 which burnt Edinburgh,and Arran released the brothers, who made a bond with him to support the French marriage plan.
In June George sent the Scottish Rothesay Herald to Guise to take her letters to London and advised her to tell Francis I of France to deal only with her, not with Arran. George spent a night at Redhall near Edinburgh with Adam Otterburn and explained his thinking to him. In September, Guise gave him a pension and he wrote to her that; "if there were but two men in Scotland that will bide at your opinion I shall be one." On 18 October George wrote to Guise from Tantallon saying he would bring armed men to Stirling, promising;
"We sall fors the gufurnor and his part-takaris to come furth to the feilddis and fecht with us, or ellis we sall hungar tham to deith."
The brothers were duly summoned for treason by Arran's parliament of 6 November 1544. The issues were quickly reconciled, and the Douglas brothers were pardoned by a parliament on 12 December 1544 for recent and previous treasons before 1542. In February 1545, George sent a letter to Henry VIII, to be forwarded by his English contact Ralph Eure, (who was killed at the battle of Ancrum Moor). George wrote that the war was losing Henry's support in Scotland and offered advice;
"the Scots are informed that you would make gentlemen no better than shepherds, and by reason of the extreme war that uses killing women and young children and Scots prisoners that come forth of England, gentlemen say that Your Majesty will have a plane conquest of this realm, and that you will kill men women and children. This bruit (rumour) puts a great fear in the peoples's hearts and turns their hearts clearly from you: but gentle handling and good words will turn the favour of the people which may be a great help to Your Majesty's affairs.
In the service of Mary of Guise
A month before the battle of Pinkie, on 9 August 1547 Hertford, now Duke of Somerset, Lord Protector of England, told the Scottish ambassador Adam Otterburn that if George Douglas would negotiate at Newcastle-upon-Tyne he might not invade Scotland. Otterburn advised Arran to allow Douglas to negotiate, writing that he would work for the commonwealth of both realms and to avoid the shedding of Christian blood. Arran objected to this diplomacy, and wished others apart from Douglas might meet at Newcastle. There was no further meeting and the Scottish army was defeated by the English invasion force at Pinkie Cleugh near Musselburgh on 10 September 1547. David Hume of Godscroft relates that Angus and Sir George were at the battle on horseback marshalling the Scottish forces.
In the summer of 1548, George Douglas maintained communication with an English commander, William Grey of Wilton. However, Wilton sent James Wilford and Thomas Wyndham to trap George at Dalkeith Palace. The Castle was taken on 3 June 1548, George escaped, but his son James, Master of Morton, was captured, "sore hurt in the thigh." Elizabeth Douglas was taken too, but Grey of Wilton released her on her promise she would convert her husband back to the English cause. George's former allies, the East Lothian lairds John Cockburn of Ormiston and Alexander Crichton of Brunstane had assisted Grey, who also commended "Newton the Scot" who fought for him at Dalkeith. In July 1548, one of George's servants was given £45 to gain intelligence in England. The money was to cover his expenses and the cost of messengers on his covert mission. In September 1549, the English soldier Thomas Holcroft hoped to organize the capture of George Douglas and facilitate the release of the St Andrew's castle Castilians who were prisoners in France.
- Fraser, William, Douglas Book, vol. 2, 298.
- Hewitt, George, Scotland under Morton, John Donald (1982/2003), 1.
- Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (1898), 615.
- Accounts of the Lord High Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 10 (1913), 130.
- Reid, David ed., Hume of Godscroft, David, History of the House of Angus, vol. 1 STS (2005), 129.
- State Papers Henry VIII, vol. 4 part 4 (1836), 456-7, Dacre to Lord Dacre, 1 Sept. 1526.
- Cameron, Jamie, James V, Tuckwell (1998), 334.
- Merriman, Marcus, The Rough Wooings, Tuckwell (2000), 114-5.
- State Papers Henry VIII, vol.5 part IV cont., (1836) pp.585-586, corrigenda.
- Registrum Honoris de Morton, vol. 2, Bannatyne Club (1853), 274-5.
- Calendar State Papers Spanish, vol.6 part 2 (1895), p.331-2 no.139.
- Clifford, Arthur, ed., Sadler State Papers, vol. 1, Edinburgh (1809), 173-4, (abbreviated, names here supplied for cross-reference)
- Reid, David, David Hume of Godscroft's History of the House of Angus, vol. 1 (2005), 107-108.
- Calendar State Papers Spanish, vol.6 part 2 (1895), p.334 no.141, p.355 no.142
- Letters & papers Henry VIII, vol.18 part 1 (1901), no.577, no.614, no.638.
- Cameron, Annie I., ed., Scottish Correspondence of Mary of Lorraine, SHS (1927), p.22, & footnote, p.23 & footnote.
- Letters & Papers Henry VIII, vol.18 part 2, (1902), no.42, no.49, no.58
- Laing, David, ed., The Works of John Knox, vol.1, Bannatyne Society (1846) p.120.
- Cameron, Annie I., ed., The Scottish Correspondence of Mary of Lorraine, SHS (1927), 89, 92, 108.
- Cameron, Annie I., ed., The Scottish Correspondence of Mary of Lorraine, SHS (1927), 111.
- Merriman, Marcus, The Rough Wooings, Tuckwell (2000), 157-8.
- State Papers Henry VIII, vol.5 part IV cont., (1836), pp.417-418, here modernised.
- Cameron, Annie I., ed., The Scottish Correspondence of Mary of Lorraine, SHS (1927), 193-194 &n.
- Merriman, Marcus, The Rough Wooing, Tuckwell (2000), 229.
- Reid, David, ed., David Hume of Godscroft's History of the House of Angus, vol. 1 (2005), 122.
- CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (1898), 115, 117, 118
- Accounts of the Lord High Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 9 (1911), 216.
- Stevenson, Joseph, ed., Selections from unpublished manuscripts in the College of Arms and the British Museum illustrating the reign of Mary Queen of Scotland, (1837), p.49-50
- Calendar of State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (1898), 502, 530.