German prisoners of war in the United States

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Camp Swift entrance during World War II

Members of the German military were interned as prisoners of war in the United States during World War I and World War II. 425,000 German prisoners lived in 700 camps throughout the United States during World War II.

World War I[edit]

Hostilities ended six months after the United States saw its first action in World War I and only a relatively small number of German prisoners of war reached the U.S.[1] Many prisoners were German sailors caught in port by U.S. forces far away from the European battlefield.[2] The United States Department of War designated three locations as POW camps during the war: Forts McPherson and Oglethorpe in Georgia and Fort Douglas in Utah.[3] The exact population of German POWs in World War I is difficult to ascertain because they were housed in the same facilities used to detain civilians of German heritage residing in the United States, but there were known to be 406 German POWs at Fort Douglas and 1,373 at Fort McPherson.[4][5] The prisoners built furniture and worked on local roads. The few dozen who died while incarcerated as POWs were buried at Ft. Douglas, Utah, the Chattanooga National Cemetery, and Fort Lyon, Colorado.[6][7][8][9]

World War II[edit]

Background[edit]

After the United States entered World War II in 1941, the Government of the United Kingdom requested American help with housing prisoners of war due to a housing shortage in Britain.[10] The United States agreed to house them[11]:5 although it was not prepared. Its military had only brief experience with a limited POW population in the last world war, and was unprepared for basic logistical considerations such as food, clothing and housing requirements of the prisoners.[12] Almost all German-speaking Americans were engaged overseas directly in combat efforts and the American government feared the presence of Germans on U.S. soil would create a security problem and raise fear among civilians.[10]

Despite many "wild rumors" about how the Allies treated their prisoners,[13]:86 some Germans were pleased to be captured by the British or Americans—fear of being captured by the Russians was widespread—because they disagreed with National-Socialism or their nation's conduct of the war.[13]:42–45,148,163 The prisoners were usually shipped in Liberty Ships returning home that would otherwise be empty,[11]:5 with as many as 30,000 arriving per month.[14] While they risked being sunk by their own U-boats on the ocean, good treatment began with the substantial meals served aboard, and upon arriving in America, the comfort of the Pullman cars that carried them to their prison camps amazed the Germans.[13]:32,70

The Geneva Convention[edit]

The camps[edit]

Typical barracks (replica) on display at the Camp Algona POW Museum.[15]

The Office of the Provost Marshal General (OPMG) supervised[11]:8 the 425,000 German prisoners. They stayed in 700 camps[14] in 46 states, although a complete list may not exist because of the small and temporary nature of some camps and the frequent use of satellite or sub-camps administratively part of larger units.[16] Other than the barbed wire and watchtowers, the camps resembled standard United States or German military training sites;[12][17][11]:33 the Geneva Convention of 1929 required the United States to provide living quarters comparable to those of its own military, which meant 40 square feet (3.71 m²) for enlisted men and 120 square feet (11.15 m²) for officers.[13]:xxii If prisoners had to sleep in tents while their quarters were constructed, so did their guards.[18] Government guidelines mandated placing the compounds away from urban, industrial areas for security purposes, in regions with mild climate to minimize construction costs, and at sites where POWs could alleviate an anticipated farm labor shortage.[17]

a current (2013) sign outside the Owosso, MI, WW-II P.O.W. camp where German soldiers were held. Note that this had been, and then was again, the Owosso racetrack

Work[edit]

The Geneva Convention's mandate of equal treatment for prisoners also meant that they were paid American military wages.[19]:78 They could work on farms or elsewhere only if they were also paid for their labor, and officers could not be compelled to work. As the United States sent millions of soldiers overseas, the resulting shortage of labor eventually meant that German POWs worked toward the Allied war effort by helping out in canneries, mills, farms and other places deemed a minimal security risk.[20]

Prisoners could not be used in work directly related to the military work, or in dangerous conditions. The minimum pay for enlisted soldiers was $0.80 a day, roughly equivalent to the pay of an American private. In 1943 the government estimated that prisoner labor cost 50 to 75% of normal free labor. While language differences and risk of escape or unreliable work were disadvantages, prisoner workers were available immediately on demand and in the exact numbers needed. While prisoners on average worked more slowly and produced less than civilians, their work was also more reliable and of higher quality.[19]:79,82,98 Part of their wages helped pay for the POW program, and the workers could use the rest as pocket money for the camp canteen.[20] (They were paid in scrip. All hard currency was confiscated with other personal possessions during initial processing for return after the war as mandated by the Convention, as money could be used during escape attempts.[21][19]:78) The government received $22 million in 1944 from prisoner wages, and that year it estimated that it had saved $80 million by using prisoners in military installations.[11]:6

Newspaper coverage of the camps and public knowledge were intentionally limited until the end of the war, in part to comply with the Geneva Convention and in part to avoid the fear of an enemy presence in such large numbers.[16] While most citizens living near camps accepted the prisoners' presence the government received hundreds of letters each week protesting their treatment. Many demanded that the POWs be immediately killed, a sentiment fueled by the regular casualty lists in American newspapers.[21][22][23] The government had difficulty in persuading the public that treating the prisoners according to the Geneva Convention made it more likely that American prisoners in Germany would be treated accordingly.[16] Labor unions were the largest opposition to the use of the prisoner workers, citing the War Manpower Commission's rules that required union participation in worker recruitment whenever possible.[19]:98–101 Given the wartime labor shortage however, especially in agriculture, many valued their contribution; as late as February 1945, politicians in rural states asked the government for 100,000 more prisoners to work on farms.[11]:6

Camp life[edit]

Life for the Germans in American POW camps was reportedly "firm but fair".[24] There were insufficient American guards, especially German speakers. They mostly supervised the German officers and NCOs who strictly maintained discipline.[12][25][11]:33–34 The Germans woke their own men, marched them to and from meals, and prepared them for work;[26] their routine successfully recreated the feel of military discipline for prisoners.[11]:34 Prisoners had friendly interaction with local civilians,[26] sometimes were allowed outside the camps without guards on the honor system[13]:104,223 (Black American guards noted that German prisoners could visit segregated restaurants that they could not.[19]:52–53), luxuries such as beer and wine were sometimes available, and hobbies or sports were encouraged.[14] Alex Funke, a former POW at Camp Algona wrote: "We all were positively impressed by the USA....We all had been won over to friendly relations with the USA."[27] Indeed, unauthorized fraternization between American women and German prisoners was sometimes a problem.[23] Several camps held social receptions with local American girls, and some Germans met their future wives as prisoners.[13]:25–26[18]

Rations[edit]

Many prisoners found that their living conditions as prisoners were better than as civilians in cold-water flats in Germany.[20] The prisoners were provided with writing materials, art supplies, woodworking utensils, and musical instruments,[24] and were allowed regular correspondence with family in Germany.[25] They ate the same rations as U.S. soldiers as required by the Geneva Convention including special meals for Thanksgiving and Christmas Day,[18] so received two packs of cigarettes a day and frequently ate meat, both rationed for American civilians.[22][23] (Cigarettes were sold in the prisoner canteen for less than outside the camp, so guards were sometimes amenable to being bribed with them.) One German later recalled that he gained 57 pounds in two years as a prisoner.[13]:59,208 Despite complaints to International Red Cross inspectors about the alleged inferiority of American white bread and coffee, prisoners recognized that they were treated better in the United States than anywhere else.[18]

Entertainment and education[edit]

Funke stated that "Nobody could become bored [as a prisoner]."[27] Prisoners held frequent theatrical and musical performances attended by hundreds or thousands, including American guards and Red Cross inspectors.[28] Movies were shown as often as four nights a week;[23] if the camp did not have a projector, prisoners often pooled their savings to purchase one.[19]:110 The cinema served as an important reeducation and propaganda tool as well as entertainment, with Hollywood anti-German films, cartoons such as "Herr Meets Hare", and the Why We Fight series used;[28][29] American World War II films shown mostly dealt with the Pacific War. Near the end of the war approved German films from a list exchanged through the Red Cross became available.[19]:110 After the liberation of the concentration camps, films of the atrocities of the holocaust were shown to the prisoners, which engendered shock, anger, and disbelief. After compulsory viewing of an atrocity film, 1,000 prisoners at Camp Butner dramatically burned their German uniforms.[19]:119 In an idea seriously considered but ultimately rejected by American military officials, a few prisoners even volunteered to fight in the war against Japan.[30]

Camps built libraries to organize their reading material and prisoners often purchased their own, but they never had enough reading material, with an average of one half book per prisoner. The YMCA printed thousands of copies of books for the camps, and even provided bookbinding material so camps could repair them due to frequent use.[19]:113 Camps had subscriptions to American newspapers, and every camp published its own newspaper[28] with poetry and short stories, puzzles and games, listings of upcoming events, and classified ads.[18] Camp authorities recognized the periodicals' value in serving as creative outlets and as accurate indicators of the prisoners' views. The tone of their articles varied; some promoted National-Socialist ideology and foresaw German victory.[19]:110–111 Even as Germany's defeat neared in early 1945, eight of 20 camp newspapers advocated NS ideology.[11]:22

Many future German CEOs benefited from education they received as prisoners in the United States.[18] Educated prisoners such as future German cabinet member Walter Hallstein[13]:150 taught classes in their areas of expertise including German, English and other foreign languages, business and mathematics. The systematically taught courses were so successful that in May 1944 the German Ministry of Education and the OKW sent through the Red Cross detailed procedures for students to receive credit at German high schools and universities.[28] Some prisoners took correspondence classes through local universities, and German universities also accepted their credits after returning home.[12]

Prisoner resistance[edit]

Committed groups of Nazi prisoners continued to exist despite American attempts to identify and separate them. Often members of the Afrika Corps who had been captured early in the war during Germany's greatest military successes,[13]:150–151 they led work stoppages, intimidated other prisoners, and sometimes killed those who cooperated with their captors.[7][17] While the American government executed 14 Germans after the war for murdering other prisoners in three incidents, hundreds of such murders may have occurred.[13]:158–159 Many devoted National-Socialists remained loyal to their political beliefs and expected a German victory until the Allies crossed the Rhine in March 1945; their faith amazed prisoners captured during and after the Battle of Normandy, who had more realistic views of the likely outcome of the war. In turn, the earlier prisoners often viewed the others with contempt, calling them "traitors" and "deserters". Fear of secret punishment by such men caused one prisoner to later state that "there was more political freedom in the German army than in an American prison camp." He and other anti-Nazis were sent to Camp Ruston in Louisiana to protect them.[13]:xx,27,114–115,151,153,157,161,167–168

Prisoners regardless of ideology often taunted their captors, such as saluting with Sieg Heils when forced to attend the lowering of the United States flag. They secretly celebrated Hitler's birthday and other NS holidays after the Americans banned them, and many became upset when Jewish American officers supervised them.[19]:48–49[11]:34–37 Less than 1% of all prisoners of war in America attempted to escape, however—about half the rate of Italian prisoners[11]:7 and less than the rate in the civilian prison system[18]— and most were unsuccessful.[20][12] The likelihood of an escapee returning to their forces overseas was very remote;[26] the wish to avoid boredom was the reason most often given by those who attempted to escape.[13]:132,152 On December 23, 1944, 25 German POWs broke out of Camp Papago Park in Arizona,[31] not far from the Mexican border, by crawling along a 178-foot tunnel.[32] By January the escapees were caught, in part because a river they intended to cross by raft turned out to be a dry river bed.[33]

Special Projects Division[edit]

The OPMG began a formal reeducation program for German prisoners in fall 1943. Named the Special Projects Division (SPD) and directed by a group of university professors, the program published Der Ruf, a prison newspaper edited by sympathetic POWs, and distributed books banned in NS Germany. The effort was kept secret because it probably violated the Geneva Convention's ban on exposing prisoners to propaganda, the possibility of German retaliation with American prisoners, and the expectation that prisoners would reject overt reeducation. After V-E Day, SPD began a series of rapid classes on democracy for some of the most cooperative prisoners. The 25,000 graduates of these classes returned directly to Germany, instead of being used for additional labor in Europe.[11]:8–10,22[13]:169–170

SPD's efforts were unsuccessful. Many in the OPMG opposed the program, in part because they believed that changing most adults' basic philosophies and values was impossible and, if successful, might cause them to choose Communism as an alternative. The American professors were almost entirely ignorant of German language or culture, as well as military and prison life. The reading material they prepared was overly intellectual and did not appeal to most prisoners, and der Ruf was unpopular as it was essentially a literary journal with little current news. Surveys of camp prisoners found no change in the views of the vast majority of prisoners from the program. This was consistent with the unchanging level of confidence found in German soldiers immediately after their capture in Europe despite steady German defeats. Their nation's complete defeat in the war and subsequent division into two countries were likely much more influential than SPD reeducation in Germans' postwar rejection of National-Socialism.[11]:8–11,21–22

After the war[edit]

Dennis Whiles, aka Georg Gärtner (July 4, 2009)

Although they expected to go home immediately after the end of the war in 1945, the majority of German prisoners continued working in the United States until 1946—arguably violating the Geneva Convention's requirement of rapid repatriation—then spent up to three more years as laborers in France and the United Kingdom.[13]:ix,xxii,26–27 Most Germans nonetheless left the United States with positive feelings about the country where they were held,[16] familiarity with the English language, and often with several hundred dollars in earnings. The funds benefited the postwar German economy on their return.[14] They had benefited from being held by a nation that largely did not hate German soldiers; a November 1943 poll found that 74% of Americans solely blamed the German government, not Germans, for the war.[11]:8 After repatriation about 5,000 Germans emigrated to the United States, and thousands of others returned later to visit.[20][13]:248 Funke reported that the visitors did so "as convinced democrats" due to their treatment.[27]

The camps in the United States are otherwise what the Associated Press later called "all but forgotten part of history", even though some former inmates went on to become prominent in postwar Germany. About 860 German POWs remain buried in 43 sites across the United States, with their graves often tended by local German Women's Clubs.[14] Even in the communities which formerly hosted POW camps for Germans, local residents often do not know the camps ever existed.[16][24] Reunions of camp inmates, their captors and local townspeople such as those held in Maine and Georgia have garnered press coverage and local interest for this unusual and infrequently mentioned aspect of the war.[14][34]

There is at least one recorded attempt by US authorities to extract information from German POWs through torture.[35] The camps for Germans were cited as precedents for various positions or failures of U.S. detainee policy during the debate over detainees at Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp.[36]

Georg Gärtner escaped from a POW camp in Deming, New Mexico on September 21, 1945, assumed a new identity and lived quietly for decades until "surrendering" on the Today Show to Bryant Gumbel in 1985. Although wanted by the FBI for forty years, he lives in Colorado under his adopted name Dennis Whiles, and wrote a book about his experiences after escaping, Hitler's Last Soldier in America.[37]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "America in the Great War," EyeWitness to History, www.eyewitnesstohistory.com, retrieved March 28, 2011
  2. ^ "Blow Up Corman, Interned Gunboat," The New York Times, April 8, 1917. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  3. ^ Yockelson, Mitchel, "The War Department: Keeper of Our Nation's Enemy Aliens During World War I," Presentation to the Society for Military History Annual Meeting, April 1998. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  4. ^ Cunningham, Raymond K., Jr.,"Fort Douglas War Prison Barracks Three Prisoners Of War", University of Utah Records Center. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  5. ^ Cunningham, Raymond K., Jr.,"German Prisoners 507 Strong, Join Interned Comrades", University of Utah Records Center. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  6. ^ Lloyd, R. Scott, "Wreath-laying honors WWI German prisoners buried at Fort Douglas", Deseret News, November 14, 2010. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  7. ^ a b Copeland, Susan, "Foreign Prisoners of War", The New Georgia Encyclopedia. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  8. ^ Janiskee, Bob, "Pruning the Parks: Chattanooga National Cemetery", NationalParksTraveler.com, December 25, 2009. Retrieved March 29, 2011
  9. ^ "Cemeteries - Fort Lyon National Cemetery," United States Department of Veterans Affairs. Retrieved March 29, 2011
  10. ^ a b Bowman, Michael, "World War II Prisoner of War Camps", The Encyclopedia of Arkansas History and Culture. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  11. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Rabin, Ron (1995). The Barbed-Wire College: Reeducating German POWs in the United States during World War II. Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-03700-0. 
  12. ^ a b c d e Krammer, Arnold P., "German Prisoners of War", Handbook of Texas Online. Published by the Texas State Historical Association. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  13. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p Carlson, Lewis H. (1997). We Were Each Other's Prisoners: An Oral History of World War II American and German Prisoners of War. New York: Basic Books. ISBN 0-465-09120-2. 
  14. ^ a b c d e f "Day of mourning will honor German POWs held in U.S.", msnbc.msn.com, November 15, 2004. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  15. ^ Camp Algona POW Museum: "You Must Remember This...", accessed April 2, 2011
  16. ^ a b c d e Billinger, Robert D., Jr., "Enemies and Friends: POWs in the Tar Heel State", Tar Heel Junior Historian 47:2 (Spring 2008). Published by North Carolina Museum of History. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  17. ^ a b c Corbett, William P., "Prisoner of War Camps", Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture. Oklahoma Historical Society. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  18. ^ a b c d e f g Krammer, Arnold (2008). Prisoners of War: A Reference Handbook. Greenwood Publishing. pp. 46–48,51–52. ISBN 0275993000. 
  19. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Thompson, Antonio (2010). Men in German Uniform: POWs in America during World War II. University of Tennessee Press. ISBN 1572337281. 
  20. ^ a b c d e Garcia, Malcolm J.,"German POWs on the American Homefront", Smithsonian.com, September 16, 2009. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  21. ^ a b Sytko, Glenn, "German POWs in North America: The Journey to Prison Camps", Uboat.net. Retrieved 2012-09-06
  22. ^ a b Flynn, Jacob, "German POWs kept in Central Florida during WWII", WestOrangeTimes.com. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  23. ^ a b c d Hawfield, Michael, "World War II camp had impact on city", Fort Wayne News-Sentinel, December 15, 1990. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  24. ^ a b c Camp Algona POW Museum. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  25. ^ a b Sytko, Glenn, "German POWs in North America", Uboat.net. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  26. ^ a b c Pepin, John, "POW Camps In the U.P.", The Mining Journal, Marquette Michigan. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  27. ^ a b c Camp Algona POW Museum: Questions and Answers of Alex Funke, accessed April 2, 2011
  28. ^ a b c d Sytko, Glenn, "German POWs in North America: Recreation", Uboat.net. Retrieved 2012-09-06
  29. ^ Waters, Michael R., Mark Long, and William Dickens. Lone Star Stalag: German Prisoners of War at Camp Hearne. 2004, Texas A&M University Press. ISBN 978-1-58544-545-5, page 27.
  30. ^ Krammer, Arnold (1979). Nazi Prisoners of War in America. Stein and Day. pp. 217–19. 
  31. ^ Pela, Robert L., "Flight From Phoenix", PhoenixNewTimes.com, March 8, 2001. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  32. ^ Moore, John Hammond, The Faustball Tunnel: German POWs in America And Their Great Escape. US Naval Institute Press 2006. ISBN 1-59114-526-0
  33. ^ "The Great Escape of '44", Arizona Stories, Season Two. KAET-TV, a broadcast service of Arizona State University. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  34. ^ Allington, Adam, "German POWs Return to Maine in Friendship", VOAnews.com, May 6, 2005. Retrieved March 28, 2011
  35. ^ Adams, Merdith Lentz, Murder and Martial Justice. The Kent State University Press 2011. ISBN 978-1-60635-075-1
  36. ^ Stephenson, Megan, "How Did Americans Feel About Incarcerating German POW's in W. W. II on US Soil?", History News Network. Published by George Mason University. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
  37. ^ Blumenthal, Ralph, "Ex POW ends 40 years of hiding", The New York Times, September 11, 1985. Retrieved 2008-01-14.

External links[edit]