Graniteville, South Carolina, train crash
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (September 2014)|
|Graniteville train crash|
|Date||January 6, 2005|
|Time||Around 2:40 am|
|Location||Graniteville, South Carolina|
|Operator||Norfolk Southern Railway|
|Type of incident||Collision|
|Cause||Incorrectly aligned railroad switch|
At roughly 2:40am EST, two Norfolk Southern trains collided near the Avondale Mills plant in Graniteville. NS local P22 (lead engine GP59 #4622) was parked on a siding near the Avondale Mills plant. NS freight train 192 (lead engine SD60 #6653), which was transporting chlorine gas, sodium hydroxide and cresol, was diverted by an improperly lined railroad switch onto the siding and collided with P22. The collision derailed both lead engines, 16 of 192's 42 freight cars, and one of P22's freight cars. One of 192's tank cars (loaded with 90 tons of chlorine) ruptured, releasing about 60 tons of the gas. About 30% of the load was recovered by industrial responders. Nine people died (eight at the time of the accident, one later as a result of chlorine inhalation), and at least 250 people were treated for chlorine exposure. In total, 5,400 residents within one mile (1.6 km) of the crash site were forced to evacuate for nearly two weeks while HAZMAT teams and cleanup crews decontaminated the area.
Nine people lost their lives in the Graniteville train disaster on the day of the accident:
- Christopher Seeling, 28, of West Columbia, South Carolina, engineer of NS train 192 (was found at the crash site and later died at the hospital);
- Willie C. Shealey, 43, of Graniteville, employee of Avondale Mills Inc. (was found in the wooded area near the Woodhead Division of Avondale Mills Inc.);
- Willie L. Tyler, 57, of Graniteville, employee of Avondale Mills Inc. (was found about 25 feet inside the entrance to the Woodhead Division of Avondale Mills Inc. and later died at the hospital);
- John Laird, 24, of North Augusta, South Carolina, employee of Avondale Mills Inc. (was also found in the wooded area near the Woodhead Division of Avondale Mills Inc.);
- Fred "Rusty" Rushton, III, 41, of Warrenville, South Carolina, employee of Avondale Mills Inc. (was found on the loading dock of the Stevens Steam Plant, owned by Avondale Mills Inc.);
- Steven Bagby, 38, of Augusta, Georgia, employee of Avondale Mills Inc. (was found in a break area in the Gregg Division of Avondale Mills Inc.);
- Allen Frazier, 58, of Ridge Spring, South Carolina, employee of Avondale Mills Inc. (was found in an office in the Gregg Division of Avondale Mills Inc.);
- Joseph L. Stone, 21, of Quebec, Canada, an employee of JW Express Trucking Company (was found in the truck's sleeper cab); and
- Tony DeLoach, 56, of Graniteville, South Carolina (was found in his home on Main Street near the train wreck).
On April 21, 2005, one more death was attributed to the accident. Leonard Mathis, a brick mason in Graniteville, was driving home from a convenience store just after the accident occurred. As he was traveling home, he passed through a portion of the chlorine cloud that resulted from the collision. His health deteriorated from that point on.
Norfolk Southern announced that it expected the disaster to cost between $US 30 to $40 million, including the corporation's self-insurance retention under its insurance policies and other uninsured costs, but not any fines or penalties that might be imposed.
On May 25, 2005, lawyers involved in the damages claims against Norfolk Southern announced that they had reached a preliminary agreement on settlements for area residents and business that were evacuated but did not seek medical attention. In this preliminary settlement, Norfolk Southern would offer each resident who was evacuated and did not seek medical attention within 72 hours of the accident a flat amount of $2,000 for the evacuation plus $200 per person per day of the evacuation. These amounts are separate from any property damage claims. Claims that involve injury or death are not included in this settlement, but are still being negotiated.
On May 22, 2006, Avondale Mills' CEO, Robert Williams Sr., announced that his firm would close all its plants, corporate and sales offices no later than July 25, throwing more than 4,000 workers across four states out of work. Mr. Felker cited the 2005 derailment as the primary reasons for the company's failure. The wreck knocked out the Gregg plant of Avondale mills, which was a key pillar to the survival of the company in a shrinking United States textile market. The plant accounted for 40% of the company's sales. Stephen Felker Jr., Avondale's manager of corporate development stated,"We were prepared to weather the storm of global competition. What we weren't prepared for was an event such as this derailment, which was completely beyond our control." Avondale Mills Inc. reached a $215 million settlement with its insurance company for damages caused by the train derailment and fatal chemical spill.
It is generally assumed[by whom?] that since the plant would have been fully insured and/or covered by Norfolk Southern's accident insurance, that the owners chose to take the settlement money and leave rather than rebuild the damaged plant. However, G. Stephen Felker Sr. stated "We do not believe that the settlement fully compensates us for the full value of the losses incurred as a result of the Norfolk Southern derailment" and said that the company intends to pursue a lawsuit or seek a settlement against Norfolk Southern.
Findings and recommendations
On November 29, 2005, the NTSB issued a report officially blaming the accident on the P22 train crew's failure to reline the switch for mainline operations. The report concluded that neither equipment failure nor crew fatigue or drug or alcohol use was a factor in the accident. It further concluded that the level and immediacy of emergency response to the accident was wholly appropriate for the situation.
As a result of this accident and a similar accident on the Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway on January 8, 2005, the United States Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) released to railroads a reminder of federal regulations on procedures for turnout operation and safety procedures. Among the federal rules regarding turnouts are:
- The normal position for turnouts on mainline tracks is for mainline through traffic.
- When trains are required to clear the mainline track, they will not report that the track is clear until there are no obstructions on the mainline track and all turnouts are set for the mainline position and locked in place.
The FRA further recommended that railroads should:
- ensure that their internal regulations include adequate safety procedures regarding turnout position.
- implement a paper trail to ensure adequate inspection of turnout position before a mainline track is declared cleared.
Avondale Mills filed suit against Norfolk Southern claiming that the railroad was negligent in its operations through Graniteville and that this alleged negligence was the root cause of the accident. After the accident, Avondale Mills was closed, laying off thousands of employees and paid more than $140 million on cleanup and repair expenses. The trial opened on March 10, 2008, in federal court in Columbia, South Carolina.
On April 24, 2008, Norfolk Southern was sued by the U.S. EPA for violations of the Clean Water Act, as Horse Creek had been polluted. In a similar lawsuit in Pennsylvania, where a derailed Norfolk Southern runaway train crashed, the state of Pennsylvania sued the railroad for similar violations and won several million dollars for environmental remediation. However, fines may be minimal when compared to the damage to the surrounding environment.
On March 8, 2010, Norfolk Southern Railway Company agreed to pay $4 million penalty to resolve alleged violations of the Clean Water Act (CWA) and hazardous materials laws for a 2005 chlorine spill in Graniteville, S.C. Under the settlement filed in federal court in Columbia, S.C., Norfolk Southern will be required to pay a civil penalty of $3,967,500 for the alleged CWA violations, to be deposited in the federal Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund. The alleged CWA violations, included in an amended complaint filed in March 2009, are for the discharge of tons of chlorine, a hazardous substance, from a derailed train tank car and thousands of gallons of diesel fuel from ruptured locomotive engine fuel tanks. For the alleged Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) violation for failure to immediately notify the National Response Center of the chlorine release, Norfolk Southern will pay a penalty of $32,500, to be deposited in the Hazardous Substance Superfund. Under the terms of the agreement, Norfolk Southern will provide incident command system training to environmental and transportation personnel; stock nearby Langley Pond with at least 3,000 fish to replace fish killed by the chlorine spill; and post the telephone number for the National Response Center to facilitate spill reporting. Further, the settlement includes a supplemental environmental project (SEP) valued at $100,000 to plant vegetation along the banks of Horse Creek to decrease erosion and sedimentation, thereby improving water quality in Horse Creek.
On May 24, 2005, Norfolk Southern was awarded the TRANSCAER National Achievement Award for 2004. TRANSCAER is an acronym for Transportation Community Awareness and Emergency Response, which aims to promote emergency preparedness among first responders and communities for accidents that involve chemical releases. Part of the reasons for NS's selection for this award were the emergency preparedness training that the railroad held in 18 of the 22 states through which the railroad hauls hazardous materials.
Texas folk artist Doug Burr memorialized the Graniteville accident in his song "Graniteville" in his 2007 released album On Promenade. The song is fictionalized account of a husband attempting to rouse his wife from sleep to escape the dangers of the chemical spill.
- Jamison, Robert D.; Department of Transportation, Federal Railroad Administration (January 10, 2005). "Notice of safety advisory 2005-01; Position of switches in non-signaled territory" (PDF). Retrieved February 1, 2005.
- Jacob Jordan (April 21, 2005). "Graniteville man's death blamed on chlorine train wreck". Associated Press. Kalmbach Publishing. Archived from the original on August 17, 2014. Retrieved May 4, 2005.
- "Norfolk Southern estimates Graniteville derailment costs". Trains News Wire. Kalmbach Publishing. Retrieved January 27, 2005.[dead link]
- Jordan, Jacob (May 25, 2005). "Lawyers for Railroad, S.C. Town Seek Deal". Associated Press (The Washington Post). Retrieved May 25, 2005.[dead link]
- DuPlessis, Jim. "Graniteville train wreck Rust ruined Avondale plant Damage had a big role in mill closures". [volume & issue needed]
- AccessNorthGa.com (2013). "Avondale settles with insurance company for train wreck damages". AccessNorthGa.com. Retrieved July 31, 2013.
- United States National Transportation Safety Board (November 29, 2005). "Report of Railroad Accident: Collision of Norfolk Southern Freight Train 192 with Standing Norfolk Southern Local Train P22 With Subsequent Hazardous Materials Release. Graniteville, South Carolina; January 6, 2005. NTSB/RAR-05/04". Archived from the original on May 14, 2011. Retrieved November 29, 2005.
- "Switch Safety Guidelines Issued to Railroad Industry to Prevent Train Accidents Caused by Misaligned Switches" (Press release). United States Federal Railroad Administration. January 11, 2005. Archived from the original on July 21, 2011. Retrieved September 27, 2006.
- "Trial begins for SC textile firm suing railroad after train wreck". Worcester Telegram & Gazette. Associated Press. March 10, 2008. Archived from the original on July 19, 2014. Retrieved March 10, 2008.
- "Norfolk Southern To Settle Claims From Graniteville Accident". TradingMarkets.com. Retrieved April 24, 2008.
- "Norfolk Southern Reaches Agreement With Avondale Mills to Settle Claims From Graniteville Accident". Norfolk Southern. Archived from the original on July 23, 2011. Retrieved April 24, 2008.
- Dow Jones Newswires (April 24, 2008). "Norfolk Southern 'Disappointed' In DOJ Graniteville Suit". CNNMoney. Retrieved April 25, 2008.[dead link]
- "Railroad accused of polluting water in South Carolina wreck". Houston Chronicle. Associated Press. April 24, 2008. Retrieved April 25, 2008.[dead link]
- Putzier, Damon (April 24, 2008). "Federal Prosecutors Say Norfolk Southern Should Be Fined For Graniteville Pollution Prosecutors say the train wreck spilled chlorine and diesel fuel into the waterways, near Graniteville, violating the Clean Water Act". WJBF. Archived from the original on July 19, 2014. Retrieved April 24, 2008.
- "03/08/2010: Railroad Company to Pay $4 Million Penalty for 2005 Chlorine Spill in Graniteville, SC". Yosemite.epa.gov. Archived from the original on June 8, 2011. Retrieved January 1, 2014.
- "Norfolk Southern Corporation Receives 2004 TRANSCAER National Achievement Award" (Press release). American Chemistry Council (reprinted by Norfolk Southern). May 24, 2005. Archived from the original on July 19, 2014. Retrieved May 26, 2005.
- NTSB Railroad Accident Report NTSB/RAR-05/04 PB2005-916304
- FRA Accident Investigation Report HQ-2005-02