|First appearance||"Buck the System"
|Last appearance||"Remember the Monsters?"
|Portrayed by||Yvonne Strahovski|
Hannah McKay was a fifteen-year-old from Clopton, Alabama when her boyfriend Wayne Randall commenced a three-state killing spree. She spent six years in juvenile detention after pleading guilty to being an accomplice. She claimed not to have actually committed any of the murders, and received immunity from prosecution after agreeing to testify against Randall.
She married an older man but poisoned him when he pressured her to have an abortion, although she later claims that she wanted to have the child. She inherited her gardening business from her mentor, whom she is later suspected of poisoning with aconitum.
When Randall decides to reveal where he buried the last of his victims, Miami Metro Homicide wants a DNA sample from her. Dexter is assigned to get the sample and is immediately taken with her, becoming uncharacteristically distracted in his work.
After Randall commits suicide, she assists in locating the remaining bodies. After uncovering the bodies of a couple Wayne killed, Dexter realizes Hannah’s story isn’t truthful. While on a date, Dexter takes Hannah to a closed Christmas-themed amusement park, where it turns out Dexter has a kill room set up. He prepares to kill Hannah, but cannot go through with it and releases her. They end up having sex in the kill room instead. They become a couple, and they both fall in love for the first time; he helps her by disposing of her abusive father, and she helps him realize that his "Dark Passenger" does not control his life.
When Sal Price, a true crime writer who has written a book about Wayne Randall, wants to write a sequel about her, she agrees to an interview. She admits to stabbing the woman at the hotel, and then poisons Price, who later collapses and dies in Dexter's apartment. Furious over Price's death, and knowing that Hannah had confessed to him, Dexter's adoptive sister Debra calls Hannah in for questioning. Debra has very little proof against Hannah and instead baits her with information about a miscarriage. Dexter later confronts Hannah at her home, telling her that Price's death was needless. Hannah is touched to learn that Dexter deleted Price's files. The two later sleep together.
Debra is convinced that Hannah has gotten away with killing Price, and asks Dexter to kill her; Dexter refuses. Debra warns Hannah that she will pay for what she has done. Hannah then spikes Debra's drinking water with Xanax, causing her to pass out while driving. When Dexter learns that Hannah has done, he reluctantly gives Debra evidence that Hannah killed Price, and Debra arrests her.
Dexter visits Hannah in prison. She admits she poisoned Debra because she tried to separate them, and he tells her he had to turn her in to protect his sister. Hannah assures Dexter that she won't tell his secret when she goes to trial. During Hannah's arraignment, Arlene slips her a substance that causes her to have a seizure. Hannah is taken to the hospital and escapes. Before disappearing, she leaves a black orchid on Dexter's doorstep.
While they are having lunch together, Dexter and Debra both feel as if they have been drugged; just before he passes out, Dexter sees Hannah standing over him. When he later regains consciousness, Dexter begins investigating Hannah, and finds that she has changed her name and married Miles Castner (Julian Sands), a wealthy businessman. Dexter goes to see Hannah, who says that she had wanted him to kill Castner, but changed her mind after realizing she is still in love with Dexter. Castner warns him to stay away from Hannah, and has him beaten up. Dexter goes to Castner's boat to protect Hannah, but finds that she has already killed him. The two of them dispose of the body, and promise to watch out for each other. They become a couple again, and make plans to flee to Argentina with Dexter's son Harrison.
Events transpire that put their plans in jeopardy, however: Hannah finds out that a private investigator and a federal marshal are looking to arrest her, and Dexter's latest intended victim, Oliver Saxon, threatens to come after his family. They book a flight, but it is delayed by a hurricane, and Dexter sends her and Harrison ahead on a bus to Jacksonville to keep them safe, planning to join them later to fly to Buenos Aires. The investigator follows Hannah onto the bus and tries to arrest her, but she gets the better of him by stabbing him with a hypodermic needle filled with a sedative, knocking him out so she and Harrison can escape. As she and Harrison board the plane to Argentina, Dexter calls and tells them both that he loves them; she is unaware that he is really saying goodbye, as he plans to fake his own death in order to keep them safe from him. In Argentina, she reads that Dexter's boat had crashed during the hurricane, and that he is presumed dead. She absorbs the news quietly, takes Harrison's hand, and walks with him to get ice cream.
- "Saturn Awards 2013 winners list: 'Avengers,' 'Breaking Bad' lead the pack". Zap2it. June 27, 2013. Retrieved November 26, 2013.