Heterocyclic amine formation in meat
Heterocyclic amines are a group of 20 chemical compounds formed during cooking. They are found in meats that are cooked to the well done stage, in pan drippings, and in meat surfaces that show a crispy brown crust. Epidemiological studies show associations between intakes of heterocyclic amines and cancers of the colon, rectum, breast, prostate, pancreas, lung, stomach, and esophagus, and animal feeding experiments support a causal relationship. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Public Health Service labeled several heterocyclic amines as likely to be carcinogenic to humans in its most recent Report on Carcinogens. Changes in cooking techniques have been shown to reduce the level of heterocyclic amines in meat.
Heterocyclic amines, meat, and cancer
After scientists discovered the carcinogenic components in cigarette smoke, they questioned whether carcinogens could also be found in foods that were smoked or burned, such as meats. In 1977, cancer-causing compounds, now known to be heterocyclic amine, were discovered in food as a result of normal household cooking processes. A total of 20 compounds fall into the category of heterocyclic amines, often abbreviated HCAs. Table 1 shows the chemical name and abbreviation of those most commonly studied.
|Chemical name||Abbreviation||Year discovered|
The compounds found in food are formed when creatine (a non-protein amino acid found in muscle tissue), other amino acids, and monosaccharides are heated together at high temperatures (125-300o C or 275-572o F) or cooked for long periods of time. HCAs form at the lower end of this range when the cooking time is long; at the higher end of the range, HCAs are formed within minutes. The most potent of the HCAs, MeIQ, is almost 24 times more carcinogenic than aflatoxin, a carcinogen produced by mold.
Most of the 20 HCAs are more toxic than benzopyrene, a carcinogen found in cigarette smoke and coal tar. MeIQ, IQ, and 8-MeIQx have been reported as the most potent mutagens using the Ames test. These HCAs are 100 times more potent carcinogens than PhIP, the compound most commonly found as a result of normal cooking procedures.
HCAs in cooked ground beef
A review of 14 studies of HCA content in ground beef cooked under home conditions found in northern Europe and the U.S. found a range of values, shown in Table 2. Because a standard serving of meat in the U.S. is 3 ounces, Table 2 includes a projection of the maximum amount of HCAs that could be found in a ground beef patty.
|HCA||Amount, ng/g||Maximum amount in 3 ounces of ground beef (in ng)|
(n.d.= none detected)
Ground beef consumption in the U.S.
Meat is a major component of American diets. Disappearance data from 1960 show the combined annual consumption per person of beef, pork, and chicken at 148 pounds; in 2004, that amount increased to 195 pounds a year. Ground beef made up 42% of the market share for beef in 2000. Beef consumption, particularly ground and processed beef, is highest in households with incomes at or below 130 percent of the poverty level. Patterns of beef intake by race/ethnicity show that non-Hispanic whites and Asians consumed the least amount of beef. Non-Hispanic blacks had the highest beef consumption with the highest per capita intake of processed beef, ground beef, and steaks compared to three other race/ethnicity groups. More than half of beef purchased in the U.S. comes from retail stores and is prepared at home. Ground beef makes up the highest per capita intakes of beef both at home and away from home. Ground beef consumption is highest among males age 12-19 who consume on average 50 pounds per year per person. The 12-19 age group showed the highest consumption of ground beef for females, but the amount (28.5 lbs) is much lower compared to that of males.
Formation of HCAs during cooking
HCA formation during cooking depends on the type of meat, the temperature of the cooking surface, the degree of browning, and the length of cooking time. Meats that are lower in fat and water content show higher concentrations of HCAs after cooking. More HCAs are formed when pan surface temperatures are higher than 220oC (428oF) such as with most frying or grilling. However, HCAs also form at lower temperatures when the cooking time is long, as in roasting. HCA concentrations are higher in browned or burned crusts that results from high cooking temperatures. The pan drippings and meat bits that remain after meat is fried have high concentrations of HCAs. Beef, chicken, and fish have higher concentrations than pork. Sausages are high in fat and water and show lower concentrations of HCA after cooking.
Ground beef patties show lower levels of HCAs if they are flipped every minute until the endpoint temperature is reached. Beef patties cooked from the frozen state show no difference in HCA levels compared to room-temperature patties.
Human exposure to HCAs
Dietary exposure to HCAs has been estimated at 1-17 ng/kg bodyweight per day. Table 3 shows the average daily lifetime consumption of HCAs for subgroups of the U.S. population. This analysis was based on the food intake data of 27215 people participating in the 1994 to 1996 Continuing Survey of Food Intakes by Individuals (CSFII) survey. Approximately 16 percent of HCA exposure came from hamburgers.
|HCA type||Lifetime average intake - All, ng/day||Lifetime average intake - All men, ng/kg/day|
African American males had 50-100% higher intakes than white males, and African American boys consumed three times as many HCAs as white males (Table 4).
|HCA type||White||African American||Asian/Pacific Islander|
HCAs and cancer risk
HCAs contribute to the development of cancer by causing mutations in genes, causing new cells to grow in an uncontrolled manner and form a tumor. Epidemiological studies have linked consumption of well-done meats with an increased risk of certain cancers, including cancer of the colon or rectum. Scientists who analyzed all research articles on the topic of meat consumption and colon cancer, estimated that red meat consumption contributed to 7 to 9% of colon cancer cases in European men and women.
Long-terms studies of rats showed that PhIP causes cancer of the colon and mammary gland in rats. Female rats given doses of 0, 12.4, 25, 50, 100, or 200 ppm of PhIP in their feed showed a dose-dependent incidence of adenocarcinomas. The offspring of female rats who were exposed to PhIP while pregnant had a higher prevalence of adenocarcinomas than offspring of rats who had not been exposed. This was true even for the offspring that were not exposed to any PhIP themselves. PhIP was also found to be transferred mothers to offspring in their milk.
The effects of HCAs and well-done cooked meat on humans are less well established. Meat consumption, especially of well-done meat and meat cooked at a high temperature is often used as an indirect measure of exposure to HCAs. A review was made of all research studies reported between 1996 and 2007 that examined relationships between HCAs, meat, and cancer. Twenty-two studies were found; of these, 18 showed a relationship between either meat intake or HCA exposure and some form of cancer. HCA exposure was measured in 10 of the studies, and of those, 70% showed an association with cancer. The authors concluded that a high intake of well-done meat and/or high exposure to certain HCAs may be associated with cancer of the colon, breast, prostate, pancreas, lung, stomach, and esophagus.
A recent study found that the relative risk for colorectal cancer was increased at intakes >41.4 ng/day. There was some evidence of increased relative risk with intakes of MeIQx greater than or equal to 19.9 ng/day, but the trend was not as strong as for PhIP.
Recent studies have had mixed results, finding no relationship between dietary heterocyclic amines and lung cancer in women who had never smoked, no relationship between HCA intake and prostate cancer risk, but suggesting a positive association between red meat, PhIP, and bladder cancer, and increased risk of advanced prostate cancer with intakes of meat cooked at high temperatures.
Although not all research studies report an association between HCA and/or meat intake and cancers, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Public Health Service National Toxicology Program found sufficient evidence to label four HCAs as "reasonably anticipated to be a human carcinogen" in its twelfth Report on Carcinogens, published in 2011. The HCA known as IQ was first listed in the tenth report in 2002. MeIQ, MeIQx, and PhIP were added to the list of anticipated carcinogens in 2004. The Report on Carcinogens states that MeIQ has been associated with rectal and colon cancer, MeIQx with lung cancer, IQ with breast cancer, and PhIP with stomach and breast cancer. However, no current federal guidelines focus on the recommended consumption limit of HCA levels in meat.
Insufficient studies have been done to ascertain a cause and effect relationship. The attribution of individual HCAs on human illness is difficult to make because they do not occur individually in foods. Other elements of the diet, such as fat or carbohydrate intake may enhance or reduce the effects of HCAs in the human body.
- Sugimura,T.(1997). Overview of carcinogenic heterocyclic amines. Mutation Research, 376, 211-219.
- Norat T, Lukanova A, Ferrari P, Riboli E. (2002). Meat consumption and colorectal cancer risk: dose-response meta-analysis of epidemiological studies. International Journal of Cancer, 98, 241-256.
- Skog KI, Johansson AE, Jagerstad MI. (1998) Carcinogenic heterocyclic amines in model systems and cooked foods: A review on formation, occurrence, and intake. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 36,879-896.
- Turesky, RJ. (2007). Formation and biochemistry of carcinogenic heterocyclic aromatic amines in cooked meats. Toxicology Letters, 168, 219-227.
- Nobuyuki I, Hasegawa R, Imaidi K, Tamano S, Hagiwara A, Hirose M, Shirai T. (1997). Carcinogenicity of 2-amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP) in the rat. Mutation Research, 376, 107-114.
- Davis CG, Lin B. (2005). Factors affecting U.S. beef consumption. USDA report LDP-M-135-02.
- Skog KI, Johansson AE, Jagerstad MI. (1998). Carcinogenic heterocyclic amines in model systems and cooked foods: A review on formation, occurrence and intake. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 36, 879-896.
- Augustsson K, Lindblad J, Overik E, Steineck G. (1999). A population-based dietary inventory of cooked meat and assessment of the daily intake of food mutagens. Food Additives and Contaminants, 16, 215-225.
- Knize, MG, Felton JS. (2005). Formation and human risk of carcinogenic heterocyclic amines formed from natural precursors in meat. Nutrition Reviews, 63, 158-165.
- Persson E, Oroszvari BK, Tornberg E, Sjoholm I, Skog K. (2008). Heterocyclic amine formation during frying of frozen beefburgers. International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 43, 62-68.
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Public Health Service, National Toxicology Program. (2011). Report on Carcinogens, 12th ed.
- Bogen KT, Keating GA. (2001). U.S. dietary exposures to heterocyclic amines. Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology, 11, 155-168.
- Weisburger, J.H. (2002). Comments on the history and importance of aromatic and heterocyclic amines in public health. Mutation Research, 506-507, 9-20.
- Zheng, W., Lee, S. (2009). Well-done meat intake, heterocyclic amine exposure, and cancer risk. Nutrition and Cancer, 61, 437-446.
- Rohrmann S, Hermann S, Linseisen J. (2009). Heterocyclic aromatic amine intake increases colorectal adenoma risk: finding from a prospective European cohort study. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 89, 1418-24.
- Lim W, Khoon LC, Eng P, Leong SS, Lim E, Lim TK, Ng A, Poh WT, Tee A, Salim A, Seow A. (2011). Meat consumption and risk of lung cancer among never-smoking women. Nutrition and Cancer, 63, 850-859.
- Sander A, Linsesen J, Rohrmann S. (2011). Intake of heterocyclic aromatic amines and the risk of prostate cancer in the EPIC-Heidelberg cohort. Cancer Causes Control, 22, 109-114.
- Ferrucci LM, Sinha R, Ward MH, Graubard BI, Hollenbeck AR, Kilfoy BA, Shatzkin A, Michaud DS, Cross AJ. (September 15, 2010). Meat and component of meat and the risk of bladder cancer in the NIH-AARP diet and health study. Cancer, doi:10.1002/cncr.25463
- John EM, Stern MC, Sinha R, Koo JK. (2011). Meat consumption, cooking practices, meat mutagens, and risk of prostate cancer. Nutrition and Cancer, 63, 525-537.
- National Cancer Institute. "Chemicalsin Meat Cooked at High Temperatures". Retrieved 2011-11-15.