History of Roman-era Tunisia
||It has been suggested that this article be merged into Africa (Roman province). (Discuss) Proposed since November 2013.|
Part of a series on the
|History of Tunisia|
History of Roman-era Tunisia describes first the Roman Africa Province. Rome took control of Carthage after the Third Punic War (149-146). There was a period of Berber kings allied with Rome (see prior article). Lands surrounding Carthage were annexed and reorganized, and the city of Carthage rebuilt, becoming the third city of the Empire. A long period of prosperity ensued; a cosmopolitan culture evolved. Trade quickened, the fields yielded their fruits. Settlers from across the Empire migrated here, forming a Latin-speaking ethnic mix. Some Berbers rose in society, e.g., Apuleius, while other Berbers remained rural, unlettered, and poor. Several Emperors from Africa reigned. Christianity became strong, and included Augustine of Hippo; yet it was troubled by the Donatist schism. During the eclipse of the Roman Empire, several prominent Berbers revolted. A generation later the Vandals, a Germanic kingdom, arrived and reigned over the former Africa province for nearly a century. A series of Berbers regimes established self-rule at the periphery. The Byzantine Empire eventually recaptured from the Vandals its dominion in 534, which endured until the Islamic conquest, completed in 705. Then came the final undoing of ancient Carthage.
- 1 Roman Province of Africa
- 1.1 Renaissance and prosperity
- 1.2 Latin culture and the Berbers
- 1.3 Emperors from Africa
- 1.4 Christianity, and its schism
- 1.5 Berber revolts
- 2 Post-Roman successors
- 3 See also
- 4 Reference notes
Roman Province of Africa
Following the defeat of Carthage in the Third Punic War (149-146), the Roman Republic annexed the city and its vicinity, including rich and developed agricultural lands; their long-time Berber ally Massinissa had died shortly before the fall of the city.
Adjacent lands to the west were allocated to their Berber allies, who continued to enjoy recognition as independent Berber kingdoms. At first the old city Utica, north of ruined Carthage, served as provincial capital; yet Carthage was rebuilt eventually.
Africa Province then came to encompass the northern half of modern Tunisia, an adjacent region of Algeria (i.e., all of ancient Numidia), plus coastal regions stretching about 400 km to the east (into modern Libya), known then as Tripolitania.
People from all over the Empire migrated into the Roman Africa Province, most importantly merchants, traders, and mainly veterans in early retirement who settled in Africa on farming plots promised for their military service. Historians like Theodore Mommsen estimated that under Hadrian nearly 1/3 of the eastern Numidia population (roughly modern Tunisia) was descended from Roman veterans.
Renaissance and prosperity
City of Carthage
The rise of the city of Carthage from the ashes began under Julius Caesar (100-44 BC) and continued under Augustus (63 BC - 14 AD), notwithstanding reported ill omens. It became the new capital of Africa Province. Resident in the city was a Roman praetor or proconsul. Carthage as the urban center of the Roman Africa not only recovered, but flourished, especially during the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd centuries. Yet only about one sixth of the population could participate fully in the culture of city life, as "the other five sixths lived in a poverty that was at times terribly hard to bear and almost impossible to escape." Nonetheless, public buildings and spaces, such as the thermal baths, were available. "For a pittance, a poor man could surround himself with splendid marble halls, the finest art and the most pleasant of atmospheres."
As the city expanded, the building industry drew on local materials, on marble and various woods. Africa Province became known for fine mosaics, of both decorative and representational designs, crafted by its artisans. Found within Carthage and also in villas of the countryside, many large mosaics formed the floors of courtyards and patios. Beyond the city, many pre-existing Punic and Berber towns found fresh vigor and prosperity. Many new settlements were founded, especially in the rich and fertile Bagradas (modern Medjerda)river valley, north and northwest of Carthage. An aqueduct about 120 km. in length, built by the Emperor Hadrian (r.117-138), travels from a sanctuary high up Jbel Zaghouan overland about 70 km. to ancient Carthage. It was repaired and put into use during the 13th century, and again in modern times.
Carthage, and other cities in Roman Africa, contain the ruins or the remains of large structures dedicated to popular spectacles. The urban games performed there included the infamous blood sports, with gladiators who fought wild beasts or each other for the whim of the crowd. The Telegenii was one of the gladiator associations of the region. Although often of humble origins, a handsome, surviving gladiator might be "considered someone worthy of adulation by the young ladies of the audience."
Another city entertainment was the theater. The renowned Greek tragedies and comedies were staged, as well as contemporary Roman plays. Burlesque performances by mimes were popular. Much more costly and less vulgar were productions featuring pantomimes. The African writer Apuleius (c.125-c.185) describes attending such a performance which he found impressive and delightful. An ancient epitaph here celebrates Vincentius, a popular pantomime (quoted in part):
He lives forever in the thoughts of the people... just, good and in his every relationship with each person irreproachable and sure. There was never a day when, during his dancing of the famous pieces, the whole theater was not captivated enough to reach the stars."
Peace and prosperity came to Carthage and Africa Province. Eventually Roman security forces began to be drawn from the local population. Here the Romans governed well enough that the Province became integrated into the economy and culture of the Empire, attracting immigrants. Its cosmopolitan, Latinizing, and diverse population enjoyed a reputation for its high standard of living. Carthage emerged near the top of major Imperial cities, behind only Alexandria and Rome.
Rome "held fast" the lands of Carthage after its fall (146 BCE), yet did so initially out of a "perversity" engendered by war, i.e., less to develop the harvest and benefit themselves, than to keep others off. Many Punic survivors of the defeated city, including owners of olive groves, vineyards, and farms, had "fled into the hinterland".
Public lands (ager publicus) passed to Rome by right of conquest, and many privately held lands also, those ruined or differently abandoned, or that had unpaid taxes, or otherwise. Some rural lands good for agriculture, which had been used up to then only seasonally by Berber pastoralists, were also taken and distributed for planting. Accordingly many nomads (and small farmers, too) "were reduced to abject poverty or driven into the steppes and desert." Tacfarinas led a sustained Berber insurgency (17-24) against Rome; yet these rural tribal forces eventually met defeat. Thereafter the expansion of farming operations over the provincial lands did produce a higher yield. Yet Rome "never succeeded in keeping the nomads of the south and west permanently in check."
Great estates were formed by investors or the politically favored, or by emperors out of confiscated lands. Called latifundia, their farming operations were leased out to coloni often from Italia, who settled around the owner's 'main house'--thus forming a small agrarian town. The land was divided into "squares measuring 710 meters across". Many small farms were thus held by incoming Roman citizens or army veterans (the pagi), as well as by the prior owners, Punic and Berber. The quality and extend of large villas with comfort amenities, and other farm housing, found throughout Africa Province dating to this era, evidence the wealth generated by agriculture. Working the land for its fruits was very rewarding.
Rich agricultural lands led the province to great prosperity. New hydraulic works increased the extend and intensity of the irrigation. Olives and grapes had for long been popular products commonly praised; however, the vineyards and orchards had been devastated during the last Punic war; also they were intentionally left to ruin because their produce competed with that of Roman Italia. Instead Africa Province acquired fame as the source of large quantities of fine wheat, widely exported—though chiefly to Rome. The ancient writers Strabo (64 BC-c. 21 AD), Pliny (23-c. 79 AD), and Josephus (37-c. 95 AD) praised the quality of African wheat. The Baradas river valley was acclaimed as productive as the Nile. Later, when Egypt began to supplant Africa Province as the supplier of wheat to Rome, the grape and the olive began reappearing again in the fields of the province, toward the end of the 1st century. St. Augustine (354-430) wrote that in Africa lamps fueled by olive oil burned well throughout the night, throwing light over the neighborhoods.
Evidence, from artifacts and the often large mosaics of great villas, indicates that one favorite sport of the agrarian elite was the hunt. Depicted are well-dressed sportsmen (in embroidered riding tunics with striped sleeves). Mounted on horseback they go cross-country in pursuit of illustrated game—here perhaps a jackal. Various wild birds are also shown as desired prey, to be gotten with traps. On the floor of a patio, a greyhound appears to be chasing a hare across the surface of its mosaic.
Commerce and trade
Ceramics and pottery, skills developed and practiced for many centuries under the prior Phoenician-derived, urban culture, continued as an important industry, Both oil lamps and amphorae (containers with two handles) were produced in quantity. This pottery, of course, complemented the local production of olive oil, the amphorae being valuable not only as hard goods, but also useful for oil transportation locally and for export by ship. Numerous ancient oil presses have been found, producing from the harvested olive both oils for cooking and food, and oils for burning in lamps. Ceramics were also crafted into various statuettes of animals, humans, and gods, found in abundance in regional cemeteries of the period. Later, terra-cotta plaques showing biblical scenes were designed and made for the churches. Much of this industry was located in central Tunisia, e.g., in and around Thysdrus (modern El Djem), a drier area with less fertile agricultural lands, but ample in rich clay deposits.
The export of large amounts of wheat, and later of olive oils, and wines, required port facilities, indicated are (among others): Hippo Regius (modern Annaba), Hippo Diarrhytus (modern Bizerte), Utica, Carthage, Curubis (north of modern Nabeul), Missis, Hadrumentum, Gummi and Sullectum (both near modern Mahdia), Gightis (near Djerba isle), and Sabratha (near modern Tarabulus [Tripoli]). Marble and wood was shipped out of Thabraca (modern Tabarka). Ancient associations engaged in export shipping might form navicularii, collectively responsible for the commodities yet granted state privileges. Inland trade was carried on Roman roads, built both for the Roman legions and for commercial and private use. A major road led from Carthage southwest to Theveste (modern Tébessa) in the mountains; from there a road led southeast to Tacapes (modern Gabès) on the coast. Roads also followed the coastline. Buildings were erected occasionally along such highways for the convenience of traders with goods and other travelers.
Other products of Africa Province were shipped out. An ancient industry at Carthage involved cooking up a Mediterranean condiment called garum, a fish sauce made with herbs, an item of durable popularity. Rugs and wool clothing were fabricated, and leather goods. The royal purple dye, murex, first discovered and made famous by the Phoenicians, was locally produced. Marble and wood, as well as live mules, were also important export items.
Local trade and commerce was conducted at mundinae (fairs) in rural centers at set days of the week, much as it is today in souks. In villages and towns macella (provision markets) were established. In cities granted a charter the market was regulated by the municipal aediles (Roman market officials dating to the Roman Republic), who inspected the vendor's instruments for measuring and weighing. City trading was often done at the forum, or at stalls in covered areas, or at private shops.
Expeditions ventured south into the Sahara. Cornelius Balbus, Roman governor then at Utica, occupied in 19 BC. Gerama, desert capital of the Garamantes in the Fezzan (now west-central Libya). These Berber Garamantes had long-term, though unpredictable, breakable, contacts with the Mediterranean. Although Roman trade and other contact with the Berber Fezzan continued, on and off, raid or trade, extensive commercial traffic across the Sahara, directly to the more productive and populous lands south of the harsh deserts, had not yet developed; nor would it for many centuries.
A personal example illustrates the depth and scope of social integration in the Empire, as the imperial Roman culture reached out to people living far from the capital, to those born in a provincial city of no great importance. From 2nd-century Roman Africa came the lawyer Julian, who enjoyed an extraordinary career.
Julian's life demonstrates the opportunities available to gifted provincials. Also it gives a view of Roman Law, whose workings crafted much of the structure holding together the various nationalities across the Empire. Apparently Julian came from a family of the Latin culture which had gradually become established in Africa Province, although his youth and early career are not recorded.
Salvius Julianus (c.100-c.170), Roman jurist, Consul in 148, was a native of Hadrumetum (modern Sousse, Tunisia) on the east coast of Africa province. He was a teacher; one of his students, Africanus, was the last recorded head of the influential Sabinian school of Roman jurists. In Roman public life, Julian eventually came to hold several high positions during a long career. He acquired great contemporary respect as a jurist, and modernly is regarded as one of the best in Roman legal history. "The task of his life consisted, in the first place, in the final consolidation of the edictal law; and, secondly, in the composition of his great Digest in ninety books."
Julian served the Empire at its top echelon, on the Counsilium (imperial council) of three emperors: Hadrian (r. 117-138), Antonius Pius (r. 138-161), and Marcus Aurelius (r.161-180). His life spanned a particularly beneficial era of Roman rule, when relative peace and prosperity reigned. Julian had been tribune; he "held all the important senatorial offices from Quaestor to Consul". Later, after his service on the emperor's Counsilium, he left for Germania Inferior to become its Roman governor. He served in the same capacity at Hispania Citerior. At the end of his career, Julian became the Roman governor of his native Africa Province. An inscription found near his native Hadrumetum (modern Sousse, Tunisia) recounts his official life.
The emperor Hadrian appointed Julian, this native of a small city in Africa province, to revise the Praetor's Edict (thereafter called the Edictum perpetuum). This key legal document, then issued annually at Rome by the Praetor urbanus, was at that time a most persuasive legal authority, pervasive in Roman Law. "The Edict, that masterpiece of republican jurisprudence, became stabilized. ... [T]he famous jurist Julian settled the final form of the praetorian and aedilician Edicts."
Later Julian authored his Digesta in 90 books; this work generally followed the sequence of subjects found in the praetorian edict, and presented a "comprehensive collection of responsa on real and hypothetical cases". The purpose of his Digesta was to expound the whole of Roman Law.
In the 6th century, this 2nd-century Digesta of Salvius Julianus was repeatedly excerpted, hundreds of times, by the compilers of the Pandectae, created under the authority of the Byzantine emperor Justinian I (r. 527-265). This Pandect (also known as the Digest, part of the Corpus Juris Civilis) was a compendium of juristic experience and learning. "It has been thought that Justinian's compilers used [Julian's Digesta] as the basis of their scheme: in any case nearly 500 passages are quoted from it." The Pandect, in addition to its official rôle as part of the controlling law of the eastern Roman (Byzantine) Empire, also became a principal source for the medieval study of Roman Law in western Europe.
About Julian's personal life little is known. Apparently he became related in some way (probably through his daughter) to the family of the Roman emperor Didius Julianus, who reigned during the year 93.
Julian died probably in Africa province, as its Roman governor or shortly thereafter. This was during the reign of the philosophical emperor Marcus Aurelius (r.161-180), who described Julian in a rescript as amicus noster (Latin: "our friend"). "His fame did not lessen as time went on, for later Emperors speak of him in the most laudatory terms. ... Justinian [6th century] speaks of him as the most illustrious of the jurists." "With Iulianus, the Roman jurisprudence reached its apogee."
Latin culture and the Berbers
People from all over the Empire began to migrate into Africa Province, merchants, traders, officials, most importantly veterans in early retirement who settled in Africa on farming plots promised for their military service. A sizable Latin speaking population developed that was multinational in background; they shared the region with those speaking Punic and Berber languages. Usually the business of the empire was conducted in Latin, so that a markedly bi- or tri-lingual situation developed. Imperial security forces began to be drawn from the local population, including the Berbers. The Romans apparently sounded the right notes, which facilitated general acceptance of their rule.
"What made the Berbers accept the Roman way of life all the more readily was that the Romans, though a colonizing people who captured their lands by the might of their arms, did not display any racial exclusiveness and were remarkably tolerant of Berber religious cults, be they indigenous or grafted from the Carthaginians. However, the Roman territory in Africa was unevenly penetrated by Roman culture. Pockets of non-Romanized Berbers continued to exist throughout the Roman period, even in such areas as eastern Tunisia and Numidia."
That the majority of the Berbers adjusted to the Roman world, of course, does not signify their full acceptance. Often the presence of cosmopolitan cultural symbols coexisted with the traditional local customs and beliefs, i.e., the Roman did not supplant the Berber, but merely augmented the prior Berber culture, often the Roman being on a more transient level of adherence.
Lucius Apuleius (c.125-c.185), a Berber author of Africa Province, wrote using an innovative Latin style. Although often called Lucius Apuleius, only the name Apuleius is certain. He managed to thrive in several Latin-speaking communities of Carthage: the professional, the literary, and the pagan religious. A self-described full Berber, "half Numidian, half Gaetulian", his origins lay on the upper Bagradas (modern Medjerda) river valley, in Madaura (modern M'Daourouch). In the town lived many retired Roman soldiers, often themselves natives of Africa. His father was a provincial magistrate, of the upper ordo class. When he was still young his father died, leaving a relative fortune to him and his brother.
His studies began at Carthage, and continued during years spent at Athens (philosophy) and at Rome (oratory), where he evidently served as a legal advocate. Comparing learning to fine wine but with an opposite effect, Apuleius wrote, "The more you drink and the stronger the draught, the better it is for the good of your soul." He also traveled to Asia Minor and Egypt. While returning to Carthage he fell seriously ill in Oea (an ancient coastal city near modern Tripoli), where he convalesced at the family home of an old student friend Pontianus. Eventually Apuleius married Prudentilla, the older, wealthy widow of the house, and mother of Pontianus. Evidently the marriage was good; Sidonius Apollinaris called Prudentilla one of those "noble women [who] held the lamp while their husbands read and meditated." Yet debauched and greedy in-laws (this characterization by Apuleius) wantonly claimed he had murdered Pontianus; they did, however, prosecute Apuleius for using nefarius magic to gain his new wife's affections. At the trial in nearby Sabratha the Roman proconsul Claudius Maximus presided. Apuleius, then in his thirties, crafted a trial speech in his own defense, which in written form makes his Apology; apparently he was acquitted. A well-regarded modern critic characterizes his oratory, as it appears in his Apologia:
"We feel throughout the speech a keen pleasure in the display of superior sophistication and culture. We can see how he might well have dazzled the rich citizens of Oea for a while and how he would also soon arouse deep suspicions and hostilities. Particularly one feels that he is of a divided mind about the accusation of wizardry. He deals with the actual charges in tones of amused contempt, yet seems not averse from being considered one of the great magicians of the world."
Apuleius and Prudentilla then moved to Carthage. There he continued his Latin writing, dealing with Greek philosophy, with oratory and rhetoric, and also fiction and poetry. Attracting a significant following, several civic statues were erected in his honor. He showed brilliance speaking in public as a "popular philosopher or 'sophist', characteristic of the second century A.D., which ranked such talkers higher than poets and rewarded them greatly with esteem and cash... ." "He was novelist and 'sophist', lawyer and lecturer, poet and initiate. It is not surprising that he was accused of magic--".
His celebrated work of fiction is Metamorphoses, by moderns commonly called The Golden Ass. A well-known work, Apuleius here created an urbane, inventive, vulgar, extravagant, mythic story, a sort of fable of the ancient world. The plot unfolds in Greece where the hero, while experimenting with the ointment of a sorceress, is changed not into an owl (as intended) but into a donkey. Thereafter his ability to speak leaves him, but he remains able to understand the talk of others. In a famous digression (one of many), the celebrated folktale of Cupid and Psyche is artfully told by a crone. Therein Cupid, son of the Roman goddess Venus, falls in love with a beautiful but mortal girl, who because of her loveliness has been jinxed by Cupid's mother; the god Jupiter resolves their dilemma. The hero as donkey listens as the story is told. After such and many adventures, in which he finds comedy, cruelty, onerous work as a beast-of-burden, circus-like exhibition, danger, and a love companion, the hero finally manages to regain his human form—by eating roses. Isis, the Egyptian goddess, in answer to his petitions, directs her priests during a procession to feed the flowers to him. "At once my ugly and beastly form left me. My rugged hair thinned and fell; my huge belly sank in; my hooves separated out into fingers and toes; my hands ceased to be feet... and my tail... simply disappeared." In the last few pages, the hero continues to follow the procession, entering by initiations into the religious service of Isis and Osiris of the Egyptian pantheon.
Metamorphoses is compared by Jack Lindsay to two other ancient works of fiction: Satyricon by Petronius and Daphnis and Chloe by Longus. He also notes that at the end of Metamorphoses "we find the only full testimony of religious experience left by an adherent of ancient paganism... devotees of mystery-cults, of the cults of the savior-gods... ." H. J. Rose comments that "the story is meant to convey a religious lesson: Isis saves [the hero] from the vanities of this world, which make men of no more worth than beasts, to a life of blissful service, here and hereafter." About Apuleius's novel Michael Grant suggests that "the ecstatic belief in mystery religions [here, Isis] marked, in some sense, the transition between state-paganism and Christiantiy." Yet later he notes that "the Christian Fathers, after long discussion, were disposed to let Apuleius fall from favour."
St. Augustine mentions his fellow African Apuleius in his The City of God. When Apuleius lived was an age, Augustine elsewhere decries, of damnabilis curiositas. In discussing Socrates and Plato on 'the souls of gods, airy spirits, and humans,' Augustine refers to "a Platonist of Madaura", Apuleius, and to his work De Deo Socratis [The God of Socrates]. Augustine, holding the view that the world was under the lordship of the devil, challenged the pagans their reverence for particular gods. Referring to what he found as moral confusion or worse in stories of these gods, and their airy spirits, Augustine suggests a better title for Apuleius' book: "he should have called it De Daemone Socratis, of his devil."
That Apuleius worked magic was widely accepted by many of his contemporaries; he was sometimes compared to Apollonius of Tyana (died c.97), a magician (whom some pagans later claimed as a miracle-worker, equal to Christ). Apuleius himself was drawn to mystery religions, particularly the cult of Isis. "He held the office of sacerdos prouinciae at Carthage." "In any event Apuleius became for the Christians a most controversial figure."
Apuleius used a Latin style that registered as elocutio novella ("new speech") to his literary contemporaries. This style expressed the every day language used by the educated, along with naturally embedded archaisms. It worked to transform the more formal, classical grammar once favored since Cicero (106-43 BC). To rhetoricians perhaps it would be asiatic as opposed to attic style. Also new speech pointed toward the future development of modern Romance languages. Some suggest a style source in Africa, "owing its rich colours to the Punic element... his Madauran origins"; yet, while calling Africa informative, Lindsay declares it insufficient:
"[W]e cannot reduce his style as a whole to African influences. His mixture of ornate invention and rhetorical ingenuity with archaic and colloquial forms marks him rather as a man of his epoch, in which the classical heritage is being transformed by a welter of new forces."
Phrases like "oppido formido" [I greatly fear] litter his pages. Apuleius' "prose is a mosaic of internal rhymes and assonances. Alliteration is frequent." One who involutarilly remains alive after a loved one's death is "invita remansit in vita". "This may seem an over-nice analysis of a verbal trick; but Apuleius' creative energy resides precisely in this sort of thing--".
The success of the Berber Apuleius, however, may be regarded as more an exception than the rule. Evidently many native Berbers adopted to the Mediterranean-wide influences operating in the province, eventually intermarrying, or otherwise entering the front ranks as notables. Yet the majority did not. There remained a social hierarchy consisting of the Romanized, the partly assimilated, and the unassimilated (here were the many rural Berbers who did not know Latin). Yet in this schema considered among the "assimilated" might be very poor immigrants from other regions of the Empire. These imperial distinctions overlay the preexisting stratification of economic classes, e.g., there continued the practice of slavery, and there remained a coopted remnant of the wealthy Punic aristocracy.
The stepped-up pace and economic demands of a cosmopolitan urban life could impact very negatively on the welfare of the rural poor. Large estates (latifundia) that produced cash crops for export often were managed for absentee owners and used slave labor. These 'agrobusiness' operations occupied lands previously tilled by small local farmers. At another social interface met the fundamental disagreement and social tensions between pastoral nomads, who had their herds to graze, and sedentary farmers. The best lands were usually appropriated for planting, often going to the better-connected socially, politically. These economic and status divisions would become manifest from time to time in various ways, e.g., the collateral revolt in 238, and the radical, quasi-ethnic edge to the Donatist schism.
Emperors from Africa
Septimius Severus (145-211, r.193-211) was born of mixed Punic Ancestry in Lepcis Magna, Tripolitania (now Libya), where he spent his youth. Although he was said to speak with a North African accent, he and his family were long members of the Roman cosmopolitan elite. His eighteen-year reign was noted for frontier military campaigns. His wife Julia Domna of Emesa, Syria, was from a prominent family of priestly rulers there; as empress in Rome she cultivated a salon which may have included Ulpian of Tyre, the renowned jurist of Roman Law.
After Severus (whose reign was well regarded), his son Caracalla (r.211-217) became Emperor; Caracalla's edict of 212 granted citizenship to all free inhabitants of the Empire. Later, two grand nephews of Severus through his wife Julia Domna became Emperors: Elagabalus (r.218-222) who brought the black stone of Emesa to Rome; and Severus Alexander (r.222-235) born in Caesarea sub Libano (Lebanon). Though unrelated, the Emperor Macrinus (r.217-218) came from Iol Caesarea in Mauretania (modern Sharshal, Algeria).
The Gordiani dynasty
There were also Roman Emperors from the Province of Africa. In 238 local proprietors rose in revolt, arming their clients and agricultural tenants who entered Thysdrus (modern El Djem) where they killed their target, a rapacious official and his bodyguards. In open revolt, they then proclaimed as co-emperors the aged Governor of the Province of Africa, Gordian I (c.159-238), and his son, Gordian II (192-238). Gordian I had served at Rome in the Senate and as Consul, and had been the Governor of various provinces. The very unpopular current Emperor Maximinus Thrax (who had succeeded the dynasty of Severus) was campaigning on the middle Danube. In Rome the Senate sided with the insurgents of Thysdrus. When the African revolt collapsed under an assault by local forces still loyal to the emperor, the Senate elected two of their number, Balbinus and Pupienus, as co-emperors. Then Maximus Thrax was killed by his disaffected soldiers. Eventually the grandson of Gordian I, Gordian III (225-244), of the Province of Africa, became the Emperor of the Romans, 238-244. He died on the Persian frontier. His successor was Philip the Arab.
Christianity, and its schism
Felicitas & Perpetua
The Roman Imperial cult was based on a general polytheism that, by combining veneration for the paterfamilias and for the ancestor, developed a public celebration of the reigning Emperor as a father and divine leader. From time to time compulsory displays of loyalty or patriotism were required; those refusing the state cult might face a painful death. While polytheists might go along with little conviction, such a cult ran directly contrary to the dedicated Christian life, based on a confessed foundation of a single triune deity.
In the Province of Africa lived two newly baptised Christians, both young women: Felicitas a servant to Perpetua a noble. Felicitas was then pregnant and Perpetua a nursing mother. Together in the arena both were publicly torn apart by wild animals at Carthage in 203 AD. Felicitas and Perpetua became celebrated among Christians as saints. An esteemed writing circulated, containing the reflections and visions of Perpetua (181-203), followed by a narrative of the martyrdom. These manuscript Acts were soon read aloud in Churches throughout the Empire.
Three significant theologians arose in the Province, all enjoying native African ancestry: Tertullian, Cyprian, Augustine.
Tertullian (160-230) was born, lived, and died at Carthage. An expert in Roman law, a convert to Christianity and then a priest, his Latin books on theology were once widely known. He articulated an early understanding of the Trinity. Tertullian later came to espouse an unforgiving puritanism, after Montanus, and so ended in heresy.
St. Cyprian (210-258) was Bishop of Carthage, and a martyr. Also a lawyer and a convert, he considered Tertullian his teacher. Many of Cyprian's writings kindly offer moral counsel, and are read today. His book De Unitate Ecclesiae [On Church Unity] (251) also became well known. He accepted the Church's correction of these views (which he then renounced): that a repentant heretic required a new baptism; that a bishop in his diocese was supreme.
Augustine of Hippo
St. Augustine (354-430), Bishop of Hippo (modern Annaba), was born at Tagaste in Numidia (modern Souk Ahras). His mother St. Monica, a pillar of faith, evidently was of Berber heritage. Augustine himself did not speak a Berber language; his use of Punic is unclear. At Carthage, Augustine received his higher education. Later, while professor of Rhetoric at Milano (then the Roman imperial capital), he pursued his belief in Manichaean teachings. Following his strong conversion to Christianity, and after his mother died at Ostia in Italia, Augustine returned to Africa. Here he served as a priest, and later as bishop of Hippo; as the author of many works, he eventually became a primary influence on subsequent Christian theology.
Well-versed in the pagan philosophy of the Greco-Roman world, Augustine both criticized its perceived shortcomings, and employed it to articulate the message of Christianity. Although open to the study and close reading of his fellow African writer, Apuleius (c.125-185), a pagan thaumaturge, Augustine strongly criticized his understanding of spiritual phenomena. In a well-known work, The City of God, Augustine embarks on wide-ranging discussions of Christian theology, and also applies his learned views to history. He harshly criticizes the ancient state religion of Rome, yet frankly admires traditional Roman civic virtues; in fact he opines that their persistent practice found favor with God (unknown in name to them), hence the progress of the Roman cause throughout the Mediterranean. Later he traces the history of Israel as guided by God, and searches out the gospels of Christianity.
Augustine remains one of the most prominent and most admired of all Christian theologians. His moral philosophy remains influential, e.g., his contribution to the further evolved doctrine of the Just War, used to test whether or not a military action may be considered moral and ethical. His books, e.g., The City of God, and Confessions, are still widely read and discussed.
The Donatist schism was a major disruption to the church. The schism followed a severe Roman persecution of Christians ordered by the Emperor Diocletian (r.284-305). An earlier persecution had caused divisions over whether or how to accept back into the church contrite Christians who had apostatized under state threats, abuse, or torture. Then in 313 the new Emperor Constantine by the Edict of Milan had granted tolerance to Christianity, himself becoming a Christian. This turnabout led to confusion within the Church; in North Africa this accentuated the divide between wealthy urban members aligned with the Empire, and the local rural poor who were salt-of-the-earth believers (which included as well social and political dissidents). In general, agrarian Christian Berbers tended to be Donatists, although more assimilated urban Berbers probably were Catholic. To this challenge the Church did not respond well. The Donatists became centered in southern Numidia, the Catholics in Carthage.
One issue was whether a priest could perform his spiritual office if not personally worthy of the holy sacraments. The Donatist schismatics set up parallel churches in order to practice a ritual purity as a colletive body like ancient Israel, a purity beyond that required by the Catholic Church.
Some Donatists sought to become martyrs by provocative acts. A disorderly, rural extremist group became associated with the Donatists, the circumcellions, who opposed taxes, debt collection, and slavery, and would obstruct normal commerce in order to protect the poor. The Donatist schism also became later linked to two revolts led by the Berber half-brothers, Firmus (372-375), and then Gildo (395-398). As a bishop Augustine came to condemn the Donatists throngs for rioting; at one time there were Imperial persecutions. Church negotiations lasted about a century until finally the Catholics declared Donatism a heresy in 405, though general tolerance persisted until the ban became enforced late in the 6th century.
The two armed conflicts described below may or may not differ from the revolt of Tacfarinas in 17-24 AD. According to one view, the two conflicts were not class struggles, nor Berber versus Roman insurrections, although containing potential elements of each. More likely the fighting concerned "a dynastic struggle pitching one lot of African nobles, with their tribes, against another." Although enjoying maybe "unquestioningly loyal tribesmen on [their] great estates" the nobles themselves held a divided loyalty stemming from their ambivalent role as mediators between Roman Empire elites and local tribal life, mostly rural. Based on subsistence farming, or herding, such tribes remained remote from the literate cities. To their Berber subjects "the nobles offered protection in exchange for tribute and military service." Protection promised safety against attacks by another tribe, but also against slave raiders from the cities. The nobles themselves required revenue and the ability to marshall "armed might" on the one hand, and on the other "their fluency in Roman cultural forms and their ability to communicate as equals with the rest of the Roman elites." If so equipped the nobles "occupied key positions in Roman provincial administration." Yet an unexpected shift in status among the nobles might on occasion trigger a desperate resort to arms, an intra-noble dynastic struggle.
Another view holds that the nobles Firmus and Gildo each continued the struggle of the commoner Tacfarinas, that the fight involved class issues and pitted Berber against Roman. In the intervening 350 years the struggle had gone on—hot or cold, or 'underground'. Both Firmus and Gildo enlisted the dispossessed by aligning with the dissenting Donatist churches and its more radical circumcellion movement. The conflicts were part of the long effort by native agricultural people to reclaim their farming and pasture lands, seized by the Romans as a result of military victories. Professor Laroui differentiates two primary perspectives on Maghriban history of the Roman period, i.e., colonial and liberal. The colonial perspective conforms to the "dynastic struggle view" first suggested above; it adopts the interests of Imperial Rome and its clients. The liberal perspective takes the conquered and colonized view, that of the dispossessed farmers and herders, the expropriated natives—former proprietors of the land. Taking this "liberal" view, Laroui sees the conflict here as centuries old, and as more of an ethnic struggle for fairness and justice.
Firmus (died 375) and Gildo (died 398) were half-brothers, from a family of Berber landowners whose Roman affiliation was recognized by the imperial government at Constantinople. Their father Nubel was known as a regulus ("little king") of a Mauri tribe of Berbers, according to the historian Ammianus Marcellinus. Nubel the father held three positions: influential leader in Berber tribal politics; Roman official with high connections; and, private master of large land holdings. Nubel probably is the same person as Flavius Nubel, the son of a vir perfectissimus and Comes (Roman titles of prestige and authority). Flavius Nubel himself was a commander of Roman cavalry, whose inscription also credits to him the construction of a local Christian church. Six sons of Nubel are listed: Firmus, Sammac, Gildo, Mascezel, Dius, and Mazuc. In addition to his wife Nonnica, the father Nubel had concubines, "a Christianized version of polygamy." The names of Nubel's children probably indicate an ambivalent cultural strategy, half-imperial, half-tribal, half Roman, half Berber. Gildo from the Libyan root GLD signifies a "ruler" (in modern Berber "Aguelid"). Firmus and Dius derive from Latin. Sammac and Mascezel are also Berber. A daughter's name Cyria is Greek.
Sammac became holder of "a fortified estate built up... like a city" whose inhabitants were local Mauri Berbers. An inscription erected by Sammac refers to his endorsement by the tribal Mauris and to his authority conferred by Imperial Rome. Sammac was a close friend of the Comes ("Count") of Africa, Romanus; he also enjoyed substantial family connections. Yet by order of his brother Firmus, Sammac was assassinated for unstated reasons (sibling rivalry is suggested). Firmus sought to justify his actions, but Romanus effectively blocked his efforts, and denounced him to higher Roman officials. Cornered, Firmus took up arms. Hence Ammianus Marcellinus calls Firmus perduellis (national enemy), rebellis (insurgent), and latro (brigand); the nearby bishop Augustine of Hippo calls him rex barbarus (barbarian king). The historian Gibbon, however, blames a corrupt Romanus for the revolt.
Firmus gained support for his revolt (372-375) from three of his brothers and from Mauri tribal allies that he through his family could summons to the struggle. Also attracted were the dissendent Donatist Christian churches, and anti-Roman, anti-taxation sentiment. Evidently Firmus styled himself King of Mauritania. Perhaps he went over to the side of the rural dispossessed and championed their cause. Yet he was opposed by his younger brother Gildo, who remained aligned with Rome. The formidable Comes Theodosius (father of the future Emperor) led a Roman force to Africa against Firmus. The subsequent military campaign, wrote Ammianus, tore at social loyalties, "disrupted the balance of power relationships in the region." In the fighting that led to the defeat of Firmus, Gildo served the Romans under the Comes Theodosius.
Gildo a decade later in 386 became the Comes of Africa, commander of its Roman military forces, the effective leader. Gildo's appointment resulted from his long association with the house of Theodosius, whose son now reigned at Constantinople in the east as the Emperor Theodosius I the Great (r.379-395). Gildo's daughter Salvina also "had married into the ruling house and into the Constantinopolitan establishment." The Empire, divided into East and West, endured turbulence. Magnus Maximus ruled in the West, having overthrown its Emperor Gratian in 383. Then Maximus moved to claim the purple; for a while in 387 he occupied Africa. Theodosius declared Maximus a "usurper" and after invading Italia in 388 he defeated Maximus in battle. In the meantime in Africa the Comes Gildo had occupied a problematic position during the conflict; his loyalty to Emperor Theodosius was put to the test with questioned but passable results. In 394 at Milano in Italia Stilicho, a half-Vandal Roman general, became regent of the West. With Egypt's grain assigned to the East, Italy's main source was Gildo's Africa. Preferring to deal directly with Theodosius at Constantinople, Gildo suggested the "transfer" of Africa to the East, anathema to Stilicho. Stilicho's propaganist Claudian in his poem De bello Gildonico mocked Gildo's disloyalty.
On the death of Emperor Theodosius I in 395, Gildo "gradually waived his loyalty". His regime drew upon Mauri Berber alliances, and was supportive of Donatist churches (then internally divided, its radicals called circumcelliones). Gildo in 397 declared his loyalty to the new, weak eastern Emperor. "Gildo started his rebellion by withholding the shipment of wheat to Rome." Conflicting evidence may indicate that Gildo "confiscated the imperial lands and distributed them among the circumcelliones and his troops." Ironically, Gildo's defiance was opposed by his own brother Mascezel, who served Stilicho. Conflict between the two brothers had already become bitter, murderous. Driven from the field by Stilicho, Gildo failed to escape east by ship and died captive in 398. Mascezel died soon after. Gildo's daughter Salvina raised her children in Constantinople at the imperial court, in its Christian community. The Vandals led by Gaiseric crossed over to Africa in 429.
These events show a once powerful, 4th-century, Berbero-Roman family in the context of the Mediterranean-wide Empire. "As Roman aristocrats, Nubel's family was not unique in exploiting a local power base in order to play a role at the centre." They also demonstrate the complexities of the loyalties tugging on the Africans of that time and place. Or, on the other hand, beneath all the political complexity may exist a simpler story of the dispossessed seeking capable leaders to further their struggle for the land.
The Decline of the Roman Empire in the West was a gradual process punctuated by unheard of events. After eight centuries secure from foreign attack, Rome fell to the Visigoths in 410. By 439 Carthage had been captured by Vandals under Gaiseric (see below). These changes were traumatic to Roman citizens in Africa Province including, of course, those acculturated Berbers who once enjoyed the prospects for livelihood provided by the long fading, now badly broken Imperial economy.
Yet also other Berbers might see a chance for betterment if not liberation in the wake of Rome's slide toward disorder. Living within the empire in urban poverty or as rural laborers, or living beyond its frontiers as independent pastoralists primarily but also as tillers of the soil, were Berbers who might find new political-economic opportunities in Rome's decline, e.g., access to better land and trading terms. The consequent absence of Imperial authority at the periphery soon led to the emergence of new Berber polities. These arose not along the sea coast in the old Imperial cities, but centered inland at the borderland (the limes) of empire, between the steppe and the sown. This "pre-Sahara" geographic and cultural zone ran along the mountainous frontier, the Tell, hill country and upland plains, which separated the "well-watered, Mediterranean districts of the Maghreb to the north, from the Sahara desert to the south." Here Berber tribal chiefs acted through force and negotiation to establish a new source of governing authority.
From west to east across North Africa, eight of these new Berbers states have been identified, being the kingdoms of: Altava (near present-day Tlemcen); the Ouarsenis (by Tiaret); Hodna; the Aures (southern Numidia); the Nemencha; the Dorsale (at Thala, south of El Kef); Capsus (at Capsa); and, Cabaon (in Tripolitania, at Oea). The eastern-most five of these Berber kingdoms were located within the old Africa Proconsularis, and all eight were within the now defunct Diocese of Africa (314-432), Carthage its capital. Alike in situation to the newly formed Germanic kingdoms within the fallen Empire in Europe to the north, these Berber kingdoms served two disparate populations: the Romani who were "the settled communities of provincial citizens" and the "barbarians", here the Mauri, "Berber tribes along and beyond the frontier". The Romani contributed the urban resources and fiscal structure for which a civil administration was required, while the Mauri provided fruits of the countryside and satisfied essential military and security requirements. This functional and ethnic duality at the core of the Berber successor states is reflected in the title of the political leader at Altava (see here above), one Masuna, found on an inscription: rex gent(ium) Maur(orum) et Romanor(um). King Masuna of the Mauri and of the Romans must have been, in some perhaps transformed way, similar to Firmus or Gildo (see above).
In the Kingdom of Ouarsenis (by Tiaret) were built thirteen large funerary monuments known as Djedars, dating to the 5th and 6th centuries, many being square measuring 50 meters on a side and rising 20 meters high. "While their architectural form echoes a long tradition of massive North African royal mausolea, stretching back to Numidian and Mauretanian kingdoms of the 3rd-1st centuries BC, the closest parallels are with the tumuli or bazinas, with flanking 'chapels', which are distributed in an arc through the pre-Saharan zone and beyond" perhaps several thousand kilometers to the southwest (to modern Mauritania). Some display "decorative carvings and Christian motifs" although the bilingual dedicatory inscriptions are virtually illegible. "The Djedars could thus be considered the ultimate development of an indigenous, pre-Saharan funerary architectural tradition, adapted to fit a Christian, Romanized environment."
Yet an unresolved issue concerns the Christianity of independent Berbers after Roman rule, both Catholic and Donatist, i.e., Berber Christianity under the Vandals, Byzantines, and Arabs. Christianity never completely supplanted the ancient pagan beliefs of Berbers, mixed and augmented by Punic practices and later Greco-Roman. Nor did Christianity among the Berbers attain an enduring unity among its diverse and conflicting believers.
Under the Byzantines, several Berber political entities proximous to Imperial power became nominal vassals states pledging loyalty to the Empire, who invested their leaders. A major Imperial concern was, by negotiaton and trade, or by show or demonstration of might, to harness the anarchic tendencies of these more rural regimes; otherwise, to withstand any challenge. Roman urban centers, however, survived into the 7th century at Tiaret, Altaya, Tlemcen, and Volubilis, where practicing Christians wrote in Latin. Other Berber polities at the periphery of the settled regions retained their total independence.
In the 5th century, the western Roman Empire was in a steep decline. A Germanic tribal nation the Vandals had already trekked across the Empire to Hispania. In 429 under their king Gaiseric (r. 428-477) the Vandals and the Alans (their Iranian allies), about 80,000 people, traveled the 2000 km. from Iulia Traducta in Andalusia across the straits and east along the coast to Numidia, west of Carthage. The next year the Vandals besieged the city of Hippo Regius (on the coast of Numidia) while St. Augustine within awaited his natural death. Eventually in 439 the Vandals captured Carthage, which became the center of their Germanic kingdom.
The western Imperial capital at Ravenna recognized his rule in 442. Yet from Constantinople the eastern Empire attempted reconquest several times. At last in 468 a large Byzantine fleet approached Cape Bon by Carthage, and Gaiseric asked for time to consider submission to Imperial demands. When the wind changed Vandal fire ships were scudded into the fleet causing its ruin. After guaranteeing Catholic freedom of worship, Gaiseric entered a peace treaty with the Byzantines in 474, which endured about sixty years.
"Nothing could have been more unexpected in North Africa than these conquerors of Germanic origin." Initially many Berbers fought the Vandals as they arrived; after the Vandals' conquest, Berber forces remained the only military threat against them. Yet in governing their kingdom the Vandals did not maintain in full their martial posture against the Berbers, but made alliances with them in order to secure their occupation of the land. In 455 the Gaiseric sailed with an army to the city of Rome.
In religious policy, the Vandals tried to convert the urban Catholic Christians of Africa to their Arian heresy (named after the Egyptian Christian priest Arius, who taught that the Father is greater than the Son and the Spirit). The Vandal regime sent the Catholic clergy into exile and expropriated Catholic churches; in the 520s their efforts turned to persecution, including martyrdom of resisters, yet without success. The Berbers remained aloof. In all Vandal rule would last 94 years (439-533).
The Vandals did provide functional security and governed with a light hand, so that the former Roman province prospered at first. Large estates were confiscated, but with former owners as managers. Roman officials administered public affairs and Roman law courts continued, Latin being used for government business. Yet Romans would wear Vandal dress at the royal court in Carthage. Agriculture provided more than enough to feed the region and trade flourished in the towns. Yet because of their desire to maintain a superiority in status, the Vandals refused to intermarry or agreeably assimilate to the advanced culture of the Romans. Consequently, finer points were overlooked; the Vandals failed to sustain in its entirety the workable civil society situated subtly, uniquely. Berbers confederacies beyond the frontier grew increasingly powerful, dangerous to the prevailing regime.
The Eastern Romans, known also as the Byzantine Empire, eventually recaptured Rome's Africa province during the Vandalic War in 534, when led by their celebrated general Belisarius. The Byzantines rebuilt fortifications and border defenses (the limes), and entered into treaties with the Berbers. Nevertheless, for many decades security and prosperity were precarious and were never fully restored. Direct Byzantine rule didn't extend far beyond the coastal cities. The African interior remained under the control of various Berber tribal confederacies, e.g., the Byzantines contested against the Berber Kingdom of Garmules.
Early in the 7th century, several new Berber groups (the Jarid and Zanata of the Auruba) converted to Catholicism, joining Berbers already Christian, although other Berbers remained attached to their gods. In the 540s the restored Catholic Church in Africa was disrupted by the Emperor Justinian's position in favor of the Monophysite doctrine.
In the early 7th century, the Byzantine Empire entered a period of serious crises that would alter the future of Tunisia. For centuries Byzantium's greatest enemy had been the Sassanid Persians, and the two powers were chronically at war with each other (the Roman-Persian Wars). The warfare was often intense but usually resulted in small border changes. In the 7th century however, the situation changed dramatically. Persistent religious discord within the Empire, followed by the overthrow of Emperor Maurice by the tyrant Phocas, severely weakened the Byzantines. The Persians under Chosroes II invaded the Byzantine Empire, along with allies from the north: the Eurasian Avars and Slav confederacies. Much of the Empire was overrun and its end seemed near.
It was the son of the Exarch of Carthage, Heraclius (575-641), who would restore the empire's fortunes. Heraclius sailed east across the Mediterranean with an African fleet to the Byzantine capital city of Constantinople and overthrew the usurper Phocas. Heraclius then became Roman Emperor in 610. He began reorganizing the government and erecting defenses to counter threats to the capital. Notwithstanding, the Persians continued their invasion, meeting little resistance, taking Antioch in 611, Jerusalem in 614, and Alexandria in 619, in an astonishing series of victories. The hostile forces of Chosroes II soon stood before Constantinople. In response, Heraclius at great risk moved quickly a Roman army by ship east over the Black Sea, landing near his Khazar allies. In subsequent fighting the Byzantines managed to out-flank the Persians. By 627 Heraclius was marching on their capital Ctesiphon in a complete reversal of fortune. Then in 628 the Persian Shah, Chosroes II, was killed in a revolt by his generals.
As a result of these dramatic and tumultuous events, Sassanid Persia was in disarray and confusion. Consequently, the Byzantines were able to retake their provinces of Egypt and Syria. Yet with the return of the Romans, the pre-existing religious discord between the local Monophysite Christians of Egypt and the official imperial Chalcedonian Church also returned. In order to mediate this Christological conflict, Emperor Heraclius attempted to work out a theological compromise. The result was Monothelitism, whose compromise doctrine satisfied neither Monophysite nor Chalcedonian; the religious discord among Christians continued to conflict the Empire.
Yet events along the imperial frontier did not rest. To the south, the Arab peoples of the desert began to stir under the influence of a new monotheistic vision, being unified and energized by the foundational teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (570-632). In 636 at the Battle of Yarmuk to the east of the Sea of Galilee the Arab Islamic armies decisively defeated the Byzantine forces. Soon the recently lost and regained Roman provinces of Syria and Egypt would be lost again by the Byzantines—with finality—to emerging Islam.
Following the Arab invasion and occupation of Egypt in 640, there were Christian refugees who fled west, until arriving in the Exarchate of Africa (Carthage), which remained under Byzantine rule. Here serious disputes arose within the Catholic churches at Carthage over Monophysite doctrines and Monothelitism, with St. Maximus the Confessor leading the orthodox Catholics.
- Berber people
- Berber languages
- Salvius Julianus
- Septimius Severus
- Felicitas and Perpetua
- Africa Province
- Diocese of Africa
- Exarchate of Africa
- Praetorian prefecture of Africa
- North Africa during the Classical Period
- History of Tunisia
- For background information, e.g., on geography and climate, see History of Tunisia.
- For referral to authorities, see footnoted text following.
- Afri was a "classical Latin name for the Berbers". J. A. Ilevbare, Carthage, Rome and the Berbers (University of Ibadan 1981) at 177.
- The subsequent Arabic name for the region Ifriqiya evidently derives from the Roman province of Africa. Yet in the middle ages popular genealogies arose there which claimed to traced the origin of the Berber people to an archaic Arab tribe said to have come west to the Maghrib from the Yemen; the tribal leader's name was Ifriqish ibn Sayfi. Hence the Arabic name Ifriqiya (and presumably also the earlier Afri known to the Romans). Yet the then contemporary Andalusian writer Ibn Hazm (994-1064) scoffed generally at such popular genealogies, and Ibn Khaldun (1332–1406) of Tunis also held them to be false. H. T. Norris, The Berbers in Arab Literature (Beirut: Librairie du Liban 1982) at 57 (Ifriqish ibn Sayfi), at 39-40 (Ibn Hazm and Ibn Kaldun), at 32-33 (some modern views), at 33-39 (other popular medieval lineages). Compare: History of early Islamic Tunisia#Berber rôle.
- See above, Rome and the Berber kings.
- Roman provincial boundaries were redrawn several times. E.g., Jamil M. Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971), map at 32.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1970, 1977) at 35-37.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990) at 167.
- Perkins, Tunisia (Westview 1986) at 19.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990) at 181.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990), e.g., at 213, 215-216, 217-221, 223-224, 231 (mosaics).
- Jamil M. Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge Univ. 1971) at 35.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990) at 191-192.
- Wheeler, Roman Art and Arquetecture (New York: Praeger 1964) at 149, photograph of Zaghouan to Carthage aqueduct at 150.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990), e.g., at 204-210 (games).
- Cf., Michael Grant, Roman Literature (Cambridge Univ. 1954; Penguin 1958) at 20-22: brief view of ancient mime and pantomime.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990), e.g., at 221-223 (theater).
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (Simon and Schuster 1990) at 172-173, 187 ff.
- Mommsen, The Provinces of the Roman Empire (Leipzig 1885, 5th ed. 1904; London 1886, 1909; reprint 1996) at II: 306.
- Perkins, Tunisia (Westview 1986) at 18.
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 261-285, at 261-262, 270.
- See Berber kings of Roman-era Tunisia: "Tacfarinas and the land".
- Mommsen, The Provinces of the Roman Empire (Leipzig 1885, 5th ed. 1904; London 1886, 1909; reprint 1996) at II: 333-334, 339.
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 261-285, at 261, 269-272.
- Cf., Pliny (c. 23-79 CE), Naturalis Historia V, 24-25, translated as Natural History (London: Wm. Heinemann [Loeb Classical Library] 1942, 1969) vol. II (Books III-VII) at 237.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990) at 173-174.
- Mommsen, The Provinces of the Roman Empire (Leipzig 1885, 5th ed. 1904; London 1886, 1909; reprint 1996) at II: 336-338.
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 261-285, at 269-272.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990), e.g., at 225-230 (hunting).
- Ceramics and pottery traditions date back to Phoenicia. Dimitri Baramki, Phoenicia and the Phoenicians (Beirut: Kayats 1961) at 69-75.
- Slim, Mahjoubi, Belkhoja, and Ennabli, L'Antiquité (Tunis: Sud Éditions 2010) at 202-204 (ceramics), economic map at 211 (showing major olive groves in the sahel (eastern coastlands) as they are currently, and showing the ancient ceramic areas by El Djem, Gafsa, and the lower Medjerda).
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 161-185, at 272-273, in General History of Africa, volume II, Ancient Civilizations of Africa (Paris: UNESCO 1990), edited by G. Mokhtar, abridged edition.
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990) at 175-177.
- Slim, Mahjoubi, Belkhoja, and Ennabli, L'Antiquité (Tunis: Sud Éditions 2010), at 204-205, and fold-out map at end; [Histoire Générale de Tunisie, Tome 1].
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 161-185, at 272-274, in General History of Africa, volume II, Ancient Civilizations of Africa (1990).
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (1990) at 177.
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 161-185, at 273, in General History of Africa, volume II, Ancient Civilizations of Africa (1990).
- Pliny (AD 23-79), Natural History V, 36 (Heineman, Harvard Univ. 1942) at 244-245.
- Max Cary and Erik M. Warmington, The Ancient Explorers (London: Methuen 1929; revised ed., Pelican 1963) at 216-221, 219.
- Roman artifacts and a cut-stone mausoleum at Gerama, 700 km. south of the Mediterranean port of Tripoli. Mortimer Wheeler, Rome beyond the Imperial Frontiers (Penguin 1954) at 121-133, 130.
- Cf., Herodotus (c.484-c.425), The Histories IV, 181 (Penguin 1954, 1972) at 332.
- Richard W. Bulliet, The Camel and the Wheel (Harvard Univ. 1975) at 113, 138.
- A. Bathily, "Relations between the different regions of Africa" at 348-357, 350, in General History of Africa, volume III, Africa from the Seventh to the Eleventh Century (UNESCO 1992).
- Adolph Berger, Encyclopedic Dictionary of Roman Law (Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society 1953) at 522.
- Rudolph Sohm, Institutionen. Ein Lehrbuch der Geschichte und System des römischen Privatrechts (Leipzig: Duncker und Humblot 1883, 12th ed. 1905), translated as The Institutes. A textbook of the History and System of Roman Private Law (London: Oxford University, Claredon Press, 3d ed. 1907; reprint: Augustus Kelly 1970) at 97-98.
- W. W. Buckland, Text-book on Roman Law. From Augustus to Justinian (Cambridge University 1921, 3rd ed. 1963), the third posthumous edition as revised by Peter Stein, at 29.
- Diane Bowder, editor, Who Was Who in the Roman World (Ithaca: Cornell University 1980) at 119.
- Fritz Schulz, History of Roman Legal Science (Oxford University 1946, 1967) at 127.
- Fritz Schulz, History of Roman Legal Science (Oxford University 1946, 1967) at 229-230: the Digestorum libri xc of Julian.
- W. W. Buckland, Text-book on Roman Law (Cambridge University 1921, 3rd ed. 1963 by P. Stein), at 29.
- Peter Stein, Roman Law in European History (Cambridge University 1999) at 43-45. Stein quotes from a letter of the famous, 19th-century English legal historian F. W. Maitland: "[B]ut for [Justinian's] Digest [Pandect] Roman Law could never have reconquered the world." Stein (1999) at 44.
- Michael Grant, The Roman Emperers (New York: Scribner's 1985; reprint Barnes & Noble 1997) at 105. The emperor Diduis, in contrast to Julian, left no good reputation.
- W. W. Buckland, Text-book on Roman Law. (Cambridge University 1921, 3rd ed. 1963 by P. Stein) at 29, at 29 n.5.
- Laroui challenges the accepted view of the prevalence of the Latin language, in his The History of the Maghrib (1970, 1977) at 45-46.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 36.
- Brett and Fentress, The Berbers (Oxford: Blackwell 1996) at 48-49, 50 ff.
- H. J. Rose, A Handbook of Latin Literature (London: Methuen 1936, 3d ed. 1954; reprint by Dutton, New York 1960) at 520.
- Michael Brett and Elizabeth Fentress, The Berbers (Oxford: Blackwell 1996) at 42, 52.
- Jack Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 5-6, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana University 1960).
- Apuleius quoted in Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 6, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960).
- Quotation in Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 11-12, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960).
- Apuleius, The Apology and Florida of Apuleius of Madaura (Greenwood Press 1970), translated by Butler.
- Rose, A Handbook of Latin Literature (1936, 3d ed. 1954; reprint 1960) at 520-521.
- Jack Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 11, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960). Lindsay estimates the year of the trial at 155-158, no later than 161. Ibid.
- Diana Bowder, editor, Who was Who in the Roman World (Cornell Univ. 1980) at 27.
- Michael Grant, Latin Literature (Cambridge University 1954; reprint Penguin 1958) at 118, 119.
- Metamorphoses has seen many translations from its original Latin, several into English, e.g., Apuleius, The Golden Ass (Indiana University 1960), translated by Jack Lindsay.
- Apuleius: The Golden Ass: Being the Metamorphoses of Lucius Apuleius (London: Wm. Heinemann; Cambridge: Harvard Univ. 1915, 1989), two volumes, translated by W. Aldington (1566) as revised by S. Gaselee [Loeb Classical Library].
- Also: a psychological study by Marie-Louise von Franz, An Interpretation of Apuleius' Golden Ass with the tale of Eros and Psyche (University of Dallas, Spring Pub. , 2d ed. 1980).
- H. J. Rose, A Handbook of Latin Literature (1936; 3d ed. 1954; reprint 1960) at 521-522.
- Michael Grant, Latin Literature (Cambridge Univ. 1954; Penguin 1958) at 118-122. Prof. Grant mentions a shorter, prior work in Greek, Lucius or the Ass (118), though the story probably first arose as a folktale; Grant later discusses Apuleius' wide influence after 'rediscovery' by Renaissance Europe (121-122).
- Apuleius, The Golden Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960) at 82-84 (near the end of book III).
- Regarding the hero's metamorphosis: one may note the emblem (the imperial Roman eagle, or the owl of Athens) indirectly referenced by the admired bird of prey, versus the North African populist image of the libidinous donkey.
- Apuleius, The Golden Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960) at 104-142 (near the end of book IV to near the end of book VI).
- Also: a psychological study by Erich Neumann, Amor and Psyche. The Psychic Development of the Feminine. A Commentary on the Tale by Apuleius (New York: Bollingen 1956; reprint by Harper & Row/Torchbook 1962).
- Lindsay comments that Apuleius, in the episode at the bakery, provides a rare and hellish description of ancient slavery. Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 22, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960) at 156-160 (mistreatment at mill), at 191-193 (at bakery).
- Apuleius, The Golden Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960) at 242-243 (middle of book XI).
- Jack Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 13 & 21, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana University 1960). Lindsay also notes in Apuleius traces of anti-Christian views (at 21-22, 26-27).
- H. J. Rose, A Handbook of Latin Literature (1936; 3d ed. 1954; reprint 1960) at 522.
- Michael Grant, Roman Literature (Cambridge Univ. 1954; Penguin 1958) at 119 and 121.
- Augustine, De Civitate Dei (413-426) at Book VIII, chapters 14-19, 22-23, and Bk.IX, ch.3, 6, 8, 11, also Bk.XII,10; translated by Healey (1610) and revised by Tasker (1945) as The City of God (London: J.M.Dent 1945, 1967) at vol. I: 238-262, 353.
- Grant, Roman Literature (1954; Penguin 1958) at 119.
- According to Marie-Louise von Franz, in his De Deo Socratis Apuleius writes about intermediary spirits, messengers between the gods and humanity, which using Greek he calls daïmones (here analogous to angels, writes von Franz). Apuleius continues, discussing the genius (Latin) of a person, their guardian spirit, which survives their death. A righteous person's genius may develop into a lar, similar to the Roman household gods the penates; but for the morally bad person a larva [or lemur]. After death as an evil ghost the larva [or lemur] may haunt the living. Yet the lar is beneficial, which the living may welcome kindly. As an example of the latter, von Franz mentions the tombs of revered saints and sufis in North Africa, which for their followers are sources of barakah ("blessings" in Arabic). Marie-Louise von Franz, An Interpretation of Apuleius' Golden Ass (2d ed. 1980) at 12-15. Similar in this regard was the ancient Berber practice of sleeping on the graves of their ancestors.
- Perhaps Augustine understood such 'evil lordship of the world' more acutely because of his former beliefs as a dualistic Manichaean. Cf., Augustine, Confessions ([c.397-400]; New York: Doubleday/Image 1960) at 159-160 (bk.VII, ch.2); and also, works by Augustine against the Manichees, e.g., those listed by John K. Ryan, "Translator's Introduction", Ibid. 17-38, at 27.
- Compare: Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo. A biography (University of California 1967) at 244-247, i.e., Augustine as sharing in the appreciation of facets of the Neoplatonic worldview, with the pagan mystic philosopher Plotinus (204-270), so that "love of the world" was to be avoided because in this age the world remains imperfect and transient (although also "demon-haunted" and contaminated by false images, e.g., of pagan gods).
- Already in his The City of God (London: Dent 1945) [two volumes], Augustine had illustrated immoral behavior, e.g., the adultery by Jupiter (bk.II, ch.8; v.I:47) and by Venus (III,3; I:78).
- Augustine, The City of God (London: J.M.Dent 1945, 1967) at vol.I: 238 (VIII,14). Augustine acknowledges that daemones were called good by pagans (citing Labeo), but claims that since the word has become pejorative in everyday use. Augustine, The City of God (1945) at I: 269 (IX,19). Also, cf., Ibid. at I: 262 (IX,8) and at II: 245 (XIX,9).
- Diana Bowder, editor, Who was Who in the Roman World (Cornell University 1980) at 26 (Appollonius), 27 (Apuleius).
- H. J. Rose, A Handbook of Latin Literature (1936; 3d ed. 1954; reprint 1960) at 521.
- Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, at 26 (thaumaturge Appollonius and Apuleius, 'controversial' quote), at 27 ("Everyone believed in the miracles of Apuleius" citing 1888 journal article "Apuleé magicien" by Monceau), in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960).
- Diana Bowder, editor, Who was Who in the Roman World (1980) at 27.
- Rose, Handbook of Latin Literature (3d ed. 1954, 1960) at 161-163.
- Cf., Cicero, Brutus at xcv.325-326, in Cicero, v.5 ([Loeb Classical Library] 1939, 1971) at 283-285.
- Michael Grant, Roman Literature (Cambridge University 1954, reprint Penguin 1958) at 118-122. Given here are several lengthy excerpts in English translation from three ages (Elizabethan, late-19th, mid-20th) of "Metamorphoses". Fronto (early 2nd century) of Cirta, Numidia, tutor of Marcus Aurelius, is said to be an originator of elocutio novella. Grant mentions African influence as a reason for its emergence, but better he credits its creation as "the Latin of an epoch". Grant (1954, 1958) at 118.
- Lindsay, "Apuleius and his Work" 5-28, blockquote at 17, Latin quotes at 19-20, in Apuleius, The Golder Ass (Indiana Univ. 1960).
- Soren, Khader, Slim, Carthage (Simon and Schuster 1990) at 179.
- Cf., Perkins, Tunisia (Westview 1986) at 21.
- Cf., Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1970, 1977) at 35.
- Cf., below, the Gordion line of Emperors in the section Emperors from Africa.
- Also, see the above subsection Tacfarinas.
- Perkins, Tunisia (1986) at 19-23, 21.
- Cf., below, the section on Christianity.
- Lepcis Magna was formerly included in the Roman Province of Africa Proconsularis (see map above).
- Michael Grant, The Roman Emperors. A biographical guide to the rulers of Imperial Rome, 31 B.C. to A.D. 476 (New York: Scribner's 1985) at 108-113, 117-136.
- Diana Bowder (editor), Who was who in the Roman World (Cornell Univ. 1980).
- Grant, The Roman Emperors at 140-155.
- Bowder, editor, Who was Who in the Roman World.
- Joyce E. Salisbury, Perpetua's Passion. The Death and Memory of a Young Roman Woman (London: Routledge 1997) at 15-22 (state cult), at 22 (persecution order of Lucius Septimius Severus (r.193-211) issued in 202).
- Cf., Hans Kung, Christentum: Wessen und Geschichte (München: Piper Verlag 1994), translated as Christianity. Essence, history, and future (New York: Continuum 1995) at 131-133.
- W.H.Shewring, The Passion of SS. Perpetua and Felicity (London: Sheed and Ward 1931).
- Marie-Louise von Franz, The Passion of Perpetua (Irving, Texas: Spring Pub. 1980), text and commentary [Jungian Classics Series].
- Donald Attwater (ed.& rev. by John Cumming), Dictionary of the Saints (Collegeville, Minnesota: The Liturgical Press [1938, 1958] 1993) at 249.
- Joyce E. Salisbury, Perpetua's Passion. The Death and Memory of a Young Roman Woman (London: Routledge 1997) at 5-9 (Perpetua), 92-112 (her visions), 136-148 (her martyrdom).
- Eusebius (260-340), Historia Ecclesiastica, II 2, translated as The History of the Church (Penguin 1965, reprint: Minneapolis: Augsburg 1975) at 75.
- Tertullian, Adversus Praxean, excerpted by Henry Bettenson in his The Early Christian Fathers (Oxford Univ. 1956) at 133-137.
- Dom Charles Poulet, Histoire de l'Eglise (Paris: Gabriel Beauchesne et ses Fils 1926, 1930), fourth edition edited and translated by Sidney A. Raemers as Church History (St. Louis: B. Herder 1934, 1951) at vol. I, 108-110 (life, doctrines, e.g., "rule of faith"), also: Montanus, at I: 83-84. Tertulian in 207 adopted this heresy.
- Maureen A. Tilley discusses Tertullian as a predecessor to the Donatists, in her The Bible in Christian North Africa. The Donatist World (Minneapolis: Fortress 1997) at 20-28.
- Eusebius (260-340), Historia Ecclesiastica, II 2, translated as The History of the Church (Penguin 1965; reprint: Minneapolis: Augsburg 1975) at 88.
- Poulet, Church History (1930, 1934) at I: 97-99 (unforgivable sins), 99-101 and 103-105 (baptism by heretics), 110-111 (Cyprian's books); at I: 90-91, Cyprian on the brutal persecutions under the Emperor Decius (r.245-251), who came after Philip the Arab (r.244-249), and was later followed by Valerian (r.253-260) whose persecutions martyred St. Cyprian.
- Donald Attwater (edited & revised by John Cumming), Dictionary of the Saints (Collegeville, Minnesota: The Liturgical Press [1938, 1958] 1993) at 79.
- The name Mon (from which that of his mother Monica) referred to a local Numidian goddess. Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo (University of California 1967) at 32.
- Cf., William M. Green, "Augustine's Use of Punic" at 179-190, in Semitic and Oriental Studies presented to Prof. Wm. Popper (Univ.of California 1951).
- Cf., W. H. C. Frend, A note on the Berber background in the life of Augustine in J.Theol. St. (1942) XLIII: 188-191.
- Augustine evidently could not understand the Berber idiom. Brown, Augustine of Hippo (1967) at 139.
- Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo. A biography (Univ. of California 1967) at 28-34 & 129-130 (his mother St. Monica), 46-61 (as Manichee), 130-132 (return to Africa), 299-312 (his writing the City of God).
- Etienne Gilson, Introduction à l'étude de saint Augustin (Paris: Vrin 2d ed. 1943), translated as The Christian Philosophy of Saint Augustine (New York: Random House/Vintage 1960, 1967), e.g., at 3; at 233 (finding great similarity between Plotinus and St. John the Evangelist).
- See above, subsection Lucius Apuleius, for Augustine's criticism.
- Augustine, The City of God (London: Dent 1945), 2 volumes, at [vol.I] books 1-4 (Roman pagan religion), at [vol.I] book 5, ch.12 (Roman virtue), at [vol.II] books 15-18 (Israel), at [vol.II] books 18-22 (Christianity).
- E.g., Augustine, hearing that a wise man will not wage but just war, writes:
"As if the very rememberance (sic) that he is man ought not to procure his greater sorrow in that he has cause of just wars, and must needs wage them, which if they were not just, it were not for him to deal in, so that a wise man should never have war. For it is the other men's wickedness that makes his cause just that he ought to deplore, whether it produce wars or not." The City of God (London: Dent 1945) at II: 243 (XIX,7). Also, ibid. at II: 247 (XIX,12).
- Aurelius Augustinus, De Civitate Dei ([c.413-426]), translated by Healey (1610), revised by Tasker (1945), as The City of God (London: J.M.Dent 1945), two volumes.
- Augustine, Confessiones ([c.397-400]), translated by John K. Ryan as The Confessions of St. Augustine (New York: Doubleday/Image 1960), with "Translator's Introduction" at 17-38.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib at 38 & 43-44, 46.
- Diana Bowder, editor, Who was who in the Roman World (Cornell Univ. 1980) at 35.
- Dom Charles Poulet, Histoire de l'Eglise (Paris: Gabriel Beauchesne et sus Fils 1926, 1934), translated and edited by S.A.Raemers as A History of the Catholic Church (St. Louis: Herder 1951) at vol. I, 218-228.
- Perter Brown, Augustine of Hippo. A biography (University of California 1967).
- Named after the Berber Bishop Donatus or Donatus Magnus, there being some confusion. Catholic Encyclopedia: Donatists
- Concerning Donatus or Donatus Magnes, see Tilly, The Bible in Christian North Africa. The Donatist World (Minneapolis: Fortress Press 1997): compare Donatus of 61,n18 (194,n18) & 131, with Donatus of 69-70.
- Cf., W. H. C. Frend, The Donatist Church. A Movement of Protest in Roman North Africa (Oxford Univ. 1952, 1971).
- Contra: Elizabeth Isichei, A History of Christianity in Africa (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1995) at 37-38 text, and note 78 at 359-360, who refers to strong criticism of Frend's ethnic and social-economic theories, citing A.H.M.Jones, J.Theo. St. (1959), and P.Brown, J.ROM. St. (1968).
- Maureen A. Tilley has continued questioning many assumptions about the Donatists, in her The Bible in Christian North Africa. The Donatist World (Minneapolis: Fortress Press 1997). She explicates their theological integrity in light of ancient Christianity.
- Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo. A biography (University of California 1967) at 218-219.
- It has been commonly remarked that the more rigorous quest for religious purity made by the rural Berbers, when compared to the more relaxed attitude of mainstream civilization, has led not only to Donatism with regard to Christianity, but also as regards Islam to the Berber attraction for the Kharijites, for the Fatimid Ismaili Shia, and for both the Almoravide and the Almohad movements. On the other hand, one could compare and contrast this Christian schism in North Africa with the Monophysite schism in Coptic Egypt and elsewhere.
- Joyce E. Salisbury, Perpetua's Passion. The Death and Memory of a Young Roman Woman (London: Routledge 1997) at 164, citing letters of Augustine. Salisbury remarks that North Africa was the last place in the Mediterranean region to practice human sacrifice. Ibid. at 165.
- Isichei, A History of Christianity in Africa (1995) at 38: "This [the circumcellions] was clearly a Peasant's Revolt; they lived in community near the tombs of rural martyrs, carrying clubs called Israel, attacking their propertied opponents with the war cry Deo Laudes."
- Tilley, The Bible in Christian North Africa (1997) at 94.
- Brent D. Shaw, in his "Who were the Circumcellions?" at 227-258, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004), edited by A. H. Merrills, seeks to show that how the meaning of the movement became abstracted by the Church at large, enough to become unrecognizably pejorative. "The image of the circumcellions that has now emerged is one that lives on in an odd world of its own, with no reference to any reality that had ever existed in the African countryside... ." Shaw (2004) at 248.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 41-43.
- Tilley, The Bible in Christian North Africa (1997) at 132-136.
- See Firmus and Gildo section above.
- Yet Augustine himself was attacked by Donatists, because of his 'un-Christian' youth. Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo. A biography (University of California 1967) at 233.
- Johnson, A History of Christianity (New York: Atheneum 1979) at 83-85, 88, 115.
- Brown, Augustine of Hippo at 215-225, 235, 240-241.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib at 38-44, 62.
- Michael Brett and Elizabeth Fentress, The Berbers (Oxford: Blackwell 1996) at 72-74. Here, perhaps more often, due to lack of primogeniture among the Berbers. Ibid. at 75.
- Abdallah Laroui, L'Histoire du Maghreb: Un essai de synthèse (Paris: Librairie François Maspero 1970), translated as The History of the Maghrib. An interpretive essay (Princeton University 1977) at 30-35, 51-58.
- Jamil M. Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971) at 34-44.
- Abdalah Laroui, The History of the Maghrib (Paris 1970; Princeton Univ. 1977) at 51, 54-58.
- Blackhurst comments on the multivalent dynamics that operated in Berber tribal society, where "authority was distributed between segments of the tribe, with the 'tribe' being, in reality, a constellation of clans, shifting and, ultimately, ephemeral." Andy Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 72, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (Ashgate 2004), edited by A. H. Merrills, regarding recent literature in anthropology.
- Ammianus Marcellinus (c.330-390s), Res Gestae at 29.5.2, (Harvard Univ. 1935) [Loeb classics]; cited by Blackhurst at 59, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004). From the Greek east, Ammianus wrote in Latin his Roman Imperial history; only its mid-4th century survives.
- Jamil M. Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971) at 41, 4 (map), locates the family near Mitidja (by modern Algiers), with Nubel being chief of the Juabeleni Berber clan.
- The tribe's name being Iubaleni, the father's name Nubel may be an appropriation by the tribal chief, emblematic of an eponymous tribal ancestor. Michael Brett and Elizabeth Fentress, The Berbers (Oxford: Blackwell 1996) at 294 n.66 (to text at 75).
- Andy Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 64-65 (Flavius Nuvel), at 61 (six sons), in Vandals, Romans and Berbers. New perspectives on late antique North Africa (Aldershot: Ashgate 2004), edited by A. H. Merrills.
- Michael Brett & Elizabeth Fentress, The Berbers (Oxford: Blackwell 1996) at 71-72. Nonnica & Mazuca are not discussed.
- East-West Empire map: superimposed on modern borders.
- Michael Brett and Elizabeth Fentress, The Berbers (1996) at 72: Sammac's inscription of 70-plus words is given in English translation, from his fortified estate called "Petra".
- Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 61-62, 64 (Sammac), at 62-63 (Firmus), at 65 (rivalry), in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004), edited by Merrills. Such local armed rebellions were not uncommon in the 4th-century Roman Empire.
- Edward Gibbon, History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (London: Strahan & Cadell 1776-1789) at Chapter XXV, Sec. III; Modern Library reprint: at I: 881-886, 882. Gibbon blames Romanus for greed and corruption, "till the Africans were provoked, by his avarice, to join the rebellious standard of Firmus the Moor."
- See hereinabove at subsection Donatist schism.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 41. His major Donatist ally was Optatus, a bishop in southern Numidia.
- Ammianus, Res Gestae at 29.5.28 (Harvard Univ. 1935) [Loeb]; quoted by Blackhurst at 64, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004).
- Andy Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 62-66, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004).
- The Comes Theodoius was executed at Carthage shortly thereafter in 376, during the confusion following the death of Valentinian I. Diana Bower, editor, Who's Who in the Roman World (Cornell University 1980) at 211.
- The late 4th-century designation "Africa" referred to territory corresponding to the modern Tunisia, Algeria, and Morocco.
- Michael Grant, The Roman Emperors. A biographical guide to the rulers of Imperial Rome, 31 B.C.-A.D. 476 (New York: Scribner's 1985; reprint by Barnes and Noble 1997) at 270-274.
- Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 67 (quote), at 66 & 69 (Jerome's letters), at 72 & supra (Salvina), in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004), edited by A. H. Merrills.
- Michael Grant, The Roman Emperors (1985, 1997) at 272, 274-276.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 41-42.
- Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 66-72 (Gildo's loyalty esp. at 69-70), in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004). Claudian styled Gildo tyrannus.
- Jamil M. Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971) at 40-43.
- Blackhurst in his "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 72, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004), edited by A. H. Merrills. Blackhurst at 75 conjectures that the divide among Numidian Donatist (Rogatists vs. Firmiani) might be the result of factions left over from the revolt of Firmus. Also Blackhurst, adding a contrary (not Donatist) layer of connections, notes that "Nubel, Mascezel [his fourth son] and Salvina [his granddaughter through Gildo] subscribed to Christianity of a distinctly 'Catholic' cast."
- Michael Grant, The Roman Emperors (1985, 1997) at 280.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971) at 41-43, 42.
- Abdallah Laroui, The History of the Maghrib (Paris 1970; Princeton Univ. 1977) at 56 (text at note 37).
- Gildo had killed two children of Mascezel. Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971) at 42-43.
- Blackhurst, "The House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 70 & 73 (Mascezel), at 69 n.68 & n.70 (Salvina), in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004).
- Edward Gibbon, Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (London: 1776-1789) at Chapter XXIX (near the end); Modern Library reprint, at I: 1040-1045 (Gildo). Gibbon here painted a very unattractive portrait of Gildo, as a tyrant to his people, and a slave to his avarice and lust. Ibid. at 1040.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (Cambridge University 1971) at 45.
- Blackhurst, "House of Nubel: Rebels or Players?" 59-75, at 74-75, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004), edited by Merrills.
- Abdallah Laroui, L'Histoire du Maghreb: Un essai de synthèse (Paris: Librairie François Maspero 1970), translated as The History of the Maghrib. An interpretive essay (Princeton University 1977) at 54-56.
- Laroui, The History of the Maghrib (Paris 1970; Princeton Univ. 1977) at 67-69.
- Alan Rushworth, "From Arzuges to Rustamids: State Formation and Regional Identity in the Pre-Saharan Zone" at 77-98, 77-78, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers. New perspectives on late antique North Africa (Aldershot: Ashgate 2004), edited by A. H. Merrills.
- Cf., Christian Courtois, Les Vandales et l'Afrique (Paris 1955), map at 334; modified and reproduced in Alan Rushworth, "From Arzuges to Rustamids: State Formation and Regional Identity in the Pre-Saharan Zone" at 77-98, 80, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers. New perspectives on late antique North Africa (Aldershot: Ashgate 2004), edited by A. H. Merrills.
- E.g., c.f., discussion of the Visigothic state at Toulouse, regarding the laws promulgated by the kings Euric (r.466-484) and Alaric II (r.484-507), namely the Codex Euricianus which sets out the personal law for the Goths, and the Lex Romana Visigothorum which states Roman law to be applied to the former provincial citizens of the Empire now under Gothic rule. Herwig Wolfram, Das Reich und die Germanun (Berlin: Wolf Jobst Siedler Verlag 1990), translated as The Roman Empire and Its Germanic Peoples (University of California 1997, 2005) at 156-158.
- Latin: National King of the Mauri and of the Romans. Alan Rushworth, "From Arzuges to Rustamids: State Formation and Regional Identity in the Pre-Saharan Zone" at 77-98, 86-88, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers. New perspectives on late antique North Africa (Aldershot: Ashgate 2004), edited by A. H. Merrills.
- Alan Rushworth, "From Arzuges to Rustamids: State Formation and Regional Identity in the Pre-Saharan Zone" at 77-98, 79 and 82-86, 87, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers. New perspectives on late antique North Africa (Aldershot: Ashgate 2004), edited by H. H. Merrills.
- Mark A. Handley, "Disputing the End of African Christianity" at 291-310, in Vandals, Romans and Berbers. New perspectives on late antique North Africa (Aldershot: Ashgate 2004), edited by H. H. Merrills.
- Hédi Slim, Ammar Mahjoubi, Khaled Belkhoja, Abdelmajid Ennabli, L'Antiquité (Tunis: Sud Éditions 2010) at 417-418, 423. [Histoire Générale de la Tunisie, Tome I].
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 261-285, at 283-285, in General History of Africa, Volume II. Ancient Civilizations of Africa (Paris: UNESCO 1990), edited by G. Mokhtar. Garmul, King of Mauretania, "destroyed a Byzantine army" in 571. Ibid. at 284.
- Wolfram, The Roman Empire and Its Germanic Peoples (Berlin 1990; Univ.of California 1997) at xi-xiii.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971), at 45-46.
- Herwig Wolfram, Das Reich und die Germanen (Berlin: Wolf Jobst Siedler 1990) translated as The Roman Empire and Its Germanic Peoples (University of California 1997), chap. 7, "The Vandals" at 159-182, 166-171 (Vandals), at 163, 166, 161-163 & 169-170 (Alans and Vandals), 163 & 165-167 (travel to Hispania, then to Carthage and capture).
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 48.
- A. Mahjoubi and P. Salama, "The Roman and post-Roman period in North Africa" 261-285, at 281, in General History of Africa, Volume II. Ancient Civilizations of Africa (Paris: UNESCO 1990), edited by G. Mokhtar.
- Walter Pohl, "The Vandals: Fragments of a Narrative" at 31-47, 41 (Berbers only military threat after conquest), in Vandals, Romans and Berbers (2004), edited by Merrill.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 47 (Rome, the islands), 50 (military posture).
- Wolfram, The Roman Empire and Its Germanic Peoples (Berlin 1990; Berkeley 1997) at 174-175.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 49-51.
- Herwig Wolfram, The Roman Empire and its Germanic Peoples (Berlin 1990; Berkeley 1997) at 173 (Vandal clothes at court). By a modern estimate, the population of Roman Africa would then have been about three million people. Wolfram (1990, 1997) at 167, citing Christian Courtois, Les Vandales et l'Afrique (Paris 2d ed. 1955) at 105 ff.
- Perkins, Tunisia (Westview 1986) at 23-24.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 48-49, 52-53.
- Also, see here above "Berber states".
- It is uncertain how many Berbers professed Christianity, Catholic or Donatist. Cf., H. Mones, "The conquest of North Africa and the Berber resistance" in General History of Africa (Univ.of California/UNESCO 1992) at 119-120, who opines that only a "marginal" few (called al-Afarika by Arabs) of Romanized Berbers and Punics were Christians, as well as Romans and Greeks.
- Contra: For strong indications that there was indeed substantial communities of Berber Christians, cf., e.g., here above the sections "Firmus and Gildo" and especially "Donatist schism" and "Berber states".
- A. A. Vasiliev, History of the Byzantine Empire (1917, 1923-25; Univ.of Wisconsin 1928-29, 1964) at vol. I, 176, 194-200, 211.
- Percy Sykes, A History of Persia (London: Macmillan 1915, 1921, 1930, reprinted New York: St. Martin's 1951) at vol. I, 480-486.
- For an early 20th-century view on these theological issues arising in early Christianity, cf., Dom Charles Poulet, Histoire de l'Eglise (Paris: Gabriel Beauchesne et sus Fils 1926, 1934), translated by Raemers as A History of the Catholic Church (St. Louis & London: Herder Book Co. 1951) at volume I: 238-244, and 301-307.
- The Sassanid Persians themselves soon would lose the battles of al-Qadisiyyah (637) and Nihavand (642) to the Arabs of Islam; their subsequent incorporation into the Muslim fold would result in mutual transformations. Richard N. Frye, The Golden Age of Persia (London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson 1975, 1977) at 54-73, 58, 60.
- Abun-Nasr, A History of the Maghrib (1971) at 63-65.