History of the Democratic Alliance (South Africa)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Although the Democratic Alliance of South Africa in its present form is fairly new, its roots can be traced far back in South African political history, through a complex sequence of splits and mergers.

History[edit]

Origins[edit]

The earliest ancestor of the modern day Democratic Alliance is the South African Party, which won the first general election in the Union of South Africa in 1910. The SAP was a merger of the South African Party and the Afrikaner Bond of the Cape Colony, Het Volk of Transvaal and Orangia Unie of the Orange Free State. The Progressive Party of the Cape Colony merged with Progressive Association of Transvaal and the Constitutional Party of the Orange Free State to form the Unionist Party. Natal had no institutionalised parties but politicians from the province joined the new parties. In the Cape Colony, the SAP were proponents of a multiracial franchise and its most prominent members were John Xavier Merriman and William Phillip Schreinier, whereas the Progressives led by Cecil Rhodes and Leander Starr Jameson were more firmly pro-British in orientation.

In the Union, the SAP was a broad-based party committed to unity between Afrikaners and English-speakers, typified by its leaders Louis Botha and Jan Smuts. Its more pro-British tendencies provoked a reaction from Afrikaner nationalists who formed the National Party in 1914 by J. B. M. Hertzog. The NP's rise in support and the decline of the Unionist Party led to their merger under the leadership of Smuts in 1920. The SAP lost power to a National-Labour coalition in 1924.

In 1934, the NP and the SAP entered into a coalition, which led to the creation of a merged United Party (UP), although a hardline nationalist faction led by D.F. Malan stayed out. The United Party included both liberal and conservative elements but followed a pro-Union, pro-British policy which resulted in Hertzog and his followers withdrawing from it 1939. The United Party lost power in 1948 to the National Party under Malan, who began to implement the policy of Apartheid. Smuts died two years later, his probable heir Jan Hendrif Hofmeyr had died in 1948. Hofmeyr and Piet van der Byl were said to have epitomised a more progressive outlook when addressing the racial question.

The United Party continued to exist after 1959 and was the source of several breakaway groups which merged with later ancestor parties. The party's uncertain response to Apartheid under the leadership of J.G.N. Strauss and De Villiers Graaff provoked considerable discord. Generally the party was critical of the injustices of the government's segregationist policies, but offered no clear alternative until its waning years in the 1970s, although it took an increasingly critical stance. In 1953, the Liberal Party was formed in response and existed until 1968, when it dissolved rather than restrict its membership on a racial basis. The Progressive Party was formed in 1959.

Progressive Movement[edit]

The Progressive Party (PP), was founded in 1959 when liberal members seceded from the United Party (UP). They could not agree with the inability of the UP to present an alternative to the National Party's apartheid policy. The PP emphasized constitutional reform, a Bill of Rights, an independent judiciary and the evolution towards federalism. These reform proposals were combined with advocacy of a free market economy. In 1961 only Helen Suzman was elected in parliament. For 13 years she was the only opponent of racial discrimination and other apartheid regime's abuses in the whites-only parliament, fighting against detention without trial, pass laws and influx control. From 1971 Colin Eglin was the party leader, without being a member of parliament himself. In 1974 the party won seven seats.

A year later, in July 1975, the Progressive Party merged with the Reform Party (RP), a breakaway party of the United Party. The outcome was the formation of the South African Progressive Reform Party (PRP). Former Reform Party leader Harry Schwarz was appointed chairman of the PRP's National Executive, while Eglin was elected leader.

By 1977, support for the United Party was in rapid decline, and further dissident UP members formed a Committee for a United Opposition, before joining the PRP to form the Progressive Federal Party (PFP). Later that year, the PFP became official opposition following the 1977 general election. The PFP drew support mainly from liberal English-speaking white South Africans, as owing to South Africa's apartheid laws, its membership was limited to the country's whites. The PFP was derided by right-wing whites, who claimed its initials stood for 'Packing for Perth', on account of the many white liberal supporters of the 'Progs' who were emigrating to Australia. Among the founders of the PFP included Japie Basson, a former National Party MP who had been expelled by Hendrik Verwoerd and formed his own National Union Party which later joined the United Party. Basson was one of the United Party members who left to join the Progressive Party, and eventually left the PFP and rejoined the NP in the 1980s.

What was left of the United Party merged with the Democratic Party, which had formed by moderate National Party dissidents in 1973 and led by former interior minister Theo Gerdener, to form the New Republic Party (NRP). Another offshoot of the UP was the South African Party (reviving the name of the original SAP). Both the NRP and SAP were more conservative than the PFP, but envisioned a federal solution to the country's racial question. The SAP grew closer to the ruling National Party and merged into it by 1980, and the growing verligte tendency within the National Party itself espoused expanded political participation for non-whites. The NRP was overshadowed by the PFP as an opposition party, in terminal decline by 1987 and dissolving itself shortly after. At the same time, disaffected NP members such as Dennis Worrall and Wynand Malan broke away and later formed the Independent Party which absorbed the remaining base of the NRP.

Frederik van Zyl Slabbert, PFP leader since 1979, resigned from parliament in 1986 because it had, in his view, become irrelevant. Later he formed the Institute for a Democratic Alternative for South Africa (IDASA). He was succeeded by Colin Eglin. The PFP was ousted as the official opposition by the far-right Conservative Party in the whites-only parliamentary elections held on 6 May 1987. This electoral blow led many of the PFP's leaders to question the value of participating in the whites-only parliament, and some of its MPs left to join the National Democratic Movement (NDM). The formation of the Independent Party (IP) of Denis Worrall further split the liberal opposition.

All of these currents reunited into the Democratic Party by 1989.

Parliamentary opposition to apartheid[edit]

Following the realignment of opposition politics in the 1970s, with the fall of the United Party and subsequent rise of the Progressive Federal Party as successor as the official parliamentary opposition, the National Party's authoritarian and apartheid polices faced much stronger parliamentary opposition.

Opposition to press restrictions[edit]

In 1979, the PFP launched the "strongest parliamentary measures" possible against the Advocate-General Act, that would prohibit press from reporting on allegations of corruption and irregularities without first having such allegations cleared. PFP Colin Eglin launched the attack on the bill, stating that it was an attempt by the National Party to "muzzle the press and deny the public right to know".[1][2] Helen Suzman, who attempted to delay the bill, argued that it was "essential that the press be no further restricted than it already was. It is essential that nothing hinders the press in its duty to inform the public".[3]

In 1980, the National Party introduced the National Key Points Act that made those responsible for unauthorised reporting of incidents of sabotage or other attakcs on declared national strategic targets a crime. These moves were slammed by MPs such as Harry Schwarz, who stated that "Society as a whole is not condemned because individuals transgress, and nor should the press as a whole be judges by the actions of individuals."[4][5] Stating that press restrictions marked a "turning point" in South African politics, he also argued that press freedom was a "precious treasure" and a free and courageous press was a major weapon in South Africa's defence against external threats.[6]

Bill of Rights proposal[edit]

During the Constitutional Reform Debate of 1983, the PFP attempted to incorporate a 'Bill of Rights' into the new constitution proposed by the National Party, the first motion of its kind ever brought before Parliament.[7] The motion was first submitted in August 1983, by Shadow Finance Minister Harry Schwarz. He stated that the Bill should guarantee freedom from discrimination on the ground of race, colour, sex or creed, freedom of conscience and religion, of thought, belief, opinion and expression, including freedom of the press, of association, peaceful assembly and movement, and freedom to pursue the gaining of a livelihood. It also included freedom from deprivation of life, liberty, security and property, except in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice. It would also guarantee equality before the law and equal protection and benefit of law.

Schwarz argued that if included in the constitution of the republic, it would act as a "protector of rights many people had struggled to achieve in South Africa" as well as to "act as an inspiration" to the people of South Africa and would "be a unifying factor in a country in which unity of people is essential for survival".[8] Helen Suzman, Shadow Law and Order Minister, argued that the exclusion of the bill would lead to "a further loss of civil liberties by all South Africans - in short, to one-party, one-group dictatorship in this country".[9] It was also argued that the bill would be a statement of intent demonstrating that the days of discrimination on the grounds of race or colour had come to an end.[10]

While virtually all MPs of the Progressive Federal Party supported the bill, no other party in Parliament supported it.[11] Rejecting Schwarz’s proposal, Daan van der Merwe of the Conservative Party stated that the bill, based on a "leftist-liberal political philosophy", would jeopardise the freedom of the white man.[12] New Republic Party leader Vause Raw said Schwarz "a master at platitudes" was seeking idealistic freedoms that did not exist anywhere in the world.[13] Following the rejection of Schwarz’s bill, fellow PFP MPs' Helen Suzman, Colin Eglin, Ray Swart and Dave Dalling attempted a further four times to introduce a Bill of Rights.[14] The Bills' were effectively blocked by the National Party by placing them at the end of the order paper.[15]

Democratic era[edit]

After the 1987 elections, the new PFP leader Zach de Beer concluded negotiations with the IP and the NDM to merge into the Democratic Party in 1989, and proceeded to win 36 seats in the elections that year. The DP played a vital role in the negotiation of an interim constitution which includes most of the original progressive principles and ideals. In 1991 Harry Schwarz, one of the party's founders and most prominent leaders was appointed South African Ambassador to the United States, the first opposition member to become an ambassador in South African history. In the 1994 general election, the first after apartheid was abolished, the party won only 1.7% of the vote and 10 seats in parliament. Nelson Mandela's eldest daughter Makaziwe and F. W. De Klerk's brother Willem (who was a co-founder of the party) voted for the Democratic Party in these elections.[16]

Helen Zille, the current DA leader

Soon after the elections, De Beer was succeeded by Tony Leon, who emphasized the protection of human rights, federalism and free enterprise. The party improved its performance during the 1999 general election to receive 9.6% of the vote and 38 seats, replacing the New National Party (NNP) as official opposition.

The DP merged with the NNP in 2000 to form the Democratic Alliance (DA). The much smaller Federal Alliance later also merged with the DA in preparation for the local government elections of 5 December 2000. The DA won 22% of the vote in the local government elections and secured an outright majority in the Cape Town unicity with 52.5% of the vote compared to 38% for the ANC. Peter Marais became mayor of Cape Town, and the DA also took control of 20 local municipalities in the Western Cape.

The brittle alliance with the NNP lasted only until October 2001, when the NNP left to form a new alliance with the African National Congress. The Federal Alliance also left the DA to instead join the Freedom Front Plus. With the defection of some NNP members in the Western Cape Provincial Legislature the DA lost control of the province, while the defection of some NNP councillors during the October 2002 floor-crossing window resulted in the DA losing control of Cape Town and most of the local municipalities in the Western Cape.

With the 2004 general election, the DA and ANC increased their vote share, at the expense of other opposition parties. The DA won 12.4% of the votes and 50 seats, and remains the second largest political party in South Africa. By contrast, the NNP was in terminal decline and won only 7 seats. It merged with the ANC in 2005. A political realignment had occurred in the sense that the white and Coloured electorate the NP/NNP had retained in 1994 shifted to the DA. The NNP had also been beset by internal dissension and an uncertain position towards the ANC, later cooperating with it.

On 1 March 2006, the DA won 14.8% of the vote in the local government elections, and regained control of the City of Cape Town from the ANC - the only Metropolitan Council in South Africa not controlled by the ANC. Helen Zille was elected executive mayor on 15 March 2006 and formed a coalition with six smaller parties as the DA failed to win an outright majority in the council. In the local government elections the DA had won 41.8% of the vote in Cape Town compared to 38.5% for the ANC. Two months later, Zille won the leadership of the party in a landslide vote following the retirement of long-serving Tony Leon.

As Zille opted to remain as mayor of Cape Town as well as adopt the position of leader of the DA, it was decided that another DA member would be required to represent Zille and the party in the National Assembly. Following a vote which was mainly contested between former NNP MP, Tertius Delport and Sandra Botha, Botha triumphed. Botha served as parliamentary leader until announcing her retirement from party politics in January 2009.[17]

Re-launch and 2009 elections[edit]

On 15 November 2008, the DA convened a meeting on Constitutional Hill to re-launch the party as one which no longer acts as an opposition but offers voters another choice for government. Along with this, the party also introduced a new logo, featuring a rising sun over the colours of the South African flag (representing the Rainbow Nation), and a new slogan, "One Nation, One Future."

This is in line with the new strategy the party is implementing with regard to a non-racial South Africa where everyone has equal opportunities.[18][19] Party leader, Helen Zille said the new DA would be "more reflective of our rich racial, linguistic and cultural heritage".[20] Zille has emphasised that she wants the party to be a "party for all the people" and not decline into a "shrinking, irrelevant minority".[21] She has also spoken out against the party's image as being exclusively 'white'.[22]

Fiftieth anniversary[edit]

On 13 November 2009, the Democratic Alliance marked the fiftieth anniversary of the formation of the Progressive Party in Cape Town in the old chamber of parliament. Around 20 former MPs from the DA's predecessor parties attended. Elder statesmen of the DA Colin Eglin, Harry Schwarz and Jan Steytler, along with current DA leader Helen Zille gave speeches.[23] While praising the liberal contribution to opposing and ending apartheid, they stated how South Africa and the DA still had much work to do.[24] Harry Schwarz delivered his last ever speech, following his death in February 2010. He paid tribute to Helen Zille, calling her the embodiment of the principles he and others had fought for and warned that "Freedom is incomplete if it is exercised in poverty", a phase he often used. Colin Eglin praised the liberal opposition to apartheid, stating that the principles that they had fought had been "entrenched in the Constitution". Jan Steytler stated that South Africa wanted to "face the future, not with fear, but with confidence that we can live together in harmony in a multi-racial country."[25]

Leaders[edit]

Leaders of the Democratic Alliance, and its predecessor parties:

Entered office Left office Party name
1 Jan Steytler 1 November 1959 December 1970 Progressive Party
2 Harry Lawrence2 December 1970 February 1971
3 Harry Schwarz 3 February 1975 July 1975 Reform Party
3 Colin Eglin4 February 1971 July 1975
July 1975 1977 Progressive Reform Party
1977 1979 Progressive Federal Party
4 Frederik van Zyl Slabbert 1979 1986
5 Colin Eglin 1986 1988
6 Zach de Beer 1988 1989
7,8 Zach de Beer, Denis Worrall and Wynand Malan5 1989 1994 Democratic Party
9 Tony Leon 1994 2000
2000 May 2007 Democratic Alliance
10 Helen Zille6 May 2007 present
  • 1 Between 1961 and 1970, Steytler served as party leader from outside Parliament, where Helen Suzman was the party's sole representative.
  • 2 Interim leader.
  • 3 Schwarz was leader of the Reform Party that broke away from the United Party and which merged with the Progressive Party.
  • 4 First Progressive Leader of the Opposition in Parliament (from 1977).
  • 5 Co-leaders, following the formation of the Democratic Party in 1989.
  • 6 Zille, like Steytler and Lawrence, serves as leader from outside of Parliament, where she is represented by a separate Parliamentary Leader - first Sandra Botha, and then later Athol Trollip.

Parliamentary Leaders[edit]

Parliamentary leaders of the Democratic Alliance and its predecessor parties, in the absence of a sitting party leader in Parliament:

On behalf of Entered office Left office Party name
1 Helen Suzman Jan Steytler, Harry Lawrence and Colin Eglin October 1961 April 1974 Progressive Party
2 Sandra Botha Helen Zille May 2007 April 2008 Democratic Alliance
3 Athol Trollip May 2008 October 2011
4 Lindiwe Mazibuko October 2011 present

Chairpersons[edit]

Federal chairpersons (sometimes referred to as 'national chairpersons') and chairpersons of the party's federal council (sometimes referred to as the party's 'federal executive' or the 'national council'), since the merger of the Reform Party and the Progressive Party in 1975:

Federal (National) Chairperson Years Party name Chairperson of the Federal Council
Ray Swart 1975–1977 Progressive Reform Party Harry Schwarz
1977–1979 Progressive Federal Party
Colin Eglin 1979–1986 Alexander Boraine
Peter Gastrow 1986–1987 Ken Andrew
Helen Suzman 1987–1989
Tian van der Merwe 1989–1991 Democratic Party Dave Gant
Ken Andrew 1991–1997
Errol Moorcroft 1997–2000 Douglas Gibson
Joe Seremane 2000–2010 Democratic Alliance James Selfe
Wilmot James 2010–present

Chief Executive Officers[edit]

Chief executive officers of the Democratic Alliance:

Started Ended
1 Ryan Coetzee November 2004 July 2009
2 Jonathan Moakes July 2009 incumbent

Electoral results[edit]

The following table shows the electoral performance of the Democratic Party and its predecessors in elections to the House of Assembly prior to 1994. These elections were restricted to white citizens.

Election Party name Total votes Share of votes Seats Share of seats Party Leader(s) Notes
1961 Progressive Party 69,045 8.6% 1 0.6% Jan Steytler National Party (NP) victory
1966 Progressive Party 39,717 3.1% 1 0.6% Jan Steytler NP victory
1970 Progressive Party 51,760 3.5% 1 0.6% Jan Steytler NP victory
1974 Progressive Party 58,768 5.3% 7 4.1% Colin Eglin NP victory
1977 Progressive Federal Party 177,705 16.7% 17 10.3% Colin Eglin NP victory; PFP gains official opposition status from United Party
1981 Progressive Federal Party 265,297 19.4% 27 15.2% Frederik van Zyl Slabbert NP victory; PFP remains official opposition
1987 Progressive Federal Party 288,579 13.9% 20 11.2% Colin Eglin NP victory; PFP loses official opposition status to Conservative Party
1989 Democratic Party 431,444 20.0% 34 19.1% Zach de Beer, Denis Worrall and Wynand Malan NP victory

The following table shows electoral performance for the Democratic Party and the Democratic Alliance in elections to the National Assembly since the advent of democracy in 1994.

Election Total votes Share of votes Seats Share of seats Party Leader Notes
1994 338,426 1.73% 7 1.75% Zach de Beer ANC victory
1999 1,527,337 9.56% 38 9.50% Tony Leon ANC victory; DP becomes official opposition
2004 1,931,201 12.37% 50 12.50% Tony Leon ANC victory; DA retains official opposition status
2009 2,945,829 16.66% 67 16.75% Helen Zille ANC victory; DA retains official opposition status and wins Western Cape province

References[edit]

  1. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=2069580
  2. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/Imagedir/Image4/1979/031/02144.tif
  3. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=2071420
  4. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=2073448
  5. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=2070660
  6. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/Imagedir/Image4/1979/031/01823.tif
  7. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=1917284
  8. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/Imagedir/Image4/1983/027/07120.tif
  9. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=1917303
  10. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/Imagedir/Image4/1983/027/07112.tif
  11. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=1917319
  12. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=1917014
  13. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/Imagedir/Image4/1983/027/07128.tif
  14. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=1911320
  15. ^ http://www.samedia.uovs.ac.za/cgi-bin/getpdf?id=1910703
  16. ^ Martin Meredith; Nelson Mandela: A Biography.
  17. ^ "Botha tight-lipped about her future". Primedia. 8 January 2009. 
  18. ^ "DA relaunches as 'party of government'". IOL. 15 November 2008. 
  19. ^ "DA relaunches in Johannesburg". SABC. 15 November 2008. 
  20. ^ "‘Yes we can’, chant DA faithful". The Citizen. 16 November 2008. 
  21. ^ "Zille: In for the long haul". Mail&Guardian. 20 November 2008. 
  22. ^ "DA is not a 'white party', says Zille". IOL. 24 November 2008. 
  23. ^ http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71619?oid=152985&sn=Detail
  24. ^ http://www.polity.org.za/article/da-statement-by-helen-zille-democratic-alliance-leader-on-the-anniversary-of-the-launch-of-the-progressive-party-in-the-weekly-newsletter-13112009-2009-11-13
  25. ^ http://www.polity.org.za/print-version/progressives-look-back-proudly-2009-11-13