Hocutt v. Wilson
Hocutt v. Wilson, N.C. Super. Ct. (1933) (unreported), was the first attempt to desegregate higher education in the United States. It was initiated by two African American lawyers from Durham, North Carolina, Conrad O. Pearson and Cecil McCoy, with the support of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP). The case was ultimately dismissed for lack of standing, but it served as a test case for challenging the “separate but equal” doctrine in education and was a precursor to Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954) (holding that segregated public schools were unconstitutional).
Students at the North Carolina College for Negroes, which is now North Carolina Central University in Durham, were plaintiffs in desegregation suits against the all-white University of North Carolina system. North Carolina was an ideal place for civil rights work because Durham had a generally non-violent racial status quo, the state was slightly more progressive than other Deep South states, and it was close to Washington D.C., where Charles Hamilton Houston taught the most prominent civil rights lawyers. The plaintiff was Thomas Hocutt, a student at the North Carolina College for Negroes who sought admission to the pharmacy school at the University of North Carolina. Conrad Odell Pearson and Cecil McCoy brought the case in February 1933.
Pearson graduated from Howard University’s law school under Charles Hamilton Houston and began practicing in Durham in 1932. McCoy graduated from Brooklyn Law School in 1931 and also practiced in Durham. Initially, Pearson and McCoy wrote to NAACP General Secretary Walter White for financial support. White ratified the case and sent a copy of the Margold Report on discrimination in public schools to support the attorneys. The NAACP also sent Harvard-educated William Hastie to assist Pearson and McCoy on the case.
The suit did not have the support of many black leaders in Durham. The newspaper for the North Carolina Mutual Life Insurance Company declared “[w]e have turned from pursuing the phantom of political spoils ... and are settling down to development along safe lines.” The Durham Morning Herald warned, “[t]o our way of thinking, [Pearson and McCoy] will find in the end that they have won not a victory but a costly defeat.” Additionally, James E. Shepard, president and founder of North Carolina Central University promoted segregated in-state institutions for black graduates. Shepard wanted the state to fund graduate programs for black students at his university so he refused to release Hocutt’s transcript.
When Pearson and McCoy failed to present an official transcript, Hocutt no longer satisfied the admission requirements for the Pharmacy School and the case was dismissed for lack of standing. In the end, Shepard’s plan prevailed because the state provided North Carolina Central University with an operating budget of $23,000 in 1934 and the university built graduate schools comparable to the white-only schools in the state. Despite defeat, the Hocutt case inspired other Durham lawyers to initiate civil rights actions between the 1930s and 1950s.
- "Brown v. Board at Fifty: "With an Even Hand": A Century of Racial Segregation". Library of Congress. 1849–1950. Retrieved 2013-04-24.
- The Center For Urban Affairs, North Carolina State University, Paths Toward Freedom: A Bibliographical History of Blacks and Indians in North Carolina by Blacks and Indians 172 (1976).
- See, Durham Civil Rights Leader and Lawyer, Pearson, Dies, Durham Morning Herald, June 27, 1984, at 1A.
- Samuel R. Diamont, Local Civil Rights Litigators: Durham’s African American Attorneys 1933-1954, 21 (2008) (published Ph.D. dissertation, North Carolina Central University) (on file with North Carolina Central University Archives Department).
- Id. at 31.
- Id. at 30.
- University of North Carolina, Documenting the American South, Oral History Interview with Conrad Odell Pearson, April 18, 1979. Interview H-0218. Southern Oral History Program Collection (#4007), http://docsouth.unc.edu/sohp/H-0218/menu.html.
- Diamont, supra note 4, at 30.
- Nathan R. Margold, Preliminary Report to the Joint Committee Supervising the Expenditure of the 1930 Appropriation by the American Fund for Public Service (1931).
- Id. at 32.
- Osha Gray Davidson, The Best of Enemies: Race and Redemption in the New South 50 (1996).
- Leslie Brown, Upbuilding Black Durham: Gender, Class, and Black Community Development in the Jim Crow South 310 (2008) (quoting Editorial, Durham Morning Herald, Feb. 1933, at 21, 24.
- Diamont, supra note 4, at 32.
- Id. at 33.
- See, North Carolina Central University, School of Library and Information Sciences, webpage, http://www.nccu.edu/academics/sc/slis/ (The School of Library and Information Sciences was established in 1939).
- See generally, Diamont, supra note 4.