Hudson River State Hospital
Hudson River State Hospital
Side view of main building, early 2000s
|Location:||Town of Poughkeepsie, NY|
|Area:||296 acres (120 ha)|
|Architect:||Frederick Clarke Withers, Calvert Vaux, and Frederick Law Olmsted|
|Architectural style:||High Victorian Gothic|
|Governing body:||Hudson Heritage LLC, CPC Resources|
|Added to NRHP:||June 29, 1989|
|Designated NHL:||June 30, 1989|
The Hudson River State Hospital, is a former New York state psychiatric hospital which operated from 1873 until its closure in the early 2000s. The campus is notable for its main building, known as a "Kirkbride," which has been designated a National Historic Landmark due to its exemplary High Victorian Gothic architecture, the first use of that style for an American institutional building. It is located on US 9 on the Poughkeepsie-Hyde Park town line.
Frederick Clarke Withers designed the hospital's buildings in 1867. Calvert Vaux and Frederick Law Olmsted designed the grounds. It was intended to be completed quickly, but went far over its original schedule and budget. The hospital opened on October 18, 1871 as the Hudson River State Hospital for the Insane and admitted its first 40 patients. Construction, however, was far from over and would continue for another 25 years. A century later, it was slowly closed down as psychiatric treatment had changed enough that large hospitals were no longer needed, and its services are now served by the nearby Hudson River Psychiatric Center.
The campus was closed and abandoned in 2003 and since then has fallen into a state of disrepair. Authorities struggle with the risk of arson and vandals after suspicion of an intentionally set fire. The male bedding ward, south of the main building, was critically damaged in a 2007 fire caused by lightning. The property is currently owned by CPC Resources, which has placed the land for sale.
The Hospital includes a number of unique buildings:
- Main Building (the Kirkbride), a High Victorian Gothic building used for administrative purposes
- Patient Wings, which split off the Kirkbride, housed patients. The male ward splits off to the south, and is much larger than the female wing to the north. It was struck by lightning on May 31, 2007, igniting a serious fire.
- Presbyterian and Roman Catholic churches were available to patients, one of which was near the male ward.
- A morgue, with refrigerated cold chambers was located on the northeast corner of the property
- A power house was built, and still stands, to the northeast of the Kirkbride to provide power to the various buildings. Its smokestack is visible from Route 9 as well as nearby Marist College.
- Ryon Hall opened in 1934 and housed violent or criminally insane patients. It is on the very southern property line, visible from Home Depot, in the shadow of the much larger Cheney Building.
- The Clarence O. Cheney Building, opened in 1952, is a ten-story steel structure with a brick facade. Named after Dr. Clarence O. Cheney, MD (1887-1947), the president of the American Psychiatry Association from 1935-1936, and hospital's superintendent from the 1920s until 1946, the building held doctor's offices and medical examination rooms. The building did provide some patient housing.
- The Snow Recreation Center opened in 1971 and provided recreational relief for patients, sporting two bowling alley lanes, a lunch counter, an auditorium, and an indoor swimming pool. Skylights provided natural lighting.
The entire facility was built over the last three decades of the 19th century, at great cost. Once complete, it would be used as intended for much of the first half of the next century. As psychiatry moved away from inpatient treatments, it began to decline in use until its closure at century's end. Today, it is slowly deteriorating out of public view as it awaits reuse.
19th century 
New York had opened what has since become Utica Psychiatric Center in 1843, the first state-run institution for the mentally ill. By the Civil War it was reaching its capacity, so in 1866 then Governor Reuben Fenton appointed a five-member state commission to look for a site for a second hospital in the Hudson Valley between New York and Albany, to serve New York City and the counties of Eastern New York. In January of the following year the members reported to the governor that they had temporarily secured a 296-acre (120 ha) tract of land overlooking the Hudson River north of Poughkeepsie, formerly part of the estates of James Roosevelt and William A. Davis. It would cost nothing as the citizens of Dutchess County would be offering it to the state as a gift. Two months later, the state accepted.
A nine-member Board of Managers was created and appointed to initiate and oversee construction of the actual building. They chose architect Frederick Clarke Withers to design a building according to the Kirkbride Plan, then a popular theory for the design of mental institutions. Withers planned a building 1,500 feet (457 m) in length and over 500,000 square feet (45,000 m²) in area, most of it two wings that would house patients. It was the first institutional building in the U.S. designed in the High Victorian Gothic style. Calvert Vaux and Frederick Law Olmstead, designers of New York's Central Park, laid out the surrounding landscape. Like Withers, they had been mentored by the influential Andrew Jackson Downing in nearby Newburgh.
The centerpiece of his design was the administration building, which branched off into two wings, composed of six parallel pavilions that flanked the central structure. The two wings, designed to hold 300 patients of either sex, were divided by a chapel placed between them in the yard behind the administration building so that patients could not see into the rooms of the opposite sex. The building and landscape plan were meant to aid in patients' recovery, by giving them adequate space and privacy and imbuing their healing with a sense of grandeur.
Construction began in 1868, with the cost estimated at $800,000. Cost-saving measures included the construction of a new dock on the Hudson so that building materials could be shipped more directly to the site, quarrying and cutting the foundation stones on site, mixing concrete from local materials and hiring local craftsmen instead of a general contractor. The board also deviated from the plan it had sent the state, in particular by building a shorter female wing when it came to believe that fewer patients of that sex would be admitted. As a result it is one of the few Kirkbride hospitals to have been built with asymmetrical wings.
Spending controversies and delays 
Despite the efforts to save money, the board was slightly over the $100,000 it had expected to spend that year, according to its first annual report. The main building was completed and opened, with 40 patients admitted, in October 1871. As work continued on other structures planned for the complex, so did the cost overruns. In 1873, the year county residents had been promised the hospital would be finished, the New York Times ran an editorial harshly criticizing the board for not only having gone way over budget but for lavish extravagance and waste:
The managers have entirely disregarded the law by which they were authorized to act. They have altered the plans and specifications ... Some of the details of the extravagance of the board are amazing. For instance, the first part of the work undertaken was the construction of a reservoir, into which the water was pumped from the river through an eight-inch (20 cm) iron pipe; from the reservoir the water was carried to the hospital by a twelve-inch (30 cm) iron pipe, the engine and machinery employed being on the scale of those used in supplying a neighboring city of 20,000 inhabitants. The cost of the reservoir was $100,000. Thirty thousand dollars was expended in blasting some rough rocks jutting into the reservoir, and the Superintendent gave as a reason for this that, if some of the patients were missing, they might want to rake the bottom of the reservoir to find the bodies, and with this the rocks would interfere ... The floors are laid in yellow Southern pine, the most expensive of the flooring, fitted and cut in a way greatly to enhance the cost. The heating is arranged on a scale that, with only 150 patients, ten tons (9 tonnes) of coal per day is consumed. The mention of these items sufficiently explains the disappearance of $1,200,000 of the people's money.
Some efforts were made to stop the project, but the legislature continued to appropriate funds despite further revelations like these. Construction continued until 1895, when further money could not be found. Despite this expenditure of time and money, the hospital's original plan was still not complete, and never would be.
20th century 
A Refrigerating Plant was built 1948 and a Tubercular Hospital was built in 1951 to the designs of Samuel Juster of DePace & Juster. Buildings continued to be opened and reopened in the 20th century, and as late as 1952 the institution was treating as many as 6,000 patients.
Changes in the treatment of mental illness, such as psychotherapy and psychotropic drugs, were making large-scale facilities relics and allowing more patients to lead more normal lives without being committed. Though 1971 saw the addition of the Snow Recreational center, by the late 1970s the hospital administration had decided to shut down the two main wings as few patients were residing in them and due to neglect some of the floors had collapsed. The hospital housed 1,780 patients by 1976. The state offices of Mental Health and Historic Preservation clashed over a plan to demolish the wings, even after the National Historic Landmark designation in 1989.
In the 1990s, more and more of the hospital site would be abandoned as its services were needed less and less. It was consolidated with another Dutchess County mental hospital, Harlem Valley Psychiatric Center, in 1994 and closed in 2003. The center moved operations into a much smaller building nearby, Ross Pavilion, located on a hilltop on the east side of Rt 9G.
21st Century 
In 2005, the state sold the property and subsequently, the Empire State Development Corporation sold 156 acres (63 ha) including the Main Building to Hudson Heritage LLC, a subsidiary of the Chazen Companies, for $2.75 million. Hudson Heritage and Chazen had planned to thoroughly renovate the Main Building into a combination hotel/apartment complex as the centerpiece of a residential/commercial campus, Hudson Heritage Park.
Redevelopment plans hit two setbacks in the mid- to late-2000s: in 2005, the Town of Poughkeepsie imposed a moratorium on new construction to cope with its growth. Hudson Heritage had been seeking to have a "historic revitalization district" created for the property that would help spur its growth.
Then, on May 31, 2007, lightning struck the sprawling south wing, which held male housing, causing one of the most serious fires in Dutchess County's history. It is unclear whether that portion of the building can be effectively restored after such severe damage.
In the meantime, the property has remained closed to the public, with signs posted at fenced-off entrances. Local firefighters have complained, after dealing with two fires in April 2010 that appeared to be deliberately set, that the property is not adequately secured against trespassing.
As of May 2012, the campus is owned by CPC Resources, a subsidiary of the New York City-based Community Preservation Corporation, a non-profit mortgage lender that finances multifamily developments. CPC has placed the 162-acre parcel on the market, citing that the poor economy has hindered timely development. Walmart has shown a strong interest in the property, but Poughkeepsie Town Supervisor Todd Tancredi noted that the Town Board cannot envision such a large piece of land used for a single store.
- "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. 2007-01-23.
- "Hudson River State Hospital, Main Building". National Historic Landmark summary listing. National Park Service. 2007-09-15.
- Carolyn Pitts (February, 1989). PDF (774 KB). National Park Service and PDF (1.34 MB)
- "Hudson River State Hospital for the Insane". New York Times. December 27, 1872. Retrieved May 26, 2012.
- Acts of Conscience:World War II, Mental Institutions, and Religious Objectors. 2009. Retrieved May 27, 2012.
- "Hudson River State Hospital - Cheney Building". Retrieved 2012-05-27.
- "Psychiatric Quarterly, Vol 21, No. 4". Retrieved May 26, 2012.
- "Patient Charged with Rape". The Evening News. September 21, 1987. Retrieved May 26, 2012.
- "Hudson River Insane Hospital". The New York Times. December 25, 1868., cited at Hudson River State Hospital, retrieved from historic51.org November 11, 2007.
- "Hudson River State Hospital". Retrieved 2007-11-11.
- Carla Yanni, The Architecture of Madness: Insane Asylums in the United States, Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press, 2007, 113-14
- "The Hudson River State Hospital". Harper's Weekly. February 28, 1974. Retrieved 2007-11-13.
- Fornabai, Michelle. "Advanced Architecture Studio IV". Archived from the original on 2007-09-07. Retrieved 2007-11-13.
- "Hudson River State Hospital". Retrieved 2007-11-13.
- "An Extraordinary Job". July 4, 1863. Retrieved 2007-11-13.
- American Architects Directory, First Edition (New York City: R.R. Bowker LLC, 1956), p.236
- "Honest Mistake is Laid to Rest". The Milwaukee Sentinel. June 16, 1977. Retrieved 2012-05-26.
- Rowe, Claudia (June 30, 2001). "Modern Efficiency Displaces Historic Psychiatric Hospital". The New York Times. Retrieved 2007-11-15.
- "Redevelopment Plan". Retrieved 2007-11-14.
- "Hudson Heritage Park". Retrieved 2007-11-14.
- Valkys, Michael (February 17, 2006). "Town Amends its Building Moratorium". Poughkeepsie Journal. Retrieved 2007-11-14.
- Pizzutti, Christine (June 1, 2007). "Fire engulfs building at former psychiatric center". Poughkeepsie Journal. Retrieved 2007-11-15.[dead link]
- Johnson, Bill. "6+ Alarm Structure Fire - Hudson River Psychiatric Center - Fairview Fire District". Retrieved 2007-11-15.
- Valkys, Michael (May 3, 2010). "Suspicious fires at psychiatric hospital's old campus bring security push". Poughkeepsie Journal (Gannett Corporation). Retrieved May 3, 2010.[dead link]
- Davis, John (April 28, 2012). "Psych center site development plan stalls". Poughkeepsie Journal (Gannett Corporation). Retrieved May 26, 2012.
- Historic 51, site devoted to history and preservation of Main Building.
- High Definition video from Kirkbrides HD
- Forbidden Places, history, original postcards and photos from 2004.
Videos of 2007 fire