Human Accomplishment

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Human Accomplishment : The Pursuit of Excellence in the Arts and Sciences, 800 B.C. to 1950
Author Charles Murray
Cover artist Robert Bull Design
Country United States
Publisher HarperCollins
Publication date
9 October 2003 (2003-10-09)
Pages 668
ISBN 006019247X, 9780060192471
OCLC 52047270

Human Accomplishment: The Pursuit of Excellence in the Arts and Sciences, 800 B.C. to 1950 is a book published in 2003 by Charles Murray, most widely known as the co-author of The Bell Curve, surveying outstanding contributions to the arts and sciences from ancient times to the mid-twentieth century. The book attempts to quantify and explain human accomplishment worldwide in the fields of arts and sciences by calculating the amount of space allocated to them in reference works, an area of research sometimes referred to as historiometry. HarperCollins published the 668-page book.

Index scores[edit]

Murray ranks the leading 4,000 innovators in several fields of human accomplishment from 800 BC to 1950. In each field Murray identifies a number of sources (leading encyclopedias, histories and surveys) providing information about the leading figures in the field. The rankings are made from information in these sources. A raw score is determined based on how many sources mention and on how much space in each source is devoted to a person. Then these raw scores are normalized so that the lowest score is 1 and the highest score is 100. The resulting scores are called "Index Scores".

The categories of human accomplishment where significant figures are ranked in the book are as follows: Astronomy, Biology, Chemistry, Earth Sciences, Physics, Mathematics, Medicine, Technology, Combined Sciences, Chinese Philosophy, Indian Philosophy, Western Philosophy, Western Music, Chinese Painting, Japanese Art, Western Art, Arabic Literature, Chinese Literature, Indian Literature, Japanese Literature, and Western Literature. The omission of several relative categories, including a broader Chinese art category or an Indian art category, are due to a lack of identifiable figures as most of the work is anonymous.

The following are some examples of the rankings found for individual categories.

Top Figures by Field[edit]

Combined Sciences[edit]

Figure Index score
Isaac Newton 100
Galileo Galilei 89
Aristotle 78
Johannes Kepler 53
Antoine Lavoisier 51
René Descartes 51
Christiaan Huygens 49
Pierre-Simon Laplace 48
Albert Einstein 48
Michael Faraday 46
Louis Pasteur 46
Ptolemy 43
Robert Hooke 41
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 40
Ernest Rutherford 40
Leonhard Euler 39
Charles Darwin 37
Jöns Jacob Berzelius 36
Euclid 36
James Clerk Maxwell 35

Astronomy[edit]

Figure Index score
Galileo Galilei 100
Johannes Kepler 93
William Herschel 88
Pierre-Simon Laplace 79
Nicolaus Copernicus 75
Ptolemy 73
Tycho Brahe 68
Edmond Halley 57
Giovanni Domenico Cassini 53
Hipparchus 49
Walter Baade 47
Edwin Hubble 45
Friedrich Bessel 39
William Huggins 38
George Ellery Hale 37
Arthur Eddington 37
Ejnar Hertzsprung 35
Heinrich Wilhelm Matthias Olbers 33
Gerard Kuiper 32
Johannes Hevelius 30

Biology[edit]

Figure Index score
Charles Darwin 100
Aristotle 94
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck 88
Georges Cuvier 83
Thomas Hunt Morgan 75
Carl Linnaeus 59
William Harvey 51
Theodor Schwann 48
Stephen Hales 48
Jan Swammerdam 47
Marcello Malpighi 45
Claude Bernard 45
Hugo de Vries 44
Karl Ernst von Baer 43
John Ray 42
Ernst Haeckel 41
Lazzaro Spallanzani 38
Gregor Mendel 38
Pliny the Elder 37
Albrecht von Haller 37

Chemistry[edit]

Figure Index score
Antoine Lavoisier 100
Jöns Jacob Berzelius 67
Carl Wilhelm Scheele 53
Joseph Priestley 49
Humphry Davy 46
Robert Boyle 42
John Dalton 38
Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac 37
Joseph Black 33
William Ramsay 31
Justus Liebig 31
William Crookes 30
Claude Louis Berthollet 29
Linus Pauling 27
August Kekulé 27
Dmitry Mendeleyev 25
Jan Baptist van Helmont 25
Frederick Soddy 25
Martin Heinrich Klaproth 23
Robert Bunsen 22

Earth Sciences[edit]

Figure Index score
Charles Lyell 100
James Hutton 77
William Smith 55
Georgius Agricola 51
Abraham Gottlob Werner 46
Roderick Murchison 40
Matthew Fontaine Maury 40
Louis Agassiz 37
Jean-Étienne Guettard 37
Carl Gustaf Mosander 37
Horace-Bénédict de Saussure 35
Nicolas Desmarest 33
Alfred Wegener 33
Alexandre Brongniart 31
Adam Sedgwick 31
Thomas Chrowder Chamberlin 29
Vilhelm Bjerknes 29
Eilhard Mitscherlich 29
Per Teodor Cleve 29
Maurice Ewing 26

Physics[edit]

Figure Index score
Isaac Newton 100
Albert Einstein 100
Ernest Rutherford 88
Michael Faraday 86
Galileo Galilei 83
Henry Cavendish 57
Niels Bohr 52
J. J. Thomson 50
James Clerk Maxwell 50
Pierre Curie 47
Gustav Kirchhoff 43
Enrico Fermi 42
Werner Heisenberg 41
Marie Curie 41
Paul Dirac 40
James Prescott Joule 40
Christiaan Huygens 39
William Gilbert 37
Thomas Young 37
Robert Hooke 36

Mathematics[edit]

Figure Index score
Leonhard Euler 100
Isaac Newton 89
Euclid 83
Carl Friedrich Gauss 81
Pierre de Fermat 72
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 72
René Descartes 54
Georg Cantor 50
Blaise Pascal 47
Bernhard Riemann 47
David Hilbert 40
Jakob Bernoulli 40
Diophantus 39
Gerolamo Cardano 37
François Viète 36
Adrien-Marie Legendre 36
John Wallis 36
Augustin-Louis Cauchy 35
Fibonacci 34
Archimedes 33

Medicine[edit]

Figure Index score
Louis Pasteur 100
Hippocrates 93
Robert Koch 90
Galen 74
Paracelsus 68
Paul Ehrlich 59
René Laennec 54
Elmer McCollum 49
Alexander Fleming 47
Ambroise Paré 46
Emil Adolf von Behring 44
Joseph Lister 43
Kitasato Shibasaburō 42
Thomas Sydenham 40
Andreas Vesalius 38
Gerhard Domagk 36
Alexis Carrel 36
Sigmund Freud 34
John Hunter 34
Ignaz Semmelweis 34

Technology[edit]

Figure Index score
James Watt 100
Thomas Edison 100
Leonardo da Vinci 60
Christiaan Huygens 51
Archimedes 51
Guglielmo Marconi 50
Vitruvius 43
John Smeaton 37
Henry Bessemer 34
Thomas Newcomen 33
Charles Babbage 33
Carl Wilhelm Siemens 32
John Wilkinson 32
Benjamin Franklin 32
Charles Wheatstone 32
Alfred Nobel 32
Michael Faraday 31
Denis Papin 31
George Stephenson 30
Samuel Morse 30

Western Philosophy[edit]

Figure Index score
Aristotle 100
Plato 87
Immanuel Kant 74
René Descartes 51
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel 46
Thomas Aquinas 39
John Locke 37
David Hume 36
Augustine 30
Baruch Spinoza 27
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 27
Socrates 26
Arthur Schopenhauer 24
George Berkeley 21
Friedrich Nietzsche 20
Thomas Hobbes 19
Bertrand Russell 18
Jean-Jacques Rousseau 17
Plotinus 17
Johann Gottlieb Fichte 17

Western Music[edit]

Figure Index score
Ludwig van Beethoven 100
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart 100
Johann Sebastian Bach 87
Richard Wagner 80
Joseph Haydn 56
Georg Friedrich Händel 46
Igor Stravinsky 45
Claude Debussy 45
Franz Liszt 45
Franz Schubert 44
Robert Schumann 42
Hector Berlioz 41
Arnold Schoenberg 39
Johannes Brahms 35
Frédéric Chopin 32
Claudio Monteverdi 31
Giuseppe Verdi 30
Felix Mendelssohn 30
Carl Maria von Weber 27
Christoph Willibald Gluck 26

Chinese Literature[edit]

Figure Index score
Du Fu 100
Li Bai 87
Bai Juyi 86
Su Shi 83
Han Yu 80
Qu Yuan 78
Sima Qian 68
Tao Qian 68
Ouyang Xiu 61
Yuan Zhen 49
Guan Hanqing 45
Sima Xiangru 41
Liu Zongyuan 40
Ban Gu 37
Wang Wei 35
Luo Guanzhong 34
Ma Zhiyuan 34
Wang Shifu 34
Song Yu 33
Cao Xueqin 32

Western Art[edit]

Figure Index score
Michelangelo 100
Pablo Picasso 77
Raphael 73
Leonardo da Vinci 61
Titian 60
Albrecht Dürer 56
Rembrandt 56
Giotto 54
Gian Lorenzo Bernini 53
Paul Cézanne 50
Peter Paul Rubens 49
Caravaggio 43
Diego Velázquez 43
Donatello 42
Jan van Eyck 42
Francisco Goya 41
Claude Monet 41
Masaccio 41
Vincent van Gogh 40
Paul Gauguin 38

Western Literature[edit]

Figure Index score
William Shakespeare 100
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe 81
Dante Alighieri 62
Virgil 55
Homer 54
Jean-Jacques Rousseau 48
Voltaire 47
Molière 43
Lord Byron 42
Leo Tolstoy 42
Fyodor Dostoyevsky 41
Petrarch 40
Victor Hugo 40
Friedrich Schiller 38
Giovanni Boccaccio 35
Horace 35
Euripides 35
Jean Racine 34
Walter Scott 33
Henrik Ibsen 32

Analysis[edit]

Murray collected many data for each innovator and did a statistical analysis. One result was that accomplishment has not been uniformly distributed. For example, in Italian Renaissance, accomplishment was concentrated in Florence and Venice. In the British Isles, around London, the industrial north, and lowland Scotland. He argued that most innovation has been accomplished by men, not women, and Europeans, not other ethnic and cultural groups. One explanation for the last is that Thomas Aquinas (1226-1274) influentially argued that human intelligence is a gift from God and using it to understand the world is pleasing to God.

There is a relationship between closeness to elite universities and human accomplishment (but not between non-elite universities and accomplishment). Furthermore, innovation is self–reinforcing: Where there has been innovation, likely more will occur.

The book argued that "Streams of accomplishment are fostered by political regimes that give de facto freedom of action to their potential artists and scholars". This means freedom of expression and innovation. It does not necessarily mean democracy although totalitarianism suppressed innovation. War and civil unrest did not affect innovation.

Religious liberty increased innovation. Jews had "sparse representation in European arts and sciences through the beginning of the 19C", but within a century Jews were disproportionately represented (except in astronomy). This coincided with the emancipation of Jews who earlier had been denied legal rights and access to universities and public office.

The highest scoring woman in a category was Murasaki Shikibu among Japanese literature. The highest in western literature was Virginia Woolf. The highest in science was Marie Curie.

Decline[edit]

Murray argued that the world's per capita progress in the sciences and especially the arts have declined, usually starting sometimes in the nineteenth century. In part this is due to diminishing returns. In the final chapters he abandons empirical analysis, writing "I cannot supply quantitative measures", and the analysis is "less quantitative, more speculative, and definitely more opinionated." He argued, based on Aristotle in the Nicomachean Ethics, that innovation is increased by beliefs that life has a purpose and that the function of life is to fulfill that purpose; by beliefs about transcendental goods and a sense of goodness, truth and beauty; and by beliefs that individuals can act efficaciously as individuals, and a culture that enables them to do so. Murray argued that there is an absence of this in the current secularist and nihilist society which has caused the decline.

Reviews[edit]

The Tech Law journal in a review criticized the claim that there has been a decline. "In short, Murray's statistical methods are thorough and objective up to the point where he argues that innovation is on the decline. Then, he manipulates his data."[1]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Book Review: Human Accomplishment, by Charles Murray

External links[edit]