Innocence of Muslims
Innocence of Muslims is the title attributed to a controversial anti-Islamic movie "trailer" that was written and produced by Nakoula Basseley Nakoula. Two versions of the 14-minute video were initially uploaded to YouTube in July 2012, under the titles The Real Life of Muhammad and Muhammad Movie Trailer. Videos dubbed in the Arabic language were uploaded during early September 2012. Anti-Islamic content had been added in post production by dubbing, without the actors' knowledge.
What was perceived as denigrating of the Islamic prophet Muhammad caused demonstrations and violent protests against the video to break out on September 11 in Egypt and spread to other Arab and Muslim nations and to some western countries. The protests have led to hundreds of injuries and over 50 deaths. Fatwas have been issued against the video's participants and a Pakistani minister has offered a bounty for the killing of Nakoula, the producer. The film has sparked debates about freedom of speech and Internet censorship.
Plot and description
The video titled "The Real Life of Muhammad", uploaded on July 1, 2012, has a running time of 13:03 in 480p format. The video "Muhammad Movie Trailer", was uploaded on July 2, 2012, with a running time of 13:51 in 1080p format. Both are similar in content. Most references to Islam have been overdubbed, added after the filming over the original spoken lines. Sarah Abdurrahman, a producer for WNYC's On the Media program, watched the trailer and concluded that all of the religious references had indeed been overdubbed after filming. The film's 80 cast and crew members have disavowed the film: "The entire cast and crew are extremely upset and feel taken advantage of by the producer. [...] We are deeply saddened by the tragedies that have occurred."
The script was originally written about life in Egypt 2,000 years ago and was titled Desert Warrior. It was a story about a character called "Master George". Several actors were brought in to overdub lines. They were directed to say specific words, such as "Muhammad". The video opens in a present-day setting, in which Egyptian security forces are depicted doing nothing as a mob of Muslim characters destroy Egyptian Christians' homes and property. Hiding from the attack, a doctor and his family take shelter in their home where the doctor takes up a pen and begins writing on a whiteboard: "Man + X = BT". "BT" is overdubbed as "Islamic terrorists". The young woman asks what "X" is. He tells her that she needs to discover that for herself.
The video continues with scenes set in the past. Some scenes depict the main character referred to in overdubbing as "Muhammad". In one scene, the "Muhammad" character's wife, "Khadija", suggests mixing parts of the Torah and the New Testament. In another scene, the "Muhammad" character is seen speaking to a donkey.
The New York Times stated: "The trailer opens with scenes of Egyptian security forces standing idle as Muslims pillage and burn the homes of Egyptian Christians. Then it cuts to cartoonish scenes depicting the Prophet Muhammad as a child of uncertain parentage, a buffoon, a womanizer, a homosexual, a child molester and a greedy, bloodthirsty thug."
A Vanity Fair article described the video as "Exceptionally amateurish, with disjointed dialogue, jumpy editing, and performances that would have looked melodramatic even in a silent movie, the clip is clearly designed to offend Muslims, portraying Mohammed as a bloodthirsty murderer and Lothario and pedophile with omnidirectional sexual appetites."
Film maker and promoters
The movie is reported to have been written and produced by Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, using the pseudonym of "Sam Bacile". Nakoula claimed that he was creating an epic, two-hour film; however, no such film has been located.
According to a consultant on the project, the videos are "trailers" from a full-length film that was shown only once, to an audience of fewer than ten people, at a rented theater in Hollywood, California. Posters advertising the film used the title Innocence of Bin Laden. The film's original working title was Desert Warrior, and it told the story of "tribal battles prompted by the arrival of a comet on Earth". On September 27, 2012, U.S. federal authorities stated Nakoula was arrested in Los Angeles for allegedly violating terms of his probation. Prosecutors stated that some of the violations included making false statements regarding his role in the film and his use of the alias "Sam Bacile". On November 7, 2012, Nakoula plead guilty to four of the charges against him and was sentenced to one year in prison and four years of supervised release.
In July 2011, Nakoula started casting actors for Desert Warrior, the working title at that time. The independent film was directed by a person first identified in casting calls as Alan Roberts, whose original cut and filmed dialog and script did not include references to Muhammad or Islam. According to the casting.backstage.com announcement, it was to be a "an HD 24P historical Arabian Desert adventure film" with "Sam Bassiel" as producer with shooting to start in August 2011. The lead was to be "George: male, 20–40, a strong leader, romantic, tyrant, a killer with no remorse, accent".
American non-profit Media for Christ obtained film permits to shoot the movie in August 2011, and Nakoula provided his home as a set and paid the actors, according to government officials and those involved in the production. Company president, Joseph Nassralla Abdelmasih claimed that Media for Christ's name was used without his knowledge. He also stated that film was edited afterwards without Media's involvement. Steve Klein, an anti-Muslim activist, claimed to be the spokesman for the film. Klein told journalist Jeffrey Goldberg that despite previous claims, "Bacile" is not a real person and is neither Israeli nor Jewish and that the name is a pseudonym. Israeli authorities found no sign of him being an Israeli citizen, and there was no indication of a 'Sam Bacile' living in California or participating in Hollywood filmmaking.
By September 13, 2012, "Sam Bacile" was identified as Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, a 55 year old Coptic Christian from Egypt living near Los Angeles, California, with known aliases. In the 1990s, he served time in prison for manufacturing methamphetamine. He pleaded no contest in 2010 to bank fraud charges and received 21 months in prison; being released on probation in June 2011. Nakoula claims to have written the script while in prison and raised between $50,000 and $60,000 from his wife's family in Egypt to finance the film. The FBI contacted him due to the potential for threats, but said he was not under investigation. On September 27, 2012, U.S. federal authorities arrested Nakoula in Los Angeles for suspicion of violating terms of his probation. Violations included making false statements regarding his role in the film and his use of the alias "Sam Bacile". On November 7, 2012, Nakoula plead guilty to four of the charges against him and was sentenced to one year in prison and four years of supervised release.
Law professor Stephen L. Carter and constitutional law expert Floyd Abrams have each pointed out that the government cannot prosecute the film's producer for its content because of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which protects freedom of speech in the United States. The U.S. Supreme Court has interpreted the First Amendment as invalidating government restrictions on blasphemy since 1952 and hate speech since the mid-1970s. In March 2011, the Court reiterated its position on hate speech by an 8–1 majority: "As a Nation we have chosen a different course—to protect even hurtful speech on public issues to ensure that we do not stifle public debate."
Screening and Internet upload
The video production "Innocence of Bin Laden" was advertised in the Anaheim-based newspaper Arab World during May and June 2012. The advertisement cost $300 to run three times in the paper and was paid by an individual identified only as "Joseph". The advertisements were noted by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), whose Islamic affairs director stated, "When we saw the advertisement in the paper, we were interested in knowing if it was some kind of pro-jihadist movie." Brian Donnelly, a guide for a Los Angeles based tour of famous crime scenes who noticed the poster advertising at the Vine Theater, said, "I didn't know if it was a good thing or a bad thing. We didn't know what it was about because we can't read Arabic." The earlier version of the film was screened once at the Vine Theater of June 23, 2012 to an audience of only ten people. The film had no subtitles and was presented in English. An employee of the theater stated, "The film we screened was titled The Innocence of Bin Laden," and added that it was a "small viewing".
A second screening was planned for June 30, 2012. A local Hollywood blogger, John Walsh, attended a June 29 Los Angeles City Council meeting, where he raised his concerns about the title of a film to be screened that appeared to support the leader of al-Qaeda. He said "There is an alarming event occurring in Hollywood on Saturday. A group has rented the Vine Street theater to show a video entitled Innocence of Bin Laden. We have no idea what this group is." The blog site reported that the June 30 screening had been canceled. A Current TV producer photographed the poster while it was being displayed at the theater as advertising to later discuss on the talk show The Young Turks. The poster did not denigrate Muslims, but rather referred to "my Muslim brother". In a translation provided by the ADL, the poster stated it would reveal "the real terrorist who caused the killing of our children In Palestine, and our brothers in Iraq and Afghanistan", a phrase that has been used by Palestinians to protest U.S. support of Israel.
The film was supported and promoted by pastor Terry Jones, known for a Quran-burning controversy, which also led to riots around the world. Jones said that he planned to show a 13-minute trailer at his church, the Dove World Outreach Center in Gainesville, Florida, on September 11, 2012. It was reported on September 14, 2012, that a planned screening by a Hindu organization in Toronto will be coupled with "snippets from other movies that are offensive to Christians and Hindus". Because of security concerns no public venue has been willing to show the film; the group still plans on showing the film in the future to a private audience of about 200 people. Siobhán Dowling of The Guardian reported that "a far-right Islamophobic group in Germany", the Pro Germany Citizens' Movement, has uploaded the trailer on their own website and wants to show the entire film, but authorities are attempting to prevent it.
Blocking of the YouTube video
The video clips were posted to YouTube on July 1 by user "sam bacile", however, by September, the film had been dubbed into Arabic and drew the attention of the Arabic-speaking world by blogger Morris Sadek. Sadek's own Egyptian citizenship had been revoked. A two-minute excerpt dubbed in Arabic was broadcast on September 9 by Sheikh Khalad Abdalla on Al-Nas, an Egyptian television station.
YouTube voluntarily blocked the video in Egypt and Libya and blocked the video in Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, Malaysia, India, and Singapore due to local laws while Turkey, Brazil, and Russia have initiated steps to get the video blocked. Google, Inc., the owner of YouTube, also blocked the video in Libya and Egypt citing "the very difficult situation" in those countries. In September 2012 the Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Sudan and Pakistani governments blocked YouTube for not removing the video, the website will remain suspended until the film is removed. Government authorities in Chechnya and Daghestan have issued orders to internet providers to block YouTube and Iran has announced that it is blocking Google and Gmail. Google has also agreed to block the anti Islam movie in Jordan.
The Obama administration asked YouTube to review whether to continue hosting the video at all under the company's policies. YouTube said the video fell within its guidelines as the video is against Islam, but not against Muslim people, and thus not considered "hate speech". Ben Wizner of the American Civil Liberties Union said of this, "It does make us nervous when the government throws its weight behind any requests for censorship."
2014 court ruling on removal
On February 26, 2014, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ordered YouTube to remove the video from its website by a 2-1 majority. The ruling was in response to a complaint by actress Cindy Lee Garcia, who had objected to the use of her performance, which had been partially dubbed for its inclusion in Innocence of Muslims. Garcia had believed during production that she was appearing in a film called Desert Warrior, which was described as a "historical Arabian Desert adventure film", and was unaware that anti-Islamic material would be added at the post-production stage. Garcia had argued that she held a copyright interest in her performance.
Reactions and consequences
In addition to the attacks on diplomatic missions, there were protests in many nations, through Islamic countries in the Middle East, Asia, and Africa as well as the United Kingdom, France, the Netherlands and Australia.
- 2005 Quran desecration controversy
- 2012 Afghanistan Quran burning protests
- Blasphemy law in the United States
- Fitna (2008) and subsequent protests and trial
- Joseph Burstyn, Inc v. Wilson
- Jyllands-Posten Muhammad cartoons controversy
- List of films about Muhammad
- Mohammad, Messenger of God (1976)
- Persecution of Copts
- The Satanic Verses controversy
- South Park controversies#Censorship of the depiction of Muhammed
- Submission (2004)
- Associated Press (September 20, 2012). "Anti-Muslim film got LA County permit for shoot". Reading Eagle. "Anti-Muslim film had permit allowing 1-day shoot at LA County ranch, use of fire, animals"
- "County of Los Angeles Releases Redacted Film Permit for "Desert Warriors"". FilmLA. September 20, 2012. f00043012. ""NOTE: This document has been redacted due to concerns for safety and security of persons and locations"
- Esposito, Richard, Ross, Brian and Galli, Cindy (September 13, 2012). "Anti-Islam Producer Wrote Script in Prison: Authorities, 'Innocence of Muslims' Linked to Violence in Egypt, Libya". abcnews.go.com (ABC News).
- Dion Nissenbaum, James Oberman and Erica Orden (September 13, 2012). "Behind Video, a Web of Questions". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- Zachary Zahos (September 19, 2012). "The Art of Defamation". The Cornell Daily Sun. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- Dan Murphy (September 12, 2012). "There-may-be-no-anti-Islamic-movie-at-all". The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- "Death, destruction in Pakistan amid protests tied to anti-Islam film". CNN. September 21, 2012. Retrieved 24 May 2013.
- "Egypt newspaper fights cartoons with cartoons". CBS News (Associated Press). September 26, 2012. Retrieved 24 May 2013.
- Latest Protests Against Depictions of Muhammad retrieved 1 October 2012[dead link]
- "'Our beloved Prophet is our honor!': Thousands rally in Pakistan against anti-Islam video". RT. September 29, 2012. Retrieved 1 October 2012.
- Fatwa issued by Muslim cleric against participants in an anti-Islamic film retrieved 1 October 2012[dead link]
- Ryan Villarreal (September 18, 2012). "Hezbollah Issues Fatwa Against 'Innocence Of Muslims' Makers; Rushdie Blasts Movie". Retrieved 1 October 2012.
- Egypt cleric issues fatwa against 'Innocence of Muslims' cast retrieved 1 October 2012[dead link]
- "Anti-Islam film: US condemns Pakistan minister's bounty". BBC News. 23 September 2012. Retrieved 1 October 2012.
- Thomas Fenton (September 12, 2012). "Should Innocence of Muslims be censored?". Global Post. Retrieved 3 October 2012.
- Sarah Abdurrahman (September 12, 2012). "Why Are All the Religious References in "Innocence of Muslims" Dubbed?". On the Media. Retrieved 3 July 2013.
- "Pentagon to review video of Libya attack – This Just In – CNN.com Blogs". News.blogs.cnn.com. September 12, 2012. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- Noah Shachtman with Robert Beckhusen (September 13, 2012). "Anti-Islam Filmmaker Went by ‘P.J. Tobacco’ and 13 Other Names". Wired. Retrieved July 3, 2013.
- Marquez, Miguel (September 17, 2012). "Actor: Anti-Islam filmmaker 'was playing us along'". CNN.
- David D. Kirkpatrick (September 12, 2012). "Anger Over a Film Fuels Anti-American Attacks in Libya and Egypt". The New York Times. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- "West urges end to file protests". BBC. September 14, 2012.
- Robert Mackey and Liam Stack (September 11, 2012). "Obscure Film Mocking Muslim Prophet Sparks Anti-U.S. Protests in Egypt and Libya". The New York Times.
- Gross, Michael Joseph (December 27, 2012). "The Making of The Innocence of Muslims: Cast Members Discuss the Film That Set Fire to the Arab World". Vanity Fair. Retrieved 22 May 2013.
- Gillian flaccus (Sep 12, 2012). "California man confirms role in anti-Islam film". Associated Press. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- Paul Bond (2012-09-19). "Does 'Innocence of Muslims' Actually Exist?". Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- Constable, Pamela (September 13, 2012). "Egyptian Christian activist in Virginia promoted video that sparked furor.". The Washington Post. Retrieved July 3, 2013.
- Willon, Phil (September 14, 2012). "Anti-Muslim film poster in Hollywood surprised locals". Los Angeles Times.
- Kia Makarechi (17 September 2012). "Anna Gurji & 'Innocence Of Muslims': Horrified Actress Writes Letter Explaining Her Role". The Huffington Post. Retrieved 24 September 2012.
- RISLING, GREG (September 28, 2012). "Calif. man behind anti-Muslim film ordered jailed". Yahoo News. Associated Press. Retrieved 28 September 2012.
- Kim, Victoria (November 7, 2012). "'Innocence of Muslims' filmmaker gets a year in prison". Los Angeles Times.
- Time Waster. "Feds Arrest Producer Of Controversial Anti-Islam Film On Probation Violation Charge". The Smoking Gun. Retrieved 2013-05-13.
- DW casting.backstage.com Productions is casting Desert Warrior
- Yamato, Jen (September 14, 2012). Was Inflammatory 'Innocence Of Muslims' Film Directed By 'Karate Cop,' 'Happy Hooker' Schlock Veteran? Movieline
- Chen, Adrian. ‘It Makes Me Sick’: Actress in Muhammed Movie Says She Was Deceived, Had No Idea It Was About Islam. Gawker, September 12, 2012.
- Ryan, Harriet; Garrison, Jenna (September 13, 2012). Christian charity, ex-con linked to film on Islam. Los Angeles Times
- Mark Hosenball (September 19, 2012). "U.S. activist says he was deceived over anti-Muslim film". Reuters.
- Gillian Flaccus (September 14, 2012). "Anti-Muslim film promoter outspoken on Islam". Associated Press.
- "Muhammad Film Consultant: 'Sam Bacile' is Not Israeli, and Not a Real Name – Jeffrey Goldberg". The Atlantic. August 20, 2012. Retrieved September 12, 2012.
- Peralta, Eyder. "What We Know About Sam Bacile, The Man Behind The Muhammad Movie : The Two-Way". NPR. Retrieved September 12, 2012.
- "Sam Bacile Identity Doubted". Business Insider. September 12, 2012. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- Richard Verrier (September 14, 2012). "Was 'Innocence of Muslims' directed by a porn producer?". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- Kia Makarechi (14 September 2012). "Alan Roberts & 'Innocence Of Muslims': Softcore Porn Director Linked To Anti-Islam Film". The Huffington Post. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- "California Man Confirms Role in Anti-Islam Film". Time. Retrieved September 12, 2012.[dead link]
- "Locate a Federal Inmate: Nakoula Basseley Nakoula". Federal Bureau of Prisons. 2012. Retrieved September 12, 2012.
- "Alleged anti-Muslim film producer has drug, fraud convictions". Los Angeles Times. September 13, 2012.
- Moni Basu; Chelsea J. Carter (September 14, 2012). "Sam Bacile or Nakoula Basseley Nakoula? Federal officials consider Nakoula as man behind the film". WPTV. CNN. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- Carter, Stephen L. (23 September 2012). "Anti-Muslim video incendiary but protected". The Press Democrat. Retrieved 23 September 2012.
- Abrams, Floyd (20 September 2012). "Should YouTube Have Taken Down Incendiary Anti-Muslim Video?". The Daily Beast. Retrieved 23 September 2012.
- Joseph Burstyn, Inc. v. Wilson, 343 U.S. 495 (1952).
- National Socialist Party of America v. Village of Skokie, 432 U.S. 43 (1977).
- Snyder v. Phelps, 562 U.S. __, 131 S. Ct. 1207, 179 L. Ed. 2d 172 (2011).
- Mona Shadia and Harriet Ryan (2012-09-15). "California Muslims hold vigil for slain ambassador". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- Hollie McKay (September 13, 2012). "'Innocence of Muslims' producer's identity in question; actors say they were duped, overdubbed". Fox News. Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- Jessica Garrison and Sam Quinones (September 13, 2012). "Anti-Muslim film screening: L.A. gadfly tried to warn city leaders". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- Eric Lach (September 13, 2012). "L.A. Blogger Alerted City Council To Anti-Islam Film In June". TPM. Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- Ted Johnson (September 14, 2012). "White House presses YouTube on 'Muslims' pic". Variety. Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- "California Muslims hold vigil for slain ambassador" Los Angeles Times
- Anger outweighs any empathy for US By Colin Nickerson, Globe Staff, 9/12/2002 "America is the true terrorist. It is the ally of Israel, which is killing our people. It is the country that drops bombs on poor Afghans."
- Terry Jones supports movie behind embassy bombing protests retrieved 7 October 2012
- "American Killed in Libya Attack". Ynetnews.
- Tom Godfrey (September 14, 2012). "Toronto Hindu group plans screening of Innocence of Muslims". QMI Agency.
- Etan Vlessing (September 14, 2012). "Toronto 2012: Canadian Hindu Group Plans Screening of Controversial Anti-Islam Film". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- Siobhán Dowling (September 16, 2012). "Far-right German group plans to show anti-Islamic film". guardiannews.com (London). Retrieved September 17, 2012.
- Sadik, Morris (September 5, 2012). "Global film on the Life of Muhammad Nbyalasalam and the Trial of Mohammed" (in Arabic). Coptic American National Assembly (blog). Retrieved September 12, 2012.
- "US envoy dies in Benghazi consulate attack". Al Jazeera English. September 12, 2012. Retrieved September 12, 2012.
- Mike Giglio (Sep 21, 2012). "Complaint Against Egyptian TV Host Who Aired ‘Innocence of Muslims’ Raises Free Speech Issue". The Daily Beast. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- Max Fisher (September 11, 2012). "The Movie So Offensive That Egyptians Just Stormed the U.S. Embassy Over It".
- Original broadcast (Elmo Khales TV on YouTube) cited by The New York Times on YouTube.
- "Google blocks Singapore access to anti-Islam film". Yahoo! News. September 21, 2012. Retrieved September 23, 2012.
- Google Has No Plans to Rethink Video Status, The New York Times, September 14, 2012
- Turkey seeks to ban online access to anti-Islam movie
- "Google blocks video clips in Egypt, Libya amid concerns over anti-Islam film". Al Arabiya. September 13, 2012. Retrieved September 23, 2012.
- "YouTube blocked in Pakistan for not removing anti-Islam film". New Delhi: New Delhi Television (NDTV). September 17, 2012. Retrieved September 18, 2012.
- Rory Mulholland, Fresh protests as prophet cartoons fuel Muslim fury, AFP.
- YouTube links to anti-Islam film blocked in Jordan
- Internet Providers In Chechnya Instructed To Block YouTube Over Anti-Islam Film
- Daghestan ISP Blocks YouTube Over Anti-Islamic Film
- Iran to block access to Google, Gmail amid anti-Islam film protests
- Activists troubled by White House call to YouTube, Politico, September 14, 2012
- Google ordered to remove anti-Islamic film from YouTube, Reuters, February 26, 2014.
- A controversial YouTube video haunts free speech again, The New Yorker, March 4, 2014.
- al-Salhy, Suadad (September 13, 2012). "Iraqi militia threatens U.S. interests over film". Reuters. Retrieved September 13, 2012.
- Gladstone, Rick (September 14, 2012). "Anti-American Protests Over Film Expand to More Than a Dozen Countries". The New York Times. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- "Anti-Islam film protests escalate". BBC. September 14, 2012. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- Hundreds of angry Afghans protest anti-Islam film in eastern Afghanistan – The Washington Post[dead link]
- "Protesters burn flags outside US embassy in London". The Daily Telegraph. September 14, 2012.
- "Over 100 arrested in protest of anti-Islam film outside U.S. embassy in Paris" – Daily News (New York) . Retrieved September 16, 2012.
- "Demo closes American consulate, but took place on the Dam". DutchNews.nl. Retrieved September 14, 2012.
- "As it happened: Violence erupts in Sydney over anti-Islam film". ABC News. September 15, 2012. Retrieved September 15, 2012.
- "Police gas Sydney protesters". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved September 15, 2012.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Innocence of Muslims (video).|
- YouTube channel of Sam Bacile with two videos apparently comprising extracts from the film, uploaded in July 2012.
- "US police quiz anti-Islam video suspect" (video) from al Jazeera's protests live blog
- Beware of Even Numbers - The film ‘Innocence of Muslims’ and the dangerous failing of the media on Tablet Magazine