Inversion therapy
|
|
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page.
|
Inversion therapy involves being upside down or at an inverted angle with the intention of therapeutic benefits. The process of doing so is called inverting. This can be done via hand balancing (such as in a handstand) or via hanging.
Hanging upside down by the feet in anatomical position tractions the bones of the leg and spine. However, it is rarely regarded as a serious treatment for back pain.[1]
Contents |
[edit] Batmanning
This form of inversion has been called batmanning in popular media when done for entertainment purposes.[2][3][4] It is a variant associated with planking (fad).
[edit] Claims
[edit] Traction and stretching
When the body's weight is suspended from the lower body – rather than borne on the hands as in handstands or headstands or hanging from a bar with arms at sides, which are also forms of inversion – the pull of gravity may decompress the joints of the body below the anchor. Hanging by the feet, as with gravity boots or inversion tables, causes each joint in the body to be loaded in an equal and opposite manner to standing in an identical position of joint alignment. Inversion therapy of this sort is often commercially advertised as a relief for back pain.[5]
Proponents[who?] claim that inversion therapy is particularly beneficial for the spine in that it relieves pressure on the discs and nerve roots; this in turn allows discs to recover lost moisture and to return to their original shape, decreasing the pressure they can exert on nerves. Skeptics[who?] note that pressure is also relieved when lying down in bed. Proponents[who?] counter that while gravity-related pressure is removed, the pressure of tight muscles is not, and that traction is needed to allow the possible space between spinal discs to be realized.[6]
[edit] Posture
Proponents advocate that traction can be a tool to restore proper alignment to the spine, which may assist in maintaining proper posture when later righted. As misalignment of the hips and spine can itself be a source of inflammation and pain, this is another argument for traction as a back therapy.
[edit] Flexibility
Inversion devices are promoted as a tool to be used in gaining flexibility. Static-active stretching methods impossible to perform while standing can be performed upside down for the spinal flexors, side flexors and extensors, and situps are a closed-chain exercise for the hip flexors (a static-active stretch for the hip extensors) compared to the upright exercise, leg raises, which are open-chain movements. Due to increased spacing in the joint which can occur in response to traction, the muscles crossing that joint are pre-stretched, and as such, experience a greater lengthening compared to the equivalent joint angle while under no traction (lying down) or while being compressed (standing).
[edit] Blood flow
Claims are made that inversion stimulates circulation differences due to gravity acting on the circulatory system in an opposite manner, opposing what it would normally assist, and assisting what it would normally oppose compared to standing upright. This pooling of blood and greater circulation is thought by some to increase oxygen flow to those tissues, primarily in the brain or roots of the hair,
[edit] Efficacy
Several research studies into inversion therapy have taken place, focusing on its efficacy with regard to reduction of back pain, avoidance of surgery and a decrease in employees’ lost working hours.
In 1964, the Sheffield study[7] evaluated 175 patients whose back pain left them unable to work. Following eight inversion treatments, 155 patients were able to return to their jobs full time.
In 1978, the Nosse study[8] found that EMG activity (an indicator of muscle pain) declined by 35 per cent within the first 10 seconds of inversion. The study also found that inversion increases spinal length, concluding that there was a correlation between a reduction in EMG activity and an increase in spinal length.
In 1985, the Kane study[9] demonstrated that gravity-facilitated traction produces significant intervertebral separation in the lumbar spine, concluding that gravity-facilitated traction may be an effective modality in the relief of low back pain.
In 1993[10], the Dimberg/Volvo study[11] evaluated 116 Volvo employees in a randomized controlled trial that lasted for 12 months. Three training groups were studied, and after 12 months, the researchers demonstrated a 33 per cent decrease in sick days from back pain. The average sick days lost to back pain fell by eight days per individual in the treated group. The study concluded that inversion is an efficient and cost-effective way to improve employee health and possibly reduce sick day costs to an employer.
[edit] Health risks
People who have heart disease, high blood pressure, eye diseases (such as glaucoma), or are pregnant are at higher risk for the dangers related to inversion therapy and should consult their doctors about it first. Such people would have to progress very slowly, starting at very light levels of inversion. The first time anyone tries inversion therapy with gravity, they should be sure to have someone standing by, in case assistance is required to get out of the apparatus, or if health problems are experienced.[1]
[edit] History
Inverting of the body for purported health benefits has been around for thousands of years, via yoga poses such as Sirsasana, though this was a compressed load-bearing form of inversion.
The combination of inversion therapy with traction therapy is attributed to Hippocrates around 400BC.[12]
In the 1960s, a chiropractor from California named Robert Martin began marketing the "Gravity Guidance Inversion Table", and in the 1970s his son published a book about it.
1980's featuring of inversion boots for dumbbell exercises by Richard Gere in American Gigolo was followed by a study by Goldman-Klatz in 1983 which criticized inversion.[13] In the 1985 television series MacGyver, inversion therapy is used by Richard Dean Anderson's title character. In movies it was again featured in Batman (1989 film)) where Bruce Wayne (portrayed by Michael Keaton) was shown to sleep this way.
In the 1990 television series by David Lynch Twin Peaks, the character Agent Cooper is shown engaging in inversion therapy on at least one occasion. In the 1990 movie Back to the Future Part II, the protagonist's father George McFly (portrayed by Jeffrey Weissman) is also hanging upside down. In the 1991 movie Cape Fear, Max Cady (Robert De Niro) is seen hanging upside down wearing inversion boots. In the 1999 movie Deuce Bigalow: Male Gigolo, in a testament to American Gigolo, both Oded Fehr (Antoine Laconte) and Rob Schneider (Deuce Bigalow) are also seen hanging upside down wearing inversion boots.
In the 2008 CBS sitcom Gary Unmarried, Jay Mohr, who plays the title character, treats back pain in season 1, episode 2, "Gary Gets Boundaries". In 2009, TV star Rosie O'Donnell has said that she uses inversion therapy to treat her depression.[14] Ozzy Osbourne is depicted using an inversion table in the June 24, 2010 release (Issue 1107) of Rolling Stone Magazine.[15] The year 2011 is when the "batmanning" subculture began.
[edit] See also
[edit] References
- ^ a b "University of California Berkeley expert cautioning against inversion therapy". http://wellnessletter.com/html/wl/2001/wlAskExperts0901.html.
- ^ Forget planking, it’s Batmanning Sept 7 2011, The Sun
- ^ Holy cow! Now students develop another craze... Batmanning Sept 10, 2011 by Daily Mail
- ^ Batmanning is a Christian Bale stunt with an Adam West flavour Sept 11 2011, The Guardian's Sam Leith
- ^ "Benefits of Inversion". http://www.inversioninternational.com/training_benefits.php.
- ^ "Inversion Benefits". http://www.teeter-inversion.com/inversion-benefits.asp.
- ^ Sheffield F.: Adaptation of Tilt Table for Lumbar Traction. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 45: 469-472, 1964
- ^ Nosse L.: Inverted Spinal Traction. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 59: 367-370, Aug 1978
- ^ Kane M, et al.: Effects of Gravity-facilitated Traction on Intervertebral Dimensions of the Lumbar Spine. Journal of Orthopedic and Sports Phys Ther. 281-288, Mar 1985
- ^ Medical studies
- ^ Dimberg L, et al: Effects of gravity-facilitated traction of the lumbar spine in persons with chronic low back pain at the workplace
- ^ History of Inversion: "Hippocrates .. hoists up a patient on a ladder with a series of ropes and pulleys to harness the force gravity in an effort to stretch his patients and relieve their ailments."
- ^ Canadian Chiropractor: History of Inversion
- ^ "Rosie Says She's Treated For Depression". http://www.showbuzz.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/03/07/people/main2543772.shtml.
- ^ Ozzy Osbourne Uses a Teeter Inversion Table! Aug 3, 2010