Eltingh reached his highest ranking as a singles player in February 1995, when he climbed to No. 19. In his professional career he has won four singles and 44 doubles titles.
| Outcome |
No. |
Date |
Tournament |
Surface |
Partner |
Opponents in the final |
Score in the final |
| Winner |
1. |
30 September 1991 |
Palermo, Italy |
Clay |
Tom Kempers |
Emilio Sánchez
Javier Sánchez |
3–6, 6–3, 6–3 |
| Winner |
2. |
7 October 1991 |
Athens, Greece |
Clay |
Mark Koevermans |
Menno Oosting
Olli Rahnasto |
5–7, 7–6, 7–5 |
| Winner |
3. |
28 October 1991 |
Guarujá, Brazil |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Bret Garnett
Todd Nelson |
6–3, 7–5 |
| Winner |
4. |
11 November 1991 |
Birmingham, United Kingdom |
Carpet |
Paul Wekesa |
Ronnie Båthman
Rikard Bergh |
7–5, 7–5 |
| Winner |
5. |
31 August 1992 |
Schenectady, U.S. |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Sergio Casal
Emilio Sánchez |
6–3, 6–4 |
| Winner |
6. |
11 January 1993 |
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Henrik Holm
Bent-Ove Pedersen |
7–5, 6–3 |
| Runner-up |
1. |
18 January 1993 |
Jakarta, Indonesia |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Diego Nargiso
Guillaume Raoux |
6–7, 7–6, 3–6 |
| Winner |
7. |
8 February 1993 |
San Francisco, U.S. |
Hard (i) |
Scott Davis |
Patrick McEnroe
Jonathan Stark |
6–1, 4–6, 7–5 |
| Runner-up |
2. |
15 February 1993 |
Memphis, U.S. |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
5–7, 2–6 |
| Winner |
8. |
17 May 1993 |
Rome, Italy |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Wayne Ferreira
Mark Kratzmann |
6–4, 7–6 |
| Winner |
9. |
2 August 1993 |
Hilversum, Netherlands |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Hendrik Jan Davids
Libor Pimek |
4–6, 6–2, 7–5 |
| Winner |
10. |
4 October 1993 |
Kuala Lumpur-2, Malaysia |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jonas Björkman
Lars-Anders Wahlgren |
7–5, 4–6, 7–6 |
| Runner-up |
3. |
25 October 1993 |
Beijing, China |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Paul Annacone
Doug Flach |
6–7, 3–6 |
| Winner |
11. |
15 November 1993 |
Moscow, Russia |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jonas Björkman
Jan Apell |
6–1, ret. |
| Winner |
12. |
28 November 1993 |
Doubles Championship, Johannesburg |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
7–6(4), 7–6(5), 6–4 |
| Winner |
13. |
31 January 1994 |
Australian Open, Melbourne |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Byron Black
Jonathan Stark |
6–7, 6–3, 6–4, 6–3 |
| Winner |
14. |
21 February 1994 |
Philadelphia, U.S. |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jim Grabb
Jared Palmer |
6–3, 6–4 |
| Runner-up |
4. |
28 February 1994 |
Rotterdam, Netherlands |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jeremy Bates
Jonas Björkman |
4–6, 1–6 |
| Winner |
15. |
21 March 1994 |
Key Biscayne, U.S. |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Mark Knowles
Jared Palmer |
7–6, 7–6 |
| Runner-up |
5. |
25 July 1994 |
Stuttgart Outdoor, Germany |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Scott Melville
Piet Norval |
6–7, 5–7 |
| Runner-up |
6. |
22 August 1994 |
New Haven, U.S. |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Grant Connell
Patrick Galbraith |
4–6, 6–7 |
| Runner-up |
7. |
29 August 1994 |
Schenectady, U.S. |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jan Apell
Jonas Björkman |
4–6, 6–7 |
| Winner |
16. |
12 September 1994 |
US Open, New York |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
6–3, 7–6 |
| Winner |
17. |
3 October 1994 |
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Nicklas Kulti
Lars-Anders Wahlgren |
6–0, 7–5 |
| Winner |
18. |
10 October 1994 |
Sydney Indoor, Australia |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Byron Black
Jonathan Stark |
6–4, 7–6 |
| Winner |
19. |
7 November 1994 |
Paris Indoor, France |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Byron Black
Jonathan Stark |
3–6, 7–6, 7–5 |
| Winner |
20. |
14 November 1994 |
Moscow, Russia |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
David Adams
Andrei Olhovskiy |
W/O |
| Runner-up |
8. |
27 February 1995 |
Philadelphia, U.S. |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jim Grabb
Jonathan Stark |
6–7, 7–6, 3–6 |
| Winner |
21. |
1 May 1995 |
Monte Carlo, Monaco |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Luis Lobo
Javier Sánchez |
6–3, 6–4 |
| Winner |
22. |
12 June 1995 |
French Open, Paris |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Nicklas Kulti
Magnus Larsson |
6–7, 6–4, 6–1 |
| Winner |
23. |
26 June 1995 |
Halle, Germany |
Grass |
Paul Haarhuis |
Yevgeny Kafelnikov
Andrei Olhovskiy |
6–2, 3–6, 6–3 |
| Winner |
24. |
16 October 1995 |
Tokyo Indoor, Japan |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jakob Hlasek
Patrick McEnroe |
7–6, 6–4 |
| Winner |
25. |
30 October 1995 |
Essen, Germany |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Cyril Suk
Daniel Vacek |
7–5, 6–4 |
| Winner |
26. |
13 November 1995 |
Stockholm, Sweden |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Grant Connell
Patrick Galbraith |
3–6, 6–2, 7–6 |
| Runner-up |
9. |
25 November 1995 |
Doubles Championship, Eindhoven |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Grant Connell
Patrick Galbraith |
6–7, 6–7, 6–3, 6–7 |
| Runner-up |
10. |
8 January 1996 |
Doha, Qatar |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Mark Knowles
Daniel Nestor |
6–7, 3–6 |
| Runner-up |
11. |
9 September 1996 |
US Open, New York City |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
6–4, 6–7, 6–7 |
| Winner |
27. |
21 October 1996 |
Toulouse, France |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Olivier Delaître
Guillaume Raoux |
6–3, 7–5 |
| Runner-up |
12. |
28 October 1996 |
Stuttgart Indoor, Germany |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Sébastien Lareau
Alex O'Brien |
6–3, 4–6, 3–6 |
| Winner |
28. |
4 November 1996 |
Paris Indoor, France |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Yevgeny Kafelnikov
Daniel Vacek |
6–4, 4–6, 7–6 |
| Winner |
29. |
6 January 1997 |
Doha, Qatar |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Patrik Fredriksson
Magnus Norman |
6–3, 6–2 |
| Winner |
30. |
10 March 1997 |
Rotterdam, Netherlands |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Libor Pimek
Byron Talbot |
7–6, 6–4 |
| Runner-up |
13. |
28 April 1997 |
Monte Carlo, Monaco |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Donald Johnson
Francisco Montana |
6–7, 6–2, 6–7 |
| Winner |
31. |
23 June 1997 |
Rosmalen, Netherlands |
Grass |
Paul Haarhuis |
Trevor Kronemann
David Macpherson |
6–4, 7–5 |
| Runner-up |
14. |
7 July 1997 |
Wimbledon, London |
Grass |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
6–7, 6–7, 7–5, 3–6 |
| Winner |
32. |
25 August 1997 |
Boston, U.S. |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Dave Randall
Jack Waite |
6–4, 6–2 |
| Winner |
33. |
6 October 1997 |
Toulouse, France |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Jean-Philippe Fleurian
Max Mirnyi |
6–3, 7–6 |
| Winner |
34. |
3 November 1997 |
Paris Indoor, France |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Rick Leach
Jonathan Stark |
6–2, 7–6 |
| Runner-up |
15. |
19 January 1998 |
Sydney Outdoor, Australia |
Hard |
Daniel Nestor |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
3–6, 5–7 |
| Winner |
35. |
2 February 1998 |
Australian Open, Melbourne |
Hard |
Jonas Björkman |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
6–2, 5–7, 2–6, 6–4, 6–3 |
| Winner |
36. |
2 March 1998 |
Philadelphia, U.S. |
Hard (i) |
Paul Haarhuis |
Richey Reneberg
David Macpherson |
7–6, 6–7, 6–2 |
| Winner |
37. |
9 March 1998 |
Rotterdam, Netherlands |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Neil Broad
Piet Norval |
7–6, 6–3 |
| Winner |
38. |
20 April 1998 |
Barcelona, Spain |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Ellis Ferreira
Rick Leach |
7–5, 6–0 |
| Winner |
39. |
27 April 1998 |
Monte Carlo, Monaco |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
6–4, 6–2 |
| Winner |
40. |
8 June 1998 |
French Open, Paris |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Mark Knowles
Daniel Nestor |
6–3, 3–6, 6–3 |
| Winner |
41. |
6 July 1998 |
Wimbledon, London |
Grass |
Paul Haarhuis |
Todd Woodbridge
Mark Woodforde |
2–6, 6–4, 7–6, 5–7, 10–8 |
| Winner |
42. |
9 August 1998 |
Amsterdam, Netherlands |
Clay |
Paul Haarhuis |
Dominik Hrbatý
Karol Kučera |
6–3, 6–2 |
| Winner |
43. |
31 August 1998 |
Boston, U.S. |
Hard |
Paul Haarhuis |
Chris Haggard
Jack Waite |
6–3, 6–2 |
| Runner-up |
16. |
9 November 1998 |
Paris Indoor, France |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Mahesh Bhupathi
Leander Paes |
4–6, 2–6 |
| Winner |
44. |
22 November 1998 |
Doubles Championship, Hartford |
Carpet |
Paul Haarhuis |
Mark Knowles
Daniel Nestor |
6–4, 6–2, 7–5 |