James Marcia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

James E. Marcia is a clinical and developmental psychologist. He has held professorships in US and Canadian universities, and is currently an Emeritus Professor of Psychology at Simon Fraser University in British Columbia, Canada. He is also active in clinical private practice, clinical psychology supervision, community consultation, and international clinical-developmental research and teaching.

Ego-identity status[edit]

Marcia is perhaps best known for his extensive research and writings on psychological development, with specific attention focused on adolescent psychosocial development and lifespan identity development. Erik H. Erikson had suggested that the normative conflict occurring in adolescence is the opposition between identity achievement and identity confusion. Marcia elaborated on Erikson’s proposal in a citation classic[1] by suggesting this stage consists neither of identity resolution nor identity confusion as Erikson claimed, but is better understood as the extent to which one has both explored and committed to an identity in a variety of life domains including politics, occupation, religion, intimate relationships, friendships, and gender roles. 'Two crucial areas in which the adolescent must make such commitments are ideology and occupation'.[2]

His theory of identity achievement states that there are two distinct parts contributing to the achievement of adolescent identity: a time of choosing or crisis, and a commitment. He defined a crisis as a time of upheaval where old values or choices are being reexamined and new alternatives are explored - 'times during adolescence when the individual seems to be actively involved in choosing among alternative occupations and beliefs'.[3] Both exploration and commitment are the two processes that contribute to differences in outcome during an Identity crisis. That is, whether or not (the extent to which) one explores identity alternatives and whether or not one makes a commitment to chosen alternatives.

The four identity statuses[edit]

Marcia developed the Identity Status Interview, a method of semi-structured interview for psychological identity research, that investigates an individual's extent of exploration and commitment across different life areas. Evaluating the material provided in this interview by using a scoring manual developed by Marcia and colleagues yields four possible outcomes.

The four Identity Statuses he distinguished were: Foreclosure, Identity Diffusion, Moratorium, and Identity Achievement.

Foreclosure[edit]

"The foreclosure status is when a commitment is made without exploring alternatives. Often these commitments are based on parental ideas and beliefs that are accepted without question".[4] As Marcia himself put it, "the individual about to become a Methodist, Republican farmer like his Methodist, Republican farmer father, with little or no thought in the matter, certainly cannot be said to have "achieved" an identity, in spite of his commitment".[5]

Adolescents may foreclose on the handed-down identity willingly or under pressure. The case of "negative-identity" occurs when adolescents adopt an identity in direct opposition to a prescribed identity. Marcia saw the evidence for the endorsement of authoritarian values by foreclosures as fully commensurate with a view of them as becoming the alter egos of their parents.[6]

Marcia stressed that once an identity crisis has been experienced, returning to the foreclosure status was no longer a possibility.[7]

Identity Diffusion[edit]

Adolescents unable to face the necessity of identity development avoid exploring or making commitments by remaining in an amorphous state of identity diffusion, something which may produce social isolation.[8] The least complex and mature of the four identity statuses,[9] Identity Diffusion is the mark of those who have neither explored nor made commitments across life-defining areas. They may or may not have experienced an identity crisis, with some reporting having little interest in such matters and others reporting repeated indecision.

Marcia suggested that those with identity diffusion "do not experience much anxiety because there is little in which they are invested. As they begin to care more...they move to the moratorium status, or they become so disturbed that they are diagnosed schizophrenic";[10] or may end up adopting a negative and self-destructive identity-role.[11]

Moratorium[edit]

Identity moratorium is the status of individuals who are in the midst of a crisis, whose commitments are either absent or are only vaguely defined, but who are actively exploring alternatives.[12] Marcia notes that "moratoriums...report experiencing more anxiety than do Ss in any other status...The world for them is not, currently, a highly predictable place; they are vitally engaged in a struggle to make it so".[13]

Despite such anxiety, the postmodern trend has been for more people to spend more time in the status, a phenomenon Gail Sheehy termed Provisional Adulthood.[14]

Identity achievement[edit]

Once a crisis has been experienced and worked through, Marcia considered, "a likely progression would be from diffusion through moratorium to identity achievement".[15] The latter is thus the status of individuals who have typically experienced a crisis, undergone identity explorations and made commitments. Marcia found some evidence to support his "theoretical description of Ss who have achieved an identity as having developed an internal, as opposed to external, locus of self-definition".[16]

Identity Status Shifts[edit]

Throughout the lifecycle identity status shifts will occur. When identity status change occurs (in late adolescence and young adulthood) the change is more than twice as likely to be progressive as opposed to regressive.[17] Longitudinally status change is most often a transition form moratorium to identity achievement.[18] Transitions are often inspired by disequilibrium in identity. Marcia [19] outlines how status change occurs as it relates to disequilibrium. Crisis in identity comes in the form of later adult life cycle stages and various life events. Depending on the individual, particular life events such as death of a loved one, job loss, moving, etc. may cause disequilibrium. However, this is only true when an individual has constructed some form of identity. Diffusions are stagnant. They have not made an effort to construct an identity and therefore have no identity to reform. In the case of foreclosures many will choose to live in an environment that is similar to their childhood experiences so that they may remain unchanged. When disequilibrium occurs in the life of foreclosures, the effects may be especially devastating. When disequilibrium occurs a period of re-construction begins. These periods of re-construction are called the moratorium-achievement-moratorium-achievement (MAMA) cycles.[20] In each person's life there are a minimum of three MAMA cycles, corresponding with the three remaining psychosocial stages.[21] During re-construction a person may regress to an earlier identity status.[22] It is crucial that old constructs fall so that new ones that are more encompassing of the person's identity may be constructed.[23] In the re-construction process there is still continuity with the previous identity, however the newer construction is broadened to include new life experiences and commitments.[24]

Applicability and criticism[edit]

While Marcia primarily focused on the late adolescent years, his theory is applicable in later adulthood, when identity crises may reoccur. One study, exploring correlations between the identity statuses of Marcia's model and social behaviors, focused on young adults ranging in age from 19 to 35.[25] People's identity status is not specifically limited to an age group. Individuals may explore elements tied to their identity throughout life, such as faith, ideology, and occupational preference to name a few.[26]

Using Marcia's semi-structured interview approach enables research to be flexibly adapted to different cultures. There has been a good deal of cross-cultural validation of the Identity Statuses.

Critical research has suggested however that '(a) The four statuses do not operate in a developmental sequence...(b) conscious exploration is not required for and often does not occur in identity achievement; and (c) numerous studies conducted in support of the statuses focus less on developmental issues and more on classification issues (Cote 2006)'.[27]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Marcia, J. E., (1966), Development and validation of ego identity status, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 3, pp. 551-558
  2. ^ James E. Marcia, "Ego-Identity Status", in Michael Argyle, Social Encounters (Penguin 1973) p. 340
  3. ^ Marcia, "Ego-Identity Status" p. 340
  4. ^ Identity Development - Aspects of Identity, Child Development Reference - Vol 4.
  5. ^ Marcia, "Ego-status Identity" p. 340
  6. ^ Marcia, "Ego-Identity Status" p. 353
  7. ^ Marcia, "Ego-Identity Status" p. 341
  8. ^ Identity Development - Aspects of Identity, Child Development Reference - Vol 4.
  9. ^ J. E. Cote/C. G. Levine, Identity Formation, Agency and Culture (2002) p. 19
  10. ^ Marcia, "Ego-Identity Status" p. 352
  11. ^ Ann Birch, Developmental Psychology (London 1997) p. 206
  12. ^ Identity Development - Aspects of Identity, Child Development Reference - Vol 4.
  13. ^ Marcia, "Ego-Identity Status" p. 352
  14. ^ Gail Sheehy, New Passages (London 1996) p. 43 and p. 10
  15. ^ Marcia, "Ego-identity Status" p. 341
  16. ^ Marcia, "Ego-identity Status" p. 350
  17. ^ Kroger, J., Martinussen, M., & Marcia, J. E. (2010). Identity status change during adolescence and young adulthood: A meta-analysis. Journal of Adolescence, 33, 683-698.
  18. ^ Kroger, J., Martinussen, M., & Marcia, J. E. (2010). Identity status change during adolescence and young adulthood: A meta-analysis. Journal of Adolescence, 33, 683-698.
  19. ^ Marcia, J. E. (2010). Life transitions and stress in the context of psychosocial development. In T. W. Miller (Ed.), Handbook of Stressful Transitions Across the Lifespan (pp. 19-34). doi: 10.1007/978-1-4419-0748-6_2
  20. ^ Life transitions and stress in the context of psychosocial development. In T. W. Miller (Ed.), Handbook of Stressful Transitions Across the Lifespan (pp. 19-34). doi: 10.1007/978-1-4419-0748-6_2
  21. ^ Marcia, J. E. (2010). Life transitions and stress in the context of psychosocial development. In T. W. Miller (Ed.), Handbook of Stressful Transitions Across the Lifespan (pp. 19-34). doi: 10.1007/978-1-4419-0748-6_2
  22. ^ Marcia, J. E., Simon, F. U. (2003). Treading fearlessly: A commentary on personal persistence, identity development, and suicide. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 68, 131-138.
  23. ^ Marcia, J. E. (2010). Life transitions and stress in the context of psychosocial development. In T. W. Miller (Ed.), Handbook of Stressful Transitions Across the Lifespan (pp. 19-34). doi: 10.1007/978-1-4419-0748-6_2
  24. ^ Marcia, J. E., Simon, F. U. (2003). Treading fearlessly: A commentary on personal persistence, identity development, and suicide. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 68, 131-138.
  25. ^ Hardy, S. A., & Kisling, J. W. (2006). Identity statuses and prosocial behaviors in young adulthood: A brief report. Identity: An International Journal of Theory and Research, 6(4), 363-369.
  26. ^ Identity Development - Aspects of Identity, Child Development Reference - Vol 4.
  27. ^ Thomas W. Miller, Handbook of Stressful Transitions Across the Lifespan (2009) p. 93

Further reading[edit]

  • John W. Santrock, Life-Span Development (Twelfth Edition University of Texas at Dallas, Published by Mcgraw-Hill, Copyright 2009)
  • James E. Marcia, Ego Identity (1993)
  • J. Cote, "Emerging adulthood as an institutionalized moratorium" in J. Arnett/J. Tanner eds, Emerging Adults in America (2006)
  • Seth J. Schwartz, "The evolution of Eriksonian and Neo-Eriksonian identity theory and research", Identity, 1, 7-58.

External links[edit]

James Marcia's Identity States