Pakistan and Japan Relations
Pakistan and Japan have history of a glorious relationship. The ancient Gandhara civilization, cotton trade during the British colonialism, and the re-emergence of cotton and textile interaction after World War II, modern technology, and investment drove their relations.
The Gandhara Link
The foundations their relations lie in the pre-independence period of Pakistan’s history. Both Pakistan and Japanese shared age-old ties of common cultures, traditions, outlook, and consciousness. The ancient Silk Route through China and Korea became a contact point between ancient Gandhara with Taxila as its center (present day Pakistan) and Japan. Emperor Kanishka ruled from his capital in Peshawar during the development of Buddhism. Ancient relations between the Gandhara region and Japan existed around 1300 years ago. The progressive branch of Buddhism, Mahayana Buddism (in Japanese Daijo Bukyo), embraced by Japanese, was flourished in Taxila. Daijo Bukyo gave rise to magnificent art, architecture, sculpture, and paining in Japan. Culturally, Japan seems to be an extension of ancient Gandhara civilization.
Pakistan played a significant role during 1947-51 in lifting the Occupation and restoring of its sovereignty. Pakistan was known as the 'tower of strength' on the Japanese peace treaty signed on 8 September 1951 at San Francisco as was marked by US Secretary of State John Foster Dulles. Unlike many Asian countries, Pakistan waived off war reparations to Japan to help build its economy. Not taking revenge but fostering cooperation was Pakistan’s policy toward Japan. Pakistan was among the first few countries that had ratified the Japanese peace treaty even much ahead of the United States.
Pakistan also played a leading role in Japan's postwar economic revival in the 1950s by exporting cotton and jute to Japan as textile was the only industry allowed to revive under the Occupation. SCAP-Japan sent its first trade mission to Pakistan in May 1948, headed by R. Eaton. Two months later, Japan signed a trade agreement with Pakistan in July 1948, which was also the first trade agreement signed by Japan with any country after the war. Much of Pakistan’s export was on deferred payment as Japan was short of foreign exchange. In exchange of cotton and jute, Pakistan imported textile machinery from Japan. Therefore, a mutually beneficial trade relationship emerged between them. Furthermore, a Japanese trading liaison agency was established in Karachi in 1948, which was also a diplomatic source for Japan after the war. Pakistan sent its first trade mission to Japan under Mirza Abul Isphahani in September 1948 to review Japanese textile industry for Pakistan’s benefit. Another SCAP-Japan trade mission, headed by E.B. Blatcheley, visited Pakistan in February 1949 and two more trade missions led by B.W. Adams and A.B. Snell respectively visited Pakistan to negotiate cotton and jute for Japanese industry. These visits paved the way for many other trade delegations to Pakistan to enhance trade and to promote other economic activities between the two countries.
Before regular diplomatic relations were established between Pakistan and Japan, the trade liaison offices in Karachi and Tokyo, working since 1948, were the only sources of trade and diplomatic contacts. Both countries established regular diplomatic missions on 18 April 1952, just ten days after the ratification of the Japanese peace treaty. Therefore, Pakistan established diplomatic and trade contacts with Japan since 1948 – long before Japanese sovereignty was restored by the Allied Powers.
In order to meet the acute shortage of food in Japan caused after the war, Pakistan shipped 60,000 tons of rice through Nichimen vessels to Japan in 1952 and 1953 carrying the signboard ‘Donated Rice to the Emperor of Japan by the Government of Pakistan’. Such was the national sentiment between the two sides in the 1950s.
High Level Exchanges
Pakistan appointed Mian Ziauddin as its first Ambassador to Japan on 18 April 1952 and Japan Ambassador Kiyoshi Yamagata arrived in Karachi on 4 September 1952. Pakistan and Japan exchanged the high level visits in April and May 1957. Pakistan's Prime Minister Hussain Shaheed Suharawardy was the first Asian leader to visit Japan in April 1957, which opened up the door to Japan to comeback to Asia after World War II. Within a month in May 1957, Japanese Prime Minister Nobusuke Kishi undertook visit to Pakistan, which was also the first-ever visit by a Japanese Prime Minister to Asia after the end of World War II. They, however, differed on the Kashmir dispute, One China policy, and the creation of an Asian development bank. Japan remained neutral on Kashmir and supported plebiscite in Kashmir. Japan supported Taiwan against the People’s Republic of China (PRC) but Pakistan recognized the PRC as the sole and legitimate Government of the people of China. Regarding the setting up of an Asian development bank, Pakistan wanted Japan to first establish and restore diplomatic relations with all Asian countries as they should not realize an aggressive but a cooperative Japan. The mutual diplomacy, however, further encouraged the two sides to promote trading and economic ties and creating the environment for normalizing Japanese ties with the remaining Asian nations such as China and the two Koreas. Moreover, Pakistan and Japan were important players in US Cold War strategy in Asia - Pakistan in South Asia and Japan in North East Asia.
President Muhammad Ayub Khan paid a visit to Japan on 12-19 December 1960. The invitation was extended by Japanese Emperor Hirohito in February 1960. Japan wanted to show that had fully assimilated the spirit of the San Francisco treaty and willing to boost relations with Asian nations. For Pakistan, the visit was motivated by economic reasons. Moreover, the United States was encouraging cooperation between its two allies. Ayub’s visit was the ‘grandest’ ever seen in Japan those days. He was received by the Emperor – an extraordinary welcome as dignitaries were received by prime minister. Strategically important was his stopover at Okinawa, US marine base, where US High Commissioner General Booth welcomed a non-American and non-Japanese leader first time and offered him a guard of honor. This showed an explicit trust among Japanese, Americans, and Pakistanis during the Cold War.
Following Ayub’s visit to Japan, Prime Minister Hayato Ikeda visited Pakistan on 17-20 November 1961 as a part of his Asian tour. He offered a yen loan of 20 million – Japan’s first ever to Pakistan (besides India).
Promoting mutual diplomacy between Pakistan and Japan, Crown Prince Akihito and Princess Michiko undertook a visit of Pakistan on 23-29 January 1962 to create the feeling of harmony in Asia, while reparations and normalization were still irritants in improving Japanese relations in Asia. In his welcome address the Emperor admired the Pakistan-Japan ties as under:
“Bonded not only by age of old relationship of culture and civilization but also by the modern ties of trade and cooperation, both Japan and Pakistan have first developed a unique identify of thought and we are emphatic in our belief that in between themselves both the governments and the people of these two countries are by virtue of their deep-rooted love for peace capable of exercising an irresistible influence on world opinion”
The One China policy continued to drag Pakistan relations with Japan on a different path, affecting the civil aviation agreement as Japan did not grant landing right to Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) to fly from inside China in the 1960s. China was supportive of PIA’s proposed route but Japan did not agree, apparently under US pressure. Pakistan’s civil aviation route proposal was actually a step toward the Sino-Japanese rapprochement, which Japan did not appreciate, thus creating cracks in Pakistani-Japanese relations and pushing more Pakistan toward China and mending fences with Communist bloc sourced by the Cold War activities.
The East Pakistan Debacle
Nevertheless, Pakistan remained high on the Japanese Official Development Assistance (ODA) program and revived around 18 percent of assistance disbursed during 1961-71. War in the former East Pakistan and Japanese Red Cross’s (Seki Juji) assistance to refugees who fled to Kolcatta in India, however, created differences between Pakistan and Japan. Japan viewed the crisis in East Pakistan on the basis of Bengali nationalism and supported it. On the other hand, Japan did not support the Vietnamese self-determination. Japan did not adopt complete neutrality toward the issue of East Pakistan unlike it maintained on Kashmir. Japanese political parties and social groups etc rendered support for the cause of the creation of Bangladesh. Soon war broke out in East Pakistan; Japan closed its Consulate-General in Dhaka and cut-off aid to Pakistan (and also to India). Japan recognized Bangladesh within two months on 10 February 1972, inviting more Pakistan’s criticism. Half of Japan’s loans were consumed in East Pakistan and it refused to honor and payback those loans as Japan recognized Bangladesh before Pakistan made any decision.
Decline of Japanese Interest
Moreover, Pakistan’s anti-West stance in the 1970s under the dynamic leadership of Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and his industrial nationalization policy resulted in the decline of Pakistan-Japan diplomatic interaction and decreased interest of Japan entrepreneurs. No high level exchange was taken place during this period. In spite of these strategic changes in Pakistan’s foreign relations, Japan continued to be an important destination of Pakistan’s trade. Furthermore, the normalization of the Sino-Japan ties in the 1970s sent a positive message to promoting Pakistan-Japan ties, which were further strengthened during the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan in 1979. The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan renewed the moment of Pakistan-Japan ties once again. High level exchanges were made. Japan saw a common danger of the presence of Soviet forces in Afghanistan. Japan’s energy lane passing through the Gulf could be jeopardizing if Soviets come to the warm-water ports in the Arabian Sea. Therefore, Japan extended full diplomatic and political support to Pakistan.
Renewal of Ties
President General Muhammad Zia ul Haq visited Japan on 17-22 July 1983. Reciprocating, Prime Minister Yasuhiro Nakasone visited Pakistan on 30 April 3-May 1984, first by a Japanese Minister in 23 years. His visit clearly indicated that Japan endorsed Pakistan’s policy toward Afghanistan. This was the revival of the Cold War understandings. After the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan in 1989, Japan focused more on Pakistan nuclear ambitions at a time when Pakistan just devised the ‘Look East policy’ with an aim to emulate the example of Japan and other East Asian countries to up-lift its economy after it was badly shattered during the war in Afghanistan.
Pakistan’s Look East Policy
Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto attended the funeral ceremony of Emperor Showa in February 1989. Prime Minister Toshiki Kaifu visited Pakistan on 2-3 May 1990, the first by a Japanese leader after the demise of the Cold War. He also wanted to mediate in the complicated issues between Pakistan and India as Japan became assertive after the end of the crisis in Afghanistan. Another notable diplomatic visit was undertaken by President Ghulam Ishaq Khan to Japan in November 1990 to participate in the coronation ceremony of the Emperor.
Soon after becoming Prime Minister in November 1990, Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif decided to visit Japan in July 1991, introducing a new dimension in Pakistan’s foreign relations. The visit was, however, put off as a result of domestic upheaval. The visit was made on 16-19 December 1991, which was purely investment and business related. There was some controversy stirred up about Pakistan’s nuclear program and Japan also linked up its aid policy with Pakistan’s nuclear program and delayed its loan package until bilateral discussions were held on the Nuclear Proliferation Treaty (NPT). In fact, Japan followed the American lines on the nuclear issue after the withdrawal of Soviet forces in Afghanistan. Pakistan’s motorway project between Lahore and Islamabad also invited Japanese criticism as the project was awarded to a South Korean multinational, Daewoo in 1991.
In an effort to consolidate further Pakistan-Japan ties, Prime Minister Benazir undertook an official visit to Japan in January 1996 to hold talks with her counterpart, Ryutaro Hashimoto, who eschewed from the complicated Pakistan-India issues especially after nuclear developments in South Asia. Japan wanted that both Pakistan and India should sign the anti-nuclear treaties. Following Pakistan’s nuclear detonation on 28 May 1998, Japan put economic sanctions on Pakistan.
The 9/11 Reconnects
Prime Minister Yoshiro Mori visited Pakistan on 20-21 August 2000, which was a diplomatic breakthrough in Pakistan-Japan relations after the nuclear blast. The 9/11 events put additional security and economic pressure on Pakistan. The event helped converge Pakistan-Japan security linkages once again like the renewal of their cooperation during the Afghan war. Japan realized the importance of Pakistan to drive the Taliban out from Kabul when the International Conference on Reconstruction was held in Tokyo on 21-11 January 2002.
President General Pervez Musharraf visited Japan on 12-15 March 2002. The visit was heavily loaded with the task related to combating terrorism in Afghanistan. Pakistan joined Japan’s Operation Enduring Freedom – Maritime Interdiction Operation (OEF-MIO), aiming at combating terrorists in the Indian Ocean. Under the operation, Pakistan received fuel and fresh-water facility from Japanese vessels up to January 2010 besides the vessels of other 26 allied countries. The mission was scraped as domestic differences rose high in Japan.
Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi visited Pakistan on 30 April-1 May 2005. On the economic side, a major breakthrough made with regard to the resumption of Japanese new yen loan assistance to Pakistan. In response to Koizumi’s visit to Pakistan, Prime Minister Shoukat Aziz paid a visit to Japan on 8-11 August 2005. Therefore, Pakistan toed a complicated alliance with Japan from 1951 through to 2010 with many ups and downs and setbacks.
The Paradigm Shift
The Japanese so-called idea of the ‘arc of security and freedom’ floated in 2006 in cooperation with India and Australia, a leap forward to India in the shape of civil nuclear cooperation, and approving an India-specific concessions for the supply of nuclear plants and parts at the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) in 2008, have sent negative messages to Islamabad about the growing Indo-Japanese axis in the region. These developments introduced a paradigm shift in Pakistan-Japan relations. A neutral and purely an economic Japan is always welcome by Pakistan in South Asia.
Analysis is contributed by Dr Ahmad Rashid Malik, Senior Research Fellow at the Institute of Strategic Studies Islamabad – Pakistan.
- Embassy of Japan in Pakistan
- Embassy of Pakistan in Japan
- Dialogue: Japan’s contribution in promoting Urdu praised
- Ahmad Rashid Malik, Pakistan-Japan Relations: Continuity and Change in Economic Relations and Security Interests. London & New York: Routledge 2009. http://routledge-ny.com/books/details/9780415462792/
<!-- fixcategory -->