Jean Jules Verdenal
Jean Jules Verdenal (11 May 1890 - 2 May 1915) was a French medical officer who served, and was killed, during the First World War. Verdenal and his life remain cloaked in obscurity; the little we do know comes mainly from interviews with family members and several surviving letters.
Verdenal was born in Pau, France, the son of Paul Verdenal, a medical doctor. He had a talent for foreign languages. He was athletically inclined. Verdenal as a student was interested in literature and poetry and possessed copies of Stéphane Mallarmé's Poésies and of Jules Laforgue's Poésies and Moralités Légendaires. It was perhaps Verdenal's literary inclinations that led him to become friends with American poet T.S. Eliot, whom he met in 1910 at the Sorbonne. After they parted ways, Verdenal and Eliot corresponded through letters. Verdenal was killed on 2 May 1915 while treating a wounded man on the battlefield. This was just a week into the Gallipoli Campaign and a few days shy of his twenty-fifth birthday.
Influence of Verdenal on Eliot
For Jean Verdenal, 1889-1915 mort aux Dardanelles
Or puoi la quantitate
Comprender dell' amor ch'a te mi scalda,
Quando dismento nostra vanitate,
Trattando l'ombre come cosa salda.
[Now can you understand the quantity of love that warms me towards you, so that I forget our vanity, and treat the shadows like the solid thing.]
Imagery reminiscent of Verdenal can also be found in other works, such as The Waste Land. Although he died young and his potential as a great poet was unrealized, Verdenal's memory is preserved in the work of his friend.
Verdenal in publications
In 1952 John Peter, later a novelist but then a Canadian academic, published an essay, "A New Interpretation of The Waste Land" in the journal Essays in Criticism in which he interpreted Eliot's poem The Waste Land as an elegy for a dead (male) friend. The journal got a demand from Eliot's solicitors to stop distributing the issue. The copies still on hand were destroyed and a later reprint of journal issues did not include Peter's essay. Peter wrote a letter of apology to Eliot. Seventeen years later, in 1969, four years after Eliot's death in 1965, Peter's essay was reprinted (although Peter wrote "The foregoing reprints almost verbatim an essay which was printed in Essays in Criticism in July 1952" Timothy Materer found substantial changes from the 1952 essay.) Following this reprint was another essay by Peter, titled "Postscript," where he both described the events and his feelings about the censoring and also expanding upon his original essay. In this second essay Peter identified the friend as Verdenal and quoted Eliot poems, plays and criticism to defend his position.
In 1971 Eliot's drafts to The Waste Land were published in facsimile along with notes by Valerie Eliot, the poet's widow. In January 1972, as part of a series of letters to the London Times Literary Supplement about Eliot's drafts, G. Wilson Knight made the observation that the so-called "hyacinth girl" was male. Knight expanded upon his observation in an essay later that year.
In the early 1970s George Watson made trips to France to learn more about Verdenal from his military record, his family and friends. Watson's article, "Quest for a Frenchman," published in 1976, presented his discoveries.
James E. Miller, who felt that there was a personal meaning The Waste Land, had his attention drawn to Peter and Knight. Miller expanded upon Peter's essays and his book, T. S. Eliot's Personal Waste Land, was published in 1977.
In 1998 Miller wrote about Verdenal's letters to Eliot (not available to him or to the public until 1988 when Valerie Eliot published letters by and to Eliot in the first volume of an intended series.)
Claudio Perinot, wanting to expand the scant knowledge about Verdenal, interviewed Verdenal's nephew in 1994. Perinot's findings were published in 1996.
In 2005 Miller also had a biography of Eliot of published. In the biography (covering the years 1888-1922) Miller provided a synopsis of Watson's and Perinot's findings and the contents of Verdenal's letters to Eliot
Claudio Perinot continued his research on Jean Verdenal and, in 2008, published further information concerning the Frenchman's cultural and family background; for the first time, the precise cause of Verdenal's death was also made known. Then, in 2011, Perinot published a composite micro-biography of Eliot's French friend, based on previously unpublished documents, such as obituary notices, photographs, letters, and reminiscences of the people who knew Jean Verdenal.
- Eliot, T. S. (1963). Collected Poems, 1909-1962. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World. ISBN 0-15-118978-1.
- Eliot, T. S. (1988). The Letters of T. S. Eliot, Volume 1, 1898-1922. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. ISBN 0-15-150885-2.
- Gallup, Donald (1969). T. S. Eliot: A Bibliography (A Revised and Extended Edition). New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
- Knight, G. Wilson. "Thoughts on The Waste Land". The Denver Quarterly 7 (2): 1–13.
- Materer, Timothy (January 2012). "T. S. Eliot and his Biographical Critics". Essays in Criticism (Oxford University Press) LXII (1): 41–57. doi:10.1093/escrit/cgr028.
- Miller, James E. (1977). T. S. Eliot's Personal Waste Land. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press. ISBN 0-271-01237-4.
- Miller, James E. (1998). "T.S. Eliot's 'Uranian Muse': The Verdenal Letters". ANQ II (4): 4–20.
- Perinot, Claudio (1996). "Jean Verdenal: T.S. Eliot's French Friend". Annali di Cà Foscari (Venice: Università di Venezia) XXXV (1-2): 265–275.
- Perinot, Claudio (2008). "Further Notes on the Friendship of Jean Verdenal and T.S. Eliot". ANQ 21 (3): 44–51.
- Perinot, Claudio (2011). "Jean Verdenal: An Extraordinary Young Man: T.S. Eliot’s mort aux Dardanelles". South Atlantic Review 76 (3): 33–50.
- Peter, John (July 1952). "A New Interpretation of The Waste Land". Essays in Criticism II (3): 242–66.
- Peter, John (April 1969). "A New Interpretation of The Waste Land". Essays in Criticism XIX (3): 140–64.
- Peter, John (April 1969). "Postscript". Essays in Criticism XIX (3): 165–75.
- Seymour-Jones, Carole (2001). Painted Shadow: A Life of Vivienne Eliot. London: Constable & Robinson. ISBN 0-271-01237-4.
- Watson, George (1976). "Quest for a Frenchman". The Sewanee Review (Sewanee, Tennessee: University of the South). LXXXIV (3): 466–475.
Notes and citations
- Primary sources: Watson, Perinot, Eliot 1988
- Father: Perinot, p. 267
- Languages: Perinot, p. 268
- Languages: Watson, p. 468
- Athletic: Perinot, p. 266
- Athletic: Eliot 1988, p. 35
- Personal library: Perinot, p. 272
- Personal library: Watson, p. 468
- Letters: None of Eliot's letters to Verdenal survive, but seven letters written by Verdenal to Eliot were donated in 1967 to Harvard University's Houghton Library by Theresa (Garrett) Eliot, the widow of T.S. Eliot's older brother, Henry Ware Eliot Jr. These letters, dating between July 1911 and December 1912, have been published in their original French and in English translations by John Weightman (Eliot 1988, pp. 20–25,27–36). Both James Miller and Carole Seymour-Jones have provided notes about the affection between Verdenal and Eliot displayed in the letters (Miller 1998) (Seymour-Jones, pp. 49–54).
- Battlefield death: Watson, p. 467
- Perinot, 2008, pp 49-50
- Perinot, 2011, p 44
- Dedication: Eliot 1963, p. 1
- Peter, 1952
- Peter, 1969, "Postscript"
- Peter, 1969, "New Interpretation"
- Eliot, 1971
In 1923 Eliot had sold his drafts of The Waste Land to an arts patron, John Quinn (Eliot, 1971, p. xxvi). After Quinn's death it appeared that the drafts were lost but it was announced in October 1968 that the Berg Collection of the New York Public Library had acquired them (Eliot, 1971, p. xxix).
- Times Literary Supplement, January 14, 1972, p.3646
This article also discussed Eliot's life in Paris in 1910-1911.
- Miller, 1998
- Miller, 2005
- Miller, 2005, pp. 117-135
- Perinot 2008
- Perinot 2011