- For the Irish cricketer of the same name, see John Crawfurd (cricketer)
|2nd Resident of Singapore|
27 May 1823 – 15 August 1826
|Monarch||George IV (1820–1830)|
|Preceded by||Major-Gen. William Farquhar|
13 August 1783|
Islay, Argyll, Scotland
|Died||11 May 1868
South Kensington, London, England
John Crawfurd FRS (13 August 1783 – 11 May 1868) was a Scottish physician, colonial administrator and diplomat, and author. He is now best known for his work on Asian languages, his History of the Indian Archipelago, and his role in founding Singapore.
- 1 Early life
- 2 In the East Indies
- 3 Diplomat
- 4 Later life
- 5 Last years
- 6 Works
- 7 Family
- 8 References
- 9 Notes
- 10 External links
He was born on Islay, in Argyll, Scotland, the son of Samuel Campbell, a physician, and Margaret Campbell; and was educated at the school in Bowmore. He followed his father's footsteps in the study of medicine and completed his medical course at the University of Edinburgh in 1803, at the age of 20.
In the East Indies
In 1811, Crawfurd accompanied Raffles on Lord Minto's Java Invasion against the Dutch. Raffles was appointed Lieutenant-Governor of Java by Minto during the 45-day operation, and Crawfurd was appointed the post of Resident at the Court of Yogyakarta in November 1811. There he took a firm line against Sultan Hamengkubuwana II. The Sultan was encouraged by Pakubuwono IV of Surakarta to assume he had support in resisting the British; who sided with his opponents his son the Crown Prince and Pangeran Natsukusuma. The Sultan's palace, the Kraton Ngayogyakarta Hadiningrat, was besieged and taken by British-led forces in June 1812.
Crawfurd was sent on diplomatic missions to Bali and the Celebes (now Sulawesi). His knowledge of the local culture supported Raffles's government in Java. Raffles, however, wanted to introduce land reform in the Cheribon residency. Crawfurd, with his experience of India and the zamindari, was a supporter of the "village system" of revenue collection. He opposed Raffles's attempts to introduce individual (ryotwari) settlement into Java.
Java was returned to the Dutch in 1816, and Crawfurd went back to England that year, shortly becoming a Fellow of the Royal Society, and turning to writing. Within a few years he was recalled to South-East Asia, as a diplomat; his missions were of limited obvious success.
In 1821, Crawfurd's expertise was recognised by Governor-General Lord Hastings, who sent him on a mission as an envoy to the courts of Siam (now Thailand); and then to Cochinchina (now Vietnam). He was accompanied by George Finlayson as naturalist; and travelled with notes on Buddhism, as it was understood at the time, from Horace Hayman Wilson.
The mission to the court of King Rama II was nearly the first official visit to one of the most powerful nations in the region since the Siam–England war of 1687 with the previous Siamese Ayutthaya Kingdom. Hastings was especially interested in learning more about Siamese policy with regard to the northern Malay states. The contact with Siam paved the way for closer relations with Britain, leading King Rama II to ally his kingdom with the British in the First Anglo-Burmese War (1824–1826). It in turn helped Captain Henry Burney conclude the Treaty of Amity and Commerce (Siam–United Kingdom) in June 1826 in the reign of King Rama III.
At Bangkok in May 1822 Crawfurd met Anouvong (Chao Anou), the future rebel and king in what is now Laos, a first diplomatic contact for the UK. This visit was despite the isolation into which the mission had fallen. A Vietnamese embassy had arrived not long before, and tensions were high. Since Crawford's brief opposed the interests of court figures including the Raja of Ligor and Nangklao, there was little prospect of success. By October relations were at a low ebb. Crawfurd moved on to Saigon, but Minh Mạng refused to see him.
Resident of Singapore
Crawfurd was appointed British Resident of Singapore in March 1823. He was under orders to reduce the expenditure on the existing factory there, but instead responded to local commercial representations, and spent money on reclamation work on the river. He also concluded the final agreement between the East India Company, and Sultan Hussein Shah of Johor with the Temenggong, on the status of Singapore on 2 August 1824. It was the culmination of negotiations started by Raffles in 1819, and the agreement is now sometimes called the Crawfurd Treaty. He also had input into the Anglo-Dutch Treaty of 1824 dealing with spheres of influence in the East Indies.
Crawfurd was on familiar terms with Munshi Abdullah. He edited and contributed to the Singapore Chronicle of Francis James Bernard, the first local newspaper that initially appeared dated 1 January 1824. Crawford Street [sic] and Crawford Bridge [sic] in Singapore are named after him.
Crawfurd was sent on another envoy mission to Burma in 1826, by Hastings's successor Lord Amherst, in the aftermath of the First Anglo-Burmese War. It was to be his last political service for the Company. The party included Adoniram Judson as interpreter and Nathaniel Wallich as botanist. Crawfurd's journey to Ava up the River Irrawaddy was by paddle steamer, the Diana: it had been hired by the East India Company for the war, where it had seen action and travelled 400 miles up the Irrawaddy. There were five local boats, and soldiers making up a party of over 50.
Crawfurd at the court found Bagyidaw temporising despite a weak position with the British forces in Arakan and Tenasserim. The king conceded only a trade agreement, in return for a delay in indemnity payments; and sent his own mission to Calcutta.
The expedition fortuitously was delayed on the return journey for repairs. Crawfurd collected significant fossils, north of Magwe on the left bank of the river, in seven chests. Back in London, William Clift identified a new species of mastodon (more accurately Stegolophodon) from them; Hugh Falconer also worked on the collection. The finds, of fossil bones and wood, were discussed further in a paper by William Buckland, giving details; and they brought Crawfurd the friendship of Roderick Murchison, Foreign Secretary of the Geological Society. There were also collected 18,000 botanical specimens, many of which went to the Calcutta Botanic Garden.
In the United Kingdom Crawfurd spent around 40 years in varied activities. He wrote as an orientalist, geographer and ethnologist. He tried parliamentary politics, without success; he agitated for free trade; and he was a publicist for and against colonisation schemes, in line with his views. He also represented the interests of British traders based in Singapore and Calcutta.
Radical parliamentary candidate
Crawfurd made several unsuccessful attempts to enter the British Parliament in the 1830s. His campaign literature featured universal suffrage and the secret ballot, free trade and opposition to monopolies, public education and reduction of military spending, and opposition to regressive taxation and the taxation of Dissenters for a state church, with nationalisation of Church of England properties. He joined the Parliamentary Candidate Society, founded by Thomas Erskine Perry (his brother-in-law), to promote "fit and proper" Members of Parliament. He also joined the Radical Club, a breakaway from the National Political Union founded in 1833 by William Wallis.
Crawfurd unsuccessfully contested, as an advanced radical, Glasgow in 1832, Paisley in 1834, Stirling Burghs in 1835, and Preston in 1837. At Glasgow he polled fourth (there were two MPs for the borough), with Sir Daniel Sandford third. In March 1834 it was Sandford who was elected at Paisley. Alexander's East India and Colonial Magazine struck a note of regret after his defeat at Stirling Burghs.
On 31 January 1834 Crawfurd supported Thomas Perronet Thompson in a meeting agitating against the Corn Laws. Thomas Carlyle alluded, in notes on one of Jane Welsh Carlyle's letters, to Crawfurd speaking at a radical meeting at the London Tavern set up by Charles Buller on 21 November 1834; in which he showed much more originality than John Arthur Roebuck, but lost his thread.
In Preston in the 1837 general election Crawfurd had the Liberal nomination in a three-cornered fight for two seats, as Peter Hesketh-Fleetwood was regarded as a waverer by the Conservatives who ran Robert Townley Parker against him; but he polled third. He also supported John Temple Leader's candidacy at Westminster against Sir Francis Burdett, being deputy chairman on his election committee (with Thomas Prout, chairman Sir Ronald Craufurd Ferguson). Crawfurd spoke with George Grote at a meeting for Leader at the Belgrave Hotel.
A lifelong advocate of free trade policies, in A View of the Present State and Future Prospects of the Free Trade and Colonization of India (1829), Crawfurd made an extended case against the East India Company's approach, in particular in excluding British entrepreneurs, and in failing to develop Indian cotton. He had had experience in Java of the export possibilities for cotton textiles. He then gave evidence in March 1830 to a parliamentary committee, on the East India Company's monopoly of trade with China. Robert Montgomery Martin criticised Crawfurd, and the evidence of Robert Rickards, an ex-employee of the Company, for exaggerating the financial burden of the monopoly on tea. Crawfurd put out a pamphlet, Chinese Monopoly Examined. Ross Donnelly Mangles defended the East India Company in 1830, in an answer addressed to Rickards and Crawfurd. When the Company's charter came up for renewal in 1833, the China trade monopoly was broken. Crawfurd's part as parliamentary agent for interests in Calcutta had been paid (at £1500 per year); his publicity work had included facts for an Edinburgh Review article written by another author.
Colonisation of Australia
In reviewing Edward Gibbon Wakefield's New British Province of South Australia, and subsequent writing in the Westminster Review, Crawfurd gave an opinion against systematic colonisation. He considered that abundant land and individual enterprise were the necessary elements. Robert Torrens, who floated the South Australian Land Company, replied to the Westminster Review line in Colonization of South Australia (1835). Part I of the book is a Letter to Crawfurd.
In 1843 Crawfurd gave evidence to the Colonial Office on Port Essington, on the north coast of Australia, to the effect that its climate made it unsuitable for settlement. He returned to the topic in a debate in 1858 on settlements on the Victoria River, as had been suggested by Sir George Everest. He generally opposed Sir Roderick Murchison's promotion of European colonisation of Australia, as far as it applied to the north coast.
Lobbyist for South and South-East Asia issues
When the Stamp Act 1827 was passed, meaning that all public documents in India would have to pay a stamp tax (including newspapers as well as legal documents), Crawfurd was hired as London agent for a group of British merchants in Calcutta opposing the legislation. Crawfurd involved Joseph Hume, and he obtained newspaper coverage for his cause, including in The Examiner where the precedents from America were cited. He also wrote pamphlets himself, in which he advocated an end to the East India Company monopoly, and European colonisation. These moves occurred in 1828–9; in 1830 Crawfurd approached William Huskisson directly. His lobbying continued with the free trade issues mentioned above. Inquiry into the System of Taxation in India, Letters on the Interior of India, an attack on the newspaper stamp-tax and the duty on paper entitled Taxes on Knowledge (1836) is a related work.
In 1855 Crawfurd went with a delegation to the Board of Control of the East India Company, with representations on behalf of the Straits dollar as an independent currency. Crawfurd lobbied in both Houses of Parliament, with George Keppel, 6th Earl of Albemarle acting to bring a petition to the Lords, and William Ewart Gladstone putting the case in the Commons. Among the arguments put was that the dollar was a decimal currency, while the rupee used by traders, and legal tender in East India Company territories since it was coined in 1835, was not. In 1856 a Bill to change the status quo on coins minted and issued from India was defeated.
Crawfurd wrote prolificly. His views have been seen as inconsistent: a recent author wrote that "[...] Crawfurd seemed to embody a complex mixture of elements of coexisting but ultimately contradictory value systems". A comment about "hasty general opinions from a few instances", by George Bennett on the topic of Papuan people, has been taken to be aimed at Crawfurd.
Diplomat and traveller
In retirement after the Burmese mission, Crawfurd wrote books and papers on Eastern subjects. His envoy experiences from missions were written up in Journals in 1828 and 1829. This documentation was reprinted nearly 140 years later by Oxford University Press.
- Journal of an Embassy to the Court of Ava in 1827 (1829)
- Journal of an Embassy to the Courts of Siam and Cochin-China, exhibiting a view of the actual State of these Kingdoms (1830)
- Descriptive Dictionary of the Indian Islands and Adjacent Countries (1856)
According to Jane Rendall's concept of "Scottish orientalism", Crawfurd is a historian of the second generation. His History of the Indian Archipelago (1820), in three volumes, was his major work. Crawfurd was a critic of much of what the European nations had done in the area of Asia he covered.
An Historical and Descriptive Account of China (1836) was a joint work in three volumes from the Edinburgh Cabinet Library, with Hugh Murray, Peter Gordon, Thomas Lynn, William Wallace, and Gilbert Thomas Burnett.
- Grammar and Dictionary of the Malay Language (1852)
Crawfurd held strong views on what he saw as the backwardness of the economy of India of his time. He attributed it to the weakness of Indian financial institutions, compared to Europe. His opinions were in an anonymous pamphlet A Sketch of the Commercial Resources and Monetary and Mercantile System of British India (1837) now attributed to him. Like Robert Montgomery Martin, he saw India primarily as a source of raw materials, and advocated investment based on that direction. A harsh critic of the existing Calcutta agencies, he noted the absence of bill broking in India and suggested that an exchange bank should be set up.
While Crawfurd produced work that was ethnological in nature over a period of half a century, the term "ethnology" had not even been coined when he began to write. Attention has been drawn to his latest work, from the 1860s, which was copious. It met much criticism at the time, and has also been scrutinised in the 21st century.
Crawfurd held polygenist views, based on multiple origins of human groups; and these earned him, according to Sir John Bowring, the nickname "the inventor of forty Adams". In The Descent of Man by Charles Darwin, Crawfurd is cited as believing in 60 races. He expressed these views to the Ethnological Society of London (ESL), a traditional stronghold of monogenism (belief in a unified origin of humankind) where he had come in 1861 to hold office as President.
Crawfurd believed in different races as separate creations by God in specific regional zones, with separate origins for languages, and possibly as different species. With Robert Gordon Latham of the ESL, he also opposed strongly the ideas of Max Müller on an original Aryan race.
Papers of the 1860s
Crawford wrote in 1861 in the Transactions of the ESL a paper On the Conditions Which Favour, Retard, and Obstruct the Early Civilization of Man, in which he argued for deficiencies in the science and technology of Asia. In On the Numerals as Evidence of the Progress of Civilization (1863) he argued that the social condition of a people correlates with the numeral words of their language. Crawfurd used domestication frequently as a metaphor. His racist views on black people were laughed at, during the British Association meeting at Birmingham in 1865.[need quotation to verify]
A paper by Crawfurd, On the Physical and Mental Characteristics of European and Asian Races of Man, given 13 February 1866, argued for the superiority of Europeans. It particularly laid emphasis on European military dominance as evidence. Its thesis was directly contradicted at a meeting of the Society some weeks later, by Dadabhai Naoroji.
Crawford's agenda and alleged distortions
Recent critics have sought to clarify the agenda to which Crawfurd was writing, at this time, when he had become prominent in a young and still fluid field and discipline. Ellingson has accused Crawfurd of distorting the idea of the noble savage. Trosper has taken Ellingson's analysis a step further, attributing to Crawfurd a conscious "spin" put on the idea of primitive culture, a rhetorically sophisticated use of a "straw man" fallacy, achieved by bringing in, irrelevantly but for the sake of incongruity, the figure of Jean-Jacques Rousseau.
Ellingson argues that Crawfurd gave up his writing on the topic of the "savage" to pursue the implications of Darwin's thought on human evolution, which were unwelcome to him. Right at the end of his life, in 1868, Crawfurd was using a "missing link" argument against Sir John Lubbock, in what Ellingson describes as a misrepresentation of a Darwinist viewpoint based on the idea that a precursor of humans must still be extant.
Ellingson points to a work of William Falconer, On the Influence of Climate from 1781, with an attack on Rousseau, as a possible source of Crawfurd's thinking; while also pointing out some differences. Ellingson also places Crawfurd in a British group among those of his period whose anthropological views not only turned on race, but who also drew conclusions of superiority from those views, others being Luke Burke, James Hunt, Robert Knox, and Kenneth R. H. Mackenzie.
Crawford's attitudes were not, however, based on human skin colour; and he was an opponent of slavery, having written an article "Sugar without Slavery" with Thomas Perronet Thompson in 1833 in the Westminster Review. Charles Darwin identified Crawfurd's racial views as "Pallasian", i.e. the analogue for humankind of the theories of Peter Simon Pallas.
The predominant approach in the ESL went back to James Cowles Prichard. In the view of Thomas Trautmann, in Crawfurd's attack on the Aryan theory there is a final rejection of the "languages and nations" approach, which was Prichard's, and a consequent freeing of (polygenist) racial theory.
Crawfurd married Horatia Ann, daughter of James Perry. The writer Oswald John Frederick Crawfurd was their son. The couple knew John Sterling, and the Carlyles. Thomas Carlyle met Henry Crabb Robinson at dinner at the Crawfurds (25 November 1837, at 27 Wilton Crescent), making a poor impression.
- Terry Jay Ellingson (2001), The Myth of the Noble Savage; Google Books.
- Ernest C. T. Chew (2002), 'Dr John Crawfurd (1783–1868): The Scotsman Who Made Singapore British', Raffles Town Club, vol. 8 (July–Sept). Singapore : Raffles Town Club.
- Turnbull, C. M. "Crawfurd, John". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/6651. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- Clements Robert Markham, The Fifty Years' Work of the Royal Geographical Society (1881), p. 53; archive.org.
- Merle Calvin Ricklefs, A History of Modern Indonesia since c. 1200 (2001), pp. 148–9; Google Books.
- Tony Day, Fluid Iron: state formation in Southeast Asia (2002), p. 118; Google Books.
- Joshua Eliot, Liz Capaldi, Jane Bickersteth,Indonesia Handbook (2001), p. 167; Google Books.
- Bennett Zon, Representing Non-Western Music in Nineteenth-century Britain (2007), p. 31; Books.
- Bastin, John. "Malayan Portraits: John Crawfurd", in Malaya, vol.3 (December 1954), pp.697–698.
- Hudson, Giles. "Finlayson, George". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/9468. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- p. 11; Google Books.
- Steam, Duncan (14–20 May 2004). "Dr. John Crawfurd and the Mission to Thailand, 1822" (Column). A Slice of Thai History. Pattaya Mail. Retrieved 11 August 2011. "This in turn helped Captain Henry Burney conclude a treaty of commerce with Thailand in June 1826."
- Crawfurd, John (21 August 2006) . "VI. — Visit from a Chief of Lao.". Journal of an embassy from the governor-general of India to the courts of Siam and Cochin China 1 (second ed.). London: H. Colburn and R. Bentley. pp. 207–209. OCLC 03452414. Retrieved 13 February 2012. "May 19. .... In the afternoon I had a visit from a native chief; a circumstance which did not often take place, for our vicinity to the Prah-klang's house, and the fear of exciting the jealousy of the Go- vernment, prevented many persons from calling upon us, who were otherwise well disposed to do so. The manners of this individual, who was a native of Lao, were singular. When he enter- ed the room, I begged him to be seated; but before complying, he made three obeisances to- wards the palace, then three towards the residence of the Prah-klang, and three more to the company before him. His conversation was frank and in- telligent, and he appeared well-informed respect- ing his own country, which forms so interesting and considerable, but to Europeans so little known, a portion of the present Siamese Empire."
- Mayurī Ngaosīvat, Pheuiphanh Ngaosyvathn, Paths to Conflagration: fifty years of diplomacy and warfare in Laos, Thailand, and Vietnam, 1778-1828 (1998), p. 110–2; Google Books.
- Nicholas Tarling (editor), The Cambridge History of Southeast Asia: Vol. 2, The nineteenth and twentieth centuries (1992), p. 42; Google Books.
- Stephen Dobbs, The Singapore River: a social history, 1819-2002 (2003), pp. 25–6; Google Books.
- Carl A. Trocki, Prince of Pirates: the temenggongs and the development of Johor and Singapore, 1784-1885 (2007), p. 72 note 15; Google Books.
- R. Haller-Trost, Historical Legal Claims: a study of disputed sovereignty over Pulau Batu Puteh (Pedra Branca) (1993), p. 18; Google Books.
- Justin Corfield, Historical Dictionary of Singapore (2010), p. 73; Google Books.
- Dru C. Gladney, Making Majorities: constituting the nation in Japan, Korea, China, Malaysia, Fiji, Turkey, and the United States (1998), p. 155; Google Books.
- Francis T. Seow, The Media Enthralled: Singapore revisited (1998), p. 6; Google Books.
- Crawfurd's published Diary, SOAS transcription (PDF).
- Data on the Diana.
- Thomas J. Misa, Leonardo to the Internet: technology & culture from the Renaissance to the present (2004), p. 101; Google Books.
- David Joel Steinberg, In Search of Southeast Asia: a modern history (1971), p. 105; Google Books.
- M. J. S. Rudwick, Worlds before Adam: the reconstruction of geohistory in the age of reform (2008), p. 221; Google Books.
- Moore, D. T. "Falconer, Hugh". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/9110. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- John Claudius Loudon, Edward Charlesworth, John Denson (editors), Magazine of Natural History, vol. 1 (1829), p. 186; Google Books.
- Robert A. Stafford, Scientist of Empire: Sir Roderick Murchison, Scientific Exploration and Victorian Imperialism (2002), p. 111; Google Books.
- David Amigoni, Colonies, Cults and Evolution: literature, science and culture in nineteenth-century writing (2007), p. 5; Google Books.
- Henry Fairfield Osborn, Mabel Rice Percy, Proboscidea: a monograph of the discovery, evolution, migration and extinction of the mastodonts and elephants of the world vol. 2 (1936), p. 827; archive.org.
- Ellingson, p. 264; Google Books.
- Papers relating to the Parliamentary Candidates Society, London Radicalism 1830-1843: A selection of the papers of Francis Place (1970), pp. 15-25. URL: http://www.british-history.ac.uk/report.aspx?compid=39481 Date accessed: 26 January 2012.
- The Radical Club, and other papers', London Radicalism 1830-1843: A selection of the papers of Francis Place (1970), pp. 119-134. Date accessed: 30 January 2012.
- Prothero, Iorwerth. "Wallis, William (fl. 1824–1830), silk weaver and radical leader". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/48772. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- Dictionary of National Biography, Crawfurd, John (1783–1868), orientalist, by R. K. Douglas. Published 1888.
- The Royal kalendar and court and city register for England, Scotland, Ireland and the colonies: for the year 1833 (1833), p. 115; Google Books.
- Curthoys, M. C. "Sandford, Daniel Keyte". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/24632. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- Alexander's East India and Colonial Magazine, vol. 9 (1835), p. 426; Google Books.
- Tait's Edinburgh Magazine, March 1834, vol. 1 p. 140; Google Books.
- carlyleletters.dukejournals.org, Thomas Carlyle's notes to a letter of Jane Carlyle.
- Henry Wordsworth Clemesha, A History of Preston in Amounderness (1912), p. 265; archive.org.
- The Spectator, 6 May 1837, vol. 10, p. 429; Google Books.
- The Spectator, 6 May 1837, vol. 10, p. 415; Google Books.
- Giorgio Riello, Om Prakash, How India Clothed the World: the world of South Asian textiles, 1500-1850 (2009), pp. 42–6; Google Books.
- Report of the Select Committee of the House of Commons on the Affairs of the East India Company: China Trade (1830) p, 420; Google Books.
- historyofparliamentonline.org, Rickards, Robert (1769-1836), of Sloane Street, Mdx..
- Robert Montgomery Martin, British Relations with the Chinese Empire in 1832: comparative statement of the English and American trade with India and Canton (1832, p. 114; Google Books.
- Dictionary of National Biography, Mangles, Ross Donnelly (1801–1877), chairman of the East India Company, by E. I. Carlyle. Published 1901.
- Michael Greenberg, British Trade and the Opening of China 1800-1842 (1969), Ch. VII The Victory of the Free Traders; Google Books.
- Greenberg, pp. 183–4; Google Books.
- Malini Johar Schueller, Edward Watts, Messy Beginnings: postcoloniality and early American studies (2003), pp. 123–4; Google Books.
- Australian Dictionary of Biography, Torrens, Robert (1780–1864).
- Robert Torrens, Colonization of South Australia (1835), p. 1; Google Books.
- Robert A. Stafford, Scientist of Empire: Sir Roderick Murchison, Scientific Exploration and Victorian Imperialism (2002), p. 45; Google Books.
- Stafford, p. 55; Google Books.
- Glenn Burgess, Matthew Festenstein, English Radicalism, 1550-1850 (2007), pp. 298–9; Google Books.
- Burgess and Festenstein, p. 306 note 51; Google Books.
- Charles Burton Buckley, An Anecdotal History of Old Times in Singapore, vol. 2 (1902), pp. 596–9; archive.org.
- Anthony Webster, Gentlemen Capitalists: British Imperialism in South East Asia, 1770-1890 (1998), p. 171; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 310; Google Books.
- Bronwen Douglas and Chris Ballard (editors), Foreign Bodies: Oceania and the Science of Race 1750–1940, p. 200 note 58 (PDF).
- Avril A. Powell, Scottish Orientalists and India: The Muir Brothers, Religion, Education and Empire (2010), p. 152; Google Books.
- James A. Boon, Affinities and Extremes: crisscrossing the bittersweet ethnology of East Indies history, Hindu-Balinese culture, and Indo-European allure (1990), p. 30; Google Books.
- British Library, Javanese and Old Javanese language collections
- K. Alexander Adelaar, Nikolaus Himmelmann, The Austronesian Languages of Asia and Madagascar (2005), p. 489; Google Books.
- K. N. Chaudhuri, The Economic Development of India under the East India Company 1814-58: A Selection of Contemporary Writings (1971), p. 4; Google Books.
- Chaudhuri, p. 15; Google Books.
- Blair B. Kling, Partner in Empire: Dwarkanath Tagore and the age of enterprise in eastern India (1976), p. 71; Google Books.
- Kling, p. 203; Google Books.
- Samuel Taylor Coleridge, John Colmer (editor), On the Constitution of the Church and State (1976), p. 89; Google Books.
- Autobiographical Recollections of Sir John Bowring (1877), p. 214; archive.org.
- s:The Descent of Man (Darwin)/Chapter VII
- David N. Livingstone, Adam's Ancestors: race, religion, and the politics of human origins, 2008, p. 113; Google Books.
- Edward Beasley, The Victorian Reinvention of Race: new racisms and the problem of grouping in the human sciences (2010), p. 188 note 50; Google Books.
- Michael Adas, Machines as the Measure of Men: science, technology, and ideologies of Western dominance (1990), p. 302; Google Books.
- Stephen Chrisomalis, The Cognitive and Cultural Foundations of Numbers, p. ii, in The Oxford Handbook of the History of Mathematics (2009), p. ii; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 306; Google Books.
- Beasley, p. 18; Google Books.
- Theodore Koditschek, Liberalism, Imperialism, and the Historical Imagination: Nineteenth-Century Visions of a Greater Britain (2011), p. 263; Google Books.
- Adas, p. 175; Google Books.
- Ronald L. Trosper, Resilience, Reciprocity and Ecological Economics: Northwest Coast sustainability (2009), p. 29; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 318; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 322; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 300; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 239; Google Books.
- Ellingson, p. 265; Google Books.
- George Stocking, Jr., Victorian Anthropology (1987), p. 252.
- Michael J. Turner, Independent Radicalism in Early Victorian Britain (2004), p. 195; Google Books.
- Jeremy Bentham, Sir John Bowring, John Stuart Mill (editors), Westminster Review, p. 247; Google Books.
- Thomas R. Trautmann, Languages and Nations: the Dravidian proof in colonial Madras (2006), p. 223; Google Books.
- Dictionary of National Biography, Crawfurd, Oswald John Frederick (1834–1909), author, by S. E. Fryer. Published 1912.
- Carlyle Letters page, Jane Welsh Carlyle's Journal, October 1855–July 1856, note 99.
- carlyleletters.dukejournals.org, Thomas Carlyle to John A. Carlyle; 12 December 1837 note 14.
Major-Gen. William Farquhar
|Resident of Singapore
27 May 1823 – 15 August 1826
Governor of the Straits Settlements