Deering in 1938
|Born||John W. Deering
|Died||October 31, 1938
Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
|Other names||Fred Davis|
|Criminal penalty||Execution by firing squad|
|Criminal status||Executed on October 31, 1938 at Sugar House Prison|
|Conviction(s)||First-degree murder – 1938|
John W. Deering (September 1898 – October 31, 1938) was the subject of an experiment to observe what would happen to the human heart during death by gunshot. Deering, an American facing execution by the state of Utah for the May 1938 murder of Oliver R. Meredith Jr., volunteered to have himself hooked up to an electrocardiogram while he was shot by a firing squad. The test indicated that his heart stopped in about 15 seconds of being hit, although other bodily functions, such as breathing, continued for a longer period of time.
Deering, who was raised in Chicago, Illinois, stated that he had a tumultuous childhood. Due to neglect, he was committed to a reformatory from the ages of thirteen to eighteen. Aspiring to join the military since his youth, Deering joined the U.S. Merchant Marines, but soon found himself incarcerated at San Quentin State Prison and Folsom State Prison, both in California.
When I was a kid raising hell everyone told me I'd end up on the gallows, so I thought I'd fool them. Also, there's an old saying I like: 'Live by the sword and die by the sword.'—John Deering, October 1938
At around 9:00 pm on May 9, 1938 in Salt Lake City, 52-year-old real estate businessman Oliver R. Meredith Jr. was found shot and bleeding to death in his car. Meredith was taken nearby to the Madsen Apartments, where he lived with his wife, and died soon afterwards. A .38-caliber shell casing was found nearby and matched bullets retrieved from Meredith's body and also from a carjacking on May 7 of Maurice L. Howe and his wife, Lucie. The couple from Ogden identified Deering as the assailant who had also robbed them of $11 that night in Salt Lake City. Investigators found a .38 Colt automatic pistol that had been sold for $3 around May 12 to a pawnbroker near the Palace Casino in Reno, Nevada. The firearm was traced to Deering and was matched to the bullets from the crime scenes through ballistic fingerprinting.
Arrest and confession
On July 29, 1938, Deering was arrested in Hamtramck, Michigan on suspicion of robbing the Hamtramck Finance Company. Having already spent 17 years behind bars, Deering did not want to face another 15 years imprisonment in Michigan. Hoping to be executed after hearing of his mother's death, Deering confessed to kidnapping the Howes and killing Meredith in Salt Lake City. Deering stated that he ran away after the shooting, and read about Meredith's death in a newspaper on the following day. His statement mentioned killing another man on a freight train and disposing of the body in a swamp, though that victim remained unidentified. Investigators later determined that Deering had been responsible for the shootings of two police officers in Salt Lake City and another in Portland, Oregon. Deering was also implicated in the murder of George L. Olson in Twin Falls, Idaho and the torture-killing case of Hazel and Nancy Frome in Van Horn, Texas, but evidence was not found to connect him to those cases.
Deering was charged with the murder of Meredith on August 1, and was extradited to Utah on August 6. Right before being placed on a train back to Salt Lake City, Deering stated: "I don't mind dying. I see the futility of it all."
Trial and incarceration
Deering opposed the appointment of a defense attorney during his arraignment before Judge Herbert M. Schiller on August 11, 1938. His murder trial commenced on September 19 at the Third District Court under Judge Schiller while initially represented by attorney Edgar C. Jensen. Deering admitted his regret for shooting and killing Meredith to steal his automobile. He asked to be executed "without all the red tape and rigamarole of courts." The trial was marked by an outburst from Deering against the court for entering a mandatory plea of not guilty on his behalf. At one point, Deering was restrained by handcuffs after violently protesting the need to call the elderly widow of Meredith as a witness, despite his confessions. Judge Schiller noted Deering's "most extraordinary attitude" in refusing counsel and seeking his "constitutional right" to plead guilty to face the death penalty. The jury delivered a guilty verdict on September 21 after only an hour of deliberation; Deering thanked them and said, "you've done your duty."
The court later appointed public defender Clifford L. Ashton to represent Deering, who requested execution by firing squad over the other option of hanging at his sentencing hearing on September 24. As no requests for retrial nor commutation of sentence were pursued, his execution date was reached in only about three months from his arrest. Deering's sister Dorothy DeVaney wrote to him, hoping that he would "fight the case", but to no avail.
While awaiting his death sentence, Deering sought to be a model inmate and became popular with the prison guards. He publicly stated, "Build more athletic fields and gymnasiums ... Give children more play facilities to keep their minds on wholesome activities. Give them the chance to develop that I never had."
During the night of October 30, 1938, Deering ate a last meal of pheasant, which he requested because he had never tasted it before. He was joined by his young attorney along with prison warden Owen Nebeker and chaplain Jim B. Moreton. During his meal, Deering said, "From here on, I've got to be an actor ... Nobody must know what goes on inside of me." However, he agreed to allow physicians to monitor his heart activity over the course of his execution, believed to be the first such experiment to be conducted.
At 6:30 am on October 31, Deering was taken to a room at Sugar House Prison in the Sugar House neighborhood of Salt Lake City. 75 witnesses gathered to witness the event while blankets were placed over the windows to block the view from hundreds of curious spectators who had gathered outside. A guard placed a target over Deering's heart and a hood over his head. Prison doctor Stephen H. Besley connected sensors on Deering's wrists to an electrocardiogram, which indicated that his heart rate jumped from 72 beats per minute to over 180 when he was strapped to a chair in front of the firing squad. The five marksmen, each paid $50 by the county, were selected by Sheriff S. Grant Young. The names of the marksmen were kept secret; one was provided a rifle loaded with a blank cartridge so that they would not know who fired the lethal shot. After thanking the warden for treating him well, Deering spoke his last words: "Good-bye and good luck! Okay, let it go."
22 seconds later, Deering was shot at the time of 6:46 am. His heart entered into a spasm for 4 seconds and gradually stopped after 15.6 seconds. However, he continued to breathe and struggle in his chair for nearly a minute. Deering was pronounced dead at 6:48½ am, 134.4 seconds after his heart had stopped. He was 40 years old.
I'm going out there and prove that those guys who said life begins at 40 are cockeyed liars.—John Deering, October 1938
On November 1, 1938, Doctor Besley discussed his observations of Deering with the press: "He put on a good front. The electrocardiograph film shows his bold demeanor hid the actual emotions pounding within him. He was scared to death." Deering's eyes, which he had willed for corneal transplantation, were immediately removed, frozen, and flown via United Airlines to San Francisco. On November 8, a surgeon confirmed that tissue from Deering's corneas successfully restored sight to a 27-year-old blind man, whose name was withheld at the surgeon's request. Some of the corneal tissue was also implanted in the eyes of a four-year-old boy who had been blind since birth. Deering had previously offered the transplant to blind Utah County attorney Arnold C. Roylance, who was medically unable to accept the offer. Deering's body was donated to the medical department of the University of Utah, so that, in his own words, he could finally receive a "high class education".
- Blood atonement
- Capital punishment in Utah
- Capital punishment in the United States
- John David Duty, another convict who pursued the death penalty in Oklahoma, but took nine years to be executed after later filing appeals.
- "Firing Squad Ends Career of Murderer". Telegraph Herald 102 (41) (Dubuque, Iowa). International News Service. October 31, 1938. p. 1. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- "Questioned in Frome Deaths". Berkeley Daily Gazette. United Press International. August 2, 1938. p. 1. Retrieved February 11, 2011.
- Boese, Alex (2007). "Heartbeat at Death". Elephants on Acid: And Other Bizarre Experiments. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. pp. 246–249. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- "Deering Kin Urges Him To Fight For Life". Deseret News 351 (35). August 9, 1938. p. 9. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- Elder, Robert K.; Terkel, Studs (2010). Last Words of the Executed. University of Chicago Press. p. 119. Retrieved November 1, 2010.
- Gillespie (1997). The Unforgiven. p. 115. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- Hobbs, Gladys (October 24, 1938). "John Deering Has No Fear As Death Nears". Deseret News 352 (20). p. 9. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- Gillespie (1997). The Unforgiven. p. 115.
- "Bullet Test Will Aid In Slaying Case". Deseret News 350 (42). May 24, 1938. p. 5. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- "Police Expect Early Return of S.L. Slayer". Deseret News 351 (30). August 3, 1938. p. 9. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- "Crime: By the Sword". Time. November 7, 1938. p. 164. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- "Science Sees Human Heart Cease Action". The Evening Independent 31 (309). Associated Press. October 31, 1938. p. 2. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- Hobbs, Gladys (October 31, 1938). "Deering Dies With Thanks Upon His Lips". Deseret News 352 (26). pp. 1–3. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- "Hidden Rifles to Fulfill Execution Wish of Slayer". The Pittsburgh Press 55 (123). United Press International. October 27, 1938. p. 2. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- "Early End To Olsen Slaying Mystery Seen". Deseret News 350 (46). May 28, 1938. p. 9. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- "Robbery Suspect to Face Murder Charge". Berkeley Daily Gazette. United Press International. August 6, 1938. p. 11. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- "Handcuffs Ordered For Accused Man". Deseret News 351 (69). September 20, 1938. p. 11. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- "Deering Will Die For Crime On Monday". Deseret News 352 (24). October 28, 1938. p. 13. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- Gillespie (1997). The Unforgiven. p. 117.
- "Firing Squad Will Execute Deering Oct. 31". Deseret News 351 (73). September 24, 1938. p. 3. Retrieved February 14, 2011.
- Schindler, Hal (January 28, 1996). "Taylor's Death Was Quick . . . But Some Weren't So Lucky". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved June 26, 2010.
- "Cardiograph Records Action of Heart When Murder is Executed". Sarasota Herald-Tribune (24). Associated Press. October 31, 1938. p. 3. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- Gillespie (1997). The Unforgiven. p. 117.
- "To Die Before Firing Squad". Lodi News-Sentinel (1016). United Press International. October 31, 1938. p. 1. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- Society. "Firing Squad Ready to Execute Killer". The Pittsburgh Press 55 (126). United Press International. October 30, 1938. p. 12. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- "Execution Recorded". Lawrence Journal-World 82 (260). Associated Press. October 31, 1938. p. 4. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- Hobbs, Gladys (October 31, 1938). "Science Benefits By Execution Deering". Deseret News 352 (26). p. 3. Retrieved February 15, 2011.
- "Mrs. Simms Aids Campaign From Bed In Hospital". Chicago Tribune. October 27, 1938. p. 3. Retrieved December 21, 2010. "A slayer who faces a firing squad at dawn Monday at his own request said today, 'I'm going out there and prove that those guys who said life begins at 40 are cockeyed liars.' Less than two months ago, John W. Deering observed his 40th birthday."
- "Dead Convict's Eyes Flown To San Francisco: Operations To Be Made With Optics". Lodi News-Sentinel (1017). United Press International. November 1, 1938. p. 1. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- "Man Sees First Time Through Killer's Eyes". The Montreal Gazette. Associated Press. November 9, 1938. p. 9. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- Hobbs, Gladys (November 9, 1938). "Blind Man Is Aided By Deering Eyes". Deseret News 352 (34). p. 13. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- "John Deering Offers Eyes And Body To Science As He Awaits Firing Squad". Deseret News 352 (25). October 29, 1938. p. 1. Retrieved December 20, 2010.
- Gillespie (1997). The Unforgiven. p. 117.
- "Series: Gang Busters". Jerry Haendiges Vintage Radio Logs. February 28, 2010. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
- Gillespie, L. Kay (1997). The Unforgiven: Utah's Executed Men. Salt Lake City: Signature Books. pp. 115–117. ISBN 978-1-56085-098-4. OCLC 37361748.
- Midgley, L. (December 4, 1938). "You Can't Be Brave Facing Death". Albuquerque Journal. p. 19.