Jonathan Pollard

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Jonathan Pollard
Jonathan Pollard.png
Born Jonathan Jay Pollard
(1954-08-07) August 7, 1954 (age 60)
Galveston, Texas, U.S.
Other names Thomas Richered Pollard Jr
Occupation Former intelligence analyst and spy for Israel
Religion Judaism
Criminal charge
Violations of the Espionage Act
Criminal penalty
Life imprisonment
Criminal status Incarcerated in the Federal Bureau of Prisons system
Spouse(s) Anne Henderson Pollard (divorced)
Elaine Zeitz, aka Esther Pollard (current)
Parents Morris Pollard (father)
Molly Pollard (mother)

Jonathan Jay Pollard (born August 7, 1954) is an American prison inmate who pled guilty in 1987 to selling classified information to Israel while working as a civilian intelligence analyst.[1] He was sentenced to life in prison; but because his offenses were committed prior to November 1987, he could become eligible for parole as early as November 2015.[2][3]

Pollard is the only American ever to receive a life sentence for passing classified information to an ally of the U.S.[4] Israeli officials, American and Israeli activist groups, and American politicians who see his punishment as unfair have lobbied continuously for reduction or commutation of his sentence.[5] The Israeli government issued a formal apology to the U.S. in 1987 for its role in Pollard's espionage.[6] Since then, it has made repeated attempts, through both official and unofficial channels, to negotiate his release. Israel granted Pollard citizenship in 1995, but did not publicly admit buying classified information from him until 1998.[7] Pollard's rabbi has written that Pollard "expressed regret" for his actions,[8] and argue that he was never charged with treason (which is only applicable, technically, in cases that involve an enemy state).[5]

In contrast, there is considerable ongoing resistance to any form of clemency from numerous officials familiar with the case, including former CIA director George Tenet, multiple former U.S. Secretaries of Defense, a bipartisan group of U.S. congressional leaders, and members of the American intelligence community.[9][10] Opponents maintain that the damage to American national security as a result of Pollard's activities was far more severe and enduring than publicly acknowledged.[9] Intelligence officials contend that at least some of the information purchased from Pollard ended up in the Soviet Union.[9] His motives, they argue, were monetary, not idealistic or patriotic.[9] He stole classified documents related to China that his wife used to advance her personal business interests.[11] He admitted shopping his services to countries other than Israel.[12] There is evidence that he sold classified information to South Africa, and attempted to do so with Pakistan.[12] He also attempted to broker arms deals with South Africa, Argentina, Taiwan, Pakistan, and Iran.[9]

Pollard's case was later compared to that of Ben-ami Kadish, another U.S. citizen who pled guilty to charges of passing classified information to Israel in the same period.[13][14]

Biography[edit]

Early life[edit]

Jonathan Jay Pollard was born in Galveston, Texas, in 1954, to a Jewish family, the youngest of three siblings.[9] In 1961, his family moved to South Bend, Indiana, where his father, an award-winning microbiologist, taught at Notre Dame.[9]

At an early age Pollard became aware of the horrific toll the Holocaust had taken on his immediate family, and when he was about to become a Bar Mitzva he asked his parents to visit the death camps.[8] Pollard's family made a special effort to instill a sense of Jewish identity in their children, and were devoted to the cause of Israel and impressed their love for the country upon their children.[15] Growing up in an area that had very few Jews, Pollard was often bullied as a child, nevertheless he was deeply involved with the Jewish groups in his area.

Pollard grew up with what he called a "racial obligation" to Israel,[16] and made his first trip to Israel in 1970, as part of a science program visiting the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot. While there, he was hospitalized after a fight with another student. One Weizmann scientist remembered Pollard as leaving behind "a reputation of being an unstable troublemaker, the worst case of this kind in the history of the summer camp".[17]

After completing high school, Pollard attended Stanford University, where he completed a degree in political science in 1976.[9] While there, he is remembered by several of his acquaintances as boasting that he was a dual citizen of the United States and Israel and claiming to work for the Mossad and to have attained the rank of colonel in the Israel Defense Forces. None of these claims were true.[18][19][20] Later, Pollard enrolled in several graduate schools, but never completed a postgraduate degree.[9]

Pollard's future wife, Anne Henderson (born (1960-05-01) 1 May 1960 (age 54)), had moved to Washington DC in fall 1978 to live with her (recently divorced) father, Bernard Henderson. According to her father, in summer 1981 she moved into a house on Capitol Hill with two other women and, through a friend of one of her roommates, she first met Pollard. He later claimed to have fallen in love during their first meeting – they were "an inseparable couple" by November 1981, and in June 1982, when her Capitol Hill lease expired, she moved into Pollard's apartment in Arlington, Virginia.[21] In December 1982, the couple moved into downtown Washington, DC, to a two-bedroom apartment at 1733 20th Street NW, near Dupont Circle. They would remain there until their arrest in 1985, at which time they were paying US$750 per month in rent.[22] They did not marry until August 9, 1985 – more than a year after Pollard began spying for Israel – in a civil ceremony in Venice, Italy.[23]

Early career[edit]

In 1979, after leaving graduate school, Pollard began applying for intelligence service jobs, first at the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and then the U.S. Navy. Pollard was turned down for the CIA job after taking a polygraph test in which he admitted to prolific illegal drug usage between 1974 and 1978.[24] He fared better with the Navy and on 19 September 1979 he was hired by the Navy Field Operational Intelligence Office (NFOIO), an office of the Naval Intelligence Command (NIC), as an intelligence specialist working on Soviet issues at the Navy Ocean Surveillance Information Center (NOSIC), a department of NFOIO. A background check was required to receive the necessary security clearances, but no polygraph test. In addition to a 'Top Secret' clearance, a more stringent 'Sensitive Compartmented Information' (SCI) clearance was required. The Navy asked for but was denied information from the CIA regarding Pollard, including the results of their pre-employment polygraph test showing Pollard's excessive drug use.[24] Pollard was given temporary non-SCI security clearances pending completion of his background check, which was normal for new hires at the time and assigned to temporary duty at another NIC Department, the Naval Intelligence Support Center (NISC) Surface Ships Division, where he could be employed in tasks not requiring SCI clearance. NOSIC's current operations center and the NISC were co-located in Suitland, Maryland, inside the Washington D.C. "Beltway", the forerunner to today's National Maritime Intelligence-Integration Office.

Two months after Pollard was hired, the technical director of NOSIC, Richard Haver, requested that he be terminated.[24] This came after a conversation with the new hire in which Pollard offered to start a back-channel operation with the South African intelligence service and lied about his father's involvement with the CIA.[24] Instead of terminating Pollard, Haver's boss reassigned him to a Navy human intelligence (HUMINT) operation, Task Force 168 (TF-168), an office within Naval Intelligence Command (NIC), the headquarters for Navy intelligence operations (located in a separate building, but still within the Suitland Federal Center complex.) This was apparently because Pollard had a friend from graduate school in the South African intelligence service.[24] In the vetting process for this position, Pollard, it was later discovered, lied repeatedly: he denied illegal drug use, claimed his father had been a CIA operative, misrepresented his language abilities and his educational achievements, and claimed to have applied for a commission as officer in the Naval Reserve.[24] A month later Pollard received his SCI clearances and was transferred from NISC to TF-168.

While transferring to his new job at TF-168, Pollard again initiated a meeting with someone far up the chain of command, this time with Admiral Sumner Shapiro, Commander, Naval Intelligence Command (CNIC) about an idea he had for TF-168 and South Africa. (The TF-168 group had passed on his ideas.) After the meeting, Shapiro immediately ordered that Pollard's security clearances be revoked and that he be reassigned to a non-sensitive position. According to The Washington Post, Shapiro dismissed Pollard as a "kook", saying later, "I wish the hell I'd fired him."[25]

Because of the job transfer, Shapiro's order to remove Pollard's security clearances slipped through the cracks. However, Shapiro's office followed up with a request to TF-168 that Pollard's trustworthiness be investigated by the CIA. The CIA found Pollard to be a risk and recommended that he not be used in any intelligence collection operation. A subsequent polygraph test was inconclusive, although it did prompt Pollard to admit to making false statements to his superiors, prior drug use, and having unauthorized contacts with representatives of foreign governments.[26] The special agent administering the test felt that Pollard, who at times "began shouting and shaking and making gagging sounds as if he were going to vomit", was feigning illness to invalidate the test, and recommended that he not be granted access to highly classified information.[26] Pollard was also required to be evaluated by a psychiatrist.[26]

Pollard's clearance was reduced to Secret.[26] Pollard subsequently filed a grievance and threatened lawsuits to recover his SCI clearance, and subsequently began receiving excellent performance reviews.[27] In 1982, after the psychiatrist concluded Pollard had no mental illness, Pollard's clearance was upgraded to SCI once again. In October 1984, after some reorganization of the Navy's intelligence departments, Pollard applied for and was accepted into a position as an analyst for the Naval Intelligence Command.[citation needed]

Espionage[edit]

Surveillance video frame of Pollard in the act of stealing classified documents

Shortly after Pollard began working at NIC/TF-168, he met Aviem Sella, a combat veteran of the Israeli Air Force, at the time on leave from his position as a colonel to gain a master's degree in computer science as a graduate student at New York University. Pollard told Sella that he worked for U.S. naval intelligence, detailed to him specific incidents where U.S. intelligence was withholding information from Israel, and offered himself as a spy. Though Sella had wondered whether Pollard was part of an FBI sting operation to recruit an Israeli, he ended up believing him. Sella then phoned his air-force intelligence commander in Tel Aviv for further instructions, and the call was switched to the air-force chief of staff. Sella was ordered to develop a contact with Pollard, but be careful, as either the Americans were offering a "dangle" in order to root out foreign intelligence operations, or if this was a genuine spy Sella would have to pay careful attention to his work.[28]

Within a few days, in June 1984, Pollard started passing classified information to Sella and received, in exchange, $10,000 cash and a very expensive diamond and sapphire ring, which Pollard later used to propose marriage to his girlfriend Anne. Pollard was paid well by the Israelis: he received a salary that eventually reached twenty-five hundred dollars a month, and tens of thousands of dollars in cash disbursements for hotels, meals, and even jewelry. In his pre-sentencing statement to Judge Robinson, Pollard depicted the money as a benefit that was forced on him. "I did accept money for my services," he acknowledged, but only "as a reflection of how well I was doing my job." He went on to assert that he had later told his controller, Rafi Eitan, a longtime spy who at the time headed Lekem, a scientific-intelligence unit in Israel, that "I not only intended to repay all the money I'd received but, also, was going to establish a chair at the Israeli General Staff's Intelligence Training Center outside Tel Aviv."[29][30]

Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) investigator Ronald Olive has alleged that Pollard passed classified information to South Africa,[31] and attempted, through a third party, to sell classified information to Pakistan on multiple occasions.[12] Pollard also stole classified documents related to China on behalf of his wife, who used the information to advance her personal business-interests and kept them around the house, where investigating authorities discovered them when Pollard's espionage activity came to light.[11][32][33]

During Pollard's trial, the U.S. government's memorandum in aid of sentencing challenged "defendant's claim that he was motivated by altruism rather than greed", asserting that Pollard had "disclosed classified information in anticipation of financial gain" in other instances:

The government's investigation has revealed that defendant provided to certain of his acquaintances U.S. classified documents which defendant obtained through U.S. Navy sources. The classified documents which defendant disclosed to two such acquaintances, both of whom are professional investment advisers, contained classified economic and political analyses which defendant believed would help his acquaintances render investment advice to their clients... Defendant acknowledged that, although he was not paid for his unauthorized disclosures of classified information to the above-mentioned acquaintances, he hoped to be rewarded ultimately through business opportunities that these individuals could arrange for defendant when he eventually left his position with the U.S. Navy. In fact, defendant was involved in an ongoing business venture with two of these acquaintances at the time he provided the classified information to them...[34]

During the course of the Pollard trial, Australian authorities reported the disclosure of classified American documents by Pollard to one of their own agents, a Royal Australian Navy officer who had been engaged in a personnel-exchange naval-liaison program between the U.S. and Australia.[35] The Australian officer, alarmed by Pollard's repeated disclosure to him of data caveated No Foreign Access Allowed, reported the indiscretions to his chain of command, which in turn recalled him from his position in the U.S., fearing that the disclosures might be part of a "CIA ruse".[35] Confronted with this accusation after entering his plea, Pollard only admitted to passing a single classified document to the Australian; later, he changed his story, and claimed that his superiors ordered him to share information with the Australians.[35]

As of 2014 the full extent of the information Pollard passed to Israel has still not been officially revealed. Press reports cited a secret 46-page memorandum, which Pollard and his attorneys were allowed to view.[36] They were provided to the judge by Secretary of Defense Caspar Weinberger, who described Pollard's spying as including, among other things, obtaining and copying the latest version of Radio-Signal Notations (RASIN), a 10-volume manual comprehensively detailing America's global electronic surveillance network.[9][37]

Capture[edit]

Pollard's espionage came to light in 1985 when a coworker anonymously reported Pollard's removal of classified material from the NIC. The coworker noted that Pollard did not seem to be taking the material to any known appropriate destination, such as other intelligence agencies in the area. Although Pollard was authorized to transport documents and the coworker did claim the documents were properly wrapped, it appeared out of place that Pollard would be transporting documents on a Friday afternoon when many workers were focused more on the upcoming weekend rather than on intelligence work. Pollard's direct superior, having to complete extra work at the office on a Saturday, had walked by Pollard's desk and noticed unsecured classified material. Taking the initiative to secure it, the supervisor glanced over it and saw it was unrelated to antiterrorism matters in the Caribbean, which is what the section focused on. Looking at more unrelated documents, the supervisor believed foreign intelligence might be involved, but was unable to determine which nation might be interested.[38] Supervisors began investigating, and upon finding the enormous amount of material checked out by Pollard, and that it was outside of his area of responsibility, asked the FBI to begin an investigation.[citation needed]

Pollard was stopped and questioned by FBI agents about a week later while removing classified material from his work premises. He explained that he was taking it to another analyst at a different agency for a consultation, but his story was checked by the agents and found to be false. Pollard requested a phone call to his wife telling her where he was. As the interview was voluntary, the investigators had no choice but to grant the request. During the call to Anne Pollard used the code word "cactus", signaling that he was in trouble and that she should remove all classified material from their home, which she attempted to do,[39] enlisting the help of a neighbor.[40]

Pollard later agreed to a search of his home, which turned up only a few documents that Anne had missed. At this point the FBI decided to cede the case to Pollard's supervisors, since they had uncovered only mishandling of documents, with no proof that Pollard was passing classified information. The case broke wide open a few days later when Pollard was asked by his superiors to take a polygraph test. Instead, he admitted to illegally passing on documents, without mentioning Israel. The FBI again became involved. A short time later Pollard's neighbor, a naval officer, became concerned about safeguarding the 70-pound (32 kg) suitcase full of highly classified material that Anne had given him, and began calling around the military intelligence community asking for advice.[40] He cooperated fully with the investigation and was never charged with any crime.[41]

After his partial confession, Pollard was put under surveillance but not taken into custody. On November 21, 1985, he and his wife attempted to gain asylum at the Israeli Embassy in Washington, D.C., only to be rebuffed by the Israeli guards. FBI agents arrested him, swarming the perimeter as soon as Pollard set foot off embassy property.[42] Until this point, investigators could not confirm that Pollard had been spying for Israel; their only lead had been the speculation of Pollard's superiors.[citation needed]

After Pollard's arrest, Anne evaded an FBI agent who was following her and met Sella at a restaurant, where she informed him of her husband's arrest. Hours after Pollard was arrested, Sella and his wife, along with Yossi Yagur and Irit Erb (two other Israelis involved in the operation), fled to New York and caught flights out of the country before the FBI could stop them.[43] Anne was arrested the next day, November 22, 1985.[44]

Investigation[edit]

Prior to Pollard's plea bargain, the U.S. government began preparing a multi-count criminal indictment on him, which included drug, and tax-fraud charges along with espionage.[9] The government's indictment included allegations that Pollard used classified documents to unsuccessfully broker an arms deal with the governments of South Africa, Argentina, and Taiwan.[9] FBI investigators also determined that Pollard met with three Pakistanis and an Iranian foreigner in an attempt to broker arms in 1985.[9] Pollard eventually cooperated with investigators in exchange for a plea agreement for leniency for himself and his wife. Israel claimed initially that Pollard worked for an unauthorized rogue operation, a position they maintained for more than ten years, and agreed to cooperate with the investigation in exchange for immunity for the Israelis involved.

When asked to return the stolen material, the Israelis reportedly only turned over a few dozen low-classified documents.[45] At the time, the Americans knew that Pollard had passed tens of thousands of documents. When American investigators traveled to Israel they were treated with hostility from the moment they arrived in Israel to the moment they left.[45] The Israelis created a schedule designed to wear them down, including many hours per day of commuting in blacked out buses on rough roads, and frequent switching of buses[45] leaving them without adequate time to sleep and preventing them from sleeping on the commute.[45] The identity of Pollard's original handler, Sella, was withheld. All questions had to be translated into Hebrew and answered in Hebrew, and then translated back into English, even though all the parties spoke perfect English.[45] The Commander Jerry Agee remembers that, even as he departed the airport, airport security made a point of informing him that "you will never be coming back here again"; Agee found various items had been stolen from his luggage, upon his return to the United States.[45] The abuse came not only from the guards and officials, but also the Israeli media.[45]

Aviem Sella, Pollard's initial Israeli contact, was eventually indicted on three counts of espionage by an American court.[46] Israel refused to allow him to be interviewed unless he was granted immunity. The United States refused because of Israel's previous failure to cooperate as promised. Israel then refused to extradite Sella, instead giving him command of Tel Nof Airbase. The U.S. Congress responded by threatening to cut aid to Israel, at which point Sella voluntarily stepped down to defuse tensions.[47]

Plea agreement and trial[edit]

Pollard's plea discussions with the government sought both to minimize his chances of receiving a life sentence and to enable Anne Pollard to plead as well, which the government was otherwise unwilling to let her do. The government, however, was prepared to offer Anne Pollard a plea agreement only after Jonathan Pollard consented to assist the government in its damage assessment and submitted to polygraph examinations and interviews with FBI agents and Department of Justice attorneys. Accordingly, over a period of several months, Pollard cooperated with the government's investigation, and in late May 1986, the government offered him a plea agreement, which he accepted. By the terms of that agreement, Pollard was bound to plead guilty to one count of conspiracy to deliver national defense information to a foreign government,[48] which carried a maximum prison term of life, and to cooperate fully with the government's ongoing investigation. He promised not to disseminate any information concerning his crimes or his case, or to speak publicly of any classified information, without first submitting to pre-clearance by the Director of Naval Intelligence. His agreement further provided that failure by Anne Pollard to adhere to the terms of her agreement entitled the government to void his agreement, and her agreement contained a mirror-image provision. In return for Pollard's plea, the government promised not to charge him with additional crimes.[citation needed]

Three weeks before Pollard's sentencing, Wolf Blitzer, at the time a Jerusalem Post correspondent, conducted a jail-cell interview with Pollard and penned an article that also ran in The Washington Post headlined, "Pollard: Not A Bumbler, but Israel's Master Spy", published February 15, 1987.[49] Pollard told Blitzer about some of the information he provided the Israelis: reconnaissance satellite photography of Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) headquarters in Tunisia, which was used for Operation Wooden Leg,[50] specific capabilities of Libya's air defenses, and "the pick of U.S. intelligence about Arab and Islamic conventional and unconventional military activity, from Morocco to Pakistan and every country in between. This included both 'friendly' and 'unfriendly' Arab countries." Some commentators identified this interview as a blatant violation of the plea agreement.[51]

Prior to sentencing, Pollard and his wife Anne gave further defiant media interviews in which they defended their spying and attempted to rally Jewish Americans to their cause. In a 60 Minutes interview, Anne said, "I feel my husband and I did what we were expected to do, and what our moral obligation was as Jews, what our moral obligation was as human beings, and I have no regrets about that."[37]

On June 4, 1986, Pollard pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to deliver national defense information to a foreign government. Prior to sentencing, speaking on his own behalf, Pollard stated that while his motives "may have been well meaning, they cannot, under any stretch of the imagination, excuse or justify the violation of the law, particularly one that involves the trust of government ... I broke trust, ruined and brought disgrace to my family."[11] He admitted and apologized for taking money from the Israeli government in exchange for classified information.[11] Anne Pollard, in her own statement, stated that she did "what at the time I believed to be correct", in helping her husband and attempting to conceal stolen documents, adding "And I can't say that I would never not help him again. However, I would look for different routes or different ways."[52]

The prosecution answered these statements by saying that the Pollards had continued to violate numerous nondisclosure agreements even as the trial was taking place. The prosecutor noted one in particular, which had been signed in June 1986, alluding to Pollard's interview with Wolf Blitzer.[53] The prosecutor concluded:

[I]n combination with the breadth of this man's knowledge, the depth of his memory, and the complete lack of honor that he has demonstrated in these proceedings, I suggest to you, your honor, he is a very dangerous man.[53]

Sentencing and incarceration[edit]

Pollard was sentenced to life in prison on one count of espionage on March 4, 1987. The prosecutor complied with the plea agreement and asked for "only a substantial number of years in prison;" Judge Aubrey Robinson, Jr., who was not obligated to follow the recommendation of the prosecutor, imposed a life sentence after hearing a "damage-assessment memorandum" from the Secretary of Defense.[10]

In 1987, Pollard began his life sentence. His wife, Anne, was sentenced to five years in prison but was paroled after three and a half years due to health problems. After her parole ended, she emigrated to Israel. Jonathan divorced Anne, stating he believed he was going to be jailed for the remainder of his life and did not want Anne to be bound to him.[38] In May that year, Pollard asked Avi Weiss to be his personal rabbi.[8]

Following his divorce, Pollard married Esther "Elaine" Zeitz, an activist based in Toronto who had been working to free him[54] Mrs. Pollard is active in the Israeli media on her husband's behalf, calling for his release or criticizing officials whom she believes have forgotten about him. In 1996 she embarked upon a public hunger strike in an unsuccessful effort to secure Pollard's release.[55] There have been some questions in the media as to whether the two are legally wed.[56]

From 1986 until his sentencing in June 1987, Pollard was held at FCC Petersburg in Virginia, about a three-hour drive south of Washington. Immediately after sentencing, he was moved from Petersburg to a federal prison hospital in Springfield, Missouri, where he was placed in a solitary cell and given a battery of mental health tests.[57] After one year in the psychiatric prison, in June 1988, he was transferred to the federal maximum security prison in Marion, Illinois. In 1993 he was transferred to a slightly less harsh facility in Butner, North Carolina. At the time of Pollard's sentencing there was a rule that mandated parole for federal inmates who had served 30 years out of a life sentence with parole eligibility, provided they had maintained a clean record in prison.

His Federal Bureau of Prisons ID is #09185-016. He is incarcerated in FCI Butner Medium at the Butner Federal Correction Complex in North Carolina. The Bureau of Prisons (BOP) projects his release date as November 21, 2015.[58]

According to a Haaretz article, if Pollard is released in 2015, he will be escorted by FBI agents to the gates of the Israeli embassy in Washington, D.C. and transferred to Israeli custody.[59] However, a Jerusalem Post editorial states that if Pollard is paroled, the U.S. government will still be legally able to keep him in the United States and under heavy restrictions for 15 years.[60]

Appeals[edit]

In the district court, Pollard's attorney filed a motion to withdraw his plea and for other relief; the motion was denied. United States v. Jonathan Jay Pollard, 747 F. Supp. 797 (1990). He unsuccessfully appealed that denial. United States v. Pollard, 959 F.2d 1011, 295 U.S. App. D.C. 7, 1992 U.S. App. LEXIS 4695 (1992). The appeal was also denied. Several years later, with a different attorney, Pollard filed a petition for habeas corpus. A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled two-to-one to deny Pollard's petition, primarily due to the failure of Pollard's original attorneys to file his appeal in a timely manner. Judge Stephen F. Williams dissented, in his words, "because the government's breach of the plea agreement was a fundamental miscarriage of justice requiring relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2255".[61]

In July 2005, the District of Columbia Circuit rejected Pollard's latest appeal. Pollard had sought a new trial on the grounds of ineffective assistance of counsel, and he sought to receive classified documents pertinent to his new lawyers' efforts in preparing a clemency petition. The Court of Appeals rejected both arguments, however, and Pollard remains imprisoned. On February 10, 2006, lawyers for Pollard filed a petition for certiorari with the United States Supreme Court to attempt to gain access to the classified documents. The brief was based on the notion that the separation of powers doctrine is a flexible doctrine that does not dictate the complete separation of the three branches of Government from one another. The brief argued that the Court of Appeals violated this principle in asserting sua sponte that the judiciary has no jurisdiction over the classified documents due to the fact that access was for the ultimate purpose of clemency, an executive function. In fact, the President's clemency power would be wholly unaffected by successor counsel's access to the classified documents, and the classified documents were sealed under protective order, a judicial tool. The Supreme Court denied the cert petition on March 20, 2006.

Jonathan deeply regrets the tremendous cost of his actions. The cost to the health of his ex-wife Anne; the cost to his marriage; the cost of his incarceration, the agony of isolation and the mental torture he has been forced to endure. Moreover, on more than one occasion Jonathan acknowledged that he broke the law and has expressed regret that he did not find a legal manner through which he could pass lifesaving information to Israel.

—Rabbi Avi Weiss, April 30, 1993

Israel and Pollard[edit]

Until 1998 Israel denied that Pollard was an Israeli agent. Their official position was that he worked for an unauthorized rogue operation.

In 1988, Israel and the United States reportedly considered an exchange where Pollard and his wife would be released and sent to Israel, and Israel would release Soviet spy Marcus Klingberg in exchange for the Soviet Union using its influence with Syria and Iran to release American hostages being held by Syrian and Iranian-sponsored terrorist groups.[62]

Israeli officials at one point reportedly considered offering to release Yosef Amit, an Israeli military intelligence officer who was serving a 12-year prison sentence for spying for the United States and another NATO power, in exchange for Pollard. However, Amit torpedoed the proposal, sending a letter to the State Attorney's Office emphasizing that he had no wish to be exchanged.[63]

In 1995, there were reports that Israel was considering a deal in which it would orchestrate the release of American spies imprisoned in Russia in exchange for Pollard. Under the deal, Israel would release Marcus Klingberg, an Israeli imprisoned in 1983 for spying for the Soviets, and in exchange, the Russians would release U.S. agents who had remained in prison since the dissolution of the Soviet Union. The United States would then free Pollard.[64]

On May 11, 1998, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu admitted that Pollard was an Israeli agent, handled by high-ranking officials of the Israeli Bureau for Scientific Relations (Lekem). The Israeli government paid for at least two of Pollard's trial attorneys – Richard A. Hibey and Hamilton Philip Fox III – and continues to ask for his release.[37] Netanyahu and Ehud Barak, in 1999 in the context of the Israeli elections, exchanged barbs in the media over which of them had been more supportive of Pollard. In 2002 Netanyahu visited Pollard in prison.[65] In 2007 he pledged that, if elected Prime Minister, he would bring about Pollard's release.[66]

In September 2009, Israeli State Comptroller Micha Lindenstrauss released a report that stated the Israeli government has made concerted efforts for years to gain Pollard's release, but the American government refused.[67] The Pollards rejected the findings of the report, calling it a "whitewash" of the Israeli government.[68] However, they did agree with another finding of the report that stated Pollard had been denied due legal process in the United States.

In June 2011, 70 members of the Israeli parliament (the Knesset) lent their support to the Pollard family's request that President Obama allow Pollard to visit his ailing father, Morris. When his father died soon after, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced Israel's official support for a new Pollard family request that would allow Jonathan Pollard to attend his father's funeral.[69] These requests were both ultimately denied by the U.S. government.[70]

Citizenship[edit]

In the 1990s University of Notre Dame president Theodore Hesburgh, a family friend of Pollard's, attempted to broker a deal whereby Pollard would be released, "be banished to Israel", and would renounce his U.S. citizenship.[71] Mike Royko of the Chicago Tribune wrote columns in February 1994 supporting the idea.[72] Pollard applied for Israeli citizenship in 1995; the Ministry of Interior initially refused on grounds that Israel did not grant citizenship to persons who had not yet immigrated, but reversed its decision and granted the petition on November 22, 1995.[73][74][75] White House officials expressed little enthusiasm for Hesburgh's plan, and he ceased further efforts toward it.[71]

Some sources claim that Pollard then renounced his United States citizenship and is now solely an Israeli citizen, and would be deported to Israel if he were released from prison.[76] Others continue to identify him as a U.S. citizen.[77] According to the United States Department of State, there are no peacetime regulations in effect under 8 U.S.C. § 1481(a)(6) to empower the Attorney General to process renunciations of citizenship from persons physically present in the United States, and under 8 U.S.C. § 1483, it is not possible for a person to lose U.S. citizenship while physically present in the United States except by renunciation filed with the Attorney General, or conviction of treason.[78]

Official reactions and public pro-Pollard campaigns[edit]

This sign reads "We Want Pollard Home".

In addition to the release requests by the Israeli government, there has been a long running public campaign to free Pollard. The organizers include the Pollard family, his ex-wife, Anne, and Jewish groups in the U.S. and Israel. The campaign's main points claim that Pollard spied for an ally instead of an enemy, that his sentence was out of proportion when compared to similar crimes, and that the U.S. failed to live up to its plea bargain.[79][80] Some Israeli activists compared President Bush to Hamas and Hezbollah leaders who have taken Israeli soldiers prisoner.[81][82]

Pollard's supporters argue that his sentence was excessive. Although Pollard pleaded guilty as part of a plea bargain for himself and his wife, he was shown no leniency and was given the maximum sentence with the exception of death, because he allegedly broke the terms of that plea agreement even before the sentence was handed down.[83]

The issue of his imprisonment has sometimes arisen amidst Israeli domestic politics.[84] Benjamin Netanyahu has been particularly vocal in lobbying for Pollard's release, visiting Pollard in prison in 2002. Netanyahu raised the issue with President Bill Clinton during the Wye River peace talks in 1998.[85] In his autobiography, Clinton wrote that he was inclined to release Pollard, but the objections of U.S. intelligence officials were too strong:

For all the sympathy Pollard generated in Israel, he was a hard case to push in America; he had sold our country's secrets for money, not conviction, and for years had not shown any remorse. When I talked to Sandy Berger and George Tenet, they were adamantly opposed to letting Pollard go, as was Madeleine Albright.[86]

Alan Dershowitz has been among Pollard's high-profile supporters, both in the courtroom as a lawyer and in various print media. Characterizing the sentence as "excessive", Dershowitz writes in an article reprinted in his bestselling book Chutzpah, "As an American, and as a Jew, I hereby express my outrage at Jonathan Pollard's sentence of life imprisonment for the crime to which he pleaded guilty."[87] Dershowitz writes:

[E]veryone seems frightened to speak up on behalf of a convicted spy. This has been especially true of the Jewish leadership in America. The Pollards are Jewish. ... The Pollards are also Zionists, who—out of a sense of misguided "racial imperative" (to quote Jonathan Pollard)—seem to place their commitment to Israeli survival over the laws of their own country. ... American Jewish leaders, always sensitive to the canard of dual loyalty, are keeping a low profile in the Pollard matter. Many American Jews at the grass roots are outraged at what they perceive to be an overreaction to the Pollards' crimes and the unusually long sentence imposed on Jonathan Pollard.[87]

In 2012, Malcolm Hoenlein called for Pollards' release, saying "27 years—he's paid the price for his crimes. He has expressed remorse. Enough is enough. It's time that he be let go—there is no justification that we can see for keeping him any longer, there's no cause of justice, no security interest that could possibly be served."[1]

In 2013, Rabbi Pesach Lerner, Executive Vice President of the National Council of Young Israel, cited hypocrisy of Pollard's imprisonment in America after revelations of spying against U.S. allies by the United States intelligence agencies.[88]

"In 18 years on the bench, I imposed life sentences on four defendants only [2 murderers and 2 terrorists]. Pollard's offense does not nearly approach any of those."[89]

Former US Attorney General Michael Mukasey in a letter sent to President Barack Obama

The Jerusalem City Council has also acted in support of Pollard, changing the name of a square near the official prime minister's residence from Paris Square to Freedom for Jonathan Pollard Square.[90] Tamar Fogel, a 12-year-old Israeli girl whose parents and three siblings were killed in the 2011 Itamar attack, visited Pollard shortly after the death of Pollard's father, in June 2011.[91]

Pollard claimed that he provided only information that was vital to Israeli security and that it was being withheld by the Pentagon, in violation of a 1983 Memorandum of Understanding between the two countries. The Memorandum of Understanding was an agreement between the United States and Israel regarding the sharing of vital security intelligence. According to Pollard, this included data on Soviet arms shipments to Syria, Iraqi and Syrian chemical weapons, the Pakistani atomic bomb project, and Libyan air defense systems.[92] According to the declassified CIA 1987 damage assessment of the Pollard case, under the heading "What the Israelis Did Not Ask For", the assessment notes that the Israelis "never expressed interest in U.S. military activities, plans, capabilities, or equipment". Many people claim that Israel had the legal rights to the information that Pollard passed to Israel based upon the 1983 Memorandum of understanding and the United States was breaching that Memorandum.[93][94]

Lee Hamilton, a former U.S. Congressman from Indiana who served as Chairman of the House Intelligence Committee at the time of Jonathan Pollard’s sentencing, requested that President Obama should free Pollard. Being the Chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, Lee Hamilton had complete access to all of the confidential information regarding Jonathan Pollard. On February 25, 2011 Mr. Hamilton wrote an emotional letter to President Obama requesting that his sentence be commuted. He stated, "I have been acquainted for many years with members of his family, especially his parents, and I know how much pain and anguish they have suffered because of their son's incarceration." Mr. Hamilton wrote that Mr. Pollard deserves to see his son freed.[95][96]

In 2010 representatives Barney Frank (D-Mass.), Edolphus Towns (D-N.Y.), Anthony Weiner (D-N.Y.) and Bill Pascrell (D-N.J.) wrote a letter that "notes the positive impact that a grant of clemency would have in Israel, as a strong indication of the goodwill of our nation towards Israel and the Israeli people"."[97] On November 2010, Weiner stated: "No one in the history of the United States who did something similar to Jonathan Pollard served a life sentence, nor should he."[89]

Special Assistant to President Obama Dennis B. Ross said in 2004: "Pollard received a harsher sentence than others who committed comparable crimes." Former U.S. Secretary of Defense Caspar Weinberger stated that "[t]he Pollard matter was comparatively minor. It was made far bigger than its actual importance." Stephen Fain Williams,a Senior Circuit Judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit stated: "Jonathan Pollard's life sentence represents a fundamental miscarriage of justice". In December 2010, former U.S. assistant Secretary of Defense Lawrence Korb said: "In retrospect, we know that an injustice was done to Pollard ... the man is very sick and should be released before it is too late."[89]

On November 18, 2010, 39 members of Congress submitted a Plea Of Clemency to the White House on behalf of Pollard, asking the president for his immediate release: "We see clemency for Mr. Pollard as an act of compassion justified by the way others have been treated by our justice system." They stated how there has been a great disparity by the amount of time that Pollard has served and by others who were found guilty of similar activities.[98][99][100]

Former White House Counsel, Bernard Nussbaum, wrote a letter on January 28, 2011, to President Obama stating that he extensively reviewed the Jonathan Pollard file while he served in the White House. In his letter he stated, "that a failure at this time to commute his sentence would not serve the course of justice; indeed, I respectfully believe, it would be a miscarriage of justice".[101][102]

Former Secretary of State George Shultz also wrote a letter to President Obama on January 11, 2011, urging that Jonathan Pollard sentence to be commuted. He stated, "I am impressed that the people who are best informed about the classified material he passed to Israel, former CIA Director James Woolsey and former Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee Dennis DeConcini, favor his release."[103][104]

In 2011, Henry Kissinger, former U.S. Secretary of State declared that the time had come to commute the sentence of Jonathan Pollard. On March 3, 2011, Kissinger wrote a letter to President Obama stating, "having talked with George Shultz and read the statements of former CIA Director Woolsey, former Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman DeConcini, former Defense Secretary Weinberger, former Attorney General Mukasey and others whose judgement and first-hand knowledge of the case I respect, I find their unanimous support for clemency compelling. I believe justice would be served by commuting the remainder of Jonathan Pollard's sentence of life imprisonment".[105][106][107][108]

Lawrence Korb, former Assistant Secretary of Defense under Ronald Reagan, has called on the Obama Administration to grant clemency to Pollard:

Some now argue that Pollard should be released because it would improve U.S.-Israeli relations and enhance the prospects of success of the Obama administration's Middle East peace process. Although that may be true, it is not the reason I and many others have recently written to the president requesting that he grant Pollard clemency. The reason is that Pollard has already served far too long for the crime for which he was convicted, and by now, whatever facts he might know would have little effect on national security.[109]

In the words of Lawrence Korb, “We believe that his continued incarceration constitutes a travesty of justice and a stain on the American system of justice.”[110]

Former Vice President Dan Quayle wrote a letter to President Obama on January 31, 2011, urging President Obama to commute Jonathan Pollard's sentence.[111]

On February 16, 2011, Arlen Specter wrote a letter to President Obama, stating that, as the Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, he believed Jonathan Pollard should be pardoned and released from prison. Arlen Specter was the second Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee (the first was Dennis DeConcini) to publicly call for the release of Jonathan Pollard.[112]

On March 22, 2011, more than one hundred New York State legislators signed a petition to President Obama stating, "that we see clemency for Mr. Pollard as an act of compassion justified by the way others have been treated by our justice system".[113]

Christine Quinn, Speaker of the New York City Council, wrote a letter to President Obama on December 26, 2012, formally requesting that he commute Pollard's severely disproportionate and unjust sentence. She stated that he has expressed great remorse. She wrote, "I know I share similar views with many past and current American elected officials" and "therefore, I respectfully urge you to use your constitutional power to treat Mr. Pollard the way others have been treated by our nation's justice system."[114][115][116]

In August 2011 Barney Frank sought permission from Congress to discuss the incarceration of Jonathan Pollard and called on Barack Obama to "answer the many calls for Pollard's immediate release". Frank said Pollard has paid a price much higher than anyone else that spied on a friend of the United States and more than many who spied for its enemies.[117]

Congressman Allen West from Florida, wrote a letter to President Obama on June 2, 2011, stating, "After serving 26 years behind bars, Jonathan Pollard's health is deteriorating, as is his wife's. If we can consent to the release by the British of the Lockerbie bomber back to Libya due to health concern, how can we justify keeping Mr. Pollard behind bars when his crimes were clearly not as serious as a terrorist who murdered hundreds of Americans?"[118][119]

On October 26, 2011, a bipartisan group of 18 retired U.S. Senators wrote to President Obama urging him to commute Jonathan Pollard's prison sentence to time served. The letter included senators who initially opposed his release. In the letter it stated, "Mr. Pollard will complete his 26th year of incarceration on November 21, 2011 and begin his 27th year of an unprecedented life sentence (seven of which were spent in solitary confinement). He was indicted on one count of passing classified information to an ally without intent to harm the United States—an offense that normally results in a 2–4 year sentence. He pled guilty under a plea agreement with which he fully complied but which was ignored by the sentencing judge. Mr. Pollard is the only person in the history of the U.S. to receive a life sentence for passing classified information to an ally." They conclude, "it is patently clear that Mr. Pollard's sentence is severely disproportionate and (as several federal judges have noted) a gross miscarriage of justice."[120][121]

In a letter to the editor of The Wall Street Journal, published on July 5, 2012, James Woolsey wrote that he now supports release of the convicted spy for Israel, citing the passage of time: "When I recommended against clemency, Pollard had been in prison less than a decade. Today he has been incarcerated for over a quarter of a century under his life sentence." He pointed out that of the more than 50 recently convicted Soviet and Chinese spies, only two received life sentences, and two-thirds were sentenced to less time than Pollard has served so far. He further stated that "Pollard has cooperated fully with the U.S. government, pledged not to profit from his crime (e.g., from book sales), and has many times expressed remorse for what he did." Woolsey expressed his belief that Pollard is still imprisoned only because he is Jewish. He said, "anti-Semitism played a role in the continued detention of Pollard." "For those hung up for some reason on the fact that he’s an American Jew, pretend he's a Greek- or Korean- or Filipino-American and free him," Woolsey, who is not Jewish, said in his letter to the Wall Street Journal.[122][123][124]

Angelo Codevilla, who has followed the Pollard case since serving as a senior staff member for the Senate intelligence committee from 1978 to 1985, argued that the swarm of accusations against Pollard over the years is implausible. On November 15, 2013 Professor Codevilla wrote a letter to President Obama stating," Others have pointed out that Pollard is the only person ever sentenced to life imprisonment for passing information to an ally, without intent to harm America, a crime which normally carries a sentence of 2–4 years; and that this disproportionate sentence in violation of a plea agreement was based not on the indictment but on a memorandum that was never shared with the defense. This is not how American justice is supposed to work."[125][126] In an interview to the Weekly standard, Codevilla stated, "The story of the Pollard case is a blot on American justice," The life sentence, "makes you ashamed to be an American.",[127][128]

Republican Presidential candidate Newt Gingrich has expressed support for releasing Pollard.[129]

According to American intelligence expert John Loftus, former U.S. government prosecutor and army intelligence officer, Pollard could not have revealed the identities of American spies as Pollard lacked the security clearance to access this information. In the opinion of Loftus, "Pollard's continued incarceration is due to horrible stupidity."[130]

Official requests for clemency[edit]

Yitzhak Rabin was the first Israeli prime minister to ask for the release of Pollard, requesting U.S. President Bill Clinton to pardon him in 1995.[131] Among the many requests for Pollard's release was one at the 1998 Wye River conference, where Netanyahu recalls, "if we signed an agreement with Arafat, I expected a pardon for Pollard."[7][37] Of his meeting with Netanyahu during the Wye River talks, Bill Clinton writes, "Netanyahu was threatening to scuttle the whole deal unless I released Pollard. He said I had promised him I would do so at an earlier meeting the night before, and that's why he had agreed on the other issues. In fact, I had told the prime minister that if that's what it took to make peace, I was inclined to do it, but I would have to check with our people."[86] Clinton states that Madeleine Albright, Sandy Berger, and George Tenet were all "adamantly opposed" to letting Pollard out of prison.[86]

Another Israeli request for Pollard's release was made in New York on September 14, 2005, and was declined by President George W. Bush. A request on Pollard's behalf that he be designated a Prisoner of Zion was rejected by the High Court of Justice of Israel on January 16, 2006. Another appeal for intervention on Pollard's behalf was rejected by the High Court on March 20, 2006.[132]

On January 10, 2008, the subject of Pollard's pardon was again brought up for discussion, this time by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, during President George W. Bush's first visit to Israel as President. Subsequently, this request was turned down by President Bush. The next day, at a dinner attended by several ministers in the Israeli government (in addition to U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice), the subject of Pollard's release was again discussed. This time however, Prime Minister Olmert commented that it was not the appropriate occasion to discuss the fate of the convicted Israeli spy.[133]

As President Bush was about to leave office in 2009, Pollard himself requested clemency for the first time. In an interview in Newsweek former CIA director James Woolsey endorsed Pollard's release on two conditions: that he show contrition and decline any profits from books or other projects linked to the case. Bush did not pardon him.[134]

The New York Times reported on September 21, 2010, that the Israeli government (again under Netanyahu) informally proposed that Pollard be released as a reward to Israel for extending by three months a halt to new settlements in occupied territories.[135]

On December 21, 2010, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he would formally and publicly call for Pollard's release.[136] This was the first formal request made by Israel. On January 4, 2011, Netanyahu formally submitted a letter to President Obama requesting clemency. The White House issued a statement saying the letter would be reviewed, however no official response has been given to date.

In 2012, President Shimon Peres presented a letter signed by 80 Israel legislators and addressed to President Obama requesting Pollard's release on behalf of the citizens of Israel.[137] In November 2013, Jewish Agency chairman Natan Sharansky said, "It is unprecedented in the history of the U.S. that someone who spied for a friendly country served even half the time [that Pollard has] in prison."[138]

In late March, 2014, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry reportedly offered to release Pollard as an incentive to Israel to resume negotiations with the Palestinians toward the formation of a Palestinian state. The White House, however, announced that no decision had been made on any agreement involving Pollard.[139]

In October, 2014, Elyakim Rubinstein, an Israeli Supreme Court Justice, former attorney general, and the acting Israeli ambassador to the US at the time of Pollard's arrest, called for Pollard's pardon. He said "Mistakes were made, mainly by the Israelis, but by the Americans as well, and 29 years [is] enough."[140]

In November 2014, American officials sent a letter to President Obama slamming the "unjust denial of parole" for Pollard whose "grossly disproportionate sentence continues," calling the charge the government uses to keep him imprisoned "patently false." The signatories of the letter included former CIA director James Woolsey, former Assistant U.S. Defense Secretary Lawrence Korb and former U.S. National Security Advisor Robert McFarlane.[141]

Opposition[edit]

Critics allege that Pollard's espionage—which compromised elements of four major intelligence systems—damaged American national security far more than was ever publicly acknowledged.[9] Many intelligence officials are convinced that at least some of the information Pollard sold to Israel eventually wound up in the Soviet Union.[9] At the 1998 Wye River Conference, Benjamin Netanyahu demanded Pollard's release. President Clinton ordered a formal review of the case,[86] precipitating an "incredulous" reaction within the American intelligence community.[142] Former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, along with six other former U.S. Secretaries of Defense (Melvin R. Laird, Frank C. Carlucci, Richard B. Cheney, Caspar W. Weinberger, James R. Schlesinger and Elliot L. Richardson) spoke out in opposition to clemency for Pollard.[10] They were joined by several senior congressional leaders.[10] In 1999 Seymour Hersh outlined the case against Pollard in The New Yorker.[143]

Four former directors of Naval Intelligence — William Studeman, Sumner Shapiro, John L. Butts, and Thomas Brooks — took the unusual step of issuing a public response to the call for clemency, and what they termed "the myths that have arisen from this clever public relations campaign ... aimed at transforming Pollard from greedy, arrogant betrayer of the American national trust into Pollard, committed Israeli patriot":[144][145]

Pollard pleaded guilty and therefore never was publicly tried. Thus, the American people never came to know that he offered classified information to three other countries before working for the Israelis and that he offered his services to a fourth country while he was spying for Israel. They also never came to understand that he was being highly paid for his services ...

Pollard and his apologists argue he turned over to the Israelis information they were being denied that was critical to their security. The fact is, however, Pollard had no way of knowing what the Israeli government was already receiving by way of official intelligence exchange agreements ... Some of the data he compromised had nothing to do with Israeli security or even with the Middle East. He betrayed worldwide intelligence data, including sources and methods developed at significant cost to the U.S. taxpayer. As a result of his perfidy, some of those sources are lost forever.

... Another claim Pollard made is that the U.S. government reneged on its bargain not to seek the life sentence. What is not heard is that Pollard's part of the bargain was to cooperate fully in an assessment of the damage he had done and to refrain from talking to the press prior to the completion of his sentencing. He blatantly and contemptuously failed to live up to either part of the plea agreement ... It was this coupled with the magnitude and consequences of his criminal actions that resulted in the judge imposing a life sentence ... The appellate court subsequently upheld the life sentence.

If, as Pollard and his supporters claim, he has "suffered enough" for his crimes, he is free to apply for parole as the American judicial system provides. In his arrogance, he has refused to do so, but insists on being granted clemency or a pardon.

Admiral Shapiro stated that he was troubled by the support of Jewish organizations for Pollard: "We work so hard to establish ourselves and to get where we are, and to have somebody screw it up ... and then to have Jewish organizations line up behind this guy and try to make him out a hero of the Jewish people, it bothers the hell out of me."[25]

Ron Olive, retired Naval Criminal Investigative Service, led the Pollard investigation. In his 2006 book, Capturing Jonathan Pollard – How One of the Most Notorious Spies in American History Was Brought to Justice, Olive wrote that Pollard did not serve Israel solely; he admitted passing secrets to South Africa, and to his financial advisers, and to shopping his access to Pakistan and other countries.[146]

New Republic editor Martin Peretz has argued against freeing Pollard: "Jonathan Pollard is not a Jewish martyr. He is a convicted espionage agent who spied on his country for both Israel and Pakistan (!) — a spy, moreover, who got paid for his work. His professional career, then, reeks of infamy and is suffused with depravity." Peretz called Pollard's supporters "professional victims, mostly brutal themselves, who originate in the ultra-nationalist and religious right. They are insatiable. And they want America to be Israel's patsy."[147]

Former FBI and navy lawyer M.E. "Spike" Bowman, a top legal adviser to navy intelligence at the time, with intimate knowledge of the Pollard case, has issued a detailed critique of the case for clemency. "Because the case never went to trial, it is difficult for outside observers to understand the potential impact and complexity of the Pollard betrayal," he asserted. "There is no doubt that Pollard was devoted to Israel. However, the extent of the theft and the damage was far broader and more complex than evidenced by the single charge and sentence."[148] Bowman wrote that Pollard "was neither a U.S. nor an Israeli patriot. He was a self-serving, gluttonous character seeking financial reward and personal gratification."[148]

In September 2011 Vice President Joe Biden reportedly told a group of rabbis, "President Obama was considering clemency, but I told him, 'Over my dead body are we going to let him out before his time. If it were up to me, he would stay in jail for life'."[149] Biden later denied having used those precise words, but acknowledged that the position attributed to him was accurate.[150]

In popular culture[edit]

Pollard's story inspired the movie Les Patriotes (The Patriots) by French director Éric Rochant in which American actor Richard Masur portrayed a character resembling Pollard.

The settlement Beit Yonatan in Silwan, described by Haaretz as "a residential building erected by nationalist Jews in the heart of an Arab neighborhood in East Jerusalem", is named after Pollard.[151]

Works cited[edit]

  • Olive, Ronald J. (2006). Capturing Jonathan Pollard: How One of the Most Notorious Spies in American History Was Brought to Justice. Annapolis, Maryland: Naval Institute Press. ISBN 978-1-59114-652-0. 
  • Blitzer, Wolf (1989). Territory of Lies. New York: Harper & Row. ISBN 0-06-015972-3. 
  • Goldenberg, Elliot (2000). The Hunting Horse. New York: Prometheus Books. ISBN 1-57392-854-2. 
  • Henderson, Bernard R. (1988). Pollard: The Spy's Story. New York: Alpha Books. ISBN 0-944392-00-8.  Henderson is the father of Pollard's wife, Anne
  • Shaw, Mark (2001), Miscarriage of Justice: The Jonathan Pollard Case, Paragon House Publishers. ISBN #1-55778-803-0
  • Thomas, Gordon (1999), Gideon's Spies: The Secret History of the Mossad (2012 edition), MacMillan Publishers

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b "Top US Officials: Free Jonathan Pollard Now". Retrieved November 7, 2013. 
  2. ^ "959 F.2d 1011: United States of America v. Jonathan Jay Pollard, Appellant". Justia US Law. Retrieved January 3, 2014. 
  3. ^ "Israel Might Offer Palestinian Prisoners To Obama In Exchange For Convicted Spy Jonathan Pollard". International Business Times. February 19, 2013. Retrieved January 3, 2014. 
  4. ^ The Jonathan Pollard Case. http://www.crimelibrary.com/terrorists_spies/spies/pollard/11.html Retrieved August 14, 2014.
  5. ^ a b "How former CIA chief foiled Pollard's release". ynet news. February 5, 2007. Retrieved June 20, 2011. 
  6. ^ "israel apologizes for Pollard spy plot". The Pittsburgf Press. Retrieved 22 April 2014. 
  7. ^ a b "Israel admits it spied on US". news.bbc.co.uk. May 12, 1998. Retrieved September 6, 2008. 
  8. ^ a b c Avi Weiss (April 30, 1993). "With Jonathan Pollard". Berman Jewish Policy Archive. Retrieved December 21, 2013. 
  9. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Hersh, Seymour (January 18, 1999). "Why Pollard Should Never Be Released". The New Yorker. pp. 26–33. Retrieved December 26, 2012. 
  10. ^ a b c d Best, Jr., Richard A.; Clyde Mark (January 31, 2001). "Jonathan Pollard: Background and Considerations for Presidential Clemency" (PDF). Congressional Research Service Report for Congress. The Library of Congress. Retrieved March 7, 2007. 
  11. ^ a b c d Olive 2006, p. 223.
  12. ^ a b c Olive 2006, pp. 77–78.
  13. ^ Johnson, Carrie (December 31, 2008). "Retiree Charged With Passing U.S. Documents to Israel in the 1980s Pleads Guilty". The Washington Post. Retrieved April 3, 2010. 
  14. ^ "U.S. Man Pleads Guilty to Giving Army Data to Israel (Update1)". Bloomberg. December 30, 2008. 
  15. ^ "The Jonathan Jay Pollard Spy Case". Crime Library. Retrieved 22 April 2014. 
  16. ^ Blitzer 1989, pp. 19–20.
  17. ^ Blitzer 1989, p. 30
  18. ^ Olive 2006, p. 2
  19. ^ Noe, Denise (August 7, 1954). "The Jonathan Jay Pollard Spy Case – A Bullied Boy – Crime Library on". Trutv.com. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  20. ^ Blitzer 1989, pp. 35–36
  21. ^ Henderson, Pollard: A Spy's Story (1988) pp. 112–115.
  22. ^ Henderson, page 116.
  23. ^ Katz, Leslie (February 26, 1999). "Jonathan Pollard’s ex-wife trying to build new life". Jweekly. Retrieved 22 April 2014. 
  24. ^ a b c d e f Olive 2006, pp. 8–11.
  25. ^ a b Bernstein, Adam (November 16, 2006). "Sumner Shapiro, Long-Serving Director of Naval Intelligence". The Washington Post. Retrieved September 6, 2008. 
  26. ^ a b c d Olive 2006, pp. 20–22
  27. ^ Olive 2006, p. 28
  28. ^ Thomas, p. 83
  29. ^ https://secure.netsolhost.com/cryptome.org/jya/traitor.htm
  30. ^ "Secerets, Lies and Atomic Spies, Jonathan Jay Pollard". NOVA. January 2002. Retrieved September 18, 2008. 
  31. ^ Olive 2006, p. 12
  32. ^ "NOVA Online | Secrets, Lies, and Atomic Spies | Jonathan Jay Pollard". Pbs.org. November 18, 1985. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  33. ^ Blitzer 1989, p. 102-4; 247-8
  34. ^ Olive 2006, pp. 44–45.
  35. ^ a b c Olive, pp. 44–45
  36. ^ Blitzer 1989, p. 224
  37. ^ a b c d Black, Edwin (June 29, 2002). "Why Jonathan Pollard is Still in Prison?". Forward. Archived from the original on January 7, 2006. Retrieved February 24, 2007. 
  38. ^ a b http://www.trutv.com
  39. ^ "Espionage Spying Between Friends". Time. March 16, 1987. 
  40. ^ a b Oren, Amir (September 21, 2006). "Only attempt to seek refuge in Israeli embassy incriminated Jonathan Pollard". Haaretz. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  41. ^ "THE JONATHAN JAY POLLARD ESPIONAGE CASE: A DAMAGE ASSESSMENT". archives.gov. Retrieved February 19, 2014. 
  42. ^ Hoffman, Gil (November 21, 2010). "PM asks for Pollard's release as part of freeze deal". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved November 20, 2011. 
  43. ^ Thomas, Gordon (2012). Gideon's Spies: The secret history of the Mossad. St. Martin's Griffin. ISBN 978-0312552435. 
  44. ^ Henderson, Pollard: The Spy's Story (1988) page 111.
  45. ^ a b c d e f g Olive 2006, pp. 198–201
  46. ^ Werner, Leslie Maitland (March 4, 1987). "U.S. Jurors Indict An Israeli Officer On Spying Counts". The New York Times. Retrieved December 26, 2012. 
  47. ^ Olive 2006, p. 212
  48. ^ § 794. Gathering or delivering defense information to aid foreign government, United States Code|18|794(c) Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, U.S. Code Collection
  49. ^ "Pollard: Not A Bumbler, But Israel's Master Spy". Jonathanpollard.org. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  50. ^ Black, Edwin (20 June 2002). "Does Jonathan Pollard Deserve a Life Sentence?". History News Network. 
  51. ^ Goulden, Joseph C. (December 24, 2006). "How a spy was caught and why he still stands to profit". Archived from the original on January 2, 2007. Retrieved September 6, 2008. 
  52. ^ Olive 2006, p. 225.
  53. ^ a b Olive 2006, p. 227.
  54. ^ "Pollard Married In Prison". Jonathanpollard.org. May 25, 1994. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  55. ^ "Esther Pollard continues hunger strike". HighBeam Research. Retrieved January 3, 2014. 
  56. ^ "Torontonian at centre of espionage tale Is Esther Pollard really the wife of convicted U.S. spy?". Toronto Star. December 8, 1996. 
  57. ^ Blitzer, Territory of Lies (1989) page 273.
  58. ^ "Pollard's Bureau of Prisons (BOP) profile". Bop.gov. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  59. ^ Amir Oren (November 1, 2005). "U.S. Justice Dept. Internet site: Pollard's life term to end in 2015". Haaretz. Retrieved January 3, 2014. 
  60. ^ Pollard's appeal
  61. ^ United States v. Pollard, No. 90-3276 (D.C.)
  62. ^ Pollards, hostages, part of spy swap with US, Israel
  63. ^ Kahana, Ephraim: Historical dictionary of Israeli intelligence
  64. ^ Haberman, Clyde (May 4, 1995). "Israel Lifts Secrecy Veil From Spy Convictions". The New York Times. 
  65. ^ NewsLibrary Convicted spy Pollard gets visit from Netanyahu – NewsLibrary.com
  66. ^ [1]
  67. ^ Izenberg, Dan, "State Comptroller: Every Gov't Since '96 Tried To Free Pollard, But US Wouldn't Yield", The Jerusalem Post, September 4, 2009, p. 2
  68. ^ "Lawyer lambasts Pollard report", The Jerusalem Post, September 3, 2009
  69. ^ Israeli MKs ask Obama to allow Pollard to attend his father's funeral
  70. ^ "Israelis decry US refusal to let spy see dying father". Yahoo! News. June 19, 2011. Retrieved June 20, 2011. 
  71. ^ a b Perl, Peter (1998-07-05). "The spy who's been left in the cold". The Washington Post Magazine. Retrieved June 13, 2013. 
  72. ^ "Giving aid, comfort to Pollard fan club". Gettysburgh Times. 1994-02-04. Retrieved June 13, 2013. ; "Let U.S. citizenship pay Pollard's penalty". San Antonio Express-News. 1994-02-12. Retrieved June 13, 2013. 
  73. ^ "Israel Grants Citizenship to American Spy". The New York Times. 1995-11-22. Retrieved June 13, 2013. 
  74. ^ Borg, Gary (1995-11-22). "Israel To Grant Citizenship To Convicted Spy Pollard". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved June 13, 2013. 
  75. ^ "Israel Changes Position, Will Grant Spy Citizenship". Orlando Sentinel. 1995-11-22. Retrieved June 13, 2013. 
  76. ^ "Video Review: The Case of Jonathan Pollard". Journal of Film and Video 54 (2/3). 2002. JSTOR 20688383. 
  77. ^ Carter, Chelsea J. (2013-03-14). "Obama: Iran more than a year away from developing nuclear weapon - CNN.com". CNN. Retrieved March 20, 2013. 
  78. ^ "7. Loss and restoration of United States citizenship". Foreign Affairs Manual. United States: Department of State. 2013-02-22. Retrieved March 20, 2013. 
  79. ^ The Facts of the Pollard Case, JonathanPollard.org, Retrieved October 19, 2008.
  80. ^ Why Jonathan Pollard got life. David Zwiebel (June 1997) Middle East Quarterly 4:2
  81. ^ Spy case still makes waves in Israel, Martin Patience (January 15, 2008), BBC News
  82. ^ Israel And Freedom For Jonathan Pollard, Caroline Glick (April 28, 2005) The Jerusalem Post
  83. ^ Olive 2006, p. 210
  84. ^ Tsur, Batsheva (January 21, 1999). "Netanyahu-Barak tiff over Pollard continues". Jerusalem Post. 
  85. ^ "Mideast Accord: The Spy; As Deal Came Together, a Snag Over Release of an American Spy". The New York Times. October 24, 1998. Retrieved April 3, 2010. 
  86. ^ a b c d Clinton, Bill. My Life. 2005, p. 468
  87. ^ a b Dershowitz, Alan M. Chutzpah!. 1992, p. 291
  88. ^ "Young Israel Pres: America Hypocritical on Pollard". Arutz7. Retrieved 22 April 2014. 
  89. ^ a b c "Should Jonathan Pollard be released?". Retrieved 22 April 2014. 
  90. ^ Goodenough, Stan (January 8, 2008). "Messaging Bush, Jerusalem renames city square for Pollard". Jerusalem Newswire. Retrieved September 6, 2008. 
  91. ^ Magnezi, Aviel (June 26, 2011). "Tamar Fogel meets Jonathan Pollard". Ynetnews. Retrieved June 8, 2013. 
  92. ^ Blitzer 1989, p. 166-171.
  93. ^ Ron Friedman (December 14, 2012). "Pollard gathered intel on Arab and Soviet weaponry, not US military activities, CIA document reveals". JTA. Retrieved December 14, 2012. 
  94. ^ "The Jonathan Jay Pollard Espionage Case: A Damage Assessment". The George Washington University. Retrieved January 3, 2014. 
  95. ^ "Congressman who 'saved Pollard' pleads with Obama". Jpost. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  96. ^ "Ex-Rep. Lee Hamilton appeals to Obama for Pollard". JewishJournal. March 2, 2011. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  97. ^ "Four Dems urge Pollard clemency JTA, September 23, 2010". Jta.org. September 23, 2010. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  98. ^ "Congressmen Call to Free Pollard – Politics & Gov't – News". Israel National News. November 19, 2010. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  99. ^ "Congressional letter urges Obama to release spy Jonathan Pollard". World Jewish Congress. 2010-11-19. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  100. ^ "Original Letter to Pres. Obama signed by 39 Congressmen calling for Release of Pollard". Justice for Jonathan Pollard. 2010-11-18. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  101. ^ "Former White House Counsel: Failure To Release Pollard Would Be A 'Miscarriage Of Justice'". The Yeshiva World. 2011-02-06. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  102. ^ "Letter of Former WH Legal Counsel Bernard Nussbaum to Pres. Obama: Failure to release Pollard now "a miscarriage of justice"". Justice for Jonathan Pollard. 2011-02-06. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  103. ^ Benhorin, Yitzhak (January 12, 2011). "Shultz urges Obama to free Pollard". ynetnews.com. 
  104. ^ Rubin, Jennifer (January 11, 2011). "Exclusive: George Shultz calls for Jonathan Pollard's release". The Washington Post. 
  105. ^ "Dr. Henry Kissinger's letter to President Obama: Free Jonathan Pollard". Justice for Jonathan Pollard. 2011-03-03. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  106. ^ "Jonathan Pollard – Letter to President Obama". Young Israel of Tampa Florida. May 2012. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  107. ^ "Washington - Henry Kissinger Calls On President Obama To Free Jonathan Pollard‏". Vos Iz Neias?. 2011-02-07. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  108. ^ "Kissinger asks Obama to release spy for Israel". The Washington Post. March 7, 2011. 
  109. ^ Korb, Lawrence (November 1, 2010). "Pollard's life sentence doesn't fit the crime". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  110. ^ { url = http://www.newsmax.com/alandershowitz/pollard-release-israel-palestine/2014/04/23/id/567193/ , url = http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Op-Ed-Contributors/Justice-demands-the-release-of-Pollard
  111. ^ "Dan Quayle urges Pollard release". Jweekly.com. Retrieved August 22, 2013. 
  112. ^ Hoffman, Gil (February 22, 2011). "Arlen Spector says Obama should free Pollard". The Jerusalem Post. 
  113. ^ "More than 100 NY State legislators join the call for Pollard's release". Justice for Jonathan Pollard. 2011-03-30. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  114. ^ "Quinn's letter". Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  115. ^ "My Winners and Losers of 2012 List". Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  116. ^ "Speaker Quinn Sends Letter To Obama Requesting Him To Free Pollard". Hamodia. December 26, 2012. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  117. ^ Hoffman, Gil (August 3, 2011). "'US Congressman asks to speak to House about Pollard'". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  118. ^ "Conservative Republican Congressman & Decorated War Hero Calls On Pres. Obama To Free Pollard". Justice for Jonathan Pollard. 2011-06-05. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  119. ^ "'If Lockerbie bomber was freed, why not Pollard?'". The Jerusalem Post. 2011-05-06. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  120. ^ "18 ex-senators make plea for Pollard's release". JTA. 2011-11-07. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  121. ^ "18 ex-senators issue plea to Obama: Free Pollard". The Jerusalem Post. 2011-11-09. Retrieved April 11, 2014. 
  122. ^ Woolsey, James (July 5, 2012). "It's Time to Commute Jonathan Pollard's Sentence". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved July 16, 2012. 
  123. ^ "Pollard's fate". The Jerusalem Post. 2013-11-10. Retrieved December 3, 2013. 
  124. ^ "Ex-CIA chief Woolsey blames anti-semitism for detention of Pollard". World Tribune. July 6, 2012. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  125. ^ "Intel analyst offers expert testimony to Obama on Pollard". Jpost. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  126. ^ "Former Senate intelligence staffer urges Jonathan Pollard’s release, offers expert testimony". JNS.org. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  127. ^ "Pollard Defenders Vindicated". Foundation for Defense of Democracies. 20 December 2012. Retrieved April 10, 2014. 
  128. ^ http://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-news-and-politics/119711/pollard-defenders-vindicated}
  129. ^ "With an eye toward the Jewish vote, Newt Gingrich disses Palestinians". 
  130. ^ "US intelligence expert: Pollard wrongly blamed". November 28, 2010. 
  131. ^ "Document prepared in the Knesset surveying the efforts to release Pollard". Knesset.gov.il. Retrieved February 19, 2009. 
  132. ^ "Jonathan Pollard". Jewish Virtual Library. Retrieved February 19, 2014. 
  133. ^ Finer, Jonathan (January 15, 2008). "Bush Trip Revives Israeli Push for Pardon of Spy". The Washington Post. Retrieved September 6, 2008. 
  134. ^ "Jailed For 23 Years, An Old Spy Asks For a Fresh Start". Newsweek. January 2, 2009. Retrieved July 26, 2012. 
  135. ^ Kershner, Isabel (September 21, 2010). "Israelis Float Settlement Deal Involving Spy". The New York Times. Retrieved September 21, 2010. 
  136. ^ Sobelman, Batsheva (December 22, 2010). "ISRAEL: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to seek Jonathan Pollard's release". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved December 22, 2010. 
  137. ^ Barak Ravid (April 9, 2012). "Peres to Obama: Release Israeli spy Jonathan Pollard". Haaretz. Retrieved December 25, 2013. 
  138. ^ "Jonathan Pollard Enters 29th Year in U.S. Prison". The Algemeiner. 2013-11-21. Retrieved December 1, 2013. 
  139. ^ Casey N and Mitnick J (April 1, 2014). Middle East Peace Talks Near Collapse Palestinian Leader Plans to Raise Pressure on Israel; U.S. Backs Off Plan to Free Spy. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved April 1, 2014.
  140. ^ "Top Israeli judge to US: free Pollard". i24news. October 5, 2014. 
  141. ^ "Senior U.S. officials: Charge used to keep Pollard in prison 'patently false'". Haaretz. November 20, 2014. 
  142. ^ Olive 2006, p. 248.
  143. ^ 11 January 1999 Source: Hardcopy The New Yorker, January 18, 1999, pp. 26-33. Annals of Espionage: The Traitor. The case against Jonathan Pollard. Seymour M. Hersh http://cryptome.org/jya/traitor.htm
  144. ^ W. O. Studeman; Sumner Shapiro; J. L. Butts; T. A. Brooks (December 12, 1998). "Release Pollard At the Nation's Peril". The Washington Post. p. A.23. Retrieved December 26, 2012. 
  145. ^ Olive 2006, p. 248
  146. ^ Olive, Ron (November 20, 2006). "I busted Pollard". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved September 6, 2008. 
  147. ^ Peretz, Martin (December 25, 2010) Mr. President: Do Not Free Jonathan Pollard, The New Republic
  148. ^ a b Bowman, M.E. "Spike" "The Drumbeats for Clemency for Jonathan Jay Pollard Reverberate Again, 'Intelligencer: Journal Of U.S. Intelligence Studies', Winter/Spring, 2011.
  149. ^ Cooper, Helene (September 30, 2011). "Obama Turns to Biden to Reassure Jewish Voters, and Get Them to Contribute, Too". The New York Times. 
  150. ^ Natasha Mozgovaya (October 6, 2011). "Biden denies saying Jonathan Pollard would be released 'over his dead body'". Haaretz. Retrieved April 8, 2012. 
  151. ^ "Yishai moves to legalize Jewish ownership of East Jerusalem building", 08.02.10, Haaretzcom

External links[edit]