Kelly pool (also known as pea pool, pill pool, keeley, the keilley game, and killy) is a pocket billiards game played on a standard pool table using fifteen numbered markers called peas or pills, and a standard set of sixteen pool balls. Gameplay involves players drawing peas at random from a shake bottle, which assigns to them the correspondingly numbered pool ball, kept secret from their opponents, but which they must pocket in order to win the game. Kelly pool is a rotation game, which means that players must contact the lowest numbered object ball on each shot first until the opportunity to pocket their own is presented. Two rule variants are set forth under rules promulgated by the Billiard Congress of America (BCA). In the simpler form, the object of play starts and ends with the goal of pocketing one's secret ball. In the second, in addition to the goal of pocketing one's secret ball, points are scored in various ways. In the instance where pills are unavailable, a cloth may be used to cover the balls, which are then chosen blindly, recorded, and replaced for play.
Reportedly invented by Chicagoan Calistus "Kelly" Mulvaney in 1893, kelly pool was a popular game during the early- to mid-20th century. Mentions of it were at one time common in US newspapers, often painting it in a negative light as its play was considered a stronghold of gambling. Authorities in various parts of the United States at times called for a moratorium on the game's play. Until 1964, in fact, playing the game was a fineable offense in the state of Montana.
Many billiard-specific and etymological sources point to kelly pool, or an early version of the game called kelly rotation, as the origin of the common idiom, "behind the eight ball". Some publications blithely assume the expression to be eponymously derived from the game of eight ball, but it has been pointed out that the expression came into use before eight ball was popularized, and that the game did not even use an actual 8 ball under the version first marketed to the public. The predecessor to the BCA, The National Billiard Association, meanwhile, holds that the expression simply emanates from the fact that the eight ball, being black-colored, is harder to see than other balls, thus resulting in an association with any difficult position.
According to an article which appeared in the June 29, 1913 edition of the Chicago Tribune, "Kelly pool was invented by Kelly Mulvaney". The quote is attributed in the article to Hugh E. Keough, a well-known Chicago sportswriter of 31 years. Further information is provided in a November 10, 1916 Indianapolis Star obituary for one Calistus Mulvaney, who is listed as having died the preceding day. The obituary, entitled "Originated 'Kelly Pool'", states that: "... for thirty five years [Mulvaney] was identified with Kelly pool in the loop district ... He was widely known as the father of 'Kelly pool' and better known as Kelly Mulvaney than Calistus. He was born at Fox Lake Wis[consin] sixty-five years ago."
In Calistus Mulvaney's entry in the 1910 United States Census (pictured at right), his occupation is listed as "billiard hall emp[loyee]" and his position there as "keeper". As part of the same household, Mulvaney's brother-in-law's listing appears on the same census page, with his occupation and position identically recorded. The census records Mulvaney's age in 1910 as 56, his birthdate as "about 1854", his birthplace as Wisconsin, his spouse's name as Kate, and his area of residence at that time as Chicago Ward 14, Cook Co., Illinois. Although there is a given-name discrepancy, additional illumination is provided by Simpson M. Ritter in the publication From the Annals of Sports. As Simpson is quoted in the book Sports in the Pulp Magazines by John A. Dinan:
You may not be surprised to learn that Kelly Pool was neither invented by a man named Kelly nor is it of Irish origin. Its inventor, Celestus [sic] Mulvaney, was of Irish origin but invented the game in 1893 in Chicago. The first games were played in that city at the Hannah and Hoggs Billiard Hall on Madison St.—Simpson M. Ritter, From the Annals of Sports
Kelly pool accommodates players with a wide variety of skill levels. The game is designed for group play with a minimum of 2 players, best suited for 4–6, but allowing up to 15 to take part. The Billiard Congress of America (BCA) publishes a long-standardized set of rules for the game.
At the start of kelly pool, the numbered markers (commonly called peas or pills, and sometimes tally balls or shake balls) are placed in a specially made, narrow-necked container (called variously a bottle, pea bottle, pill bottle, kelly bottle, tally bottle or shake bottle) which is shaken to randomly distribute them. Each player then draws a numbered pea from the bottle. The number of the pea drawn assigns to that player the correspondingly numbered object ball, which that player must keep secret from his opponents. The object of the game is for the player to legally pocket their assigned, undisclosed ball (sometimes called their "private number").
At the start of the game a standard set of fifteen pool object balls are racked at the foot end of a pool table, with the apex ball of the rack centered over the foot spot. Viewed from the racker's vantage point, the 1 ball is placed at the rack's apex, the 2 ball at the rack's right corner and the 3 ball at the rack's left corner (as in the game of rotation); all other object balls are placed randomly. An open break is required, meaning that at least four balls must be driven to rails (as opposed to a safety break, such as is used for the opening break in straight pool and one-pocket).
Rules of play
Kelly pool is a rotation game, which means that the lowest numbered ball on the table must be contacted by the cue ball on every shot. There are no called safeties in kelly pool; the legal pocketing (i.e., with no foul committed on the same stroke) of the lowest numbered ball on the table, permits and requires the shooter to continue play. When a ball is illegally pocketed it is spotted to the foot spot (or as close as possible, toward the foot rail).
If a foul is committed, there is no point penalty and the incoming player has the option of accepting the table in position, or requiring the offending player to continue shooting. However, when the foul is the result of jumping the cue ball off the table, or scratching it into a pocket, the incoming player has cue ball in hand from the kitchen (behind the head string), and retains the option of forcing the opponent to shoot. Whichever player ultimately shoots with cue ball in hand has the option of spotting the object ball to the foot spot if it is in the kitchen area.
There are two main scoring variations; under the first and simpler ruleset, the first player to pocket his private number wins. Under the second variation, although a player still wins by pocketing his private number, points are scored in various ways: 1) two points are given by each participant to the winning player for the pocketing of his private number; 2) a player receives one point for pocketing any other player's private number, and the player whose private number was pocketed is penalized one point (and can have a negative point total), but is not out of the game and can still win points in this way; 3) if a player whose private number is pocketed by another does not disclose this fact before a subsequent shot is taken, the non-disclosing player forfeits, immediately losing the game, and the player who made that ball is given two points instead of one. In the event that no player succeeds in pocketing his private number, gameplay ends when the last private number is potted, and the game is played again with all points values doubled.
Association with gambling
Kelly pool has long been associated with gambling—so much so, that it was made illegal in some municipalities in the US and Canada. In the state of Montana, for example, the playing of kelly pool was punishable by a $25 fine until the law was repealed in 1964. Likewise, the playing of kelly pool was banned in the Canadian province of Manitoba at least as of 1918. Gambling exploits associated with kelly pool were often depicted in Clare Briggs' comic strip of the same name, which centered on the game. The Kelly Pool strip (panel pictured at right), ran in the New York Tribune's sports section from 1912 to 1917.
From the early- to mid-20th century numerous newspaper stories cover indictments of kelly pool as a bastion of gambling. In February 1908, the county attorney of Oklahoma City denounced kelly pool, declaring "that it comes with in [sic] the pale of the law against gambling", and issued orders to the city's sheriff's department to enforce a moratorium. In April 1912 a Vincennes, Indiana resident was indicted for embezzling $11,000 from the brick company he managed reportedly due "to his infatuation with 'pea' pool and shaking dice". The following month, Mayor Mudge of Edwardsville, Illinois announced that "effective at once ... poolrooms ... must do away with all forms of gambling, including Kelly Pool." In the same vein, in 1914 Judge J.A. McIlvaine of a Washington, Pennsylvania court, in passing sentence on a pool room proprietor who allowed pea pool games to be wagered on in his establishment, announced that persons committing similar crimes would "be severely punished ... This is the most pernicious form of gambling for it starts youths to higher grades of crime."
In January 1916 a Washington D.C. billiard hall proprietor was fined $100 by a Police Court judge for allowing the game to be played at his establishment. The United States Attorney handling the case told reporters "There is considerable playing of this Kelly pool in the poolrooms of the city, where many young men lose their entire week's wages on a single Saturday night, and I propose to have it stopped, if possible." In April 1922, Charleston, West Virginia's then mayor, Grant P. Hall, declared "baseball pools, pay-ball, Kelly pool and all other forms of gambling in billiard parlors and cigar stores must cease forthwith." Likewise, in December of the same year, Oxford, Ohio's then mayor, J. M. Hughes, declared a war on all forms of gambling, announcing in the local newspaper that "schemes of chance ... [including] Kelly pool ... are contrary to law." In 1934, sports promoter and notorious gambler Jack Doyle's billiard establishment was raided and he, along with 14 patrons, were arrested for placing bets on Kelly pool.
"Behind the eight ball"
"Behind the eight ball" (or "behind the eight") is a common idiom meaning to be in trouble, stymied or thwarted, in an awkward position or out of luck. It is often assumed that the expression derives from the inability to use the 8 ball in a combination in the game of eight-ball—if the cue ball is directly behind the 8 ball a player has no direct shot route. Numerous billiards-specific and etymological publications state that the expression derives instead from kelly pool, or an early version of kelly pool called kelly rotation.
Billiards historian Michael Ian Shamos in The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Billiards (1993), citing information provided by Charles C. Peterson (first president of the Billiard Association of America), and Steve Mizerak and Michael E. Panozzo in Steve Mizerak's Complete Book of Pool (1990), indicate that ascribing the phrase's origin to the game of eight ball results in an anachronism, the phrase being traceable to at least 1919, while the form of game that became "eight-ball" was not described by that name, and its rules were not published in any official rule book, until after 1940. The game that would ultimately be named "eight ball," after a physical 8 ball became part of play, was invented shortly after 1900. That precursor game was little known until it was popularized in 1925 under the name B.B.C. Co. Pool by the Brunswick-Balke-Collender Company, marketed by them with a special set of balls that did not have a numbered 8 ball, but rather came with a ball set consisting of seven of one color, seven of another, and an unnumbered black ball. Thus, multiple-time world champion Steve Mizerak explains that behind the eight ball cannot derive from the game of eight ball as "the phrase predates the game ... by at least 20 years."
Two different kelly pool-based derivations for behind the eight ball are provided in diverse sources. As noted, in kelly pool each player is randomly assigned a specific ball of the fifteen ball rack, which must be made in numerical order. The game ends when any player makes his assigned ball. Based on these rules, one origin theory holds that when a large number of players are participating, players assigned balls numerically higher than 8—that is, balls that are behind the 8 ball in order—have little chance of winning. This is a result of the likelihood that random distribution will result in multiple players with assigned balls numbered lower than 8 having an opportunity to shoot first, and that with such large a number of players at least one will come to the table with the opportunity to shoot at his assigned ball.
A second theory refers to a kelly pool rule variation under which the 8 ball is excluded from assignment as a secret number and, if another ball strikes the 8 ball at any time during play, the player responsible is penalized. "So a position directly behind the eight ball is a position of great hazard."
A more generic origin of the phrase that is independent of any particular game's rule, instead depending from a property of the 8 ball itself, is proffered by Billiard Congress of America predecessor, The National Billiard Association, which organization was the governing body of American billiards from 1921 to 1941:
It is generally conceded that the 8-ball is the most difficult for the player to see clearly in the execution of his shot. This, because it is black, naturally the edges of the ball, or in fact any part of the ball, do not stand out as clearly as colored. Therefore, professional players, if possible, avoid being forced to play the 8-ball from a difficult position or with the cue ball a long distance from the 8-ball because it is more difficult to see clearly. In reality, this fact was what started the now common saying, 'behind the eight ball,' used in the player's vernacular in the sense that being in any kind of a difficult point on the table, many times calls for the remark that one is 'behind the eight ball.' In other words, they use this to explain any difficult situation that may confront them in the game.—The National Billiard Association (1936)
- Shamos, Michael Ian (1993). The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Billiards. New York, NY: Lyons & Burford. pp. 24, 26, 85, 128 and 168. ISBN 1-55821-219-1.
- Staff writer(s) (November 10, 1916). "Originated 'Kelly Pool.'". The Indianapolis Star. p. 9. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, May 24, 2009.
- Zollars, H. (June 29, 1913). "Kelly Pool in the Days of Real Sport". Chicago Daily Tribune. p. E4. Retrieved May 24, 2009.
- Staff writer(s) (June 10, 1912). "Hugh E. Keough" (PDF). The New York Times. Retrieved May 24, 2009.
- Calistus Mulvaney's entry in the 1910 United States Census. Refer to File:1910 Census detail-Calistus Mulvaney.jpg.
- Dinan, John A. (1998). Sports in the pulp magazines. North Carolina: McFarland. pp. 100–101. ISBN 0-7864-0481-7. Retrieved May 24, 2009.
- BCA Rules Committee (November 1992). Billiards – the Official Rules and Record Book. Iowa City, Iowa: Billiard Congress of America. pp. 137–9. ISBN 1-878493-02-7.
- Laurance, Ewa Mataya; Shaw, Thomas C. (1999). The Complete Idiot's Guide to Pool & Billiards. New York, NY: Alpha Books. p. 355. ISBN 0-02-862645-1.
- Associated Press (March 6, 1964). "Obsolete Montana Laws". The Montana Standard and The Butte Daily Post. p. Front page. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, May 28, 2009.
- Staff writers (February 22, 1918). "Stopped Pea Pool Game". Manitoba Free Press. p. 9. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 25, 2009.
- Polsky, Ned (1969). Hustlers, beats, and others. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books. p. 21. OCLC 9234. Retrieved May 24, 2009.
- Search of Ancestry.com's periodical database of digitized newspapers with the search parameter
gambling "kelly pool"reveals hundreds of relevant newspaper stories.
- Staff writers (February 27, 1908). "Denounces Kelly Pool: County Attorney Issues Orders to Sheriff to Stop Game". The Evening News, Ada Oklahoma. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, May 31, 2009.
- Staff writers (April 12, 1912). "Shortage Due to "Pea" Pool". The Sheboygan Press. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 25, 2009.
- Staff writers, St. Louis Post-Dispatch (May 10, 1913). "The Ideal Poolroom". The Edwardsville Intelligencer. p. Front page. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 6, 2009.
- Staff writers (February 12, 1914). "Judge McIlvaine Issues Warning". The Charleroi Mail. p. Front page. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 26, 2009.
- Staff writers (January 20, 1916). "District Court News: Kelly Pool is Marked for Slaughter". The Washington Post. p. 3. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 6, 2009.
- Staff writers (April 13, 1922). "Gambling Must Cease, Says Mayor in Order to the Police Chief". Charleston Daily Mail. p. front cover. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, May 31, 2009.
- Staff writers (December 2, 1922). "Mayor Starts Gambling War". Hamilton Daily News. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, May 28, 2009.
- "BILLIARD Rooms Raided. The Police Seize Jack Doyle and 14 Kelly Pool Players.". The New York Times. December 19, 1934. Retrieved February 21, 2007.
- Ann Nevins and Dan Nevins (1977). From the Horse's Mouth. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. p. 13. ISBN 0-13-331520-7.
- Ammer, Christine (1997). The American Heritage Dictionary of Idioms. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company. p. 51. ISBN 0-395-72774-X.
- Ciardi, John (1980). A browser's dictionary, and native's guide to the unknown American language. New York: Harper & Row. p. 118. ISBN 978-0-06-010766-6.
- Steve Mizerak and Michael E. Panozzo (1990). Steve Mizerak's Complete Book of Pool. Chicago, Ill: Contemporary Books. pp. 126–7. ISBN 0-8092-4255-9.
- Korach, Myron; John B. Mordock (2002). Common Phrases and Where They Come From. New York: Lyons Press. p. 158. ISBN 978-1-58574-682-8.
- Crumpacker, Bunny (2007). Perfect Figures. New York: St. Martin's Press. p. 140. ISBN 978-0-312-36005-4. Retrieved June 18, 2009.
- Brewer, Ebenezer Cobham; Ivor H. Evans (1970). Brewer's dictionary of phrase and fable (2nd, revised ed.). London: Cassell. p. 367. ISBN 978-0-304-93570-3.
- Funk, Charles Earle (1948). A hog on ice, and other curious expressions (1st ed.). New York: Harper & Bros. p. 108. OCLC 3891233.
- Mathews, Mitford McLeod (1959). American Words. Cleveland: World Pub. Co. p. 44. OCLC 254546082.
- Urdang, Laurence; Walter W. Hunsinger; Nancy LaRoche (1985). Picturesque expressions (2nd ed.). Detroit: Gale Research. p. 193. ISBN 978-0-8103-1606-5.
- Billiard Congress of America (1995–2005) A Brief History of the Noble Game of Billiards by Mike Shamos. Retrieved February 22, 2007.
- Jewett, Bob (February 2002). "8-Ball Rules: The many different versions of one of today's most common games". Billiards Digest Magazine: 22–23.
- Morris, William (November 19, 1958). "Word, Wit and Wisdom". The Troy Record. p. 12. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 18, 2009.
- Brewer, Ebenezer Cobham (1953). Dictionary of phrase & fable (8th ed.). New York: Harper & Bros. p. 326. OCLC 1300751.
- "Today's Answers to Questions". The Helena Daily Independent. February 7, 1937. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 18, 2009.
- "Behind the 8-ball". Kingston Daily Freeman (Kingston, NY). October 8, 1936. p. 15. Accessed through Ancestry.com database, June 24, 2009.
- Todd, Arthur James; William Fisher Byron; Howard L. Vierow (1937). The Chicago recreation survey, 1937. Chicago: Chicago Recreation Commission. p. 52. OCLC 38440252.