|Place of birth||Scotland|
|* Senior club appearances and goals counted for the domestic league only.
† Appearances (Goals).
Born in Scotland, Gilmartin was one of a number of Scots who travelled South to join the newly formed Yorkshire club after United had advertised for players in the Scottish press. He played regularly during his one season at Bramall Lane, making 41 appearances although the majority of these were friendly games. He also played in all of the games that made up United's first FA Cup campaign, including the record 13-0 loss to Bolton Wanderers.
With United looking to sign a better standard of player in order to compete in League football Gilmartin was released in the summer of 1890.
|This biographical article relating to sport in Scotland is a stub. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it.|